CITY SANITATION PLAN - Ministry of Urban Development
CITY SANITATION PLAN - Ministry of Urban Development
CITY SANITATION PLAN - Ministry of Urban Development
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
BAREILLY<br />
DRAFT <strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong><br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT<br />
PREFACE<br />
ABSTRACT<br />
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS<br />
LIST OF FIGURES/ CHARTS/ GRAPHS<br />
LIST OF TABLES<br />
CHAPTER 01<br />
INTRODUCTION<br />
1.1 CONTEXT<br />
1.2 <strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> RANKING<br />
1.3 EXPECTED OUTPUTS<br />
1.4 NUSP AND STATE <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong><br />
1.5 CSP PURPOSE AND OBJECTIVES<br />
1.6 CSP APPROACH, SCOPE AND LIMITATIONS<br />
1.7 CSP METHODOLOGY<br />
1.8 CSP COMMUNICATION NEEDS ASSESSMENT<br />
CHAPTER 02<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> PROFILE<br />
2.1 TOPOGRAPHY, CLIMATE & DEMOGRAPHY<br />
2.2 ECONOMY<br />
2.3 URBAN POVERTY & SLUMS<br />
2.4 GOVERNANCE & INSTITUTIONAL ARRANGMENTS<br />
CHAPTER 03<br />
SITUATIONAL ANALYSIS OF <strong>SANITATION</strong> IN THE <strong>CITY</strong><br />
3.1 SERVICE PROFILE OF THE <strong>CITY</strong><br />
3.1.A WATER SUPPLY<br />
3.1.B SEWERAGE<br />
3.1.C STORM WATER DRAINAGE<br />
3.1.D SOLID WASTE<br />
3.2 ASSESSMENT OF <strong>SANITATION</strong> FACILITIES AND SITUATION IN POTENTIAL AREAS<br />
3.2.A <strong>SANITATION</strong> FACILITIES AND SITUATION AT HOUSEHOLD LEVEL<br />
3.2.B <strong>SANITATION</strong> FACILITIES AND SITUATION IN SLUM AREAS (COMMUNITY TOILETS)<br />
3.2.C <strong>SANITATION</strong> FACILITIES AND SITUATION IN PUBLIC AREAS (PUBLIC TOILETS)<br />
3.2.D <strong>SANITATION</strong> FACILITIES AND SITUATION IN INSTITUTIONAL AREAS<br />
3.2.E <strong>SANITATION</strong> FACILITIES AND SITUATION AT HOSPITALS<br />
3.2.F <strong>SANITATION</strong> FACILITIES AND SITUATION AT SCHOOLS<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 2
3.2.G <strong>SANITATION</strong> FACILITIES AND SITUATION AT COMMERCIAL/ MARKET PLACES<br />
3.2.H <strong>SANITATION</strong> AND SITUATION AT INDUSTRIAL AREAS<br />
3.2.I SITUATIONAL ANALYSIS OF WATER BODIES<br />
3.3 COST RECOVERY AND USER CHARGES<br />
3.4 IEC AND AWARENESS ISSUES<br />
CHAPTER 04<br />
4.1 INFERENCES/ GAPS IDENTIFICATION AND REQUIREMENTS<br />
4.2 IEC AND AWARENESS- MESSAGES & CHANNELS<br />
CHAPTER 05<br />
KEY POTENTIAL ISSUES<br />
5.1 IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS OF KEY POTENTIAL ISSUES USING MATRIX METHOD<br />
5.2 PRIORITIZING THE IDENTIFIED POTENTIAL ISSUES USING MATRIX METHOD<br />
5.3 SOLUTIONS TO KEY POTENTIAL ISSUES USING MATRIX METHOD<br />
CHAPTER 06<br />
PROPOSALS/ RECOMMENDATIONS<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
6.1 SWOT ANALYSIS<br />
6.2 VISION<br />
6.3 <strong>SANITATION</strong> OPTIONS<br />
6.3.1 TECHNOLOGICAL OPTIONS<br />
6.3.2 FINANCING OPTIONS<br />
6.3.3 COMPARATIVE ASSESSMENT OF OPTIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS OF MOST APPROPRIATE OPTIONS<br />
6.3.4 INSTITUTIONAL ARRANGEMENTS<br />
6.3.5 IMPLEMENTATION ARRANGEMENTS<br />
6.3.6 LINKAGE WITH STATE <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong><br />
6.3.7 IEC AND COMMUNITY ACTION <strong>PLAN</strong><br />
6.3.8 MONITORING AND EVALUATION<br />
ROAD MAP<br />
REFERENCES<br />
APPENDIX<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 3
1.1 CONTEXT<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
CHAPTER 01<br />
INTRODUCTION<br />
The population <strong>of</strong> India is 1027 million with approximately 28% or 285 million living in urban centers and<br />
it is expected that the share <strong>of</strong> urban population will increase to about 40% <strong>of</strong> total population by the<br />
year 2021. This is in sharp contrast to only 60 million (15 percent) who lived in urban areas in 1947 when<br />
the country became independent. During the last fifty years the population <strong>of</strong> the country has grown<br />
two and half times, while the urban India has grown by nearly five times. The positive role <strong>of</strong><br />
urbanization has <strong>of</strong>ten been over-shadowed by the deterioration in the physical environment and<br />
quality <strong>of</strong> life in the urban areas caused by widening gap between demand and supply <strong>of</strong> essential<br />
services and infrastructure. It is further associated with many problems, such as high levels <strong>of</strong> poverty,<br />
environmental stress, risks to productivity, high health costs, and lack <strong>of</strong> access to basic services, such as<br />
water supply, sanitation, and housing. The insufficient availability <strong>of</strong> services, inadequate awareness and<br />
also poor operation and maintenance has also given rise to poor sanitation conditions. Hence, therefore,<br />
proper allocation <strong>of</strong> resources both in terms <strong>of</strong> human and monetary will improve the sanitary<br />
conditions and also awareness among people – in turn improve the hygienic conditions <strong>of</strong> the city.<br />
Since the level <strong>of</strong> investments and participation required for this sector i.e. on water supply, sanitation<br />
and solid waste management is <strong>of</strong> very high order, it is felt that the national level initiatives are required<br />
that would bring the Central, State and Local governments and on the other side Non-government<br />
organizations and public participation are also required together to ensure proper flow <strong>of</strong> necessary<br />
funds to bring about any kind <strong>of</strong> developments and improvements in these sectors to an acceptable<br />
levels in tune with the international standards. The government should also recognize the urban issues<br />
which require integrated approaches that specifically target the urban poor and slum areas, promote<br />
sanitation and sewerage services at basic household levels to community levels and develop the city as a<br />
living eco-sanitation and foster the involvement <strong>of</strong> private sectors and also the civil societies.<br />
According to the survey organized by MoUD, Bareilly is ranking #187 out <strong>of</strong> 436 cities in India<br />
considering different indicators. Bareilly has only scored 36.1/100 in these different considered<br />
indicators.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 4
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
Considering Bareilly, this city and its development activities are the prime drivers <strong>of</strong> sanitation and<br />
sewerage problems and also problems in solid and liquid waste management and in other key potential<br />
areas such as slaughter houses, hospitals, public places, institutions, industries and schools, the Vision<br />
provides incentives or development strategies at every possible potential areas at local level, and also<br />
incentives that can be undertaken at institutional, structural and fiscal reform levels that are necessary<br />
for improved and sustainable service delivery systems – addressing all sectors/ groups <strong>of</strong> population and<br />
also enhance the operation and maintenance <strong>of</strong> these services. The incentives also include IEC strategies<br />
and action plans to bring awareness and improve the public participation in well-utilization <strong>of</strong> available<br />
sanitation and sewerage services. Thus, in order to propose any strategies/ proposals for the<br />
improvements <strong>of</strong> the city’s sanitation and sewerage conditions and reduce the potential problems <strong>of</strong> the<br />
city, it is very important to make a situational analysis <strong>of</strong> the current conditions. The following section<br />
provides the city overview <strong>of</strong> Bareilly giving primary introduction to study area.<br />
1.2 CSP <strong>SANITATION</strong> RANKING<br />
The MoUD, GoI, proposal to commission agencies, appointed on the basis <strong>of</strong> competitive bidding<br />
amongst short-listed ones, to carry out sanitation rating exercises for the 436 Class-I cities <strong>of</strong> India. In<br />
order to ensure that bidders bid for providing standard outputs and these are administered uniformly<br />
across cities to enable comparison, it was necessary to lay out a methodology (see Annexure 01) that<br />
followed a standard set <strong>of</strong> steps, fixes the protocol for data collection and analysis, and uses a consistent<br />
analysis and evaluation scheme leading to valid and comparable results. This note details the<br />
methodology that will form a part <strong>of</strong> the Request for Proposals (RFP) from short-listed agencies. This will<br />
become the basic framework that will guide the agencies’ rating exercises, and sets out the standard<br />
tasks to be accomplished as a part <strong>of</strong> the rating exercise.<br />
Three Categories <strong>of</strong> Indicators<br />
The rating exercise will involve three categories <strong>of</strong> indicators:<br />
1. Output Indicators: pertain to the city having achieved certain results or outputs in different<br />
dimensions <strong>of</strong> sanitation ranging from behavioral aspects and provision, to safe collection,<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 5
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
treatment and disposal without harm to the city’s environment. There are nine main output-<br />
indicators accounting for 50 points <strong>of</strong> the total <strong>of</strong> 100 points.<br />
2. Process Related: indicators pertain to systems and procedures that exist and are practiced by<br />
the city agencies to ensure sustained sanitation. There are seven main process-indicators<br />
accounting for 30 points <strong>of</strong> the total <strong>of</strong> 100 points.<br />
3. Outcome Related: indicators include the quality <strong>of</strong> drinking water and that <strong>of</strong> water in water-<br />
bodies <strong>of</strong> city, as also the extent <strong>of</strong> reduction in sanitation-related and water-borne diseases in<br />
the city over a time period. There are three main outcome-indicators accounting for 20 points <strong>of</strong><br />
a total <strong>of</strong> 100 points (The weights for output, process and outcome indicators are valid for this<br />
round <strong>of</strong> rating. In later years, with improvements in the situation <strong>of</strong> cities and better availability<br />
<strong>of</strong> data, greater importance and hence, weights will be accorded to outcome indicators).<br />
Ideally, data for the above outputs, processes and outcomes are regularly collected by city authorities<br />
but at present, very few cities will have, at best, partial data available. This rating exercise will help in<br />
highlighting the need for regular data-collection and monitoring <strong>of</strong> indicators.<br />
Based on CSP ranking methodology (see Annexure 01) which is applied to the current study city i.e.<br />
Bareilly, following indicators at different levels and giving marks to each indicator resulted in overall<br />
marks for Bareilly city as 36.01/ 100, which states the rank is # 188 for Bareilly city out <strong>of</strong> 423 cities in<br />
India (see Annexure 02). The following chart shows the total points and secured points for the Bareilly<br />
city for different indicators.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 6
1A_i<br />
1A_ii<br />
City Sanitation Rating Project<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> SCORE SHEET<br />
City Name Bareilly (M Corp)<br />
State Name UTTAR PRADESH<br />
City category Other Class 1<br />
Total score for the city (with color code) 36.101<br />
Population (as per 2001Census) 720315<br />
Population (as per projection) 828362<br />
1.Total Of Output Related Indicators 16.6<br />
2. Total Of Process Related Indicators 11.6<br />
3. Total Of Outcome Related Indicators 8.0<br />
1. OUTPUT RELATED INDICATORS<br />
DETAILS:<br />
Access and use <strong>of</strong> toilets by urban poor<br />
and other un-served households<br />
(including slums) by individual and<br />
community sanitation facilities<br />
Estimated population <strong>of</strong> the sample<br />
slums practicing open defecation<br />
Access and use <strong>of</strong> toilets for floating and<br />
institutional populations - adequate<br />
public sanitation facilities<br />
Proportion <strong>of</strong> Functional and working<br />
Toilets to number <strong>of</strong> field visit points<br />
No. <strong>of</strong> instance <strong>of</strong> urination/ open<br />
defecation<br />
1A_iii No open defecation visible<br />
Proportion <strong>of</strong> field visits where OD was<br />
visible to the total field visit points<br />
Max<br />
Marks<br />
Max<br />
Marks -<br />
4<br />
Marks<br />
Obtained<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
Deduction<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 7<br />
4.0<br />
Max<br />
Marks -<br />
4<br />
0.5<br />
1<br />
Max<br />
Marks -<br />
4<br />
0.3<br />
Instances <strong>of</strong> "OD" on railway track 21<br />
Max<br />
1A_iv Manual Scavenging eliminated in City Marks -<br />
4<br />
Whether Manual scavenging being<br />
practiced in ULB<br />
No<br />
Proportion <strong>of</strong> total properties with safe Max<br />
1B collection arrangements for human Marks -<br />
excreta<br />
6<br />
Marks<br />
Awarded<br />
3.0 3.0<br />
2.1 0.5 1.6<br />
4.0 2.5 1.5<br />
4.0 0.0 4.0<br />
4.0 1.5 2.5
1C<br />
1E<br />
1F<br />
1G<br />
1H<br />
Percentage <strong>of</strong> properties having safe<br />
collection arrangements <strong>of</strong> human<br />
excreta<br />
Total instances <strong>of</strong> breakage, ex-filtration<br />
or overflow <strong>of</strong> fecal matter observed<br />
Proportion <strong>of</strong> total black waste water<br />
generation that is treated and safely<br />
disposed <strong>of</strong>f<br />
Percentage <strong>of</strong> black wastewater treated<br />
and safely disposed <strong>of</strong>f after Secondary<br />
treatment<br />
Total no. <strong>of</strong> instance <strong>of</strong> unsafe disposal<br />
or dumping <strong>of</strong> black-water into water<br />
courses, water bodies, or open areas<br />
Proportion <strong>of</strong> treated wastewater that is<br />
recycled and reused for non potable<br />
applications<br />
Percentage <strong>of</strong> treated wastewater<br />
recycled and re-used (after Secondary<br />
treatment)<br />
Proportion <strong>of</strong> total storm-water and<br />
drainage that is efficiently and safely<br />
managed (3 points for 100%)<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 8<br />
85.8<br />
3.0<br />
Max<br />
Marks -<br />
9<br />
0.0<br />
3.0<br />
Max<br />
Marks -<br />
3<br />
0.0<br />
Max<br />
Marks -<br />
3<br />
Percentage Storm water Coverage 100.0<br />
Percentage <strong>of</strong> drain-overflow and<br />
breakage are found in more than 50% <strong>of</strong> 0.0<br />
observation points<br />
Whether more than 50% <strong>of</strong> the road<br />
network observed/reported to be prone<br />
to recurrent flooding/water logging<br />
Proportion <strong>of</strong> total solid waste<br />
generation that is regularly collected<br />
Percentage <strong>of</strong> total solid waste<br />
generated that is regularly collected<br />
Instances <strong>of</strong> solid waste observed to be<br />
visibly littered in the city<br />
Proportion <strong>of</strong> total solid waste<br />
generation that is treated and safely<br />
disposed <strong>of</strong>f<br />
Percentage <strong>of</strong> total solid waste<br />
generation that is treated and safely<br />
No<br />
Max<br />
Marks -<br />
4<br />
91.0<br />
8.0<br />
Max<br />
Marks -<br />
4<br />
0.0<br />
0.0 1.5 0.0<br />
0.0 0.0<br />
3.0 0.0 3.0<br />
3.0 2.0 1.0<br />
0.0 0.0
1I<br />
2A<br />
2B<br />
disposed <strong>of</strong>f<br />
City wastes cause no adverse impacts on<br />
surrounding areas outside city limits<br />
No. <strong>of</strong> locations where land or water<br />
body outside the city receiving any<br />
untreated human excreta or untreated<br />
solid waste (including leachate)<br />
Instances <strong>of</strong> untreated grey water<br />
(water flowing in the drains)<br />
2. PROCESS RELATED INDICATORS<br />
M&E systems are in place to track<br />
incidences <strong>of</strong> open defecation<br />
Does the ULB have a mechanism in place<br />
to monitor incidents <strong>of</strong> Open<br />
Defecation? (Y/N)<br />
If yes, is data <strong>of</strong> OD incidents collected<br />
on a monthly basis? (Y/N)<br />
Is such data reported on a regular basis<br />
(monthly) in public forums? (Y/N)<br />
Are awards/ incentives given to<br />
discourage Open Defecation? (Y/N)<br />
All sewerage systems in the city are<br />
working properly and there is no ex-<br />
filtration<br />
Has the ULB provided gear and safety<br />
equipment to the sanitary<br />
workers?(Y/N)<br />
Whether Mechanical systems are being<br />
used for monitoring and<br />
cleaning/maintenance <strong>of</strong> sewers (Y/N)<br />
Max<br />
Marks -<br />
5<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
5.0 5.0 0.0<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 9<br />
3.0<br />
0.0<br />
Max<br />
Marks<br />
Max<br />
Marks -<br />
4<br />
NO<br />
NO<br />
NO<br />
NO<br />
Max<br />
Marks -<br />
5<br />
YES<br />
YES<br />
Are workers provided Insurance/<br />
YES<br />
Provident Fund/ Gratuity? (Y/N)<br />
Does the ULB have a complaint redressal<br />
system for sewerage related<br />
YES<br />
complaints?(Y/N)<br />
Cost Recovery for Sewerage Services 0.0<br />
Marks<br />
Obtained<br />
Deduction<br />
Marks<br />
Awarded<br />
0.0 0.0<br />
4.0 5.0
2C<br />
2D<br />
2E<br />
Septage / sludge is regularly cleaned,<br />
safely transported and disposed after<br />
treatment, from on-site systems in the<br />
city<br />
Has the ULB provided safety gear and<br />
equipment to the sanitary<br />
workers?(Y/N)<br />
Whether the mechanical system is in<br />
place for cleaning <strong>of</strong> Tanks and Pits (Y/N)<br />
Whether the cleaning and disposal <strong>of</strong><br />
sludge from tanks and pits are<br />
monitored (Y/N)<br />
whether there is functioning grievance<br />
redressal mechanism for Septage<br />
related complaints?(Y/N)<br />
Are workers provided Insurance/<br />
Provident Fund/ Gratuity? (Y/N)<br />
Storm water drainage systems<br />
functioning and maintained<br />
Is there centralized database/map <strong>of</strong><br />
drainage system available (Y/N)<br />
Is cleaning, repairs and maintenance <strong>of</strong><br />
drains undertaken pre-monsoon (Y/N)<br />
Is cleaning, repairs and maintenance <strong>of</strong><br />
drains undertaken at one other season<br />
than pre-monsoon (Y/N)<br />
Solid waste management (collection and<br />
treatment) systems are efficient<br />
ULB has either framed their own rules or<br />
formally adopted MSW 2000 rules for<br />
SW Collection and Treatment (Y/N)<br />
Percentage <strong>of</strong> households and<br />
establishments covered by daily door-todoor<br />
solid waste collection system<br />
Proportion <strong>of</strong> the city’s streets<br />
effectively covered by regular streetsweeping<br />
(at least once a day)<br />
Proportion <strong>of</strong> waste that is processed or<br />
recycled (in a waste recycling facility<br />
operated by ULB/agents)<br />
Max<br />
Marks -<br />
10<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
0.0 0.0<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 10<br />
NO<br />
NO<br />
NO<br />
NO<br />
NO<br />
Max<br />
Marks -<br />
4<br />
NO<br />
YES<br />
YES<br />
Max<br />
Marks -<br />
5<br />
YES<br />
100.0<br />
0.1<br />
0.0<br />
2.0 2.0<br />
2.1 2.1
2F<br />
2G<br />
Percentage <strong>of</strong> Cost Recovery for SWM<br />
Services<br />
Documented operational system and<br />
clear institutional responsibility assigned<br />
for the services<br />
Whether written manual and<br />
procedures existing in practice for<br />
Sewerage<br />
Whether written manual and<br />
procedures existing in practice for<br />
Septage<br />
Whether written manual and<br />
procedures existing in practice for Storm<br />
water drainage<br />
Whether written manual and<br />
procedures existing in practice for Solid<br />
waste management<br />
Sanctions for deviance on part <strong>of</strong><br />
polluters and institutions is clearly laid<br />
out and followed in practice<br />
State/ULB Act explicitly provides for<br />
punishing/fining <strong>of</strong>fenders a)Letting out<br />
untreated human excreta in the open<br />
(Y/N)<br />
State/ULB Act explicitly provides for<br />
punishing/fining <strong>of</strong>fenders Littering<br />
Rules and regulations are framed and<br />
being implemented in practice for a)<br />
Letting out untreated human excreta in<br />
the open(Y/N)<br />
Rules and regulations are framed and<br />
being implemented in practice b)<br />
Littering<br />
There are instances <strong>of</strong> fining or<br />
punishing people in the last one year for<br />
following (Y/N)<br />
Letting out untreated human excreta in<br />
the open (number <strong>of</strong> instances)<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 11<br />
0.0<br />
Max<br />
Marks -<br />
4<br />
NO<br />
NO<br />
NO<br />
NO<br />
Max<br />
Marks -<br />
3<br />
YES<br />
YES<br />
YES<br />
YES<br />
NO<br />
Littering (number <strong>of</strong> instances) YES<br />
Whether monitoring system exists to<br />
point out polluters (Y/N)<br />
YES<br />
Whether reports produced (Y/N) YES<br />
0.0 0.0<br />
2.5 2.5
3. OUTCOME RELATED INDICATORS<br />
Max<br />
Marks<br />
Max<br />
3A Quality <strong>of</strong> drinking water<br />
Marks -<br />
7<br />
Number <strong>of</strong> samples passing quality tests 17.0<br />
3B<br />
Water Quality in water bodies in and<br />
around city<br />
Max<br />
Marks -<br />
7<br />
Number <strong>of</strong> samples passing quality tests 0.0<br />
3C<br />
Reduction in water Bourne disease<br />
incidence amongst city population<br />
Max<br />
Marks -<br />
6<br />
Percentage reduction in diarrheal<br />
disease over last 3 years<br />
28.8<br />
Marks<br />
Obtained<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
Deduction<br />
Marks<br />
Awarded<br />
6.0 6.0<br />
0.0 0.0<br />
2.0 2.0<br />
Thus, one <strong>of</strong> the main objective <strong>of</strong> the City Sanitation Plan is to increase the points <strong>of</strong> Bareilly in these<br />
different indicators, which is only possible after detailed understanding and analysis <strong>of</strong> the existing<br />
situation and ground realities. Based on the situational analysis, key potential issues and gaps are<br />
identified and then recommendations are made which are economically feasible and ecologically<br />
sustainable.<br />
1.3 EXPECTED OUTCOMES<br />
The expected outcomes <strong>of</strong> Bareilly City Sanitation Plan are as follows:<br />
Brings out the Bareilly City Sanitation Situational Analysis<br />
Highlights the major sanitation gaps and recommendations to overcome them in a acceptable<br />
timeframe<br />
Roll out the ‘Sanitation Vision and Goals’ for Bareilly City to become ODF city by 2015.<br />
IEC & Awareness action plan with indicative budget<br />
Suggest low cost and high impact initiatives before the DPRs are prepared /funding approved by<br />
central/state governments<br />
Suggest convergence <strong>of</strong> institutions and people participation in city sanitation<br />
Suggest institutional & regulatory framework to improve and sustain the sanitary services<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 12
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
The following section provides the background information on goals, objectives and approach <strong>of</strong><br />
National <strong>Urban</strong> Sanitation Policy which is the prime basis for this study i.e. improving the sanitary<br />
conditions <strong>of</strong> the city.<br />
1.4 NUSP AND STATE <strong>SANITATION</strong> STRATEGIES<br />
The National <strong>Urban</strong> sanitation Policy launched during 2008 envisages “All Indian cities and towns<br />
become totally sanitized, healthy and livable and ensure and sustain good public health and<br />
environmental outcomes for all their citizens with a special focus on hygienic and affordable sanitation<br />
facilities for the urban poor and women.”<br />
1.5 CSP PURPOSE AND OBJECTIVES<br />
The overall goal <strong>of</strong> National policy is to transform <strong>Urban</strong> India into community-driven, totally sanitized,<br />
healthy and livable cities and towns. Specific goals include:<br />
A. Awareness Generation and Behavior Change,<br />
B. Open Defecation Free Cities,<br />
C. Integrated City-Wide Sanitation,<br />
D. Sanitary and Safe Disposal, and<br />
E. Proper Operation & Maintenance <strong>of</strong> all Sanitary Installations.<br />
The City Sanitation Plan (CSP) is aimed at developing and maintaining a clean, safe and pleasant physical<br />
environment in Bareilly city to promote social, economic and physical well-being <strong>of</strong> all sections <strong>of</strong> the<br />
population. It encompasses plan <strong>of</strong> action for achieving 100% sanitation in the city <strong>of</strong> Bareilly through<br />
demand generation and awareness campaign, sustainable technology selection, construction and<br />
maintenance <strong>of</strong> sanitary infrastructure, provision <strong>of</strong> services, O&M issues, institutional roles and<br />
responsibilities, public education, community and individual action, regulation and legislation.<br />
The principal components <strong>of</strong> city-wide approach include:<br />
(a) Collection and sanitary disposal <strong>of</strong> wastes, including solid wastes, liquid wastes, excreta, industrial<br />
wastes, clinical and other hazardous wastes;<br />
(b) Storm water drainage;<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 13
(c) Cleansing <strong>of</strong> thoroughfares, markets and other public spaces;<br />
(d) Environmental sanitation education;<br />
(e) Inspection and enforcement <strong>of</strong> sanitary regulations;<br />
(f) Monitoring the observance <strong>of</strong> environmental standards.<br />
1.6 CSP APPROACH, SCOPE AND LIMITATIONS<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
The process detailed below for planning urban sanitation and wastewater management improvements<br />
<strong>of</strong>fers a step-by-step guide for:<br />
1<br />
2<br />
3<br />
4<br />
6<br />
7<br />
8<br />
9<br />
5<br />
10<br />
Preparatory<br />
Steps<br />
Constituting: CSTF<br />
Stakeholder Analysis<br />
Sensitisation / Orientation Workshop<br />
Pr<strong>of</strong>iling ULB<br />
Core Team – Technical<br />
Core Team - IEC<br />
Initiating IEC Activities<br />
Situation Analysis and Mapping Current Status<br />
Problem Analysis and Assessment <strong>of</strong> Options<br />
Developing and Consolidating CSP<br />
Formulation <strong>of</strong> Action Plans<br />
Finalization <strong>of</strong> CSP at Stakeholder Workshop<br />
Data gaps<br />
Quality<br />
Surveys<br />
Transect walks<br />
Planning for:<br />
Solutions<br />
FGDs<br />
Selecting options<br />
New facilities<br />
Behavior change<br />
Monitoring and<br />
Evaluation<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 14
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
Pr<strong>of</strong>iling ULB: As a preparatory work, a preliminary pr<strong>of</strong>iling <strong>of</strong> ULBs using SLB indicators and City<br />
Ratings to highlight the ODF status, sanitation situation, health indicators and current projects was<br />
undertaken from secondary data sources.<br />
Stakeholder Analysis: <strong>Urban</strong> Local Bodies (ULBs) are in the frontline <strong>of</strong> implementation and have a key<br />
role in ensuring sanitation and should focus on demand responsive approach. Plan formulation through<br />
stakeholder consultation will provide the foundation for CSP which has government endorsement as<br />
well as an informed civil society to monitor its implementation. To play their part, as per the<br />
requirements <strong>of</strong> CSP, institutions, organizations, individuals, NGOs, academics, journals, local<br />
councilors, industry owners, consultants, representatives <strong>of</strong> private sector and etc are identified in<br />
Nalgonda and analyzed the strengths and competencies required for sanitation.<br />
Sensitisation / Orientation Workshop: With this background knowledge, a City level orientation<br />
workshop involving CSTF and identified stakeholders had been organised at Bareilly on 15 December<br />
2010 to highlight the need to engage with issues relating to toilets access and arrangement especially in<br />
slums; awareness generation for changed behaviour and practices; community participation and<br />
mobilization to accord sanitation priority at all levels from policy to action on ground; and a number <strong>of</strong><br />
technical, institutional and financial issues to be addressed in CSP and its various steps <strong>of</strong> preparation.<br />
Constituting City Sanitation Task Force (ref annexure) : CSTF has been constituted headed by Mayor<br />
<strong>of</strong> Bareilly city to mobilize Stakeholders to elevate the consciousness about sanitation in the mind <strong>of</strong><br />
municipal agencies, government agencies and amongst the people <strong>of</strong> the city. CSTF will organize a multi-<br />
stakeholder, multi-party meeting in the preparatory stage, and take a formal resolution to make the city<br />
100% sanitized.<br />
Initiating IEC activities: The objective <strong>of</strong> well driven IEC has to be demand-driven with social marketing<br />
approaches to increase demand for toilets and ensure hygiene behaviors, promote no subsidies for<br />
household toilets in future and encourage diversity in technology and design. For this purpose ULBs may<br />
utilize suitable player for inter-personal IEC and training from the existing system like; ward<br />
development committees, health institutions, schools, National Service Scheme (NSC) volunteers, the<br />
private sector (retailers, contractors, suppliers, plumbers, masons), neighborhood committees and<br />
NGOs, Anganwadi workers.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 15
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
Situation Analysis and Mapping Current Status: The Situation Analysis, prepared by taking into<br />
consideration the ground realities, local conditions, and assessment <strong>of</strong> the present sanitation situation<br />
has been undertaken and broad framework is indicated below:<br />
Sectors Spatial units Finances Institutional<br />
Service levels and<br />
benchmarks for:<br />
Solid Waste<br />
Management<br />
Water Supply<br />
Storm Water<br />
Drainage<br />
Health Situation –<br />
Statistics and Anecdotal<br />
Comment<br />
Environmental Situation –<br />
Local and Downstream<br />
and Groundwater.<br />
Household Sanitation<br />
Slums<br />
Public Sanitary<br />
Conveniences<br />
School Sanitation<br />
Institutional Sanitation<br />
Map spatially<br />
Any town specific areas.<br />
Cost Recovery–<br />
Policy–Tariffs–<br />
Collections–<br />
Budget Transfers.<br />
PPPs.<br />
Study <strong>of</strong> current<br />
programmes (SJSRY,<br />
ILCS, etc)<br />
Institutional<br />
Arrangement –<br />
Policies, Plans,<br />
implementation,<br />
management.<br />
Staffing,<br />
Organization &<br />
Competence<br />
Tools Used: Data Templates, Survey Formats, Transect Walks along with schedules <strong>of</strong> interviews (Slums,<br />
industrial areas, water bodies), Focus Group Discussions (FGDs), Technical Analysis, Impact, Indicators,<br />
Stakeholder Consultations at city level (2-3), etc<br />
Problem Analysis and Assessment <strong>of</strong> Options: Followed by situational analysis problem and challenges<br />
have been identified in coverage, access, treatment and disposal, institutional, financial, social and<br />
cultural aspects and capacity concerns. Also reviewed comprehensive range <strong>of</strong> sanitation and<br />
wastewater management options, including industrial and municipal sewerage, sewage treatment ,<br />
conventional and low cost, centralized and decentralized sewerage, separate and combined and<br />
effluent disposal options, on-site sanitation options, separate programs for schools, public toilets,<br />
sanitation in slums, community-based NGO-supported programs etc.<br />
Purpose <strong>of</strong> options analysis is to identify plausible technical, financial and institutional solutions and<br />
will consider (i) unit cost per beneficiary, (ii) maximizing both human and environmental benefits, (iii)<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 16
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
sustainability, (iv) a long term plan, (v) government policy including land use zoning, (vi) piloting new<br />
approaches, (vii) beneficiary participation, (viii) wastewater as a resource, (ix) lessons learned from the<br />
past and (x) political commitment.<br />
Developing and Consolidating CSP: Having completed above steps, CSP has been formulated to<br />
articulate Sanitation Goals, specific quantifications both in terms <strong>of</strong> technical, capacities and financials<br />
based on stakeholder consultations and the analysis <strong>of</strong> choices made depending on costs <strong>of</strong> capital<br />
investments, operation and maintenance, monitoring, and evaluation.<br />
Project priorities for sanitation considered the following:<br />
(i) Serving the un-served urban poor<br />
(ii) Serving the un-served schools<br />
(iii) Serving the un-served public areas<br />
(iv) Institutional capacity building for sustainability and environmental monitoring<br />
(v) Grant elements for demonstration pilot projects for eco-sanitation (private developers)<br />
(vi) Rehabilitation <strong>of</strong> existing facilities.<br />
(vii) Improvement <strong>of</strong> existing sanitation (septic tank sludge and effluent treatment).<br />
(viii) Extension <strong>of</strong> existing sewerage and sewage treatment (as a last priority).<br />
Action Steps and Fund Estimation in CSP:<br />
Thus, to achieve the above mentioned goals and objectives <strong>of</strong> the current project with certain scope and<br />
limitations as mentioned earlier – requires a detailed methodology and well defined structure. The<br />
following section illustrates the detailed methodology <strong>of</strong> the research project study – considering the<br />
epistemology and ontology, appropriate strategies, methods and design. It also considers the ethical<br />
issues in detail.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 17
1.7 CSP RESEARCH METHODOLOGY<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
The current project on City Sanitation Plan for Bareilly city highlights the extent <strong>of</strong> services provided at<br />
city level and proposes strategies to improve the conditions <strong>of</strong> services with long term, medium term<br />
and short terms strategies which are at-most low cost high impact strategies. This research study<br />
requires wide range <strong>of</strong> data in various areas and population groups, to develop a robust analysis and<br />
produce outputs; and this is only possible with well-established methodology to achieve the required set<br />
<strong>of</strong> results. This chapter primarily focuses on the methodology <strong>of</strong> this research and illustrates that is<br />
undertaken in the current project. The methods used within this project were varied and chosen in<br />
order to achieve the most robust and valuable information in meeting the requirements <strong>of</strong> aims and<br />
objectives. This chapter also outlines the epistemological research methods that are most appropriate<br />
for this current research study.<br />
EPISTOMOLOGY AND ONTOLOGY CONSIDERATIONS: The research study will consider the<br />
epistemology, which acts as an important basis for any research in natural and social science projects<br />
(Willis, 2007). Since the evaluation <strong>of</strong> existing situation <strong>of</strong> services require wide range <strong>of</strong> data, the<br />
current project shall reflect on components such as water services, sewerage services, solid waste<br />
management services at city level, making sure that it reflects upon the entire sanitation and solid waste<br />
management scenario <strong>of</strong> the city. According to Sarantakos (2005), the diversity in ontology and<br />
epistemology directly influence the research study. Further, there is no single fixed rule to conduct a<br />
social research study; different people follow different methods and different ways to explain and<br />
understand the research. Underlying these different explanations are paradigms which are considered<br />
by Babbie (2007) to be fundamental models or frames <strong>of</strong> references we use to organize observations<br />
and reasoning. These different paradigms are just different ways <strong>of</strong> looking at a research study; they are<br />
neither true nor false way <strong>of</strong> approaches. These paradigms make their own assumptions about the<br />
nature <strong>of</strong> the social reality and each inspires different kinds <strong>of</strong> research (see Babbie, 2007).<br />
This research has recognized a positivist paradigm which focuses on applications that involve social<br />
aspects in natural aspects. The social aspects in this current research would be <strong>of</strong> population and the<br />
services available to them. The paradigm <strong>of</strong> positivist is the most suitable approach, since it emphasizes<br />
on human behavior and surveying different groups <strong>of</strong> population i.e. in relevant to the current study,<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 18
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
understanding the human behavior in terms <strong>of</strong> their usage <strong>of</strong> the available sanitation and sewerage<br />
facilities <strong>of</strong> different respondents. This project study also considers the situational analysis <strong>of</strong> available<br />
services provided and the usage patterns <strong>of</strong> these services by the population throughout the city. This<br />
research project study also into qualitative analysis to support the interpretations made which includes<br />
interviews, questionnaire surveys and analysis <strong>of</strong> primary and secondary data to estimate the current<br />
status <strong>of</strong> sanitation and sewerage and other key potential issues and also to evaluate the possible<br />
recommendations/ proposals to meet the goals <strong>of</strong> the project. Thus, positivism approach is most<br />
appropriate to the current study. In addition, the other possible paradigm is Critical Realm which also<br />
considers social factors involved in shaping the city and its infrastructure services and facilities. It was<br />
expected that population’s role in usage patterns <strong>of</strong> these available infrastructure facilities influence the<br />
healthy and livable conditions <strong>of</strong> the city. Since the research project study considers the population’s<br />
socio-economic and demographic details and their behavior that influences the living conditions in the<br />
city, the critical realism can also be considered as an apt approach. Further to epistemology<br />
considerations, ontology <strong>of</strong> the research considered the constructive nature. This is primarily depended<br />
upon the facts that the research being accomplished solely by population at the city level and also<br />
unavoidable personal bias in carrying out the research.<br />
RESEARCH STRATEGIES: The current research project is in assessment <strong>of</strong> key potential problems related<br />
to sanitary, sewerage and solid waste management and provides suitable strategy options to overcome<br />
them. Therefore, this involves robust and in-depth study for which Case Study Approach was used for<br />
analyzing the situation and gaps in sanitary conditions. As the case study approach <strong>of</strong> research is more<br />
precise to specific boundaries and make convenience in collection <strong>of</strong> data (Denscombe, 2007; Blaxter et<br />
al, 2006), it became the appropriate strategy for the current project study. Therefore, the case study<br />
population that was chosen for the current research study includes population at residential areas, slum<br />
areas, institutional areas, schools, hospitals, public areas, industries, market places, commercial areas<br />
and understanding the sanitary conditions at these places.<br />
RESEARCH METHODS: As this research study involves qualitative analysis that involves statistical<br />
methods to support the situational analysis and interpretations <strong>of</strong> the research team. And one <strong>of</strong> the<br />
best qualitative methods is a closed questionnaire interview which directly helps in collecting the<br />
required data and estimates the gaps and conditions – based on which the proposal could be given to<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 19
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
improve the existing conditions. In addition, there is also detailed analysis <strong>of</strong> policy reviews <strong>of</strong> various<br />
documents in order to get the complete picture <strong>of</strong> present and future scenario <strong>of</strong> the city developments.<br />
The prime objective <strong>of</strong> research study in assessing the situation <strong>of</strong> key potential problems related to<br />
sanitary, sewerage, water supply and solid waste management in the city with the chosen research<br />
paradigm is only possible with questionnaire interviews. The other possibility in the assessment includes<br />
Focus Group Discussion. This would be used on various participants or respondents within the study<br />
area, but taking care to cover entire city population and different possible potential areas those<br />
affecting from poor sanitation and sewerage facilities and high rate <strong>of</strong> open defecation. The<br />
questionnaires are the only means <strong>of</strong> gathering first hand information, thus they play vital role in any<br />
research studies (Oppenheim, 2001). Further, Oppenheim (2001) also states, questionnaires are<br />
cheapest means <strong>of</strong> data collection without any bias, less cost <strong>of</strong> processing and the best way to cover<br />
wide range <strong>of</strong> population within the study region.<br />
The questionnaire those used in this project study were <strong>of</strong> different categories and these categories are<br />
based on the criteria that complete sanitary, sewerage, water supply and solid waste <strong>of</strong> the city is<br />
understood and analyzed. The questionnaires are designed so as to get the complete picture and make<br />
the situational analysis <strong>of</strong> the city sanitary conditions – thus different questionnaires are designed for<br />
different target areas such as for households include residential, slums and other possible potential<br />
areas. The other set <strong>of</strong> questionnaires target areas such institutions, public areas (community toilets and<br />
public toilets), hospitals, schools, commercial/ market areas, industries and other potential areas such as<br />
slaughter houses and water bodies. There are separate questionnaires prepared for each category in<br />
order to know the present conditions <strong>of</strong> toilet facilities and their usage conditions. On the other hand to<br />
support these questionnaires, Focus Group Discussions are also conducted at slum areas, selected<br />
residential areas, with elected representatives and other potential areas to understand the situation <strong>of</strong><br />
sanitary, sewerage, water supply and solid waste management conditions <strong>of</strong> the city. The following table<br />
illustrates the different activities undertaken by the research team to make a situational analysis and<br />
also the focused areas <strong>of</strong> the questionnaire interviews and the type <strong>of</strong> tools used to gather the required<br />
information and also the sample sizes at each level to support and further understand the situations.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 20
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
S.NO. ACTIVITIES FOCUSED AREAS TOOLS SAMPLING SAMPLE SIZE<br />
01 Household surveys Household level Questionnaire Random Sampling<br />
02<br />
Focused Group<br />
Discussions<br />
03 Institutions<br />
04<br />
05<br />
06<br />
07<br />
08<br />
09<br />
Community Toilets<br />
Public Toilets<br />
