30.04.2013 Views

Annexure – C - Gujarat Pollution Control Board

Annexure – C - Gujarat Pollution Control Board

Annexure – C - Gujarat Pollution Control Board

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

<strong>Annexure</strong> <strong>–</strong> C<br />

Reponses to the issues raised<br />

By Concerned Persons


V[G[1FZ v ;L<br />

,MS ;]GFJ6L DF8[ ,MSM wJFZF D/[, ,[lBT ZH]VFT VG[ VZHNFZGF<br />

5|lTlGWL wJFZF VF5JFDF\ VFJ[, HJFAP<br />

S|D 5|`G 5]KGFZG] GFD<br />

VG[ ZH]VFT<br />

! 5IF"JZ6 lD+GM 5+<br />

TFoZ#q)q_(<br />

Z U,LIF6F U|FD 5\RFIT<br />

GM 5+ G\P &*<br />

TFo#q!_q_(<br />

# U,LIF6F U|FD 5\RFIT<br />

;Z5\R GM 5+ TFo<br />

*q!_q_(P<br />

$ 5R[UFD U|FD 5\RFIT<br />

GM 5+ TFo *q!_q_(<br />

5 S:AFZF U|FD 5\RFIT<br />

GM 5+ TFo*q!_q_(P<br />

& 8M, U|FD 5\RFIT GM 5+<br />

TFo*q!_q_(P<br />

U]HZFT ZFHI DFU"<br />

lJSF; lGUD wJFZF<br />

V5FI[, 5|tI]TZ<br />

HLPV[;PVFZP0LP;L<br />

wJFZF VF5JFDF\ VFJ[,<br />

5|tI]TZ<br />

HLPV[;PVFZP0LP;L<br />

wJFZF VF5JFDF\ VFJ[,<br />

5|tI]TZ<br />

HLPV[;PVFZP0LP;L<br />

wJFZF VF5JFDF\ VFJ[,<br />

5|tI]TZ<br />

HLPV[;PVFZP0LP;L<br />

wJFZF VF5JFDF\ VFJ[,<br />

5|tI]TZ<br />

HLPV[;PVFZP0LP;L<br />

wJFZF VF5JFDF\ VFJ[,<br />

5|tI]TZ<br />

HLPV[;PVFZP0LP;L<br />

wJFZF VF5JFDF\ VFJ[,<br />

lZDFS";


