A way out By Pawan Kumar Gupta

Volume I, Issue II 

LEAD LEAD ARTICLE 

ARTICLE 

Ailaan 

Ailaan 

NCRI Newsletter 

Questioning modern education: A way out 

By Pawan Kumar Gupta 

Violence at the individual level has always been there but violence perpetuated by the systems has 

surpassed all proportions in the last few centuries. The power of the modern systems rests with its 

remoteness and faceless nature. This is both frustrating for those few who try to understand and 

struggle to find a way out and mesmerising for the remaining. The irony is that the victim or the 

exploited has unknowingly become an accomplice in this game; and those who see the game, are 

often too self conscious to openly criticize it, unlike the Mahatma, as they find themselves 

enslaved by its trappings, in one way or the other. On the whole the modern systems encourage the 

violent and competitive tendencies existing in individuals. 

Human beings have invented categories, just like they have invented instruments and systems for 

convenience to achieve a certain specific purpose. But reality is not a construct. It is a given. To 

understand the reality, as it exists, we human beings need education and to facilitate the process, 

we invent categories and subjects. Categories and subjects are only a means to achieve a certain 

objective – to understand reality and then according to this understanding of reality, to establish 

meaningful relationships with various components in existence – the material world, the pranic 

world, the kingdom of birds and animals and the human beings. 

Reality exists. It IS. We can only try to understand and experience it, we can not create it. We use 

different means – subjects, categories, instruments – for this purpose. But we have an option. We 

can experience reality the way it IS or we can perceive reality as different from the way it IS. 

We have the freedom either to assume reality or to understand and experience it – the way it IS. 

Words and meanings are distinct. Words are only indicative of the meaning – the reality. The 

priority is of the meaning, which is beyond language. Meaning is the objective, words are only a 

means. Meanings exist whether we understand or not, while words are a construct to depict the 

meaning. Words are restricted in language, while meanings are beyond language. Meaning has a 

higher value than words. But modern education perpetuates the myth that words are meanings and 

are the same; that they are synonymous. If the distinction is not clear we get trapped by words (and 

the meaning that gets imposed on these words as different from the real). In that case under false 

assumption, we under-evaluate meaning and over-evaluate the word. 

Modernity is adept at creating similar confusion between reality and construct, between the 

objective and the means, between the real and the apparent. 

“No man is above the law and no man is below it.” 

~ Theodore Roosevelt 

Continued…… 

NCRI 27 February 2010


Ailaan 

Ailaan 


So modern categories have assumed or imposed meanings as different from the reality. Instead of 

using categories for our purpose we start getting used by the categories. This gives modernity the 

power over our minds, over our aspirations, desires and thus over our actions. 

The paradigm of Values is different from the paradigm of Price. Values are based on reality and 

are intrinsic, are nirapeksha, while the other is an imposition, based on comparison – sapeksha. 

Values are fixed, definitive and intrinsic and beyond time and space – they do not depend on the 

individual or societal preferences. For instance, the Value of clothing is its ability to provide 

protection to the body whether we prefer a particular kind of clothes or not. Price depends on 

external factors and is impacted among others, by both time and space. Modern education creates 

confusion between these two paradigms by equating the two thus over-evaluating the paradigm of 

price and under-evaluating the paradigm of value. Thus: 

∗ Words get equated with or even supersedes the meaning; 

∗ Understanding the other gets confused with Agreeing with the other; 

∗ Training gets equated and confused with Education; 

∗ Information with Knowledge; 

∗ Empirical knowledge/ traditional knowledge become Superstition; 

∗ Subjects and Categories take precedence over Objective/ Knowledge and Experience; 

∗ Means get confused with objective; 

∗ No distinction is made between Believing or Assuming without knowing and Knowing; 

∗ Perceiving gets equated with knowing; 

∗ Provisional with the Definitive; 

∗ Appearance (lagna) or Doing (karma) with Being (hona); 

∗ Arrogance with Self esteem; 

∗ Confidence based on comparison (sapeksha atma vishwas) with nirapeksha atma vishwas 

∗ Freedom (man marzi) with swatantrata (self organized); 

∗ Reasoning and Logic with Experiencing and Understanding; 

∗ Philosophy (a category) with Darshan (which is beyond category); 

∗ Different with Opposite; 


ARTICLE 

∗ “Development” with Real progress/ contentment; 

This is how modern myth is created – at one level it falsely equates higher value with a lower one 

by imposing the transient or provisional over the definitive and at other level it creates false 

categories and creates artificial oppositions. This starts in school when we teach “opposites”. 

Black vs white; Day vs Night but it does not stop there. 

“Authority without wisdom is like a heavy axe without an edge.” 

~ Ann Bradstreet 

Continued… 



Ailaan 

Ailaan 


It goes on.. Man vs woman. Boy vs Girl, East vs West and later on gets translated into Hindu vs 

Muslim, Developed vs undeveloped etc. etc.. Adjectives are another big problem if do not teach 

them with the awareness that they are relative, that they are subjective. 

The over emphasis of modern science - which has cast its influence on all disciplines of learning - 

on reasoning and has conditioned the mind to be only satisfied with an apparently reasonable 

sounding answer to the ‘why’ is another obstacle to seeing reality in its totality. Observation and 

experiencing a phenomena in its totality is not appreciated while a partial answer to ‘why’ satisfies 

people trained in modern education. We are conditioned to think we know when actually we are 

only believing. The over emphasis on ‘Why’ and ‘How’ has underplayed the importance of What. 

In the Society for Integrated Development of Himalayas (SIDH) we have tried to challenge some 

of these categories and assumptions of modern education. The emphasis is on ‘how to think’ rather 

than ‘what to think’. Rather than teaching what the Mahatma said we try to understand why he 

may have said what he said: 

why he never ever used the word ‘development’ in his writings or speeches without first 

qualifying it; we try and understand the assumptions behind the word “development”; 

what is the relationship between non-violence and courage to be, to be able to say no; to not be 

restricted by categories even of the man made law, if need be; 

what is the difference between opposing and non cooperation/ ignoring; 

what is the difference between sameness and equality; 

what is value; 

what is the difference between angreziat and angrezi; 

the difference between respect or trust and its demonstration; 

what are systems and how they (unknowingly) mould our thinking and actions; 

what are categories and how they may (unknowingly) influence us; 

what is the difference between getting influenced and getting inspired; 

how we can teach without textbooks by using the local – environmental and cultural – context; 

and lastly we try to refrain from using “should” in our schools. 

We feel it is extremely important today to challenge the myths and categories created by 

modernity through education. This is the only way out and to pave the path towards real freedom. 

Our experience is that it is possible to teach these things even to children. Once we are able to do 

this “Hind Swaraj” becomes easy to understand. 


ARTICLE 

Pawan Kumar Gupta, Director, Society for Integrated Development of Himalayas, Mussoorie. 

“Without feelings of respect, what is there to distinguish man from beasts?” 

~ Confucius

A way out By Pawan Kumar Gupta

Create successful ePaper yourself

Delete template?

Save as template?