VS - Kentucky Court of Justice
VS - Kentucky Court of Justice
VS - Kentucky Court of Justice
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
1148 SHAFIZADEH (SAEID)<br />
<strong>VS</strong>.<br />
SHAFIZADEH (DENISE O.)<br />
OPINION AFFIRMING IN PART,<br />
REVERSING IN PART, AND<br />
REMANDING<br />
ACREE (PRESIDING JUDGE)<br />
CLAYTON (CONCURS) AND KELLER<br />
(CONCURS)<br />
1149 HARTMAN (ANDREA KAYE)<br />
<strong>VS</strong>.<br />
HARTMAN (ERIC CREIGHTON)<br />
OPINION AFFIRMING<br />
MOORE (PRESIDING JUDGE)<br />
CLAYTON (CONCURS) AND COMBS<br />
(CONCURS)<br />
1150 JONES (WANDA), ET AL.<br />
<strong>VS</strong>.<br />
DOUGHERTY (CYNTHIA), ET AL.<br />
OPINION AFFIRMING<br />
KELLER (PRESIDING JUDGE)<br />
CLAYTON (CONCURS) AND MAZE<br />
(CONCURS)<br />
1151 MEYERS (JOHN B.)<br />
<strong>VS</strong>.<br />
ATLANTIS NORTH, INC.<br />
OPINION AFFIRMING IN PART,<br />
REVERSING IN PART, AND<br />
REMANDING<br />
CAPERTON (PRESIDING JUDGE)<br />
LAMBERT (CONCURS) AND MOORE<br />
(CONCURS)<br />
1152 WHITE (NORVILLE SHANE)<br />
<strong>VS</strong>.<br />
HARVEY (ROGER), ET AL.<br />
OPINION AFFIRMING<br />
CAPERTON (PRESIDING JUDGE)<br />
CLAYTON (CONCURS) AND NICKELL<br />
(CONCURS)<br />
1153 TRAVIS (KIM M.)<br />
<strong>VS</strong>.<br />
COMMONWEALTH OF KENTUCKY,<br />
CABINET FOR HEALTH AND FAMILY<br />
SERVICES, ET AL.<br />
OPINION AFFIRMING<br />
TAYLOR (PRESIDING JUDGE)<br />
KELLER (CONCURS) AND THOMPSON<br />
(CONCURS)<br />
COURT OF APPEALS OF KENTUCKY<br />
12/14/2012 AT 10:00 a.m.<br />
PAGE 1 <strong>of</strong> 7<br />
2010-CA-000758-MR<br />
2010-CA-002125-MR<br />
2011-CA-000825-MR<br />
TO BE PUBLISHED<br />
2010-CA-001655-MR<br />
2011-CA-000551-MR<br />
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED<br />
2010-CA-001985-MR<br />
TO BE PUBLISHED<br />
2011-CA-000035-MR<br />
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED<br />
2011-CA-000531-MR<br />
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED<br />
2011-CA-000670-MR<br />
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED<br />
JEFFERSON<br />
FAYETTE<br />
CHRISTIAN<br />
JEFFERSON<br />
MONTGOMERY<br />
FRANKLIN
1154 AMSHOFF (JOHN RICHARD)<br />
<strong>VS</strong>.<br />
AMSHOFF (MARTINA DENISE WALLS),<br />
ET AL.<br />
OPINION AFFIRMING<br />
KELLER (PRESIDING JUDGE)<br />
TAYLOR (CONCURS) AND VANMETER<br />
(CONCURS)<br />
1155 WEITER, SR. (GARY), ET AL.<br />
<strong>VS</strong>.<br />
KURTZ (JOSEPH), ET AL.<br />
OPINION AFFIRMING<br />
LAMBERT (PRESIDING JUDGE)<br />
CAPERTON (CONCURS) AND MOORE<br />
(CONCURS IN RESULT ONLY)<br />
1156 SPARKS (NICOLE R.)<br />
<strong>VS</strong>.<br />
TRUSTGARD INSURANCE COMPANY<br />
OPINION AFFIRMING<br />
MOORE (PRESIDING JUDGE)<br />
ACREE (CONCURS) AND THOMPSON<br />
(CONCURS)<br />
1157 CHRISTIAN (DAVID)<br />
<strong>VS</strong>.<br />
COMMONWEALTH OF KENTUCKY<br />
OPINION AFFIRMING<br />
MOORE (PRESIDING JUDGE)<br />
MAZE (CONCURS) AND TAYLOR<br />
(CONCURS)<br />
1158 WORKMAN (JAYSON P.)<br />
<strong>VS</strong>.<br />
COMMONWEALTH OF KENTUCKY<br />
OPINION REMANDING<br />
