31.05.2013 Views

jbgotmar

jbgotmar

jbgotmar

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

More oxford books @ www.OxfordeBook.com<br />

BIG SISTER IS WATCHING YOU 183<br />

therapy. As a condition of his therapy Rothbard was required to take the<br />

Principles of Objectivism course. He and his wife, Joey, began socializing<br />

on a regular basis with Rand and the Collective.<br />

Before long Rothbard tired of the Randian routine. He was annoyed<br />

when others questioned him after he skipped an occasional Objectivist<br />

gathering. He began to doubt Nathan’s effectiveness as a therapist, especially<br />

after Nathan criticized his marriage to Joey, a Christian. A union<br />

of two people who held confl icting premises was inherently unstable,<br />

Nathan lectured Rothbard. He should seek a partner who held rational<br />

premises instead. Still hoping that his travel phobia could be overcome,<br />

Rothbard stayed in therapy even as he wondered whether Nathan<br />

could really help him. Nathan promised the two of them would venture<br />

outside city limits together, but the trip never materialized. Meanwhile<br />

Rothbard signed up to deliver an academic paper in Georgia, believing<br />

he would be cured by the time of the conference.<br />

Instead, the academic conference became the grounds for a bitter<br />

fi nal breakup between Rothbard and the Rand circle. Tensions had<br />

been building over Rothbard’s stubborn allegiance to anarchism. After<br />

almost six months of regular contact Rand and the Collective expected<br />

Rothbard to be convinced that anarchism was unworkable. In July 1958<br />

a special Saturday night session was scheduled for Rothbard and Rand<br />

to debate. By then Rothbard had realized, “I hated the guts of [Nathan]<br />

and Ayn and the rest of the gang.” After a stormy appointment with<br />

Nathan he decided to terminate therapy and all relations with Rand’s<br />

group. The next day Nathan called to summon him to another meeting,<br />

this time with Rand alone. At issue was the paper Rothbard had written<br />

for his upcoming conference, which Nathan accused him of plagiarizing<br />

from both Rand and Barbara Branden. Outraged, Rothbard hung<br />

up the phone “on that tin Jesus.” 29 That evening’s mail brought a special<br />

delivery letter from Rand’s lawyer, outlining in detail the accusation<br />

of plagiarism and threatening a lawsuit against both Rothbard and the<br />

conference organizer, the German sociologist Helmut Schoeck.<br />

The confrontation soon spilled out into open warfare between the<br />

Collective and the Circle Bastiat. George Reisman and Robert Hessen,<br />

formerly Rothbard loyalists, took Rand’s side in the plagiarism dispute.<br />

After a tense showdown Rothbard kicked Reisman out of his apartment.<br />

Angry phone calls fl ew back and forth between Rand, Nathan,<br />

Fore more urdu books visit www.4Urdu.com

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!