Surgery and Healing in the Developing World - Dartmouth-Hitchcock
Surgery and Healing in the Developing World - Dartmouth-Hitchcock Surgery and Healing in the Developing World - Dartmouth-Hitchcock
Metabolic Maladaptation 313 cell anemia, there is no adaptive advantage of the homozygous patterns of the disease no matter where its victim lives. Sickle cell anemia is a classic unmitigated disease with enough associated morbidity that it should have been naturally selected out of the population as distinctively disadvantageous. Genetic Predetermined Disease But two factors coincide to conserve this disease. First is the fact that it is not a classic Mendelian dominant characteristic; it requires sickle hemoglobin inheritance from both parents for the true sickle cell disease. The heterogyzote is not severely effected by disease, and is instead characterized as having “sickle cell trait”. This detectable abnormality confers a survival advantage on the person who bears it, given the second factor in the environment-—malaria. The often lethal falciparum malaria parasite cannot readily infest the red cells composed of sickle trait hybrid hemoglobin, so this heterozygous condition confers a relative resistance upon the carrier to malaria infestation. Sickle cell trait, therefore, is favored in tropical regions of high falciparum endemnicity, whereas people with the sickle cell anemia are susceptible to lethal anemia crises and people with normal hemoglobin are susceptible to a lethal form of malaria. The sickle hemoglobin is a disease conserved, therefore, because it confers adaptive advantage to coexistant falciparum malaria—-and the incidence of the two diseases can be drawn on coterminus maps. 49 Acquired Disease Two important distinctions are drawn in comparison with the “conserved diseases” of sickle cell hemoglobin and hypothyroidism that make them remarkably different. The hemoglobinopathies are familial and are inherited as genetic characteristics. In fact, the genetic mutation in the case of sickle hemoglobin has been defined down to a “point mutation” in a single base pair that gives rise to the synthesis of the abnormal sickle hemoglobin. Penetrance and expression of the sickle gene is high and sickle cell anemia “breeds true”, with little evidence of amelioration of the disease state by other biologic adaptations. Hemoglobin status is genetically determined, does not remarkably interfere with fertility and is congenital—-a term that will be used to mean literally that one is “born with” the condition. Genetic differences that can be passed on and environmental adaptive advantage are the two kinds of ingredients evolutionary biology can work with over time to select in, or out, those genetic predeterminants that are more, or less, adaptive. Hypothyroidism is acquired. Within an adult individual’s lifetime—or, indeed, within a short period of treatment—it can be abolished—and was, within a generation of iodized salt introduction in the West, and within the period of observation in this study. Earlier, and largely discredited, suggestions 50 held that there may have been “a genetical [sic] factor in endemic goiter”, but this has been disproven by several lines of evidence. First, hypothyroidism is a state of reduced fertility, with the more profound the hypothyroidism, the less able the individual to reproduce. Second, the disease is curable in the adult, and no transmission of the disorder then occurs in the offspring. But, is not cretinism congenital? Yes, in the sense that the term’s literal meaning is to be “born with” the disorder; but it is not genetic and familial. Cretinism is a disease acquired in utero, and such profound failure to develop may occur that cretinism may be irreversible at the time it is recognized and treated after birth. Even cretin women, if they are iodine repleted and should happen to become pregnant, 29
