“MONSTROUS AND ILLEGAL PROCEEDINGS”: LAW ...

“MONSTROUS AND ILLEGAL PROCEEDINGS”: LAW ... “MONSTROUS AND ILLEGAL PROCEEDINGS”: LAW ...

dataspace.princeton.edu
from dataspace.princeton.edu More from this publisher
28.06.2013 Views

government action to protect the town. The paper then printed new assaults on Thevenet, declaring him to be a “thief.” The article further noted that while Thevenet had brought “outrageous” [tremendo] charges “in the theater, the allegations against him by the entire population that detests him and only looks upon him with distain were even more outrageous.” The article further noted that Latorre’s government had, “in view of Sotto’s report” fully vindicated the JEA’s honor, “a word one cannot direct in the same way towards [Thevenet].” 58 Confronted again with a direct challenge to his honor, Thevenet brought charges against the paper and the JEA for libel. Berro, however, blocked the action and rejected Thevenet’s claims. 59 In effect, Berro proclaimed the matter of Thevenet’s reputation settled in the town. Further trials to protect his honor were no longer necessary. The verdict in essence reconfirmed the outcome of the local struggle over control of the JEA. The national government’s designated representative publicly declared the relative status of the competing groups in the town. In doing so, the verdict also reaffirmed the relationship between the increasingly dominant faction of local colorados in Salto and Latorre’s national government. Specifically, Berro’s verdicts preserved the rights of elites in the periphery to determine questions of personal reputation and with it the distribution of private law rights locally. In effect, the judge ratified the local outcome. Berro offered the national government’s support, including its ability to eliminate local dissent through the military, in exchange for recognition of its sovereign authority. In this way, the courts played an important role in blending locality and loyalty together to forge the compromises at the heart of emerging states in the borderlands. 























































 58 D. Emilio E. Thevenet c. D. Eulogio Arisaga por injurias, AGN-SJ. Salto. Letrados Civiles, n. 318 (1879). 59 Ibid. 354
 
 


By the dawn of the 1880s, national judges like Berro had established their place within the legal and political system in Salto. They heralded a shift in which national authorities became participants in the struggles to define the content of borderlands legalities. In the process, they also began to transform the borderlands legal order into one bound much more explicitly by national borders. Throughout the 1880s, the economic and political center of gravity in the Uruguayan interior shifted inexorably away from cross- border connections and towards Montevideo. The advent of cold storage further oriented the interior ranching economy towards the export of beef products to Europe instead of Brazil. Exports flowed out of stockyards in Montevideo and along the lower Uruguay. Immigrants streamed into Montevideo and its surrounding hinterlands. The Brazilian ranching community’s influence in Uruguay’s national politics correspondingly declined. These processes culminated in the final triumph of national authorities over rebellious blanco ranchers in the short-lived 1897 revolution led by Aparicio Saravia. Through it all, however, Salto’s courts remained a refuge for important aspects of borderland legalities. Notions of vecindad, personal reputation and local factional associations continued to define the town’s legal politics. In this sense, many of the elements of borderlands legalities that would have been familiar to litigants a half century earlier persisted. Even as states appeared to consolidate their hold on putative national territories through modern armies, administrative reforms, codes and a professional judiciary, these elements continued to be warped by the persistence of local legal politics. The courts remained active spaces where older peripheral legal norms could find room within emerging national sovereignties and continue to define the meaning of the law for Salto’s residents. Reputation and Leadership of the Liberal Party in Rio Grande do Sul 355
 
 


By the dawn of the 1880s, national judges like Berro had established their place<br />

within the legal and political system in Salto. They heralded a shift in which national<br />

authorities became participants in the struggles to define the content of borderlands<br />

legalities. In the process, they also began to transform the borderlands legal order into one<br />

bound much more explicitly by national borders. Throughout the 1880s, the economic and<br />

political center of gravity in the Uruguayan interior shifted inexorably away from cross-<br />

border connections and towards Montevideo. The advent of cold storage further oriented<br />

the interior ranching economy towards the export of beef products to Europe instead of<br />

Brazil. Exports flowed out of stockyards in Montevideo and along the lower Uruguay.<br />

Immigrants streamed into Montevideo and its surrounding hinterlands. The Brazilian<br />

ranching community’s influence in Uruguay’s national politics correspondingly declined.<br />

These processes culminated in the final triumph of national authorities over rebellious blanco<br />

ranchers in the short-lived 1897 revolution led by Aparicio Saravia.<br />

Through it all, however, Salto’s courts remained a refuge for important aspects of<br />

borderland legalities. Notions of vecindad, personal reputation and local factional associations<br />

continued to define the town’s legal politics. In this sense, many of the elements of<br />

borderlands legalities that would have been familiar to litigants a half century earlier<br />

persisted. Even as states appeared to consolidate their hold on putative national territories<br />

through modern armies, administrative reforms, codes and a professional judiciary, these<br />

elements continued to be warped by the persistence of local legal politics. The courts<br />

remained active spaces where older peripheral legal norms could find room within emerging<br />

national sovereignties and continue to define the meaning of the law for Salto’s residents.<br />

Reputation and Leadership of the Liberal Party in Rio Grande do Sul<br />

355
<br />


<br />

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!