Hospitals<br />
School Sanitation<br />
Slaughter Houses<br />
Commercial/<br />
market areas<br />
Slum areas,<br />
residential areas,<br />
elected<br />
representatives,<br />
and other<br />
potential areas<br />
Collector <strong>of</strong>fice,<br />
Municipal <strong>of</strong>fice,<br />
Bus & Rail station,<br />
etc.,<br />
Upto 500<br />
households (can<br />
be more in high<br />
populated cities)<br />
Check list Random Sampling 12 – 15 FGDs<br />
Questionnaire Random Sampling 10 (in Nos)<br />
All potential areas Questionnaire Random Sampling 50 – 100%<br />
All potential areas Questionnaire Random Sampling 50 – 100%<br />
All Hospitals with<br />
100+ beds (must)<br />
or 50 – 100 beds<br />
Primary,<br />
Secondary, High<br />
school and all<br />
government<br />
schools<br />
Questionnaire Random Sampling 10 – 15 (in Nos)<br />
Questionnaire Random Sampling<br />
50 – 100%; 10%<br />
(>10 lacs)<br />
Potential areas Questionnaire Random Sampling 2 – 3 (in Nos)<br />
Potential areas<br />
(include<br />
questionnaires<br />
both for<br />
shopkeeper and<br />
customers)<br />
Questionnaire Random Sampling 10 – 15 (in Nos)<br />
10 Industries Potential areas Questionnaire Random Sampling 5 – 10 (in Nos)<br />
11 Secondary Data - Check list - -<br />
12 Water Bodies Potential areas Questionnaire Random Sampling 50 – 100%<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 21
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
ETHICAL ISSUES: The nature <strong>of</strong> the current study is highly sensitive, due to involvement <strong>of</strong> various<br />
targeted population <strong>of</strong> the city. It was also important to make the respondents actively and positively<br />
respond and participate in the questionnaire interviews and focused group discussions – which was<br />
done by making the questionnaires confidential and self-explanatory and focused group discussions<br />
much more interactive and confidential. Further, these activities such as questionnaire interviews and<br />
focused group discussions involved the research team’s explanations to the respondents about the<br />
project brief, process <strong>of</strong> the project study, role <strong>of</strong> respondents, and each question (if possible), assisting<br />
them in filling up the questionnaire when he/she faces any difficulties. All the personal details were<br />
remained anonymous in this current project study. It is also further important to consider the<br />
communication needs assessment for any improvements or developments in a society.<br />
1.8. CSP COMMUNCATION NEEDS ASSESSMENT<br />
Bareilly Communication Needs Assessment for Information, Education and Communication Strategy<br />
Introduction: Information, Education and Communication (IEC) & Capacity Building strategy are integral<br />
to the core issue <strong>of</strong> developing the city sanitation plan. In fact it will lead to development <strong>of</strong> robust yet<br />
effective awareness and communication strategy for promoting hygiene & sanitation in the city to<br />
trigger behavior change and demand for sanitation. The strategy will aim for citizen participation in<br />
improving city sanitation specifically reaching out to the slum dwellers and urban poor in the city. It will<br />
evolve a methods, tools & techniques, and use <strong>of</strong> various media (interpersonal, print, electronic, folk<br />
etc) including advocacy with opinion leaders, NGOs/CBOs and other stakeholders to deliver awareness<br />
strategy in the city.<br />
Objectives: The objective <strong>of</strong> IEC & Capacity Building Strategy is to evolve an effective plan <strong>of</strong> sustainable<br />
programmes for capacity building and sensitization <strong>of</strong> implementers, education and enhanced<br />
awareness for stakeholders specifically citizens regarding sanitation activities in Bareilly city. The<br />
strategy is designed to:<br />
Strengthening CSP implementation by Nagar Nigam Bareilly (NNB) through training and capacity<br />
building;<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 22
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
Sensitize citizens for adopting water wastage minimization, segregation & management <strong>of</strong> solid<br />
waste and open defecation free practices through IEC campaign.<br />
By working at both the levels mentioned above a culture <strong>of</strong> communications and consultations is<br />
fostered leading to participation.<br />
Methodology: Bareilly is a prominent city <strong>of</strong> UP state. The city faces specific challenge <strong>of</strong> Water and<br />
Sanitation services. This pose challenges to the city administration with respect to water supply, toilets,<br />
solid waste management and storm water drainage. It is found that communication strategy is a crucial<br />
element in improving service delivery standards. However, apart from educating citizens on health and<br />
hygiene, improving municipal processes by way <strong>of</strong> citizen consultation and participation remains a<br />
necessary goal; without citizen inputs right from the design stage to implementation <strong>of</strong> water and<br />
sanitation projects risk failure.<br />
Communication needs assessment identified three stages for implementation <strong>of</strong> Information, Education<br />
and Communication strategy for improvement in water and sanitation services. These are 1) Awareness,<br />
2) Process and 3) Compliance. While it is generally understood that these stages would lead to better<br />
citizen participation in the schemes, it is in fact imperative for all stakeholders to be appraised <strong>of</strong> them<br />
from their own specific stand points. Awareness includes an understanding <strong>of</strong> health and hygiene<br />
related education specifically directed towards slums. Equally important is an awareness <strong>of</strong> municipal<br />
<strong>of</strong>ficials about the problems face by all the city residents including slum & middle class households and<br />
sanitation workers. This awareness is generally taken for granted. Here, we propose that open and<br />
specific appraisals be carried out without assuming too much <strong>of</strong> prior knowledge regarding sanitation<br />
issues. Next is to create processes which are essential to maintain improved services. These could<br />
include citizen participation in community toilet maintenance, outsourcing <strong>of</strong> operations and<br />
maintenance to private partners in public toilets, solid waste management and establishing citizen<br />
grievance resolution systems to name a few. A consolidation <strong>of</strong> these gains can only occur when all<br />
stakeholders comply with the laid down norms. As system <strong>of</strong> incentivizing desirable behaviors and<br />
weeding out undesirable behaviors must be developed, these programmes, processes and goals will be<br />
set by the Nagar Nigam.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 23
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
The key idea is to carry out a needs assessment within the existing infrastructure <strong>of</strong> service delivery.<br />
Following steps were identified before visiting the field:<br />
1. Identifying stakeholder groups and available channels <strong>of</strong> communication<br />
2. Focus Group Discussions, Interviews, Transect Walks<br />
3. Topic Guides and Probes prepared for each stakeholder group.<br />
4. Field assessment <strong>of</strong> communications needs to be carried out.<br />
These methods helped us to evolve a case study approach towards communication needs assessment<br />
for Bareilly city. Case study approach <strong>of</strong>fers the best possible method for evolving a Information,<br />
Education and Communications strategy for the city concerned. The random sampling based survey will<br />
be labor intensive and time consuming. Moreover, such a survey is likely to conceal extreme situations<br />
within the city. A case study approach utilizing information sampling can reveal much more through<br />
discussions with citizens on the margins and those on the frontlines <strong>of</strong> implementation.<br />
Stakeholders: Opinion leaders to be targeted as a high influence group both for interviews and<br />
implementation <strong>of</strong> communications strategies among residents, establishments and Nagar Nigam<br />
<strong>of</strong>ficials. Residents include all those living within city municipal limits; they can be classified as HIG, LIG<br />
and slum dwellers. Shopkeepers and commercial establishments constitute a separate group especially<br />
for generation <strong>of</strong> market waste. Specifically, in Bareilly a series <strong>of</strong> focus group discussions (FGDs)<br />
conducted with slum residents in various parts <strong>of</strong> the city. Interview and discussions included <strong>of</strong>ficials<br />
from various Nagar Nigam departments particularly Health & Sanitary <strong>of</strong>ficials, sanitation workers,<br />
prominent citizens, residents in middle class areas, NGOs involved in water and sanitation sector,<br />
shopkeepers, media persons etc.<br />
Locations for FGDs & Transect Walks were selected to represent the variety <strong>of</strong> samples. Slum locations<br />
can be classified based on local knowledge. Generally, slum in outskirts and those in interiors <strong>of</strong>fer two<br />
different typologies. The core city areas are predominantly by business class. Similarly there are slum on<br />
the outskirts are predominant with Muslim, SC or ST population.<br />
Probes for interviews and FGDs:<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 24
1. Residents including slum residents<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
Awareness regarding Health and Hygiene: The current practices and awareness regarding ill-<br />
effects <strong>of</strong> lack <strong>of</strong> sanitation, ODF, hand washing, water logging etc.<br />
Awareness regarding government schemes/policies for improving water and sanitation: NUSP,<br />
DUDA, sources and channels <strong>of</strong> such knowledge and communication.<br />
Awareness regarding various technical options toilets.<br />
Willingness to upgrade sanitation facilities: financial, space and behavioral constraints<br />
Participation in any public awareness campaign regarding sanitation, agencies that carried the<br />
campaign and learning from the campaign.<br />
Activities <strong>of</strong> local SHGs and other community organizations such as RWAs.<br />
Media consumption patterns reading newspapers, Cable TV etc<br />
Information regarding demography <strong>of</strong> the slum, quality <strong>of</strong> water supply etc.<br />
Complaint resolution system: complaints and mechanisms <strong>of</strong> resolution, how do they deal with<br />
water and sanitation crisis, approaching local corporators, complain to Nagar Nigam, satisfaction<br />
level with current arrangement.<br />
2. Municipal <strong>of</strong>ficials<br />
Role envisaged for communication for implementing CSP.<br />
Channels <strong>of</strong> communication at Nagar Nigam’s disposal, extent to which these channels are being<br />
exploited.<br />
Technological options, geographic and infrastructural issues involved in implementing Water<br />
and Sanitation schemes.<br />
M&E, feedback, support, rewards: Maintenance <strong>of</strong> citizen grievance records, discernible<br />
patterns in complaints, efficiency <strong>of</strong> complaint redressal.<br />
Details <strong>of</strong> any specific communication campaign being taken up, Content, Channels used, budget<br />
allocated, awareness regarding multiplying message through media.<br />
Kinds <strong>of</strong> training given to Safai Karamcharies for safe disposal <strong>of</strong> waste etc and their satisfaction<br />
level what has been provided to them.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 25
3. Commercial establishment and Public places<br />
Observation regarding sanitation is these places.<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
Practices involved in disposal <strong>of</strong> commercial waste such as door to door collection, segregation.<br />
O&M practices, regular upkeep <strong>of</strong> public places.<br />
Major complaints, public redressal mechanisms and its effectiveness.<br />
Willingness to pay user charges for public toilets.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 26
INTRODUCTION<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
CHAPTER 02<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> PROFILE<br />
Bareilly pronunciation is a metro city in Bareilly district in the northern Indian state <strong>of</strong> Uttar Pradesh.<br />
Standing on the Ramganga River, it is the capital <strong>of</strong> Rohilkhand Division and is a center for the<br />
manufacture <strong>of</strong> furniture and for trade in cotton, grain, and sugar. This fast-growing city is also known as<br />
Bans-Bareilly, due to its big bamboo market. Bareilly is also known as the counter-magnet city because it<br />
is equidistant from New Delhi and Lucknow and has a lot <strong>of</strong> potential for setting up industries to attract<br />
people to settle. It is one <strong>of</strong> the biggest city <strong>of</strong> Uttar Pradesh state. Historically it was the part <strong>of</strong> the<br />
ancient kingdom <strong>of</strong> Panchal. In the Medieval period it was under the Rohillas. The modern city's<br />
foundation was laid by Mukrand Rai in 1657.<br />
The Bareilly city is located on the banks <strong>of</strong> river Ramganga, in the fertile indo-gangetic plain, and it is<br />
also the head quarter <strong>of</strong> Rohilkhand division and Bareilly Commissionary. It is situated on NH 24 and 5<br />
State and National Highways’ coverage on it. The adjoining districts are Nainital in north, Pilibhit in east,<br />
Shahjahanpur in southeast and Budaun in south. It is the largest urban centre in western zone <strong>of</strong> Utter<br />
Pradesh, outside the NCR and has been identified as the counter magnet city <strong>of</strong> the region in 1962.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 27
2.1 TOPOGRAPHY, CLIMATE & DEMOGRAPHY<br />
TOPOGRAPHY<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
Bareilly is located at 28°10′N, 78°23′E, and lies in northern India. It borders Pilibhit and Shahjahanpur on<br />
east and Rampur on west, Udham Singh Nagar (Uttarakhand) in north and Badaun in south. Bareilly lies<br />
entirely in the Ganges plains. The low-lying Ganges plains provide fertile alluvial soil suitable for<br />
agriculture. However, these some lower part <strong>of</strong> plains is prone to recurrent floods. Bareilly lies on the<br />
bank <strong>of</strong> river Ramganga and there are seven rivers passing through this district. The<br />
lower Himalayan range is just 40 km from it and it lies in north <strong>of</strong> it.<br />
CLIMATE<br />
Bareilly has a humid subtropical climate with high variation between summer and winter temperatures.<br />
Summers are long, from early April to October, with the monsoon season in between. Winter starts in<br />
October and peaks in January and is notorious for its heavy fog. Extreme temperatures range from 4 °C<br />
to 44 °C. The annual mean temperature is 25 °C (77 °F), monthly mean temperatures range from 14 °C<br />
to 33 °C (58 °F to 92 °F). The average annual rainfall is approximately 1714 mm (28.1 inches), most <strong>of</strong><br />
which is during the monsoons in July and August.<br />
The temperature <strong>of</strong> the district fluctuates from a maximum <strong>of</strong> 44ºC in the months <strong>of</strong> May-June to a low<br />
<strong>of</strong> 4ºC during the cool months <strong>of</strong> Dec-Jan. The climate <strong>of</strong> the district is influenced by its proximity to the<br />
hills and the tarai swamps in the north. Although the air is dry in summers, it contains moisture during<br />
the rest <strong>of</strong> the year. The district goes through a cycle <strong>of</strong> four seasons, during the year. The cool winters<br />
from December to February, followed by the warm summers which continue till about the middle <strong>of</strong><br />
June, relief from the heat coming in the form <strong>of</strong> the South-West monsoons, ushering during the rainy<br />
season which lasts till the end <strong>of</strong> September; October and November constitute the post-monsoon<br />
season.<br />
DEMOGRAPHY<br />
According to the 2001 census report <strong>of</strong> the Government <strong>of</strong> India, the total population <strong>of</strong> Bareilly City<br />
Region (Bareilly Municipal Corporation and Bareilly Cantt.) is 875,165 having distribution as 53% males<br />
and 47% females nearly. The area under the city region is 123.46 km². The density <strong>of</strong> the population is<br />
among the high in the country touching 5000 per km 2 . The main population consists<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 28
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
<strong>of</strong> Jatavs and Balmikis, and other castes such as the Baniyas,Kurmi, Thakurs, Kayasthas & Punjabis<br />
Hindus from 62% <strong>of</strong> population and Muslims 26% mainly Ansari, Behna, Rohilla, Rayeen, Ranghar and<br />
Shaikh) <strong>of</strong> the population, Sikhs form about 10% <strong>of</strong> population and rest are Jain ,Buddhist and Christians.<br />
Bareilly has an average literacy rate <strong>of</strong> 81%, higher than the national average <strong>of</strong> 59.5%, with 88% <strong>of</strong> the<br />
males and 65% <strong>of</strong> females literate making it under top three districts in terms <strong>of</strong> literacy in Uttar<br />
Pradesh . The main languages spoken are Hindi, Urdu, English, Punjabi, and Kumauni. For administrative<br />
convenience, the district <strong>of</strong> Bareilly has been divided into six tehsils namely Aonla, Faridpur,<br />
Bareilly, Mirganj, Nawabganj, and Baheri and 14 blocks.<br />
2.2 ECONOMY<br />
Since the period <strong>of</strong> Liberalization in India, Bareilly is one <strong>of</strong> the fastest growing cities in the region on<br />
account <strong>of</strong> its booming economy. Trade and commerce have flourished in the urban city and followed<br />
diversification, though the rural economy <strong>of</strong> the district is largely agrarian.<br />
Brands: Following the foray <strong>of</strong> Multi-national corporations in the city, a significant capital infusion and<br />
various investments have occurred throughout the city in different sectors. Bareilly, today, has most <strong>of</strong><br />
the major global apparel brands including Adidas, Reebok, and Levi’s. Reebok has also opened their<br />
Factory Outlet in Bareilly which is located at Pilibhit By-Pass Road. Nike is to open an outlet soon.<br />
Accompanying these are all other well-known clothing, footwear and accessory brands which have their<br />
authorized show-rooms and commercial outlets in the 'Civil Lines areas' and 'D.D.Puram area' <strong>of</strong> the city.<br />
Most <strong>of</strong> the major automobile companies like Toyota, Mahindra & Mahindra, Tata Motors, Maruti<br />
Suzuki, General Motors, Hyundai, and Honda have their showrooms and service centers in the city.<br />
Industries: Bareilly houses a lot <strong>of</strong> Industries in the industrial zone called the Parsakhera Industrial Zone.<br />
Major Companies such as Coca- Cola, Camphor & Allied Products Ltd., Paras, Vadilal, Mercury and many<br />
others are present in the City.<br />
The Ahmadabad-based Ice-cream maker Vadilal has its manufacturing plant in Bareilly. The plant is the<br />
sole plant in Northern and Eastern India and caters to both the zones. Vadilal enjoys a 10-12% market<br />
share in the Rs 120-crore Delhi market and around 6-8% in the Rs 200-crore eastern market, which<br />
comprises territories such as Kolkata, Orissa, Jharkhand and Bihar.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 29
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
Media: A lot <strong>of</strong> Hindi Newspapers including Dainik Jagran, Hindustan, Amar Ujala, Aaj are printed in the<br />
city. Various English Newspapers including the Times <strong>of</strong> India, The Hindu, Hindustan Times, and The<br />
Economic Times can be found on the stalls at around 7 a.m. as they are published in the Delhi NCR and<br />
sent to the city.<br />
HT Media Ltd has recently come out with a printing facilities in Bareilly, printing <strong>of</strong> its Hindi newspaper<br />
"Hindustan" starting October 10, 2009 and catering to the Rohilkhand area <strong>of</strong> western Uttar Pradesh<br />
comprising <strong>of</strong> Bareilly, Pilibhit, Shahjahanpur, Lakhimpur and Badaun districts. They also plan to start<br />
printing the local edition <strong>of</strong> their English Daily "The Hindustan Times" very soon.<br />
The city also has its dedicated News Channel called the Alliance News Channel which broadcasts local<br />
news at different slots throughout the day.<br />
Agriculture: Corporate giant Hindustan Unilever has undertaken contract farming <strong>of</strong> rice in Bareilly and<br />
Punjab and its success has ensured low-cost, better-quality produce for its products. The company now<br />
plans to extend the experiment but feels an enabling environment in terms <strong>of</strong> agri-laws and<br />
infrastructure facilities is required for the purpose.<br />
Passport Office: The Passport Office, Bareilly was created in 1983 as a subordinate <strong>of</strong>fice <strong>of</strong> <strong>Ministry</strong> <strong>of</strong><br />
External Affairs under the supervision <strong>of</strong> Central Passport Organization. The issue <strong>of</strong> passport is a central<br />
subject under the Indian Constitution and allotted to the <strong>Ministry</strong> <strong>of</strong> External Affairs, Initially Passport<br />
Office, Bareilly was catering to the needs <strong>of</strong> residents <strong>of</strong> the State <strong>of</strong> Uttrakhand and 24 Districts <strong>of</strong><br />
Western Uttar Pradesh. Separate passport Office for the residents <strong>of</strong> Meerut, Aligarh and Agra Division<br />
was opened in the year 1997 at Ghaziabad on bifurcation <strong>of</strong> this <strong>of</strong>fice. Again the <strong>of</strong>fice bifurcated and<br />
another passport <strong>of</strong>fice at Dehradun was opened in June 2008 for the residents <strong>of</strong> the State <strong>of</strong><br />
Uttrakhand.<br />
Today, this <strong>of</strong>fice deals with the issue <strong>of</strong> passport/travel documents to the citizens <strong>of</strong> 12 districts <strong>of</strong><br />
Uttar Pradesh i.e. Bareilly, Shahjahanpur, Pilibhit, Badaun, Moradabad, Rampur, Bijnor, Jyotiba Phule<br />
Nagar, Firozabad, Kashi Ram Nagar, Etah & Mainpuri.<br />
Electricity: In 2009, Uttar Pradesh Power Corporation Limited (UPPCL) moved a step ahead in<br />
implementing the franchisee system in the power sector <strong>of</strong> the state. Under the new system, private<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 30
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
players will be awarded contract to maintain and supply power in nine cities <strong>of</strong> the state. The same<br />
companies will be the outsource points for collecting revenue on behalf <strong>of</strong> the state government. The<br />
system will be implemented in nine cities <strong>of</strong> the state on a pilot basis. Bareilly, Agra, Kanpur, Moradabad<br />
and Gorakhpur will be covered in the first phase.<br />
Fuel: The Indian government initiated the ten per cent ethanol-blending programme on a pilot basis in<br />
two districts - Bareilly in Uttar Pradesh and Belgaum in Karnataka. Bareilly also has CNG and Auto-LPG<br />
outlets operated by Satya Service station owned by Hon. Shri Raj Kumar Agarwal, first mayor <strong>of</strong> the city.<br />
Bareilly became the first district in India to implement Bio-fuel norms.<br />
There are about 2500 commercial establishments registered at Nagar Nigam. The average growth rates<br />
<strong>of</strong> commercial establishments are high compared to hotels & restaurants. This also increases additional<br />
burdens on existing infrastructure facilities. The following table gives the statistical figures <strong>of</strong> trade and<br />
commerce establishments for the year 2009 – 2010.<br />
Total Number <strong>of</strong> establishments 2498<br />
Commercial Number n/a<br />
Hotels & Restaurants Number n/a<br />
Offices & Institutions Number n/a<br />
Markets Number n/a<br />
2.3 URBAN POVERTY AND SLUMS<br />
Though no recent study is available to accurately assess the extent <strong>of</strong> poverty levels in Bareilly but from<br />
the discussions with various stakeholders we understand that poverty levels are quite high in Bareilly.<br />
In addition to this, more than twenty percent <strong>of</strong> the population in Bareilly stays in areas marred with<br />
unhygienic living conditions and lack <strong>of</strong> civic amenities. The urban infrastructure is not satisfactory<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 31
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
enough to bring homogenous development in new areas. The growth <strong>of</strong> housing stock is not able to<br />
keep pace with the population growth. This has increased the housing stock deficit which has given rise<br />
to slum dwellings.<br />
As per the survey conducted by DUDA and documents from NNB, total notified slums in Bareilly are 85.<br />
According to census 2001, the slum population was 77109 i.e. 20.5 percent <strong>of</strong> total Population. As per<br />
the survey conducted by S.U.D.A in 2000-01, the population was 77109 and total households were<br />
10050. A large number <strong>of</strong> below poverty line (BPL) population (about 25%) also live-in slums. The<br />
current slum population is about 2.44 lacs with 31850 <strong>of</strong> households i.e. about 26.47% <strong>of</strong> the total<br />
population.<br />
ULB Pr<strong>of</strong>ile Year 2001 Year 2010<br />
Slum Population 77109 244373<br />
Slum Households 10050 31850<br />
No. <strong>of</strong> slums 85 85<br />
Water Supply Facilities: It may be seen that in slums access to individual water connections is low and<br />
people generally use public stand posts, hand pumps, or wells in a few cases. Majority <strong>of</strong> households<br />
(55%) get water from public stand posts and only 19% percent have individual taps. It has been observed<br />
that main source <strong>of</strong> water supply in slum areas is hand pumps and wherever piped water supply is there,<br />
either supply is inadequate or it’s not regular or it’s very dirty. They are only able to use the water after<br />
carrying out the sedimentation and filtering. Out <strong>of</strong> total households in slum, about 30 percent have<br />
electricity whereas others use either kerosene, wood etc.<br />
Sanitation Facilities: Presently, access to sanitation services is markedly less than access to other basic<br />
services. While, it may be worthwhile to note that the proportion <strong>of</strong> people having access to sanitation<br />
in urban areas is considerably greater when compared to their rural counterparts, the problems are<br />
more exacerbated in slums. <strong>Urban</strong> sanitation is perceived as being important because <strong>of</strong> the health<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 32
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
factor. In case <strong>of</strong> slums, it has been observed that sanitation facilities are worst and in alarming<br />
condition.<br />
Majority <strong>of</strong> households use public toilets followed by households using individual flush. Even then open<br />
defecation is still at a large scale i.e. about 35% <strong>of</strong> the slum households openly defecate. During the visit<br />
in slums located at different part <strong>of</strong> the Bareilly city, it has been observed that sanitation condition is still<br />
very poor in most <strong>of</strong> the slum areas considering only 20 percent people have individual toilets and the<br />
others i.e. approx. 5 percent use community toilets and 35 percent still go for open defecation. The<br />
present condition is shown in the situational analysis <strong>of</strong> sanitation facilities in slum areas<br />
To minimize open defecation and to bring improvement in overall sanitation, two schemes have been<br />
introduced: a) Low Cost Sanitation Scheme b) Construction <strong>of</strong> Community toilets. These provisions <strong>of</strong><br />
individual toilets and construction <strong>of</strong> community toilets has reduced the open defecation in Bareilly city<br />
– to some extent. The percentage share <strong>of</strong> slum population still open defecate is about 25% (details in<br />
situational analysis).<br />
During visit to different slums following observations were made:<br />
Poor construction i.e. bad designing, usage <strong>of</strong> poor quality material etc. and maintenance<br />
Lack <strong>of</strong> proper management <strong>of</strong> community toilets<br />
Inadequate water supply and lighting in the toilets<br />
Cleaning service is not administered properly.<br />
Unhygienic condition <strong>of</strong> the public toilets<br />
Distance<br />
Lack <strong>of</strong> willingness to pay and use the community toilet facility<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 33
Sewerage System and Solid Waste Management in slum areas:<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
In most <strong>of</strong> the slums, sewerage system is either non-existent or it is found chocked. The problem <strong>of</strong><br />
blocked sewerage also exists in the slums where people stay in pucca houses. The open drains in the<br />
slums are <strong>of</strong> very small size and are mostly blocked due to lack <strong>of</strong> cleaning and solid waste finding its<br />
way into drains. There is no proper way <strong>of</strong> solid waste disposal which exists at the slum level. In 30% <strong>of</strong><br />
the slums solid waste is collected by govt. or private persons but disposal sites are either non-existent or<br />
are poorly managed. In many slums solid waste can be seen flowing in the drains leading to chocked<br />
drains and health hazardous situation.<br />
Key issues:<br />
As per the DUDA and NNB, total notified slums in Bareilly are 85. The current slum population is<br />
about 2.44 lakh with about 32000 <strong>of</strong> households i.e. about 26% <strong>of</strong> the total population.<br />
Majority <strong>of</strong> households i.e. more than 51 percent live in Kutcha Houses made <strong>of</strong> grass, mud etc. and<br />
jhuggi jhopri’s. Only 21 percent stay in Pucca Houses. In slums, about 47 percent have their own<br />
houses whereas 41% lives in as tenant whereas rest is living as unauthorized occupants.<br />
It may be seen that in slums access to individual water connections is low and people generally use<br />
public stand posts, hand pumps, or wells in a few cases. Majority <strong>of</strong> households (55%) get water<br />
from public stand posts and only 19% percent have individual taps.<br />
It has been observed that main source <strong>of</strong> water supply in slum areas is hand pumps and wherever<br />
piped water supply is there, either supply is inadequate or it’s not regular or it’s very dirty.<br />
Lack <strong>of</strong> proper shelter, poor access to basic needs and lack <strong>of</strong> awareness make the slum dwellers life<br />
style very poor. About 25 percent <strong>of</strong> the Bareilly’s population is living in slums; hence all housing<br />
programmes should target provision <strong>of</strong> better shelter for them on priority basis.<br />
In many <strong>of</strong> the slums water through public stand posts and hand pumps have been provided but it<br />
has been observed that lots <strong>of</strong> water is wasted.<br />
Only in a few slums sewerage lines have been provided and they were <strong>of</strong>ten chocked.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 34
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
No proper mechanism <strong>of</strong> solid waste disposal exists. Either the disposal sites are non-existent or<br />
even if they exist, they are located at faraway place which the slum dwellers find inconvenient to<br />
use. The few waste disposal sites that exist are in a sad state <strong>of</strong> affairs as they are not cleaned on a<br />
daily basis and the waste gets scattered all over the place creating a health hazard.<br />
In most <strong>of</strong> the slums, no provision has been made to provide storm water drains. Due to which<br />
water logging takes place adding to the unhygienic condition within the slums.<br />
While the city has made provision for public sanitation facilities in a few slums, still about 25-30% <strong>of</strong><br />
slum population goes for open defecation, causing both a health hazard and a problem <strong>of</strong> safety.<br />
At present the number <strong>of</strong> notified slum is 85 and strategies for rehabilitation and implementation <strong>of</strong><br />
central and state government schemes can only be carried out in the notified slums. There is a need<br />
to carry out a fresh survey to cover all slums and poor communities so that the actual demand for<br />
housing and basic services for urban poor can be ascertained and overall city environment can be<br />
improved.<br />
2.4 GOVERNANCE AND INSTITUTIONAL ARRANGEMENTS<br />
'Good governance' is the overarching objective <strong>of</strong> public administration in the civic arena. In virtually all<br />
sectors <strong>of</strong> public intervention and service delivery, it is now agreed that unless and until the state <strong>of</strong><br />
governance is 'good', service or product delivery will not be proper. In the recent past, a large number <strong>of</strong><br />
people and organizations have given a variety <strong>of</strong> definitions <strong>of</strong> what governance is all about.<br />
Governance is defined differently in terms <strong>of</strong> the context. According to one definition, “the ways in<br />
which stakeholders interact with each other in order to influence the outcomes <strong>of</strong> public policies " is<br />
public governance. According to the World Bank, “the manner in which power is exercised in the<br />
management <strong>of</strong> a country's economic and social resources for development " is good governance.<br />
There are today dozens <strong>of</strong> definitions <strong>of</strong> what governance and good governance is. However, if one has<br />
to summaries and list downs the ten characteristics <strong>of</strong> good governance, they would be:<br />
Citizen involvement, participation and satisfaction<br />
Transparency in all decision making<br />
Accountability <strong>of</strong> actions taken<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 35
Equality and social inclusion<br />
Ethical and honest behavior<br />
Ability to compete in a global environment<br />
Efficiency <strong>of</strong> service delivery<br />
Respect for democratic values<br />
Respect for the rule <strong>of</strong> law<br />
Use <strong>of</strong> appropriate technology and environmental sustainability<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
The United Nations-HABITAT launched a Global Campaign on <strong>Urban</strong> Governance in the year 1999 in<br />
order to support the implementation <strong>of</strong> the Habitat Agenda goal <strong>of</strong> "sustainable human settlements<br />
development in an urbanizing world ". The goal <strong>of</strong> the Campaign is to contribute to the eradication <strong>of</strong><br />
poverty through improved urban governance. It is now widely believed that the quality <strong>of</strong> governance is<br />
the key factor for the eradication <strong>of</strong> poverty and the creation <strong>of</strong> prosperity in cities. The United Nations-<br />
HABITAT has also been propagating the concept <strong>of</strong> the 'inclusive city'; a city which promotes growth<br />
with equity, a place where everyone, regardless <strong>of</strong> their economic status, gender, race, ethnicity or<br />
religion, is enabled and empowered to fully participate in the social, economic and political<br />
opportunities that cities have to <strong>of</strong>fer.<br />
The definition <strong>of</strong> urban governance according to the Campaign is as follows: "<strong>Urban</strong> Governance is the<br />
sum <strong>of</strong> the many ways individuals and institutions, public and private, plan and manage the common<br />
affairs <strong>of</strong> the city. It is a continuing process through which conflicting or diverse interests may be<br />
accommodated and cooperative action can be taken. It includes formal institutions as well as informal<br />
arrangements and the social capital <strong>of</strong> citizens". Further, the Campaign also defines good urban<br />
governance as follows: "<strong>Urban</strong> governance is inextricably linked to the welfare <strong>of</strong> the citizenry. Good<br />
urban governance must enable women and men to access the benefits <strong>of</strong> urban citizenship. Good urban<br />
governance, based on the principle <strong>of</strong> urban citizenship, affirms that no man, woman or child can be<br />
denied access to the necessities <strong>of</strong> urban life, including adequate shelter, security <strong>of</strong> tenure, safe water,<br />
sanitation, a clean environment, health, education and nutrition, employment and public safety and<br />
mobility. Through good urban governance, citizens are provided with the platform which will allow<br />
them to use their talents to the full to improve their social and economic conditions".<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 36
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
In order to implement the good urban governance agenda, the United Nations HABITAT has proposed<br />
that good urban governance is characterized by the following principles:<br />
Sustainability<br />
Subsidiary<br />
Equity<br />
Efficiency<br />
Transparency and accountability<br />
Civic engagement and citizenship and<br />
Security<br />
Based on the above, several nations have drawn up action plans for good urban governance in their<br />
respective contexts. It is in this broad world view, taking into specific cognizance the peculiarities <strong>of</strong><br />
urbanization and urban local administration in India, for the better health <strong>of</strong> Government it is important<br />
to have good coordination and self responsibility <strong>of</strong> the government organizations from central to local<br />
level and also proper coordination with local NGO’s, private organizations and community participation.<br />
Thus, based on the same – the recommendations/ proposals also focus on the capacity building <strong>of</strong> public<br />
and private organizations at different levels. But, it is also important to consider the legal background <strong>of</strong><br />
different organizations and their functions and jurisdictions before proposing the strategies for<br />
improvements.<br />
<strong>Urban</strong> Areas are the engines <strong>of</strong> economic growth. The quality <strong>of</strong> civic infrastructure and civic services<br />
has a critical bearing on economic development <strong>of</strong> the city and State as a whole. The 74th amendment<br />
to the constitution devolved the role <strong>of</strong> management and development <strong>of</strong> the city to the elected<br />
representatives <strong>of</strong> the city through the city’s <strong>Urban</strong> Local Body (ULBs). Hence the ULBs are both the<br />
custodians <strong>of</strong> civil infrastructure and providers <strong>of</strong> civic services. Thus, ULBs are catalysts <strong>of</strong> economic<br />
growth <strong>of</strong> a city. However, the management <strong>of</strong> a city like Bareilly is a complex task and several<br />
institutions are involved in it, as given below.<br />
Agencies Involved In Providing <strong>Urban</strong> Services in Bareilly :<br />
UP Housing & <strong>Development</strong> Board<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 37
Functions <strong>of</strong> the Nagar Nigam Bareilly<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
The UP Municipal Corporation Adhiniyam, 1959 as amended from time to time provides for majority <strong>of</strong><br />
the function listed in the 12th schedule <strong>of</strong> the constitution. These are:<br />
<strong>Urban</strong> planning including town Planning<br />
Regulation <strong>of</strong> land-use and construction <strong>of</strong> buildings<br />
Planning for economic and social development<br />
Roads and bridges<br />
Water Supply for domestic, industrial and commercial purposes<br />
Public health, sanitation, conservancy and solid waste management<br />
Fire services<br />
<strong>Urban</strong> forestry, protection <strong>of</strong> the environment and promotion <strong>of</strong> ecological aspects<br />
Safeguarding the interests <strong>of</strong> weaker sections <strong>of</strong> the society, including the handicapped and<br />
mentally retarded<br />
Slum improvement and up gradation<br />
Provision <strong>of</strong> <strong>Urban</strong> amenities and facilities such as parks, gardens, playgrounds<br />
Promotion <strong>of</strong> cultural, educational and aesthetics aspects<br />
Burials, burial grounds; cremations, cremation grounds and electric crematoriums<br />
Cattle Ponds; Prevention <strong>of</strong> cruelty to animals<br />
Vital Statistics including registration <strong>of</strong> births and deaths<br />
Public amenities including street lighting, parking lots, bus stops and Public Conveniences<br />
Regulation <strong>of</strong> slaughter houses<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 38
Nagar Nigam Bareilly (NNB) :<br />
The administrative chart <strong>of</strong> NNB is given below:<br />
Varishth Nagar Swasth Adhikari<br />
Zonal health <strong>of</strong>ficers<br />
Chief Sanitary Inspectors (2)<br />
Sanitary Inspectors (5)<br />
DEPARTMENT Supervisors<br />
Safai karamcharis<br />
HEALTH DEPARTMENT<br />
Nagar Ayukt<br />
Upper Nagar Ayukt<br />
Sahayak Nagar Ayukt<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
Chief Engineer<br />
Executive Engineers<br />
Assistant Engineers<br />
Junior Engineers<br />
ENGINEERING<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 39
U.P. HOUSING AND DEVELOPMENT BOARD<br />
U.P. Housing and <strong>Development</strong> Board have been set up under the Act <strong>of</strong> 1965 in April 1966. It has<br />
been established to implement the various housing and development schemes in a planned way and<br />
to bring harmony by keeping in mind the state level and national level residential policy and<br />
programmes.<br />
The main objectives <strong>of</strong> U.P. Housing and <strong>Development</strong> Board are to:<br />
Make the plan for all residence related activities in the urban areas and to get them<br />
implemented fast and in effective way;<br />
Receive grant and loan from central and state government, commercial bank, financial<br />
organizations, public bodies etc.<br />
Acquire the land and construct roads, electricity, water supply, and other urban facilities and<br />
to arrange and distribute the land and constructed houses according to the demand from<br />
registered people<br />
Make special arrangement for the houses for the backward class and scheduled caste and<br />
tribe, security workers and freedom fighters.<br />
OVERLAP OF INSTITUTIONAL RESPONSIBILITIES<br />
The multiplicity <strong>of</strong> organizations involved in providing urban services makes the management <strong>of</strong><br />
affairs <strong>of</strong> the city highly complex. It becomes essential to define the roles and responsibilities <strong>of</strong> each<br />
<strong>of</strong> the Agencies very clearly. The inter-relationships <strong>of</strong> various departments play an important role in<br />
making available good quality <strong>of</strong> services to the community /citizens <strong>of</strong> the city. More-over<br />
overlapping <strong>of</strong> some <strong>of</strong> the functions requires a high level <strong>of</strong> coordination. The following table<br />
indicates the service-wise planning, implementation and operation and maintenance function being<br />
carried out by various agencies involved in providing services in Bareilly <strong>Urban</strong> Area. It will be seen<br />
that many services are being provided by more than one agency resulting in avoidable delays at the<br />
time <strong>of</strong> handing over the assets who has to ultimately maintain them.