ACREE (PRESIDING JUDGE)<br />
NICKELL (CONCURS) AND STUMBO<br />
(CONCURS)<br />
1159 BUTCHER (RICHARD)<br />
<strong>VS</strong>.<br />
COMMONWEALTH OF KENTUCKY<br />
OPINION AFFIRMING<br />
DIXON(PRESIDING JUDGE)<br />
ACREE (CONCURS) AND VANMETER<br />
(CONCURS)<br />
COURT OF APPEALS OF KENTUCKY<br />
12/14/2012 AT 10:00 a.m.<br />
PAGE 2 <strong>of</strong> 7<br />
2011-CA-000860-MR<br />
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED<br />
2011-CA-001058-MR<br />
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED<br />
2011-CA-001119-MR<br />
TO BE PUBLISHED<br />
2011-CA-001288-MR<br />
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED<br />
2011-CA-001292-MR<br />
2011-CA-001293-MR<br />
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED<br />
2011-CA-001381-MR<br />
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED<br />
NELSON<br />
JEFFERSON<br />
LAUREL<br />
HOPKINS<br />
CALLOWAY<br />
FAYETTE
1160 BAGBY (JAMES)<br />
<strong>VS</strong>.<br />
COMMONWEALTH OF KENTUCKY<br />
OPINION AFFIRMING<br />
TAYLOR (PRESIDING JUDGE)<br />
MAZE (CONCURS) AND MOORE<br />
(CONCURS)<br />
1161 COOK (DALLAS LEE)<br />
<strong>VS</strong>.<br />
COMMONWEALTH OF KENTUCKY<br />
OPINION AFFIRMING<br />
DIXON (PRESIDING JUDGE)<br />
ACREE (CONCURS) AND VANMETER<br />
(CONCURS)<br />
1162 WALLACE (MARK B.), ET AL.<br />
<strong>VS</strong>.<br />
AUTO STORE, LLC<br />
OPINION AFFIRMING<br />
CLAYTON (PRESIDING JUDGE)<br />
COMBS (CONCURS) AND THOMPSON<br />
(CONCURS IN RESULT ONLY)<br />
1163 RILEY (PENNY)<br />
<strong>VS</strong>.<br />
T/G AUTOMOTIVE SEALING<br />
KENTUCKY, LLC<br />
OPINION AFFIRMING<br />
MOORE (PRESIDING JUDGE)<br />
MAZE (CONCURS) AND TAYLOR<br />
(CONCURS)<br />
1164 NATIONWIDE INSURANCE COMPANY<br />
<strong>VS</strong>.<br />
MADISON (JOHN G.), ET AL.<br />
OPINION AFFIRMING<br />
LAMBERT (PRESIDING JUDGE)<br />
CAPERTON (CONCURS) AND<br />
VANMETER (DISSENTS AND FILES A<br />
SEPARATE OPINION)<br />
1165 SLAVEY (JAMES ALLEN)<br />
<strong>VS</strong>.<br />
SLAVEY (HEATHER SHAWNA)<br />
OPINION AFFIRMING<br />
MAZE (PRESIDING JUDGE)<br />
DIXON (CONCURS) AND NICKELL<br />
(CONCURS)<br />
COURT OF APPEALS OF KENTUCKY<br />
12/14/2012 AT 10:00 a.m.<br />
PAGE 3 <strong>of</strong> 7<br />
2011-CA-001411-MR<br />
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED<br />
2011-CA-001551-MR<br />
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED<br />
2011-CA-001574-MR<br />
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED<br />
2011-CA-001580-MR<br />
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED<br />
2011-CA-001614-MR<br />
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED<br />
2011-CA-001695-MR<br />
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED<br />
TAYLOR<br />
JEFFERSON<br />
JEFFERSON<br />
CHRISTIAN<br />
BARREN<br />
PULASKI
COURT OF APPEALS OF KENTUCKY<br />
12/14/2012 AT 10:00 a.m.<br />
PAGE 4 <strong>of</strong> 7<br />
1166 SUMMERS (FORMERLY QUEENO)<br />
(REBEKAH)<br />
<strong>VS</strong>.<br />
QUEENO (TERRY L.)<br />
OPINION AFFIRMING<br />
ACREE (PRESIDING JUDGE)<br />
