Click Here - Gujarat Pollution Control Board
Click Here - Gujarat Pollution Control Board Click Here - Gujarat Pollution Control Board
The written comments_if received,by the regulatory authority in response to the public Notice and clarification submitted by project pioponent. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. Represententation from Faryavaran Mitra. l"plY from Project groponent with respect to representative of p[ry avaranMitra. Reply for letter received from "paryavtaranMitra" regarding Lodation site oi Public Hearing. Reply for letter receivrcd &om " Kharapasvariya gram panchayatl,, Representation from "Anjar vidhansabha yuva cottgt"s samitis" Representation from "Anjar Taluka Congress Samiti.', ..* J7
At.r *gxrt-o} 3. ?L ?g PARYAVARAN fu!ilTRA {JA51'3StA$} 5St, Raj Avenue, 8l'raikaka Nagar R*ad, frlr" T**it*j Sross Rcad, Thaliej, Ahrnedab*d - 3** *5S Telefax - t0791 ?68${3et " Phsne: {Sf9} *S8${8*1 Email : paqraya.anmitraSahoo.ce** t$if*bsite: ilttp:ltrperyavaranmitra.crg.in Ref: #PM/Itr/6aolzoro To Shri M. Thennarasan Collector and Chairman EPH Committee, Collectorofrce, Kutch Date r5$eptember aoro Snb. I Elrvir.onmental Pubhc Hearing o,fWelsprm Power & Steel IJd at Ar$ar, Kutch 0rr ry.og.eolo Sir, We have revieh'ed EIA r€port of above mentoned projecl Following are onr commea&lsrggetions/obserratioas reprding project and EIA rcport. vt, When was Envimnmenbl Clearane applied for propoeed production and what is date of Terms of Referenm isstld? , 2. Why letter for Terms of referenae is not included in the EIA Report? Please attach a copy of the Terms of Reference issued- , 3- Why are there two options in Table r.r about proposed power plant? ,V. --5. lvhat was the pro6 of acquiring 8g acre land at the time of installation of first ptant? Why tlie additional land was aquired to the extent before initiating the plant? 6. Why coaylignite bad captive power plant has been selectd ufren project proponent is weighing on sustaiuable development? Whether alternative fuel has been thought at planniag stage? Please give d€tails. T. Please give the emct debils on water onsumption of current plant and pmposd g. Pleas give the dehiled water balance diagran with rmter utilization in eac,h application and irc dispomt. g- Sardar Samvar Narmada Nigam policy mentions tbat first priority \A'iIl be given for drinking water, wnd frr irrigatioa- the ftesh water requirement for ths project is z84e K[,D while permission o{11 egl4l&waterlg-Sv_e_q !yGUIL How can GWIL sive Bgrmissior to &t+ ie+znowaF$iffirialura6 z8+zKlDwaterforindustrialwaterfromNarmadaCaffi.rf e8+z KlDwaFF6ausuialwaterEomffida @'($we'^..,nf As Peu \$-werat"n't- Potrt$. rot'i9 10. ?age no.33 of EIA report shona Wind mse diagmm of Sural It dearly shorus that false data ' is pmvided in the EIA report D*+ EIA report doesnt mean that it can pwide misleading inforuation and c"n correct in Finat EIA reporl This EIA report should be rejected and fresh EPH shotrld be organise with fresh EIA Report with factual fact and fuures. rr. As the wind rose diagram in tbe SIA report (of Kutch based pmjeet) is of Surat, *re air quality monitoring and data for mmpling locatiors canno{ be the correct data. Do not say it is typographical nistake bmuse &e ensultant is ftom Sural It is se,rious offeae b misleadpublic. r2. Figure showing sampling locations on page no. g4 is not cleartyvisible and locations forAir, Grcund water, surfrce water, $oil and Noise cannot be identified from this figue.
