Untitled
Untitled Untitled
248 • • Julian after several male and female donors. Saller and Bagatti (1949: 169, 177, inscription no. 8) considered this to indicate Julian as the maker of the mosaic. A small part of an inscription in a rect- angular panel in front of the apse at the church of St. Kyriakos at al-Quwaysmah (6th century) mentions the work by [… Σ] ιλανού ψη(φοθέτου) ‘Silanus the mosacist’ (Donderer 1989: 77-78, A36; Piccirillo 1993: 268, fig. 493). A small inscription in a panel in the south- west corner of the inhabited vine scroll field in Anastasius chapel at Khirbat al-Samra states: Άναστασίου ∆ομεντιανο ΰ ψεφωθέ του ‘[Work] of Anastasius [son] of Domintianus, the mosaicist’ (Donderer 1989: 54, A3; Piccirillo 1993: 308, Fig.609, 612). Several inscriptions note the work of three artists or more: • A two-line inscription located near the entrance to the chapel in the Diakonikon- Baptistry of the Memorial of Moses at Siyagha on Mt. Nebo commemorates three mosaicists. A prayer is added: …Κ(ύρι)ε, μνήσθητι Σοέλου κ(αί) Καιουμοΰ κ(αί) Ήλίου ψηφοΰητων κ(αί) παντός τοΰ οίκου αύτών ‘Lord Jesus Christ, remember the clerics and the monks and [all the] others who [rest] here [in peace]. God remember the mosaicists Soelos, Kaioumas and Elias and all their household’ (Piccirillo 1988: 155-157; 1993: 146, fig. 183; Donderer 1989: 78, A37; Dunbabin 1999: 273). • An inscription in a circular medallion near the chancel screen in St. George’s church at Mukkayyat records three mosaicists: Έργον ψηφωτήτων Ναουμα κ(αί) Κυριακός κ(αί) Θωμάς… ‘Work of the mosaicists Nauma and Kyriakos and Thomas, for the repose of Sabinus, the brother of Martyrius’ (Saller and Bagatti 1949: 168, no. 5, pl. 32; Donderer 1989: 70, A27; Piccirillo 1993: 178, fig. 248). Saller and Bagatti maintain that these named mosaicists were the makers as well as the designers of the mosaic pavement. • Two inscriptions in St. Stephen’s church at Umm al-Rasas commemorate the mosaicists, with an added prayer: a. An inscription found around the al tar in the presbyterium sanctuary refers chapter twelve to Μνήσθιτη κέ τοΰ δούλου σου Στυρακήου τοΰ ψιφωθέτοΰ Έξβοντίνου [υ]ίοΰ τοΰ Ζαδας Εύρεμήου έτέρου αύτοΰ ‘the two mosaicists (and others) Staurkaios of Esbous, son of Za da, and Euremius his colleague’ (Pic cirillo 1989: 285-6; 1993: 238, fig. 346; Donderer 1989: 79, A38; Dun babin 1999: 273). b. An inscription in the mosaic of the nave dated to 785 mentions anonymous mosacists: ‘Lord, remember thy servents the mosacists whose names thou knowest’ (Piccirillo 1989: 289; 1993: 238, fig. 384). This is comparable to the Aramaic inscription in Beth She"an small synagogue that mentions the work of anonymous artists (fig. XII-2a, see above). Dunbabin (1999: 273) suggests that in this formula, as in those on donors’ inscriptions, sometimes ‘the names could be suppressed in aspiration for a heavenly reward’. Few mosaicists were signing their names on mosaic pavements, the earliest inscription identifing a mosaicist appears on the mosaic pavement of the ‘Evron church in 415, and the practice continued until the 8th century. Most of the inscriptions found on synagoge pavements mention craftsmen with Jewish names, which implies that Jewish artists were employed in building synagogues and laying mosaic pavements, while Christian artists usually laid mosaic floors in churches. Yet a number of synagogue and church mosaics might have been paved by the same artists, team of mosaicists, or workshop (see below). The craft was apparently an inherited skill, traditionally a family occupation, as attested to by the inscriptions. Two generations of a family, Marianos and his son, together made the mosaic pavement of Beth ‘Alpha (inscription no. 1) which is unique in style and execution; and also the pavement in one room of Beth Shean synagogue A (room 7, inscription no. 2); possibly the same three-generation family is recorded at Kefar Kana and Sepphoris mosaic inscriptions. Dunbabin (1999: 275) maintains that the mosaicists’ names noted in church inscriptions are similar to names of bishops, priests, and benefactors cited on other inscriptions in the region; they are a mixture of traditional Aramaic, Greek, and especially Christian names, which suggests a