* D[P S[PV[DP 5ZLB GM<br />

5+ TFo*q!_q_(P<br />

5|tI]TZ<br />

HLPV[;PVFZP0LP;L<br />

wJFZF VF5JFDF\ VFJ[,<br />

5|tI]TZ


5|lT4<br />

5IF"JZ6 lD+<br />

5_Z4ZFH V[JgI]4<br />

EF.SFSFGUZ ZF[04<br />

Y,T[H RFZ Z:TF 5F;[4<br />

VDNFJFNv5)<br />

HFPG\P 5LPVF.PI] q S[d5<br />

qZ__(<br />

IMHGF VD,LSZ6 V[SD<br />

C/o ZFlQ8=I WMZL DFU"<br />

5[8F lJEFU4<br />

DFPD lJEFU Sd5Fpg04<br />

VF6\NP<br />

TFo *q!_q_(P<br />

lJQFI o TFZF5]Z BFT[ AUMNZF v J8FD6 v TFZF5]Z v<br />

JF;N sZFHI DFU"v (f K DFUL"I AGFJJF DF8[ G]<br />

V[GJFIZD[g8, 5a,LS CLIZL{U TFv *v!_v_(<br />

VG] o VF5GM 5+ S|D\FS 5LV[DqV[D5Lq!!$ TFoZ)q)q_(<br />

GM 5+P<br />

VF5GF ;\NE C[9/GF 5+DF\ ZH] SZ[, D]NNFVF[GF HJFA VF ;FY[<br />

;FD[, SZ[, K[\P<br />

lA0F6v p5Z D]HA<br />

GFIA SFI"5F,S .HG[Z<br />

5LPVF.PI] VF6\N


V[G[1FZ v ;L<br />

5IF"JZ6 lD+4 VDNFJFNGM TFo Z#q)qZ__(GF[ 5+<br />

S|D ZH]VFT HJFA sHLPV[;PVFZP0L;L wJFZFf<br />

! .PVF.P V[ ZL5M8" SM[6[ T{IFZ<br />

SZ[, K[ m .PVF.PV[P ZL5M8"<br />

T{IFZ SZGFZ 8LD GF ;eIMGF<br />

GFD ,FISFT VG[ VG]EJ VF5JF<br />

lJG\TL K[P<br />

Z VF IMHGF DF8[ S[8,L HDLG<br />

;\5FNG SZJFDF\ VFJX[P<br />

# HDLGGF J5ZFX 5|DF6[<br />

;\5FNLT HDLGGL lJUT VF5JLP<br />

$ ;\5FNLT YGFZ BFGUL<br />

HDLGGF DF,LSMG[ J/TZ S.<br />

ZLT[ R]SJFX[ m<br />

D[P O|LXD[G 5|E] 5|FP,L wJFZF<br />

.PVF.PV[ ZL5M8" T{IFZ SZJFDF\<br />

VFJ[, K[P .PVF.PV[P ZL5M8" T{IFZ<br />

SZGFZ 8LDGF ;eIMGL lJUT GLR[<br />

D]HA K[P<br />

!P zLDlT V[DPGFdALIFZ v sV[DP.<br />

V[gJFIZD[g8fv !5 JQF"<br />

ZP zL S[PV[;PXFC v ALP. v #5 JQF"<br />

#P zL EZT DF6[S v ALP. v !Z JQF"<br />

VF IMHGFGF Z:TF DF8[ VFXZ[ #!!<br />

C[S8Z<br />

VFJX[P<br />

HDLG ;\5FNG SZJFDF\<br />

;\5FNLT YGFZ HDLG GLR[ D]HA K[P<br />

B[TL,FIS HDLG )_<br />

@<br />

50TZ4 ZC[6FS4<br />

JFl6HILS HDLG<br />

!_@<br />

HDLG ;\5FNG VlWlGID !()$GL<br />

HMUJF.VM D]HA J/TZ R]SJFX[P<br />

5 5CM/M SZJFDF\ S[8,F hF0 VFXZ[ !*__ hF0 Z:TM 5CM/M SZJF


S5FX[ m VG[ S5FGFZ hF0GL<br />

D]bI S. HFT K[ m<br />

& S5FI[, BFGUL T[DH ;ZSFZL<br />

hF0M DF8[ J/TZ R]SJJFDF\<br />

VFJ[, K[m HM CF4 TM T[GL<br />

lJUT VF5JF lJG\TL K[P<br />

* 5IF"JZ6GL D]/E]T ;DL1FF<br />

;\TMQF SFZS ZLT[ SZJFDF\<br />

VFJ[, GYLP<br />

( !__ SLPDLGL ,\AF.GF<br />

WMZLDFU"DF\ DF+ +6 JFI]<br />

U]6JTF4 ;DL1FF SZJFDF DF8[<br />

IMuITF VF5JLP<br />

) JFI] U]6JTF VG[ VJFH U]6JTF<br />

CF,DF\ 5C[,[YL H GA/L<br />

CF,TDF\ K[P AF\WSFD SZTL<br />

JBT[ VF U]6JTF JW] AU0JFGL<br />

;\EFJGF K[4 TM JFI] VG[<br />

VJFHGL U]6JTF HF/JJF q<br />

;]WFZJF AF\WSFD JBT[ X] BF;<br />

SF/HL ,[JFDF\ VFJX[P<br />

S5FX[4 VG[ T[DF D]bItJ[ ,LD0M4<br />

;LZ;4 AA],4 BLH0M4 VF\A,L4 5L5/M<br />

VG[ AMZ0LGF D]bIF hF0M K[P<br />

CH] ;]WL SM. hF0 SF5JFDF\ VFJ[,<br />

GYL H[YL SM. J/TZ VF5JFDF\ VFJ[,<br />

GYLP<br />

5IF"JZ6 D]/E]T ;DL1FF TH7 wJFZF<br />

;\TMQF SFZS ZLT[ SZJFDF\ VFJ[, K[P<br />

;DU| ,\AF.DF\ JFCG jIJCFZ ,UEU<br />

;DFG WMZ6GM H6FIM K[P VF V\U[<br />

+6 HuIFVM GSSL SZJFDF\ VFJ[,<br />

H[DF\ ;F{YL BZFA4 ;FWFZ6<br />

5ZLl:YTL JF/F ,UEU V[S ;ZBF<br />

H\SXGM G[ 5|lTlGlW TZLS[<br />

ZFBJFDF\ VFJ[, K[4 VG[ ;F{YL<br />

