31.05.2013 Views

jbgotmar

jbgotmar

jbgotmar

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

More oxford books @ www.OxfordeBook.com<br />

LOVE IS EXCEPTION MAKING 229<br />

Her critique had little to do with colonialism, fascism, imperialism,<br />

or the other evils leftists laid at the feet of the United States. Rather,<br />

she argued that the only justifi cation for war was national self-defense,<br />

and Vietnam did not meet this criterion. Although she was opposed to<br />

Communism, Rand did not buy the domino theory that guided policymakers,<br />

whereby any nation that became Communist was seen to<br />

potentially topple its neighbors in the same direction. In the fashion<br />

of the prewar right, Rand saw hostilities in Vietnam as unrelated to life<br />

in the United States. To her, the more potent threat lay at home, where<br />

statists and socialists disguised as liberals might destroy the freedoms of<br />

America.<br />

Rand saw the draft as a sure sign that freedom was already in grave<br />

danger. She was deeply opposed to the draft and its implications for<br />

society. “Of all the statist violations of individual rights . . . the military<br />

draft is the worst,” she told her audience. “It negates man’s fundamental<br />

right, the right to life, and establishes the fundamental principle of statism—that<br />

a man’s life belongs to the state, and the state may claim it by<br />

compelling him to sacrifi ce it in battle. Once that principle is accepted,<br />

the rest is only a matter of time.” 35 Rand coupled her attack on the statist<br />

draft with an impassioned defense of young lives wasted by the war. If<br />

potential inductees turned to drugs or “the beatnik cult” in response to<br />

state enslavement, who could blame them? She was incensed that none<br />

on the right had joined her offensive; instead, she observed incredulously,<br />

it was only “the extreme left” who had demanded repeal of the<br />

draft. Rand argued that opposition to the draft should be the province<br />

of conservatives, “the alleged defenders of freedom and capitalism.” 36<br />

Framed as a statist violation of rights, conscription fi t seamlessly into<br />

her larger opposition to coercion and the initiation of force.<br />

Before long, opposition to the draft became a key part of the Objectivist<br />

worldview, despite Rand’s active discouragement of draft resistance. She<br />

had little sympathy for those who publicly protested the draft, favorably<br />

quoting Persuasion, a magazine published by NBI students, “One<br />

does not stop the juggernaut by throwing oneself against it.” 37 Her position<br />

was nuanced, or some might say contradictory: against the draft,<br />

and against the war, and against the protestors too. Some of this was<br />

merely cultural. Raised in the high European tradition, Rand viscerally<br />

objected to the messiness of the bohemian student protestors. Their<br />

Fore more urdu books visit www.4Urdu.com

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!