the toxic truth - Greenpeace

the toxic truth - Greenpeace the toxic truth - Greenpeace

greenpeace.org
from greenpeace.org More from this publisher
01.06.2013 Views

the toxic truth The wasTe: issues and quesTions Despite official investigations conducted in Côte d’Ivoire and the Netherlands following the dumping of the waste, as well as criminal prosecutions in both countries, there remain a number of questions about the waste and its likely impacts on health and the environment, which have never been answered. As noted in Chapter 5, the lack of complete disclosure about the waste has left a legacy of uncertainty for many victims, who worry about long-term health effects. Trafigura has made claims about the likely health impacts, including stating that the waste could not have caused deaths or long-term health problems. However, since the company has never disclosed key information about the waste or Trafigura’s own assessment of the impacts, these claims cannot be verified. Laboratory of Marine Waste Collection Netherlands (MAIN), formerly called Amsterdam Port Services (APS). © Zeeman Reclame GRoep/eRwin VadeR The composition of the waste: what is known? Several agencies conducted tests on the waste material carried by the Probo Koala. The most in-depth information that is available about the composition of the waste comes from the testing undertaken by Netherlands Forensic Institute (NFI). 299 In addition, two Dutch waste processing companies, AVR 300 and ATM Moerdijk, 301 analyzed samples taken by Amsterdam Port Services (APS) when the Probo Koala was in Amsterdam in July 2006. Tests were also carried out by the Centre Ivoirien AntiPollution (CIAPOL), part of the Ivorian Ministry of Environment, on samples of the waste found on the quay in Abidjan, as well as waste from the dump site, Akouédo. The available evidence confirms that the waste was hazardous. 302 This was confirmed by the courts in Netherlands: in 2010/11 Trafigura was found guilty of the illegal export of waste from the Netherlands to Africa and for “concealing the harmful nature of the waste for life and health” when the company brought the waste to Amsterdam for processing. The court quoted a statement by the NFI expert: 69 Chapter 6

70 Amnesty internAtionAl And greenpeAce netherlAnds Chapter 6 “ It has been determined that the slops contain flammable, caustic/corrosive substances (naphtha and sodium hydroxide, respectively) and hazardous to (very) toxic substances, besides substances which can release harmful to extremely toxic substances under certain conditions (sulphides, mercaptides). In view of the fact (among others) that the slops contain flammable materials (naphtha), substances which can cause severe skin injuries (including sodium hydroxide), and substances which, when the pH is lowered, decompose into (extremely) toxic mercaptans and hydrogen sulphide, we believe that the conclusion that this waste is extremely hazardous is 303 justified. ” The chemical oxygen demand (COD) of the waste APS’s initial expectation was that it was dealing with a waste with a COD of less than 2,000mg/l. However, on testing the material they found a COD of almost 500,000mg/l (this is what BMA reported to Falcon Navigation). 304 The NFI tests, which as noted above, are considered the most thorough, found a COD of 720,000mg/l. COD is used as one measure of the levels of contamination of a waste or material with oxygen-depleting chemicals, normally degradable organic chemicals, based on the relative potential for a waste to deplete or even remove oxygen from water. It is this potential for depletion of oxygen and its knock-on effects that is the reason behind the concerns for very high COD. The flashpoint of the waste The flashpoint is a measure of the temperature at which the vapour from a material might combust if exposed to an ignition source. The lower the flashpoint the higher the content of volatile combustible material present (for example, chemicals generating combustible or flammable vapours). The flashpoint of the waste was less than 21ºC. 305 Under Sections 3 and 4 of the European Hazardous Substances List Regulation and Annex III of Directive 91/689/EEC on hazardous waste, waste substances with a flashpoint of less than 55ºC qualify as hazardous waste.

70 Amnesty internAtionAl And greenpeAce ne<strong>the</strong>rlAnds<br />

Chapter 6<br />

“ It has been determined that <strong>the</strong> slops contain flammable,<br />

caustic/corrosive substances (naphtha and sodium hydroxide,<br />

respectively) and hazardous to (very) <strong>toxic</strong> substances,<br />

besides substances which can release harmful to extremely<br />

<strong>toxic</strong> substances under certain conditions (sulphides,<br />

mercaptides). In view of <strong>the</strong> fact (among o<strong>the</strong>rs) that <strong>the</strong> slops<br />

contain flammable materials (naphtha), substances which can<br />

cause severe skin injuries (including sodium hydroxide), and<br />

substances which, when <strong>the</strong> pH is lowered, decompose into<br />

(extremely) <strong>toxic</strong> mercaptans and hydrogen sulphide, we believe<br />

that <strong>the</strong> conclusion that this waste is extremely hazardous is<br />

303<br />

justified. ”<br />

The chemical oxygen demand (COD) of <strong>the</strong> waste<br />

APS’s initial expectation was that it was dealing with a waste<br />

with a COD of less than 2,000mg/l. However, on testing <strong>the</strong><br />

material <strong>the</strong>y found a COD of almost 500,000mg/l (this is what<br />

BMA reported to Falcon Navigation). 304 The NFI tests, which as<br />

noted above, are considered <strong>the</strong> most thorough, found a COD<br />

of 720,000mg/l. COD is used as one measure of <strong>the</strong> levels<br />

of contamination of a waste or material with oxygen-depleting<br />

chemicals, normally degradable organic chemicals, based on<br />

<strong>the</strong> relative potential for a waste to deplete or even remove<br />

oxygen from water. It is this potential for depletion of oxygen<br />

and its knock-on effects that is <strong>the</strong> reason behind <strong>the</strong> concerns<br />

for very high COD.<br />

The flashpoint of <strong>the</strong> waste<br />

The flashpoint is a measure of <strong>the</strong> temperature at which <strong>the</strong><br />

vapour from a material might combust if exposed to an ignition<br />

source. The lower <strong>the</strong> flashpoint <strong>the</strong> higher <strong>the</strong> content of<br />

volatile combustible material present (for example, chemicals<br />

generating combustible or flammable vapours). The flashpoint<br />

of <strong>the</strong> waste was less than 21ºC. 305 Under Sections 3 and 4<br />

of <strong>the</strong> European Hazardous Substances List Regulation and<br />

Annex III of Directive 91/689/EEC on hazardous waste, waste<br />

substances with a flashpoint of less than 55ºC qualify as<br />

hazardous waste.

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!