VMKM 5|N]QFLT lJ:TFZ ,LW[, K[P<br />

JFI]GL U]6JTF DF8[ TDFD JFCGM<br />

S[ H[ D8LZLI, ,FJGFZ K[ T[G[<br />

D8LZLI, -M/FTF V8SFJJF -F\SJFDF\<br />

VFJX[P CM8DL1F %,Fg8DF\YL ZH<br />

5|N]QF6 VMK] SZJF TDFD SF/HL<br />

;\TMQF SFZS ZLT[ ,[JFDF\ VFJX[P<br />

TDFD Z:TF ;FO ZFBJFDF\ VFJX[<br />

VG[ N/ VG[ SFNJ N]Z SZJFDF\<br />

VFJX[P HM H~Z H6FX[ TM Z:TFGL<br />

;5F8LG 5F6L VUZ CM;YL ;FO<br />

SZJFDF\ VFJX[P %,Fg84 DXLGZL<br />

T[DH ;FWGMG[ V[JL ZLT[<br />

JF5ZJFDF\ VFJX[ S[ H[YL ZH<br />

VMKFDF\ VMKL pEL YFIP CM8<br />

DL1F %,Fg8 GHLSGF ZC[6FSYL<br />

5__ DL8Z H[8,F N]Z ZFBJDF\ VFJX[<br />

VG[ T[DF ZH N]Z SZJF DF8[GF<br />

I]GL8 ZFBJFDF\ VFJX[P lGSF, YTF<br />

D8LZLI, DF8[ 5IF"JZ6 ;]Z1FF<br />

VlWlGID !)(& C[9/GF HMUJF.VM<br />

S0S ZLT[ VD,L SZFX[P


!_ K DFUL"I Z:TM 5]6" SZJF DF8[<br />

S[8,M ;DI YJFGL VFXF K[ m<br />

!! Z:TFGL A\G[ AFH] AF\WSFDGF<br />

;DI NZdIFG VFH]AFH]GL<br />

B[TL,FIS HDLG 5Z X] V;Z<br />

YJFGL ;\EFJGF K[ m<br />

!Z HDLGGF p5,F :TZG[ YGFZ<br />

V;ZG] lJQ,[QF6 AF\WSFD SZTF<br />

5C[,F VG[ 5KL SZJFDF\<br />

VFJX[m<br />

!# 5IF"JZ6 jIJ:YF5G %,FGGF<br />

VD,LSZ6 SZJF DF8[ HJFANFZ<br />

.HFZNFZMGF GFDGL IFNL<br />

VF5JF lJG\TL K[P<br />

!$ AF\WSFD JBT[ :YFlGS ,MSMG[<br />

SZFZDF\ ZMHUFZL VF5JF<br />

DF8[ SM. VU|TF D/X[ m<br />

!5 EFZT ;ZSFZGF JG VG[ 5IF"JZ6<br />

lJEFU wJFZF VF IMHGF DF8[<br />

VF5JFD\F VFJ[, 8d;" VMO<br />

Z[OZg; VF5JF lJG\TL K[P<br />

VJFH U]6JTF o %,Fg8 VG[ ;FWGM<br />

JF5ZTL JBT[ AF\WSFDDF\ EFZT<br />

;ZSFZGF VJFH V\U[GF<br />

WFZFWMZ6M H/JFX[P JFCGMGL<br />

HF/J6L lGIDLT VG[ IMuI ZLT[<br />

SZFX[P GHLSGF ZC[6FSGF !5_<br />

DL8Z T[DH Z1FLT VG[ VGFDT<br />

H\U,GF 5__ DL8Z lJ:TFZDF\ Z!o__<br />

YL &o__ ;]WL S,FS SFD A\W<br />

ZC[X[PlTJ| VJFHGL GHLSGF T[DH<br />

S|;L\U %,Fg8GL GHLSGF<br />

SFDNFZMG[ IMuI S50F VG[ ;FWGM<br />

V5FX[P<br />

VFXZ[ #& DF;DF\ K DFUL"I Z:TM<br />

5]6" YJFGL VFXF K[P<br />

B[TL ,FIS HDLG VMKL YJFGL D]bI<br />

;\EFJGF K[P H[GF DF8[ WFZF<br />

WMZ6 D]HA J/TZ R]SJFX[P H]NF<br />

H]NF 5IF"JZ6 jIJ:YF5G 5U,FGF<br />

J056DF\ 5F6L TYF HDLG 5|N]QF6<br />

VMKFDF\ VMK] GHLSGF lJ:TFZGL<br />

HDLGDF\ YFI T[GL SF/HL ZBFX[P<br />

GF4 HDLGF p5,F :TZGL DF8L<br />

AF\WSFD JBT[ A[ Z:TFGL DwI<br />

EFUDF\ T[DH -M/FJDF\ J5ZFX[P<br />

VF SFD DF8[ .HFZNFZ CH] ;]WL<br />

GSSL SZJFDF\ VFJ[, GYLP<br />

CFP<br />

8d;" VMO Z[OZg; VF ;FY[ ;FD[, K[P


<strong>Gujarat</strong> State Road Development Corporation Ltd. Improvement and<br />

Widening of Bagodara-Wataman-Tarapur-Vasad road [ State Highway <strong>–</strong> 8 ]<br />

The earlier presentation on the proposed improvement and strengthening of Bagodara-<br />

Wataman-Tarapur-Vasad road of state highway-8.included salient features like proposed<br />

Right of Way, Construction aspects, Existing land user pattern, need of the project,<br />

environmental aspects related to water and land etc. It was also informed by the project<br />

proponent that the proposed widening shall entail additional land acquisition. After detailed<br />

deliberations by the experts, additional Terms of Reference were prescribed<br />