29 314 Surgery and Healing in the Developing World can be delivered of a neurologically, metabolically normal offspring, even if the treatment came too late in the mother’s life to reverse the mental retardation experienced in her own period of in utero development. An example which can be used to illustrate a nongenetic acquired abnormality in the adult that might also be present congenitally in a child is hypertrophy of the heart muscle, the myocardium. In sports medicine, athletes are seen who after a period of conditioning and training have developed myocardial hypertrophy in order to compensate for the increased demand of the work load of distance aerobic effort, such as marathon running. The same abnormality may be found in the newborn with a ventricular septal defect at birth, whose myocardium hypertrophies to accomodate the increased flow of shunted blood. In both instances of hypertrophy of the myocardium, and in the similar phenomenon of thyroid hypertrophy, some genetic traits may have rendered the individual more susceptible to the stress, but the abnormality is fundamentally an acquired one, and it can be eliminated from the somatotype by treatment without the genotype conveying this trait in the absence of similar stress. Without a genetically determined trait that would be transmissable through unimpaired fertility, evolutionary biology lacks the two levers of natural selective advantage under circumstances of environmental stress. Nutrient Environmental Stress One of the environmental stresses that has been common in nearly all parts of the world at one time or another has been caloric insufficiency. Famines have occurred from pole to equator under environmental circumstances from drought to glaciation. There is little suppportable claim that starvation induces hypothyroidism, but rather that those who have hypothyroidism are better adapted to reduced calorie intake. Iodine deficient environments have the highest incidence of hypothyroidism—-acquired, not inherited, in such a micronutrient milieu—and in such environments hypothyroid individuals could better withstand what would be for individuals with normal metabolism, macronutrient insufficiency. As with the endocrine manifestations of diabetes, that even in the adult acquired form has a genetic predisposition, there may be a genetic predilection for goiter or for cretinism in some instances. The fetus seems to preferentially sequester more than the maternal share of iodine-—and this is evidenced by the large goiter growth during pregnancy of some women under observation in this study who delivered babies who were marginally compensated, or at least not florid cretins. Cretinism was prevented by a shifting of the scarce iodine to the fetus at a cost of a more severe adult acquired goiter; this compensation may be genetically predetermined. This would reflect an acquired biologic adaptation to energy-resource-poor environments on the part of those individuals whose energy requirements were minimized by their depressed metabolic rates acquired by micronutrient iodine deficiency. Decreased fertility is a collective biologically acquired response that further decreases demand on caloric resources. Coincidence, merely by chance association, is an improbable explanation for the fact that hypothyroidism is found in highest incidence in the world’s calorie resource-poor regions. Coincidence is also a less satisfactory explanation that these regions of endemic hypothroidism have not developed as intensely into complex societies, taking into consideration the effect of this decrease in human energy utilization.
- Page 278 and 279: Reconstructive Surgery in the Tropi
- Page 280 and 281: Reconstructive Surgery in the Tropi
- Page 282 and 283: Reconstructive Surgery in the Tropi
- Page 284 and 285: Reconstructive Surgery in the Tropi
- Page 286 and 287: Reconstructive Surgery in the Tropi
- Page 288 and 289: Reconstructive Surgery in the Tropi
- Page 290 and 291: Reconstructive Surgery in the Tropi
- Page 292 and 293: CHAPTER 1 CHAPTER 27 Factors Influe
- Page 294 and 295: Distribution and Incidence of Tropi
- Page 296 and 297: Distribution and Incidence of Tropi
- Page 298 and 299: Distribution and Incidence of Tropi