KEY ISSUES<br />
The critical issues that emerge from the existence <strong>of</strong> multiple agencies include:<br />
Spatial and functional fragmentation<br />
Overlapping functions<br />
Multiple accountability lines<br />
High service delivery gaps and<br />
Increasing <strong>Urban</strong> poverty<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
Lack <strong>of</strong> clarity in local functions: The Constitution 74th Amendment Act, 1992 envisages that the<br />
functions listed in 12th schedule <strong>of</strong> the Constitution is entrusted to elected municipalities. This is<br />
with a view to minimize ambiguities and overlapping functions between local bodies and other<br />
authorities. However, in practice, several agencies are responsible for the functions and in some<br />
cases local bodies have no role.<br />
Inter-institutional conflicts: The large number <strong>of</strong> departments, institutions, agencies and <strong>of</strong>ficers<br />
undertaking similar, related and overlapping functions or the functions not clearly defined lead to<br />
conflicts in operation. Moreover the various agencies over the same or overlapping jurisdiction and<br />
are not in a position to understand and evaluate the backward and forward linkages associated with<br />
these functions.<br />
Municipal-Parastatal Coordination: There is a lack <strong>of</strong> coordination between urban local bodies and<br />
parastatals in areas such as inter-municipal, inter district and inter-state roads, Storm water drainage<br />
and sewerage, common amenities like whole -sale markets, truck terminals, bus stations, garbage<br />
dumping yards, landfill sites. The real problem is noticed in plan implementation. No clearly defined<br />
mechanism exists to take up such works in an integrated manner taking into account the<br />
geographical factors.<br />
Managerial Coordination Issues: There are many managers connected with metropolitan service<br />
delivery and infrastructure management. All these make the task <strong>of</strong> metropolitan management<br />
highly complex and difficult. In addition to general coordination between urban and rural local<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 43
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
authorities, there are several inter-departmental and inter institutional coordination issues, which<br />
arise in day to day administration <strong>of</strong> the metropolitan area.<br />
Jurisdictional Issues: It is very difficult to arrive at a common boundary for all services. The<br />
geographical Area required for internalizing the costs and benefits <strong>of</strong> a service like urban transport,<br />
water supply, storm water drainage etc.<br />
If such matching is not ensured, there will be perennial problems <strong>of</strong> service revenues falling short <strong>of</strong><br />
service costs, mounting inter -institutional conflicts, increased cost <strong>of</strong> public administration, lack <strong>of</strong><br />
integrated development and imposition <strong>of</strong> high social cost on the public. Thus it is important that the<br />
jurisdictional issues are sorted out carefully.<br />
While it is important to keep the costs <strong>of</strong> metropolitan administration low, exploitation <strong>of</strong><br />
development potential <strong>of</strong> the metro area and its contribution to national wealth and income should<br />
be the primary consideration for metropolitan spatial organization.<br />
Grievance Redressal: The Grievance Redressal mechanism in the city is weak and the people are<br />
made to run from pillar to post for grievance redressal. There is also no proper platform to provide<br />
information to the citizens on all services. Lack <strong>of</strong> awareness and information is affecting the<br />
citizen’s access to grievance redressal mechanisms. Though citizen’s charters are established for the<br />
service providing agencies, majority <strong>of</strong> the public is not aware <strong>of</strong> the duties and rights under the<br />
same.<br />
Institutional Strategies<br />
There is a need to address the institutional and other challenges to provide good governance to the<br />
city. Unless the roadblocks are removed, economic development is hampered and efficient service<br />
delivery becomes difficult. This adversely affects the community particular the ‘poor’. There is need,<br />
therefore, to restructure the governance framework, remove the roadblocks and streamline the<br />
lines <strong>of</strong> accountability. The governance reforms become all the more critical in the context <strong>of</strong><br />
Bareilly, which has got the dying city reputation to become more competitive and to become an<br />
investment destination. The city should <strong>of</strong>fer high quality services and promote inclusiveness and<br />
citizen friendly governance institution. Only when it is environment friendly and is well governed,<br />
the vision <strong>of</strong> the city can be realized. The institutional strategies required include:<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 44
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
Spatial integration <strong>of</strong> NNB surrounding municipalities and their service providing agencies<br />
for better planning and delivery <strong>of</strong> services (Bareilly Metropolitan Area)<br />
Establishing clear lines <strong>of</strong> accountability <strong>of</strong> service delivery agencies Constituting<br />
autonomous service delivery agencies in different structures like water supply, sanitation,<br />
sewerage, transport, roads, solid waste management etc. with NNB playing the role <strong>of</strong> a<br />
regulator.<br />
Performance based memorandum <strong>of</strong> understanding (MOU) between the Municipality (NNB)<br />
and various service delivery agencies, focusing on targets and outcomes<br />
Institutional Implementation Mechanisms<br />
Within the overall framework, institutional and implementation mechanisms need to be worked out.<br />
These include:<br />
Establishing a Reform monitoring Unit as an ‘Overseeing Body’ to monitor the reforms under<br />
way and being proposed<br />
Strengthening local Government capacities by outsourcing project management and M & E<br />
function<br />
Establishing appraisal mechanism for institutions and processes<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 45
3.1. SERVICE PROFILE OF THE <strong>CITY</strong><br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
CHAPTER 03<br />
SITUATIONAL ANALYSIS OF <strong>SANITATION</strong> IN THE <strong>CITY</strong><br />
Like most <strong>of</strong> the other Nagar Nigam, there is a large gap between the level <strong>of</strong> infrastructure services<br />
required for the city and the actual services to cater the proliferating population. In addition to this,<br />
there is also lack <strong>of</strong> operation and maintenance <strong>of</strong> existing infrastructure facilities and services –<br />
which in turn deteriorating the existing services and facilities and making much worse conditions<br />
with the city limits. The city is having high percentage share <strong>of</strong> slum population results in more<br />
unhygienic and unhealthy pockets <strong>of</strong> areas in and around the city limits. The existing facilities and<br />
services to these slum populations are also not able to cater the needs; instead - it is creating more<br />
stress on the city ecology, environment and health due to its improper functioning.<br />
Considering the existing service pr<strong>of</strong>ile <strong>of</strong> the Bareilly city which was designed to cater the growing<br />
population <strong>of</strong> Bareilly city with a population <strong>of</strong> 9.23 lacs (projected population from Census data<br />
which states that according to Census 2001 the population is 7.2 lacs); with the current family size <strong>of</strong><br />
07 - the number <strong>of</strong> households for the population size <strong>of</strong> 9.23 lacs are 1.2 lacs. Within this set <strong>of</strong><br />
population there are 85 notified slums areas which is accounting to about 25% <strong>of</strong> the total<br />
population (census 2001) i.e. about 6.28 lacs with the family size <strong>of</strong> 07 – the number <strong>of</strong> households<br />
for the slum population is 1.28 lacs. The service pr<strong>of</strong>ile <strong>of</strong> the city in this current report focuses on<br />
water supply, sewerage, and solid waste and sanitation facilities.<br />
3.1.1. WATER SUPPLY<br />
The total length <strong>of</strong> distribution network in the city is about 578 km and this network distribution<br />
includes both slum and non slum areas. The city is divided into 04 zones and the total number <strong>of</strong><br />
service connections is about 54608 which include only residential service connections. And these<br />
residential service connections include bulk supply and connections to apartments. In addition to<br />
these residential service connections, there are about 2457 commercial service connections and<br />
these include commercial establishments, shops and small scale industries.<br />
Further to this, the duration <strong>of</strong> water supply in the city is about 6 hours per day and this is further<br />
bifurcated into 3 hours in the morning and 3 hours in the evening. In addition to the household<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 46
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
service connections, there are also about 512 public stand posts and most <strong>of</strong> them are located in<br />
slum areas. The following table illustrates the broad overview <strong>of</strong> water supply facilities in the city.<br />
Data Total<br />
Working Not<br />
working/disconnected<br />
No. <strong>of</strong> Power Bores 49 49 Nil<br />
No. <strong>of</strong> hand bores 2610 2560 50<br />
No. <strong>of</strong> Bore wells Nil Nil Nil<br />
No. <strong>of</strong> Storage Reservoirs 22 22 Nil<br />
Length <strong>of</strong> Distribution Network(KM) 578.2<br />
Number <strong>of</strong> Service Connections 54608<br />
Domestic HSC House service connections 52151<br />
Commercial Connections 2457<br />
Duration 6 Hrs<br />
Number <strong>of</strong> PSPs (Public Stand Posts) 512<br />
No. <strong>of</strong> tankers(capacities also) 10 Nos., 3000 it capacity <strong>of</strong> each<br />
Total water Supplied in MLD(ward wise - 36) 102 MLD<br />
Zone -1 27 MLD<br />
Zone -2 36 MLD<br />
Zone -3 28 MLD<br />
Zone -4 11 MLD<br />
It is also important to consider the basic background information <strong>of</strong> the city likely about – number <strong>of</strong><br />
wards, slum settlements, area <strong>of</strong> the city, population distribution, number <strong>of</strong> residential properties<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 47
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
and non residential properties. The following table illustrates the data on the above mentioned<br />
categories.<br />
Unit Yr.2009<br />
Number <strong>of</strong> Wards Number 70 wards & 4<br />
zones<br />
Number <strong>of</strong> Slum Settlements Number 85<br />
Area Sq. Kms 106<br />
Population Number 923138<br />
Number <strong>of</strong> Residents Properties Number 120000<br />
Number <strong>of</strong> Non Residents Properties Number 2498<br />
The following table illustrates the property details <strong>of</strong> both residential and non residential areas in<br />
respective zones. This table also gives the areas <strong>of</strong> each zone and road length in each zone.<br />
Ward<br />
or<br />
Zone<br />
Name<br />
Slums Area (sq km) Population<br />
(number)<br />
(num<br />
ber)<br />
Households<br />
(number)<br />
Properties<br />
(number)<br />
Total Slum Total Slum Total Slum Reside<br />
ntial<br />
Non<br />
residential<br />
Road<br />
Length<br />
Zone-1 30 43.56 N.D. 253667 78654 N.D. N.D. 26361 N.D. 152.121<br />
Zone-2 19 20.10 N.D. 292650 43934 N.D. N.D. 48665 N.D. 167.886<br />
Zone-3 20 19.66 N.D. 226348 53676 N.D. N.D. 22201 N.D. 157.849<br />
Zone-4 16 23.11 N.D. 150474 47109 N.D. N.D. 23089 N.D. 109.625<br />
Total 85 106.4<br />
3<br />
0.00 923138 22337<br />
3<br />
0.00 0.00 12031<br />
6<br />
2498<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 48
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
The following table illustrates the water supply served to total population in the city and also the<br />
population served in the slum areas.<br />
Ward<br />
or Zone<br />
Name<br />
Total Population<br />
Coverage<br />
Slum<br />
population<br />
Population Served (%) Pop Served Cover<br />
age<br />
Slum (%) Per<br />
capita<br />
Supply<br />
lpcd<br />
%<br />
Passin<br />
g<br />
RC<br />
Test<br />
Availability<br />
Hours/day<br />
1 253667 190250 75% 78654 N.D. N.D. N.D. 100% 6 Hours<br />
2 292650 234120 80% 43934 N.D. N.D. N.D. 100% 6 Hours<br />
3 226348 181078 80% 53676 N.D. N.D. N.D. 100% 6 Hours<br />
4 150474 60190 40% 47109 N.D. N.D. N.D. 100% 6 Hours<br />
Total/a<br />
verage<br />
923138 665638 72% 223373 N.D. N.D. N.D. 100%<br />
It is also important to understand the type <strong>of</strong> connections in the city in different sectors. Statistical<br />
analysis shows that most <strong>of</strong> the connections at different levels are unmetered and non –functional<br />
metered connections. The following table illustrates the statistical figures <strong>of</strong> type <strong>of</strong> connections.<br />
Type <strong>of</strong> connection Unit<br />
Metered<br />
(Functional)<br />
Metered<br />
(nonfunctional)<br />
Unmetered Total<br />
House service Number Nil 35526 16625 52151<br />
Public taps Number Nil Nil 512 512<br />
Commercial Number Nil 1674 783 2457<br />
Industrial Number Nil Nil Nil Nil<br />
Institutional Number Nil Nil Nil Nil<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 49
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
Bulk supply Number Nil Nil Nil Nil<br />
Other Number Nil Nil Nil Nil<br />
Total Number Nil 37200 17920 55120<br />
The following table illustrates the type <strong>of</strong> connections that the household served. There are about<br />
54608 connections in house services, where as that <strong>of</strong> slum households are about 8865. There are<br />
also about 512 public taps connections and <strong>of</strong> which 149 public taps are serving to households in<br />
slum areas. In addition to these household connections and public taps, there are also about 1800<br />
functional hand pumps in the city and <strong>of</strong> which there are about 900 located in slum areas. The<br />
following table illustrates number <strong>of</strong> households and population served by water.<br />
Households Served<br />
Type <strong>of</strong> connection Unit Residential Slums<br />
House service Number 54608 8865<br />
Public taps Number 512 149<br />
Bulk supply Number Nil Nil<br />
Other Number Nil Nil<br />
Sub-total Number 55120 9014<br />
Other types <strong>of</strong> service Number By Tankers By Tankers<br />
Hand pumps (Functional) Number 1827 783<br />
Tankers Number - -<br />
Sub-total Number 45486 9797<br />
Total HHs served Number About 80,000 20424<br />
Total Population Served Number 636098 223156<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 50
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
The following table illustrates the different sources <strong>of</strong> water installed and total volume <strong>of</strong> water<br />
generated from different sources. Statistical figures related to sources <strong>of</strong> water and volume <strong>of</strong> water<br />
generated shows that the total volume <strong>of</strong> water produced from all different sources together is<br />
about 113 MLD and the majority share i.e. about 102 MLD is produced from ground water.<br />
Sources <strong>of</strong> water<br />
Type <strong>of</strong> Source Unit Installed<br />
capacity<br />
Volume Metered<br />
(Y/N)<br />
Ground water (power pumps) MLD 102.0 102.0 N<br />
Other sources (Hand pump) MLD 11.00 11.00 N<br />
Total 113.00 113.00<br />
The total length <strong>of</strong> distribution network in the city is about 578.20 Kms i.e. about 65 sq.km <strong>of</strong> total<br />
area <strong>of</strong> city is covered with distribution networks. And the total service storage capacity in the<br />
network is about 22.975 ML. The following statistical table also illustrates the water storage and<br />
distribution network within the city.<br />
Water storage and Distribution Network<br />
Length <strong>of</strong> distribution network Kilometers 578.20<br />
Average age <strong>of</strong> distribution Years 30<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 51
Total service storage capacity in network Million liters 22.975<br />
Tankers Trips Trips/Month As required<br />
New connections added in 2008-09 Number 516<br />
Total area covered by distribution<br />
network<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
65 Sq.Km<br />
The water service quality in Bareilly city is satisfactory. The average duration <strong>of</strong> water supply is<br />
about 6 hours a day. The average pressure in the system is about 4 metres and residual pressure at<br />
critical measure point is about only 1.5 meters. There are also leaks reported in the pipe line<br />
network and pipe breaks reported which causes hindrance to quality <strong>of</strong> water supply services. The<br />
following table illustrates the water service quality factors.<br />
Water Service Quality<br />
Average duration <strong>of</strong> water supply Hours/day 6.00<br />
Average pressure in the system Meters 4.00<br />
Residual pressure at critical<br />
measurement point<br />
Meters 1.5<br />
Leaks reported in the year Number 1125<br />
Leaks repaired in the year Number 1125<br />
Pipe breaks repaired in the year Number 415<br />
Details <strong>of</strong> Water Quality Lab Utility/Other Other<br />
The following table illustrates the treated water quality surveillance with accordance to number <strong>of</strong><br />
samples tested for residual chlorine, bacteriological and physical/ chemicals at different points and<br />
the number <strong>of</strong> tests passed.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 52
Treated Water Quality Surveillance<br />
Sample Location<br />
At the outlet <strong>of</strong> WTP<br />
At intermediate points<br />
Sampling<br />
Residual<br />
Chlorine<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
Number <strong>of</strong> Samples Tested For<br />
Bacteriological<br />
At consumer end 4580 4500 36 44<br />
Total 4580 36 44<br />
Total Tests Passed 4580 4500 36 44<br />
Tests required as per standard ND ND ND ND<br />
Physical/<br />
chemical<br />
The following table illustrated the customer services from water supply department to general<br />
public.<br />
Customer Services<br />
Complaints on no water, quality <strong>of</strong> water during the<br />
year<br />
Number 52<br />
Complaints redressed within 24 hrs during the year Number 48<br />
Other complaints recorded during the year Number 1125<br />
Other complaints resolved during the year Number 1112<br />
The following table illustrates the ways <strong>of</strong> making complaints about the service <strong>of</strong> water supply<br />
Ways <strong>of</strong> making complaints<br />
At utility <strong>of</strong>fice Yes/No Yes<br />
Letter Yes/No Yes<br />
Telephone Yes/No Yes<br />
E-mail Yes/No Yes<br />
SMS Yes/No Yes<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 53
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
But the level <strong>of</strong> computerization is not available at any level <strong>of</strong> organization. The following table<br />
shows the level <strong>of</strong> computerization at different sectors <strong>of</strong> water supply department.<br />
Level <strong>of</strong> computerization<br />
Billing System Yes/No No<br />
Customer Complaints Yes/No No<br />
Accounts Yes/No No<br />
Administration/HR Yes/No No<br />
The following table illustrates the percentage share <strong>of</strong> total budget <strong>of</strong> water supply for urban poor.<br />
ULB policy for providing water to the urban poor<br />
Please state the policy<br />
20% <strong>of</strong> the Total Budget <strong>of</strong> water supply is mandatory for urban poor.<br />
It is also important to consider the staff information for water supply department. The following<br />
table illustrates the number <strong>of</strong> technical and non technical staff information <strong>of</strong> water supply<br />
department.<br />
Staff Information<br />
Category<br />
Unit Technical<br />
Nontechnical<br />
Class I Number 01 Nil<br />
Class II Number 01 Nil<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 54
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
Class III Number 04 18<br />
Class IV Number 38 84<br />
Contracted staff Number Nil Nil<br />
Other Number Nil Nil<br />
Total Number 44 102<br />
On the other hand, there is also private sector participation in water supply operations. The<br />
following table illustrates the service contracted to private sector and their type <strong>of</strong> contracts, its<br />
contract period and value.<br />
Private Sector Participation in Water Supply Operations<br />
Service Contracted<br />
Contract<br />
Type<br />
Contract<br />
Period<br />
Value Rs.<br />
Per Year<br />
Operation <strong>of</strong> Tube Well Labor rate 1 Year 27.00 Lac<br />
Hand pump Maintenance Job work 1 Year 13.41 Lac<br />
The following table illustrates the financial information <strong>of</strong> the water supply department:<br />
Financial Information<br />
Annual Operating Revenues from<br />
Consumption<br />
Opening Balance as on 31-03-08 Rs. Lakhs 120.16<br />
Demand raised for the period 2008-<br />
09<br />
Rs. Lakhs 201.45<br />
House Service Connections Rs. Lakhs 104.56<br />
- Public taps Rs. Lakhs Nil<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 55
- Commercial Rs. Lakhs N.D.<br />
- Industrial Rs. Lakhs Nil<br />
- Bulk supply Rs. Lakhs Nil<br />
- Other Rs. Lakhs Nil<br />
Total Revenue Demand Rs. Lakhs 426.17<br />
Collection against arrears Rs. Lakhs 73.53<br />
Collection against current demand Rs. Lakhs 171.58<br />
Closing Balance as on 31-03-09 Rs. Lakhs 181.06<br />
Other revenues (taxes, connection<br />
fees)<br />
Debt Service (interests & principal) in<br />
Rupees<br />
Annual Operation Expenses (Rupees in Lakhs)<br />
Category<br />
Rs. Lakhs Nil<br />
Regular Staff Costs Rs. Laks 261.00<br />
Contracted Staff Costs Rs. Laks 27.00<br />
Electricity charges/Fuel costs Rs. Laks 498.00<br />
Chemical Costs Rs. Laks 7.50<br />
Repairs/Maintenance costs Rs. Laks 169.00<br />
Contracted Service Costs Rs. Laks Nil<br />
Bulk Supply (Raw/Treated Water) Rs. Laks Nil<br />
Depreciation Rs. Laks Nil<br />
Other Costs Rs. Laks Nil<br />
Total Rs. Laks 962.50<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
Rs. Lakhs 2.17<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 56
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
The following table illustrates the capital expenditure and different sources <strong>of</strong> capital investments <strong>of</strong><br />
water supply department.<br />
Key Issues:<br />
Capital expenditure during the year Rs. Lakhs 93.36<br />
Sources <strong>of</strong> capital investments<br />
Government Grants Rs. Lakhs 8.93<br />
Loans from Government Rs. Lakhs Nil<br />
Loans from Multilaterals Rs. Lakhs Nil<br />
Loans from Public Banks Rs. Lakhs Nil<br />
Loans from Private banks Rs. Lakhs Nil<br />
Market Borrowing Rs. Lakhs Nil<br />
Total Rs. Lakhs 8.93<br />
The total water supplied is about 124 MLD.<br />
The availability <strong>of</strong> water is adequate but distribution system needs improvement.<br />
Issues are that numbers <strong>of</strong> connection is not increasing due to excess use <strong>of</strong> ground water,<br />
low pressure and unreliable service, low utilization due to old and leaky system, Inadequate<br />
funds for O&M.<br />
The need is felt to expand distribution as demand is high.<br />
The piped water supply <strong>of</strong> Bareilly City was started about 30 years ago.<br />
The distribution network covers 60% <strong>of</strong> the city area.<br />
The leakage (UFW - unaccounted-for water) is estimated to be 30 percent due to old and<br />
leaky pipelines.<br />
The most significant drawback <strong>of</strong> Bareilly water supply is the huge amount <strong>of</strong> water wastage<br />
and negligible revenue collection from public utilities (for example parks and fire fighting<br />
etc.) and stand posts which takes away about 10 percent <strong>of</strong> water.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 57
SEWERAGE<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
The total length <strong>of</strong> sewerage network pipes in the city is about 206.2 km but, the age <strong>of</strong> the<br />
sewerage network pipes is about 35 years. Further, the total area covered by sewerage network is<br />
only about 25 sq.km. The total municipal water supplied is about 113 MLD and that from other<br />
sources is about 11.54 MLD. The total water supplied is about 124.54 MLD <strong>of</strong> which 99.2 MLD <strong>of</strong><br />
waste water is being generated from different sources within the city. The following table illustrates<br />
the volume <strong>of</strong> drinking water consumed and waste water generated from different sources within<br />
the city.<br />
Volumes <strong>of</strong> Drinking Water Consumed and Wastewater Generated<br />
Type <strong>of</strong> connected Property Unit ULB<br />
Drinking Water Consumed Wastewater<br />
Water<br />
Supply<br />
Other<br />
Source<br />
Total<br />
Generated<br />
80% <strong>of</strong><br />
water<br />
supplied<br />
Residential MLD n.a. n.a n.a n.a.<br />
Public taps MLD n.a. n.a. n.a. n.a.<br />
Industrial MLD n.a. n.a. n.a. n.a.<br />
Institutional MLD n.a. n.a. n.a. n.a.<br />
Other MLD n.a. n.a. n.a. n.a.<br />
Total MLD 113.0 11.54 124.54 99.2<br />
The following table illustrates the length <strong>of</strong> sewer lines in each zone and the area covered,<br />
properties with toilets connected to sewer lines, flood prone areas and water logging areas.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 58
Ward/<br />
Zone<br />
Zone -<br />
1<br />
Zone -<br />
2<br />
Zone -<br />
3<br />
Zone -<br />
4<br />
Sever Lines Properties with toilets<br />
connected to<br />
Length Area<br />
covere<br />
d<br />
(km) (sq km)<br />
Sewer<br />
s lines<br />
Soak<br />
pits<br />
Storm<br />
drains<br />
or<br />
canals<br />
Properti<br />
es<br />
without<br />
access<br />
to<br />
toilets<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
Standalone<br />
Sewage<br />
w/effluent<br />
disposal<br />
Flood<br />
Prone<br />
Areas<br />
(numbe<br />
r)<br />
Waterlogging<br />
Flooding<br />
(number<br />
)<br />
43 9.00 1517 N.D. N.D. N.D. N.D 05 07<br />
71 8.46 4044 N.D. N.D. N.D. N.D 12 14<br />
59 3.97 4045 N.D. N.D. N.D. N.D - 06<br />
33 4.33 2022 N.D. N.D. N.D. N.D 04 03<br />
Total 206 25.76 11628 N.D. N.D. 10026 N.D 21 30<br />
But, there is no treatment <strong>of</strong> the waste water that is being generated within the city.<br />
It is also important to consider the Septage management in the city. The sludge and effluent waste<br />
that is being collected in the soak pits and septic tanks is being collect by the Septage sucking<br />
machines handled by NNB. But the sludge that is being collected, discharged/disposed into open<br />
drains. The following table illustrates the Septage management in the city:<br />
Septage Management<br />
Does to NNB practice Septage Management Yes/No Yes<br />
Septage Sucking Machines available within NNB Number 2<br />
Private Septage Machine Licensed by NNB Number Nil<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 59
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
The following are the sewerage related complaints recorded in the year and the number <strong>of</strong> sewerage<br />
related complaints rectified in the year.<br />
Sewage related complaints Recorded in the year Number 3850<br />
Sewage related complaints Rectified in the year Number 3837<br />
There are different ways <strong>of</strong> making complaints. The following table illustrates the ways <strong>of</strong> making<br />
complaints.<br />
Ways <strong>of</strong> making complaints<br />
At Utility <strong>of</strong>fice Yes/No Yes<br />
Letter Yes/No Yes<br />
Telephone Yes/No Yes<br />
E-Mail Yes/No No<br />
SMS Yes/No No<br />
Policy for Sewerage connection for the urban poor<br />
There is no any specific policy for sewer connections to urban poor. But normal fee’s for sewer<br />
connection is only Rs. 250/- which is very less and any one got sewer connection by deposit Rs. 250/-<br />
only.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 60
The following table illustrates the staff information details:<br />
Staff Information<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
Type <strong>of</strong> Staff Unit Technical Non Technical<br />
Class I Number 01 Nil<br />
Class II Number 01 Nil<br />
Class III Number 02 01<br />
Class IV Number 12 103<br />
Other Number Nil 35<br />
Contracted Staff Number Nil Nil<br />
Total Number 16 139<br />
There is also private sector participation in sewage activities. The following table illustrates the<br />
private sector participation in sewage, service contracted, its contract type, period and its value.<br />
Private Sector Participate in Sewage<br />
Service Contracted Contact Type Period Value Rs<br />
Sewer Cleaning Labor Rate 3 month 4.95<br />
Operation <strong>of</strong> Sewer Pumping Station Job Work 1 year 4.05<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 61
The following table illustrates the financial information<br />
Financial Information<br />
Annual Operating Revenues (Rupees in Lakhs)<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
Opening Balance as on 31 st March 2008 Rs.Lakhs 26.19<br />
Demand Raised for the Period 2008-09 Rs.Lakhs 50.80<br />
Collection against arrears Rs.Lakhs 9.38<br />
Collection against current Demand Rs.Lakhs 21.89<br />
Closing Balance as on 31 st March 2009 Rs.Lakhs 19.53<br />
Other Revenue (Taxes, Connection Fees) Rs.Lakhs N.D.<br />
Annual Operating Expense (Rupees in Lakhs)<br />
Staff Rs.Lakhs 94.98<br />
Power/Fuel Rs.Lakhs 21.46<br />
Chemicals Rs.Lakhs nil<br />
Repairs/Maintenance Rs.Lakhs 92.23<br />
Administrative & other establishment Rs.Lakhs N.D.<br />
Contracted Labor Rs.Lakhs 19.80<br />
Deprecation Rs.Lakhs N.D.<br />
Contractor costs for O&M Rs.Lakhs N.D.<br />
Total Rs.Lakhs 228.47<br />
Type <strong>of</strong> Staff Unit No. <strong>of</strong> Staff<br />
Class I Number 03<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 62
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
Class II Number 04<br />
Class III Number 16<br />
Class IV Number 320<br />
Other Number -<br />
Contracted Staff Number 130<br />
Total Number 473<br />
Annual Operating Expense (Rupees in Lakhs)<br />
Staff Rs.Lakhs 80.00<br />
Equipment Rs.Lakhs 04.60<br />
Repairs/Maintenance Rs.Lakhs 12.10<br />
Administrative & other establishment Rs.Lakhs 5.00<br />
Contracted Labor Rs.Lakhs 11.70<br />
Contractor costs for Maintenance Rs.Lakhs 10.00<br />
Total Rs.Lakhs 123.40<br />
Debt Service (interests & principals) Rs.Lakhs Nil<br />
Capital Expenditure For the year Rs.Lakhs 123.40<br />
The following table illustrates the source <strong>of</strong> capital investments<br />
Source <strong>of</strong> Capital investment<br />
Government Grant Rs.Lakhs 80.00<br />
Loans from Government Rs.Lakhs Nil<br />
Loans from Foreign Agencies Rs.Lakhs Nil<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 63
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
Government Banks Rs.Lakhs Nil<br />
Commercial Banks/Bonds Rs.Lakhs Nil<br />
Total Rs.Lakhs 80.00<br />
Key Issues:<br />
The source <strong>of</strong> sewer is mostly from domestic households.<br />
The total length <strong>of</strong> sewerage network pipes in the city is about 206.2 km but, the age <strong>of</strong> the<br />
sewerage network pipes is only about 35 years.<br />
The total area covered by sewerage network is only about 25 sq.km<br />
The thus produced waste water is about 99.2 MLD from all the sources within the city.<br />
No sewerage treatment plant.<br />
STORM WATER DRAINS<br />
The following table illustrates the storm water drainage network for each zone. The table illustrates<br />
the number <strong>of</strong> slum areas in each zone, total area <strong>of</strong> storm water drainage network in each zone and<br />
total length <strong>of</strong> roads in each zone. This also illustrates the total length <strong>of</strong> drains – primary, secondary<br />
and tertiary drains within the city. The following also illustrates the major flood prone drains.<br />
Word Name Read Total Length <strong>of</strong> Drains Flood Prone<br />
Length Primary Secondary Tertiary Areas<br />
(K.M) (K.M) (K.M) (K.M) (Number)<br />
Ward-1 Jatavpura 6.636 9.60 1.60 0.80 -<br />
Ward-2 Biharipur Civil<br />
Lines<br />
Ward-3 Nawada<br />
Shakhan<br />
5.840 6.60 3.00 2.00 -<br />
9.212 13.20 3.20 1.80 -<br />
Ward-4 Suger Foctory 4.845 7.50 1.00 1.10 -<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 64
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
Ward-5 Noumehla 10.872 15.20 4.10 2.50 -<br />
Ward-6 Nakpur 7.366 12.10 1.50 1.13 One<br />
Ward-7 Delapeer 13.530 19.40 4.20 3.40<br />
Ward-8 VeerBatti 8.455 14.10 1.80 0.90 One<br />
Ward-9 Haziyapur 8.775 9.92 3.40 2.08 -<br />
Ward-10 Katra Chand<br />
Khan<br />
5.435 8.50 1.50 0.80 -<br />
Ward-11 Sanjay Nager 12.735 21.60 2.32 1.50 -<br />
Ward-12 Sneiya Dhan<br />
Singh<br />
12.445 17.40 4.15 3.32 One<br />
Ward-13 I.V.R.I 8.358 14.80 1.20 0.60 -<br />
Ward-14 Marinath 7.547 11.40 2.30 1.27 One<br />
Ward-15 Harunagla 14.340 22.90 3.25 2.50 One<br />
Ward-16 Awas Vikas 10.973 18.50 2.25 1.0 -<br />
Ward-17 Nadousi 10.767 20.30 0.600 0.500 -<br />
Ward-18 Madel Town 12.872 17.10 3.50 2.30 -<br />
Ward-19 Moula Nagar 6.246 8.70 2.25 1.53 -<br />
Ward-20 Bankhana 5.626 7.5 2.40 1.30 -<br />
Ward-21 Azam Nagar 9.352 16.80 1.21 0.600 -<br />
Ward-22 Kanjadasspur 7.365 10.60 2.50 1.50 -<br />
Ward-23 Partapur<br />
Choudry<br />
Ward-24 Banipur<br />
Choudry<br />
8.676 13.85 2.10 1.25 -<br />
10.556 17.75 2.20 1.15 One<br />
Ward-25 Katghar 6.353 8.15 2.70 1.75 One<br />
Ward-26 Knoongoyan 6.340 10.60 1.50 0.70 -<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 65
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
Ward-27 Swale Nagar 10.827 19.90 1.30 0.400 One<br />
Ward-28 Kalilpur 10.736 20.20 1.60 - -<br />
Ward-29 Indra Nagar 8.772 11.65 3.25 2.50 -<br />
Ward-30 Malukpur 5.372 7.15 2.30 1.15 -<br />
Ward-31 Rampur<br />
Gardun<br />
Ward-32 Faridapur<br />
Choudry<br />
Ward-33 Choudry<br />
Moulla<br />
10.872 16.15 3.20 2.25 -<br />
6.448 8.400 2.600 1.800 One<br />
6.533 7.400 3.200 2.100 -<br />
Ward-34 Mathurapur 12.553 22.50 1.800 0.800 -<br />
Ward-35 Kuwarpur 5.363 7.400 2.200 1.00 -<br />
Ward-36 Gandhi Udhyan 10.735 15.10 3.600 2.80 -<br />
Ward-37 Shaukara 6.732 9.10 2.80 1.50 -<br />
Ward-38 Shikarpur 7.656 9.75 3.20 2.25 One<br />
Ward-39 Biharipur<br />
Mamran<br />
6.358 9.40 3.30 - -<br />
Ward-40 Saidpur Hakins 12.357 20.50 2.70 1.50 One<br />
Ward-41 Bukharpura 8.353 10.90 3.50 2.25 -<br />
Ward-42 Subhash Nagar 5.782 7.85 2.10 1.45 One<br />
Ward-43 Surkha Chavni 14.268 24.30 2.75 1.35 -<br />
Ward-44 Gandhi Nagar 9.356 14.05 3.10 1.45 -<br />
Ward-45 Joherpur 11.753 18.100 3.60 1.80 -<br />
Ward-46 Nawada<br />
Jogiyan<br />
15.835 26.800 3.20 1.60 -<br />
Ward-47 Bhoor 6.340 8.100 3.10 1.40 -<br />
Ward-48 Peer Bhoura 8.537 13.200 2.30 1.20 -<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 66
Ward-49 Rhapura<br />
Choudry<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
10.977 15.800 3.80 2.30 -<br />
Ward-50 So<strong>of</strong>i Tola 5.265 7.700 1.70 1.10 -<br />
Ward-51 Phaltoon Ganj 6.358 10.300 1.60 0.80 -<br />
Ward-52 Bhidhouliya 12.753 18.800 3.90 2.80 -<br />
Ward-53 Khannu<br />
Mhoulla<br />
5.380 8.500 1.40 0.80 -<br />
Ward-54 Kanker Tola 6.563 9.70 2.30 1.10 -<br />
Ward-55 Gulab Nagar 6.872 10.20 2.50 0.900 -<br />
Ward-56 Shabad 5.932 9.30 1.80 0.700 -<br />
Ward-57 Maheshpur<br />
Atariya<br />
11.768 20.10 2.80 0.600 One<br />
Ward-58 Shadana 6.454 8.55 2.75 1.50 -<br />
Ward-59 Bagariya<br />
Puranmal<br />
6.968 11.05 1.80 0.95 -<br />
Ward-60 Katkuiya 6.350 10.35 2.35 - -<br />
Ward-61 Nawi Basti 7.360 10.10 2.40 2.20 -<br />
Ward-62 Shiklapur 5.323 6.35 2.50 1.75 -<br />
Ward-63 Allamgiri Ganj 5.872 8.85 2.75 - -<br />
Ward-64 Chuk<br />
Mahmood<br />
8.427 13.30 2.40 1.10 -<br />
Ward-65 English Ganj 3.762 8.30 3.10 - -<br />
Ward-66 Shoudagran 6.378 9.75 2.85 - -<br />
Ward-67 Azaz Nagar 10.810 10.55 2.80 2.25 -<br />
Ward-68 Rholi Tola 8.756 15.10 2.30 - -<br />
Ward-69 Ghar Shakh<br />
Mithoo<br />
0.368 10.200 2.40 - -<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 67
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
Ward- 70 Rabri Tola 5.130 8.40 1.80 - -<br />
Total<br />
586.881 903.22 176.43 92.68<br />
The flood prone areas are – ganesh nagar, shanty vihar, ravindar nagar, ganga nagar, mandinath,<br />
vishwanath puram, veera batatti, Subhash nagar, joginavadaa, hajiyapura, sanjay nagar, chak<br />
mahamud, yejajnagar ghautiya, gausai ghautai, indira nagar, bakarganj etc.<br />
Key Issues:<br />
Each ward is having primary, secondary and tertiary drains <strong>of</strong> different lengths.<br />
The waste drained into these nallas - includes waste water from households, commercial<br />
areas, and industrial areas.<br />
Most <strong>of</strong> the open/ closed drains are chocked with solid waste and sludge.<br />
There are many flood prone drains within the city.<br />
SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT<br />
There is a heavy waste generated within the city from many sources, but there is no household door<br />
to door collection <strong>of</strong> solid waste management services in the city. The total waste generated in the<br />
city is about 450 metric tons per day. And the majority share <strong>of</strong> waste that is being generated is from<br />
households. There is also relatively high share <strong>of</strong> waste generation i.e. about 95 MT/day from<br />
markets. The following table illustrates the quantity <strong>of</strong> waste generation from different sources<br />
within the city.<br />
Waste Generation<br />
Waste Generated by Households MT/day 230<br />
Waste Generated by Street Sweeping MT/day 39<br />
Waste Generated by Hotels and<br />
Restaurants<br />
MT/day 52<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 68
Waste Generated by Markets (Vegetable<br />
Markets, Mandis etc)<br />
Waste Generated by Commercial<br />
Establishments ( Institutions, etc)<br />
Waste Generated by other sources ( debris,<br />
horticulture waste etc)<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
MT/day 95<br />
MT/day 14<br />
MT/day 20<br />
Total Estimated Waste Generated MT/day 450<br />
There is no arrangement <strong>of</strong> solid waste treatment in the city. Since, there is no processing/ recycling<br />
unit – the extent <strong>of</strong> municipal solid waste recovered is nil. The waste that is being collected from the<br />
secondary sources <strong>of</strong> points is being disposed <strong>of</strong>f in the open dump sites. The total waste that is<br />
being generated from different sources within the city is about 450 MT/ day and the total waste that<br />
is being collected and disposed <strong>of</strong>f is about only 420 MT/ month. The rest 30 MT is loss due to<br />
transportation losses.<br />
EXTENT OF SCIENTIFIC DISPOSAL OF MUNICIPAL SOLID WASTE 0<br />
Quantity <strong>of</strong> Waste Disposal<br />
Quantity <strong>of</strong> waste disposed in compliant landfill sites MT/month 0<br />
Quantity <strong>of</strong> waste disposed in open dump sites MT/month 420<br />
There are many problems raised by public in solid waste management, but the efficiency in redressal<br />
<strong>of</strong> customer complaints in about 96%. The following table illustrates the redressal mechanism details<br />
<strong>of</strong> solid waste management.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 69
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
EFFICIENCY IN REDRESSAL OF CUSTOMER COMPLAINTS 96.35417<br />
Customer Service<br />
Complaints received during the year Number 768<br />
Complaints resolved within 24 hours during the year Number 740<br />
The following table illustrates the financial information on solid waste management.<br />
Financial Information - Operational Expenditure on SWM during previous<br />
year<br />
Regular Staff & Administration Rs. In<br />
Lakhs<br />
Outsourced/Contracted Staff Costs Rs. In<br />
Lakhs<br />
Electricity Charges/Fuel Costs Rs. In<br />
Lakhs<br />
Chemical Costs Rs. In<br />
Lakhs<br />
Repair/Maintenance Costs Rs. In<br />
Lakhs<br />
Contracted Services Cost Rs. In<br />
Lakhs<br />
Other Costs (Specify) Rs. In<br />
Lakhs<br />
2,331.7<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 70<br />
9<br />
13.21<br />
216.60<br />
Total Operational Expenses Rs. In 2577.6<br />
6.00<br />
0<br />
0<br />
10
Staff Information<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
Lakhs<br />
Senior Management-Health Officer (Sanctioned) Number 2<br />
Senior Management-Health Officer (Working) Number 2<br />
Sanitary Inspector (Sanctioned) Number 2<br />
Sanitary Inspector (Working) Number 0<br />
Sanitary Supervisor (Sanctioned) Number 3<br />
Sanitary Supervisor (Working) Number 2<br />
Maistries/Safai Karam chari (Sanctioned) Number 250<br />
Maistries/Safai Karam chari (Working) Number 242<br />
Cleaners/Drivers (Sanctioned) Number 450<br />
Cleaners/Drivers (Working) Number 567<br />
Labourers (Sanctioned) Number 0<br />
Labourers (Working) Number 0<br />
Others Specify Number 0<br />
Total (Sanctioned) Number 707<br />
Total (Working) Number 813<br />
Key Issues<br />
The issues confronting in collection <strong>of</strong> garbage at Bareilly are as under:-<br />
No processing/ recycling facilities.<br />
No door to door collection <strong>of</strong> waste.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 71
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
The dumping grounds, by roadside and elsewhere, are unhygienic and have deplorable look.<br />
Disposal <strong>of</strong> waste into drains leads to choking <strong>of</strong> drains<br />
Rains washed out part <strong>of</strong> garbage from these secondary points into drains and Nalas which<br />
leads to silting.<br />
Mixing <strong>of</strong> bio-medical and other forms <strong>of</strong> waste with municipal waste is a serious health<br />
hazard.<br />
Lack <strong>of</strong> segregation <strong>of</strong> bio-degradable and non-degradable waste at source<br />
Large scale public littering leading to inattentiveness <strong>of</strong> street sweeping and cleaning<br />
activities<br />
Shortage <strong>of</strong> staff and lack <strong>of</strong> motivation amongst the existing staff<br />
Presently there is no waste processing plant at Bareilly and the total waste is dumped<br />
openly.<br />
At present waste generation in the city is around 450MT per day.<br />
For Bareilly, household and organic waste constitutes largest component followed by inert<br />
material such as building material and debris etc. in overall composition <strong>of</strong> waste i.e. waste<br />
generated from households, commercial establishments and institutions in Bareilly.<br />
The main sources <strong>of</strong> waste generation includes Residential, commercial, industrial<br />
establishments, hospital & nursing homes, hotels & restaurants, slaughter houses, street<br />
sweeping, sanitary drains and construction and demolition sites.<br />
The quantity <strong>of</strong> waste generated from these medical institutions is approx 2.74 tonnes per<br />
day.<br />
Out <strong>of</strong> total bio -waste generated, only 1350 Kg (about 20 %) is sent to the centralized bio-<br />
medical waste management facility. Some estimate that about 30 percent <strong>of</strong> bio-medical<br />
waste is getting mixed up with other type <strong>of</strong> waste.<br />
Most <strong>of</strong> the slaughtered waste is thrown into the nallas. Total waste generation is<br />
approximately 4-5ton/day.<br />
The dust generated through street sweeping constitutes 5% (72.35 MT) <strong>of</strong> total waste.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 72
The drain silt constitutes about 15% <strong>of</strong> the MSW generated in Bareilly city.<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
A major portion <strong>of</strong> this waste is generally used in reconstruction activities for filling up <strong>of</strong> the<br />
low-lying areas or kutcha road – i.e. about 20% <strong>of</strong> this waste is collected at these sites and<br />
become a part <strong>of</strong> MSW.<br />
3.2. ASSESSMENT OF <strong>SANITATION</strong> FACILITIES AND SITUATION IN POTENTIAL AREAS<br />
<strong>SANITATION</strong> FACILITIES AND SITUATION AT HOUSEHOLD LEVEL (SLUM AND NON-SLUM AREAS):<br />
An extensive survey has been conducted, which includes primary household surveys, focused group<br />
discussions and field visit surveys - that are primarily conducted to understand the exiting situation<br />
<strong>of</strong> sanitation facilities at household levels both in slum and non slum areas and identify the key<br />
issues and gaps in the sanitary facilities at this level. The present population in total city is about 9.23<br />
lacs with a bifurcation <strong>of</strong> slum and non slum population. Statistics show that there is about 26% <strong>of</strong><br />
the slum population i.e. about 2.44 lacs and the remaining in non slum areas i.e. about 6.79 lacs. The<br />
non slum population includes HIG, MIG and LIG and also non notified slums that can be categorized<br />
into low income population groups. The number <strong>of</strong> slums that are notified are about 85 in number<br />
that spread across the city. In addition to these notified slums there are number <strong>of</strong> unnotified slums<br />
and are categorized in low income groups in Bareilly. Further considering the number <strong>of</strong> households<br />
in slum areas – the number <strong>of</strong> households in slum areas is about 31850 and the number <strong>of</strong><br />
households in non slum areas is about 88466. The following table shows the population and<br />
household distribution in slum and non slum areas.<br />
Non Slum Slum<br />
Percentage 73.53% 26.45%<br />
Population 6.76 lacs 2.44 lacs<br />
Household 88466 31850<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 73
total no. <strong>of</strong> HH 120316<br />
slum pop 244170<br />
non slum pop 678968<br />
total 923138<br />
slum HH 31850<br />
non slum HH 88466<br />
total 120316<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
% no. <strong>of</strong> HH<br />
dry latrine 10.8 12994<br />
pour flush 74.2 89274<br />
no toilets 15 18047<br />
CT 6.37 1150<br />
OD 14.04 16897<br />
Further considering the different types <strong>of</strong> individual toilet facilities in Bareilly city are soak pit toilets,<br />
pour flush toilets, Kuddi. Kuddi is a small structure built on bricks and is directly connected to an<br />
open nalla. This is very prevalent in slum areas. The only difference is that these people don’t open<br />
defecate rather leaves it directly to drain which is much more dangerous. Gaddewali is also<br />
prevalent in places where there is availability <strong>of</strong> space good enough. A pit like structure is built with<br />
admeasuring 4X4 or 4X6 structure closed by a slab. This gets filled generally by a year or two and is<br />
cleaned by the municipal vehicle (sludge sucking machine and thrown into a bigger nalas) on the<br />
payment basis. From the primary analysis, focused group discussion and stakeholder meetings it is<br />
known that about 94% <strong>of</strong> the non slum households are with household individual toilets – and these<br />
household individual toilets include pit latrine, water closet, and septic tank. In addition to the above<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 74
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
mentioned households and their access to different types <strong>of</strong> individual toilets – there is also certain<br />
portion <strong>of</strong> population, i.e. from the primary survey analysis shows that there is about 1% <strong>of</strong> the total<br />
number <strong>of</strong> households in non slum areas using community toilets.<br />
non slum population total<br />
total 678968 923138<br />
access to toilets 638230 784732<br />
no toilets 40738 138406<br />
CT 407 8816<br />
OD 40331 129590<br />
non slum HH total<br />
total 88466 120316<br />
access to toilets 83158 102268<br />
no toilets 5308 18048<br />
CT 53.08 1150<br />
OD 5255 16898<br />
The analysis shows that there are about 83158 households have access to individual household<br />
toilets i.e. about 6.38 lacs population from non slum areas. There is about 5% <strong>of</strong> the total number <strong>of</strong><br />
households do not have any kind <strong>of</strong> access to toilets i.e. about 5255 households i.e. about 40<br />
thousand <strong>of</strong> population in non slum areas defecate openly. This is only because <strong>of</strong> the number <strong>of</strong><br />
unnotified slums/ low income group households/ population categories into non slum regions and<br />
location <strong>of</strong> low income groups.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 75
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
Further considering the sanitation facilities in slum areas, the access to individual toilets is very poor.<br />
There is more access to community toilets than the individual/ private toilets. The different types <strong>of</strong><br />
toilets at individual level in slum areas that are most prevalent are pour flush toilets, Kuddi,<br />
Gaddewali/ soak pit and community toilets. The usage <strong>of</strong> community toilets is very prevalent in slum<br />
areas. The pour flush type <strong>of</strong> toilets at individual level includes the individual toilets provided by ILCS<br />
i.e. about 5826 HH are constructed mainly in slum areas to reduce the open defecation and improve<br />
the sanitary conditions by DUDA.<br />
Further considering the percentage share <strong>of</strong> households/ population having access to household<br />
individual toilets is about 60% <strong>of</strong> the households and these also include the individual pour flush<br />
toilets build by different agencies as mentioned above. These different types <strong>of</strong> households include<br />
pour flush, soak pits, toilets connected to open drain. From the primary survey analysis, focused<br />
group discussions and field visits shows that there are about 5% <strong>of</strong> slum households in addition to<br />
the private/ public individual toilets there are also community toilets in the slum areas – which<br />
majorly cater to the certain share <strong>of</strong> the slum population. There are about 23 community toilets in<br />
Bareilly city – <strong>of</strong> which 21 community toilets are located in slum areas, each catering to about 15 (no.<br />
<strong>of</strong> seats in a community toilet) X 35 (no. <strong>of</strong> persons per seat per day) i.e. about a total population <strong>of</strong><br />
8049 i.e. about 1097 households i.e. about 5% <strong>of</strong> the total slum populations are dependent on<br />
community toilets. This shows that there is about 36.5% <strong>of</strong> the total slum population are using other<br />
options i.e. open defecation is very common i.e. about 11643 slum households i.e. about 89259 <strong>of</strong><br />
population.<br />
slum population total<br />
Total 244170 923138<br />
access to toilets 146502 784732<br />
no toilets 97668 138406<br />
CT 8409 8816<br />
OD 89259 129590<br />
slum HH total<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 76
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
Total 31850 120316<br />
access to toilets 19110 102268<br />
no toilets 12740 18048<br />
CT 1097 1150<br />
OD 11643 16898<br />
Finally for the analysis, it is shown that about 5% <strong>of</strong> the non slum area population and about 36.5%<br />
<strong>of</strong> the slum area populations do not have any access to toilet facilities and they open defecate. This<br />
shows that about 40331 persons in non slum areas i.e. about 5255 <strong>of</strong> households defecate openly.<br />
And about 89259 persons in slum areas i.e. about 11643 households defecate openly. On the whole<br />
there are about 1.29 lacs <strong>of</strong> total population i.e. about 16898 <strong>of</strong> households <strong>of</strong> Bareilly city i.e. about<br />
14.04% <strong>of</strong> the total population/ households <strong>of</strong> Bareilly open defecate.<br />
Key Issues:<br />
The present population in total city is about 9.23 lacs with a bifurcation <strong>of</strong> slum and non<br />
slum population. Statistics show that there is about 27% <strong>of</strong> the slum population i.e. about<br />
2.44 lacs and the remaining in non slum areas i.e. about 6.74lacs.<br />
The numbers <strong>of</strong> slums that are notified are about 85 in number that spread across the city.<br />
In addition to these notified slums there are number <strong>of</strong> unnotified slums and are categorized<br />
in low income groups in Bareilly.<br />
The different types <strong>of</strong> individual toilet facilities in Bareilly city are soak pit toilets, WC with<br />
septic tanks, pour flush toilets , Kuddi etc.<br />
About 94% <strong>of</strong> the non slum households are with household individual toilets – and these<br />
household individual toilets include pit latrine, water closet with septic tank.<br />
There is about 1-2% <strong>of</strong> the total number <strong>of</strong> households in non slum areas using community<br />
toilets.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 77
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
There is about 5% <strong>of</strong> the total number <strong>of</strong> households do not have any kind <strong>of</strong> access to<br />
toilets i.e. about 5255 households i.e. about 40 thousand <strong>of</strong> population in non slum areas<br />
defecate openly.<br />
The percentage share <strong>of</strong> households/ population having access to household individual<br />
toilets is about 60% <strong>of</strong> the households and these also include the individual pour flush toilets<br />
build by different agencies as mentioned above.<br />
There are about 5% <strong>of</strong> slum households in addition to the private/ public individual toilets<br />
there are also community toilets in the slum areas.<br />
About 89259 persons in slum areas i.e. about 11643 households defecate openly.<br />
There are about 1.29 lacs <strong>of</strong> total population i.e. about 16898 <strong>of</strong> households <strong>of</strong> Bareilly city<br />
i.e. about 14.04% <strong>of</strong> the total population/ households <strong>of</strong> Bareilly open defecate.<br />
<strong>SANITATION</strong> FACILITIES AND SITUATION AT COMMUNITY TOILETS:<br />
One <strong>of</strong> the most dependent sanitary facilities in the city for about 5 – 10% <strong>of</strong> the total households is<br />
community toilets. There are about 23 community toilets with about 21 <strong>of</strong> them located in slum<br />
areas and the rest in non slum regions i.e. in low income group areas. Thus, it is important to analyze<br />
the situation <strong>of</strong> these facilities for any further improvements or to give any proposals for situational<br />
development <strong>of</strong> the existing status. The following table gives the distribution <strong>of</strong> community toilets<br />
according the different development agencies in Bareilly.<br />
Organization Community Toilets<br />
DUDA 02<br />
NEDA 21<br />
Further to this, from the primary survey analysis and field verification the total number <strong>of</strong> seats<br />
available in any community toilet, on an average, is about 10-15 seats. And the total number <strong>of</strong> users<br />
per day per seat is about 35 persons. This shows that the total numbers <strong>of</strong> persons dependent on<br />
community toilets are about 8816 i.e. about 1150 households i.e. about 5-7% <strong>of</strong> the total<br />
population. But, it has been noticed that most <strong>of</strong> the community toilets available in slum areas are in<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 78<br />
23
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
bad condition. Thus, it is important to analyze the condition <strong>of</strong> these toilets. The following graph<br />
shows the percentage distribution <strong>of</strong> community toilets according to condition <strong>of</strong> toilets.<br />
The analysis shows that about 50% <strong>of</strong> the available community toilets are in bad state. The<br />
infrastructure facilities in these toilets are almost broken conditions but even then, the people are<br />
still dependent upon these community toilets. But about 6% <strong>of</strong> the community toilets are not in a<br />
usable state. There are few community toilets i.e. only about 2% are in good and 19% are in average<br />
conditions. The condition <strong>of</strong> these community toilets depend upon the maintenance <strong>of</strong> them. With<br />
the same regard, the analysis shows that about 60% <strong>of</strong> the community toilets are cleaned regularly<br />
i.e. more than once a day. Further, about 20% <strong>of</strong> them are cleaned at least once a day. And about 5%<br />
<strong>of</strong> them are not at all cleaned. There are also certain numbers <strong>of</strong> community toilets i.e. about 15% <strong>of</strong><br />
them are cleaned at least once in a week. The following graph illustrates the percentage distribution<br />
<strong>of</strong> community toilets according to frequency <strong>of</strong> cleaning.<br />
In addition to the above mentioned analysis, the primary survey results also focused on type <strong>of</strong><br />
latrine available in these community toilets. This is mainly to analyze how the management <strong>of</strong> the<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 79
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
waste is done. The following graph shows the percentage share <strong>of</strong> community toilets according to<br />
type <strong>of</strong> latrine.<br />
The analysis shows that about 30% <strong>of</strong> the community toilets are equipped with pour flush pit latrines<br />
and about 37% <strong>of</strong> them with water closets. There are also about 17% <strong>of</strong> the community toilets with<br />
dry pit latrine and the rest with service and unimproved pit latrines. The type <strong>of</strong> latrine provided in<br />
these community toilets reflect upon the sludge management. The following graph illustrates the<br />
percentage distribution <strong>of</strong> community toilets according to different types <strong>of</strong> fecal sludge<br />
management.<br />
The analysis shows that about 32% <strong>of</strong> the community toilet facilities are connected to septic tanks<br />
and about 44% <strong>of</strong> them are connected to sewer lines. And the primary survey analysis and field<br />
verification shows that there relatively small proportion with manual scavenging. It is also important<br />
to consider – where actually the effluent sludge goes. There are different options such as septic<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 80
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
tanks, to sewer and to nalas. The sludge that is collected into septic tanks is disposed-<strong>of</strong>f improperly.<br />
And the present conditions <strong>of</strong> the septic tanks are also bad. From the analysis, about 30% <strong>of</strong> the<br />
community toilets with septic tanks are in broken status or over flowing. This is creating the<br />
surrounding areas very unhygienic and with stinking smell – that creates hurdle to most <strong>of</strong> the usage<br />
<strong>of</strong> community toilets. In about 80% <strong>of</strong> the community toilets with septic tanks, the fecal sludge<br />
collected from these septic tanks by the municipalities or private sludge sucking machine and they<br />
dispose it into nearby nalas. This shows that there need to some serious or potential problems in<br />
sludge management systems with community toilets. In addition to the disposal <strong>of</strong> sludge produced<br />
at community toilets there are also about 10% <strong>of</strong> the community toilets using the sludge to soak pits.<br />
There are about 15% <strong>of</strong> the community toilets whose sludge is directly let into open nalas.<br />
In addition to the above mentioned sludge management, there is also effluent waste that is<br />
generated from the community toilets – which also require proper disposal mechanisms. The<br />
analysis shows that there is about 98% <strong>of</strong> the community toilets have no proper effluent waste<br />
management. There are all let into open drains. There is only about 2% <strong>of</strong> the number <strong>of</strong> community<br />
toilets effluent waste disposed/ connected to sewer lines. The following graph shows the percentage<br />
share <strong>of</strong> community toilets according to their discharge mechanism <strong>of</strong> effluent waste.<br />
In addition to the above mentioned analysis, it is also important to consider who all are responsible<br />
for O&M arrangements <strong>of</strong> these community toilets. There are different government bodies, private<br />
agencies and NGOs those are responsible for O&M arrangements <strong>of</strong> these community toilets. The<br />
different organizations those are responsible are Nagar Nigam, DUDA, Jal Nigam, NEDA, Nagla Teja<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 81
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
etc. The following graph shows the percentage distribution <strong>of</strong> community toilets according to O&M<br />
arrangements.<br />
The two agencies responsible for the O&M <strong>of</strong> community toilets in Bareilly city are DUDA and NEDA.<br />
There is about 96% <strong>of</strong> the total number <strong>of</strong> community toilets whose O&M is done by DUDA and<br />
about 4% <strong>of</strong> them who’s O&M are done by NEDA.<br />
Key issues:<br />
1. There are about 23 community toilets with about 96% <strong>of</strong> them located in slum areas and the<br />
rest in non slum regions i.e. in low income group areas.<br />
2. The total numbers <strong>of</strong> persons dependent on community toilets are 5 – 10% <strong>of</strong> the total<br />
population.<br />
3. About 50% <strong>of</strong> the available community toilets are in bad state, but about 5% <strong>of</strong> the<br />
community toilets are not in a usable state.<br />
4. No O&M <strong>of</strong> community toilets and its infrastructure.<br />
5. No proper fecal sludge management.<br />
6. The fecal sludge collected from these septic tanks by the municipalities sludge sucking<br />
machine and they dispose it into nearby nallas leading to the rivers.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 82