1. Detailed study flora & fauna of the study area and impact analysis due to proposed<br />

project<br />

2. Detailed study on hydrology, drainage pattern of the study area and impact analysis<br />

due to proposed project and mitigation measures.<br />

3. Land acquisition details and change in land use pattern due to proposed project<br />

especially with respect to agricultural land as well as likely impact.<br />

4. Impact on water bodies surrounding the project site i.e. in study area due to proposed<br />

project..<br />

5. Top soil management plan for the proposed project.<br />

6. Detailed Environmental Management Plan of the stone crushing plants, hot mix<br />

plants, Ready Mix Concrete plants that may come up temporarily for this projects.<br />

7. Detailed Safety provisions proposed during the construction of the project..<br />

8. Bar chart of the project specifying time period.<br />

9. Details on the consumption of water during construction and operation, source of<br />

water supply and permissions from the concerned authority in the case of ground<br />

water extraction.<br />

10. Clearance from the Forest department for the existing tree cutting and details of<br />

compensatory plantation plan.<br />

11. Detailed Environment Management Plan along with all proposed mitigation measures<br />

for both construction phase and operation phase.<br />

12. Base line status of Ambient air quality and modeling indicating the likely impact on<br />

ambient air quality due to proposed activities in operation phase.<br />

13. Detailed green-belt development plan.<br />

14. Highway design drawing with cross section showing road thickness, super elevation,<br />

road slope to drain water etc


5|lT4<br />

;Z5\RzL<br />

U,LIF6F U|FD 5\RFIT4<br />

D]PU,LIF6F4 TFPTFZF5]Z4 lHPVF6\NP<br />

HFPG\P 5LPVF.PI] q S[d5<br />

qZ__(<br />

IMHGF VD,LSZ6 V[SD<br />

C/o ZFlQ8=I WMZL DFU"<br />

5[8F lJEFU4<br />

DFPD lJEFU Sd5Fpg04<br />

VF6\NP<br />

TFo *q!_q_(P<br />

lJQFI o AUMNZF v J8FD6 v TFZF5]Z v JF;N sZFHI DFU"v (f K<br />

DFUL"I AGFJJF ;FD[ U,LIF6F UFD[ pEL YGFZ D]xS[,L<br />

AFATP<br />

VG] o VF5GM 5+ S|D\FS G\P &* TFo#q!_q_( GM 5+P<br />

VF5GF UFD 5F;[ ;FAZDTL GNLDF\ 5]ZGF SFZ6[ K[


5|lT4<br />

;Z5\RzL<br />

U,LIF6F U|FD 5\RFIT4<br />

D]PU,LIF6F4 TFPTFZF5]Z4 lHPVF6\NP<br />

HFPG\P 5LPVF.PI] q S[d5<br />

qZ__(<br />

IMHGF VD,LSZ6 V[SD<br />

C/o ZFlQ8=I WMZL DFU"<br />

5[8F lJEFU4<br />

DFPD lJEFU Sd5Fpg04<br />

VF6\NP<br />

TFo *q!_q_(P<br />

lJQFI o OT[5]ZF RMS0LYL ;FAZDTL A|LH ;]WL A\G[ ;F.0 lGSF,<br />

SZJF AFAT[P<br />

VG] o VF5GM TFo*q!_q_( GM 5+P<br />

VF5GL ZH}VFT VgJI[ H6FJJFG]\ S[ OT[5]ZF RMS0LYL ;FAZDTL<br />

A|LH ;]WL Z:TFGL A\G[ ;F.0DF\ 5F6LGF lGSF, DF8[ U8ZM AGFJL 5F6L<br />

GNLDF\ ;C[,F.YL JCL HFI T[ ZLT[ Z:TFGF HDLGGF ,[J,MGL RSF;L<br />

5F6LGF lGSF, DF8[ IMuI jIJ:YF SZJFGF VFIMHG DF8[ TF\l+S ZLT[<br />

RSF;L VFU/GL SFI"JFCL CFY WZJFDF\ VFJX[P<br />

GFIA SFI"5F,S .HG[Z<br />

5LPVF.PI] VF6\N


5|lT4<br />

;Z5\RzL<br />

5R[UFD U|FD 5\RFIT4<br />

