14.06.2013 Views

LAST DITCH OF DEMOCRACY - Majority Rights

LAST DITCH OF DEMOCRACY - Majority Rights

LAST DITCH OF DEMOCRACY - Majority Rights

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

the manuscript so as to show what we really do know and can know,<br />

about one of the finest poets that ever lived, sortin’ out what is<br />

ascertainable from what is not ascertainable. How the stuff was first<br />

written down. No autograph stuff, but the earliest copies, and then the<br />

later manuscript editings: some of ’em under the general supervision, or<br />

stimulus, of Lord Medici.<br />

All this may seem very specialized. However I found it of interest, and<br />

were it not for this tiresome war I should be writin’ to Mr. Bird, now<br />

probably Doctor O. Bird, as he was adoin’ his thesis on the above<br />

mentioned comment by del Garbo’s (no relation of Greta’s), to point out<br />

that whatever I said about Guido’s genial thought, his probably having<br />

read some Avicenna, and the general ideas entertained by the better<br />

minds of his time on the subject of LIGHT. That needed some attention<br />

to terminology. I should now want to add to what I printed, and to<br />

correlate it with Aristotle’s Metaphysics, I mean Aristotle’s particular<br />

treaties [treatise] called “Metaphysics,” and that Guido Cavalcanti might<br />

have taken his terminology from it, almost entirely.<br />

del Garbo refers to Aristotle and to the treatise. So mebbe Bird has done<br />

so in any case. But the matter is interesting at least to a small number of<br />

people who think that precise terminology matters; and that that poem<br />

and comment give one a very nice chance for ascertainin’, gettin’ your<br />

idea clearer and more precise, as to the likenesses and differences<br />

between 18th century thought and our own. Have we got better at<br />

thinkin’? Do we think with greater clarity? Or has the so-called program<br />

of science merely got us all cluttered up mentally and pitched us into<br />

greater confusion?<br />

No, the comment on a medieval poem don’t just stop there, any more<br />

than Frobenius’ research just STOPS with some bit of African sculpture,<br />

or with some prehistorical drawin’ on the side of a rock. Grosseteste<br />

writin’ on light, hooks up with the ideogram of the sun and moon at the<br />

start of Confucius’ testament. Incidentally, if medieval bishops in

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!