characteristically mixed origin of the society and that they too were apparently local craftsmen. The small numbers of craftsmen’s inscriptions intimates that only a few artists signed their work. Even more significant is the absence of craftsmen who signed more than one pavement, except for Beth "Alpha and Beth She"an, as noted earlier. This fact might serve as evidence of a single work by the artists, or that signing pavements was not a customary practice. Terms Used in the Inscriptions for Mosaicist or Artist It is notable that different words or terms for the mosaicist or artist are used in synagogues and church inscriptions: The terms used in synagogue inscriptions are הנמוא omna and ןמא oman, in Aramaic and Hebrew respectively, and τεχνίτ[αι] in Greek. In Talmudic literature the Aramaic term הנמוא omna means artisan or skilled builder (M. Berachot II, 4; JT. Hag. II, 1, 77b, line 15). The Greek term used at Beth ‘Alpha is τεχνίτ [αι] (‘occupied in skilled labour’ = artists) (Sukenik 1932: 47). Hestrin (1960: 66) proposes that these artisans or artists might have been responsible for the mosaic, but also for the building, for two reasons: first, the same term appears in Syria carved on lintels and tomb walls, and is used there for both artisan and builder; second, the only ornaments are inside, on the mosaic floors, which were thus the only places for inscriptions. In sum, the Aramaic, Hebrew, and Greek terms can be explained as meaning artisan, craftsman, or builder. This is also attested by Butler (1929: 254): ‘there was no great difference in the function of designer and builder. One must assume that in most cases the architect was also the builder or contractor and may have been himself an artisan as well’. The Greek derivatives of the term psifothetai: ψεφωθέ, ψεφωτήτων, ψιφωθέτο, ψηφωθήτων, and ψηφοθέτης, appear on several mosaic inscriptions and mean ‘mosaicist’, comparable to the Latin tessellarius and tessellare, musseotes or mussiator (Donderer 1989: 20-21, nos. A3, A27, A35, A37, A38; Piccirillo 1993: 47). Tzaferis (1987: 49*) claims that the term ψηφοθέτου refers to the one who ‘laid the tesserae after the foundation and tracing were finished by other professionals’. The Greek Èργον ‘work of’ or ‘made by’ appears on several inscriptions in reference to the work of the mosaicist (Donderer 1989: 16, 34, mosaicists, workshops, and the repertory 249 168; nos. A1, A25, A27). For the use of this word see particularly the Beth "Alpha inscription, which describes clearly the work done by two mosacists/ artists. Another term, Χιροθεσία ‘handwork’, is inscribed for the same two artists in side room 7 in Beth She"an synagogue A. B. Identifying Mosaicists and Artists Mosaicists and workshops might be identified by analysis of stylistic and technical idiosyncrasy of the mosaic, as well as by examination of the motifs and patterns. Identity could be determined by theme preference, resemblance of ornamentation details, similarity of techniques used, and stylistic and typical features. Dauphin (1987: 189) claims that the geographical distribution is significant in defining workshops, for instance, the various designs of the inhabited scrolls, although none of the designs constitutes a chronological criterion. Similarity in themes, scenes, and designs might also be related to fashion, trend, or an inherited preference. These similarities notwithstanding, mosaicists and craftsmen may be identified through their consistent use of the same stylistic features and characteristics, and by the technical details. Some craftsmen have distinctive technical habits, which distinguish their work. Examples of identical themes executed by different artists are the designs of the zodiac scheme and Torah shrine panels on mosaic pavements of the synagogues at Hammath Tiberias, Beth ‘Alpha and Sepphoris, which are dated to different periods. A number of pavements are considered and described as especially interesting by their style, design details, and content: The Artists of the Hammath Tiberias Synagogue Pavements The synagogue mosaic of the Hammath Tiberias synagogue (stratum IIa) dates to the last decades of the 3rd or the first quarter of 4th century. It was destroyed in the 5th century either by official order or by an earthquake (Dothan 1981: 68; 1983: 52, 67). Dunbabin (1999: 189, note 6) proposes a later date for the mosaics of this stratum, between the late 4th and early 5th century. This is based on the geometric mosaics with the rainbowstyle, looped patterns, and the semis of rosebuds ornaments which are more characteristic of the
- Page 291 and 292: V.5 City representations: a. Beth L
- Page 293 and 294: V.7 The sail boat: a. Beth Leontis,
- Page 295 and 296: VI.1 Gaza synagogue pavement.