D]P5R[UFD4 TFPTFZF5]Z4 lHPVF6\NP<br />

lJQFI o JF;N AUMNZF CF.J[GL ZH]VFT AFATP<br />

VG] o VF5GM TFo*q!_q_( GM 5+P<br />

HFPG\P 5LPVF.PI] q S[d5<br />

qZ__(<br />

IMHGF VD,LSZ6 V[SD<br />

C/o ZFlQ8=I WMZL DFU"<br />

5[8F lJEFU4<br />

DFPD lJEFU Sd5Fpg04<br />

VF6\NP<br />

TFo *q!_q_(P<br />

VF5GL ZH}VFTDF\ H6FjIF D]HA JZ;0FYL U,LIF6FGL JrR[GL<br />

ZM0GL ,\AF.DF\ 5F6LGF HyYFGL TF\l+S ZLT[ RSF;6L SZL H~lZIFT<br />

D]HAGF 5], q GF/F AGFJJFGL SFI"JFCL CFY WZFX[P<br />

GFIA SFI"5F,S .HG[Z<br />

5LPVF.PI] VF6\N


5|lT4<br />

;Z5\RzL<br />

S:AFZF U|FD 5\RFIT4<br />

D]PS:AFZF4 TFPTFZF5]Z4 lHPVF6\NP<br />

lJQFI o AUMNZF JF;N ;LS; ,[G Z:TF AFATP<br />

VG] o VF5GM TFo*q!_q_( GM 5+P<br />

HFPG\P 5LPVF.PI] q S[d5<br />

qZ__(<br />

IMHGF VD,LSZ6 V[SD<br />

C/o ZFlQ8=I WMZL DFU"<br />

5[8F lJEFU4<br />

DFPD lJEFU Sd5Fpg04<br />

VF6\NP<br />

TFo *q!_q_(P<br />

GJLG AGGFZ K DFUL"I Z:TM AFZDF;L JFCG jIJCFZ DF8[ RF,]<br />

ZC[ T[ ZLT[ H~lZIFT D]HAGL p\RF.GM SZJFDF\ VFJX[P<br />

VF5GL ZH}VFTGF D]N'F G\PZ4# VG[ $ VgJI[ H6FJJFG]\ S[4<br />

VF5GF 5+DF\ NXF"J[, VF lJ:TFZGF !5 UFDM DF8[ TF\l+S ZLT[ RSF;6L<br />

SZL 5F6LGL VFJS VG[ HFJSG[ wIFGDF\ ,. H~lZIFT D]HAGF<br />

UZGF/Fq5],GL HMUJF. SZJFDF\ VFJX[P<br />

GFIA SFI"5F,S .HG[Z<br />

5LPVF.PI] VF6\N


5|lT4<br />

;Z5\RzL<br />

8M, U|FD 5\RFIT4<br />

D]P8M,4 TFPTFZF5]Z4 lHPVF6\NP<br />

HFPG\P 5LPVF.PI] q S[d5<br />

qZ__(<br />

IMHGF VD,LSZ6 V[SD<br />

C/o ZFlQ8=I WMZL DFU"<br />

5[8F lJEFU4<br />

DFPD lJEFU Sd5Fpg04<br />

VF6\NP<br />

TFo *q!_q_(P<br />

lJQFI o TFZF5]Z YL AUMNZF CF.J[ ZM0GL 5CM/F. JWTF 8M,<br />

UFDDF\ XF/F4 D\lNZ TYF DSFGG] GSXFG YJF AFATP<br />

VG] o VF5GM TFo*q!_q_( GM 5+P<br />

VF5GL ZH}VFT VgJI[ H6FJJFG]\ S[4 VUFpGL VF5GL ZH}VFTG[<br />

wIFG[ ,. VG[ Z:TFGL 5YZ[BFG[ wIFG[ ,. TF\l+S VlE5|FI D]HA UFDGL<br />

;FD[GF T/FJGF ;FD[GF lSGFZF 5F;[YL ,. HJFG]\ VFIMHG SZ[, K[P<br />

VF5GL ZH}VFT VgJI[ ClZHG SM,MGL 5F;[ GF/F D}SJF DF8[<br />

TF\l+S H~lZIFTM RSF;L HM GF/F D}SJFGL H~lZIFT H6FX[ TM T[ V\U[<br />

AF\WSFD JBT[ SFI"JFCL CFY WZJFDF\ VFJX[P<br />

GFIA SFI"5F,S .HG[Z<br />

5LPVF.PI] VF6\N


5|lT4<br />

D[P S[PV[DP5ZLB<br />

EFZT 5[|8M,LID SM5M"Z[XG ,LP<br />

TFZF5]Z v J8FD6 ZM0<br />

U,LIF6FP #((&Z5<br />

lHPVF6\NP<br />

HFPG\P 5LPVF.PI] q S[d5<br />

qZ__(<br />

IMHGF VD,LSZ6 V[SD<br />

C/o ZFlQ8=I WMZL DFU"<br />

5[8F lJEFU4<br />

DFPD lJEFU Sd5Fpg04<br />

VF6\NP<br />

TFo *q!_q_(P<br />

lJQFI o AUMNZF v TFZF5]Z K DFUL"I Z:TF AFAT[P<br />

VG] o VF5GM TFo*q!_q_( GM 5+P<br />

VF5GL ZH]VFT VgJI[ U,LIF6FvOT[5]Z RMS0L 5F;[ JFCG<br />

jIJCFZGL H~lZIFT D]HA VF.PVFZP;LPGL HMUJF. D]HA TF\l+S ZLT[<br />

RSF;6L SZL IMuI SFI"JFCL CFY WZFX[P<br />

GFIA SFI"5F,S .HG[Z<br />

5LPVF.PI] VF6\N


<strong>Annexure</strong> C<br />

Representation of affected persons during<br />

Public Hearing and reply of representative of<br />

applicant.<br />

Sr.<br />

No.<br />

Name of Person and his<br />

representation<br />

1 Paryavaran Mitra letter dated<br />

23-9-08<br />

2 Galiyana Gram Panchayat<br />

letter no. 67 dated 3-10-08<br />