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
7. 50% <strong>of</strong> the available community toilets are in bad state. The infrastructure facilities in these<br />
toilets are almost broken conditions but even then, the people are still dependent upon<br />
these community toilets.<br />
8. About 6% <strong>of</strong> the community toilets are not in a usable state<br />
9. About 30% <strong>of</strong> the communities toilets are equipped with pour flush pit latrines and about<br />
37% <strong>of</strong> them with water closets. There are also about 17% <strong>of</strong> the community toilets with dry<br />
pit latrine and the rest with service and unimproved pit latrines.<br />
10. About 32% <strong>of</strong> the community toilet facilities are connected to septic tanks and about 50% <strong>of</strong><br />
them are connected to sewer lines.<br />
11. In about 80% <strong>of</strong> the community toilets with septic tanks, the fecal sludge collected from<br />
these septic tanks by the municipalities or private sludge sucking machine and they dispose<br />
it into nearby nalas which lead to Ganga River.<br />
12. In addition to the disposal <strong>of</strong> sludge produced at community toilets there are also about 10%<br />
<strong>of</strong> the community toilets using the sludge at bio gas treatment.<br />
13. There is about 98% <strong>of</strong> the community toilets have no proper effluent waste management.<br />
There are all let into open drains. There is only about 2% <strong>of</strong> the number <strong>of</strong> community toilets<br />
effluent waste disposed/ connected to sewer lines.<br />
Key Issues <strong>of</strong> Fecal Sludge Management:<br />
FS management component<br />
and aspect<br />
Emptying + collection<br />
Technical<br />
-Limited or no<br />
accessibility to pits<br />
-Inappropriate<br />
emptying equipment<br />
-Manual, nonmechanized<br />
emptying<br />
Institutional/Financial -Poor<br />
management<br />
service<br />
-Users. low<br />
affordability for pit<br />
emptying<br />
-Lack <strong>of</strong> information<br />
(e.g. on how septic<br />
Causes Problems Consequences<br />
- Overflowing pits<br />
_ Emptying<br />
frequency <strong>of</strong>ten<br />
very low<br />
_ Informal or<br />
emergency<br />
emptying <strong>of</strong><br />
pits and<br />
indiscriminate<br />
disposal <strong>of</strong> FS<br />
At neighbourhood<br />
level, mainly<br />
--Health hazards<br />
from openly<br />
dumped FS and<br />
through use <strong>of</strong><br />
contaminated water<br />
_ Eye and nose<br />
sores<br />
_ Non-functionality<br />
<strong>of</strong> infrequently<br />
emptied septic<br />
tanks-solids carryover<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 83
Transport<br />
tanks work)<br />
Technical -Lack <strong>of</strong> suitable<br />
disposal or<br />
treatment sites at<br />
short distance from<br />
the area <strong>of</strong> FS<br />
collection<br />
Institutional -Lack <strong>of</strong> urban<br />
planning - lack <strong>of</strong><br />
suitable disposal or<br />
treatment sites at<br />
short distance from<br />
the area <strong>of</strong> FS<br />
collection<br />
-Lack <strong>of</strong> involvement<br />
<strong>of</strong> private sector<br />
service Providers<br />
-Lack <strong>of</strong> suitable<br />
incentive and<br />
sanctions structure<br />
Treatment<br />
Technical Lack <strong>of</strong> proven and<br />
appropriate<br />
treatment options<br />
Financial/economic FS treatment exists:<br />
private collectors<br />
/entrepreneurs<br />
avoid the paying <strong>of</strong><br />
treatment fees<br />
Institutional/Financial -Lack <strong>of</strong> political will<br />
to invest in<br />
treatment<br />
- Lack <strong>of</strong> effective<br />
cost recovery<br />
- Lack <strong>of</strong> urban<br />
planning<br />
-Lack <strong>of</strong> information<br />
Disposal<br />
Institutional Lack <strong>of</strong><br />
implementation <strong>of</strong><br />
FS treatment<br />
-Collectors dump FS<br />
in an uncontrolled<br />
manner at the<br />
shortest possible<br />
distance from<br />
where FS was<br />
collected<br />
FS is dumped<br />
untreated<br />
-Non-availability <strong>of</strong><br />
suitable treatment<br />
sites<br />
-discharge <strong>of</strong><br />
untreated FS<br />
haphazardly<br />
Indiscriminate<br />
dumping <strong>of</strong><br />
untreated FS<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
At municipal level,<br />
mainly:<br />
-Pollution <strong>of</strong> surface<br />
and (shallow)<br />
Groundwater<br />
- Eye and nose sores<br />
- Health hazards<br />
from use <strong>of</strong><br />
contaminated<br />
surface water (e.g.<br />
for<br />
vegetable irrigation)<br />
At municipal level,<br />
mainly:<br />
-Health hazards<br />
through use <strong>of</strong><br />
contaminated water<br />
sources and water<br />
pollution<br />
Water pollution and<br />
risks to public health<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 84
schemes <strong>of</strong> town<br />
planning and<br />
designation <strong>of</strong><br />
suitable treatment<br />
sites; lack <strong>of</strong><br />
adequate fee<br />
structure and<br />
incentives for<br />
transport <strong>of</strong> FS to<br />
treatment sites<br />
- Indiscriminate<br />
dumping <strong>of</strong><br />
untreated FS<br />
- Water pollution<br />
and risks to public<br />
health<br />
-Lack <strong>of</strong> promotion<br />
and marketing <strong>of</strong><br />
bio-solids produced<br />
in FS treatment<br />
High-quality biosolids<br />
remain<br />
unused and need<br />
to be land filled<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
-Depletion <strong>of</strong> soil<br />
organic fraction and<br />
deterioration <strong>of</strong> soil<br />
productivity<br />
<strong>SANITATION</strong> FACILITIES AND SITUATION AT COMMERCIAL/ MARKET PLACES FOR SHOPKEEPERS:<br />
As reported by NNB, there are about 3000 shops & commercial establishment registered at Nagar<br />
Nigam. At this rate the total waste contributed by commercial establishment to MSW is about 109<br />
MT/ Day approximately. In addition to waste generation from the commercial and market places<br />
tones <strong>of</strong> garbage is left on the road sides and disposed <strong>of</strong>f on the road sides and the total waste left<br />
out on the road sides per month is about 39 tones.<br />
In addition to the waste generation, there are also some potential issues related to sanitation<br />
facilities at individual shops. This reflects on the safe disposal or proper usage <strong>of</strong> sanitation facilities<br />
within or nearby respective shops would definitely reduce the open defecation. But, the situational<br />
analysis <strong>of</strong> these sanitation facilities at commercial/ market places show some contrast. This can be<br />
related to gender category, since the provision and usage <strong>of</strong> sanitary facilities depend upon the<br />
gender category. The following graph illustrates the percentage share <strong>of</strong> commercial shops<br />
according to male/ female workers in their respective shops.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 85
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
The analysis show that there are about 98% <strong>of</strong> the commercial shops with male workers and the rest<br />
2% <strong>of</strong> commercial places having their shops with female population. This can reflect upon the<br />
provision <strong>of</strong> toilet facilities is also must for the female workers at the shops itself and also same is<br />
the case with male workers. But this is not the case with majority <strong>of</strong> the male workers population.<br />
Most <strong>of</strong> the male workers use some community toilets, public toilets nearby and some in the<br />
commercial complexes itself. And there is also certain percentage share <strong>of</strong> male workers population<br />
who openly defecate. Further to this, the usage <strong>of</strong> toilet facilities also reflects upon the duration <strong>of</strong><br />
stay at the work places. The more the duration <strong>of</strong> work hours – the more are the chances to usage<br />
the availability <strong>of</strong> toilets or open defecating (in necessity). The following graph shows the percentage<br />
share <strong>of</strong> commercial shops according to duration <strong>of</strong> work hours.<br />
The analysis shows that there about 70% <strong>of</strong> the commercial shops where the working hours are<br />
ranging in 11-15 hours per day. And there are also commercial places with fewer working hours i.e.<br />
in between 1-10 hours. The field verifications and focused group discussions shows that the<br />
commercial shops with fewer working hours are mainly petty shops which hardly have any toilets<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 86
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
and depend upon public toilets or community toilets and also certain percentage <strong>of</strong> population<br />
openly defecate. Further to this, there are majority share <strong>of</strong> commercial shops that have more<br />
working hours and also to certain percentage share <strong>of</strong> shops with complex toilets. The availability <strong>of</strong><br />
usage <strong>of</strong> toilet facilities further also depends upon the number <strong>of</strong> workers in each commercial shop.<br />
The more the number <strong>of</strong> workers - the less is the chance <strong>of</strong> persons in using the toilets (if available in<br />
commercial complex) and more is the chances <strong>of</strong> open defecation (in case <strong>of</strong> emergency). The<br />
following graph shows the percentage share <strong>of</strong> commercial/ market places in accordance to the<br />
number <strong>of</strong> workers.<br />
The analysis shows that the number <strong>of</strong> workers population in any given commercial shop is in<br />
between 3-5 i.e. about 55% <strong>of</strong> the commercial shops is having workers population in between 3-5.<br />
Thus, it is important to consider the availability <strong>of</strong> sanitary facilities in the commercial shops or<br />
within the vicinity. Further to this, it is also important to consider the number <strong>of</strong> commercial shops<br />
with male and female category. The following graph shows the percentage share <strong>of</strong> commercial/<br />
market places in accordance to the number <strong>of</strong> workers in male category.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 87
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
The following graph shows the percentage share <strong>of</strong> commercial/ market places in accordance to the<br />
number <strong>of</strong> workers in female category.<br />
The analysis show that there are about 92% in male category and 3% in female category <strong>of</strong> the<br />
commercial places/ shops with number <strong>of</strong> workers ranging in between 1-5. This shows that the<br />
number <strong>of</strong> workers population in majority share <strong>of</strong> commercial places is very low. This reflects on<br />
the usage <strong>of</strong> toilets (in case <strong>of</strong> availability) i.e. there is no much population in each commercial shop<br />
and the chance in getting the opportunity in using the available toilets (if available) is also high.<br />
Further to this, the usage <strong>of</strong> toilets is also dependent upon the availability <strong>of</strong> toilets in commercial<br />
shops/ complexes. The following graph illustrates the percentage share <strong>of</strong> commercial places<br />
according to the availability <strong>of</strong> toilets in their own complex/ shop.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 88
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
The analysis shows that there is only about 35% <strong>of</strong> the commercial/ market places having some kind<br />
<strong>of</strong> toilet facilities within the complex. But, there is certainly a large percentage share <strong>of</strong> commercial<br />
places i.e. about 65% <strong>of</strong> them is having no toilet facilities. This shows that there is certain<br />
dependency on community toilets or public toilets and the rest open defecate. Further to this, the<br />
analysis also focused on number <strong>of</strong> seats availability in these commercial places where the toilet<br />
availability is there. The number <strong>of</strong> seat availability also focuses on number <strong>of</strong> people using them.<br />
The more the number <strong>of</strong> seat availability – the more is the population using the toilets. The following<br />
graph illustrates the percentage share <strong>of</strong> commercial/ market places according to the number <strong>of</strong><br />
seats.<br />
The analysis shows that there is about 50%<br />
<strong>of</strong> the number <strong>of</strong> commercial/ market places having toilet facilities with number <strong>of</strong> seats ranging 1-5.<br />
There is also about 35% <strong>of</strong> the number <strong>of</strong> commercial/ market places with number <strong>of</strong> seats ranging<br />
6-10. There are also 15% <strong>of</strong> the commercial places having only urinals in their complex/ shop.<br />
Further to this, it is also relevant to understand that whether the workers are allowed to use the<br />
available toilets. The more the usage <strong>of</strong> available toilets within the commercial/ market places – thus<br />
reduces the open defecation. The following graph illustrates the percentage share <strong>of</strong> number <strong>of</strong><br />
commercial shops (having toilets in their complex) who allow the workers to use the toilets.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 89
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
The analysis show that – even though the toilets are available within the complex and provision is<br />
provided for the workers – about 40% <strong>of</strong> the commercial places do not allow the workers to use that<br />
provision. This results in usage <strong>of</strong> public/ community toilets nearby or openly defecates. Further, the<br />
usage <strong>of</strong> community toilets or public toilets in case <strong>of</strong> absence <strong>of</strong> any complex toilets in commercial<br />
shops also depends upon the awareness <strong>of</strong> the existence <strong>of</strong> public toilets in the premises. The<br />
following graph illustrates the percentage share <strong>of</strong> workers having awareness <strong>of</strong> public toilets in the<br />
premises.<br />
The analysis shows that there are only 100% <strong>of</strong> the total workers in commercial places who are<br />
aware <strong>of</strong> availability <strong>of</strong> public toilets in the premises <strong>of</strong> the shops. Thus, based on the above<br />
mentioned analysis, the following graph illustrates the percentage share <strong>of</strong> commercial shops and<br />
their usage patterns <strong>of</strong> toilets i.e. whether they use the complex toilets or public toilets or open<br />
defecate or wait for an opportunity.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 90
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
The analysis shows that there is relatively high percentage use <strong>of</strong> public toilets by the workers in the<br />
commercial places and market areas. And there is relatively low percentage <strong>of</strong> open defecation in<br />
these areas which is very unhygienic and unhealthy sign. The usage <strong>of</strong> complex toilets is only about<br />
20% <strong>of</strong> the workers population. Further to this, there are also concerns about the sludge<br />
management in case <strong>of</strong> provision <strong>of</strong> toilets at commercial places and market places. The following<br />
graph shows the percentage share <strong>of</strong> number <strong>of</strong> toilets (available) at commercial places according to<br />
the type <strong>of</strong> sludge management.<br />
The majority <strong>of</strong> toilet facilities those are available at the commercial shops i.e. about 70% <strong>of</strong> them<br />
have septic tanks for their sludge management. The sludge that is accumulated in these tanks is<br />
cleared once in every year by the municipality or private vehicle and the waste is disposed <strong>of</strong>f. But<br />
the disposal <strong>of</strong> the sludge is also not proper. The sludge that is collected from the septic tanks is<br />
thrown <strong>of</strong>f into open nallas. Further to this, there also few toilets connected to sewer lines and few<br />
directly let into open drains. Hence, there is an urgent need to proper provision <strong>of</strong> toilets and proper<br />
disposal system in these commercial areas and market places. In addition to the waste generation<br />
from different commercial shops, the sanitation provision is also creating problems at alarming rate.<br />
Further to this, it is also important to understand the willingness to have pay and use toilets (in case<br />
<strong>of</strong> any further proposals for provision <strong>of</strong> toilets) in the premises <strong>of</strong> commercial shops. The following<br />
graph illustrates the percentage share <strong>of</strong> shopkeepers and workers willingness to pay and use the<br />
toilets.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 91
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
The analysis show that there fewer amount <strong>of</strong> shopkeepers or workers who are willing to pay any<br />
amount for the use <strong>of</strong> toilets. Further, it is also analyzed in case <strong>of</strong> willingness to pay any amount<br />
majority <strong>of</strong> people are ready to pay for monthly passes i.e. about 65% <strong>of</strong> them are willing to take<br />
monthly passes for using the public toilets (who do not have any access to toilets). And the amount<br />
they are willing to spend on monthly passes is about 70% <strong>of</strong> them range in between 20 – 30 (in Rs)<br />
per month and about 20% - less than 20 (in Rs) and about 10% <strong>of</strong> the shopkeepers are willing to take<br />
monthly passes ranging in between 30 – 40 (in Rs).<br />
In addition to the sanitation conditions at the commercial areas, analysis also focused on waste<br />
disposal mechanisms. The overall waste generation from commercial establishments is creating<br />
unhealthy conditions within the city due to unsafe disposal mechanisms. The analysis and field<br />
surveys show that there is huge amount <strong>of</strong> waste that is disposed <strong>of</strong>f on to the road sides and nalas.<br />
The following graph shows the percentage share <strong>of</strong> commercial shops according to their disposal<br />
mechanism.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 92
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
The analysis show that there is about 49% <strong>of</strong> the commercial shops who dispose <strong>of</strong>f their waste on<br />
the road side and about 13% into nalas. These are two unhealthy way <strong>of</strong> disposal <strong>of</strong> waste – thus<br />
creating unhygienic conditions. There is about 20% <strong>of</strong> the shops who dispose <strong>of</strong> the waste into<br />
nearby bins and 18% <strong>of</strong> shops have some collection mechanisms – who collect the waste and<br />
dispose <strong>of</strong> into some nearby disposal bins i.e. by private sweepers.<br />
Further, the amount spend by these 48% <strong>of</strong> the shops to the waste collectors is ranging from 300 –<br />
700 (in Rs) per month, on an average. About 48% <strong>of</strong> the total shops who pay to the waste collectors<br />
are paying about this amount i.e. in between 300 – 700. There are about 52% <strong>of</strong> them who pay in<br />
between 100 – 300 (in Rs) per month, on an average. The waste collection takes place once daily and<br />
in few cases daily twice and once in 2 days. On the whole, about 80% <strong>of</strong> the shops have their waste<br />
collection regularly. And the rest other 20% <strong>of</strong> the shops do not have proper collection <strong>of</strong> their waste<br />
which is polluting the environment both aesthetically and healthy and production <strong>of</strong> flies and insects<br />
borne diseases- and also resulting in unsafe disposal in due course <strong>of</strong> time. The majority levels <strong>of</strong><br />
satisfaction among the shopkeepers in terms <strong>of</strong> their waste disposal and sanitary conditions are very<br />
poor.<br />
<strong>SANITATION</strong> FACILITIES AND SITUATION AT COMMERCIAL/ MARKET PLACES FOR CUSTOMERS:<br />
The other type <strong>of</strong> sanitation facilities that are must at commercial/ market places is for customers.<br />
This also play a vital role in creating some burdens on environment in case <strong>of</strong> absence <strong>of</strong> any sanitary<br />
facilities. From the analysis, the average time spends by any customer in market places is in between<br />
2-4 hours and some cases more than 5 hours. Hence, it is important to consider the provision <strong>of</strong><br />
toilet facilities to these commuters. There are public toilets situated in few market areas and<br />
complex toilets which can be <strong>of</strong> public use. But, it is also important that there should be awareness<br />
among public that there are some kind <strong>of</strong> toilet provisions for them (in case <strong>of</strong> any availability). The<br />
following graph shows the percentage <strong>of</strong> customers in commercial areas and market places those<br />
aware <strong>of</strong> toilet provision in the premises <strong>of</strong> commercial areas/ market areas.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 93
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
The analysis shows that about 50% <strong>of</strong> the customer population does not have any awareness <strong>of</strong> any<br />
provision <strong>of</strong> toilet facilities in market areas or commercial shops. There are also places (where the<br />
customer population is very high) where is no provision <strong>of</strong> public toilets or complex toilets in the<br />
commercial shops. There are places such as Lodamandi, Noori Darwaza, Sindhi Bazar, Subhas<br />
market, and Raja ki market – where there is no provision any sanitary facilities.<br />
The average time spend by any customer is optimum. Hence, in case <strong>of</strong> emergency the usage<br />
patterns are also important to consider. There are many options available for the general public in<br />
commercial areas such as use the available toilets in shops, usage <strong>of</strong> public toilets if available, or wait<br />
for an opportunity. And there are chances <strong>of</strong> open defecation. The following graph illustrates the<br />
distribution <strong>of</strong> percentage share <strong>of</strong> general public in commercial areas according to usage patterns<br />
(in case <strong>of</strong> emergency).<br />
The analysis show there is no usage <strong>of</strong> complex toilets or toilets provided in shops by the customers<br />
in case <strong>of</strong> any emergency. The usage <strong>of</strong> public toilets in commercial areas is only about 32% and<br />
there is about 9% <strong>of</strong> open defecation by the customer populations in commercial areas. Hence,<br />
therefore, there should be proper provision <strong>of</strong> toilet facilities in commercial areas for general public<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 94
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
use. It is also important to understand the willingness to pay and use the toilets for general public.<br />
And the analysis show that there is only about 39% <strong>of</strong> them willing to have pay and use toilets. And<br />
the amount they are willing to pay is in between 2 – 3 (in Rs).<br />
In addition to the sanitary facilities, the other problem that is encountered by general public that is<br />
causing the inconvenience is garbage in market areas. And about 62% <strong>of</strong> the customers say that they<br />
are feel inconvenience and are unsatisfactory with present conditions <strong>of</strong> garbage in market areas.<br />
The common and prevalent problems faced by general public in market areas due to improper<br />
garbage disposal are – blocking the roads, smell from road side bins and also smell from chocked<br />
nalas.<br />
Key issues:<br />
1. More number <strong>of</strong> male workers population and more number <strong>of</strong> working hours.<br />
2. About 35% <strong>of</strong> the commercial/ market places having some kind <strong>of</strong> toilet facilities within the<br />
complex.<br />
3. High percentage use <strong>of</strong> public toilets by the workers in the commercial places and market<br />
areas.<br />
4. About 5 - 10% <strong>of</strong> workers open defecate.<br />
5. No proper sludge management.<br />
6. Willingness to buy monthly passes for the usage <strong>of</strong> public/ community toilets.<br />
7. Poor solid waste disposal and collection mechanisms.<br />
8. The general customer po/public does not have any awareness <strong>of</strong> any provision <strong>of</strong> toilet<br />
facilities in market areas or commercial shops.<br />
9. No provision <strong>of</strong> community/ public toilets in high density commercial areas.<br />
10. No usage <strong>of</strong> complex toilets or toilets provided in shops by the customers in case <strong>of</strong> any<br />
emergency.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 95
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
11. The usage <strong>of</strong> public toilets in commercial areas is only about 50% and there is about 10% <strong>of</strong><br />
open defecation by the general public in commercial areas.<br />
12. No willingness to pay and use for public toilets.<br />
13. The common and prevalent problems faced by general public in market areas due to<br />
improper garbage disposal are – blocking the roads, smell from road side bins and also smell<br />
from chocked nalas.<br />
<strong>SANITATION</strong> FACILITIES AND SITUATION AT HOSPITALS:<br />
Key information:<br />
1. Total number <strong>of</strong> hospitals: 141<br />
2. Total number <strong>of</strong> hospitals with 100+ beds: 04<br />
3. Total waste generated from 141 hospitals: 9.97 tones (9044.63 kgs)<br />
The total solid waste that is being generated in a month from all the hospitals together is about 9.97<br />
tones (9044.63 kgs). The following graph illustrates the distribution <strong>of</strong> hospitals according to the<br />
number <strong>of</strong> beds in them – which reflects upon the amount <strong>of</strong> waste generation per day.<br />
The primary survey analysis show that there are about 50% <strong>of</strong> hospitals with beds ranging from 51-<br />
100 and about 30% with 100+ beds. This shows that the share <strong>of</strong> medium sized hospitals is<br />
generating more waste i.e. on an average <strong>of</strong> 0.25 kg per bed per day. And the total waste produced<br />
from all hospitals together -the medical establishments in Bareilly city generates approximately 16<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 96
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
MT/ Day waste <strong>of</strong> which about 8.5 MT/ Day which goes to Municipal stream and rest is Bio-medical<br />
waste. A very brief pr<strong>of</strong>ile <strong>of</strong> the waste generation, collection and transportation <strong>of</strong> this waste is<br />
given before. This also depends upon the different services provided by different hospitals. The<br />
more the number <strong>of</strong> services at any particular hospital the more is the waste generation. The<br />
following graph illustrates the percentage share <strong>of</strong> number <strong>of</strong> hospitals that provide different<br />
services.<br />
There is about 60% share <strong>of</strong> the hospitals that provide all services and about 30% <strong>of</strong> them do not<br />
provide all the facilities (such as sophisticated surgeries). But, there are few hospitals that provide<br />
even the training, practices and education to students. This reflect on the percentage <strong>of</strong> waste<br />
(Liquid+solid) <strong>of</strong> the 60% <strong>of</strong> the hospitals is very high. The amount <strong>of</strong> waste generated at any<br />
particular hospital depends upon the above mention character. The following graph illustrates the<br />
quantity <strong>of</strong> solid waste produced by hospitals per day.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 97
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
There is an average <strong>of</strong> 0.25 – 0.35 kg <strong>of</strong> solid waste that is being produced by each bed in about 80%<br />
share <strong>of</strong> total available hospitals. This resulted in generation <strong>of</strong> about solid waste ranging in between<br />
1 – 30 kgs per day. And about 20% <strong>of</strong> the hospital number generates solid waste in between 31 – 60<br />
kgs per day. There are also relatively small percentage number <strong>of</strong> hospitals those relatively generate<br />
(more than 120Kg per day) more waste. Prior to collection, the waste that is generated at hospitals<br />
should have color coding. The following graph shows the percentage share <strong>of</strong> hospitals that have<br />
coding for the waste produced.<br />
There is relatively large share <strong>of</strong> hospitals i.e. about 90% <strong>of</strong> the available hospitals doing the color<br />
coding for the solid waste. But there are about 10% <strong>of</strong> the hospitals that do not have any color<br />
coding. Further to this, there is different arrangement made by different hospitals for their waste<br />
collections. The majority <strong>of</strong> bio-medical waste that is generated by hospitals is being collected by<br />
private agencies; and the rest by the municipality vehicles. The following graph illustrates the<br />
percentage share <strong>of</strong> hospitals according to the different arrangements made for disposal <strong>of</strong> Bio<br />
medical waste.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 98
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
The disposing <strong>of</strong> bio-medical waste should be according to bio-medical waste rules, 1998. But, there<br />
are about 90% <strong>of</strong> the hospitals those following these rules, but the rest does not. The following<br />
graph illustrates the percentage share <strong>of</strong> hospitals according to those having system <strong>of</strong> disposing<br />
BMW in accordance with Bio medical waste rules, 1998.<br />
The segregation <strong>of</strong> biodegradable and non biodegradable wastes at the point <strong>of</strong> disposal i.e. at<br />
hospitals – about 90% <strong>of</strong> them do not segregation, but the rest do not. This thus, on the whole<br />
created fewer burdens on treatment plants. The following graph shows the percentage share <strong>of</strong><br />
hospitals according to the system <strong>of</strong> segregation <strong>of</strong> biodegradable and non biodegradable wastes.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 99
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
These segregated BMW and non BMW – <strong>of</strong> which majority is being collected by the private agencies<br />
– and the collection frequency is at least once in 24 hours, thus, reducing the exposure <strong>of</strong> these toxic<br />
wastes near and the surrounding <strong>of</strong> hospitals.<br />
In addition to solid waste, there is also large quantity <strong>of</strong> liquid waste that is generated from different<br />
hospitals. The following graph illustrates the quantity (in liters) <strong>of</strong> liquid waste produced from<br />
different hospitals.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 100
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
The other type <strong>of</strong> waste that is produced by all hospitals is liquid waste. This includes – blood,<br />
mucus, secretion and urine. There is about 60% share <strong>of</strong> the total hospitals who are generating<br />
about 6 – 10 liters <strong>of</strong> liquid waste and about 20% - more than 10 ltr <strong>of</strong> liquid waste. This shows that<br />
relatively a very high quantity <strong>of</strong> liquid waste is being generated from the hospitals, which has to<br />
treat properly before letting it out into sewerage or nalas, where as in absence <strong>of</strong> it results in high<br />
levels <strong>of</strong> toxicities. The following graph illustrates the percentage share <strong>of</strong> number <strong>of</strong> hospitals<br />
according to their type <strong>of</strong> disposal outlet <strong>of</strong> liquid waste that is generated at the source points.<br />
One <strong>of</strong> most toxic waste from the hospitals is liquid waste – which has to treat at the point <strong>of</strong><br />
disposal before letting it out into the drains, nalas or any other sources <strong>of</strong> disposals. But, none <strong>of</strong> the<br />
hospitals is provided with any separate setup for any primary treatment <strong>of</strong> the liquid waste and<br />
directly let out into sewerage and this flows into nalas.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 101
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
The other type management that should be done at the hospitals is to have a proper mechanism for<br />
management <strong>of</strong> sludge from hospital cesspools before them letting out into sewerage. Even in this<br />
case, there are only 20% <strong>of</strong> them practicing the proper mechanism and the rest 80% <strong>of</strong> the hospitals<br />
letting them directly into sewerage, thus leading to nallas. The following graph illustrates the<br />
percentage share <strong>of</strong> number <strong>of</strong> hospitals according to their mechanism for management <strong>of</strong> sludge<br />
from hospital cesspools.<br />
Key issues:<br />
1. Half the number <strong>of</strong> hospitals are with beds 50+; 0.3 kg/bed/day (on average)<br />
2. 60% <strong>of</strong> hospitals provide all facilities – generation <strong>of</strong> more waste at each sources<br />
3. 40% <strong>of</strong> hospitals generate more than 60kg <strong>of</strong> bio medical waste/ day.<br />
4. 70% <strong>of</strong> hospitals produce more than 8lts <strong>of</strong> liquid waste/day<br />
5. 90% <strong>of</strong> hospitals – does not follow Bio-medical waste rules, 1998.<br />
6. 100% <strong>of</strong> hospitals discharge their liquid BMW into sewerage/open drains/nallas.<br />
7. 80% <strong>of</strong> hospitals do not treat their fecal sludge leading to sewerage/open drains.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 102
<strong>SANITATION</strong> FACILITIES AND SITUATION AT INSTITUTIONS:<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
The other potential area where the provision <strong>of</strong> toilets is a must is institution buildings. The floating<br />
population in these buildings such as collectorate <strong>of</strong>fice, bus station, railway station, district court,<br />
RTO <strong>of</strong>fice, Bareilly <strong>Development</strong> Authority, Nagar Nigam Bareilly and so on, is very high – where<br />
the provision <strong>of</strong> toilets is a must for general public and employees <strong>of</strong> respective buildings and even<br />
in case <strong>of</strong> availability – there should be proper maintenance <strong>of</strong> the sanitary facilities. There is some<br />
provision <strong>of</strong> toilets to general public in all these public institution buildings, but the sanitary<br />
conditions at these building and within the premises is very poor. It is important to understand the<br />
present condition <strong>of</strong> existing toilets at these public buildings. The following graph shows the<br />
percentage distribution <strong>of</strong> institutional buildings where toilet facilities are available according to<br />
their present conditions.<br />
The analysis show that the toilet conditions in these institutional buildings is satisfactory. But, there<br />
is no proper maintenance <strong>of</strong> these existing toilets, even though the usages <strong>of</strong> these toilets are very<br />
high. Even though the conditions <strong>of</strong> toilets are bad – public still use them in case <strong>of</strong> emergency, due<br />
to no provision <strong>of</strong> other toilet facilities in nearby premises. These general public comprise <strong>of</strong> both<br />
male and female population – thus, it is important to have separate toilets for male and female and<br />
the institutional building should have separate toilets for male and female category. There is<br />
sufficient number <strong>of</strong> toilet seats provided both to male and female category i.e. on an average<br />
ranging in between 10 – 15 for both female and male category, but there is lack <strong>of</strong> maintenance <strong>of</strong><br />
these toilets.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 103
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
In addition to provision <strong>of</strong> sanitary facilities to general public, toilets are also provided to employees<br />
in all these institutional buildings. The provision <strong>of</strong> toilets are provided both to male and female<br />
category separately with sufficient number <strong>of</strong> seats i.e. on an average ranging from 10 – 15 seats for<br />
male category and 5 – 10 for female category.<br />
The condition and functionality <strong>of</strong> these toilets also reflects upon the availability <strong>of</strong> infrastructure<br />
facilities within the toilets and they are water supply, doors, lights and buckets. And the analysis<br />
show that all the toilets are facilitated with water supply, doors and buckets. But, there are only 70%<br />
<strong>of</strong> the institutional toilets with electricity connections. In addition to these infrastructure facilities –<br />
the source <strong>of</strong> water facilities in these toilets are mainly over head tanks i.e. municipal water and<br />
ground water. The following graph shows the percentage distribution <strong>of</strong> toilets according to the<br />
source <strong>of</strong> water supply.<br />
The analysis show that about 70% <strong>of</strong> the public institutional buildings toilets are facilitated with<br />
overhead tank as the prime source <strong>of</strong> water supply and the rest with ground water. In addition to<br />
the minimal infrastructure facilities, there should also be minimal maintenance in these facilities.<br />
The following graph illustrates the percentage share <strong>of</strong> institutional toilets according to their<br />
maintenance.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 104
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
The analysis shows that the about 70% <strong>of</strong> the available toilets are well maintained and the rest <strong>of</strong><br />
the 30% <strong>of</strong> them are in bad state – which need immediate improvements. From the field verification<br />
and survey analysis, the improvements that are required can be categorized as follows:<br />
a. Upgrade infrastructure<br />
b. Provide continuous water supply<br />
c. Proper maintenance<br />
d. Cleaning at regular intervals<br />
Key Issues:<br />
1. No proper maintenance <strong>of</strong> these existing toilets.<br />
2. the conditions <strong>of</strong> toilets are bad – public still use them in case <strong>of</strong> emergency, due to no<br />
provision <strong>of</strong> other toilet facilities in nearby premises.<br />
3. Toilets are also provided to employees in all these institutional buildings but not properly<br />
maintained.<br />
4. No proper infrastructure facilities in these toilets – include electricity and water supply.<br />
5. Bareilly <strong>Development</strong> Authority - found few toilets in worst condition.<br />
6. Nagar Nigam Bareilly - found toilet in worst condition.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 105
<strong>SANITATION</strong> FACILITIES AND SITUATION AT SCHOOLS:<br />
Key information: Primary School<br />
1. Total number <strong>of</strong> primary schools: 129<br />
2. Total number <strong>of</strong> students: 22846<br />
3. Total number <strong>of</strong> primary schools with toilet facilities: 115<br />
4. Total number <strong>of</strong> primary schools without toilet facilities: 14<br />
Key information: Junior High School<br />
1. Total number <strong>of</strong> junior high school: 80<br />
2. Total number <strong>of</strong> students: 13406<br />
3. Total number <strong>of</strong> junior high schools with toilet facilities: 71<br />
4. Total number <strong>of</strong> junior high schools without toilet facilities: 9<br />
Key Information: High School<br />
1. Total number <strong>of</strong> high schools: 44<br />
2. Total number <strong>of</strong> students: 28288<br />
3. Total number <strong>of</strong> high schools with toilets: 44<br />
4. Total number <strong>of</strong> high schools without toilets: 0<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
One <strong>of</strong> the most important sectors where the sanitary facilities should be carefully assessed is in<br />
schools. The primary survey has being conducted at school level to understand the sanitary<br />
conditions <strong>of</strong> schools. The analysis the boy’s strength is relatively higher than the girl’s strength, on<br />
an average; whereas in case <strong>of</strong> teacher’s population – the female’s strength is higher than male’s<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 106
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
strength. This reflects on the provision <strong>of</strong> toilets i.e. there should be more number <strong>of</strong> toilet<br />
provisions for boy’s student population when compared with girl’s student population. But, it is vice<br />
versa in case <strong>of</strong> teacher’s population. Further to these basic demographic details, the number <strong>of</strong><br />
worker’s population in any particular school is dominated by female workers than male workers. The<br />
primary survey analysis and field verification shows that there are many schools that are deprived<br />
with workers i.e. about 40% <strong>of</strong> the schools do not have any workers to maintain the cleanliness <strong>of</strong><br />
the surroundings <strong>of</strong> the school. And about 30% <strong>of</strong> the school’s cleanliness is done by students<br />
themselves.<br />
Further the analysis focuses on the sanitary conditions in the schools. The analysis shows that about<br />
15% <strong>of</strong> the schools do not have any kind <strong>of</strong> toilet facilities. The graphs below illustrate the<br />
percentage distribution <strong>of</strong> total number <strong>of</strong> schools according to availability <strong>of</strong> toilets in male and<br />
female category.<br />
The primary survey analysis shows that about 80% <strong>of</strong> numbers <strong>of</strong> schools have toilet facilities for<br />
boys’ category and about 85% <strong>of</strong> number <strong>of</strong> schools has toilet facilities for girls’ category. The rest <strong>of</strong><br />
schools which do not have any sanitary facilities use other options. From the analysis it can be<br />
observed that about 15% <strong>of</strong> schools who do not have access to toilet facilities both in male and<br />
female category end up majorly in open defecation in or around the premises <strong>of</strong> respective schools<br />
and in some cases use toilets at home or neighbors (in case <strong>of</strong> girls).<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 107
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
The analysis shows that about 85% <strong>of</strong> schools have access to toilets in female category and in the<br />
rest <strong>of</strong> the schools - they use other options. And in case <strong>of</strong> access to toilets in male category, there<br />
are only about 65% <strong>of</strong> the schools having access and the rest <strong>of</strong> the schools have other options. In<br />
majority <strong>of</strong> the schools, the male population openly defecates i.e. about 90% <strong>of</strong> the schools without<br />
toilets use options such as open defecation. And in case <strong>of</strong> female teachers they generally wait for<br />
opportunity and in emergency open defecation is the only option in few schools. Further it is also<br />
important to consider the schools having the sewerage connection and those schools without having<br />
any sewerage connection should have other options such as septic tanks, soak pits or open to drains.<br />
The analysis <strong>of</strong> primary surveys and stake holder meetings shows that about 95% <strong>of</strong> the schools have<br />
sewerage connection and about 4% <strong>of</strong> school toilets to septic tanks and the rest 1% <strong>of</strong> the toilets to<br />
open drains.<br />
In addition to the availability <strong>of</strong> toilet facilities and sludge disposal mechanisms – the infrastructure<br />
facilities in these toilets also play a vital role in making use <strong>of</strong> them and create a usable environment<br />
<strong>of</strong> the toilets. The infrastructure facilities within these toilets can mainly be categories as electricity<br />
connections and water connections. But, there are only about 40% <strong>of</strong> the schools with toilets having<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 108
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
electricity connections. The following graph shows the percentage share <strong>of</strong> school toilets with<br />
electricity connection according to their working conditions.<br />
The analysis shows that there are about 98% <strong>of</strong> toilets with electricity connections are in working<br />
state and rest does not. In addition to this the other infrastructure facilities that is must is water<br />
connections facilities. The following graph shows the percentage share <strong>of</strong> number <strong>of</strong> school toilets<br />
having provision <strong>of</strong> water connections.<br />
The analysis shows that there are about 70% <strong>of</strong> the schools with functional water connections. In<br />
addition to this, the sources <strong>of</strong> water supply that cater the needs in the school are bore wells,<br />
tankers and municipal water. The following graph shows the percentage distribution <strong>of</strong> schools<br />
according to their type <strong>of</strong> sources <strong>of</strong> water supply.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 109
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
The analysis show that about 55% <strong>of</strong> the schools depend upon bore well as the prime source <strong>of</strong><br />
water supply and about 28% on municipal water. There are about 16% <strong>of</strong> schools who do have any<br />
kind <strong>of</strong> sourced <strong>of</strong> water supply. Alternatively, all the school students generally bring water from<br />
home and about 80% <strong>of</strong> them go to neighbors in case <strong>of</strong> emergency. Further to this, it is also<br />
important to have some storage facilities. The following graph shows the percentage share <strong>of</strong> school<br />
toilets with having some storage facilities.<br />
The analysis shows that in case <strong>of</strong> schools with having water supply – there should also have some<br />
storage facilities and about 90% <strong>of</strong> them do have some kind <strong>of</strong> storage facilities in the schools. There<br />
are about 10% <strong>of</strong> the schools with no water storage facilities. The different types <strong>of</strong> water storage<br />
facilities in schools are overhead tanks, underground sumps and few schools fill into barrels. It is also<br />
important to consider<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 110
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
Even though both the availability <strong>of</strong> toilet in schools exist and the infrastructure is provided in these<br />
toilets, it is important to analyze the working conditions <strong>of</strong> them – which decides the usage patterns<br />
<strong>of</strong> the toilets in the school. Based on the above mentioned different categories the functionality has<br />
being defined. The following graph shows the percentage distribution <strong>of</strong> schools according to their<br />
toilet’s working conditions.<br />
The analysis shows that there are about 90% <strong>of</strong> the schools whose toilets are in any working<br />
conditions. There are only about 10% <strong>of</strong> the schools whose available toilets are not in working.<br />
Further to this, the field analysis and survey results show that these non functionality <strong>of</strong> the school’s<br />
toilet can be categorized with damaged doors, no water supply, no ventilation and the toilet itself is<br />
in dilapidated state. These are the observed problems that make the available toilets unusable. In<br />
addition to the functionality <strong>of</strong> the toilets, there should also be proper cleaning or maintenance <strong>of</strong><br />
these functional toilets in these schools. The following graph shows the percentage distribution <strong>of</strong><br />
schools with functional toilets according to their maintenance.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 111
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
The analysis shows that there are about 84% <strong>of</strong> the school’s functional toilets which are cleaned at<br />
regular intervals. There are also about 16% <strong>of</strong> them which do not follow any timing in their cleaning<br />
activities <strong>of</strong> their toilets. The survey analysis and field verifications show that the school’s toilets that<br />
are cleaned regularly – follow a regular interval i.e. the toilets are cleaned at least once in a day.<br />
Further to toiletry details, the analysis also focused on provision <strong>of</strong> wash basin facilities within the<br />
schools. The analysis shows that there are about only 38% <strong>of</strong> schools which are having wash basin<br />
facilities within the schools. The following graph shows the percentage distribution <strong>of</strong> number <strong>of</strong><br />
schools according to wash basin provisions.<br />
Further to this, the analysis also focused on some minimum requirement that are needed to be<br />
provided to these wash basins to have proper functionality. It is not just enough to have just the<br />
provision <strong>of</strong> wash basins in the schools, it is also important to provide minimum infrastructure to<br />
these fixtures and they can be categorized into water supply and proper maintenance. From the<br />
analysis, it is being shown that about 70% <strong>of</strong> the schools with wash basins do not have any kind <strong>of</strong><br />
water supply connections. And about 10% <strong>of</strong> them not cleaned properly or not well maintained and<br />
about 10% are not in proper shape i.e. there are almost in broken stage. In addition to this, there are<br />
about 10% <strong>of</strong> school’s wash basins – not in a usable state.<br />
In addition to the availability and functionality <strong>of</strong> these school toilets and other toiletry<br />
infrastructure – it is important to understand and analyze the responsible agents and budget<br />
allocated for proper maintenance <strong>of</strong> these facilities at school. From the analysis, it is being shown<br />
that about 80% <strong>of</strong> the school’s O&M is carried by school employees themselves and the rest by<br />
government. Further, the amount that is being allocated for the O&M <strong>of</strong> school by government is<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 112
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
about 3500 – 5000 (in Rs) per annum. But, the amount that is being allocated is not separately for<br />
school toilets maintenance. It is the overall school maintenance budget allocation for the entire year,<br />
which is hardly sufficient for any kind <strong>of</strong> developments or improvements <strong>of</strong> toilet facilities in these<br />
schools.<br />
Based on the above mentioned budget allocation and responsible agents for O&M, there are about<br />
85% <strong>of</strong> the schools who made few improvements to the toilets during the last 3 years. And the<br />
improvements are only related to minimal – such as fixing up the doors, fixing up the water<br />
connection, painting <strong>of</strong> walls and doors, flooring, and cleaning at regular intervals. Thus, this also<br />
show that majority <strong>of</strong> schools with toilets have further improvements to avoid further damage. In<br />
addition to toilet cleaning status, it is also important to consider the cleaning activities for the water<br />
storage facilities and the school premises. The analysis shows that about 58% <strong>of</strong> the schools have<br />
their cleaning activities done for storage facilities for every 6 months and about 32% <strong>of</strong> them<br />
annually. There are about 10% <strong>of</strong> schools who do not have any kind <strong>of</strong> cleaning activities in schools<br />
and its infrastructure.<br />
In addition to this, solid waste disposal is also important to consider. The waste generated at school<br />
premises can be disposed and it is being categorized into road side bins, open site disposals, into<br />
drains and door to door collection. The analysis shows that about 64% <strong>of</strong> the schools dispose their<br />
waste into road side bins; and about 13% on open sites and the rest through regular door to door<br />
collection. Thus, it can be concluded that the solid waste disposal mechanism at schools is safe. In<br />
addition to this, the all the schools in Bareilly has a curriculum which provides basic sanitary and<br />
hygiene education to the students which reflects upon proper usage and maintenance <strong>of</strong> the toilets<br />
at schools by students.<br />
Key Issues:<br />
1. About 40% <strong>of</strong> the schools do not have any workers to maintain the cleanliness <strong>of</strong> the<br />
surroundings <strong>of</strong> the school<br />
2. About 47% <strong>of</strong> the schools whose toilets are not in any working conditions.<br />
3. About 30% <strong>of</strong> the school’s cleanliness is done by students themselves<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 113
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
4. about 15% <strong>of</strong> schools who do not have access to toilet facilities both in male and female<br />
category end up majorly in open defecation in or around the premises <strong>of</strong> respective schools<br />
and in some cases use toilets at home or neighbors (in case <strong>of</strong> girls).<br />
5. No proper infrastructure facilities<br />
6. About 20% <strong>of</strong> schools who do have any kind <strong>of</strong> sourced <strong>of</strong> water supply.<br />
7. There are about 10% <strong>of</strong> the schools with no water storage facilities.<br />
8. Only 25% <strong>of</strong> schools which are not having wash basin facilities within the schools.<br />
9. About 75% <strong>of</strong> the schools with wash basins do not have any kind <strong>of</strong> water supply<br />
connections. And about 10% <strong>of</strong> them not cleaned properly or not well maintained and about<br />
10% are not in proper shape i.e. there are almost in broken stage. In addition to this, there<br />
are about 10% <strong>of</strong> school’s wash basins – not in a usable state.<br />
10. No O&M for schools toilets and no proper budget allocation for improvements.<br />
11. About 64% <strong>of</strong> the schools dispose their waste into road side bins; and about 23% on open<br />
sites and the rest through regular door to door collection.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 114
IEC AND AWARENESS ISSUES<br />
Open Defecation<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
The number <strong>of</strong> villages located at the outskirts <strong>of</strong> the city has been merged with Nagar Nigam<br />
Bareilly but over the period <strong>of</strong> time no civic development has taken place in these areas. Most <strong>of</strong> the<br />
households in these areas are not having the provision <strong>of</strong> any kind <strong>of</strong> toilets and maximum people<br />
open defecate in the fields around these localities.<br />
Community Toilets<br />
There are twenty one community toilets in the city mainly located in slum areas. As <strong>of</strong> now these<br />
toilets are not looked after properly and having several inherent problems. In the worst case<br />
scenario these are in dilapidated condition with crumbling building, leaking septic tanks, broken<br />
seats, and broken doors, with no water arrangement and no provision <strong>of</strong> routine upkeep &<br />
maintenance. Such toilets are seen in Jawahar Nagar Bihar Basti, Azam Nagar, Haru Nagla, Gandha<br />
Nala etc. Open defecation sites and garbage dumps in the proximity <strong>of</strong> community toilets are a<br />
common sight. Moreover, it has been noticed that in most <strong>of</strong> community toilets, children are<br />
allowed to use the community toilets. The children accompanying their mothers defecate in and<br />
around the community toilets in open drains. It is essential to classify toilets based on the survey<br />
results to devise a plan <strong>of</strong> action. Broadly, the toilets would need the following measures. In worst<br />
case scenario this may require rebuilding the entire toilets complex. Generally, deteriorating<br />
infrastructure such as cracks in septic tanks, broken seats and doors need to be repaired. Proper<br />
operation and maintenance <strong>of</strong> theses toilets assumes significance in the context <strong>of</strong> promoting toilet<br />
usage. Where the toilets are not maintained properly, people tend to go back to the habit <strong>of</strong> open<br />
defecation. Cleaner and well maintained community toilets will ensure their better usage and in turn<br />
arrest the open defecation habit <strong>of</strong> people. An IEC campaign involving local NGOs and SHGs is<br />
recommended to bring the change in the behavior <strong>of</strong> people.<br />
Commercial Areas<br />
Commercial areas and markets are lacking the provision <strong>of</strong> toilets and urinals. Roads and streets<br />
sweeping is done irregularly by the Nagar Nigam Safai Karamcharis and waste piles up fast on the<br />
roads/streets sides. There is no provision <strong>of</strong> dustbins in the commercial places/markets and the<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 115
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
people tend to throw the waste on the roadside or in the drains/nallas. The waste/garbage in most<br />
these areas is collected once in two or three days.<br />
Water Supply<br />
Pipe water supply network is there but without any metering. This leads to maximum wastage <strong>of</strong><br />
water particularly at public stand posts in the slum/LIG areas. Thus there is ample scope for public<br />
awareness, as most people don’t seem to bother about the optimum utilization <strong>of</strong> water. To<br />
overcome the shortage <strong>of</strong> water, Jalkal Vibhag has installed about hand pumps in the slum/LIG<br />
areas. Besides this large number <strong>of</strong> households have made their own private arrangement <strong>of</strong> hand<br />
pumps; Illegal connections and resultant leakages in the pipeline are very common resulting in<br />
mismanagement & supplying <strong>of</strong> contaminated water to the consumers. In such a scenario it is not<br />
unusual that people <strong>of</strong> Bareilly city prefer the hand pump water to the supplied water for domestic<br />
purpose.<br />
Solid Waste Management<br />
There is no arrangement <strong>of</strong> door to door collection and segregation <strong>of</strong> municipal waste at source in<br />
the city. As <strong>of</strong> now, the municipal waste is unscientifically dumped openly at the outskirts <strong>of</strong> the<br />
city. There is a need to organize the solid waste management on priority and expedite the<br />
completion <strong>of</strong> ongoing integrated solid waste management project.<br />
Sanitation Consciousness: Current Status <strong>of</strong> Services and Behavior<br />
Generally, slums located in outskirts <strong>of</strong> the city and those in interior <strong>of</strong>fer two different typologies.<br />
The core and old city areas are predominantly Muslim population; representing diversity in terms <strong>of</strong><br />
demography. And the slums on the outskirts are predominant with SC or ST population. Based on<br />
these typologies we have identified the following stakeholder groups and their behavioral patterns:<br />
Stakeholder<br />
Groups<br />
Slums Outskirts Man Nagla, Haroo<br />
Areas <strong>of</strong> Habitation Socio-cultural/Behavioural Patterns<br />
Nagla, Shikarpur,<br />
Open defecation is prevalent.<br />
Most <strong>of</strong> the households are not having the<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 116
Slums Inner<br />
City<br />
Nadaushi, Veer<br />
Bhatti, Joharpur etc<br />
and other areas as<br />
marked on the map<br />
Saidpur Hawking,<br />
Surkha Chawni,<br />
Banipur Chaudhary<br />
and other such areas<br />
as marked on the<br />
map.<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
toilet/latrine facilities and all the habitants <strong>of</strong><br />
these areas open defecate in the fields.<br />
There is no provision <strong>of</strong> community toilets in<br />
these areas.<br />
There is no provision <strong>of</strong> door to door collection<br />
but residents throw garbage on the open<br />
road/street or in vacant land,/drains/nallas.<br />
No pipe water supply network and the source<br />
<strong>of</strong> water supply is hand pumps.<br />
There is no drainage system and water logging<br />
take place at low lying areas.<br />
This area is having community toilets with<br />
several operation and maintenance challenges.<br />
Children are not allowed to enter the<br />
community toilets<br />
Open defecation by children in drains and open<br />
spaces is common.<br />
Water Scarcity and poor state <strong>of</strong> community<br />
toilets forces elders also to defecate in open<br />
but, it is not very common. Some community<br />
toilets do not have water, electricity connection<br />
with broken toilet seats force people to<br />
defecate in close vicinity.<br />
People are in some ways constrained in going<br />
out to defecate in the inner city areas. Open<br />
areas such as Public Park land or vacant plots<br />
have become open defecation spots.<br />
Most <strong>of</strong> community toilets discharge their<br />
waste into open nallas/drains.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 117<br />
.