- Page 297 and 298: VI.3 Jerusalem ‘Armenian’ churc
- Page 299 and 300: VI.6-8 Petra Church: North Aisle mo
- Page 301 and 302: VI.8
- Page 303 and 304: VI.10 The church of the Deacon Thom
- Page 305 and 306: VI.12 Amphorae depicted on inhabite
- Page 307 and 308: VI.14 Bird of prey on inhabited vin
- Page 309 and 310: VI.16 Baskets on inhabited vine scr
- Page 311 and 312: VI.18 Vine leaves and bunches of gr
- Page 313 and 314: VI.20 Subdued animals: a. Be’er S
- Page 315 and 316: VII.2 Transporting grapes: a. El Ha
- Page 317 and 318: VII.4 Flute player: a. Beth She’a
- Page 319 and 320: VII.6 Snake and mongoose confrontat
- Page 321 and 322: VII.8 Dog chasing hare/rabbit on ch
- Page 323 and 324: Inhabited Vine Scrolls Pavements A
- Page 325 and 326: similar in the general depiction of
- Page 327 and 328: etween synagogue and church 233 Fig
- Page 329 and 330: part are evidently connected: almos
- Page 331 and 332: etween synagogue and church 237 Fig
- Page 333 and 334: Mukhayyat (Bagatti 1949: 99, pl. 29
- Page 335 and 336: time. They might have contained gen
- Page 337 and 338: Artists, workshops and schools of m
- Page 339 and 340: • The same artisans are mentioned
- Page 341: 1933: 146, No. 23, 8; 1934: 73 =198
- Page 345 and 346: The Sepphoris Mosaicists The Seppho
- Page 347 and 348: on horseback spearing a leopard wit
- Page 349 and 350: Odysseus fighting the monster Scyll
- Page 351 and 352: Figure XII-6. Hall A mosaic, Monast
- Page 353 and 354: mosaicists, workshops, and the repe
- Page 355 and 356: Dating The Monastery was dated by i
- Page 357 and 358: mosaicists, workshops, and the repe
- Page 359 and 360: connections with Egypt, and perhaps
- Page 361 and 362: mosaicists, workshops, and the repe
- Page 363 and 364: different themes based on comparabl
- Page 365 and 366: esults were mosaics in the old Diak
- Page 367 and 368: Jews toartists and craftsmen. Among
- Page 369 and 370: epeated use was supplemented by fre
- Page 371 and 372: mosaicists, workshops, and the repe
- Page 373 and 374: of designs from general pattern boo
- Page 375 and 376: concluding remarks, comments, and o
- Page 377 and 378: concluding remarks, comments, and o
- Page 379 and 380: concluding remarks, comments, and o
- Page 381 and 382: concluding remarks, comments, and o
- Page 383 and 384: list of sites 289 LIST OF SITES Sit
- Page 385 and 386: Site Date Centuries CE Jordan (Arab
- Page 387 and 388: VII.10 Jabaliyah Diakonikon mosaic
- Page 389 and 390: VII.12 Hunter/soldier on foot with
- Page 391 and 392: VII.14 Feline with cub: a. Gaza syn
248<br />
•<br />
•<br />
Julian after several male and female donors.<br />
Saller and Bagatti (1949: 169, 177, inscription<br />
no. 8) considered this to indicate Julian<br />
as the maker of the mosaic.<br />
A small part of an inscription in a rect-<br />
angular panel in front of the apse at the<br />
church of St. Kyriakos at al-Quwaysmah<br />
(6th century) mentions the work by [… Σ]<br />
ιλανού ψη(φοθέτου) ‘Silanus the mosacist’<br />
(Donderer 1989: 77-78, A36; Piccirillo<br />
1993: 268, fig. 493).<br />
A small inscription in a panel in the south-<br />
west corner of the inhabited vine scroll field<br />
in Anastasius chapel at Khirbat al-Samra<br />
states: Άναστασίου ∆ομεντιανο ΰ ψεφωθέ<br />
του ‘[Work] of Anastasius [son] of Domintianus,<br />
the mosaicist’ (Donderer 1989: 54,<br />
A3; Piccirillo 1993: 308, Fig.609, 612).<br />
Several inscriptions note the work of three artists<br />
or more:<br />
• A two-line inscription located near the<br />
entrance to the chapel in the Diakonikon-<br />
Baptistry of the Memorial of Moses at<br />
Siyagha on Mt. Nebo commemorates three<br />
mosaicists. A prayer is added: …Κ(ύρι)ε,<br />