- Page 1 and 2: GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD REG
- Page 8 and 9: Annexure-B1 A Statement showing iss
- Page 10 and 11: If company has 600 acre land & gree
- Page 12 and 13: Give the type & no of contractor. f
- Page 14 and 15: have increased Representation from
- Page 16 and 17: Shri Grunvant Vaghela, Additional l
- Page 18 and 19: iq-{ld frq{r }iidl tur,ierqi soo r
- Page 21 and 22: iq'flql]aer eL) grq{l gr{qr{t a{t}
- Page 23 and 24: t.t lrerq qqdl qlqlt q]W U3 qrs.rr-
- Page 25: 'to r1) ro) erq{qlqorltl ?,tu[{t ?d
- Page 29 and 30: ?p 3 '} {! d' F I I t II ! ) t \ T
- Page 31 and 32: O }S Af DO b 13 * fl.. .a s 3 a\ d
- Page 33 and 34: .Gc 1. Shri Hardik Shah, Member Sec
- Page 35 and 36: \/VELSPI,IN WETSPUN POWER AND STEEL
- Page 37 and 38: I \9VELSPIII\l hazardous waste is g
- Page 39 and 40: \'A/ELSPIII\I irrigation. The fresh
- Page 41 and 42: -w' B{N lQr lrnr \,VELSPIIN L9 Plea
- Page 43 and 44: 1. Name & Address of the Unit A ,.{
- Page 45 and 46: o€jyu. #-x' w 1. Name & Address o
- Page 47 and 48: 1. Name & Address of the Unit 2. Da
- Page 49 and 50: .-_ ffi \E7t -l n"6'-', Phone : 232
- Page 51 and 52: ,{ */ e O 3 !; \ n t: a ;, c :: {}
- Page 53 and 54: Welspun Power and Steel Limited, su
- Page 55 and 56: gas emission rate emission ffom the
- Page 57 and 58: finn*xwre- 5. The detail water cons
- Page 59 and 60: 10 - N ,t IT tot SAMPLIiIG LOCATIOI
- Page 61 and 62: I 6l
- Page 64 and 65: a L (, o o ! oooc ! er |! g| .E .9
- Page 66 and 67: E o o o o| c l( tt L tu r! ! o p gl
- Page 68 and 69: Annexure - 8 r Storage of Furnace O
- Page 70 and 71: Annexure - 9 : CREP guidelines for
- Page 72 and 73: Annexure - 10 : Environment clearan
- Page 74 and 75: 3.0 lror ote, Coal. Lignit€/Coal
At.r *gxrt-o}<br />
3. ?L<br />
?g<br />
PARYAVARAN fu!ilTRA<br />
{JA51'3StA$}<br />
5St, Raj Avenue, 8l'raikaka Nagar R*ad, frlr" T**it*j Sross Rcad, Thaliej, Ahrnedab*d - 3** *5S<br />
Telefax - t0791 ?68${3et " Phsne: {Sf9} *S8${8*1<br />
Email : paqraya.anmitraSahoo.ce** t$if*bsite: ilttp:ltrperyavaranmitra.crg.in<br />
Ref: #PM/Itr/6aolzoro<br />
To<br />
Shri M. Thennarasan<br />
Collector and Chairman EPH Committee,<br />
Collectorofrce,<br />
Kutch<br />
Date r5$eptember aoro<br />
Snb. I Elrvir.onmental Pubhc Hearing o,fWelsprm Power & Steel IJd at Ar$ar,<br />
Kutch 0rr ry.og.eolo<br />
Sir,<br />
We have revieh'ed EIA r€port of above mentoned projecl Following are onr<br />
commea&lsrggetions/obserratioas reprding project and EIA rcport.<br />
vt, When was Envimnmenbl Clearane applied for propoeed production and what is date of<br />
Terms of Referenm isstld?<br />
, 2. Why letter for Terms of referenae is not included in the EIA Report? Please attach a copy of<br />
the Terms of Reference issued-<br />
, 3- Why are there two options in Table r.r about proposed power plant?<br />
,V. --5. lvhat was the pro6 of acquiring 8g acre land at the time of installation of first ptant?<br />
Why tlie additional land was aquired to the extent before initiating the plant?<br />
6. Why coaylignite bad captive power plant has been selectd ufren project proponent is<br />
weighing on sustaiuable development? Whether alternative fuel has been thought at<br />
planniag stage? Please give d€tails.<br />
T. Please give the emct debils on water onsumption of current plant and pmposd<br />
g. Pleas give the dehiled water balance diagran with rmter utilization in eac,h application and<br />
irc dispomt.<br />
g- Sardar Samvar Narmada Nigam policy mentions tbat first priority \A'iIl be given for drinking<br />
water, wnd frr irrigatioa- the ftesh water requirement for ths project is z84e K[,D while<br />
permission o{11 egl4l&waterlg-Sv_e_q !yGUIL How can GWIL sive Bgrmissior to &t+<br />
ie+znowaF$iffirialura6<br />
z8+zKlDwaterforindustrialwaterfromNarmadaCaffi.rf e8+z KlDwaFF6ausuialwaterEomffida @'($we'^..,nf As Peu \$-werat"n't- Potrt$. rot'i9<br />
10. ?age no.33 of EIA report shona Wind mse diagmm of Sural It dearly shorus that false data '<br />
is pmvided in the EIA report D*+ EIA report doesnt mean that it can pwide misleading<br />
inforuation and c"n correct in Finat EIA reporl This EIA report should be rejected and<br />
fresh EPH shotrld be organise with fresh EIA Report with factual fact and fuures.<br />
rr. As the wind rose diagram in tbe SIA report (of Kutch based pmjeet) is of Surat, *re air<br />
quality monitoring and data for mmpling locatiors canno{ be the correct data. Do not say it<br />
is typographical nistake bmuse &e ensultant is ftom Sural It is se,rious offeae b<br />
misleadpublic.<br />
r2. Figure showing sampling locations on page no. g4 is not cleartyvisible and locations forAir,<br />
Grcund water, surfrce water, $oil and Noise cannot be identified from this figue.
Change language