Carl%20Sagan%20-%20The%20Demon%20Haunted%20World

Carl%20Sagan%20-%20The%20Demon%20Haunted%20World Carl%20Sagan%20-%20The%20Demon%20Haunted%20World

giancarlo3000
from giancarlo3000 More from this publisher
04.10.2012 Views

THE DEMON-HAUNTED WORLD prayer works, why can't God cure cancer or grow back a severed limb? Why so much avoidable suffering that God could so readily prevent? Why does God have to be prayed to at all? Doesn't He already know what cures need to be performed? Dossey also begins with a quote from Stanley Krippner, MD (described as 'one of the most authoritative investigators of the variety of unorthodox healing methods used around the world'): [T]he research data on distant, prayer-based healing are promising, but too sparse to allow any firm conclusion to be drawn. This after many trillions of prayers over the millennia. As Cabeza de Vaca's experience suggests, the mind can cause certain diseases, even fatal diseases. When blindfolded patients are deceived into believing they're being touched by a leaf such as poison ivy or poison oak, they produce an ugly red contact dermatitis. What faith-healing characteristically may help are mind-mediated or placebo diseases: some back and knee pains, headaches, stuttering, ulcers, stress, hay fever, asthma, hysterical paralysis and blindness, and false pregnancy (with cessation of menstrual periods and abdominal swelling). These are all diseases in which the state of mind may play a key role. In the late medieval cures associated with apparitions of the Virgin Mary, most were of sudden, short-lived, whole-body or partial paralyses that are plausibly psychogenic. It was widely held, moreover, that only devout believers could be so cured. It's no surprise that appeals to a state of mind called faith can relieve symptoms caused, at least in part, by another, perhaps not very different state of mind. But there's something more: the Harvest Moon Festival is an important holiday in traditional Chinese communities in America. In the week preceding the festival, the death rate in the community is found to fall by 35 per cent. In the following week the death rate jumps by 35 per cent. Control groups of non-Chinese show no such effect. You might think that suicides are responsible, but only deaths from natural causes are counted. You might think that stress or overeating might account for it, but this could hardly 222

Obsessed with Reality explain the fall in death rate before the harvest moon. The largest effect is for people with cardiovascular disease, which is known to be influenced by stress. Cancer showed a smaller effect. On more detailed study, it turned out that the fluctuations in death rate occurred exclusively among women 75 years old or older. The Harvest Moon Festival is presided over by the oldest women in the households. They were able to stave off death for a week or two to perform their ceremonial responsibilities. A similar effect is found among Jewish men in the weeks centred on Passover - a ceremony in which older men play a leading role - and likewise, worldwide for birthdays, graduation ceremonies and the like. In a more controversial study, Stanford University psychiatrists divided eighty-six women with metastatic breast cancer into two groups - one in which they were encouraged to examine their fears of dying and to take charge of their lives, and the other given no special psychiatric support. To the surprise of the researchers, not only did the support group experience less pain, but they also lived, on average, eighteen months longer. The leader of the Stanford study, David Spiegel, speculates that the cause may be Cortisol and other 'stress hormones' which impair the body's protective immune system. Severely depressed people, students during exam periods, and the bereaved all have reduced white blood cell counts. Good emotional support may not have much effect on advanced forms of cancer, but it may work to reduce the chances of secondary infections in a person already much weakened by the disease or its treatment. In his nearly forgotten 1903 book, Christian Science, Mark Twain wrote The power which a man's imagination has over his body to heal it or make it sick is a force which none of us is born without. The first man had it, the last one will possess it. Occasionally, some of the pain and anxiety or other symptoms of more serious diseases can be relieved by faith-healers - however, without arresting the progress of the disease. But this is no small benefit. Faith and prayer may be able to relieve some symptoms of disease and their treatment, ease the suffering of the afflicted 223

Obsessed with Reality<br />

explain the fall in death rate before the harvest moon. The largest<br />

effect is for people with cardiovascular disease, which is known to<br />

be influenced by stress. Cancer showed a smaller effect. On more<br />

detailed study, it turned out that the fluctuations in death rate<br />

occurred exclusively among women 75 years old or older. The<br />

Harvest Moon Festival is presided over by the oldest women in<br />

the households. They were able to stave off death for a week or<br />

two to perform their ceremonial responsibilities. A similar effect<br />

is found among Jewish men in the weeks centred on Passover - a<br />

ceremony in which older men play a leading role - and likewise,<br />

worldwide for birthdays, graduation ceremonies and the like.<br />

In a more controversial study, Stanford University psychiatrists<br />

divided eighty-six women with metastatic breast cancer into two<br />

groups - one in which they were encouraged to examine their<br />

fears of dying and to take charge of their lives, and the other given<br />

no special psychiatric support. To the surprise of the researchers,<br />

not only did the support group experience less pain, but they also<br />

lived, on average, eighteen months longer.<br />

The leader of the Stanford study, David Spiegel, speculates that<br />

the cause may be Cortisol and other 'stress hormones' which<br />

impair the body's protective immune system. Severely depressed<br />

people, students during exam periods, and the bereaved all have<br />

reduced white blood cell counts. Good emotional support may not<br />

have much effect on advanced forms of cancer, but it may work to<br />

reduce the chances of secondary infections in a person already<br />

much weakened by the disease or its treatment.<br />

In his nearly forgotten 1903 book, Christian Science, Mark<br />

Twain wrote<br />

The power which a man's imagination has over his body to<br />

heal it or make it sick is a force which none of us is born<br />

without. The first man had it, the last one will possess it.<br />

Occasionally, some of the pain and anxiety or other symptoms of<br />

more serious diseases can be relieved by faith-healers - however,<br />

without arresting the progress of the disease. But this is no small<br />

benefit. Faith and prayer may be able to relieve some symptoms<br />

of disease and their treatment, ease the suffering of the afflicted<br />

223

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!