01.05.2013 Views

TRACING VEDIC DIALECTS - People.fas.harvard.edu

TRACING VEDIC DIALECTS - People.fas.harvard.edu

TRACING VEDIC DIALECTS - People.fas.harvard.edu

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

distinguish the language of an occupation, a class, and certainly a caste, from<br />

that of other groups.<br />

*****<br />

All of these developments must, again, be kept separate from the so-called<br />

Eastern anaptyxis found in the Eastern Aśoka inscriptions (e.g., in Orissa) 208<br />

and in Ardhamāgadhī. 209 This trait is, of course, attested in written form only<br />

since the third cent. B.C. (Aśoka), and indirectly, in some Eastern forms, in<br />

Pāli. The Western and Southern languages (Śaurasenī, Pāli, Mahārāṣṭrī)<br />

tend to assimilate consonant clusters, e.g., apatya: Eastern Aśoka inscr.<br />

(Khalsi, Dhauli in Orissa) apatiya, Western (Girnar) and Northern<br />

(Shabazgarhi) apaca, Pāli (an)apacca (O.v. Hinüber, Überblick, p. 87).<br />

Anaptyxis, therefore, cannot be claimed to explain the forms tuvaṃ, etc.,<br />

found in Pāli and Śaurasenī, and Bhāsa (mentioned above, see Kuiper, IIJ<br />

30). However, the development seems to be foreshadowed by a few<br />

interesting occurrences of anaptyxis in Middle and Late Vedic.<br />

A case like ŚBM upavasath¡ya :: ŚBK upavasathyá- is very instructive, as it<br />

represents a major split in the treatment of this word in the various Vedic<br />

śākhās. 210<br />

upavasathyá-<br />

AB 3.45; (cf. aupavasathya- AB 7.32);<br />

ṢB 1.4.6, DŚS 2.1.22, 5.1.33; LŚS 2..1.20, 2.5.28; upavasathyaprabhṛti- DŚS<br />

7.3.10; LŚS 3.3.12; GB 1.4.7, 1.4.8; ŚBK 4.6.1.26, 4.9.2.5; 3.2.7.4; and Kāṇva<br />

text corresponding to ŚBM 9.2.1.1 (See Caland, ed. ŚBK p.469)<br />

upavasath¡ya-<br />

TB 1.5.9.7; BŚS 3.15:1, 5.1:7, 10.16:19, 10.19:3, 12.20:21, 15.11:11 16.24:3,<br />

17.11:9, 18.41:7,23.2:22, 23.3:22, 24.20:4, 24.21:6, 26.2:18, VaikhŚS 18.9:9;<br />

JUB 1.17.2.3, 1.17.2.5; ŚBM 9.2.1.1<br />

The Non-Eastern ("Western": Śāṇḍilya) part of the Mādhy. version of ŚBw<br />

(ŚB 6-10) and the Central TB, along with several Taitt. Sūtras and the<br />

208<br />

Note that the Orissan pronunciation of Vedic texts continues this until today, see MSS<br />

44, p.283 sqq.<br />

209<br />

See: O.v. Hinüber, Überblick, § 75 p.60, §153 p.87; cf. also Sprache d.Buddh. in<br />

Zentralasien: Gāndharī p.31.<br />

210<br />

Cf. Kuiper, IIJ 30, 2; Wackernagel, Ai Gr. I, 202; Ved. Var. II § 784 sqq..<br />

74

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!