- Page 300 and 301: CHAPTER 1 CHAPTER 28 Population Dyn
- Page 302 and 303: Population Dynamics Of Surgical Tro
- Page 304 and 305: Metabolic Maladaptation 289 Introdu
- Page 306 and 307: Metabolic Maladaptation 291 some of
- Page 308 and 309: Metabolic Maladaptation 293 In this
- Page 310 and 311: Metabolic Maladaptation Table 1. Si
- Page 312 and 313: Metabolic Maladaptation Table 4. Go
- Page 314 and 315: Metabolic Maladaptation 299 the rev
- Page 316 and 317: Metabolic Maladaptation Table 5. As
- Page 318 and 319: Metabolic Maladaptation Table 6. Co
- Page 320 and 321: Metabolic Maladaptation 305 the ris
- Page 322 and 323: Metabolic Maladaptation Table 8. Go
- Page 324 and 325: Metabolic Maladaptation Table 10. G
- Page 326 and 327: Metabolic Maladaptation Table 12. C
- Page 330 and 331: Metabolic Maladaptation 315 Biologi
- Page 332 and 333: Metabolic Maladaptation 317 from io
- Page 334 and 335: Metabolic Maladaptation 319 25. Lon
- Page 336 and 337: CHAPTER 1 CHAPTER 30 Nutrition and
- Page 338 and 339: Nutrition and Development in Africa
- Page 340 and 341: CHAPTER 1 CHAPTER 31 Uterine Ruptur
- Page 342 and 343: Uterine Ruptures in Rural Zaire Tab
- Page 344 and 345: Uterine Ruptures in Rural Zaire 329
- Page 346 and 347: CHAPTER 1 CHAPTER 32 Vesicovaginal
- Page 348 and 349: Vesicovaginal Fistula in Democratic
- Page 350 and 351: CHAPTER 1 CHAPTER 33 Ophthalmology
- Page 352 and 353: Ophthalmology Figure 2. Refractive
- Page 354 and 355: Ophthalmology Figure 4. A tonometer
- Page 356 and 357: Ophthalmology 341 ml of 40 mg/ml IV
- Page 358 and 359: Ophthalmology Figure 6. Axis determ
- Page 360 and 361: Ophthalmology 345 thalmic set prepa
- Page 362 and 363: Ophthalmology 347 Procedures Region
- Page 364 and 365: Accommodating Deficits in Material
- Page 366 and 367: Accommodating Deficits in Material
- Page 368 and 369: Accommodating Deficits in Material
- Page 370 and 371: Accommodating Deficits in Material
- Page 372 and 373: Accommodating Deficits in Material
- Page 374 and 375: Abscesses and Other Infections Trea
- Page 376 and 377: Abscesses and Other Infections Trea
Metabolic Maladaptation<br />
313<br />
cell anemia, <strong>the</strong>re is no adaptive advantage of <strong>the</strong> homozygous patterns of <strong>the</strong> disease<br />
no matter where its victim lives. Sickle cell anemia is a classic unmitigated<br />
disease with enough associated morbidity that it should have been naturally selected<br />
out of <strong>the</strong> population as dist<strong>in</strong>ctively disadvantageous.<br />
Genetic Predeterm<strong>in</strong>ed Disease<br />
But two factors co<strong>in</strong>cide to conserve this disease. First is <strong>the</strong> fact that it is not a<br />
classic Mendelian dom<strong>in</strong>ant characteristic; it requires sickle hemoglob<strong>in</strong> <strong>in</strong>heritance<br />
from both parents for <strong>the</strong> true sickle cell disease. The heterogyzote is not severely<br />
effected by disease, <strong>and</strong> is <strong>in</strong>stead characterized as hav<strong>in</strong>g “sickle cell trait”. This<br />
detectable abnormality confers a survival advantage on <strong>the</strong> person who bears it,<br />
given <strong>the</strong> second factor <strong>in</strong> <strong>the</strong> environment-—malaria. The often lethal falciparum<br />
malaria parasite cannot readily <strong>in</strong>fest <strong>the</strong> red cells composed of sickle trait hybrid<br />
hemoglob<strong>in</strong>, so this heterozygous condition confers a relative resistance upon <strong>the</strong><br />
carrier to malaria <strong>in</strong>festation. Sickle cell trait, <strong>the</strong>refore, is favored <strong>in</strong> tropical regions<br />
of high falciparum endemnicity, whereas people with <strong>the</strong> sickle cell anemia are susceptible<br />
to lethal anemia crises <strong>and</strong> people with normal hemoglob<strong>in</strong> are susceptible<br />
to a lethal form of malaria. The sickle hemoglob<strong>in</strong> is a disease conserved, <strong>the</strong>refore,<br />
