21.06.2013 Views

Final Draft - Preview Matter - Florida State University

Final Draft - Preview Matter - Florida State University

Final Draft - Preview Matter - Florida State University

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

Phersipnai, but these heads are badly damaged, so a secure identification is not possible. 139 Of<br />

the two infernal creatures depicted below the funeral couch, only the identity of Kerberos is<br />

secure. The demon holding the oar wears the typical dress of Charu(n) and is bearded; on the<br />

other hand, an oar has replaced Charu(n)’s usual mallet, and snake-like tails spring from this<br />

figure’s waist. 140 This figure has been identified as Charu(n) but also Skylla. 141 This may indeed<br />

be an anguiped Charu(n) since the oar may refer to the journey one makes to the afterlife. Even<br />

so, the oar should not necessarily be taken as a direct reference to the Greek ferryman of the<br />

dead, Charon, since there is little similarity between Charon and Charu(n) and the dead may<br />

proceed to their final rest over both land and water. 142<br />

Due to the absence of Etruscan literature, we possess no narratives that feature Charu(n),<br />

nor are there dedications that indicate that he received cult. 143 Charu(n) is also rarely the sole<br />

subject of an art object, and is more generally a subsidiary figure, either added to known<br />

narratives such as the sacrifice of Trojan prisoners by Achilles or to generic scenes of the<br />

departure of the deceased to the underworld. Charu(n) is also often multiplied and may refer to a<br />

type of demon as opposed to an individual. 144 These factors result in a difficultly in defining<br />

Charu(n)’s “personality.” 145 The actions of this demon in art further confuse the issue, as<br />

sometimes he casually leans on his hammer as if to converse with other figures around him, 146 or<br />

he raises his hammer in a menacing fashion. These conflicting views are reflected in scholarship<br />

dealing with this demon. For example, E. Richardson states, “Sinister though he may look, his<br />

139 Proietti 1986, 237.<br />

140 Matheson (2004, 350) discusses the possibility of Typhon having two serpent tails for legs as well.<br />

141 Mavleev and Krauskopf (1984, 234) include the Tomb of the Reliefs in the LIMC entry on Charu(n) and list the<br />

anguiped figure as Charu(n)-Skylla. Blanck (1986, 18-9) and De Ruyt (1934, 135) refer to this figure as an<br />

anguiped, masculine Skylla.<br />

142 De Ruyt (1934, 229-30) links Charu(n) and Charon linguistically, but notes that this is where the resemblance<br />

ends. A ferryman appears in the Tomb of the Blue Demons, but he does not possess the same iconographic<br />

attributes as Charu(n). Krauskopf (2006, 67-9) notes the variations in which the dead reach the afterlife as well as<br />

the importance of the journey in and of itself.<br />

143 Richardson 1976, 243.<br />

144 Jannot 1997, 141. Charu(n)’s reduplication may be similar to the presence of Faunus and many fauni; the<br />

possibility of a group of demons sharing the same name does not rule out the presence of an individual personality<br />

amongst them. When comparing Charu(n) and Typhon, one may note a further problem with identifying the<br />

anguiped figures in the Tomb of the Typhon as multiple “Typhons.” In Greek myth, Typhon is always a single<br />

figure and is not part of a larger group such as the Giants. In Etruscan art, the appearance of several demons that all<br />

bear the label Charu(n) on the same monument indicates a different conception of identity.<br />

145 For Charu(n) as individual or multiplicity see De Grummond 2006a, 214.<br />

146 The appearance of a “conversational” Charu(n), which may be seen in Beazley 1947, Pl. XXXI.2, may be similar<br />

to the euphemistic taming of hostile spirits through wordplay such as calling the Furies the Eumenides.<br />

34

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!