13.05.2013 Views

View/Open - UZSpace Home

View/Open - UZSpace Home

View/Open - UZSpace Home

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

"object" or "target" ofthis search. Logotherapists look for some "symbolicpast ex­<br />

perience that is meaningful", while psychoanalysts look for symptoms and/or pro­<br />

blems that were deeplyrooted in early childhoodexperiences, motivatedby uncons­<br />

cious factors (Hjelle & Ziegler 1992:120).<br />

Froma psychodynamic point ofview, especiallyfrom an objectrelational view point,<br />

the purpose ofgaining insight about internalrepresentations ofsignificant others and<br />

developmental changesin the patient's/client's way ofviewinginterpersonalrela­<br />

tions, is lacking. There is "insight" in the sense that the patient/clientdiscovers that<br />

there is meaning to be found in an experiencedsymbol,but there is no particular in­<br />

sight in the important role oftransferenceand counter-transference issues that are<br />

centralfor object relationspersonologists (Kernberg 1976 & 1986).<br />

From an ego psychological point ofview (Hartmann 1939), logotherapists do no take<br />

the conflict-resolving functions ofthe ego thoroughly enough into account in the<br />

healingprocess. The logotherapeutic aim or purpose is rather simple. Just find an<br />

experienced symboland elevate the patient/clientto a cognitive level where he/she<br />

will discoverthat there is something meaningful in the past symbolicexperience that<br />

can assist hiin/herto transcend to a new better present and future lifellifestyle. Ego<br />

psychologists would argue thathumanbeings are far more too complexto simply ef­<br />

fect real changein the life ofa patient/clientby simply discovering"past meaningful<br />

experiential symbols."<br />

Interpersonal personologists like Harry Stack Sullivan (1953) would also criticize the<br />

way this logotherapeutic technique operates because "symbolic meaningful experien­<br />

ces" cannot be separated from social phenomenathat are very often, for example,<br />

rooted in parent-childrelationships(Kendall & Hammen 1995:71). Althoughlogo-<br />

79

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!