DIXON (CONCURS) AND VANMETER<br />
(CONCURS)<br />
1167 COMMONWEALTH OF KENTUCKY,<br />
CABINET FOR HEALTH AND FAMILY<br />
SERVICES<br />
<strong>VS</strong>.<br />
L. (R. R.), ET AL.<br />
OPINION AFFIRMING<br />
NICKELL (PRESIDING JUDGE)<br />
STUMBO (CONCURS) AND ACREE<br />
(DISSENTS AND FILES SEPARATE<br />
OPINION)<br />
1168 JACKSON (MELISSA), ET AL.<br />
<strong>VS</strong>.<br />
GHAYOUMI, D.C. (MEHDI), ET AL.<br />
OPINION AFFIRMING<br />
LAMBERT (PRESIDING JUDGE)<br />
COMBS (CONCURS) AND NICKELL<br />
(CONCURS)<br />
1169 SISCO (EUGENE)<br />
<strong>VS</strong>.<br />
COMMONWEALTH OF KENTUCKY<br />
JUSTICE AND PUBLIC SAFETY<br />
CABINET, ET AL.<br />
OPINION AFFIRMING IN PART,<br />
VACATING IN PART, AND REMANDING<br />
CAPERTON (PRESIDING JUDGE)<br />
COMBS (CONCURS IN RESULT ONLY)<br />
AND NICKELL (CONCURS IN RESULT<br />
ONLY)<br />
1170 BROCK (DEBRA), ET AL.<br />
<strong>VS</strong>.<br />
LOUISVILLE METRO HOUSING<br />
AUTHORITY<br />
OPINION VACATING AND REMANDING<br />
COMBS (PRESIDING JUDGE)<br />
NICKELL (CONCURS) AND LAMBERT<br />
(CONCURS IN RESULT ONLY)<br />
2011-CA-001902-ME<br />
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED<br />
2011-CA-001919-ME<br />
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED<br />
2011-CA-002017-MR<br />
TO BE PUBLISHED<br />
2011-CA-002063-MR<br />
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED<br />
2011-CA-002244-MR<br />
TO BE PUBLISHED<br />
JEFFERSON<br />
HART<br />
JEFFERSON<br />
PIKE<br />
JEFFERSON
1171 DAVIS (JEAN E.)<br />
<strong>VS</strong>.<br />
CRAFTON (MARY H.), ET AL.<br />
OPINION AFFIRMING<br />
KELLER (PRESIDING JUDGE)<br />
CLAYTON (CONCURS) AND MAZE<br />
(CONCURS)<br />
COURT OF APPEALS OF KENTUCKY<br />
12/14/2012 AT 10:00 a.m.<br />
PAGE 5 <strong>of</strong> 7<br />
1172 ALLEN (GINA), AS ADMINISTRATRIX OF<br />
THE ESTATE OF MARGARET HILLMAN,<br />
DECEASED<br />
<strong>VS</strong>.<br />
EXTENDICARE HOMES, INC., ET AL.<br />
OPINION AFFIRMING<br />
TAYLOR (PRESIDING JUDGE)<br />
MAZE (CONCURS) AND MOORE<br />
(CONCURS)<br />
1173 T. (J.T.)<br />
<strong>VS</strong>.<br />
COMMONWEALTH OF KENTUCKY,<br />
CABINET FOR HEALTH AND FAMILY<br />
SERVICES, ET AL.<br />
OPINION AFFIRMING<br />
MAZE (PRESIDING JUDGE)<br />
DIXON (CONCURS) AND NICKELL<br />
(CONCURS)<br />
1174 ROGERS (KATRICIA)<br />
<strong>VS</strong>.<br />
PENNYRILE ALLIED COMMUNITY<br />
SERVICES, INC.<br />
OPINION REVERSING AND<br />
REMANDING<br />
NICKELL (PRESIDING JUDGE)<br />
DIXON (CONCURS) AND MAZE<br />
(DISSENTS AND FILES SEPARATE<br />
OPINION)<br />
1175 ELKINS (BRENDA K.)<br />
<strong>VS</strong>.<br />
LKLP CAC, INC. , ET AL.<br />
OPINION AFFIRMING<br />
TAYLOR (PRESIDING JUDGE)<br />
CLAYTON (CONCURS) AND MAZE<br />
(CONCURS)<br />
2012-CA-000039-MR<br />
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED<br />
2012-CA-000050-MR<br />
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED<br />
2012-CA-000136-ME<br />
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED<br />
2012-CA-000204-MR<br />
TO BE PUBLISHED<br />
2012-CA-000335-WC<br />