3 Galiyana Gram Panchayat<br />

letter dated 7-10-08<br />

4 Pachegam Gram Panchayat<br />

letter dated 7-10-08<br />

5 Kasbara Gram Panchayat<br />

letter dated 7-10-08<br />

6 Toll Gram Panchayat letter<br />

dated 7-10-08<br />

Reply from<br />

GSRDC<br />

Reply from GSRDC<br />

Reply from GSRD<br />

Reply from GSRD<br />

Reply from GSRD<br />

Reply from GSRD<br />

Reply from GSRD<br />

Remarks


7 M/s. K.M. Parikh letter dated<br />

7-10-08<br />

To<br />

Paryavaran Mitra,<br />

502, Raj Avenue,<br />

Bhaskarnagar Road,<br />

Nr. Thaltej Cross Road,<br />

Thaltej, Ahmedabad - 380059<br />

Reply from GSRD<br />

No. PIU/Camp/2008<br />

Project Implementation Unit<br />

C/o National Highway Sub<br />

Division<br />

R&B D Compound, Anand<br />

Dt: 7-10-2008<br />

Sub : Environmental Public Hearing of expansion of SH-8 Wataman<br />

Tarapur Six Lane Highway at Tarapur on 7-10-08<br />

Ref : Your letter no. PM/MP/115/2008 dated 23-09-2008.<br />

With reference to your subject the comments / suggestions /<br />

observation regarding project EIA report raised vide your letter under<br />

reference our reply is enclosed herewith.<br />

D.A.: As above.<br />

Dy. Executive Engineer


Project Implementation Unit<br />

GSRDC, Anand<br />

Copy submitted to: Regional Officer, <strong>Gujarat</strong> <strong>Pollution</strong> <strong>Control</strong> <strong>Board</strong>,<br />

Vadodara for favour of information.<br />

Letter from Paryavaran Mitra Ahmedabad letter dtd 23-9-2008<br />

Sr.No. Question Reply from GSRDC<br />

1 Who has prepared EIA report for the<br />

Project? Please give member name and<br />

qualification with experience of EIA<br />

preparation team.<br />

2 How much land would be acquired for<br />

the project?<br />

3 Give land use break up of acquired<br />

land?<br />

4 What is mode of compensation for<br />

acquired land for private land owners?<br />

5 How many trees would be cut during<br />

expansion? What are the main species<br />

of trees to be cut?<br />

6 Whether compensation has been given<br />

for cut trees in private / government<br />

land? If yes please give details thereof.<br />

M/s Frischmann Prabhu I Pvt Ltd has<br />

prepared the EIA report. The following<br />

members has prepared EIA report,<br />

1. Mr. Nambiar ME (Env) 15 Yrs<br />

2. Mr. K.S.Shah B.E. 35 Yrs<br />

3. Mr. Bharat Manek B.E. 12 Yrs<br />

Approximately 311 ha. of land will<br />

required to be acquired for the project<br />

(including Two bypasses namely Borsad<br />

Bypass and Vasad Bypass respectively)<br />

The land use break up of acquired land:<br />

Agricultural land <strong>–</strong> 90%<br />

Barren Land<br />

Commercial <strong>–</strong> 10%<br />

Residential<br />

Provisions of as per land acquisition Act,<br />

1894<br />

Approximately 1700 trees will be cut for<br />

expansion main species are Neem, Siras,<br />

babul, khijadia, pipal, ambli, & bordi are<br />

to be cut.<br />

So far no tree is cut hence no<br />

compensation is paid.


