Sarhad Provincial Conservation Strategy - IUCN

Sarhad Provincial Conservation Strategy - IUCN Sarhad Provincial Conservation Strategy - IUCN

cmsdata.iucn.org
from cmsdata.iucn.org More from this publisher
07.07.2013 Views

3 R E S P O N D I N G T O T H E I S S U E S health care, rural water supply, sanitation, and population control. Environmental concerns are being addressed by implementation of Pakistan's high-profile NCS and various counterpart provincial conservation strategies. Several institutions—such as a privatization commission, a Federal bureau of investment, and an energy board—have been set up to pursue the privatization of state enterprises and to encourage additional private-sector investment. With respect to greater public participation, the experience of the Aga Khan Rural Support Programme is being replicated in a National Rural Support Programme. The Sarhad Rural Support Corporation is now operating in the NWFP, as is the Balochistan Rural Support Programme. An increasing number of donor projects and locally funded programmes are also seeking to involve people in their activities. As a result, a strong and expanding network of NGOs is emerging. The NWFP is in the lead in implementing the SAP and the NCS in Pakistan. NCS implementation is being pursued through this SPCS, which is based on the objectives, priorities, and recommendations of the NCS adapted to the needs, potentials, and aspirations of the people of the NWFP. The basic objectives, underlying the NCS are found in Box 3.1. The new development paradigm is also characterized by a culture of participation and privatization. The process of partnering communities and NGOs is relatively more advanced in the NWFP. This is mainly THE NCS OBJECTIVES BOX 3.1 ■ Use ecosystems for development in a way that ensures their future viability and conservation. ■ Development should not lead to the depletion of natural resources but instead rely on the interest of nature’s capital as well as enhance the quantity and quality of nature’s capital stock. ■ Non-renewable resources such as fossil fuels and minerals are finite and must be used in a manner that is sustainable. Fossil fuels should be exploited in a way that extends the transition period long enough for alternatives to become available. Biomass, for example, can be substituted for fossil fuels. ■ Ensure that where resources are used as a repository for waste removal, their assimilative capacities are available to future users. 20 SARHAD PROVINCIAL CONSERVATION STRATEGY because participation and self-help have been found here for centuries. Moreover, the modern form of participatory development in Pakistan was born in the Daudzai Project near Peshawar, which has now been replicated in most other projects and programmes. There is a growing recognition in the Government about the need and promise of partnerships with the private sector and the growing number of NGOs, although there are still doubts about the groups' competence, skills, and motivation. Giving the private sector and community groups a lead role in projects is just beginning. The private sector and NGOs are concerned about the transparency of decision making in the Government, and fear reversion to the older policies of oppression and control. There is a need to establish a reliable Government-NGO-private sector relationship that is based on mutual trust and confidence. As most NGOs depend on grants, they are sometimes seen as opportunistic. Regardless of this skepticism, the emerging culture of participation is encouraging. With more freedom to operate, social and market forces will themselves eliminate the unreliable organizations. From a sustainable development perspective, privatization may improve the efficiency of industries, production processes, and the quality of products. But the impact on the environment is not clear. Alliances may emerge that will resist environmental legislation. On the other hand, privatization can also result in greater investment in environmental technology and generate more employment. Moreover, more public funds will be available for environmental rehabilitation and compensation for the potentially negative effects of industrialization. The privatization policy can also help in widening the tax base, particularly if environmental taxation is considered. However, given the modest levels of industrial activity in the province, the impact of privatization is not yet very pronounced in the NWFP. Many contemporary development programmes in the NWFP are part of the new paradigm of sustainable development. But this must be seen as an evolving process. For example, the emerging concept of sustainable human development extends the original ideas of sustainable development with a largely sin-

gular focus on the development of individual human capacity, and proposes an expanded concept that involves measuring the improvement of people's ability to organize themselves, participate, network, and take collective action. It implies that there must be new ways to monitor and measure development. This includes the need to evaluate participatory institutions, improvements in systems of decision making, and better governance. As the United Nations Development Programme (UNDP) points out in the Human Development Report 1994: “To address the growing challenge of human security, a new development paradigm is needed that puts people at the center of development, regards economic growth as a means and not an end, protects the life opportunities of future generations and respects the natural systems on which all life depends.” With reference to the NWFP, it seems obvious that there is value in the kind of solutions offered by organizations such as UNDP. Thus in the main body of this report there is both a conventional emphasis on environment and development and an overt emphasis on people, peoples' organizations, and the mechanisms to allow people to define their interactions and their development priorities. This approach is embodied in different sections of the report on governance, partnership, communications, and assessing progress towards sustainability. The organizations in our society that are neither political parties, Government agencies, nor profitmaking private companies are commonly defined as the ‘civil society’. In the NWFP these would include chambers of commerce, rural development organizations, labour unions, cultural organizations, environmental groups, human rights commissions, and educational associations. The strength of the sector determines the extent to which private and Government interests are balanced, and indeed determines the strength of the democracy. Thus, in addition to a theme of sustainable human development as a thread running through much of the SPCS, there is a well defined objective of strengthening civil society. This has been embodied in the process of developing the strategy itself, by consulting, networking, and contracting NGOs to undertake the work. More specifically, the entire NGO pro- R E S P O N D I N G T O T H E I S S U E S 3 gramme and elements of the communication programme are fundamentally geared to develop civil society. Added to these are the proposed environmental bill of rights, legally mandated environmental assessment processes, and basic environmental quality improvements envisaged in the proposed environmental legislation for the NWFP. A strong civil society, strong village organizations, strong NGOs, and strong community-based organizations—particularly where linked through strong rural support programmes—are the areas where the objectives of the SPCS are first likely to be met. Equally important is the need for linkages between Government and civil society. There is a danger in developing too much new language or terminology to define very basic ideas. In essence, civil society is a concept of developing partnership between people, organizations, and Government. This need not be a complex subject, but it is important to emphasize in the NWFP. Respect for law is tenuous. Understanding of the underpinnings of democracy is weak or deliberately undermined. Pride in action is strong, but belief in good governance does not transform a proud individual into a good citizen. In the NWFP, despite all the legal, political, financial, and development problems, there appears to be a distinct willingness to move forward. This was most obvious in the overwhelming spontaneous response to the public consultations held at both the district and the village level, but it is also significant that the political leadership and senior bureaucracy are consistently supportive and enthusiastic. The province faces overwhelming obstacles to achieving sustainable development, but there is reason for optimism. 3 . 4 C O N T E M P O R A RY DEVELOPMENT WORK IN THE NWFP The commitment of the Government of NWFP towards environmental rehabilitation and resource conservation has now attracted the interest of many bilateral and multilateral foreign donor agencies that provide financial as well as technical assistance. This SARHAD PROVINCIAL CONSERVATION STRATEGY 21