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED<br />
TAYLOR<br />
TRIGG<br />
RUSSELL<br />
PERRY<br />
WORKERS'<br />
COMP
1176 HUNTER (JEFFREY)<br />
<strong>VS</strong>.<br />
MUSIC (CHANEL)<br />
OPINION AFFIRMING<br />
DIXON (PRESIDING JUDGE)<br />
MAZE (CONCURS) AND NICKELL<br />
(CONCURS)<br />
COURT OF APPEALS OF KENTUCKY<br />
12/14/2012 AT 10:00 a.m.<br />
PAGE 6 <strong>of</strong> 7<br />
1177 P. (W. R.)<br />
<strong>VS</strong>.<br />
CABINET FOR HEALTH AND FAMILY<br />
SERVICES, ET AL.<br />
OPINION VACATING AND REMANDING<br />
CLAYTON (PRESIDING JUDGE)<br />
STUMBO (CONCURS) AND THOMPSON<br />
(CONCURS)<br />
1178 SHELBY INDUSTRIES, LLC<br />
<strong>VS</strong>.<br />
ESTATE OF BRIAN LARSH, ET AL.<br />
OPINION AFFIRMING<br />
KELLER (PRESIDING JUDGE)<br />
CLAYTON (CONCURS) AND MAZE<br />
(CONCURS)<br />
1179 YOUNG (ANGELYNNA)<br />
<strong>VS</strong>.<br />
HATFIELD (ANITA S.)<br />
OPINION DISMISSING<br />
KELLER (PRESIDING JUDGE)<br />
ACREE (CONCURS) AND MOORE<br />
(CONCURS)<br />
1180 L. (M. W.)<br />
<strong>VS</strong>.<br />
S., III (T. B.), ET AL.<br />
OPINION AFFIRMING<br />
COMBS (PRESIDING JUDGE)<br />
LAMBERT (CONCURS) AND NICKELL<br />
(CONCURS)<br />
1181 CENTRAL SERVICES, INC.<br />
<strong>VS</strong>.<br />
YARBROUGH (MARY ANN), ET AL.<br />
OPINION AFFIRMING IN PART,<br />
VACATING IN PART AND REMANDING<br />
LAMBERT (PRESIDING JUDGE)<br />
COMBS (CONCURS) AND KELLER<br />
(CONCURS)<br />
2012-CA-000610-ME<br />
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED<br />
2012-CA-000657-ME<br />
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED<br />
2012-CA-000667-WC<br />
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED<br />
2012-CA-000693-ME<br />
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED<br />
2012-CA-000867-ME<br />
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED<br />
2012-CA-001121-WC<br />
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED<br />
FLOYD<br />
HART<br />
WORKERS'<br />
COMP<br />
HARRISON<br />
OLDHAM<br />
WORKERS'<br />
COMP
COURT OF APPEALS OF KENTUCKY<br />
12/14/2012 AT 10:00 a.m.<br />
PAGE 7 <strong>of</strong> 7<br />
*******************************************************************************************************************<br />
ORDER DENYING PETITION FOR REHEARING:<br />
LV VENTURES, LLC, ET AL. 2011-CA-000473-MR FAYETTE<br />
<strong>VS</strong>. 2011-CA-000640-MR<br />
TREY SCHOTT, ET AL. 2011-CA-001132-MR<br />
ENTERED 12/13/12<br />
SHERRI GAIL CLARK (NOW PUCKETT) 2011-CA-000490-MR GRAVES<br />
<strong>VS</strong>. 2011-CA-000540-MR<br />
WILLIAM THOMAS CLARK<br />
ENTERED 12/10/12<br />
RANDY A. MAREMA, ET AL. 2011-CA-000995-MR HARDIN<br />
<strong>VS</strong>.<br />
FIRST FEDERAL SAVINGS BANK OF<br />
ELIZABETHTOWN, INC.<br />
ENTERED 12/13/12<br />
******************************************************************************************************************<br />
ORDER DENYING WRIT OF PROHIBITION:<br />
NATALIE MOORCROFT 2012-CA-001895-OA WARREN<br />
<strong>VS</strong>.<br />
CATHERINE RICE HOLDERFIELD<br />
12/10/12
Change language