7 Environmental baseline monitoring has<br />

not been carried out satisfactorily<br />

8 Please justify only 3 air quality<br />

monitoring station in 100 km stretch of<br />

highways<br />

9 Air quality and noise quality are<br />

already in poor conditions. At time of<br />

construction quality would be worsen.<br />

What special care would be taken to<br />

preserve / improve air and noise quality<br />

during construction?<br />

Environmental baseline monitoring is<br />

carried out satisfactorily by the expert.<br />

The traffic characteristics are more or less<br />

homogenous throughout the entire stretch-<br />

three locations were chosen to represent<br />

the potential worst scenarios as well as<br />

well as normal scenarios, more or less<br />

equidistant from each other- two are busy<br />

junctions, and third is a comparatively less<br />

polluted area<br />

All vehicles for air quality delivering<br />

materials to the site shall be covered to<br />

avoid spillage of materials. Every<br />

precaution to reduce the level of dust<br />

emission for the hot mix plant up to the<br />

satisfaction. All existing highways and<br />

roads works shall be kept clean and clear<br />

of all dust/mud. If required the Engineer,<br />

the road surfaces shall be hosed or<br />

watered using necessary equipment.<br />

Plants, machinery and equipment shall be<br />

so handled (including dismantling) so as<br />

to minimize generation dust. The hot <strong>–</strong><br />

mix plant be sited at least 500 m from the<br />

nearest habitation, shall be fitted with dust<br />

extraction units in order. The discharge<br />

standards promulgated under the<br />

Environment Protection Act, 1986 shall<br />

be strictly adhered to.<br />

The for noise quality plants and<br />

equipment used in construction (including<br />

the aggregate crushing plant) shall strictly<br />

conform to the GOI noise standards.<br />

Maintenance of vehicles shall be regular<br />

and proper. In construction sites within<br />

150 m of the nearest habitation and 500 m<br />

of protected and reserved forests. Workers


10 What is expected completion time of<br />

six lane highway project?<br />

11 What would be impact on surrounding<br />

agriculture land during construction<br />

phase on both side of road?<br />

12 Whether topsoil analysis before and<br />

after construction is proposed to assess<br />

impact on soil?<br />

13 Please given detail list of contractors<br />

who are responsible for implementation<br />

of Environment Management Plan.<br />

14 Whether local people will get priority<br />

in contract employment during<br />

construction?<br />

15 Please give TOR of the of the Project<br />

given by MoEF.<br />

in vicinity of strong noise and workers<br />

working with or in crushing, compaction,<br />

or concrete mixing operations shall be<br />

provided with protective clothing and<br />

appliances.<br />

The expected completion time period of<br />

six lanes highway project is 36 months.<br />

Loss of agricultural land is the only<br />

significant impact -It shall be<br />

compensated as per norms. Environmental<br />

management measures elaborated under<br />

various headings will ensure that the<br />

impacts due to water & soil pollution is<br />

minimum on the nearby land.<br />

No, top soil is going to be utilized for<br />

construction but the same will be utilized<br />

in median & slope.<br />

Contractor is yet to be finalized.<br />

Yes<br />

TOR given by MoEF is attached herewith.


<strong>Gujarat</strong> State Road Development Corporation Ltd. Improvement and<br />

Widening of Bagodara-Wataman-Tarapur-Vasad road [ State Highway <strong>–</strong> 8 ]<br />

The earlier presentation on the proposed improvement and strengthening of Bagodara-<br />

Wataman-Tarapur-Vasad road of state highway-8.included salient features like proposed<br />

Right of Way, Construction aspects, Existing land user pattern, need of the project,<br />

environmental aspects related to water and land etc. It was also informed by the project<br />

proponent that the proposed widening shall entail additional land acquisition. After detailed<br />

deliberations by the experts, additional Terms of Reference were prescribed<br />

1. Detailed study flora & fauna of the study area and impact analysis due to proposed<br />

project<br />

2. Detailed study on hydrology, drainage pattern of the study area and impact analysis<br />

due to proposed project and mitigation measures.<br />

3. Land acquisition details and change in land use pattern due to proposed project<br />

especially with respect to agricultural land as well as likely impact.<br />

4. Impact on water bodies surrounding the project site i.e. in study area due to proposed<br />

project..<br />

5. Top soil management plan for the proposed project.<br />

6. Detailed Environmental Management Plan of the stone crushing plants, hot mix<br />

plants, Ready Mix Concrete plants that may come up temporarily for this projects.<br />

7. Detailed Safety provisions proposed during the construction of the project..<br />

8. Bar chart of the project specifying time period.<br />

9. Details on the consumption of water during construction and operation, source of<br />

water supply and permissions from the concerned authority in the case of ground<br />

water extraction.<br />

10. Clearance from the Forest department for the existing tree cutting and details of<br />

compensatory plantation plan.


11. Detailed Environment Management Plan along with all proposed mitigation measures<br />

for both construction phase and operation phase.<br />

12. Base line status of Ambient air quality and modeling indicating the likely impact on<br />

ambient air quality due to proposed activities in operation phase.<br />

13. Detailed green-belt development plan.<br />

14. Highway design drawing with cross section showing road thickness, super elevation,<br />

road slope to drain water etc<br />

To<br />

Sarpanch<br />

Galiyana Gram Panchayat,<br />

Tal. Tarapur,<br />

Dist. Anand<br />

No. PIU/Camp/2008<br />

Project Implementation Unit<br />

C/o National Highway Sub<br />

Division<br />

R&B D Compound, Anand<br />

Dt: 7-10-2008<br />

Sub : Problems due to Six laning of Bagodara -Wataman - Tarapur -<br />

Vasad Road S H-8.<br />

Ref : Your letter dated 3-10-2008.<br />

You have represented regarding flood due to Sabarmati river<br />

near your village in last three years and water logging due to roads, the<br />

necessary action will be taken after verifying the possibilities of providing


additional CD works in proposed six laning after considering quantum of<br />

water.<br />

To<br />

Sarpanch<br />

Galiyana Gram Panchayat,<br />

Tal. Tarapur,<br />

Dist. Anand<br />

Dy. Executive Engineer<br />

PIU, Anand<br />

No. PIU/Camp/2008<br />

Project Implementation Unit<br />

C/o National Highway Sub<br />

Division<br />

R&B D Compound, Anand<br />

Dt: 7-10-2008<br />

Sub : Regarding Water Disposal from Fatepura Crossing to Sabarmati<br />

Bridge.<br />

Ref : Your letter dated 7-10-2008.<br />

With reference to your representation for disposal of flood<br />

water, road side drainage on both sides of the road from Fatepura Crossing<br />

to Sabarmati Bridge, the levels of the road sides will be checked and as per<br />