because it confers adaptive advantage to coexistant falciparum malaria—-<strong>and</strong> <strong>the</strong><br />
<strong>in</strong>cidence of <strong>the</strong> two diseases can be drawn on coterm<strong>in</strong>us maps. 49<br />
Acquired Disease<br />
Two important dist<strong>in</strong>ctions are drawn <strong>in</strong> comparison with <strong>the</strong> “conserved diseases”<br />
of sickle cell hemoglob<strong>in</strong> <strong>and</strong> hypothyroidism that make <strong>the</strong>m remarkably<br />
different. The hemoglob<strong>in</strong>opathies are familial <strong>and</strong> are <strong>in</strong>herited as genetic characteristics.<br />
In fact, <strong>the</strong> genetic mutation <strong>in</strong> <strong>the</strong> case of sickle hemoglob<strong>in</strong> has been<br />
def<strong>in</strong>ed down to a “po<strong>in</strong>t mutation” <strong>in</strong> a s<strong>in</strong>gle base pair that gives rise to <strong>the</strong> syn<strong>the</strong>sis<br />
of <strong>the</strong> abnormal sickle hemoglob<strong>in</strong>. Penetrance <strong>and</strong> expression of <strong>the</strong> sickle gene<br />
is high <strong>and</strong> sickle cell anemia “breeds true”, with little evidence of amelioration of<br />
<strong>the</strong> disease state by o<strong>the</strong>r biologic adaptations. Hemoglob<strong>in</strong> status is genetically<br />
determ<strong>in</strong>ed, does not remarkably <strong>in</strong>terfere with fertility <strong>and</strong> is congenital—-a term<br />
that will be used to mean literally that one is “born with” <strong>the</strong> condition. Genetic<br />
differences that can be passed on <strong>and</strong> environmental adaptive advantage are <strong>the</strong> two<br />
k<strong>in</strong>ds of <strong>in</strong>gredients evolutionary biology can work with over time to select <strong>in</strong>, or<br />
out, those genetic predeterm<strong>in</strong>ants that are more, or less, adaptive.<br />
Hypothyroidism is acquired. With<strong>in</strong> an adult <strong>in</strong>dividual’s lifetime—or, <strong>in</strong>deed,<br />
with<strong>in</strong> a short period of treatment—it can be abolished—<strong>and</strong> was, with<strong>in</strong> a generation<br />
of iodized salt <strong>in</strong>troduction <strong>in</strong> <strong>the</strong> West, <strong>and</strong> with<strong>in</strong> <strong>the</strong> period of observation<br />
<strong>in</strong> this study. Earlier, <strong>and</strong> largely discredited, suggestions 50 held that <strong>the</strong>re may have<br />
been “a genetical [sic] factor <strong>in</strong> endemic goiter”, but this has been disproven by<br />
several l<strong>in</strong>es of evidence. First, hypothyroidism is a state of reduced fertility, with <strong>the</strong><br />
more profound <strong>the</strong> hypothyroidism, <strong>the</strong> less able <strong>the</strong> <strong>in</strong>dividual to reproduce. Second,<br />
<strong>the</strong> disease is curable <strong>in</strong> <strong>the</strong> adult, <strong>and</strong> no transmission of <strong>the</strong> disorder <strong>the</strong>n<br />
occurs <strong>in</strong> <strong>the</strong> offspr<strong>in</strong>g.<br />
But, is not cret<strong>in</strong>ism congenital? Yes, <strong>in</strong> <strong>the</strong> sense that <strong>the</strong> term’s literal mean<strong>in</strong>g<br />
is to be “born with” <strong>the</strong> disorder; but it is not genetic <strong>and</strong> familial. Cret<strong>in</strong>ism is a<br />
disease acquired <strong>in</strong> utero, <strong>and</strong> such profound failure to develop may occur that cret<strong>in</strong>ism<br />
may be irreversible at <strong>the</strong> time it is recognized <strong>and</strong> treated after birth. Even<br />
cret<strong>in</strong> women, if <strong>the</strong>y are iod<strong>in</strong>e repleted <strong>and</strong> should happen to become pregnant,<br />
29