21.06.2013 Views

Untitled - Get a Free Blog

Untitled - Get a Free Blog

Untitled - Get a Free Blog

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

Book Twelve<br />

narrative of book 13, cf. Von der Miihll, Hypomnema 206. The assaults of<br />

Asios, Hektor, and Sarpedon would naturally be launched simultaneously,<br />

and perhaps are to be so understood, but in the usual epic manner are<br />

narrated as if sequential.<br />

in For the suggestion that either fjvioxos or Oep&mov is a personal name<br />

here see 13.386^ It is unusual for the charioteer not to be named in these<br />

contexts.<br />

113-17 This foreshadowing of Asios' death reads like the setting up of<br />

an immediate narrative goal, like the prediction of Agamemnon's injury at<br />

1 i.igiff., but Asios does not in fact die in the assault on the wall, in whose<br />

defence Idomeneus plays no recorded part, in spite of the fact that his<br />

station was vr|cov sir' dpiorepd. The aristeia of Idomeneus marks the first<br />

stage of the Achaean counter-attack (13.36iff.), and Asios was his second<br />

victim (13.383-93)-<br />

113 vfjiTios (-ov, etc.) is highly formular (i8x //., 9X Od. as runover<br />

word in the first foot) and therefore probably a traditional way in which<br />

the narrator, in spite of his apparent objectivity, intruded a personal comment<br />

on his story, see Edwards, vol. v 5.<br />

115 = 8.499. "I^ l os is normally feminine in the epic. A neuter form "IAIOV<br />

arm) is attested only at 15.71 (see n.), where Aristarchus emended it away.<br />

fjVEUoeaaa is the regular epithet in this position (7X and HyAphr 280), cf.<br />

3-305".<br />

118-19 eTcraTO, 'charged', is aorist of (p)i6|iai, see 11.358 and n. Arn/A<br />

refer the form to sTui, as did the poet at least sometimes: the digamma<br />

is ignored at 13.90, 17.285. en' dpiorepd: the 'normal orientation when<br />

there is movement from one part of the battlefield to another' (Fenik, TBS<br />

41): see also 11.498 and 5-355n. The poet can say hrl 8e£i6q>iv TTCCVTOS<br />

OTpccToO (13.308), but that expression is not formular. Oddly, formulas for<br />

movement to the right are lacking. 'Left' usually means left from the<br />

Achaean viewpoint (so Cuillandre, La Droite et la gauche 99), and it was vncov<br />

ETT' dpiorepd where Asios was slain, cf. 13.674-6. But it remains odd that<br />

his opponents here are leaders of a Thessalian contingent, some of the<br />

Thessalians at least being brigaded on the Achaean right, see 11.5-9^ and<br />

introduction to this Book. Aristarchus (Arn/A) on the strength of this<br />

passage stationed the Lapithai next to Idomeneus, i.e. on the left. The<br />

matter is surprisingly difficult to resolve, cf. 13.68 m., and the attempt may<br />

be futile; the narrative as usual is focused on the foreground and works<br />

through a cast of characters rather than a strategic plan. — The poet seems<br />

to envisage some means of passing the ditch in front of the gate. Over it the<br />

Achaeans are streaming ovv iTrTroicriv KCCI oxeoxpi, and Asios, mounted,<br />

follows. Any ancient or medieval audience would recognize the situation<br />

330

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!