μνήσθητι Σοέλου κ(αί) Καιουμοΰ κ(αί)<br />
Ήλίου ψηφοΰητων κ(αί) παντός τοΰ οίκου<br />
αύτών ‘Lord Jesus Christ, remember the<br />
clerics and the monks and [all the] others<br />
who [rest] here [in peace]. God remember<br />
the mosaicists Soelos, Kaioumas and Elias<br />
and all their household’ (Piccirillo 1988:<br />
155-157; 1993: 146, fig. 183; Donderer<br />
1989: 78, A37; Dunbabin 1999: 273).<br />
• An inscription in a circular medallion near<br />
the chancel screen in St. George’s church at<br />
Mukkayyat records three mosaicists: Έργον<br />
ψηφωτήτων Ναουμα κ(αί) Κυριακός κ(αί)<br />
Θωμάς… ‘Work of the mosaicists Nauma<br />
and Kyriakos and Thomas, for the repose<br />
of Sabinus, the brother of Martyrius’ (Saller<br />
and Bagatti 1949: 168, no. 5, pl. 32; Donderer<br />
1989: 70, A27; Piccirillo 1993: 178,<br />
fig. 248). Saller and Bagatti maintain that<br />
these named mosaicists were the makers as<br />
well as the designers of the mosaic pavement.<br />
• Two inscriptions in St. Stephen’s church<br />
at Umm al-Rasas commemorate the mosaicists,<br />
with an added prayer:<br />
a. An inscription found around the al tar<br />
in the presbyterium sanctuary refers<br />
chapter twelve<br />
to Μνήσθιτη κέ τοΰ δούλου σου<br />
Στυρακήου τοΰ ψιφωθέτοΰ Έξβοντίνου<br />
[υ]ίοΰ τοΰ Ζαδας Εύρεμήου<br />
έτέρου αύτοΰ ‘the two mosaicists (and<br />
others) Staurkaios of Esbous, son of<br />
Za da, and Euremius his colleague’<br />
(Pic cirillo 1989: 285-6; 1993: 238,<br />
fig. 346; Donderer 1989: 79, A38;<br />
Dun babin 1999: 273).<br />
b. An inscription in the mosaic of the nave<br />
dated to 785 mentions anonymous<br />
mosacists: ‘Lord, remember thy servents<br />
the mosacists whose names thou<br />
knowest’ (Piccirillo 1989: 289; 1993:<br />
238, fig. 384). This is comparable to<br />
the Aramaic inscription in Beth She"an<br />
small synagogue that mentions the<br />
work of anonymous artists (fig. XII-2a,<br />
see above). Dunbabin (1999: 273) suggests<br />
that in this formula, as in those<br />
on donors’ inscriptions, sometimes ‘the<br />
names could be suppressed in aspiration<br />
for a heavenly reward’.<br />
Few mosaicists were signing their names on<br />
mosaic pavements, the earliest inscription identifing<br />
a mosaicist appears on the mosaic pavement<br />
of the ‘Evron church in 415, and the practice<br />
continued until the 8th century. Most of the inscriptions<br />
found on synagoge pavements mention<br />
craftsmen with Jewish names, which implies that<br />
Jewish artists were employed in building synagogues<br />
and laying mosaic pavements, while Christian<br />
artists usually laid mosaic floors in churches.<br />
Yet a number of synagogue and church mosaics<br />
might have been paved by the same artists, team<br />
of mosaicists, or workshop (see below). The craft<br />
was apparently an inherited skill, traditionally a<br />
family occupation, as attested to by the inscriptions.<br />
Two generations of a family, Marianos and<br />
his son, together made the mosaic pavement of<br />
Beth ‘Alpha (inscription no. 1) which is unique<br />
in style and execution; and also the pavement in<br />
one room of Beth Shean synagogue A (room 7,<br />
inscription no. 2); possibly the same three-generation<br />
family is recorded at Kefar Kana and<br />
Sepphoris mosaic inscriptions.<br />
Dunbabin (1999: 275) maintains that the<br />
mosaicists’ names noted in church inscriptions<br />
are similar to names of bishops, priests, and benefactors<br />
cited on other inscriptions in the region;<br />
they are a mixture of traditional Aramaic, Greek,<br />
and especially Christian names, which suggests a