You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
106<br />
portrayed on most of the comparable mosaic<br />
pavements (Table V.1). Three fishes swim towards<br />
a Nilotic plant, and a youth pursues a pelican, on<br />
a fragment of a mosaic upper panel at El-Hammam,<br />
Beth She"an, probably from the Roman<br />
period (Zori 1957; Schapiro and Avi-Yonah 1960:<br />
15; Adler 2003: 72, pls. 79, 80). A fish is seen in<br />
the Nile waves in the scene on the nave mosaic<br />
of Zay al-Gharby (Piccirillo 1993: 324, fig. 677).<br />
One fish is depicted in the Nilotic scene on a panel<br />
of the mosaic at Jiyé, and a pair of fishes are on<br />
its border (Ortali-Tarazi and Waliszewski 2000:<br />
figs. 3, 4). The presence of fishes in the Nilotic<br />
landscape emphasizes the river’s current and its<br />
abundant water.<br />
Birds<br />
The most concentrated repertoire of types of birds<br />
on a Nilotic scene—cormorants, doves, ducks,<br />
geese, herons, and swan—is portrayed quite realistically<br />
on the two floors of Tabgha (pl. V.8f;<br />
Fig.V-2). A crane appears at Beth She"an and<br />
Haditha (pls. V.1, 2). A flamingo killing a snake<br />
appears at Tabgha, and at Sepphoris the bird in a<br />
similar scene is probably a stork (fig. V-2, pl. V.3).<br />
In earlier examples, such as the Nile mosaics of<br />
Palestrina and the Casa del Fauno at Pompeii,<br />
the theme is represented as a fight between a<br />
mongoose and a cobra (pl. VII.6) (Balty 1976;<br />
Meyboom 1995: 27, 243, note 74, figs. 15, 28;<br />
see also the appearance of this scene in mosaics<br />
with inhabited scrolls and with the Orpheus<br />
design). A pair of ducks are portrayed at Haditha;<br />
a duck resting in a lotus cup appears at Sepphoris,<br />
Tabgha north transept, Emmaus, and Beth<br />
Guvrin. Recurrent and popular motifs, which are<br />
standard features of Nilotic scenes, include a pair<br />
of swimming ducks and the motif of a duck resting<br />
in a lotus cup (pl. V.8b,c,e), which became a<br />
design for decorative use (Whitehouse 1979: 19,<br />
44-45). Many of the plants and animals are realistically<br />
depicted and reveal knowledge of the species<br />
‘more than their place of origin’ (Hamarneh<br />
1999: 187). Although many birds are portrayed<br />
on these pavements they are differently rendered;<br />
no single pattern seems to be their source.<br />
Various hunting or animal assault episodes are<br />
sometimes part of the Nilotic scenes, for example,<br />
on the lower part of the Nile Festival mosaic<br />
pavement at Sepphoris and on the border frieze<br />
mosaic at el-Meqerqesh, Beth Guvrin. Some of<br />
the Nilotic scenes also show activity by putti or<br />
pygmies.<br />
chapter five<br />
The full scheme of the Nilotic scene with all<br />
the iconographic elements (Table V.1) appears<br />
only at Beth She"an. The city with towers, plants,<br />
fishes, and birds appear on all the pavements.<br />
The Nile personification is portrayed on the Beth<br />
She"an and Sepphoris pavements. The Nilometer<br />
is depicted on the Beth She"an, Tabgha, and Sepphoris<br />
floors. The sailboat and animal combat is<br />
rendered on the Beth She"an and Haditha mosaics.<br />
At Sepphoris the buffalo-crocodile combat scene<br />
and the sailing boat are missing. At Haditha, the<br />
Nilometer and the Nile personification are omitted.<br />
At Tabgha, the Nile personification, the buffalo-crocodile<br />
combat scene and the sailing boat<br />
are absent, and the pavements are almost completely<br />
filled with Nilotic plants and birds while<br />
human figures are absent. The most common elements<br />
of Nilotica presented in these mosaics are<br />
the water plants and birds, which appear on all<br />
the floors, but at Beth She"an there are very few<br />
of them. The representation of the city, named<br />
‘Alexandria’ or ‘Egypt’, and the Nilometer seem<br />
to be the most important elements even though<br />
they appear only on some of these mosaic pavements.<br />
Tabgha is the only pavement that might<br />
have been chosen because of its close proximity<br />
to water, the Sea of Galilee, whereas all the<br />
other mosaic floors do not seem to have a specific<br />
reason for the depiction of Nilotic landscapes. The<br />
Sepphoris mosaic is the only one that portrays<br />
the typical elements of the Nilotic theme, but in<br />
addition it illustrates the festival celebration and<br />
announcement of the Nile inundation.<br />
C. Interpretation<br />
The question arises whether the Nilotic scenes<br />
have a specific meaning in their pagan, Jewish<br />
and Christian contexts. The tradition of Nilotic<br />
images goes back to the Hellenistic period. The<br />
meaning and function of the Nilotic scenes is in<br />
controversy—are they Egyptian or non-Egyptian.<br />
Most scholars maintain a secular view, the Nilotic<br />
scenes represent a phenomenon of using motifs of<br />
exotic character for decorative purposes, mostly<br />
with imaginative rather than realistic content, suggesting<br />
affluence and well-being, with no allegorical-biblical<br />
significance. Kitzinger (1965: 10;<br />
1976: 52,54, 59) states that the Nilotic motifs were<br />
geographic and topographic themes introduced<br />
in the 5th century, and need not have any symbolic<br />
meaning; it is impossible to say what was