Shopkeepers Commercial<br />
Higher Income<br />
Group<br />
Residents<br />
Low Income<br />
Group<br />
Residents<br />
Municipal<br />
<strong>of</strong>ficials<br />
Areas/Markets like<br />
Kotwali, Ghanta<br />
Ghar, railway station<br />
road, bus stand and<br />
other areas on map<br />
Civil lines, Model<br />
town, vikas colony<br />
indra colony etc and<br />
areas locatable on<br />
map<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
Bareilly is prominent industrial city <strong>of</strong> UP.<br />
General hygiene & sanitation awareness is far<br />
below among the shopkeepers; particularly<br />
meat, milk products, vegetables/fruits or<br />
eatable shops.<br />
Most <strong>of</strong> the shopkeepers throw their waste on<br />
the road/street side or in nallas. The nallas get<br />
clogged and cleaned at irregular intervals by<br />
Nagar Nigam.<br />
No provision <strong>of</strong> dustbins in the commercial<br />
areas and markets.<br />
Very few public toilets and urinals in the market<br />
areas.<br />
No door to door collection<br />
Irregular water supply is a major issue for the<br />
residents.<br />
Residents tend to install motors to draw up<br />
water to first and second floors. These motors<br />
are attached directly to the supply pipe posing<br />
problems to those down the line.<br />
Marked by individual toilets, irregular sweeping<br />
<strong>of</strong> street, occasional clearing <strong>of</strong> drains.<br />
Irregular water supply<br />
Dumping <strong>of</strong> solid waste in open on roadside<br />
City Wide Officials should call meetings <strong>of</strong> shopkeepers<br />
specially butchers/eatable vendors to raise<br />
their awareness about hygiene and to promote<br />
safe practices <strong>of</strong> waste disposal.<br />
Nagar Nigam <strong>of</strong>ficials need help to enhance<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 118
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
their capacities for better implementation <strong>of</strong><br />
sanitation projects.<br />
A better co-ordination between various<br />
departments such as JalKal Vibhag, BDA is<br />
required.<br />
Nagar Nigam should look into operational as<br />
well as maintenance aspects <strong>of</strong> community<br />
toilets.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 119
4.1. SUMMARY OF THE KEY ISSUES<br />
Slum areas:<br />
Key issues:<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
CHAPTER 04<br />
INFERENCES/ GAP IDENTIFICATIONS<br />
Lack <strong>of</strong> proper shelter, poor access to basic needs and lack <strong>of</strong> awareness make the slum dwellers<br />
life style very poor. About 25 percent <strong>of</strong> the Bareilly’s population is living in slums; hence all<br />
housing programmes should target provision <strong>of</strong> better shelter for them on priority basis.<br />
In many <strong>of</strong> the slums water through public stand posts and hand pumps have been provided but<br />
it has been observed that lots <strong>of</strong> water is wasted.<br />
The quality <strong>of</strong> piped water supply, which slum dwellers receive, is very poor and suspected to be<br />
contaminated. Without filtration it is impossible for them to use it for drinking purpose.<br />
Only in a few slums sewerage lines have been provided and they were <strong>of</strong>ten chocked.<br />
No proper mechanism <strong>of</strong> solid waste disposal exists. Either the disposal sites are non-existent or<br />
even if they exist, they are located at faraway place which the slum dwellers find inconvenient to<br />
use. The few waste disposal sites that exist are in a sad state <strong>of</strong> affairs as they are not cleaned on<br />
a daily basis and the waste gets scattered all over the place creating a health hazard.<br />
In most <strong>of</strong> the slums, no provision has been made to provide storm water drains. Due to which<br />
water logging takes place adding to the unhygienic condition within the slums.<br />
While the city has made provision for public sanitation facilities in a few slums, still about 25-<br />
30% <strong>of</strong> slum population goes for open defecation, causing both a health hazard and a problem <strong>of</strong><br />
safety.<br />
At present the number <strong>of</strong> notified slum is 85 and strategies for rehabilitation and<br />
implementation <strong>of</strong> central and state government schemes can only be carried out in the notified<br />
slums. There is a need to carry out a fresh survey to cover all slums and poor communities so<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 120
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
that the actual demand for housing and basic services for urban poor can be ascertained and<br />
overall city environment can be improved.<br />
More than twenty percent <strong>of</strong> the population in Bareilly stays in areas marred with unhygienic<br />
living conditions and lack <strong>of</strong> civic amenities. The urban infrastructure is not satisfactory enough<br />
to bring homogenous development in new areas. The growth <strong>of</strong> housing stock is not able to<br />
keep pace with the population growth. This has increased the housing stock deficit which has<br />
given rise to slum dwellings.<br />
There are 85 notified slum with current population is about 2.44 lakh having about 32000 <strong>of</strong><br />
households i.e. about 26% <strong>of</strong> the total population.<br />
Majority <strong>of</strong> households i.e. more than 51 percent live in Kutcha Houses made <strong>of</strong> grass, mud etc.<br />
and jhuggi jhopri’s. Only 21 percent stay in Pucca Houses. In slums, about 47 percent have their<br />
own houses whereas 41% lives in as tenant whereas rest is living as unauthorized occupants.<br />
It may be seen that in slums access to individual water connections is low and people generally<br />
use public stand posts, hand pumps, or wells in a few cases. Majority <strong>of</strong> households (55%) get<br />
water from public stand posts and only 19% percent have individual taps.<br />
It has been observed that main source <strong>of</strong> water supply in slum areas is hand pumps and<br />
wherever piped water supply is there, either supply is inadequate or it’s not regular or it’s very<br />
dirty.<br />
Presently, access to sanitation services is markedly less than access to other basic service.<br />
In case <strong>of</strong> slums, it has been observed that sanitation facilities are worst and in alarming<br />
condition.<br />
Water Supply<br />
Key Issues:<br />
The total water supplied in MLD is about 124.<br />
The availability <strong>of</strong> water is adequate but distribution system needs improvement.<br />
Issues are that numbers <strong>of</strong> connection is not increasing due to excess use <strong>of</strong> ground water,<br />
low pressure and unreliable service, low utilization due to old and leaky system, Inadequate<br />
funds for O&M.<br />
The need is felt to expand distribution as demand is high.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 121
The piped water supply <strong>of</strong> Bareilly City was started about 30 years ago.<br />
The distribution network covers 60% <strong>of</strong> the city area.<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
The leakage (UFW - unaccounted-for water) is estimated to be 30 percent due to old and<br />
leaky pipelines.<br />
The most significant drawback <strong>of</strong> Bareilly water supply is the huge amount <strong>of</strong> water wastage<br />
Sewerage<br />
Key Issues:<br />
and negligible revenue collection from public utilities (for example parks and fire fighting<br />
etc.) and stand posts which takes away about 10 percent <strong>of</strong> water.<br />
The source <strong>of</strong> sewer is mostly from domestic households but the waste generated from<br />
industries also flow into sewers.<br />
The total length <strong>of</strong> sewerage network pipes in the city is about 206.2 km but, the age <strong>of</strong> the<br />
sewerage network pipes is only about 35 years.<br />
The total area covered by sewerage network is only about 25 sq.km<br />
The thus produced waste water is about 99.2 MLD from all the sources within the city.<br />
No sewerage treatment plant.<br />
There is surplus sewage, which gets discharged in River without treatment.<br />
The waste water generated from different types <strong>of</strong> industries is left into sewer without any<br />
primary treatment at industries itself.<br />
Strom water drainage<br />
Key Issues:<br />
Each zone is having primary, secondary and tertiary drains <strong>of</strong> different lengths.<br />
The waste drained into River through these nalas - includes waste water from households,<br />
commercial areas, and industrial areas.<br />
Most <strong>of</strong> the open/ closed drains are chocked with solid waste and sludge.<br />
There are many flood prone drains within the city.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 122
Solid Waste Management<br />
Key Issues:<br />
No processing/ recycling facilities.<br />
No door to door collection <strong>of</strong> waste.<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
The dumping grounds, by roadside and elsewhere, are unhygienic and have deplorable look.<br />
Disposal <strong>of</strong> waste into drains leads to choking <strong>of</strong> drains<br />
Rains washed out part <strong>of</strong> garbage from these depots into drains and Nalas which leads to<br />
silting.<br />
Mixing <strong>of</strong> Bio-medical and other forms <strong>of</strong> waste with municipal waste is a serious health<br />
hazard.<br />
Lack <strong>of</strong> segregation <strong>of</strong> bio-degradable and non-degradable waste at source<br />
Large scale public littering leading to inattentiveness <strong>of</strong> street sweeping and cleaning<br />
activities<br />
Shortage <strong>of</strong> staff and lack <strong>of</strong> motivation amongst the existing staff<br />
Presently there is no waste processing plant at Bareilly and the total waste is taken to<br />
disposal size.<br />
At present waste generation in the city is around 450MT per day.<br />
For Bareilly, household and organic waste constitutes largest component followed by inert<br />
material such as building material and debris etc. in overall composition <strong>of</strong> waste i.e. waste<br />
generated from households, commercial establishments and institutions in Bareilly.<br />
The main sources <strong>of</strong> waste generation includes Residential, commercial, industrial<br />
establishments, hospital & nursing homes, hotels & restaurants, slaughter houses, street<br />
sweeping, sanitary drains and construction and demolition sites.<br />
Collection is conducted in two stages – primary and secondary collection.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 123
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
Total hazardous waste generated from the Industries is about 18 tons per day. Out <strong>of</strong> total<br />
industrial waste, the generation <strong>of</strong> hazardous waste containing chromium is bout 10-15 MT<br />
per day.<br />
The quantity <strong>of</strong> waste generated from these medical institutions is approx 2.74 tonnes per<br />
day.<br />
Out <strong>of</strong> total bio -waste generated, only 1350 Kg (about 20 %) is sent to the centralized bio-<br />
medical waste management facility. Some estimate that about 30 percent <strong>of</strong> bio-medical<br />
waste is getting mixed up with other type <strong>of</strong> waste.<br />
Most <strong>of</strong> the slaughtered waste is thrown into the bakarmandi nala. Total waste generation is<br />
approximately 4-5ton/day.<br />
The dust generated through street sweeping constitutes 5% (72.35 MT) <strong>of</strong> total waste.<br />
The drain silt constitutes about 10% <strong>of</strong> the MSW generated in Bareilly city.<br />
A major portion <strong>of</strong> this waste is generally used in reconstruction activities for filling up <strong>of</strong> the<br />
low-lying areas or kutcha road – i.e. about 20% <strong>of</strong> this waste is collected at these sites and<br />
become a part <strong>of</strong> MSW.<br />
Households (Slum and non slum areas)<br />
Key Issues:<br />
The present population in total city is about 9.23 lacs with a bifurcation <strong>of</strong> slum and non<br />
slum population. Statistics show that there is about 27% <strong>of</strong> the slum population i.e. about<br />
2.44 lacs and the remaining in non slum areas i.e. about 6.74lacs.<br />
The number <strong>of</strong> slums that are notified are about 85 in number that spread across the city. In<br />
addition to these notified slums there are about 20-30 unnotified slums and are categorized<br />
in low income groups in Bareilly.<br />
The different types <strong>of</strong> individual toilet facilities in Bareilly city are soak pit toilets, pour flush<br />
toilets, Kuddi.<br />
About 94% <strong>of</strong> the non slum households are with household individual toilets – and these<br />
household individual toilets include pit latrine, water closet, and septic tank.<br />
There is about 1-2% <strong>of</strong> the total number <strong>of</strong> households in non slum areas using community<br />
toilets.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 124
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
There is about 5% <strong>of</strong> the total number <strong>of</strong> households do not have any kind <strong>of</strong> access to<br />
toilets i.e. about 5255 households i.e. about 40 thousand <strong>of</strong> population in non slum areas<br />
defecate openly.<br />
The percentage share <strong>of</strong> households/ population having access to household individual<br />
toilets is about 60% <strong>of</strong> the households and these also include the individual pour flush toilets<br />
build by different agencies as mentioned above.<br />
There are about 5% <strong>of</strong> slum households in addition to the private/ public individual toilets<br />
there are also community toilets in the slum areas.<br />
About 89259 persons in slum areas i.e. about 11643 households defecate openly.<br />
There are about 1.29 lacs <strong>of</strong> total population i.e. about 16898 <strong>of</strong> households <strong>of</strong> Bareilly city<br />
i.e. about 14.04% <strong>of</strong> the total population/ households <strong>of</strong> Bareilly open defecate.<br />
Community Toilets:<br />
Key issues<br />
1. There are about 23 community toilets with about 96% <strong>of</strong> them located in slum areas and the<br />
rest in non slum regions i.e. in low income group areas.<br />
2. The total numbers <strong>of</strong> persons dependent on community toilets are 5 – 10% <strong>of</strong> the total<br />
population.<br />
3. About 50% <strong>of</strong> the available community toilets are in bad state, but about 5% <strong>of</strong> the<br />
community toilets are not in a usable state.<br />
4. No O&M <strong>of</strong> community toilets and its infrastructure.<br />
5. No proper fecal sludge management.<br />
6. The fecal sludge collected from these septic tanks by the municipalities sludge sucking<br />
machine and they dispose it into nearby nalas which lead to River.<br />
7. 50% <strong>of</strong> the available community toilets are in bad state. The infrastructure facilities in these<br />
toilets are almost broken conditions but even then, the people are still dependent upon<br />
these community toilets.<br />
8. About 6% <strong>of</strong> the community toilets are not in a usable state<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 125
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
9. About 30% <strong>of</strong> the communities toilets are equipped with pour flush pit latrines and about<br />
37% <strong>of</strong> them with water closets. There are also about 17% <strong>of</strong> the community toilets with dry<br />
pit latrine and the rest with service and unimproved pit latrines.<br />
10. About 32% <strong>of</strong> the community toilet facilities are connected to septic tanks and about 50% <strong>of</strong><br />
them are connected to sewer lines.<br />
11. In about 80% <strong>of</strong> the community toilets with septic tanks, the fecal sludge collected from<br />
these septic tanks by the municipalities or private sludge sucking machine and they dispose<br />
it into nearby nalas which lead to Ganga River.<br />
12. In addition to the disposal <strong>of</strong> sludge produced at community toilets there are also about 10%<br />
<strong>of</strong> the community toilets using the sludge at bio gas treatment.<br />
13. There is about 98% <strong>of</strong> the community toilets have no proper effluent waste management.<br />
There are all let into open drains. There is only about 2% <strong>of</strong> the number <strong>of</strong> community toilets<br />
effluent waste disposed/ connected to sewer lines.<br />
Commercial/ market places<br />
Key issues:<br />
1. More number <strong>of</strong> male workers population and more number <strong>of</strong> working hours.<br />
2. About 35% <strong>of</strong> the commercial/ market places having some kind <strong>of</strong> toilet facilities within the<br />
complex.<br />
3. High percentage use <strong>of</strong> public toilets by the workers in the commercial places and market<br />
areas.<br />
4. About 5 - 10% <strong>of</strong> workers open defecate.<br />
5. No proper sludge management.<br />
6. Willingness to buy monthly passes for the usage <strong>of</strong> public/ community toilets.<br />
7. Poor solid waste disposal and collection mechanisms.<br />
8. 0% <strong>of</strong> the customer population does not have any awareness <strong>of</strong> any provision <strong>of</strong> toilet<br />
facilities in market areas or commercial shops.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 126
9. No provision <strong>of</strong> community/ public toilets in high density commercial areas.<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
10. No usage <strong>of</strong> complex toilets or toilets provided in shops by the customers in case <strong>of</strong> any<br />
emergency.<br />
11. The usage <strong>of</strong> public toilets in commercial areas is only about 50% and there is about 10% <strong>of</strong><br />
open defecation by the customer populations in commercial areas.<br />
12. No willingness to pay and use for public toilets.<br />
13. The common and prevalent problems faced by general public in market areas due to<br />
Hospitals<br />
Key issues:<br />
improper garbage disposal are – blocking the roads, smell from road side bins and also smell<br />
from chocked nalas.<br />
1. Half the number <strong>of</strong> hospitals are with beds 50+; 0.3 kg/bed/day (on average)<br />
2. 60% <strong>of</strong> hospitals provide all facilities – generation <strong>of</strong> more waste at each sources<br />
3. 40% <strong>of</strong> hospitals generate more than 60kg <strong>of</strong> bio medical waste/ day.<br />
4. 70% <strong>of</strong> hospitals produce more than 8lts <strong>of</strong> liquid waste/day<br />
5. 90% <strong>of</strong> hospitals – does not follow Bio-medical waste rules, 1998.<br />
6. 100% <strong>of</strong> hospitals discharge their liquid BMW into sewerage.<br />
7. 80% <strong>of</strong> hospitals do not treat their fecal sludge into sewerage leading to open drains.<br />
Institutions<br />
Key Issues:<br />
1. No proper maintenance <strong>of</strong> these existing toilets.<br />
2. the conditions <strong>of</strong> toilets are bad – public still use them in case <strong>of</strong> emergency, due to no<br />
provision <strong>of</strong> other toilet facilities in nearby premises.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 127
Schools<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
3. Toilets are also provided to employees in all these institutional buildings but not properly<br />
maintained.<br />
4. No proper infrastructure facilities in these toilets – include electricity and water supply.<br />
5. Bareilly <strong>Development</strong> Authority - found few toilets in worst condition.<br />
6. Nagar Nigam Bareilly - found few toilets in worst condition.<br />
Key Issues:<br />
1. About 40% <strong>of</strong> the schools do not have any workers to maintain the cleanliness <strong>of</strong> the<br />
surroundings <strong>of</strong> the school<br />
2. About 47% <strong>of</strong> the schools whose toilets are not in any working conditions.<br />
3. About 30% <strong>of</strong> the school’s cleanliness is done by students themselves<br />
4. about 15% <strong>of</strong> schools who do not have access to toilet facilities both in male and female<br />
category end up majorly in open defecation in or around the premises <strong>of</strong> respective schools<br />
and in some cases use toilets at home or neighbors (in case <strong>of</strong> girls).<br />
5. No proper infrastructure facilities<br />
6. About 20% <strong>of</strong> schools who do have any kind <strong>of</strong> sourced <strong>of</strong> water supply.<br />
7. There are about 10% <strong>of</strong> the schools with no water storage facilities.<br />
8. Only 25% <strong>of</strong> schools which are not having wash basin facilities within the schools.<br />
9. About 75% <strong>of</strong> the schools with wash basins do not have any kind <strong>of</strong> water supply<br />
connections. And about 10% <strong>of</strong> them not cleaned properly or not well maintained and about<br />
10% are not in proper shape i.e. there are almost in broken stage. In addition to this, there<br />
are about 10% <strong>of</strong> school’s wash basins – not in a usable state.<br />
10. No O&M for schools toilets and no proper budget allocation for improvements.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 128
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
11. About 64% <strong>of</strong> the schools dispose their waste into road side bins; and about 23% on open<br />
sites and the rest through regular door to door collection.<br />
Issues related to Open Defecation & Sewerage:<br />
In maximum households, the toilet flush are not connected to soakpits. The water from<br />
septic tanks goes directly into drains which is very unhygienic. The existing sewer lines are<br />
not adequate and very old.<br />
People are ready to pay User Charges for the sanitation services in the city.<br />
The wastewater should be reused/recycled after treatment for agricultural purposes,<br />
washing clothes/cars /vehicles etc.<br />
Slum sanitation should be given high priority.<br />
Most <strong>of</strong> the city drainage system is clogged with polythenes bags and it should be cleaned<br />
regularly.<br />
The condition <strong>of</strong> the city drainage system is very poor and need immediate repairs and<br />
regular upkeep/maintenance.<br />
The large drains are being encroached by dwelling units, milk diaries, shopkeepers etc and<br />
thus difficult to clean & maintain them. It should be checked so that sanitary conditions <strong>of</strong><br />
the city are improved.<br />
The use <strong>of</strong> Polythene Bags should be banned in the city. In fact, polythene bags are<br />
worsening the sanitary conditions <strong>of</strong> the city.<br />
There is acute shortage <strong>of</strong> the community toilets in the city and thus compelling the people<br />
particularly in slum and LIG areas to defecate in the open. More community toilets should<br />
be constructed in the city.<br />
Sewerage Treatment Project should come up in the city like solid waste management<br />
project.<br />
Sanitation Awareness Campaign should be arranged twice a month particularly in slum and<br />
LIG areas. Media/posters/skits and other tools should be used for the sanitation awareness<br />
campaign in schools; markets awareness campaigns should be organized. A system should<br />
be introduced to seek people’s feedback and opinion about the sanitation services in the<br />
city.<br />
Before passing the proposed house maps, it should be ensured that the house is having<br />
provision <strong>of</strong> waterborne toilets and facility <strong>of</strong> rain water harvesting.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 129
Issues relating to Solid Waste Management:<br />
Most <strong>of</strong> the people throw the household garbage in the open and drains.<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
Over the period <strong>of</strong> time, the solid waste and garbage is being dumped and accumulated at<br />
various places in the city.<br />
There is no provision <strong>of</strong> door-to-door collection <strong>of</strong> garbage in the city.<br />
The vegetable & fruit Mandis are occupying space on the roadside and major source <strong>of</strong><br />
biodegradable garbage which is not cleaned regularly and thus polluting the environment <strong>of</strong><br />
city.<br />
Most <strong>of</strong> the street/road sweeping waste and garbage are thrown in the drains and nalas by<br />
the safaikaramcharies.<br />
The solid as well as liquid waste <strong>of</strong> slaughter houses in the city is being dumped in the open<br />
& discharged in the nalas. It is a totally unhygienic and major health hazard for the city.<br />
Dust bins and Garbage Containers should be permanently placed in the markets/identified places<br />
and some responsible agency should be designated to collect the garbage regularly.<br />
The Safai karamcharies should be motivated to perform their duties honestly and<br />
meticulously to keep the city clean and green.<br />
The cattle waste is directly thrown/ discharged in to the nalas/drains.<br />
GAP IDENTIFICATION<br />
The total number <strong>of</strong> household having no access to any type <strong>of</strong> sanitary facilities in Bareilly<br />
are 18047 households – <strong>of</strong> which 12740 household in slums and 5307 households in non<br />
slum areas – there can be proposals for individual toilets, community toilets or group toilets<br />
to overcome the gaps and have open defecation free city.<br />
In addition to the proposals stated above - there should be attention required for the<br />
Community/ public toilets at the following mentioned places: NEKAPUR, BALMIKI BASTI,<br />
JASAULI, GANDA NALA, INDIRA MARKET, KISHORE BAZAR, CHAUPULA BAGIYA, CHAUPULA<br />
ROAD, JAWAHAR NAGAR, SUFFI TOLLAA, AAJAZ NAGAR, and RAJ NAGAR.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 130
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
The provision <strong>of</strong> toilets at commercial complexes also plays a vital role. Thus the toilet<br />
facilities at commercial complexes that require immediate construction are as follows:<br />
BALMIKI BASTI, INDIRA MARKET<br />
Addressing the sewerage waste water and storm water drainage, construction <strong>of</strong> Sewerage<br />
Treatment Plant would give best results<br />
Addressing sludge management issues at household toilets and community toilets.<br />
Proper operation and maintenance <strong>of</strong> all the public toilets located at commercial/ market<br />
places.<br />
Proper garbage disposal <strong>of</strong> garbage management at commercial/ market places.<br />
Proper sludge management <strong>of</strong> public toilets.<br />
Scientific disposal <strong>of</strong> solid and liquid waste generated at all the hospitals.<br />
The toilet facilities at institutional building that require immediate attention/<br />
improvements/ rehabitation are as follows: BAREILLY RAILWAY STATION, and NAGAR<br />
NIGAM BAREILLY.<br />
The other toilets provided at public institutional buildings should be rehabitalated with<br />
proper infrastructure facilities and requires O&M.<br />
Immediate attention should be focused on provision <strong>of</strong> sanitary facilities at the following<br />
schools: basic Siksha parisadiya primary school (ward no. 01), sarswati sishu Mandir (ward<br />
no. 03) , primary pattashala school (ward no. 03), aadha shilla school (ward no. 03), junior<br />
high school makarndapur sarkar (ward no. 04), apolo public school (Mandi road, ward no.<br />
04), jak and jill school (ward no. 04), sishu uthaan Siksha samithi (ward no. 05), schools at<br />
Indira nagar and janakpuri, ganesh gyan public school (ward no. 06), schools in ward no. 08<br />
(does not have toilets), purva madymik vidyalai (jasauli, ward no. 01), madyamik vidyalai<br />
(jakira, ward no: 01), jilat high school (ward no. 01), mehak high school (ward no 02), indira<br />
school (ward no 02), vudaro school (Rajendra nagar, ward no 06), sarswati ram Mandir<br />
school (indira nagar, ward no 06), agraseen public school (ward no 06), junior high schools in<br />
ward no 06 near prem nagar, shaabad, aarya samaj, gandhi nagar.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 131
Proper operation and maintenance <strong>of</strong> existing toilets at all schools.<br />
Proposals <strong>of</strong> DEWATS to avoid direct outflow <strong>of</strong> open drains into River.<br />
4.2. IEC AND AWARENESS –MESSAGES & CHANNELS<br />
Household Survey<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
About 250 households particularly in slum areas were surveyed to gauge water and sanitation<br />
situation in Bareilly city. Though the data does not claim to yield statistically significant results for<br />
Bareilly, there were some interesting findings. About 30% households are not having access to toilets<br />
and thus defecating in open. More surprisingly few houses are reporting manual scavenging. There<br />
is no door to door collection except in few pockets started recently as pilot project and high<br />
proportion <strong>of</strong> the respondents are dumping solid waste in designated container (if available) or open<br />
site on the road/street side. However, 86% <strong>of</strong> households claimed that Nagar Nigam Safai<br />
Karamcharis pick up the waste from their areas once in two or three days. About 38% <strong>of</strong> the<br />
residents opined that their streets are not swept regularly and 41% complained that drains are<br />
either cleaned once a week or irregularly. An overwhelming majority said they take their water and<br />
sanitation complaints to elected representatives. Further 53% said they complained directly through<br />
face to face interactions with Nagar Nigam <strong>of</strong>ficials (sanitary supervisors) and 27% complained on<br />
telephone.<br />
Public toilets in commercial places<br />
According to our survey there are very few public toilet facilities in the commercial areas or<br />
markets <strong>of</strong> the city. Most <strong>of</strong> the commercial places and markets are having some arrangement <strong>of</strong><br />
urinals particularly for gents only. Few shopkeepers use the existing public urinals and maximum<br />
people urinate in open drains. Sampled respondents have appreciated the idea <strong>of</strong> pay and use<br />
toilets if proper toilet facilities are made available. If they have to pay they prefer monthly pass <strong>of</strong><br />
Rs.20. Our survey results indicate that while on one hand shopkeepers and customers are<br />
experiencing difficulties due to lack <strong>of</strong> access to toilets, the overall willingness for pay per use option<br />
was found to be low. In such a situation a behavior change campaign is first required to create<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 132
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
demand for toilets. Then it could be recommended to build toilets in commercial areas on pay and<br />
use terms. Shopkeepers could opt for monthly passes and customers pay per use.<br />
Community Toilets<br />
As explained, in the worst case scenario these are in dilapidated condition with crumbling building,<br />
leaking septic tanks, broken seats, and broken doors, with no water or electricity or maintenance<br />
person. Several <strong>of</strong> these community toilets need to be rebuilt. Our survey covered 17 (100%)<br />
community toilets in Bareilly, merely 26% <strong>of</strong> these are in fully serviceable condition. About 62% are<br />
reported to be in bad implying that they are in unsanitary or dilapidated condition. Investing in<br />
community toilets is a pressing need for the city. At present O&M work is being shared by a host <strong>of</strong><br />
organizations including Nagar Nigam, DUDA, NEDA and Sulabh. No Correlation has been found<br />
between condition <strong>of</strong> toilets and the organization responsible for O&M.<br />
Key Messages for Stakeholders<br />
National <strong>Urban</strong> Sanitation Policy 2008, by the <strong>Ministry</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Urban</strong> <strong>Development</strong>, Government <strong>of</strong> India<br />
has outlined constitution, roles and responsibilities <strong>of</strong> City Sanitation Task Forces envisaging multi-<br />
stakeholder involvement. Some eminent persons from the city (from fields <strong>of</strong> academics, NGOs,<br />
media, art, business etc) could be included into this task force. At a more micro level, creation <strong>of</strong><br />
Ward Sanitation Action Committees headed by corporators <strong>of</strong> the concerned wards and comprising<br />
members from NNB, <strong>of</strong>fice bearers <strong>of</strong> RWAs, Safai Karamcharies is recommended.<br />
A set <strong>of</strong> powerful mnemonics related to sanitation could be one <strong>of</strong> the ways <strong>of</strong> beginning the process<br />
<strong>of</strong> developing sanitation consciousness- say something like ‘swach ghar samridh parivar’. The<br />
messages that need to be put across to the stakeholders are as follows:<br />
Target<br />
Audience<br />
Nagar Ayukt,<br />
NN Health &<br />
Sanitary<br />
Messages/Themes Channels <strong>of</strong> Communication<br />
Seeking community inputs for building<br />
and repairing community and<br />
individual toilets, toilets should be<br />
Training Programs for Officials<br />
from Nagar Nigam, Jal Kal<br />
Vibhag, DUDA<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 133
<strong>of</strong>ficials,<br />
Corporators etc<br />
Corporators,<br />
Office bearer <strong>of</strong><br />
Slum Resident<br />
Federations,<br />
NGOs<br />
representing<br />
slums in inner<br />
City<br />
designed for social acceptance.<br />
Anti- open defecation and sanitation<br />
campaigns<br />
How to ensure compliance from<br />
people through rewards/Punishments<br />
Better co-ordination between various<br />
departments including NNB, DUDA,<br />
Jal Kal for implementation <strong>of</strong> City<br />
Sanitation Plan<br />
Safe handling <strong>of</strong> garbage by Sanitation<br />
workers<br />
Promoting source segregation at<br />
source and dump yards<br />
Safe deposition <strong>of</strong> garbage by<br />
Contractors<br />
Consultations on preventing open<br />
defecation, especially highlighting the<br />
risks on railway line<br />
Consultation seeking inputs <strong>of</strong><br />
residents on improving community<br />
toilets and their usage<br />
Toilet options two pit, septic tank<br />
Safe disposal <strong>of</strong> Human Excreta<br />
Contamination due to Fecal Matter<br />
Health and hygiene: Diarrhea, GE,<br />
Malaria, Scabies<br />
Consultation <strong>of</strong> water supply situation<br />
Consultation on expectations form<br />
Municipality<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
Participation in interactive<br />
programmes such as transact<br />
walks etc to promote city<br />
sanitation<br />
CSTF meetings, CSP workshops,<br />
Newspaper Advertisement<br />
calling for meeting/seeking<br />
participation in transect walks<br />
Press Conference-sharing the<br />
goals and plan <strong>of</strong> action for CSP<br />
with press persons<br />
Videos on best practices and<br />
their impact<br />
Organising interactive<br />
programmes with elected<br />
representatives and <strong>of</strong>ficials.<br />
These could include transact<br />
walks in slum areas<br />
RWA/SRF/NGO Meeting<br />
Door to door campaign<br />
Newspaper Advertisement.<br />
Press Conference<br />
Screening <strong>of</strong> videos for sanitation<br />
awareness<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 134
Corporators,<br />
<strong>of</strong>fice bearers<br />
<strong>of</strong> Slum<br />
Resident<br />
Federations<br />
representing<br />
slums in City<br />
Outskirts<br />
Office bearers<br />
<strong>of</strong> Residents<br />
Welfare<br />
Association<br />
middleclass<br />
localities<br />
Water and<br />
sanitation<br />
<strong>of</strong>ficials<br />
Consultation seeking inputs <strong>of</strong><br />
residents on improving community<br />
toilets and their usage<br />
Health Risks due to open defecation<br />
Toilet options two pit, septic tank<br />
Contamination due to Fecal Matter<br />
Safe disposal <strong>of</strong> Human Excreta<br />
Health and hygiene: Diarrhea, GE,<br />
Malaria, Scabies<br />
Consultation on problems with water<br />
supply<br />
Consultation on expectations form<br />
NNB<br />
Consultation on problems with current<br />
toilets<br />
Consultation on septic tank cleaning<br />
Consultation on Environmental<br />
sanitation<br />
Consultation <strong>of</strong> water supply situation<br />
Consultation <strong>of</strong> willingness to pay user<br />
charges<br />
Consultation on expectations from<br />
NNB<br />
Display responsibilities <strong>of</strong> <strong>of</strong>ficials viz<br />
Sanitation Inspectors in their Circles<br />
especially in the vicinity <strong>of</strong> open<br />
defecation areas, markets, public<br />
parks, slaughter houses, around water<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
Organising interactive<br />
programmes with elected<br />
representatives and <strong>of</strong>ficials.<br />
These could include walks in the<br />
outskirt slums.<br />
RWA/SRF/NGO Meeting<br />
Door to door campaign<br />
Newspaper Advertisement<br />
Press Conference<br />
Screening <strong>of</strong> videos and films at<br />
meetings<br />
Meetings with <strong>of</strong>ficials,<br />
Door to door campaigning<br />
Newspaper Advertisement<br />
Cable TV<br />
Educational videos screening at<br />
meetings<br />
Printed pamphlets given with<br />
newspapers, newspaper<br />
advertisements, painting on<br />
Elevated/underground reservoirs<br />
Print the phone numbers <strong>of</strong><br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 135
Water and<br />
Sanitation<br />
Workers<br />
Shopkeepers,<br />
Commercial<br />
establishments,<br />
SSI units<br />
bodies<br />
Establish public grievance redressal<br />
mechanism.<br />
Appreciation <strong>of</strong> what people desire<br />
Importance <strong>of</strong> safe handling <strong>of</strong> waste,<br />
protective gear<br />
Important messages like not burning<br />
plastics, not dropping waste on the<br />
way to dump sites, intermediate bins<br />
Educating residents about Segregation<br />
<strong>of</strong> waste<br />
Do not dump garbage in by lanes, in<br />
drains<br />
Organize a meeting with NNB to<br />
appraise the <strong>of</strong>ficials <strong>of</strong> their<br />
grievances<br />
If you need to dispose heavy waste<br />
call the NNB and ask for a tractor.<br />
Improving sanitation facilities within<br />
the shops and factories for workers<br />
and customers<br />
Participation in Public toilets building<br />
and maintenance<br />
City Wide Keep houses and neighborhood clean<br />
Boil/Filter the Water before drinking<br />
Wash your hands before and after<br />
eating/drinking<br />
Don’t allow mosquitoes to breed in<br />
your neighborhood<br />
Immunize Children<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
responsible <strong>of</strong>ficials on the NNB<br />
garbage lifting vehicles<br />
Training Programs, Workshops<br />
on better gear, improved<br />
practices, consultations with<br />
Safai Karamcharis or sanitary<br />
worker unions<br />
Area specific meeting with<br />
shopkeepers, slaughter house<br />
operators , traders and<br />
representatives <strong>of</strong> SSI units<br />
Road Side Billboards<br />
News Paper Advertisements<br />
City TV Cable<br />
Short Films or videos to be<br />
screened in theatres etc.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 136
Don’t share clothes <strong>of</strong> persons<br />
infected with skin diseases<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 137
IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS OF KEY POTENTIAL ISSUES USING MATRIX METHOD<br />
KEY ISSUES<br />
IMPACT SCALE/ PRIORITY RANK I II III<br />
I 1/1<br />
II 2/1<br />
III 3/1<br />
Open Defecation<br />
Schools with no toilets<br />
Poor O&M <strong>of</strong> school<br />
toilets<br />
No public toilets at<br />
commercial/ market<br />
places<br />
Poor arrangements <strong>of</strong><br />
operation and<br />
maintenance <strong>of</strong> both<br />
community and public<br />
toilets<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
CHAPTER 05<br />
KEY POTENTIAL ISSUES<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 138<br />
½<br />
Waste disposal in open<br />
drains<br />
2/2<br />
No proper Fecal sludge<br />
management <strong>of</strong> community<br />
and public toilets and even at<br />
household level (those using<br />
septic tank)<br />
Low drinking water quality<br />
No proper maintenance <strong>of</strong><br />
Institutional toilets<br />
3/2<br />
No door to door collection <strong>of</strong><br />
household waste<br />
Unscientific disposal <strong>of</strong> liquid<br />
waste and fecal sludge from<br />
hospitals, community toilets<br />
and public toilets<br />
1/3<br />
% sewerage coverage<br />
2/3<br />
High Slaughter house<br />
waste disposal into<br />
nalas<br />
Industrial waste into<br />
nalas without primary<br />
treatment<br />
3/3<br />
Encroachments, waste<br />
dump sites - Water<br />
bodies
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
The existing situation <strong>of</strong> the cities (i.e. key problems are listed out – further, analysis for their<br />
consequences and their impacts.) A matrix is developed to highlight the areas <strong>of</strong> high priority that<br />
need to be addressed by ULB.<br />
PRIORITIZING THE IDENTIFIED POTENTIAL ISSUES USING MATRIX METHOD<br />
IMPACT SCALE/ PRIORITY RANK I II III<br />
I 1/1<br />
II 2/1<br />
III 3/1<br />
Individual toilets<br />
Community toilets<br />
Public toilets<br />
School sanitation<br />
O&M arrangements<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 139<br />
1/2<br />
Strom water drainage<br />
2/2<br />
Fecal sludge management<br />
Water Quality<br />
Institutional toilets<br />
3/2<br />
Solid waste management<br />
Liquid waste management<br />
1/3<br />
Sewerage System<br />
2/3<br />
Water supply<br />
Slaughter house waste<br />
Industrial waste<br />
3/3<br />
Water bodies
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
CHAPTER 06<br />
PROPOSALS/ RECOMMENDATIONS<br />
This section essentially deals with the requirements at the city level for sanitation services to<br />
support urban stability, enable social balance, economic growth and development and are<br />
imperative for the improvement <strong>of</strong> urban public services in Bareilly. Although there have been some<br />
national and state initiatives to increase sanitation coverage in Bareilly, a substantial part <strong>of</strong> urban<br />
population, especially in slums, has no adequate sanitation facilities made available to them by the<br />
government machinery.<br />
6.1 SWOT Analyses<br />
Long- term<br />
Mid - term<br />
Short - term<br />
The importance <strong>of</strong> SWOT analysis lies in its ability to help clarify and summaries the key issues and<br />
opportunities facing a sector. Value lies in considering the implications <strong>of</strong> the things identified and it<br />
can therefore play a key role in helping a sector to set objectives and develop new strategies. The<br />
ideal outcome would be to maximize strengths and minimize weaknesses in order to take advantage<br />
<strong>of</strong> external opportunities and overcome the threats. The biggest advantages <strong>of</strong> SWOT analysis is that<br />
it is simple and only costs time to do. It can help generate new ideas as to how a sector can use a<br />
particular strength to defend against threats in the performance. If a sector is aware <strong>of</strong> the potential<br />
threats then it can have responses and plans ready to counteract them when they happen. SWOT<br />
Analysis is the foundation for evaluating the internal potential and limitations and the likely<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 140
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
opportunities and threats from the external environment. It views all positive and negative factors<br />
inside and outside the sector that affect the success. A consistent study <strong>of</strong> the environment in which<br />
the sector operates helps in forecasting/predicting the changing trends and also helps in including<br />
them in the decision-making process <strong>of</strong> the particular sector in the context <strong>of</strong> Bareilly.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 141
SWOT Analysis for Nagar Nigam Bareilly -Water Supply<br />
Strengths<br />
60% <strong>of</strong> city coverage with piped water supply<br />
Average six hours daily water supply<br />
Opportunities<br />
Improving water quality and reducing water borne diseases<br />
Rehabilitation <strong>of</strong> the existing lines<br />
Constant vigilance to control illegal connections<br />
IEC campaign to overcome illegal connections from rising main and<br />
usage <strong>of</strong> untreated water leading to contamination<br />
Encouraging individual metered connection to increase revenue<br />
IEC to bring forth change in the mindset to go for Individual<br />
metered connections<br />
Weaknesses<br />
Lack <strong>of</strong> metered connections<br />
Leakages<br />
Using private electric pumps to suck water<br />
Illegal connections<br />
Water borne diseases due to poor quality <strong>of</strong> water supplied<br />
Threats<br />
Poor service in some areas<br />
Contamination due to household & commercial waste directly<br />
lead to open drains and nallas
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
SWOT Analysis for Nagar Nigam Bareilly - Sewerage & Storm Water Drainage<br />
Strengths<br />
Extensive nallas and drain network<br />
Approximately 25-30% <strong>of</strong> city covered by sewer lines<br />
Opportunities<br />
Plan and develop a sewerage treatment plants<br />
IEC campaign against throwing garbage in storm water drains<br />
Weaknesses<br />
Threats<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 143<br />
No sewerage treatment plant ‘STP’<br />
35 years old sewerage network<br />
Black and gray water not treated<br />
Household and commercial waste directly lead to open drains<br />
and nallas<br />
All nallas /drains discharging in water bodies<br />
Stagnated water bodies are major source <strong>of</strong> pollution and health<br />
hazard
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
SWOT Analysis for Nagar Nigam Bareilly - Solid Waste Management<br />
Strengths<br />
New integrated solid waste management project under PPP model is<br />
coming up<br />
Willingness to pay for the user charges<br />
Opportunities<br />
Effective IEC campaign to illustrate and explain the hazards <strong>of</strong><br />
unscientific disposal <strong>of</strong> municipal waste can stop the citizens from<br />
dumping the garbage in open<br />
Willingness to pay for the user charges can be converted in educating<br />
people to give the waste in a segregated manner<br />
CBOs are more than willing to participate in any sort <strong>of</strong> campaign to<br />
improve the quality <strong>of</strong> life<br />
Weaknesses<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 144<br />
No door to door collection<br />
Gap between the waste generated and collected in the city<br />
Open dumping sites are located inside the city<br />
No system in place for tracking the collection and transportation<br />
<strong>of</strong> the waste<br />
Threats<br />
Gap between generation and collection has let large amount <strong>of</strong><br />
garbage in the city leading to public health hazards<br />
Open dumping sites are major public health hazards
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
SWOT Analysis for Nagar Nigam Bareilly - Open defecation, community toilets and public toilets<br />
Strengths<br />
Community / Public toilets have been built for the population <strong>of</strong> the<br />
city<br />
Opportunities<br />
Increasing number <strong>of</strong> Community Toilets would bring down the<br />
instances <strong>of</strong> open defecation to a large extent<br />
Rehabilitation <strong>of</strong> existing Community Toilets<br />
BOT models in building toilets have high chances<br />
IEC & Behavioral Change campaign can bring down the cases <strong>of</strong> open<br />
defecation<br />
Weaknesses<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 145<br />
No M & E system for tracking Open Defecation<br />
Few community toilets for large slum population<br />
Number <strong>of</strong> community toilets are in unusable condition<br />
Most <strong>of</strong> community toilets leading waste to open drains<br />
Threats<br />
