“MONSTROUS AND ILLEGAL PROCEEDINGS”: LAW ...

“MONSTROUS AND ILLEGAL PROCEEDINGS”: LAW ... “MONSTROUS AND ILLEGAL PROCEEDINGS”: LAW ...

dataspace.princeton.edu
from dataspace.princeton.edu More from this publisher
28.06.2013 Views

ordered.” 211 Gándara complained that “there is no plausible reason for the delay.” Gándara’s alarm was well justified. With fraud allegations pending against him in front of a blanco judge, Bica appeared to be using his political connections with the juez de paz to flee. Gándara wrote to Real, stating that the juez de paz “had no interest in pursuing the Dispatch from this tribunal before [Bica’s] evasion to the neighboring province of Corrientes.” 212 During the month-long delay, Bica in fact had shifted most of his fungible assets across the border into Corrientes and out of the Salto court’s jurisdiction. Still determined, Gándara traveled to Paysandú. He requested that the judge there embargo Bica’s remaining goods to cover his commercial debts. In Paysandú, Gándara again pointed to Bica’s reputation. He noted that “the respondent does not have well-known roots here” and “his notorious bad faith makes it likely he will abscond with additional goods.” 213 In short, Bica was an outsider: the opposite of an honorable vecino. He could not be trusted to respect the court’s jurisdiction, his creditors’ rights or his commercial obligations. The court in Paysandú issued a contempt order against Bica. Back in Salto, Real issued a similar demand against Bica and the juez de paz. 214 By then, Bica had crossed into to Corrientes. Bica had escaped, but at the cost of much of his property in the Estado Oriental. Gándara seized possession on behalf of several creditors of Bica’s substantial landholdings. 215 Bica’s commercial operations in the Estado Oriental were crippled. This posed a problem not only for his personal economic situation, but also for that of his factional and familial allies in Alegrete. Recall again that the Ribeiros were engaged in a prolonged battle with Canabarro over political control of the Brazilian borderlands. Each 























































 211 Ibid., 6bis. 212 Ibid. 213 Ibid., 8-8bis. 214 Ibid., 10. 215 Ibid. 
 248
 


side sought to dictate the distribution of private law rights on both sides of the border. For the Ribeiros, the loss of an important political ally like Bica posed a substantial problem. They had failed to protect an important ally’s property in the Estado Oriental. Such a reversal threatened to undermine their political power and personal reputations back in Brazil. Much like Miguel Gelabert had suffered economically based on a perceived inability to obtain justice in Mercedes, the judicial defeat of a prominent ally in the Estado Oriental equally threatened the Ribeiros’ claims to be able to dispense justice and protect the legal rights of their factional allies. Once again, the shock waves from a single legal reversal could radiate across the borderlands and produce renewed conflicts in a variety of strategic locations. With his honor in question across the border in the Estado Oriental, Bica had to work to restore his own personal prestige in Corrientes. Bica settled in the correntino department of Monte Caseros. The department was situated in Corrientes’ southern and eastern borderlands along the west bank of the Uruguay River. Here, both Mitre and Urquiza were engaged throughout the 1850s in a struggle to influence the local departmental commanders in their ongoing conflicts with the distant provincial government in the city of Corrientes. Urquiza quickly moved to establish a relationship with the exiled Brazilian rancher. The two men entered into a commercial partnership in 1855. Bica agreed to supply Urquiza’s vast saladero with cattle from his correntino ranch. Urquiza’s commercial ties to the Brazilian rancher also provided a political ally in his own struggles to control the correntino borderlands. The two men began forging a reciprocal relationship that could be deployed in the province’s intensifying political conflicts. 216 























































 216 Macchi, Urquiza: el Saladerista, 31-32. 
 249
 


ordered.” 211 Gándara complained that “there is no plausible reason for the delay.”<br />

Gándara’s alarm was well justified. With fraud allegations pending against him in front of a<br />

blanco judge, Bica appeared to be using his political connections with the juez de paz to flee.<br />

Gándara wrote to Real, stating that the juez de paz “had no interest in pursuing the Dispatch<br />

from this tribunal before [Bica’s] evasion to the neighboring province of Corrientes.” 212<br />

During the month-long delay, Bica in fact had shifted most of his fungible assets<br />

across the border into Corrientes and out of the Salto court’s jurisdiction. Still determined,<br />

Gándara traveled to Paysandú. He requested that the judge there embargo Bica’s remaining<br />

goods to cover his commercial debts. In Paysandú, Gándara again pointed to Bica’s<br />

reputation. He noted that “the respondent does not have well-known roots here” and “his<br />

notorious bad faith makes it likely he will abscond with additional goods.” 213 In short, Bica<br />

was an outsider: the opposite of an honorable vecino. He could not be trusted to respect the<br />

court’s jurisdiction, his creditors’ rights or his commercial obligations. The court in<br />

Paysandú issued a contempt order against Bica. Back in Salto, Real issued a similar demand<br />

against Bica and the juez de paz. 214 By then, Bica had crossed into to Corrientes.<br />

Bica had escaped, but at the cost of much of his property in the Estado Oriental.<br />

Gándara seized possession on behalf of several creditors of Bica’s substantial<br />

landholdings. 215 Bica’s commercial operations in the Estado Oriental were crippled. This<br />

posed a problem not only for his personal economic situation, but also for that of his<br />

factional and familial allies in Alegrete. Recall again that the Ribeiros were engaged in a<br />

prolonged battle with Canabarro over political control of the Brazilian borderlands. Each<br />

























































<br />

211 Ibid., 6bis.<br />

212 Ibid.<br />

213 Ibid., 8-8bis.<br />

214 Ibid., 10.<br />

215 Ibid.<br />


 248
<br />

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!