gular focus on the development of individual human<br />

capacity, and proposes an expanded concept that<br />

involves measuring the improvement of people's ability<br />

to organize themselves, participate, network, and<br />

take collective action. It implies that there must be<br />

new ways to monitor and measure development. This<br />

includes the need to evaluate participatory institutions,<br />

improvements in systems of decision making,<br />

and better governance.<br />

As the United Nations Development Programme<br />

(UNDP) points out in the Human Development Report<br />

1994: “To address the growing challenge of human<br />

security, a new development paradigm is needed that<br />

puts people at the center of development, regards economic<br />

growth as a means and not an end, protects the<br />

life opportunities of future generations and respects the<br />

natural systems on which all life depends.”<br />

With reference to the NWFP, it seems obvious that<br />

there is value in the kind of solutions offered by organizations<br />

such as UNDP. Thus in the main body of this<br />

report there is both a conventional emphasis on environment<br />

and development and an overt emphasis on<br />

people, peoples' organizations, and the mechanisms<br />

to allow people to define their interactions and their<br />

development priorities. This approach is embodied in<br />

different sections of the report on governance, partnership,<br />

communications, and assessing progress<br />

towards sustainability.<br />

The organizations in our society that are neither<br />

political parties, Government agencies, nor profitmaking<br />

private companies are commonly defined as<br />

the ‘civil society’. In the NWFP these would include<br />

chambers of commerce, rural development organizations,<br />

labour unions, cultural organizations, environmental<br />

groups, human rights commissions, and educational<br />

associations. The strength of the sector determines<br />

the extent to which private and Government<br />

interests are balanced, and indeed determines the<br />

strength of the democracy.<br />

Thus, in addition to a theme of sustainable human<br />

development as a thread running through much of the<br />

SPCS, there is a well defined objective of strengthening<br />

civil society. This has been embodied in the<br />

process of developing the strategy itself, by consulting,<br />

networking, and contracting NGOs to undertake<br />

the work. More specifically, the entire NGO pro-<br />

R E S P O N D I N G T O T H E I S S U E S 3<br />

gramme and elements of the communication programme<br />

are fundamentally geared to develop civil<br />

society. Added to these are the proposed environmental<br />

bill of rights, legally mandated environmental<br />

assessment processes, and basic environmental quality<br />

improvements envisaged in the proposed environmental<br />

legislation for the NWFP.<br />

A strong civil society, strong village organizations,<br />

strong NGOs, and strong community-based<br />

organizations—particularly where linked through<br />

strong rural support programmes—are the areas<br />

where the objectives of the SPCS are first likely to be<br />

met. Equally important is the need for linkages<br />

between Government and civil society.<br />

There is a danger in developing too much new<br />

language or terminology to define very basic ideas.<br />

In essence, civil society is a concept of developing<br />

partnership between people, organizations, and<br />

Government. This need not be a complex subject, but<br />

it is important to emphasize in the NWFP. Respect for<br />

law is tenuous. Understanding of the underpinnings<br />

of democracy is weak or deliberately undermined.<br />

Pride in action is strong, but belief in good governance<br />

does not transform a proud individual into a<br />

good citizen.<br />

In the NWFP, despite all the legal, political, financial,<br />

and development problems, there appears to be<br />

a distinct willingness to move forward. This was most<br />

obvious in the overwhelming spontaneous response<br />

to the public consultations held at both the district<br />

and the village level, but it is also significant that the<br />

political leadership and senior bureaucracy are consistently<br />

supportive and enthusiastic.<br />

The province faces overwhelming obstacles to<br />

achieving sustainable development, but there is reason<br />

for optimism.<br />

3 . 4<br />

C O N T E M P O R A RY DEVELOPMENT<br />

WORK IN THE NWFP<br />

The commitment of the Government of NWFP<br />

towards environmental rehabilitation and resource<br />

conservation has now attracted the interest of many<br />

bilateral and multilateral foreign donor agencies that<br />

provide financial as well as technical assistance. This<br />

SARHAD PROVINCIAL CONSERVATION STRATEGY 21

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!