Open Defecation has become a major public health hazard<br />
Mosquitoes leading to several diseases and instances <strong>of</strong> skin<br />
diseases
6.2 VISION AND SPECIFIC GOALS<br />
Bareilly City to become totally sanitized, livable and sustain good public health and environmental<br />
outcomes for all the citizens with a special focus on hygienic and affordable sanitation facilities for<br />
the urban poor by 2015.<br />
SPECIFIC GOALS<br />
a) Awareness generation and behaviour change<br />
b) Making Bareilly a open defecation free city<br />
c) Re-Orienting Institutions and Mainstreaming Sanitation<br />
d) Sanitary and Safe Disposal <strong>of</strong> human excreta and liquid wastes<br />
e) Proper Operation & Maintenance <strong>of</strong> all Sanitary Installations<br />
The city’s concerted efforts would be in achieving the vision and the goals in a stipulated timeframe.<br />
6.3 <strong>SANITATION</strong> OPTIONS<br />
6.3.1 TECHNOLOGICAL OPTIONS<br />
Application <strong>of</strong> technology is one <strong>of</strong> a number <strong>of</strong> integrated measures required to improve sanitary<br />
conditions. Although sanitation is <strong>of</strong>ten understood as dealing with urine and excreta, the definition<br />
<strong>of</strong> sanitation is much broader and concerns the conditions relating to public health. To improve<br />
sanitation, the entire environment needs to be looked at in a holistic manner so that improvements<br />
in one area are not undermined by the neglect <strong>of</strong> another, and to prevent the problem being<br />
transported elsewhere with the discharge <strong>of</strong> untreated sewage or indiscriminate tipping <strong>of</strong> solid<br />
waste.<br />
The infrastructure necessary to provide a sanitation facility which is safe, reliable, private, protected<br />
from the weather and ventilated, keeps smells to the minimum, easy to keep clean, minimises the risk<br />
<strong>of</strong> the spread <strong>of</strong> sanitation-related diseases by facilitating the appropriate control <strong>of</strong> disease carrying<br />
flies and pests, and enables safe and appropriate treatment and/or removal <strong>of</strong> human waste and<br />
wastewater in an environmentally sound manner. Technology does not fail humans; humans fail
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
technology if the introduced technology cannot be sustained in the socio-economic, personal or<br />
cultural environment. The users are <strong>of</strong>ten blamed for the failure but the reality is that failure occurs<br />
because the technology is inappropriate to the circumstances.<br />
Regardless <strong>of</strong> the technology selected, making sanitation improvements in any community requires<br />
careful planning and concerted investment efforts between households and government. Lacking<br />
proper coordination, some investments can become very wasteful and redundant. For instance, the<br />
disposal <strong>of</strong> contaminated wastewater in densely populated areas is both expensive and technically<br />
challenging, while the prospects for charging for this service are limited. Thus, if water services are<br />
introduced in an area without a proper drainage and sewerage system, there will be no way to take<br />
away the volumes <strong>of</strong> wastewater.<br />
Sanitation systems can be divided into ‘onsite’ and ‘<strong>of</strong>fsite’ technologies. Onsite sanitation systems<br />
aim to contain human excreta at the point <strong>of</strong> generation (the household level). Onsite sanitation can<br />
be classified into two main categories: ‘wet’ which require water for flushing; and ‘dry’ which do not<br />
require any water for flushing. This type <strong>of</strong> infrastructure comprises <strong>of</strong> (improved) latrines, septic<br />
tanks and other household level technologies that do not involve sewerage.<br />
Offsite sanitation systems transport human excreta to another location for treatment, disposal or<br />
use. Offsite sanitation can be classified into two main categories: ‘decentralized’ and ‘centralized’.<br />
Decentralized systems include systems where groups <strong>of</strong> two or more houses are linked to a network<br />
leading to a communal treatment system. Wastewater systems serving one or several communities<br />
are termed centralized systems.<br />
Technology Option for On-site sanitation systems<br />
Septic Tank with soak pits<br />
Application Level- Household, Apartments, Institutions<br />
Septic tanks consist <strong>of</strong> a chamber or series <strong>of</strong> chambers into which wastewater is discharged and<br />
contained. Sediment and solids settle at the bottom <strong>of</strong> the tank and organic wastes are decomposed<br />
by the action <strong>of</strong> bacteria. The effluent from septic tanks may contain pathogens and should be<br />
discharged into a soak away. In practice, many septic tanks in India discharge effluent to the nearest<br />
open drain.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 147
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
Liquid flows into the tank and heavy particles sink to the bottom, while scum (oil and fat) floats to<br />
the top. With time, the solids that settle at the bottom are degraded anaerobically. However, the<br />
rate <strong>of</strong> accumulation is faster than the rate <strong>of</strong> decomposition, and the accumulated sludge must be<br />
removed at some point. Generally, Septic Tanks should be emptied and cleaned every 2 to 5 years,<br />
although they should be checked yearly to ensure proper functioning. The design <strong>of</strong> a Septic Tank<br />
depends on the number <strong>of</strong> users; the amount <strong>of</strong> water used per capita, the average annual<br />
temperature, the pumping frequency and the characteristics <strong>of</strong> the wastewater. A variation <strong>of</strong> the<br />
Septic Tank is called an aqua privy, which is a simple storage and settling tank located directly below<br />
the toilet, so that the excreta fall into the tank. To prevent odor from surfacing, a water seal must be<br />
maintained but it may not completely prevent smells and the tank must be frequently desludged.<br />
Adequacy: A Septic Tank is appropriate where there is a way <strong>of</strong> dispersing or transporting the<br />
effluent. Because the Septic Tank must be desludged regularly, a vacuum truck should be able to<br />
access the location. Often Septic Tanks are installed in the home, under the kitchen or bathroom<br />
which makes emptying difficult. If Septic Tanks are used in densely populated areas, onsite<br />
infiltration should not be used otherwise the ground will become oversaturated and excreta may rise<br />
up to the surface posing a serious health risk. Instead, the Septic Tank should be connected to a<br />
sewer and the effluent should be transported to a subsequent treatment or disposal site. Septic<br />
Tanks can be installed in every type <strong>of</strong> climate although the efficiency will be affected in colder<br />
climates. Even though the Septic Tank is watertight, it should not be constructed in areas with high<br />
groundwater tables or where there is frequent flooding. Aqua privies can be built indoors and above<br />
ground and are appropriate for rocky or flood prone areas where pits or other technologies would<br />
not be appropriate. However, because they require frequent emptying and constant maintenance,<br />
they are only recommended for very specific applications.<br />
Health Aspects/Acceptance: Although the removal <strong>of</strong> pathogens is not high, the entire tank is below<br />
the surface so users do not come in contact with any <strong>of</strong> the wastewater. Users should be careful<br />
when opening the tank because noxious and flammable gases may be released. Septic Tanks should<br />
have a vent. A vacuum truck should be used to empty the sludge from the Septic Tank. Users should<br />
not attempt to empty the pit themselves except with a manual technology.<br />
Maintenance: Septic Tanks should be checked to ensure that they are watertight and the levels <strong>of</strong><br />
the scum and sludge should be monitored to ensure that the tank is functioning well. Because <strong>of</strong> the<br />
delicate ecology, care should be taken not to discharge harsh chemicals into the Septic Tank. The<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 148
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
sludge should be removed annually using a vacuum truck to ensure proper functioning <strong>of</strong> the Septic<br />
Tank.<br />
Pros & Cons:<br />
Can be built and repaired with locally available materials<br />
Long service life<br />
No real problems with flies or odours if used correctly<br />
Low capital costs, moderate operating costs depending on water and emptying<br />
Small land area required<br />
No electrical energy required<br />
Low reduction in pathogens, solids and organics<br />
Effluent and sludge require secondary treatment and/or appropriate discharge<br />
Requires constant source <strong>of</strong> water<br />
Reference: Mara, DD (1996), Low-Cost <strong>Urban</strong> Sanitation. Wiley, Chichester, UK (Sizing, volume and<br />
emptying calculations and example design solutions, Chapter 6)<br />
Pour Flush toilet with double leach pit<br />
Application Level- Household<br />
A Pour Flush Toilet is like a regular Flush Toilet except that instead <strong>of</strong> the water coming from the<br />
cistern above, it is poured in by the user. When the water supply is not continuous, any cistern Flush<br />
Toilet can become a Pour Flush Toilet. Just like a traditional Flush Toilet, there is a water seal that<br />
prevents odours and flies from coming back up the pipe. Water is poured into the bowl to flush the<br />
toilet <strong>of</strong> excreta; approximately 2 to 3L is usually sufficient. The quantity <strong>of</strong> water and the force <strong>of</strong><br />
the water must be sufficient to move the excreta up and over the curved water seal. Both pedestals<br />
and squatting pans can be used in the pour flush mode. Due to demand, local manufacturers have<br />
become increasingly efficient at mass-producing affordable, Pour Flush Toilets and pans. The S-shape<br />
<strong>of</strong> the water seal determines how much water is needed for flushing. To reduce water requirements,<br />
it is advisable to collect toilet paper or other dry cleansing materials separately. The waterseal at the<br />
bottom <strong>of</strong> the Pour Flush Toilet or pan should have a slope <strong>of</strong> 25 to 30°. Water seals should be made<br />
out <strong>of</strong> plastic or ceramic to prevent clogs and to make cleaning easier. The optimal depth <strong>of</strong> the<br />
water seal is approximately 2cm to minimize the water required to flush the excreta. The trap should<br />
be approximately 7cm in diameter.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 149
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
Adequacy: The water seal is effective at preventing odors and it is appropriate for those who sit or<br />
squat (pedestal or slab) as well as those who cleanse with water. It is only appropriate when there is<br />
a constant supply <strong>of</strong> water available. The Pour Flush Toilet requires much less water than a<br />
traditional cistern Flush Toilet. However, because a smaller amount <strong>of</strong> water is used, the Pour Flush<br />
Toilet may clog more easily and thus, require more maintenance. If water is available, this type <strong>of</strong><br />
toilet is appropriate for both public and private applications. Pour Flush Toilets are adequate for<br />
almost all climates.<br />
Health Aspects/Acceptance: The Pour Flush Toilet (or squatting pan) prevents users from seeing or<br />
smelling the excreta <strong>of</strong> previous users. Thus, it is generally well accepted. Provided that the water<br />
seal is working well, there should be no odors and the toilet should be clean and comfortable to use.<br />
Maintenance: Because there are no mechanical parts, Pour Flush Toilets are quite robust and rarely<br />
require repair. Despite the fact that water is used continuously in the toilet, it should be cleaned<br />
regularly to prevent the buildup <strong>of</strong> organics and or/stains. To prevent clogging <strong>of</strong> the Pour Flush<br />
Toilet, it is recommended that dry cleansing materials be collected separately and not flushed down<br />
the toilet.<br />
Pros & Cons<br />
The water seal effectively prevents odors<br />
The excreta <strong>of</strong> one user are flushed away before the next user arrives<br />
Suitable for all types <strong>of</strong> users (sitters, squatters, wipers and washers)<br />
Low capital costs; operating costs depend on the price <strong>of</strong> water requires a constant source <strong>of</strong><br />
water (can be recycled water and/or collected rain water)<br />
Requires some education to be used correctly<br />
Reference: Mara, DD (1996), Low-Cost <strong>Urban</strong> Sanitation. Wiley, Chichester, UK.<br />
(Provides detailed drawings <strong>of</strong> Indian glass-fibre squat pan and trap with dimensions and critical<br />
design criteria. A description <strong>of</strong> how to modify a Pour Flush Toilet to a cistern Flush Toilet is<br />
included)<br />
Single Ventilated Improved Pit (VIP)<br />
Application Level- Household,<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 150
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
The Single VIP is a Ventilated, Improved Pit. It is an improvement over the Single Pit because<br />
continuous airflow through the ventilation pipe vents odours and acts as a trap for flies as they<br />
escape towards the light. Despite their simplicity, well-designed Single VIPs can be completely smell<br />
free, and be more pleasant to use than some other water-based technologies. Flies that hatch in the<br />
pit are attracted to the light at the top <strong>of</strong> the ventilation pipe. When they fly towards the light and<br />
try to escape they are trapped by the fly-screen and die. The ventilation also allows odours to escape<br />
and minimizes the attraction for flies.<br />
The vent pipe should have an internal diameter <strong>of</strong> at least 110mm to a maximum <strong>of</strong> 150mm and<br />
reach more than 300mm above the highest point <strong>of</strong> the toilet superstructure. The vent works better<br />
in windy areas but where there is little wind, its effectiveness can be improved by painting the pipe<br />
black; the heat difference between the pit (cool) and the vent (warm) creates an updraft that pulls<br />
the air and odours up and out <strong>of</strong> the pit. To test the efficacy <strong>of</strong> the ventilation, a small, smoky fire<br />
can be lit in the pit; the smoke should be pulled up and out <strong>of</strong> the vent pipe and not remain in the pit<br />
or the superstructure.<br />
The mesh size <strong>of</strong> the fly screen must be large enough to prevent clogging with dust and allow air to<br />
circulate freely. Aluminium screens, with a hole-size <strong>of</strong> 1.2 to 1.5mm have proven to be the most<br />
effective. The top diameter <strong>of</strong> the Single VIP should be between 1 to 1.5m and be dug at least 3m<br />
deep, although the deeper the better. Deep pits can last up to 15, 20, 30 or more years. As the<br />
effluent leaches from the Single VIP and migrates through unsaturated soils, faecal organisms are<br />
removed. The degree <strong>of</strong> faecal organism removal varies with soil type, distance travelled, moisture<br />
and other environmental factors and thus, it is difficult to estimate the necessary distance between<br />
a pit and a water source. A minimum distance <strong>of</strong> 30m between the pit and a water source is<br />
recommended to limit exposure to chemical and biological contamination.<br />
Adequacy: Treatment processes in the Single VIP are limited, and therefore, pathogen reduction and<br />
organic degradation is not significant. However, since the excreta are contained, pathogen<br />
transmission to the user is limited. This technology is a significant improvement over Single Pits or<br />
open defecation.<br />
Single VIPs are appropriate for peri-urban areas; single pits in urban or dense areas are <strong>of</strong>ten difficult<br />
to empty and/or have insufficient space for infiltration. Depending on the pit depth, depth to the<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 151
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
water table, number <strong>of</strong> users and soil conditions, some pits can be used for 20 years without<br />
emptying. VIPs are especially appropriate when water is scarce and where there is a low<br />
groundwater table. They should be located in an area with a good breeze. They are not suited for<br />
rocky or compacted soils or for areas that flood frequently.<br />
Health Aspects/Acceptance A Single VIP can be a very clean, comfortable, and well accepted<br />
sanitation option. However some health concerns exist:<br />
• Latrine leachate can contaminate groundwater;<br />
• Pits are susceptible to failure/overflowing during floods;<br />
• Health risks from flies are not completely removed by ventilation.<br />
Maintenance: To keep the Single VIP free <strong>of</strong> flies and odours, regular cleaning and maintenance is<br />
required. Dead flies, spider webs, dust and other debris should be removed from the ventilation<br />
screen to ensure a good flow <strong>of</strong> air.<br />
Pros & Cons:<br />
Flies and odours are significantly reduced (compared to non-ventilated pits)<br />
Does not require a constant source <strong>of</strong> water<br />
Suitable for all types <strong>of</strong> users<br />
Can be built and repaired with locally available materials<br />
Can be used immediately after construction<br />
Low (but variable) capital costs depending on materials and pit depth<br />
Small land area required<br />
Sludge requires secondary treatment and/or appropriate discharge<br />
Costs to empty may be significant compared to capital costs<br />
Reference: Mara, DD (1996), Low-Cost <strong>Urban</strong> Sanitation. Wiley, Chichester, UK. (Provides detailed<br />
design information.)<br />
Double Ventilated Improved Pit (VIP)<br />
Application Level-Household, Public Toilet, Community Toilet<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 152
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
The Double VIP has almost the same design as the Single VIP with the added advantage <strong>of</strong> a second<br />
pit that allows the technology to be used continuously and allows for safer and easier emptying. By<br />
using two pits, one pit can be used while the contents <strong>of</strong> the second pit rests, drains, reduces in<br />
volume, and degrades. When the second pit is almost full (the excreta is 50cm from the top <strong>of</strong> the<br />
pit), it is covered, and the contents <strong>of</strong> the first pit are removed. Due to the extended resting time (at<br />
least 1 year <strong>of</strong> filling/resting) the material within the pit should be sanitized and humus-like. The<br />
Double VIP is specifically designed to produce humus and as such, it requires regular additions <strong>of</strong><br />
soil, ash and/or leaves.<br />
The superstructure may either extend over both holes or it may be designed to move from one pit to<br />
the other. In either case, the pit that is not being filled should be fully covered and sealed to prevent<br />
water, garbage and animals (and/or people) from falling into the pit. The ventilation <strong>of</strong> the two pits<br />
can be accomplished using one ventilation pipe moved back and forth between the pits or each pit<br />
can be equipped with its own dedicated pipe. The two pits in the Double VIP are continually used<br />
and should be well lined and supported to ensure longevity.<br />
Adequacy: The Double VIP is more appropriate than the Single VIP for denser, peri-urban areas. The<br />
material is manually emptied, so vacuum truck access to the pits is not necessary. The users can<br />
remove the pit material after a sufficient resting time <strong>of</strong> one or more years even though the<br />
treatment processes in the pit are not complete and the material is not entirely hygienic. The Double<br />
VIP technology will only work properly if the two pits are used sequentially and not concurrently.<br />
Therefore, an adequate cover for the out <strong>of</strong> service pit is required. Double VIPs are especially<br />
appropriate when water is scarce and where there is a low groundwater table. They should be<br />
located in an area with a good breeze. They are not suited for rocky or compacted soils (that are<br />
difficult to dig) or for areas that flood frequently.<br />
Health Aspects/Acceptance: The Double VIP can be a very clean, comfortable and well accepted<br />
sanitation option. However some health concerns exist:<br />
• Latrine leachate can contaminate groundwater;<br />
• Pits are susceptible to failure/overflowing during floods; and<br />
• Health risks from flies are not completely removed by ventilation.<br />
Maintenance: To keep the Double VIP free <strong>of</strong> flies and odours, regular cleaning and maintenance is<br />
required. Dead flies, spider webs, dust and other debris should be removed from the ventilation<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 153
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
screen to ensure a good flow <strong>of</strong> air. The out <strong>of</strong> service pit should be well sealed to reduce water<br />
infiltration and a proper alternating schedule must be maintained.<br />
Pros & Cons:<br />
Longer life than Single VIP (indefinite if maintained)<br />
Flies and odours are significantly reduced (compared to non-ventilated pits)<br />
Does not require a constant source <strong>of</strong> water<br />
Suitable for all types <strong>of</strong> users<br />
Can be built and repaired with locally available materials<br />
Small land area required and can be used immediately after construction<br />
Can be used immediately after construction<br />
Low/moderate reduction in pathogens<br />
Higher capital cost than Single VIP<br />
Reference: Mara DD (1984), The Design <strong>of</strong> Ventilated Improved Pit Latrines (UNDP Inter reg. Project<br />
INT/81/047). The World Bank+ UNDP, Washington.<br />
Community Toilet Block- The Sulabh Model<br />
Application Level- Slum, Low Income Areas, General Public Area<br />
A community toilet block is a shared facility provided for a group <strong>of</strong> residents or an entire<br />
settlement. Pour flush technology is generally used though dry ‘ecological sanitation’ (ecosan) toilet<br />
blocks have been piloted in a few locations. Washing facilities are sometimes included in the block.<br />
These are usually constructed in low income residential areas and slum to cater to the local<br />
community who would otherwise have no access to sanitation. Provided these are managed well<br />
and maintained, this system can be effective in meeting the needs <strong>of</strong> the local community and<br />
promoting improved public health.<br />
Adequacy: As far as possible, separate circular pits should be constructed as these are structurally<br />
more stable and the sludge is dry and safe to handle. Where separate circular pits <strong>of</strong> standard sizes<br />
cannot be constructed due to space constraint, pits <strong>of</strong> smaller diameter (not less than 750mm) be<br />
provided, but the depth should be increased suitably to provide required storage volume and<br />
infiltration surface area. If it is not possible to construct small diameter pits, combined oval, square<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 154
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
or rectangular pits divided into two equal compartments by a partition wall can be provided. The<br />
partition wall should be taken 300mm below the bottom <strong>of</strong> the pit and be plastered on both sides<br />
with cement mortar <strong>of</strong> 1:6 ratio. The partition wall and pit lining in 300mm width adjoining the<br />
partition wall should not have holes. However the possibility <strong>of</strong> water from one pit finding its way to<br />
the other pit is very much there. Therefore the desludging <strong>of</strong> the filled up pit has to be done with<br />
care to avoid health hazards.<br />
Health Aspects/Acceptance:<br />
Hygienically and technically appropriate, and socio-culturally acceptable<br />
Eliminates mosquito, insect and fly breeding.<br />
Free from health hazards and does not pollute surface or ground water, if proper<br />
precautions and safeguards are taken during construction.<br />
Can be located within the premises as it is free from foul smell and fly/mosquito nuisance<br />
etc.<br />
Maintenance: For the best maintenance <strong>of</strong> these types <strong>of</strong> toilets the user should remember that<br />
before using, they have to wet the pan by pouring only a little quantity <strong>of</strong> water, after defecation,<br />
have to pour 1.5 to 2 litres <strong>of</strong> water in the pan for flushing. Half litre <strong>of</strong> water should be poured in<br />
the pan after urination and the pan should be cleaned once a day with a brush or a broom and with<br />
soap powder periodically. Very important component is not to allow kitchen, bathroom waste water<br />
or rain water to enter the pits also the other solid wastes like kitchen waste, rags, cotton, sweepings<br />
etc. should not be thrown in the pan, as this could block the toilet. When the first pit in use is full,<br />
the flow should be diverted to the second pit and the filled up pit should be desludged after 1.5 to 2-<br />
year rest period. The first pit can then be put to reuse, when the second pit fills up.<br />
Pros and Cons<br />
Affordable and easy to construct with locally available materials<br />
Design and specifications can be modified to suit householder's needs and affordability.<br />
Can be constructed in different physical, geological and hydrogeological conditions.<br />
Can be constructed on upper floors <strong>of</strong> houses.<br />
Pits are generally designed for 3-year desludging interval, but if desired, it can be designed<br />
for longer periods or it can be reduced even to two years.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 155
Maintenance is easy, simple and costs very little.<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
Needs only 1.5 to 2 litres <strong>of</strong> water for flushing, while conventional flush toilet needs 12 to 14<br />
litres <strong>of</strong> water.<br />
Needs less space than a septic tank toilet system.<br />
Does not need scavengers for cleaning the pits or disposal <strong>of</strong> sludge. This can be done by the<br />
householder.<br />
Makes available rich fertilizer and soil conditioner.<br />
Can be easily connected to sewers when introduced in the area.<br />
A low volume flushing cistern could be attached to avoid pour flushing.<br />
Reference: http://www.sulabhinternational.org<br />
Technology Option for Off-site sanitation systems<br />
Sewerage<br />
Application Level- City Wide<br />
Costly sewerage-based systems are unlikely to be cost effective solutions in most urban areas.<br />
Instead, decentralized excreta management systems are required. While many technological<br />
solutions exist, awareness and knowledge <strong>of</strong> them is limited to a small group <strong>of</strong> experts and needs to<br />
be broadened. Similarly, the technical knowledge <strong>of</strong> decision-makers needs to be increased. In some<br />
situations, such as for slums above water, appropriate technological solutions are yet to be found<br />
and more innovation is needed. Also, comparisons <strong>of</strong> primary and secondary costs and further<br />
investigation <strong>of</strong> what does and does not work, in the case <strong>of</strong> community-developed and managed<br />
facilities would be helpful.<br />
Maintenance: Sewers and manhole chambers will occasionally require structural repair or<br />
replacement, and broken and missing manhole covers should be replaced immediately. In gravity<br />
sewers, wastewater and solids are flushed along the sewer line to a treatment plant. If sewers are<br />
laid to self-cleansing velocities, they should require little routine maintenance. However, silting can<br />
be a problem where falls are limited and/or storm run-<strong>of</strong>f carrying silt enters sewers. In such<br />
situations, periodic rodding, flushing or jetting will be required to remove blockages. Where<br />
pumping is required, considerably more attention will be required to operate and maintain pumps<br />
and other associated electro-mechanical equipment.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 156
Pros and Cons<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
Operation and maintenance costs can be high, especially where pumping is required or silt and other<br />
solids cannot effectively be excluded from the sewer. As a result, many service providers rely upon<br />
subsidies to keep the system functional.<br />
Sewers <strong>of</strong>ten become heavily silted and lose hydraulic capacity or become completely<br />
blocked.<br />
Illegal storm water collections may lead to hydraulic overload <strong>of</strong> the sewerage system during<br />
heavy rainfall events. This may result in the flow <strong>of</strong> run<strong>of</strong>f contaminated with excreta<br />
flowing in streets and sometimes houses.<br />
In order to save electricity costs, pumping station operators <strong>of</strong>ten maintain wastewater<br />
levels in the wet well above the invert level <strong>of</strong> the incoming sewer. This reduces flow<br />
velocities in the incoming sewer and leads to rapid siltation.<br />
In many cases a sewerage system is built in isolation from the sewage treatment plant and<br />
the two do not connect.<br />
Households may not connect their facilities to the sewer network due to high connection<br />
charges and low willingness to pay.<br />
Simplified Sewers or Shallow Sewers<br />
Application Level- Neighborhood and City Wide<br />
Simplified Sewers describe a sewerage network that is constructed using smaller diameter pipes laid<br />
at a shallower depth and at a flatter gradient than conventional sewers. The Simplified Sewer allows<br />
for a more flexible design associated with lower costs and a higher number <strong>of</strong> connected<br />
households. Expensive manholes are replaced with simple inspection chambers. Each discharge<br />
point is connected to an interceptor tank to prevent settle-able solids and trash from entering the<br />
sewer. As well, each household should have a grease trap before the sewer connection.<br />
Another key design feature is that the sewers are laid within the property boundaries, rather than<br />
beneath the central road. Because the sewers are more communal, they are <strong>of</strong>ten referred to as<br />
condominium sewers. Oftentimes, the community will purchase, and connect to, a single legal<br />
connection to the main sewer; the combined effluent <strong>of</strong> the auxiliary sewer network flows into the<br />
main sewer line. Because simplified sewers are laid on or around the property <strong>of</strong> the users, higher<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 157
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
connection rates can be achieved, fewer and shorter pipes can be used and less excavation is<br />
required as the pipes will not be subjected to heavy traffic loads. However, this type <strong>of</strong> Conveyance<br />
technology requires careful negotiation between stakeholders since design and maintenance must<br />
be jointly coordinated. All Grey water should be connected to the Simplified Sewer to ensure<br />
adequate hydraulic loading. Inspection chambers also function to attenuate peak discharges into the<br />
system. For example, a 100mm diameter sewer laid at a gradient <strong>of</strong> 1m in 200m (0.5%) will serve<br />
around 200 households <strong>of</strong> 5 people (10,000 users) with a wastewater flow <strong>of</strong> 80L/person/day.<br />
Although watertight sewers are the ideal, they may be difficult to achieve, and therefore the sewers<br />
should be designed to take into account the extra flow that may result from storm water infiltration.<br />
Blocks <strong>of</strong> community-based Simplified Sewers are connected to an existing Conventional Gravity<br />
Sewer or routed to a Simplified Sewer main constructed with pipes <strong>of</strong> a larger diameter. A Simplified<br />
Sewer main can still be placed at a shallow depth providing it is placed away from traffic.<br />
Adequacy: Where the ground is rocky or the groundwater table is high, the excavation <strong>of</strong> trenches<br />
for pipes may be difficult. Under these circumstances, the cost <strong>of</strong> installing sewers is significantly<br />
higher than in favorable conditions. Regardless, Simplified Sewerage is less expensive than<br />
Conventional Gravity Sewerage because <strong>of</strong> its shallow installation depth. Simplified Sewers can be<br />
installed in almost all types <strong>of</strong> settlements and are especially appropriate for dense, urban<br />
settlements. To prevent clogging and maintain the sewers, good pre-treatment is required. It is<br />
recommended that the scum from Grey water, heavy solids and garbage be removed from the<br />
wastewater prior to entering the sewer.<br />
Health Aspects/Acceptance: If constructed and maintained well, sewers are a safe and hygienic<br />
means <strong>of</strong> transporting wastewater. Users must be well educated about the health risks associated<br />
with maintaining/ cleaning blockages and inspection chambers.<br />
Maintenance: Pre-treatment with interceptor tanks and a grease trap is essential. The homeowner<br />
must maintain the interceptor tanks and the grease trap. Ideally, households will also be responsible<br />
for the maintenance <strong>of</strong> the sewers; however in practice this may not be feasible. Alternatively, a<br />
private contractor or users committee can be hired to assume responsibility for the maintenance as<br />
inexperienced users may not detect problems before they become severe, and therefore, more<br />
costly to repair. A related problem is that households may drain storm water into the sewer. This<br />
practice should be discouraged whenever possible. Blockages can usually be removed by opening<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 158
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
the sewer and forcing a length <strong>of</strong> rigid wire through the sewer. Inspection chambers must be<br />
emptied periodically to prevent grit overflowing into the system.<br />
Pros & Cons:<br />
Can be built and repaired with locally available materials<br />
Construction can provide short-term employment to local labourers<br />
Capital costs are between 50 and 80% less than Conventional Gravity Sewers; operating<br />
costs are low<br />
Can be extended as a community changes and grows<br />
Requires expert design and construction supervision<br />
Requires repairs and removals <strong>of</strong> blockages more frequently than a Conventional Gravity<br />
Sewer<br />
Effluent and sludge (from interceptors) requires secondary treatment and/or appropriate<br />
discharge.<br />
Reference: Mara, DD, (1996) Low-Cost Sewerage, Wiley, Chichester, UK. (Assessment <strong>of</strong> different<br />
low-cost systems and case studies)<br />
Anaerobic Baffled Reactor (Popularly called as DEWATS)<br />
Application Level- Neighborhood, Household, Public<br />
An Anaerobic Baffled Reactor (ABR) is an improved septic tank because <strong>of</strong> the series <strong>of</strong> baffles under<br />
which the wastewater is forced to flow. The increased contact time with the active biomass (sludge)<br />
results in improved treatment. The system operates without mechanical means and sewage flows by<br />
gravity through the different components <strong>of</strong> the system. Up to 1,000 cubic metre <strong>of</strong> domestic and<br />
non-toxic industrial sewage can be treated by this system. DEWATS applications are based on the<br />
principle <strong>of</strong> low-maintenance since most important parts <strong>of</strong> the system work without electrical<br />
energy inputs and cannot be switched <strong>of</strong>f intentionally (BORDA). DEWATS applications provide<br />
state-<strong>of</strong>-the-art-technology at affordable prices because all <strong>of</strong> the materials used for construction<br />
are locally available. DEWATS approach is an effective, efficient and affordable wastewater<br />
treatment solution for not only small and medium sized enterprises (SME) but also for the un-served<br />
urban households in developing countries, especially South Asia. For instance, DEWATS can operate<br />
in individual households, at the neighborhood level and even in small and big factories not<br />
connected to sewage lines. DEWATS can also treat municipal waste. The recycled water is used for<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 159
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
irrigation or for growing plants and is absolutely safe for human use. In certain urban areas the<br />
processed water is taken for use as flush- water in toilets.<br />
Adequacy: This technology is easily adaptable and can be applied at the household level or for a<br />
small neighborhood. An ABR can be designed for a single house or a group <strong>of</strong> houses that are using a<br />
considerable amount <strong>of</strong> water for clothes washing, showering, and toilet flushing. It is mostly<br />
appropriate if water use and supply <strong>of</strong> wastewater are relatively constant. This technology is also<br />
appropriate for areas where land may be limited since the tank is installed underground and<br />
requires a small area. It should not be installed where there is a high groundwater table as<br />
infiltration will affect the treatment efficiency and contaminate the groundwater.<br />
Health Aspects/Acceptance: Although the removal <strong>of</strong> pathogens is not high, the ABR is contained so<br />
users do not come in contact with any <strong>of</strong> the wastewater or disease causing pathogens. Effluent and<br />
sludge must be handled with care as they contain high levels <strong>of</strong> pathogenic organisms. To prevent<br />
the release <strong>of</strong> potentially harmful gases, the tank should be vented.<br />
Maintenance: Adequate arrangements must be made for periodic removal <strong>of</strong> sludge from the first<br />
compartment. Sludge accumulation in the baffled compartments should be much less. Although<br />
desludging at regular intervals is necessary, it is important that some active sludge is left in each <strong>of</strong><br />
the compartments to maintain a stable treatment process. ABR tanks should be checked to ensure<br />
that they are watertight and the levels <strong>of</strong> the scum and sludge should be monitored to ensure that<br />
the tank is functioning well. Because <strong>of</strong> the delicate ecology, care should be taken not to discharge<br />
harsh chemicals into the ABR. The sludge should be removed annually using a vacuum truck to<br />
ensure proper functioning <strong>of</strong> the ABR.<br />
Pros & Cons<br />
Resistant to organic and hydraulic shock loads<br />
No electrical energy required<br />
Can be built and repaired with locally available materials<br />
Grey water can be managed concurrently<br />
Long service life and no real problems with flies or odours if used correctly<br />
High reduction <strong>of</strong> organics<br />
Moderate capital costs, moderate operating costs depending on emptying; can be low cost<br />
depending on number <strong>of</strong> users<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 160
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
Requires constant source <strong>of</strong> water and effluent requires secondary treatment and/or<br />
appropriate discharge<br />
Requires expert design and construction<br />
Reference:<br />
a) Sasse, L. 1998. DEWATS: Decentralized Wastewater Treatment Systems in Developing Countries.<br />
Bremen Overseas Research and <strong>Development</strong> Association, (BORDA), Bremen, Germany<br />
b) Consortium for DEWATS Dissemination (CDD) Society, Bangalore<br />
c) The Vigyan Vijay Foundation, New Delhi<br />
6.3.1a. Options for Removal and Transport <strong>of</strong> Fecal Sludge and Septage<br />
Fecal sludge management must be integral part <strong>of</strong> every sanitation plan, which builds on on-site<br />
sanitation facilities. Sludge management is an indispensable part <strong>of</strong> the maintenance <strong>of</strong> these<br />
facilities. However, in reality sludge management is <strong>of</strong>ten neglected in sanitation planning because<br />
the need for it is less apparent than it is for the provision <strong>of</strong> water supply or toilet facilities. Even<br />
when a sanitation plan foresees a component for sludge management, its implementation is <strong>of</strong>ten<br />
impaired for the same reasons. On-site sanitation systems are <strong>of</strong>ten perceived as cheap in<br />
comparison to sewerage systems, because the investment costs are covered by individuals and not<br />
by the public bodies. However, fecal sludge management is an important cost factor, which cannot<br />
be neglected and which has always to be taken into account when sanitation systems are planned.<br />
Conventional on-site sanitation includes facilities like pit latrines, community/public toilets, flush<br />
toilets connected to septic tanks, etc. In these sanitation systems, feces, urine, and in some cases<br />
grey water is mixed and the sludge produced can be quite diluted. The efforts for sludge collection,<br />
transport and treatment are high, because the sludge is <strong>of</strong> high volume and difficult to handle.<br />
The removal <strong>of</strong> sludge from toilet facilities, and the transport to the site <strong>of</strong> treatment or disposal is<br />
the first important component <strong>of</strong> fecal sludge management. Hygiene with sludge handling is usually<br />
an important issue when manual pit or vault emptying is common. The workers whether<br />
independent or employees <strong>of</strong> private or municipalities, are rarely aware <strong>of</strong> the health risks and may<br />
use no protection during their work.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 161
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
Source Characteristics Emptying and cartage implications<br />
Dry pits/vaults Highly concentrated quasi-solids Vacuum desludging systems are<br />
with high pathogen content required for cleaning <strong>of</strong> single pit<br />
(depending upon residence Latrines.<br />
time in latrine).<br />
Leach pits As above, but higher moisture content Twin pits can be emptied manually<br />
without the need for specialized<br />
equipment.<br />
Septic tanks Varies enormously depending Septage vacuum trucks are widely<br />
on the number <strong>of</strong> people utilizing utilized for cleaning <strong>of</strong> septic tanks.<br />
the septic tank, water consumption,<br />
tank size, and pumping frequency.<br />
Adopted from ‘A Guide to Decision-making—Sanitation Technology Options for <strong>Urban</strong> India’,<br />
<strong>Ministry</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Urban</strong> <strong>Development</strong> (MoUD) with support from the Water and Sanitation Program South<br />
Asia.<br />
6.3.2 FINANCING OPTIONS<br />
Expansion <strong>of</strong> sanitation systems will not be possible unless an institution or group <strong>of</strong> individuals,<br />
preferably the intended users, are willing to pay user charges for the new facilities required. Even<br />
when facilities have been provided, they will fail sooner or later unless funds are available to cover<br />
their ongoing operation and maintenance. So, it will be impossible to first provide and then sustain<br />
services to cities as a whole unless the finances <strong>of</strong> those who are responsible for providing and<br />
managing them are sound. Most conventional financing goes to established services in already<br />
served areas and to conventional technological and administrative systems. This approach is not<br />
going to fulfill the sanitation target <strong>of</strong> the MDGs and beyond. To revise the current trend <strong>of</strong> an ever-<br />
growing sanitation backlog in poor urban areas we need not only to invest more and more wisely,<br />
but also finance in much more creative ways.<br />
Every proposal for a sanitation service, and its non-technical components, needs financing. The<br />
amounts required can be estimated in the early stages <strong>of</strong> strategic planning, and should include costs<br />
to be incurred by the municipal government and other parties. The strategy will consider both the<br />
initial capital and recurrent financing needs. The sustainability <strong>of</strong> most sanitation systems depends on<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 162
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
having adequate recurrent funds for operations and maintenance. Financing is <strong>of</strong>ten regarded as the<br />
defining factor in sanitation development. This is true, especially if a city relies only on the local<br />
government budget. However, with a good citywide sanitation plan, a municipal government will plan<br />
to access finances from other sources, such as central government, state government, the private<br />
sector and the public.<br />
Furthermore, since the nominal amount <strong>of</strong> municipal budget is small, sanitation budgets are<br />
correspondingly small. The citywide sanitation strategy can propose a larger allocation from the<br />
municipal budget and recommend optimizing use <strong>of</strong> funds from other sources. Increasing the<br />
municipal budget allocation for sanitation requires commitment from all relevant decision makers,<br />
both in the legislative and executive bodies. Approval from the local legislature is key, and such<br />
support can be gained if the sanitation working group designs awareness-building activities for all<br />
decision makers. Thus, strategies for developing funding for sanitation needs to be supported by<br />
strategies for developing non-technical components, especially community participation, policy and<br />
regulation, and institutions. Without the support <strong>of</strong> these components, the sanitation working group<br />
would have difficulty in obtaining additional financing for sanitation development. These mutual<br />
linkages will be described in the citywide sanitation plan.<br />
Sanitation<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 163
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 164
SL.NO FINANCING SOURCE APPROACH<br />
1 13 th Finance Commission The 13 th Finance Commission has funding for <strong>Urban</strong> Local Bodies. The additional<br />
advantage to the ULB is that <strong>of</strong> 12 th Finance Commission grant utilized for Solid Waste<br />
Management. The State Government has to guide the ULB’s to utilize the funds<br />
appropriately and achieve the goals <strong>of</strong> sanitation in an acceptable manner. The 13 th FC<br />
grants can be pooled to providing sanitation facilities if the State takes up the issue <strong>of</strong><br />
Sanitation in a mission mode. Only a mission mode approach would enable the ULB’s to<br />
achieve open defecation free city status.<br />
2 State Finance Commission The State Finance Commission plays a vital role in cities achieving open defecation free<br />
status. The SFC grants help the cities to take care <strong>of</strong> the salaries <strong>of</strong> the municipal<br />
employees apart from providing funds for the other basic services to the urban citizens<br />
apart from urban poor.<br />
3 <strong>Urban</strong> Infrastructure <strong>Development</strong> Scheme<br />
for Small & Medium Towns (UIDSSMT)<br />
4<br />
<strong>Ministry</strong> <strong>of</strong> Housing and <strong>Urban</strong> Poverty<br />
Alleviation (MoHUPA)<br />
Under the ministry <strong>of</strong> <strong>Urban</strong> <strong>Development</strong>, there are several components which have<br />
funding options for sanitation. UIDSSMT has urban infrastructure and governance<br />
component which can funds for building sewerage network & STP, water supply ,<br />
integrated SWM etc.<br />
<strong>Ministry</strong> <strong>of</strong> Housing and urban poverty alleviation provides large amount <strong>of</strong> finance for<br />
the <strong>Urban</strong> Slums in India. The <strong>Ministry</strong> has several poverty alleviation programmes<br />
which cater to the needs <strong>of</strong> housing in turn catering to the issue <strong>of</strong> sanitation by<br />
constructing toilets in the housing structure. Large numbers <strong>of</strong> toilets have been built<br />
and good number <strong>of</strong> dry latrines have been converted to pour flush latrines.