technical requirement, onward necessary action will be taken.


To<br />

Sarpanch<br />

Pachegam Gram Panchayat,<br />

Tal. Tarapur,<br />

Dist. Anand<br />

Sub : Regarding Vasad - Bagodara Highway.<br />

Ref : Your letter dated 7-10-2008.<br />

Dy. Executive Engineer<br />

PIU, Anand<br />

No. PIU/Camp/2008<br />

Project Implementation Unit<br />

C/o National Highway Sub<br />

Division<br />

R&B D Compound, Anand<br />

Dt: 7-10-2008<br />

CD works / bridges shall be provided between Varasda to<br />

Galiana after technical verification of hydraulic calculations.<br />

Dy. Executive Engineer<br />

PIU, Anand


To<br />

Sarpanch<br />

Kasbara Gram Panchayat,<br />

Kasbara<br />

Tal. Tarapur,<br />

Dist. Anand<br />

No. PIU/Camp/2008<br />

Project Implementation Unit<br />

C/o National Highway Sub<br />

Division<br />

R&B D Compound, Anand<br />

Dt: 7-10-2008<br />

Sub : Regarding Bagodara - Vasad Six lane road.<br />

Ref : Your letter dated 7-10-2008.<br />

The top level of proposed six lane road will be raised to such a<br />

way that traffic movement remains for all seasons.<br />

Regarding point no. 2, 3 and 4 of your representation it is to<br />

state that, the CD work / Bridge will be provided as per the requirement<br />

after necessary technical checking of the water flow of all the 15 villages of<br />

this area will be considered.<br />

Dy. Executive Engineer


To<br />

Sarpanch<br />

Toll Gram Panchayat,<br />

Toll, Tal. Tarapur,<br />

Dist. Anand<br />

PIU, Anand<br />

No. PIU/Camp/2008<br />

Project Implementation Unit<br />

C/o National Highway Sub<br />

Division<br />

R&B D Compound, Anand<br />

Dt: 7-10-2008<br />

Sub : Damages to School, Temple and houses due to widening of<br />

Tarapur - Bagodara road.<br />

Ref : Your letter dated 7-10-2008.<br />

With reference to your representation it is to state that,<br />

Considering your previous representation, it has been planned to aligned<br />

the road on opposite side of village and near the bank of lake.<br />

Regarding your representation for providing CD works near<br />

Harijan Colony, the technical requirement will be checked and if required,<br />

CD works shall be provided during construction phase.<br />

Dy. Executive Engineer<br />

PIU, Anand


To<br />

Sarpanch<br />

Gaiyana Gram Panchayat,<br />

Galiyana,<br />

Tal. Tarapur,<br />

Dist. Anand<br />

No. PIU/Camp/2008<br />

Project Implementation Unit<br />

C/o National Highway Sub<br />

Division<br />

R&B D Compound, Anand<br />

Dt: 7-10-2008<br />

Sub : Creation of Problems to Galiaya Village due to Six laning of<br />

Bagodara - Vataman - Tarapur - Vasad Road (SH - 8).<br />

Ref : Your letter no. 67 dated 3-10-2008.<br />

It is represented that, during last three years, the flood water of<br />

Sabarmati River could not be disposed off through CD work of the road<br />

near your village. possibilities of providing additional CD works shall be<br />

technically checked after considering quantum of water the action shall be<br />

taken for the proposed six-lane road.<br />

Dy. Executive Engineer<br />

PIU, Anand


To<br />

M/s. K.M. Parikh<br />

Bharat Petroleum Corporation Limited,<br />

Tarapur - Vataman Road,<br />

Galiyana - 388625<br />

Dist. Anand<br />

No. PIU/Camp/2008<br />

Project Implementation Unit<br />

C/o National Highway Sub<br />

Division<br />

R&B D Compound, Anand<br />

Dt: 7-10-2008<br />

Sub : Regarding Bagodara - Tarapur Six lane Road.<br />

Ref : Your letter dated 7-10-2008.<br />

In response to your representation, as per requirement of<br />

traffic, the provision of IRC Technical scrutiny the necessary action shall<br />

be taken near Galiyana - Fatepur Crossing.<br />

Dy. Executive Engineer<br />

PIU, Anand

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!