Shane Moran - Alternation Journal
Shane Moran - Alternation Journal
Shane Moran - Alternation Journal
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
and comn~unities organising theinselves along democratic lines', are elusive in t<br />
work. He gives priority to the political and administrative, brilliantly portr<br />
ciistortion ol'custorn under colonialisvn and explaining its self-perpetuation, r<br />
looking towards the contrary tendencies of evolutionary social change and t<br />
o~le have been forced to endure more than 30 wars since 1970. All this adds up to the<br />
*rayal of a continental society in dreadful stagnation because of the lack of an<br />
onomic dynamic, a society in which pride ofplace is taken by the military, and where<br />
inar~ people have to turn to the rural areas and traditiolial authority for some shelter<br />
of tradition to thc demands of the city. The argument of Citizen ~rnd Subjiect<br />
con,pelling at olle level but inadequate at another because Mamdani fails to grap<br />
the ravages ofmodern society. But beyond this negative picture it is also important<br />
gister the effective challenges of civil society, the increasing participation of<br />
with the esserltial sociological fact that the process of the dissolution of traditio en in economic activities, the battle for survival and for property under these<br />
authority is inexorable and continues apace.<br />
Cornpared to the ebb and flux of politics-the ability to manoeuvre a<br />
ditiolls, the growth of a landless proletariat with weaker sentimental attachinent to<br />
land. Quantity can change fairly rapidly into quality as has been witnessed in<br />
perfor111 policy gy:ymnastics-tl~is trend seelns slow and unuseful. But without<br />
perspective we call be insensitive to the contrary trends to traditionalisln laten<br />
Lo-banisation, a growing youthful population, and the ~ainl'ul but progress1<br />
babwe where recently there has been the most extraordinary flowering of civil<br />
clety around the fulcru~n of the trade unions. These initiatives by Africans in Africa<br />
Mamdani's eclectic purview.<br />
e~nancipatio~i of women from rural patriarchy. There are also the contradict0 Finally, it is worth stressing that structures, states, and civil society have to rest<br />
tendcncies in pblic consciousness signalled by the crossing over to more 'mod certain econo~nic base, and this truth is not the exclusive property of a Marxist<br />
attitudes towards sexual identity, sexual abuse, land ownership by women, relig erspective. The relation between state and economy is central to the question of the<br />
freedom, and inter-racial marriage, etc. These trends indicate the tendencies SaPpl<br />
away the raw<br />
power of~nilitant traditionalism such as that of Inkatha. On<br />
its war mobilisation subsides-as eventually it has to since it is COmlnitte<br />
stabilisation of social relations on a capitalist basis-then the rational core of In<br />
e, and cannot be demoted as a regional obsession". Lines of analysis which pursue<br />
relationship between state and economy as the basis for an understanding of the<br />
racter of the state are suggestive of its future developtnent. The African state has to<br />
located within the processes of continental disintegration and reconstruction, and<br />
defo~~nation of tradition will be found to be absent and in its place a savage wtipat world markets. The most recent beginnings of an upturn in growth may presage<br />
leader against leader could result. The main proble~n Inkatha faces is the gro prospects for civil society. If Africa had the economic basis, then the real<br />
divorce between itself and its business supporters now that the ANC leadership aries ~narking off civil society from rural despotism, the opportunities for the<br />
wholeheartedly embraced the task of financial stability and lnonetary restraint,<br />
prioritised the building of a black capitalist class rather than redressillg of social nee<br />
Yet is the extent of the acco~nrnodation to the forccs of tradition that even a radi<br />
commentator withill the ANC defends a merger of the party of ~nodernising national<br />
with that of its most destructive traditionalist opponent (Crollin 1998). While<br />
i~~dicates the abiding power of decentralised despotism, it can also be read as indica<br />
the possibility that decentralised despotism is not an im~novable monolith but is rat<br />
in process, fluctuating violently between dissolution and a willed consolidation. S<br />
are the contradictions of conteniporary South Africa.<br />
In terms of the broader perspective required by a rejuvenated African Stu<br />
citizen L-indSl~D/ect is limited by a weak conception of the political economy of Afri<br />
e revival of civil society in war-tom regions, could shift apace. We need to<br />
mber that at the beginning of the various developinent decades in the 1950s, the<br />
pita income of ~riany African countries was similar to those of South East Asia,<br />
ofwho~n have doubled per capita incomes in a decade. What has been the critical<br />
r in Africa's political and econo~nic stagnation? The bifurcated state is a key<br />
ent in the mode of domination, but is it the essential factor in explaining the<br />
sse, or do we have to seek out the data of Africa's marginalisation in world<br />
ets, and combinations of state explanations and the economy?<br />
a lack of recognitioil that Africa is the Third World's Third World, a stagnant bat<br />
ofthe internatiol~al economy, a continent marginalised and brutally exploited in<br />
uld suggest that, despite Mamdani's powerful methodological synthesis, we need<br />
eturn to the eie~nents of political economy for a comprehensive analytic apparatus.<br />
In n2y ,\-ark on growth of social moven~cnts in lnanda (Hemson 1996) 1 argue that<br />
Peter Evans has used concepts such as 'embedded autonomy' to analyse thc burca~~cratic<br />
,,(>tcntial for democratic civic structures depends on tile quality and commitment to clia<br />
ation, combined with intense connection to the surrounding social str~~cture (particularly<br />
lcadcl-sllip. sucj1 a leadersllip callnot be guaranteed. but neither slio~~ld tile possibil' st rial capital), as a formative element of the state's ability to develop a modern economy.<br />
ijcmocracy tjlrl,Llsll co17-imunjty participation be cntil.cly excluded. l'll~ role of conciousnc redatory' states are located along with 'developniental' states within a continuum of tl~e<br />
o,.galiisation 1ll tlie contest ofpo\\ier, locally and nationally. is avital factor. l'lie vigor(>~ls c hievement of developnient. Sorne African states are specil?cally cliaracterisable as being<br />
till- ,x,LL.cr ill illis aplxnrs to have left an irilporlalll legacy of civic ciclllocracy w rolled by those who 'plunder without any more regard for the welfal-e oftlie citizenry than a<br />
tilt 11ationa1 ~novcmeilt appears in disarl-ay. ator has for the welfare of its prey' (Evans 1905:44).