5<br />
Kanshi Ram Sehari Garib Awas Yogna<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 166<br />
A government <strong>of</strong> Uttar Pradesh programme. Envisages building one lakh houses every<br />
year for economically weaker sections <strong>of</strong> the society over the next five years. The<br />
District Magistrates have been made responsible for the implementation <strong>of</strong> the scheme<br />
and the Uttar Pradesh Housing Board is involved in Planning and Construction. The<br />
houses, built under the scheme, will have facilities like clean drinking water, toilets,<br />
streetlamps and it will be carried out in a phased manner. This is good source <strong>of</strong> funding<br />
as houses are built with urban basic services.<br />
4a ILCS The Centrally Sponsored Scheme <strong>of</strong> Low Cost Sanitation for Liberation <strong>of</strong> Scavengers<br />
started from 1980-81 initially through the <strong>Ministry</strong> <strong>of</strong> Home Affairs and later on through<br />
the <strong>Ministry</strong> <strong>of</strong> Welfare. From 1989-90, it came to be operated through the <strong>Ministry</strong> <strong>of</strong><br />
<strong>Urban</strong> <strong>Development</strong> and later on through <strong>Ministry</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Urban</strong> Employment and Poverty<br />
Alleviation now titled <strong>Ministry</strong> <strong>of</strong> Housing & <strong>Urban</strong> Poverty Alleviation. The main<br />
components are Central Subsidy <strong>of</strong> 75%, State Subsidy <strong>of</strong> 15% and beneficiary share <strong>of</strong><br />
10%. A detailed difference between the previous and the new scheme is given below<br />
this table.<br />
4b Rajiv Awas Yojana Rajiv Awas Yojana is a scheme sponsored by the ministry <strong>of</strong> Housing and <strong>Urban</strong> Poverty<br />
Alleviation. Rajiv Awas Yojana (RAY) for the slum dwellers and the urban poor envisages<br />
a ‘Slum-free India’ through encouraging States/Union Territories to tackle the problem<br />
<strong>of</strong> slums in a definitive manner. The goals <strong>of</strong> RAY will be driven and incentivized by the<br />
provision <strong>of</strong> central support for slum redevelopment and construction <strong>of</strong> affordable<br />
housing conditional to a set <strong>of</strong> reforms necessary for urban development to become<br />
inclusive. This specific programme also would enable the city to achieve complete
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 167<br />
sanitized situation as the major problem <strong>of</strong> sanitation arises from slums and Ray would<br />
take care <strong>of</strong> this issue.<br />
6 ULB’s Finance The Nagar Nigam also has considerable income for creating some provision for<br />
sanitation scheme in the city. As the state Municipalities act also specifies some <strong>of</strong> the<br />
duties to be performed under sanitation, some amount can be exclusively earmarked in<br />
the municipal budget to take sanitation in a mission mode till the city achieves the Open<br />
Defecation free status.<br />
7 <strong>Ministry</strong> <strong>of</strong> Social Justice and Empowerment <strong>Ministry</strong> <strong>of</strong> Social Justice and empowerment is also funding in a significant way to take<br />
care <strong>of</strong> the welfare <strong>of</strong> manual scavengers and their family. It is also heartening to note<br />
that big numbers <strong>of</strong> Manual Scavengers were reported in Uttar Pradesh. Relieving these<br />
people would not fetch the adequate results as the livelihood option would bring them<br />
back to the same work as they occupied before. The ministry has plan for rehabilitation<br />
<strong>of</strong> the families through several ways. Adequate amount <strong>of</strong> finance can be availed from<br />
this ministry to eliminate manual scavenging in existing places and rehabilitation <strong>of</strong> the<br />
families who has practiced before.<br />
8 Sarva Shikshya Abhiyan (MoHRD) <strong>Ministry</strong> <strong>of</strong> Human Resource <strong>Development</strong> is a potential source <strong>of</strong> financing as school<br />
sanitation is also a major component in the city sanitation plan. The SSA component has<br />
funding for school sanitation. The Nagar Nigam with the support <strong>of</strong> the district<br />
magistrate and education department should make efforts to pool in money for school<br />
sanitation.<br />
9 PPP Public Private Participation is another potential area which has been explored by the<br />
Nagar Nigam to an extent but not to the maximum. PPP has a great potential in Bareilly<br />
as the city is a heritage centre and the population is also willing to pay for the services.<br />
Till now few public toilets have been constructed with PPP but many more community<br />
as well as public toilets can be built in Bareilly city. Few parks and street lights have<br />
been constructed under PPP but more projects can be done by following some models
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 168<br />
in south as well as north. This would relieve the city from capital investment and reduce<br />
the burden in bringing finance. As a response to an insufficient provision <strong>of</strong> basic urban<br />
services and a lack <strong>of</strong> access to finance and other resources by ULBs that aim to increase<br />
access to sanitation services, a number <strong>of</strong> PPP options have emerged. These include:<br />
service contracts; performance-based service contract; joint sector company to<br />
implement and finance the project; a management contract for operations and<br />
maintenance (O&M); and construction cum build-operate-transfer (BOT) contract.<br />
<strong>Ministry</strong> has come out with a guidance note on Guidelines on India: <strong>Urban</strong> Water and<br />
sanitation Services, sector reform and successful Public-Private Partnerships.<br />
10 NGO NGO’s have played a significance role in transforming sanitation sector in India. Take for<br />
example Sulabh has played a major role in easing the burden on the ULB’s. They are<br />
there almost length and breadth <strong>of</strong> the country. Their contribution in reducing the<br />
magnitude <strong>of</strong> Open defecation is noteworthy. The model adopted by them is also<br />
unique as they have developed their own model against the standard world known<br />
models based on experience. There are few more like SPARC who have made significant<br />
contribution in pay and use system. The pay and use system in the form <strong>of</strong> monthly<br />
cards will also help bringing down the incidences <strong>of</strong> OD as well give scope for going for<br />
individual toilets with low cost involved in construction. There are several NGO’s which<br />
are ready to invest and look after Operation and maintenance. There are some NGO’s<br />
which are working on partial cost by the NGO and then partial by the beneficiary<br />
through installments and bank.
ILCS Scheme Details:<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
Earlier Provision Revised Provision<br />
1. The scheme has been taken on a 'whole town basis' and the<br />
towns having population less than 5 lacs are being covered<br />
2. Pattern <strong>of</strong> Assistance: The HUDCO is providing loan and a mix <strong>of</strong><br />
subsidy from the Central Government in a synchronized manner<br />
as per the following financing pattern.<br />
Category Subsidy Loan<br />
Beneficiary contribution<br />
EWS 45% 50% 5%<br />
LIG 25% 60% 15%<br />
MIG/HIG Nil 75% 25%<br />
3. The present unit cost for different categories <strong>of</strong> sanitary latrines<br />
is as follows:-<br />
5 user unit Rs4000.00, 10 user unit Rs6000.00, 15 user unit<br />
Rs7000.00 Super structure cost not included.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 169<br />
The earlier programme was town-wise for population upto 5 lacs as per<br />
1981 census which need not be restricted any more as the whole<br />
country is to be declared as scavenger free. The new guidelines will<br />
cover all towns on "All Town" basis.<br />
75% subsidy for the EWS beneficiaries, 15% <strong>of</strong> State's contribution and<br />
10% <strong>of</strong> Beneficiaries contribution.<br />
Provision <strong>of</strong> subsidy including the superstructure in case <strong>of</strong> individual<br />
toilets: An upper ceiling <strong>of</strong> Rs. 10,000/-for complete unit <strong>of</strong> pour flush<br />
units with superstructure.
4. No provision <strong>of</strong> IEC component.<br />
5. No involvement/ participation <strong>of</strong> NGOs at implementation<br />
stage.<br />
6. Technology used for construction and conversion <strong>of</strong> toilets was<br />
as per HUDCO's pattern/recommendation.<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 170<br />
It is proposed to include the Information, Education and Communication<br />
(IEC) component with 1% <strong>of</strong> the total central allocations under the<br />
scheme in each <strong>of</strong> the financial year with the <strong>Ministry</strong>. In case the funds<br />
retained are not utilised, these may be utilised in the projects.<br />
NGOs may be involved by the State Governments in the implementation<br />
<strong>of</strong> the scheme in various activities meant for the benefit <strong>of</strong> EWS<br />
population under the scheme with maximum charges upto 15% over and<br />
above the total project cost to be borne by the Centre and States in the<br />
ratio <strong>of</strong> 5:1 at different stages <strong>of</strong> implementation.<br />
Options like septic tank, connecting to small bore or conventional sewer<br />
network etc. may also be permitted under the cost ceiling. Technology<br />
which can enable to tap local resources should be permitted to be<br />
adopted. State implementing agencies may decide the technology best<br />
suited for the site/ locality which may be adopted.
6.3.3 COMPARATIVE ASSESSMENT OF OPTIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS OF MOST<br />
APPROPRIATE OPTIONS<br />
The surveys along with several other tools used in the methodology have significantly contributed to<br />
this particular section. This section also reveals most appropriate options for the city in redeeming to<br />
be highly sanitized and become livable. Instead <strong>of</strong> creating just infrastructure for no reason is <strong>of</strong> no<br />
use and is also a burden on the Nagar Nigam. In such case a supply driven approach would be <strong>of</strong><br />
greater help but not a perfect solution also as sometime people will be concerned about their own<br />
place and just surroundings but would have not understood the significance <strong>of</strong> cities sanitation<br />
situation. In such cases the research groups along with the <strong>of</strong>ficials arrive at solutions which are<br />
environmental friendly and good for the city as such.<br />
Fig:<br />
Supply Driven Approach for Sanitation<br />
Providers<br />
Capital and 'technical'<br />
Expertise<br />
Information on Information<br />
Sanitation services<br />
& Facilities<br />
needs and local on possibilities<br />
Situation<br />
Demand for services<br />
Willingness to pay<br />
Local Knowledge<br />
Users<br />
Recent thinking on service provision stresses that infrastructure schemes must respond to user<br />
demand by providing what potential users want and are willing to pay for. This ‘demand responsive’<br />
approach has replaced the old emphasis on supplying what pr<strong>of</strong>essionals think is good for users,<br />
regardless <strong>of</strong> whether the users want what is supplied or are willing to pay for it. While clearly an
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
improvement on the old supply driven approach, the pure demand-responsive approach is also<br />
inadequate in a number <strong>of</strong> respects.<br />
It is based on what intended service users know, thus limiting scope for change and<br />
innovation.<br />
It ignores the fact that service users are likely to be concerned only with their immediate<br />
surroundings, so that demand for local improvements may be at the expense <strong>of</strong> the wider<br />
environment.<br />
In equating demand with willingness to pay, it perhaps overlooks the fact that the main<br />
problem may be either that sanitation providers are unwilling to charge users for the full<br />
cost <strong>of</strong> services, or that poor people are unable to pay for the full cost <strong>of</strong> the services.<br />
It fails to pay sufficient attention to the capacity <strong>of</strong> service deliverers to respond to demand.<br />
This is a particularly important point where existing service delivery systems are weak.<br />
The market correlation approach<br />
The approach assumes that sanitation is a commodity that should be sold like any other commodity,<br />
for instance a car. People should therefore be <strong>of</strong>fered a range <strong>of</strong> sanitation options from which they<br />
can choose. This approach has two basic drawbacks:<br />
It assumes that individual sanitation users can act independently <strong>of</strong> one another with each<br />
achieving the optimum result for him or her. In practice, this is rarely the case and people<br />
need to act together if the best results are to be achieved.<br />
It ignores the fact that different stakeholders may have different objectives. There is a real<br />
danger that the choices <strong>of</strong> community members will relate to their immediate needs and<br />
ignore the wider environmental implications <strong>of</strong> their sanitation choices.<br />
The user knows best approach<br />
This approach assumes that sanitation-related choices should be based solely on user preferences<br />
and that the role <strong>of</strong> pr<strong>of</strong>essionals is to facilitate those choices. It underestimates the value <strong>of</strong><br />
'pr<strong>of</strong>essional' knowledge. Like the market analogy approach, it assumes that all stakeholders have<br />
the same priorities and will act as a coherent group at the local level. These weaknesses mean that<br />
the approach encourages local ad-hoc activity at the expense <strong>of</strong> overall planning. For example;<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 172
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
people request for sewerage everywhere but the pr<strong>of</strong>essionals would know the feasibility <strong>of</strong><br />
proposing such an option which is <strong>of</strong> high cost.<br />
Shared decision-making - a better approach to sanitation selection<br />
The best choices are likely to be those that take into account the knowledge, concerns and priorities<br />
<strong>of</strong> both pr<strong>of</strong>essionals and users. When all factors are taken into consideration, there will generally be<br />
a best sanitation option in any given situation. The challenge is for users and pr<strong>of</strong>essionals work<br />
together and pool their knowledge so as choose this best option. An illustration <strong>of</strong> the process <strong>of</strong><br />
shared choice is given below:<br />
Pr<strong>of</strong>essional with<br />
Partial information<br />
Dialogue Leading to<br />
Preliminary Choice <strong>of</strong><br />
Sanitation Option<br />
Pilot test <strong>of</strong> proposal<br />
Fully informed choice based on<br />
experience<br />
Plan<br />
Community with<br />
Partial Information<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 173
RECOMMENDATIONS OF MOST APPROPRIATE OPTIONS<br />
1 Sewerage Bareilly city is already having approximately 15-20% <strong>of</strong> coverage <strong>of</strong> sewer lines but there<br />
is no provision <strong>of</strong> Sewerage Treatment Plant ‘STP’. STP is highly recommended for the<br />
safe disposal <strong>of</strong> effluent/wastewater <strong>of</strong> the city.<br />
2 DEWATS This is the best option for number <strong>of</strong> Nallas discharging directly into the water bodies.<br />
DEWATS has a procedure <strong>of</strong> doing a feasibility test and then come up with a plan. The<br />
detailed write up about DEWATS has already been given in the sanitation option section.<br />
CDD Bangalore and Vijay Vigyan Foundation, Delhi are some <strong>of</strong> the expert agencies in<br />
constructing and operationalising DEWATS in India.<br />
3 Community Toilet Block-The Sulabh Model Community toilets are constructed in low income residential areas and slum to cater to<br />
the local community who would otherwise have no access to sanitation. Provided these<br />
are managed well and maintained, this system can be effective in meeting the needs <strong>of</strong><br />
the local community and promoting improved public health. In Bareilly city, as on-site<br />
sanitation option, thirty seven community toilets are existing. Community toilets not only<br />
provide sanitation facility but at the same time have a demonstrative effect as well. The<br />
people using these become habitual users <strong>of</strong> toilets, and in turn realize the need for<br />
individual household toilets. Community toilets thus are the effective tools for bringing<br />
behavioral changes amongst the public residing in the slum areas as well as in generating<br />
a demand for the use <strong>of</strong> the individual toilets. As <strong>of</strong> now there are slum/LIG areas/villages<br />
on the outskirts <strong>of</strong> the city without any community toilet arrangement in Bareilly. A list <strong>of</strong>
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 175<br />
places where community toilets have to be built is given in the gaps and requirement<br />
section <strong>of</strong> the sanitation plan.<br />
4 Sulabh Shauchalaya Sulabh Shauchalaya is a low cost pour flush water-seal sanitary latrine. It is an improved<br />
version <strong>of</strong> the designs already available in the country based on research conducted by<br />
different organizations and institutions on pour flush water-seal latrines. The designers <strong>of</strong><br />
Sulabh Shauchalaya sought to provide an appropriate, efficient, cost effective and<br />
affordable excreta disposal system and to free scavengers from having to collect night soil<br />
and carry it on their heads. This has to be promoted at the individual level in Bareilly so<br />
that the low cost attracts the customers and the option is also in comply with the<br />
pollution control board standards. This specific option has to be communicated effectively<br />
throughout the city so as to promote possession <strong>of</strong> individual toilets at the household<br />
level in city as well as in slum & LIG areas.<br />
5 Shared Latrine In areas where there is not enough space for individual household latrines particularly in<br />
core city, the sharing <strong>of</strong> latrines between several families may provide a useful solution.<br />
The ownership <strong>of</strong> the latrines generally belongs to one <strong>of</strong> the houses, the owner <strong>of</strong> all the<br />
houses, or else ownership is shared between the households. Costs <strong>of</strong> pit emptying and<br />
other repairs can be included in the rent, but this can cause problems if the owner does<br />
not live there. Alternatively, residents can collaborate to clean the latrine and collect<br />
money to get it emptied and cleaned when necessary. Pour Flush toilet with double leach<br />
pit technology would enable the household to use it for long term as well as in a more
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 176<br />
environmental friendly manner with less cost. Information on technology and its<br />
feasibilities are given in the sanitation technology section for further reference.<br />
6 Pour Flush toilet with double leach pit This is an appropriate technology for promoting individual toilets in the city. This<br />
technology would enable the household to use it for long term as well as in a more<br />
environmental friendly manner with less cost. A careful Septage management would<br />
make this system a success. The Nagar Nigam should go with a strong IEC campaign and<br />
make sure that people go for individual toilets. Information on technology and its<br />
feasibilities are given in the sanitation technology section for further reference.<br />
7 Septic tank with soak pits This is a wide speared option which is used in apartments or in houses with multiple<br />
portions. It is a fact that there are several apartments which have septic tanks but not<br />
soak pits. Septic tank without soak pits is a dangerous trend and it has to be avoided. The<br />
construction <strong>of</strong> septic tank with soak pits can be made sure with the system <strong>of</strong> building<br />
laws making it mandatory. Regular monitoring and evaluation with a proper Septage<br />
management would also fetch required results. Information on technology and its<br />
feasibilities are given in the sanitation technology section for further reference.<br />
Special focus on community toilets due to space constraints and its capacity to deal with needs <strong>of</strong> the urban poor<br />
Large and sizable investment has been made for the construction <strong>of</strong> community toilets, which have become either hazardous, unhygienic or abandoned due<br />
to poor construction and planning, or lack <strong>of</strong> water supply or lack <strong>of</strong> proper maintenance. At the same time it must be understood that community toilets<br />
are specifically important for slum, especially where it may not be possible to construct individual household toilets due to the non-availability <strong>of</strong> space.
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
The reasons for failure <strong>of</strong> community toilets<br />
TECHNICAL ISSUES FINANCIAL ISSUES INSTITUTIONAL & BEHAVIOURAL ISSUES<br />
Faulty construction, not conforming to norms <strong>of</strong><br />
availability <strong>of</strong> sustainable water supply, ventilation,<br />
natural lighting etc.,<br />
Lacking in special provision for children and<br />
handicapped /disabled persons<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 177<br />
Insufficient funds for running the system Non-consultations with community on design and<br />
location <strong>of</strong> Community Toilets<br />
Non-availability <strong>of</strong> funds for<br />
augmentation, rectification and up<br />
gradation <strong>of</strong> facilities.<br />
Lack <strong>of</strong> motivation and non-generation <strong>of</strong> felt need<br />
towards sanitation<br />
Lacking in safety and security for women Lack <strong>of</strong> public health and hygiene education among<br />
poor sections <strong>of</strong> society<br />
Lack <strong>of</strong> operation and maintenance. Lack <strong>of</strong> sensitization on gender issue.
Under these circumstances not only the construction but devising measures for strengthening<br />
operational and maintenance aspect <strong>of</strong> the community toilets becomes all the more important. This<br />
scenario necessitates initiatives not only in the construction but over and above in the ‘Operation &<br />
Maintenance’ (O& M) <strong>of</strong> community toilets.<br />
Involving user groups in maintenance is another measure tried successfully in southern part <strong>of</strong> the<br />
country. The chances <strong>of</strong> success <strong>of</strong> these groups are more when women are actively involved. This<br />
was learnt from the experiences <strong>of</strong> one <strong>of</strong> the Municipal Corporation Trichy in Southern part <strong>of</strong> the<br />
India. The women <strong>of</strong> the area were involved in construction <strong>of</strong> community toilets. The women group<br />
“SHE - Team (Sanitation and Hygiene Education - Team)” was formed to take up the maintenance<br />
responsibility <strong>of</strong> the community toilet under pay and use system. The women group soon could able<br />
to earn money out <strong>of</strong> the toilet maintenance and further invested the money in renovation <strong>of</strong> an<br />
abandoned community toilets nearby which was earlier used by men. They replaced the damaged<br />
water closets in the men’s community toilet and attended other repair and renovation works in the<br />
toilet. The men <strong>of</strong> the area started using the renovated community toilet and avoided open<br />
defecation in the slum. For children, the community has decided to construct a separate toilet<br />
adjacent to the pay and use latrines meant for men and women. They could design and construct a<br />
child friendly toilet. The child friendly toilet is being used by the girls and boys <strong>of</strong> the slum who are<br />
below 6 years old. Therefore, community participation especially <strong>of</strong> women has great chance <strong>of</strong><br />
successful O &M <strong>of</strong> community toilets.<br />
Therefore, a system based on empowerment <strong>of</strong> users, owning, operation & maintenance and<br />
collection <strong>of</strong> service charges by user groups seems to be a sustainable solution for rehabilitation <strong>of</strong><br />
defunct community toilets and also for the construction <strong>of</strong> new ones.<br />
6.3.4 INSTITUTIONAL ARRANGEMENTS<br />
Institutional arrangement is one <strong>of</strong> the most crucial aspects <strong>of</strong> sanitation. It is a common factor in all<br />
urban local bodies that infrastructure would be put in place with the support <strong>of</strong> respective state<br />
government and national government at different levels <strong>of</strong> finance and implementation support. It is<br />
observed and proven that, over a period <strong>of</strong> time the responsibility is taken by none and the<br />
infrastructure remains unused or the infrastructure and its conditions deteriorate so much it<br />
becomes a dead investment. No agency concerned in the city vicinity would be in a position would
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
be in a place to monitor it. This has been a crucial issue in sanitation which has hampered the growth<br />
in terms <strong>of</strong> sanitation and also has pushed the cities to look unhygienic by redundant services.<br />
Therefore, having a sound institutional arrangement would enable the infrastructure to be used in a<br />
proposed manner to its fullest capacity.<br />
Many a times the institutional arrangements cannot be confined with one agency in an urban local<br />
body as the activities come under multiple agencies which would make it more cumbersome. This<br />
issue <strong>of</strong> multiple agencies handling the same issues can be resolved only with a good number <strong>of</strong><br />
convergent meetings and responsibilities to deliver are to be guided by the state government. Each<br />
agency handling its own thing is also important but in turn they should also have co-ordination to<br />
make sure that the duties do not limit themselves to their circles but the duties should enable the<br />
city to look more hygienic in terms <strong>of</strong> living conditions. For Example: Slums although directly come<br />
under DUDA, the Nagar Nigam also has greater responsibility in making sure that the slum receives<br />
all the urban basic services required. In this type <strong>of</strong> situation, a combined effort from DUDA and<br />
Nagar Nigam would make better living for the slum dwellers rather each agency handling the<br />
situation in its own way. In the same way the Nagar Nigam has the responsibility <strong>of</strong> constructing<br />
community toilets in the slums, this can happen in the best manner only if both the agencies come<br />
together.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 179
Stakeholders Multiple Stakeholders and<br />
required co-ordination<br />
Civil Society Household level<br />
CBO’s<br />
Resident Welfare Associations<br />
Role to be performed<br />
Civil society has to play a crucial role in promotion and maintenance <strong>of</strong><br />
sanitation situation in the city. This is a first <strong>of</strong> a kind exercise where in the<br />
institutional arrangement civil society is added. The justified reason would be<br />
that most <strong>of</strong> the time the responsibility <strong>of</strong> operation and maintenance <strong>of</strong><br />
sanitation services are left on the Nagar Nigam or any other government<br />
agency. This attitude has to change and civil society should own the<br />
infrastructure given by the government. The Nagar Nigam should make special<br />
moves in this regard as to make sure that the civil society takes the<br />
responsibility <strong>of</strong> maintaining the given infrastructure.<br />
Apart from this, regular involvement in IEC campaign in the city and keeping<br />
the awareness on sanitation movement in the city is <strong>of</strong> greater responsibility<br />
<strong>of</strong> the civil society as this cannot be done by local government alone.<br />
Educating the violators on sanitation also falls in the larger preview <strong>of</strong> the civil<br />
society as sanitation has greater dent in behavior change.<br />
Local NGOs Health Based, The local NGO’s have crucial task to perform as they would know the city<br />
better than anybody within their own sector. NGO’s, apart from their routine
Elected representatives<br />
Sanitation Based,<br />
<strong>Development</strong> Based,<br />
& Education Based NGOs<br />
MP<br />
MLA<br />
Corporators<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 181<br />
work <strong>of</strong> carrying out different projects, should get involved in other activities<br />
by giving handholding support to the corporation in monitoring and evaluation<br />
<strong>of</strong> sanitation activities. The NGO’s also should guide the corporation with their<br />
rich experience in the field in right direction as to approach communities<br />
according to the need.<br />
The NGO’s also should get involved extensively in sanitation IEC activities as to<br />
make the effort more fruitful and effective. Regular reporting <strong>of</strong> the situation<br />
<strong>of</strong> different sector in the city also helps the corporation take appropriate<br />
measures enable proper services.<br />
There are greater responsibilities to performed by the elected representatives.<br />
The elected representatives would know the problems and the scenario <strong>of</strong><br />
particular community better than anyone else. So it is in this regard the role <strong>of</strong><br />
elected representatives become crucial. They have to be proactive and<br />
monitor the development work at regular intervals as to bring it to the notice<br />
<strong>of</strong> the commissioner or responsible authority to make sure that the works<br />
happen in a systematic manner
Ward Members<br />
Nagar Nigam Bareilly JalKal Vibhag<br />
DUDA<br />
BDA<br />
Health Department.<br />
Education Department<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 182<br />
The elected representatives should also get engaged in IEC activities taken up<br />
by the concerned ULB as to bring awareness among the people to go for<br />
better sanitation. Their appeal and presence would make larger difference<br />
with regard to sanitation scenario.<br />
Nagar Nigam Bareilly has a vital role and responsibility in sanitation apart from<br />
the other things it handles. There is a requirement <strong>of</strong> co-ordination between<br />
different stakeholders in the NNB. This is a herculean task.<br />
As the responsibility <strong>of</strong> different sectors rests with different agencies,<br />
the nagar nigam has to regularly monitor and keep itself informed.<br />
Issues <strong>of</strong> amending the building bye laws and any other policy matters<br />
Nagar Nigam has to have co-ordination with BDA as to make sure it<br />
happens with consensus.<br />
Nagar Nigam & JDA has to work together to construct more public<br />
toilets.<br />
Nagar Nigam and DUDA should take combined responsibility <strong>of</strong> bringing
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 183<br />
sanitation facility to the slums. As slums form the crucial section in<br />
sanitation, a greater co-ordination is expected.<br />
The JalKal Vibhag support the Nagar Nigam in planning and execution <strong>of</strong><br />
water supply works. So there is a requirement <strong>of</strong> larger co-ordination<br />
between the agencies.<br />
A considerable amount <strong>of</strong> co-ordination is required between Nagar<br />
Nigam and Health Department as health indicators also form a major<br />
portion in sanitation ranking. Regular reporting <strong>of</strong> health indicators from<br />
the health department would enable the Nagar Nigam to take<br />
appropriate actions in this regard<br />
Nagar Nigam should have a better co-ordination with school education<br />
department as school sanitation is also a priority in overall sanitation.<br />
The co-ordination should be in assessing requirements, making demands<br />
and getting funds from the concerned agency to make school sanitation<br />
better in the corporation limit.<br />
Nagar Nigam should also take adequate interest in insisting the hospitals<br />
to discharge the bio medical liquid waste after a primary treatment. This<br />
can be decisive with regard to public health. The Nagar Nigam should call
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 184<br />
for a meeting with the health department <strong>of</strong>ficials and pollution control<br />
board to make sure that the hospitals adhere to BMW Rules 1998<br />
There are some general responsibilities <strong>of</strong> the Nagar Nigam in making city a<br />
sanitized city are as follows:<br />
Planning, and execution <strong>of</strong> sanitation projects on its own or through<br />
agencies;<br />
Operation and maintenance <strong>of</strong> environmental sanitation services;<br />
Enable participatory approaches for provision and maintenance <strong>of</strong><br />
environmental services.<br />
Implementation and creating awareness for health and hygiene
State Government<br />
<strong>Urban</strong> <strong>Development</strong> Department<br />
Directorate <strong>of</strong> <strong>Urban</strong> Local Bodies<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
Financing and implementation strategy<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 185<br />
Ensuring availability <strong>of</strong> land in slums and poor settlements for sanitation<br />
Put in place enabling laws, by-laws and Rules for environmental sanitation<br />
Devolving <strong>of</strong> power, authority, finance & personnel to the ULBs and<br />
finance, ensuring accountability <strong>of</strong> para-statals to the ULBs<br />
Promote capacity building <strong>of</strong> ULBs through technical assistance and training<br />
to the Nagar Nigam staff<br />
Steering <strong>of</strong> Programme implementation<br />
Creating enabling policy regime for PPP and<br />
Monitoring <strong>of</strong> Programme implementation<br />
Pollution Control Board Setting standards for environmental pollution<br />
Public Health Engineering<br />
Department<br />
Planning and implementation <strong>of</strong> specific sanitation projects in cities and towns
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
Health Department Ensuring public safeguards and outcomes<br />
Para Statals and <strong>Urban</strong><br />
<strong>Development</strong> Authorities<br />
National Government <strong>Ministry</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Urban</strong> <strong>Development</strong><br />
<strong>Ministry</strong> <strong>of</strong> Housing and <strong>Urban</strong><br />
Poverty Alleviation<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 186<br />
Planning, financing and implementation <strong>of</strong> environmental sanitation services<br />
Policy Guidelines for planning, financing and implementation<br />
Monitoring and evaluation <strong>of</strong> implementation<br />
Apart from these roles and responsibilities at the informal level there are certain specified responsibilities the agencies have to perform. Below<br />
list would give clear indications on institutional arrangements:
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
Sector/Component Regulating Authority Present arrangement Required arrangement<br />
Planning and<br />
Construction<br />
Operation and<br />
Maintenance<br />
Water Supply Nagar Nigam Bareilly Jal Nigam Jal Kal Water supply is regulated through Nagar Nigam<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 187<br />
Bareilly. Prior to that the Jal Kal was called as Jal<br />
Sansthan and it was directly under the State<br />
Government. Now with the additional department<br />
with Nagar Nigam, the Jal Kal should be able to<br />
provide safe drinking water with better quality with<br />
regular checks on the tests done on water quality. A<br />
grievance redressal mechanism has to be put in place<br />
for tracking water pollution and contamination apart<br />
from public complaints on water supply. There should<br />
also some regular check on quality <strong>of</strong> the water bodies<br />
This can happen only with Nagar Nigam+Jal Kal+Public<br />
coming together.<br />
Solid Waste Management Nagar Nigam PPP/Private PPP/Private SWM regulating authority is Nagar Nigam and with the<br />
recent PPP on SWM the construction along with
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 188<br />
operation and maintenance has gone to the private<br />
sector. Nagar Nigam with its <strong>of</strong>ficials should have a<br />
check on the performance <strong>of</strong> the private sector as to<br />
see that the SWM is completely take care. SWM<br />
cannot happen overnight and it requires help from<br />
different groups at different levels. The people have to<br />
be educated through IEC campaigns on source<br />
segregation and importance <strong>of</strong> SWM. NGO<br />
participation is very much sought as they have better<br />
communication strategy to approach. The community<br />
should be prepared to pay for the services and this can<br />
happen over a period <strong>of</strong> time by educating as well as<br />
doing a pilot work and showing the performance to<br />
bring change in the mindset <strong>of</strong> the people.<br />
The arrangement would be:<br />
Nagar Nigam+Private Agency +DUDA+NGO’s+Resident<br />
Welfare Associations<br />
Community Toilets Nagar Nigam NGO NGO Although community toilets are regulated by the<br />
Nagar Nigam but it is the NGO’s who are really taking
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 189<br />
care <strong>of</strong> it. As it has been recorded in the situation<br />
analyses most <strong>of</strong> the Community Toilets are in very<br />
bad condition leading to difficulty for the communities<br />
to use it in the absence <strong>of</strong> individual toilets. There<br />
should be a periodical checking <strong>of</strong> the status <strong>of</strong><br />
community toilets by the Nagar Nigam <strong>of</strong>ficials as to<br />
make sure that the facilities are in place. This also calls<br />
for a more robust grievance redressal mechanism.<br />
The arrangement would be:<br />
Nagar Nigam+NGO+DUDA+RWA<br />
Public Toilets Nagar Nigam PPP/Private Nagar Nigam There are very few public toilets are available in<br />
Bareilly city. Due to operation and maintenance<br />
problem, public toilets remain unusable most <strong>of</strong> the<br />
time. The O&M <strong>of</strong> public toilets has to be converted<br />
into BOT model and regular checks on the<br />
maintenance should be done by the Nagar Nigam<br />
<strong>of</strong>ficials.<br />
Septage Management Nagar Nigam Nagar Nigam Nagar Nigam Septage management solely rests with the Nagar<br />
Nigam. As <strong>of</strong> now cleaning <strong>of</strong> septic tanks and pits is
School Sanitation School Education<br />
Department<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 190<br />
done by the Nagar Nigam only. The sludge is thrown<br />
into bigger nallahs without treatment. There are many<br />
toilets which are directly connected to drain. This has<br />
to be monitored and Nagar Nigam should take the<br />
help <strong>of</strong> Jal Kal to make treatment arrangement and<br />
ensure safe disposal <strong>of</strong> Septage.<br />
Nagar Nigam+Jal Kal<br />
SED SED This is one component which is <strong>of</strong> greater importance<br />
and greater magnitude also. There is required<br />
attention for upgrading school sanitation. The Nagar<br />
Nigam also should take active role in school sanitation<br />
by extending sanitation options and Septage<br />
management support to the School Education<br />
Department as this has direct bearing on sanitation<br />
situation and public health in the city<br />
SED+Nagar Nigam+Jal Kal
Bio-Medical Waste Nagar Nigam/Health<br />
Dept.<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 191<br />
Private Private Bio Medical waste is a prominent issue although not<br />
projected at that level. The liquid BMW is let out to<br />
the nallas or drains without treatment. The liquid<br />
waste has to be treated within the hospital and then<br />
let to the sewerage. This can happen with Nagar<br />
Nigam taking serious note and has to co-ordinate with<br />
the health sector to bring forth the change. The solid<br />
BMW is collected by the private agency but <strong>of</strong>ten<br />
dumped in open places in the outskirts <strong>of</strong> the city<br />
leading to serious public health issues. The Nagar<br />
Nigam should regularly monitor and ensure proper<br />
treatment <strong>of</strong> BMW.<br />
Nagar Nigam+NGO+Hospitals+Jal Kal<br />
Industrial Waste Nagar Nigam/PCB Jal Nigam Jal Kal The pollution control board has greater role to play in<br />
insisting on safe disposal <strong>of</strong> industrial waste.<br />
Nagar Nigam+PCB+Industries
6.3.5 IMPLEMENTATION ARRANGEMENTS<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
An implementation arrangement for sanitation is crucial as defining an agency to implement would be easier but to assess the situation and<br />
maintain after completion would be a much higher task. Institutional capacity to carry forward and the required preparation before putting<br />
system into place plays the vital role. This section has identified some crucial requirements for successful sanitation in the city. Some <strong>of</strong> the<br />
issues to be addressed before implementing and in the process <strong>of</strong> implementing have been identified as below:<br />
Sl.no<br />
Implementation arrangement Responsibility<br />
1 Creating a State Level Steering Committee (SLSC) for both driving the programme and establishing a<br />
coordination mechanism for orchestrated action <strong>of</strong> multiple actors involved in the programme. The<br />
State level committee should also be in a position monitor and give interim report to the concerned<br />
ministry. The steering committee should not limit itself to monitoring but also give timely support in<br />
terms clarification and advice on sanitation issues. The committee should act a modem to put forth<br />
the success and difficulties a ULB faces and also provide adequate support in policy issues pertaining<br />
to sanitation<br />
2 Creating a City Sanitation Cell comprising <strong>of</strong> Nagar Ayukt, Environmental Engineer, CMO, Health<br />
Officer, Sanitary Inspectors and Sanitation Workers. The ‘Environmental Engineer’ should be made<br />
over all responsible to coordinate the sanitation activities on day to day basis and directly report to<br />
Nagar Ayukt.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 192<br />
State Government<br />
Nagar Nigam
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
3 The City Sanitation Task Force which already exists in city should be ask for the periodic reviewing <strong>of</strong><br />
progress made in achieving the sanitation mission. As it is not feasible for the CSTF to meet very<br />
regularly but the Mayor should be updated about the progress as the political representatives are kept<br />
informed which is very crucial for the achievement<br />
4 Capacity Building for the Nagar Nigam <strong>of</strong>ficials is a greater requirement. The municipal <strong>of</strong>ficials may<br />
not be aware <strong>of</strong> the technical, financial, environmental and institutional requirements attached with<br />
sanitation. So, before the implementation begins, the <strong>of</strong>ficials have to be trained at different level<br />
from different expert institutions. The state government has to make investment on this but it would<br />
be worthier investment as they would remain as assets in achieving the goals set for sanitation. There<br />
are some National Resource Centres identified by the <strong>Ministry</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Urban</strong> development and <strong>Ministry</strong> <strong>of</strong><br />
Housing and poverty Alleviation all over India and their help can be sought in capacity building. There<br />
is a requirement for field visits for the municipal <strong>of</strong>ficials including the Nagar Ayukt and this would<br />
give them hands on experience <strong>of</strong> the good practices in sanitation.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 193<br />
Nagar Nigam<br />
State Government and Nagar<br />
5 Strengthening information and performance monitoring systems State Government and Nagar<br />
6 Capacity building for NGO’s and CBO’s is also essential before implementing sanitation programme.<br />
This capacity building in turn would help the ULB in operation and maintenance after the<br />
implementation<br />
7 Legal Framework is very important for the sanitation mission to take place. There will be requirement<br />
<strong>of</strong> amending the building bye laws and other municipal laws to enable the implementation process to<br />
Nigam<br />
Nigam<br />
Nagar Nigam<br />
State Government and Nagar<br />
Nigam
e successful<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
8 A fixed tenure for the <strong>of</strong>ficials to remain in the same Nagar Nigam is also one <strong>of</strong> the requirements <strong>of</strong><br />
successful sanitation initiative. The <strong>of</strong>ficials including the Nagar Ayukt should be given enough time to<br />
understand the Nagar Nigam and work accordingly. This would facilitate implementation and<br />
performance <strong>of</strong> Nagar Nigam in sanitation sector in a better way.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 194<br />
State Government
6.3.6 LINKAGE WITH STATE <strong>SANITATION</strong> STRATEGY<br />
The State Sanitation Strategy like the National <strong>Urban</strong> Sanitation Policy envisages the vision it has laid<br />
out at the national level <strong>of</strong> making all the cities highly sanitized and livable. Sanitation being a state<br />
subject has to be dealt with utmost care in implementing. The piecemeal approach to sanitation has<br />
not fetched any results so far. The state sanitation strategy envisages supporting the sanitation plans<br />
<strong>of</strong> the cities by duly acknowledging the financial constraints a ULB goes through. The state strategy<br />
urges the urban local bodies to make public aware <strong>of</strong> the financial constraints it goes through and<br />
help in providing basic necessities in a appropriate way by making provision for payment <strong>of</strong> the taxes<br />
on time. On the other hand it should encourage and facilitate the cities to take up numerous IEC<br />
activities in the city through audio visuals and video documentaries to bring awareness among the<br />
general public in achieving sanitized city status.<br />
The city sanitation plan <strong>of</strong> Bareilly has brought forth all these issues meticulously with numerous<br />
tools <strong>of</strong> methodology and suggestion in the form <strong>of</strong> IEC to be in accordance with the State Strategy.<br />
The IEC component has emerged in every section beginning from situational analyses to the last<br />
section <strong>of</strong> the plan that <strong>of</strong> IEC action plan with indicative budget.<br />
Apart from these components the other processes put forth and recommended in the State<br />
Sanitation Strategy has been followed.<br />
Sensitization Workshop Yes All stakeholders & municipal <strong>of</strong>ficials from all the<br />
department attended the workshop<br />
Pr<strong>of</strong>iling <strong>of</strong> the ULB Yes A team <strong>of</strong> experts visited the city and collected the<br />
baseline information <strong>of</strong> Bareilly city<br />
City Sanitation Task Force Yes Constituted as per guidelines <strong>of</strong> NUSP and held the<br />
meeting<br />
Situational Analyses and Mapping Yes Was done extensively with a primary survey and the<br />
current status<br />
results shared in a stakeholders workshop<br />
Problem Analyses and Gaps<br />
Yes Was done and gaps identified with suggested<br />
Identification<br />
solutions<br />
Developing consolidated CSP Yes Was done and stakeholders suggestions have been<br />
taken<br />
Formulation <strong>of</strong> action plans and<br />
finalization <strong>of</strong> CSP at stakeholder<br />
workshop<br />
Yes Would be done after the draft CSP is presented and<br />
suggestions are incorporated<br />
The plan also recommends the State Government and Nagar Nigam should take up sanitation in a<br />
mission mode and achieve the required standards. Although the state strategy does not mention<br />
about taking up sanitation drive in a mission mode, the plan suggests it to as the UP cities need<br />
immediate attention so that the city will also take it as a priority and achieve goals one by one as to
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
fall in comply with the national vision <strong>of</strong> NUSP. Needless to mention, the plans attract huge money in<br />
terms <strong>of</strong> grants and in terms <strong>of</strong> donation from international donors apart from the existing financial<br />
structure for promoting sanitation at the ULB level.<br />
6.3.7 IEC AND AWARENESS ACTION <strong>PLAN</strong><br />
In the process related parameters <strong>of</strong> city sanitation rating methodology, Monitoring & Evaluation<br />
system for tracking open defecation find their place. Of the total 4 points given to this category,<br />
Bareilly has scored no point. Here is where initiating IEC and awareness programmes can help the<br />
municipality gain some important points. A sustained grassroots campaign couple with adequate<br />
mass media exposure is a mix that will deliver the required results. Community participation backed<br />
by improved municipal services can help Bareilly open defecation free status. Neighborhood groups<br />
such as women’s self help groups and school children can be sensitized to the issue <strong>of</strong> open<br />
defecation. Having a community monitoring system has been found to be very effective in several<br />
cities. A community level group can be formed to dissuade open defecation. For instance, a group <strong>of</strong><br />
school children armed with vigils can alert the community to anyone trying to defecate in open.<br />
Nagar Nigam sanitary inspectors and safai karamcharies can patrol marked open defecation areas.<br />
Making random visits to open defecation areas early in the morning can be institutionalized to arrest<br />
open defecation.<br />
Process Related<br />
NO INDICATORS TOTAL<br />
POINTS<br />
POINTS<br />
SECURED<br />
A M&E systems are in place to track incidences <strong>of</strong> open defecation 4 0<br />
Reduction in water borne diseases in another area <strong>of</strong> focus for the nagar nigam as it has score 02<br />
points in this category. Further IEC can help in generating awareness required to bring down the<br />
incidence <strong>of</strong> water borne diseases. The City Sanitation Ranking methodology has given weight to<br />
reducing water-borne diseases. The IEC campaign can take up personal and community hygiene as<br />
key themes. These would include water-borne diseases, other communicable ailments including skin<br />
diseases to make it more comprehensive.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 196
Outcome Related<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
NO INDICATORS TOTAL<br />
POINTS<br />
C Reduction in water-borne disease incidence amongst city population<br />
compared to baseline<br />
POINTS<br />
SECURED<br />
6 2<br />
In addition to the two pressing issues, an integrated communications campaign to promote<br />
awareness and seek participation consisting <strong>of</strong> the following will comprehensively tackle the issue <strong>of</strong><br />
sanitation. Campaign against taking water connections directly from the raising main and other<br />
illegal connections. Illegal connections cases losses <strong>of</strong> water and revenue to the Nagar Nigam;<br />
Campaign for Solid Waste segregation at source; Campaign for community participation in<br />
community toilet maintenance.<br />
Strengthening the existing computerized public grievances redressal system at Nagar Nigam<br />
Bareilly would served the citizen more effectively and efficiently. Citizens could use various means<br />
to communicate their complaints such as phone, SMS, internet etc. As <strong>of</strong> now most citizens (67%)<br />
complained directly through face to face interactions. Computerized complaint resolution system<br />
will keep records <strong>of</strong> all complaints and can be an effective tool for the Nagar Nigam to monitor<br />
trends in complaints to find areas <strong>of</strong> weakness.<br />
Channels<br />
1. Conducting circle wise meeting in the 05 sanitary circles.<br />
2. Mass media, newspapers, FM radio, local cable TV channels .<br />
Partners<br />
NNB, JalKal Vibag, local NGOs, Gyan Jyoti Siksha Samiti, local print media agencies<br />
Public Participation<br />
1. Advisory Committees: These are constituted to ensure Multi-Stakeholder involvement in<br />
sanitation projects. Members <strong>of</strong> such bodies can include prominent personalities from<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 197
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
academia, arts, culture, social sector, media etc, representatives <strong>of</strong> donor agencies, Mayor,<br />
relevant heads <strong>of</strong> departments, and even leaders <strong>of</strong> sanitation workers union. City Sanitation<br />
Task Force (CSTF) is one such body at the city level. NUSP guidelines have established the<br />
role and responsibilities <strong>of</strong> CSTF. An innovative idea gaining traction is <strong>of</strong> Ward level<br />
Sanitation Action Committees. For Bareilly such a body can be constituted at sanitary zone<br />
level. It is desirable to take governance as close to people as possible. This ensures effective<br />
public consultations and possibly community participation. A ward level body can be headed<br />
by Corporator and comprise <strong>of</strong> ward members, Safai karamcharies, representatives/<strong>of</strong>ficials<br />
from Nagar Nigam, Jal Kal, RWAs, NGOs, Self Help Groups (SHGs)<br />
2. Public Hearings: The system <strong>of</strong> public hearings is known to be effective in monitoring project<br />
progress, resolving citizen grievances. What we propose here is that public consultation is<br />
essential during designing <strong>of</strong> projects. The chances <strong>of</strong> success <strong>of</strong> a project are enhanced, as<br />
this makes sure the project is designed to benefit as many people as possible. Seeking inputs<br />
from people will make them believe that the Nagar Nigam is seeking genuine partnership.<br />
More importantly this will help to develop trust. Public hearing can help launch and<br />
integrated campaign against open defecation, illegal water connection,<br />
The timeframe <strong>of</strong> the recommended communication strategy is relevant for a period <strong>of</strong> two to three<br />
years from the beginning <strong>of</strong> implementation. The process can evolve with the implementation to<br />
incorporate any mid course improvements required. Once initiated, it can take up a wide range <strong>of</strong><br />
other issues as per the requirements <strong>of</strong> the city. There is every likelihood <strong>of</strong> such a process be<br />
institutionalized with Public Relations <strong>of</strong>ficer stationed in the municipality taking the lead.<br />
Given the growth and rapidly changing social and economic environment <strong>of</strong> the cities, it would be<br />
imperative for Nagar Nigam to develop capacity to assess changes in the situation and adapt<br />
strategies accordingly. Timely implementation <strong>of</strong> the recommendations made in this document will<br />
ensure that desired results flow in a sustained manner.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 198
Conclusion<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
Keeping in view the issues and concern expressed by the citizen during the CSTF and other stakeholders<br />
meeting and scope <strong>of</strong> city sanitation plan it is opined that less emphasized area <strong>of</strong> communication holds<br />
a vast potential for behavioral and mindset change <strong>of</strong> people . There are three important components<br />
to the communication strategy:<br />
1. Inter-personal communications: Using opinion leaders<br />
2. Engaging media and NGOs as partners in promoting sanitation consciousness<br />
3. Adapting and developing multimedia IEC materials for sanitation campaigns<br />
Interpersonal means are known to be very effective in behavior change communications. These are<br />
tedious processes to carry out but <strong>of</strong>fer better returns. It is important to understand the needs <strong>of</strong> the<br />
local community and select opinion leaders who could influence the community to further sanitation<br />
consciousness. These opinion leaders could be local NGOs, cooperators, school teachers or any other<br />
respected elder. A newspaper ad or a public service message on TV without ground level work through<br />
opinion leaders will fail to be sustainable in the long run.<br />
6.3.8 MONITORING AND EVALUATION<br />
Strategic planning should not be considered in isolation, but should rather be seen as a continuing<br />
process. Circumstances change, outcomes do not always occur in quite the way expected and it is<br />
therefore important that plans are adaptable. This will not be possible unless you have sound<br />
information upon which to base decisions to amend and adapt plan components. This suggests a need<br />
for effective monitoring and evaluation <strong>of</strong> plan components. Monitoring and evaluation <strong>of</strong> sanitation<br />
progamme is <strong>of</strong> higher importance as <strong>Urban</strong> development <strong>Ministry</strong>, Government <strong>of</strong> India publishes city<br />
sanitation ranking based on the cities performance. Before this happens it is the ULB’s requirement to<br />
have a sound monitoring and evaluation tool.<br />
Continued emphasis and allocations to sanitation from finance ministries depends on an ability to<br />
demonstrate improved sanitation outputs and outcomes. This would only be possible if effective and<br />
accurate monitoring systems are in place at all levels <strong>of</strong> government. Monitoring is also needed to<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 201
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
determine budget utilization, actual resource flows from different sources, and value for money actually<br />
achieved. Despite its importance, while developing performance monitoring for sanitation it is necessary<br />
to address constraints related to difficulty in measuring health and hygiene related outcomes and their<br />
attribution to sanitation measures. Given the household and community focus in sanitation appropriate<br />
institutional mechanisms are also needed for their participation in performance monitoring. Emphasis<br />
on performance monitoring is also required because <strong>of</strong> limited experience in scaling up approaches.<br />
Thus, synthesized feedback provided by a good performance monitoring system to policy makers is<br />
essential for continuously assessing their effectiveness and making the necessary mid-course<br />
corrections.<br />
Monitoring is a management tool that is intended to provide managers with information about how an<br />
initiative or process is performing. Monitoring takes place at intervals throughout the life <strong>of</strong> the<br />
sanitation initiative or process. Examples include monitoring <strong>of</strong> the quality <strong>of</strong> materials used in the<br />
implementation <strong>of</strong> a new sanitation initiative and monitoring <strong>of</strong> the effluent quality produced by a<br />
treatment facility.<br />
Evaluation takes place after the completion <strong>of</strong> an initiative or programme. It aims to answer such<br />
questions as were the intended objectives achieved, was the expenditure as expected and did the right<br />
people benefit as intended.<br />
The key functions <strong>of</strong> agencies in the sanitation sector are policy formulation, regulation, investment,<br />
operations and maintenance <strong>of</strong> sanitation facilities, and the commercial activity <strong>of</strong> supplying the needy<br />
with desired sanitation services. Traditionally, these functions have been carried out in most <strong>of</strong> the cities<br />
in a supply-driven way with a high degree <strong>of</strong> centralized control, little local accountability, and little<br />
involvement <strong>of</strong> consumers. The consequence has been failure to cope with the growing problems <strong>of</strong><br />
urban sanitation.<br />
Monitoring and evaluation <strong>of</strong> city sanitation plan has three purposes:<br />
To evaluate the effectiveness <strong>of</strong> the planning process, or assess the effectiveness <strong>of</strong> the phases<br />
in the preparation <strong>of</strong> the city sanitation plan, including sanitation mapping, defining the<br />
sanitation development framework, and preparation <strong>of</strong> reports. The results <strong>of</strong> the evaluation<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 202
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
will be used to improve the preparation <strong>of</strong> citywide sanitation plan in the next cycle. Monitoring<br />
and evaluation is also used to assess coordination within the sanitation working group. This type<br />
<strong>of</strong> monitoring and evaluation is generally qualitative, interactive, and participatory.<br />
To evaluate the implementation <strong>of</strong> sanitation development activities, or assess the progress and<br />
level <strong>of</strong> achievement <strong>of</strong> sanitation development activities. This monitoring and evaluation uses<br />
indicators set at the time the sanitation activities were proposed. Quantitative results will be<br />
used to evaluate whether goals and targets have been reached. The results <strong>of</strong> the evaluation will<br />
be used to improve action plans for the following year.<br />
To evaluate the benefits <strong>of</strong> sanitation development, or assess the impact <strong>of</strong> sanitation<br />
development programs against trends in sanitation conditions and general environmental<br />
conditions, level <strong>of</strong> sanitation coverage, sanitation behaviour <strong>of</strong> the community, public health<br />
conditions and environmental health risk in each section <strong>of</strong> the city. The results will be<br />
compared with the baseline conditions <strong>of</strong> the city periodically.<br />
In sanitation <strong>of</strong> the city the component <strong>of</strong> monitoring and evaluation plays a crucial role as it enables the<br />
ULB to know its position from time to time against the baseline condition or prior to sanitation initiative.<br />
Reviewing progress <strong>of</strong><br />
Plan at Regular Interval<br />
Monitoring<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 203<br />
Fig:<br />
<strong>Development</strong> <strong>of</strong><br />
City Sanitation Plan<br />
Implementing plan<br />
Components<br />
Evaluation
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
The aim is to develop monitoring systems for simpler activities and schemes and use experience gained<br />
with these to develop systems for more complex processes. When evaluating initiatives, one should not<br />
forget to ask the users what they think. They are the people most intimately affected by the success or<br />
failure <strong>of</strong> a scheme and their opinions should provide valuable information. The evaluation also can be<br />
carried out through expert agencies as there is a tendency to feel good when it is done by the ULB itself.<br />
Regular evaluation also gives added value to the project as to plan and restructure if there is a<br />
requirement in the plan for further progress.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 204
ROAD MAP<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
The city has the potential to generate several proposals in the form <strong>of</strong> different sanitation options. As<br />
the city has no sewerage coverage there have to be alternative arrangements to make the city more<br />
sanitized and achieve the required standards. This is also a primordial condition for the Nagar Nigam to<br />
go for viable options and make the city more livable.<br />
Sanitation programs must also use a menu <strong>of</strong> different approaches, such as financing at the household<br />
level and a range <strong>of</strong> affordable sanitation options for potential consumers. This may require working<br />
with a range <strong>of</strong> new partners, including public health <strong>of</strong>ficials, grassroots organizations, and private<br />
sector, something that should not be seen as a deterrent.<br />
Knowing well the resource constraints, the conventional wisdom is that a phased-development<br />
approach is ideal. The further one goes up the “sanitation ladder”, the greater the benefits for people<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 205
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
and the environment. As economic growth permits, communities can then gradually improve the quality<br />
<strong>of</strong> sanitation services with higher-cost options.<br />
The phased development can be achieved in the form <strong>of</strong> short-term, mid-term and long-term goals. This<br />
would also enable the Nagar Nigam to achieve some <strong>of</strong> the components <strong>of</strong> the sanitation policy without<br />
making heavy financial investment. A list <strong>of</strong> initiatives to be taken up is given in below table.<br />
Sl.No Timeline Initiatives<br />
1 Short-Term Community toilets<br />
The Nagar Ayukt can constitute a small team headed by the Environmental<br />
Engineer along with other <strong>of</strong>ficials who can make a rapid review <strong>of</strong> the<br />
existing community toilets and their condition with pictorial evidences.<br />
The Nagar Ayukt based on the report can call for a meeting with the<br />
agensies/NGO’s involved in operation and maintenance <strong>of</strong> the community<br />
toilets in the city and give them a timeframe to put the system in place and<br />
provide facility on regular basis.<br />
Minimum financial assistance to some existing infrastructure but the<br />
requirement <strong>of</strong> a facelift can be facilitated to make them usable.<br />
An IEC campaign that can educate the public in usage <strong>of</strong> community toilets<br />
in proper manner and bring awareness to use community toilets in case <strong>of</strong><br />
no individual toilet available at the household level instead <strong>of</strong> Open<br />
Defecation<br />
Public Toilets<br />
There are very few public toilets in Bareilly and all the toilets are not used<br />
due to maintenance. Measures should be taken to ensure proper upkeep<br />
and maintenance <strong>of</strong> public toilets.<br />
Open Defecation<br />
An effective IEC campaign with the involvement <strong>of</strong> concerned citizens,<br />
school children and NGO’s to eliminate open defecation by showing the<br />
health hazards involved in OD in slums and other potential areas.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 206
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
Documentaries and audio visuals to inform people on day to day basis till<br />
the message reach the public and there are signs <strong>of</strong> change in practice.<br />
Waste Management<br />
The city faces huge problem with waste being dump in and around the city.<br />
This problem can be solved by the administration by calling the Safai<br />
Karmacharis involved in SWM for meeting and making them aware <strong>of</strong> the<br />
hazards caused by open dumping <strong>of</strong> the waste. They in turn should<br />
communicate the same in the colonies where they go for collecting solid<br />
waste, street sweeping and cleaning the drains.<br />
Strict message should be sent across the municipal employees involved in<br />
transportation <strong>of</strong> solid waste not to dump the waste in the city outskirts<br />
but only at designated site.<br />
There is also a major problem <strong>of</strong> the cattle dung in the city. For this<br />
investment for Bio-Gas can be explored under PPP model. The other option<br />
would be asking the SWM Company to clean and use them in the<br />
composting yard.<br />
An effective IEC campaign with the involvement <strong>of</strong> concerned citizens,<br />
school children and NGO’s to adopt good practices through documentaries<br />
can be taken up.<br />
Environment pollution<br />
Most <strong>of</strong> the nallas and drains are directly discharging the wastewater into<br />
the water bodies and thus polluting the complete environment <strong>of</strong> the city .<br />
This can be controlled to an extent by ensuring the routine upkeep and<br />
maintenance by the Nagar Nigam.<br />
The water bodies can be cleaned with the help <strong>of</strong> an IEC campaign and by<br />
taking the help <strong>of</strong> resident welfare associations in the vicinity.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 207
Bio Medical Waste<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
There is big threat from the hospitals due to the way they handle Bio<br />
Medical liquid waste. The hospitals are not fully aware <strong>of</strong> the BMW rules<br />
and they have to be oriented and asked to comply with the rules and do a<br />
primary treatment at the hospital level before leaving the liquid waste in to<br />
the nallas or drain.<br />
The private agency handling BMW should be called regularly to update the<br />
Nagar Ayukt on the situation <strong>of</strong> BMW in the city and how the collection<br />
and conveyance is happening. Burning or throwing the BMW in the vicinity<br />
and anywhere should be strictly punished.<br />
Storm Water Drainage<br />
Institutionalize the upkeep & maintenance <strong>of</strong> nallas/drains<br />
Polythene bags are major cause <strong>of</strong> clogging the nallas/drains and so<br />
use <strong>of</strong> polythene less than 20 microns as per UP Act<br />
should be banned.<br />
Grievance Redressal Mechanism<br />
Grievance redressal mechanism has to be more robust and responsive to<br />
the public. This also would bring in good governance and effective delivery<br />
<strong>of</strong> basic civic services.<br />
Monitoring & Evaluation system<br />
The Nagar Nigam has to put in place an M&E system for tracking Open<br />
Defecation incidences in the city and update the data available to assess<br />
sanitation coverage and find option to move towards Open defecation Free<br />
city.<br />
2 Mid-Term Individual and Shared Toilets<br />
Construction <strong>of</strong> individual toilets must be promoted with financial<br />
assistance from different sources. The concept <strong>of</strong> privacy and dignity has to<br />
be made a major component <strong>of</strong> propaganda and through a constant IEC<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 208
campaign this can be achieved over a period <strong>of</strong> time.<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
The option <strong>of</strong> shared toilets has to be promoted through the CBO’s in<br />
places where less community toilets are there and there is place constraint<br />
to construct individual toilet. This also requires extensive IEC campaign.<br />
Community Toilets<br />
Space constraint would remain as one <strong>of</strong> the major problem for sanitation<br />
at the individual level. The Nagar Nigam should identify some place in each<br />
slum and potential places to construct community toilets. At least one slum<br />
one community toilet should be followed and best would be providing<br />
community toilets according the population ratio.<br />
DEWATS<br />
By taking help <strong>of</strong> an expert agency feasibility study should be initiated in<br />
the short term and then plans for constructing DEWATS should be<br />
promoted.<br />
As the construction would not cost so much like a typical sewerage system<br />
the Nagar Nigam should find finances for promoting DEWATS<br />
The community should be prepared to own the DEWATS system at their<br />
community level and take minimum technical support from the Nagar<br />
Nigam and external agency<br />
3 Long-Term Sewerage Network & STPs<br />
Expansion <strong>of</strong> sewerage network and STP are kept in the long term goals for<br />
the obvious reason <strong>of</strong> high investment which cannot be met by the Nagar<br />
Nigam and external funding also does not come very <strong>of</strong>ten. Different<br />
sewerage networks and STPs can be planned based on the geographical<br />
layout <strong>of</strong> the city.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 209
Integrated Storm Water Drainage<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
Integrated Storm Water Drainage system should be planned for the<br />
city.<br />
To accomplish this, local government and Nagar Nigam must change their current mindset. Many still<br />
view that water and sanitation investments are too costly and not sustainable or replicable. It is<br />
generally believed that some interventions are all that is possible. The Nagar Nigam does also disregard<br />
the squatter settlements which absorb much <strong>of</strong> growing urban population. Moreover the slum<br />
communities do not have ownership rights and are “not allowed” to invest in proper sanitary facilities,<br />
even if they have motivation and capacity.<br />
The first step is to provide basic sanitation or toilets facilities in slum and LIG. As mentioned earlier,<br />
these must ensure hygienic separation <strong>of</strong> excreta from human contact, which means feces must be<br />
confined until they are composted and safe. Regardless <strong>of</strong> the toilet technology selected, these systems<br />
must also address sanitation all the way “from toilet to river,” meaning that pathogens and pollutants<br />
cannot be allowed to enter nearby water sources, including aquifers. This is where sanitation becomes<br />
particularly challenging, as affordability and environmental cleanliness are <strong>of</strong>ten at odds. The simplest<br />
option; a pit latrine must be cleaned or emptied regularly, which is a difficult prospect in crowded<br />
areas. Pour-flush latrines require that an ample water supply is readily available, as well as properly-<br />
constructed septic tanks, drainage to carry away the wastewater, and services for eventually dealing<br />
with the collection <strong>of</strong> sludge and transfer to a septage treatment facility.<br />
Innovative partnerships must be forged to stimulate investments (PPP Model)<br />
To realize higher levels <strong>of</strong> service coverage and quality, sanitation programs must stimulate investments<br />
from as wide a range <strong>of</strong> sources as possible, including consumers themselves and the private sector.<br />
Successful public–private partnership (PPP) models can help overcome the limitations <strong>of</strong> local<br />
governments, which are under tremendous pressure in view <strong>of</strong> rapid urbanization and fast growing<br />
slum and low-income populations. In the sanitation sector, partnership arrangements between the<br />
public and private agencies, with the involvement <strong>of</strong> community networks, such as NGOs and CBOs,<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 210
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
have proven to be successful. To realize the vision and plan <strong>of</strong> city sanitation the city has to have a look<br />
on the available best models in sanitation across the country and also look for best practices.<br />
The best approach to maintenance is preventative maintenance, carrying out specific maintenance tasks<br />
on a regular basis to ensure that problems are dealt well before they become serious. The normal<br />
approach in our country is reactive maintenance or crisis maintenance, carrying out maintenance in<br />
reaction to problems as and when they occur. The problem with this approach is that it will generally<br />
cost more in the long-run than preventative maintenance. Poor design may make preventative<br />
maintenance almost impossible.<br />
Temporary improvements will not lead to lasting change and may even lead to a long-term deterioration<br />
in conditions. For instance, a covered drain that gets clogged/blocked because <strong>of</strong> lack <strong>of</strong> maintenance<br />
will overflow and may create a greater environmental nuisance than the open drain. Improvements<br />
must be sustained over time if they are to have lasting benefits and this implies the need for<br />
management arrangements for operation and maintenance that are workable and acceptable to all the<br />
concerned groups. In this regard the plan <strong>of</strong> achieving short-term, mid-term and long-term plan would<br />
facilitate much expected sustained development in terms <strong>of</strong> sanitation. The Nagar Nigam have to play<br />
pivotal role in the entire programme for the simple reason that they are legally entrusted to provide and<br />
maintain the sanitation services.<br />
Sanitation for All and All for Sanitation<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 211
BEST PRACTICES<br />
Case Study I-The first city in India where open defecation prevented in all slums<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
Tiruchirappalli City Corporation –the first city in India where open defecation prevented in all slums<br />
Gramalaya’s work is focused on implementation and filling critical knowledge gaps in the sector, up<br />
scaling community based pro poor approaches through our program and advocacy work. The 2001<br />
census <strong>of</strong> India put urban sanitation coverage at 61 percent <strong>of</strong> the population having access to<br />
individual or public toilets. Low coverage <strong>of</strong> urban sanitation is due to the inability <strong>of</strong> planned urban<br />
development to provide for sanitation access to the urban poor. Gramalaya started its urban<br />
intervention in the 186 slums <strong>of</strong> Tiruchirappalli City Corporation as the operational area aiming at<br />
declaring open defecation free zone. The involvement <strong>of</strong> community based organizations in the<br />
project coupled with City Corporation support in providing Integrated Sanitatary complexes (ISPs),<br />
<strong>of</strong>fering vacant sites for constructing community toilets with WaterAid, UK funding enabled the<br />
project a successfully demonstrated model.<br />
Gramalaya played an active role in declaring India’s first slum Kalmandhai as open defecation free<br />
(ODF) slum in Tiruchirappalli City Corporation in theyear 2002 followed by 168 slums as ODF<br />
announced with the support <strong>of</strong> Trichy City Corporation and donor agencies. This has resulted in<br />
conversion <strong>of</strong> dry earth latrines into modern flush out community toilets and eradication <strong>of</strong> manual<br />
scavenging in the city. In Tiruchirappalli city Corporation, 126 slum Communities are maintaining<br />
sanitary complexes under pay and use system with the support city Corporation. The Corporation<br />
handed over the toilets to women self help groups after new construction or renovation <strong>of</strong> the toilet.<br />
The Corporation gave the permission letter to the groups for running the community managed toilet<br />
under pay and use system. The Gramalaya experience proved that adequate involvement <strong>of</strong><br />
community and training in maintenance <strong>of</strong> public toilets and earning from user charge is a revenue<br />
model for the slum communities with sustainable approach. It also generates tremendous confidence<br />
among women to partake in slum welfare and day-to-day decision making.<br />
The review <strong>of</strong> Community managed toilets and bathing complexes in Tiruchirapalli, six years after the<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 212
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
work began, has shown that achieving clean and healthy slums does not require huge financial<br />
investment. However, what it does require is a city authority sensitive to the problems faced by slum<br />
communities and supportive <strong>of</strong> community action, dedication <strong>of</strong> communities and their support<br />
NGOs. It has been proved that communities can manage their own toilet units and when they do this,<br />
the toilet are much cleaner than when managed by municipal authorities. There have been cases<br />
where the entire community can be declared open defecation free. Further, it has shown that<br />
managing toilets leads to empowerment <strong>of</strong> women with many positive impacts in terms <strong>of</strong> personal<br />
and community development. This experience shows that after reluctance, committees do pay for<br />
using toilets and bathing and washing facilities and these services can be provided at affordable costs,<br />
even for the poorest.<br />
Toilets are only a part <strong>of</strong> the sanitation solution. Sewage, wastewater and solid waste management<br />
must also be tackled by city authorities and this is the area where they must play a lead role.<br />
Tiruchirapalli shows that community managed toilets and bathing complexes provide a model that<br />
can work at city-level when supported by city authorities where declaration <strong>of</strong> 168 slums as open<br />
defecation free made possible.<br />
Alandur Municipality-Public-Private Community Participation In Implementation Of Underground<br />
Sewerage System<br />
Alandur Municipality has succeeded in providing connections to an underground sewerage system to all<br />
its residents, including the urban poor. This was achieved through a combination <strong>of</strong> effective leadership,<br />
political will, mobilizing people's participation, financial planning and forging the right partnerships.<br />
City Pr<strong>of</strong>ile<br />
Alandur, a selection-grade municipality, is part <strong>of</strong> Kanchipuram district <strong>of</strong> Tamil Nadu. It is adjacent to<br />
Chennai, at a distance <strong>of</strong> 14 km on the southern side, and forms a part <strong>of</strong> the Chennai Metropolitan<br />
<strong>Development</strong> Area (CMDA). With hardly any industrial base, the town has developed as a residential<br />
suburb <strong>of</strong> Chennai. According to the 1991 Census <strong>of</strong> India, the town has a population <strong>of</strong> 1,25,444, with<br />
32,000 households spread over to 19.5 sq km. Approximately one-fourth <strong>of</strong> its population lives in slums.<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 213
Context<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
Alandur municipality had no underground sewerage system. Households had either septic tanks or<br />
holding tanks, and the municipality was responsible for collecting the sewage periodically in tankers and<br />
disposing it <strong>of</strong>f in low-lying areas. To address these problems, an underground sewerage system was<br />
designed for its current population, as well as for an estimated population <strong>of</strong> 3,00,000 in 2027, with the<br />
objectives <strong>of</strong> improving the standard <strong>of</strong> living <strong>of</strong> the residents; providing for disposal <strong>of</strong> sewage through<br />
an exclusive drainage network; avoiding recurring expenditure on septic tank cleaning; and preventing<br />
groundwater contamination.<br />
Implementation<br />
In 1997, the Government <strong>of</strong> Tamil Nadu decided to provide a sewerage system in 12 selected major<br />
urban centers including Alandur, in the context <strong>of</strong> a World Bank Project. The Chairperson <strong>of</strong><br />
Municipality, Mr. R. S. Bharati, took up the task <strong>of</strong> implementing this. It was decided that Tamil Nadu<br />
<strong>Urban</strong> Infrastructure Finance Services Ltd. (TNUIFSL), the state asset management company, be<br />
approached to finance the sewerage scheme. Considering the lack <strong>of</strong> financial and technical resources at<br />
the municipal level to undertake such an infrastructure project, it was decided by TNUIFSL that the<br />
municipality would undertake the project on a BOQ (Bill <strong>of</strong> Quantities) basis. The sewerage treatment<br />
plant (STP) would be built on a BOT (Build, Operate and Transfer) basis. The project entailed a)<br />
construction <strong>of</strong> an underground sewerage scheme with a network <strong>of</strong> sewer pipelines and manholes, <strong>of</strong><br />
120 kms (including 19 km main and 101 km branch lines); b) construction <strong>of</strong> a pumping house and<br />
installation <strong>of</strong> pumping machinery; and c) construction <strong>of</strong> a sewage treatment plant with a capacity <strong>of</strong><br />
24 MLD (2 units 12 MLD each) on BOT basis to IVRCL and VATec for a period <strong>of</strong> 14 years.<br />
The project work was carried out in two phases. In the first phase (the first two and a half years), 50% <strong>of</strong><br />
the branch sewers, main sewers, pump house including installation <strong>of</strong> machinery, pumping main and<br />
one 12 MLD capacity sewage treatment plant, were completed and commissioned. The remaining work<br />
relating to the project was to be carried out in the next phase. The particular challenges addressed were<br />
communication and consultations with citizens to secure their buy-in and contribution to the sewerage<br />
scheme, technical bottlenecks such as realignments necessitated by the construction <strong>of</strong> subways and<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 214
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
MRTS, terrain conditions, and procedural delays in approvals. To reduce the repayment burden on the<br />
local body, it was decided to collect deposits from at least 10,000 residents before calling for tenders;<br />
this was also to ensure effective participation <strong>of</strong> people in the project. The names <strong>of</strong> the depositors<br />
were displayed in public places to motivate others to pay. Officials and non-<strong>of</strong>ficials, especially the<br />
chairperson <strong>of</strong> Alandur municipality, organised detailed discussions with the residents <strong>of</strong> the city and<br />
resident associations, in order to explain the project details and benefits <strong>of</strong> the sewerage project as part<br />
<strong>of</strong> assessing the willingness to pay. Effective and timely communication ensured participation <strong>of</strong> key<br />
stakeholders and beneficiaries in the initiative. An election-style campaign was launched. Television and<br />
newspapers were roped in to motivate the public. Sanitary workers also conducted a door-to-door<br />
campaign in support <strong>of</strong> the project. To ensure the inclusion <strong>of</strong> the poor and slum residents, a provision<br />
was also made for community toilets connected to the sewerage system.<br />
The total project cost was estimated at Rs. 34 crores with a break-up shown in the table:<br />
Sources <strong>of</strong> Funds (Rs. in Cr.)<br />
SOURCE CONTRIBUTION % Of TOTAL<br />
TNUIDCO Loan 16 47.06<br />
Citizen's contribution 8 23.53<br />
TNUIFSL Loan 3 11.76<br />
TNUIFSL Grant 4 8.82<br />
Interest on deposits 2 5.88<br />
TNUIDCO Grant 1 2.94<br />
Total 34 100.00<br />
Tariff Structure HSC Tariff Domestic Category HSC Tariff Non Domestic - Commercial and Industrial<br />
Category<br />
Square Feet Monthly Tariff (Rs.) Square Feet Monthly Tariff (Rs.)<br />
1500-3000 100 1500-5000 600<br />
>3000 120 >5000 1000<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
To recover costs <strong>of</strong> operation, maintenance and debt servicing, the municipality decided the tariff<br />
structure through a consultative process. The tariff included a one-time deposit and a monthly tariff.<br />
They are given in Table 2. On demand from the citizens, the municipality has subsequently reduced<br />
monthly charges from Rs. 150 to Rs. 110.<br />
Impact<br />
Of the 23,000 households who paid for the services, 8,350 households were connected in the first<br />
phase, i.e. by 2005. Nearly 500 slum households out <strong>of</strong> 7,000 had sewerage connections, and 43% <strong>of</strong><br />
slum dwellers have opted for and paid for individual sewerage connections. In 2005, 14 community<br />
toilets were constructed to serve poor clusters. By the end <strong>of</strong> March 2008, all households had received<br />
sewerage connections.<br />
Sustainability<br />
The project is sustainable, as the cost towards maintaining the system is recovered from the users by<br />
means <strong>of</strong> monthly charges. There has been a regular flow <strong>of</strong> funds and timely repayment to financial<br />
institutions. Alandur sewerage project is an innovative initiative for sustainable delivery <strong>of</strong> urban<br />
services in the country. Inspired by the Alandur example, many urban local bodies, including Trichy,<br />
Tanjavur, Tirunelveli, and Ambattur, have initiated similar efforts for underground sewerage system. The<br />
Alandur experience demonstrates that mobilising people’s participation for infrastructure projects is<br />
possible through effective leadership, collective efforts and transparent procedures. Political will,<br />
effective communications, transparency and partnership with community-based organisations, are the<br />
key factors for the success <strong>of</strong> the project. Inter-departmental coordination and active involvement <strong>of</strong> all<br />
stakeholders ensured successful completion and sustenance <strong>of</strong> the project.<br />
http://www.waterawards.in/2008-winner-pr<strong>of</strong>ile-am.php<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 216
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
Kalyani Municipality-Community-Led Health Initiatives with Community Led Total Sanitation (CLTS) As<br />
The Entry Point<br />
Kalyani Municipality’s CLTS empowers local communities with the goal <strong>of</strong> creating an open, defecation-<br />
free environment, especially in slums, through a participatory approach <strong>of</strong> self-mobilization and<br />
facilitation. This brings about behavioural change to ensure 100% sustained usage <strong>of</strong> sanitary toilets,<br />
thereby making Kalyani an Open Defecation Free (ODF) area.<br />
Context<br />
Kalyani, located 65 km north <strong>of</strong> Kolkata in West Bengal, is one <strong>of</strong> the 39 municipalities under Kolkata<br />
Metropolitan Area (KMA) with a population <strong>of</strong> 0.1 million, <strong>of</strong> which approximately 50% lives in 52 slums.<br />
These people have mainly migrated from neighboring Bangladesh. Over the past ten years, more than<br />
Rs. 3 crore has been spent on different projects for constructing toilets for the urban poor, improving<br />
the sanitation pr<strong>of</strong>ile <strong>of</strong> Kalyani. Despite a lot <strong>of</strong> investment from different projects, Kalyani was not<br />
open-defecation free (ODF), as this was a common practice even amongst those given toilets free-<strong>of</strong>-<br />
cost by donor agencies. This led to a lot <strong>of</strong> health problems amongst other citizens as well.<br />
Initiative<br />
Against the above background, CLTS was conceived in late 2005 under the Kolkata <strong>Urban</strong> Services for<br />
The Poor Programme (KUSP), funded by the Department For International <strong>Development</strong> (DFID). The<br />
chairperson <strong>of</strong> Kalyani Municipality showed political will and leadership in motivating its councilors and<br />
making Kalyani an ODF town. The Board <strong>of</strong> Councilors (BoC) unanimously accepted the proposal to pilot<br />
the CLTS project in Kalyani Municipal Area in January 2006. The chief health functionary <strong>of</strong> the ULB<br />
coordinated and facilitated the implementation <strong>of</strong> the entire programme.<br />
Initially, the pilot project was implemented in five slums only. However, inspired by the success <strong>of</strong> the<br />
project, Kalyani decided to make all the 52 slums ODF. A team <strong>of</strong> experts, including a Participatory<br />
<strong>Development</strong> Consultant and medical doctors, were involved in the initiative that conducted a series <strong>of</strong><br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 217
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
awareness-creation workshops. Regular interaction with slum dwellers, nurturing <strong>of</strong> community leaders,<br />
and continuous monitoring by the CLTS team, made it possible to make all the slums ODF. Strategies<br />
adopted include not providing further subsidy for toilet construction, providing technical support to<br />
slum dwellers on low-cost sanitary toilets, increasing awareness regarding the ill-effects <strong>of</strong> open<br />
defecation, motivating and mobilising communities through participatory methods, using PRA tools and<br />
incentives for community leaders, and awards for clean ward/slum/area/school/class etc.<br />
Key Features<br />
The CLTS programme is community-led and not dependent on external support. It results in sustained<br />
behavior change and builds self-respect, dignity and self-confidence, especially in women. People are<br />
encouraged to build toilets with their own resources, creating ownership and sustained usage. Unlike<br />
free toilets, which are poorly maintained and even abandoned, people are interested in maintaining<br />
these. Proper triggering, facilitation, interaction, motivation and incentives are necessary initially. There<br />
is great potential for replication. Once people realize the need for a behavioral change to maintain<br />
sanitation, and its direct bearing on health, they do it willingly. The CLTS programme methodology<br />
makes people realize the need.<br />
Impact<br />
Kalyani was declared open-defecation free by the state <strong>of</strong> West Bengal on 29 Jan 2009. It got a cash<br />
prize <strong>of</strong> Rs. 25 lakhs to expand and continue its health programme on "Correction Of Anaemia" which is<br />
directly related to open defecation. As a first ODF town in India, Kalyani is much cleaner. Its slums have<br />
benefited not only from sanitation, but also from other developmental works. This is because ODF slums<br />
are given priority for all ULB development works. There is the visible impact <strong>of</strong> the urban poor<br />
recognizing that health is linked to sanitation. Records <strong>of</strong> the health department show a considerable<br />
decrease in gastro-intestinal disorders, and an increased number <strong>of</strong> man-days. Demand has been<br />
generated for more pay-and-use public toilets in Kalyani.<br />
http://www.waterawards.in/2009-winner-pr<strong>of</strong>ile-km.php<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 218
REFERENCES<br />
APPENDIX<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 219
ANNEXURES<br />
<strong>CITY</strong> <strong>SANITATION</strong> <strong>PLAN</strong> BAREILLY<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE STAFF COLLEGE OF INDIA, HYDERABAD Page 220