30.04.2013 Views

Annexure – C - Gujarat Pollution Control Board

Annexure – C - Gujarat Pollution Control Board

Annexure – C - Gujarat Pollution Control Board

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

<strong>Annexure</strong> <strong>–</strong> C<br />

Reponses to the issues raised<br />

By Concerned Persons


V[G[1FZ v ;L<br />

,MS ;]GFJ6L DF8[ ,MSM wJFZF D/[, ,[lBT ZH]VFT VG[ VZHNFZGF<br />

5|lTlGWL wJFZF VF5JFDF\ VFJ[, HJFAP<br />

S|D 5|`G 5]KGFZG] GFD<br />

VG[ ZH]VFT<br />

! 5IF"JZ6 lD+GM 5+<br />

TFoZ#q)q_(<br />

Z U,LIF6F U|FD 5\RFIT<br />

GM 5+ G\P &*<br />

TFo#q!_q_(<br />

# U,LIF6F U|FD 5\RFIT<br />

;Z5\R GM 5+ TFo<br />

*q!_q_(P<br />

$ 5R[UFD U|FD 5\RFIT<br />

GM 5+ TFo *q!_q_(<br />

5 S:AFZF U|FD 5\RFIT<br />

GM 5+ TFo*q!_q_(P<br />

& 8M, U|FD 5\RFIT GM 5+<br />

TFo*q!_q_(P<br />

U]HZFT ZFHI DFU"<br />

lJSF; lGUD wJFZF<br />

V5FI[, 5|tI]TZ<br />

HLPV[;PVFZP0LP;L<br />

wJFZF VF5JFDF\ VFJ[,<br />

5|tI]TZ<br />

HLPV[;PVFZP0LP;L<br />

wJFZF VF5JFDF\ VFJ[,<br />

5|tI]TZ<br />

HLPV[;PVFZP0LP;L<br />

wJFZF VF5JFDF\ VFJ[,<br />

5|tI]TZ<br />

HLPV[;PVFZP0LP;L<br />

wJFZF VF5JFDF\ VFJ[,<br />

5|tI]TZ<br />

HLPV[;PVFZP0LP;L<br />

wJFZF VF5JFDF\ VFJ[,<br />

5|tI]TZ<br />

HLPV[;PVFZP0LP;L<br />

wJFZF VF5JFDF\ VFJ[,<br />

lZDFS";


* D[P S[PV[DP 5ZLB GM<br />

5+ TFo*q!_q_(P<br />

5|tI]TZ<br />

HLPV[;PVFZP0LP;L<br />

wJFZF VF5JFDF\ VFJ[,<br />

5|tI]TZ


5|lT4<br />

5IF"JZ6 lD+<br />

5_Z4ZFH V[JgI]4<br />

EF.SFSFGUZ ZF[04<br />

Y,T[H RFZ Z:TF 5F;[4<br />

VDNFJFNv5)<br />

HFPG\P 5LPVF.PI] q S[d5<br />

qZ__(<br />

IMHGF VD,LSZ6 V[SD<br />

C/o ZFlQ8=I WMZL DFU"<br />

5[8F lJEFU4<br />

DFPD lJEFU Sd5Fpg04<br />

VF6\NP<br />

TFo *q!_q_(P<br />

lJQFI o TFZF5]Z BFT[ AUMNZF v J8FD6 v TFZF5]Z v<br />

JF;N sZFHI DFU"v (f K DFUL"I AGFJJF DF8[ G]<br />

V[GJFIZD[g8, 5a,LS CLIZL{U TFv *v!_v_(<br />

VG] o VF5GM 5+ S|D\FS 5LV[DqV[D5Lq!!$ TFoZ)q)q_(<br />

GM 5+P<br />

VF5GF ;\NE C[9/GF 5+DF\ ZH] SZ[, D]NNFVF[GF HJFA VF ;FY[<br />

;FD[, SZ[, K[\P<br />

lA0F6v p5Z D]HA<br />

GFIA SFI"5F,S .HG[Z<br />

5LPVF.PI] VF6\N


V[G[1FZ v ;L<br />

5IF"JZ6 lD+4 VDNFJFNGM TFo Z#q)qZ__(GF[ 5+<br />

S|D ZH]VFT HJFA sHLPV[;PVFZP0L;L wJFZFf<br />

! .PVF.P V[ ZL5M8" SM[6[ T{IFZ<br />

SZ[, K[ m .PVF.PV[P ZL5M8"<br />

T{IFZ SZGFZ 8LD GF ;eIMGF<br />

GFD ,FISFT VG[ VG]EJ VF5JF<br />

lJG\TL K[P<br />

Z VF IMHGF DF8[ S[8,L HDLG<br />

;\5FNG SZJFDF\ VFJX[P<br />

# HDLGGF J5ZFX 5|DF6[<br />

;\5FNLT HDLGGL lJUT VF5JLP<br />

$ ;\5FNLT YGFZ BFGUL<br />

HDLGGF DF,LSMG[ J/TZ S.<br />

ZLT[ R]SJFX[ m<br />

D[P O|LXD[G 5|E] 5|FP,L wJFZF<br />

.PVF.PV[ ZL5M8" T{IFZ SZJFDF\<br />

VFJ[, K[P .PVF.PV[P ZL5M8" T{IFZ<br />

SZGFZ 8LDGF ;eIMGL lJUT GLR[<br />

D]HA K[P<br />

!P zLDlT V[DPGFdALIFZ v sV[DP.<br />

V[gJFIZD[g8fv !5 JQF"<br />

ZP zL S[PV[;PXFC v ALP. v #5 JQF"<br />

#P zL EZT DF6[S v ALP. v !Z JQF"<br />

VF IMHGFGF Z:TF DF8[ VFXZ[ #!!<br />

C[S8Z<br />

VFJX[P<br />

HDLG ;\5FNG SZJFDF\<br />

;\5FNLT YGFZ HDLG GLR[ D]HA K[P<br />

B[TL,FIS HDLG )_<br />

@<br />

50TZ4 ZC[6FS4<br />

JFl6HILS HDLG<br />

!_@<br />

HDLG ;\5FNG VlWlGID !()$GL<br />

HMUJF.VM D]HA J/TZ R]SJFX[P<br />

5 5CM/M SZJFDF\ S[8,F hF0 VFXZ[ !*__ hF0 Z:TM 5CM/M SZJF


S5FX[ m VG[ S5FGFZ hF0GL<br />

D]bI S. HFT K[ m<br />

& S5FI[, BFGUL T[DH ;ZSFZL<br />

hF0M DF8[ J/TZ R]SJJFDF\<br />

VFJ[, K[m HM CF4 TM T[GL<br />

lJUT VF5JF lJG\TL K[P<br />

* 5IF"JZ6GL D]/E]T ;DL1FF<br />

;\TMQF SFZS ZLT[ SZJFDF\<br />

VFJ[, GYLP<br />

( !__ SLPDLGL ,\AF.GF<br />

WMZLDFU"DF\ DF+ +6 JFI]<br />

U]6JTF4 ;DL1FF SZJFDF DF8[<br />

IMuITF VF5JLP<br />

) JFI] U]6JTF VG[ VJFH U]6JTF<br />

CF,DF\ 5C[,[YL H GA/L<br />

CF,TDF\ K[P AF\WSFD SZTL<br />

JBT[ VF U]6JTF JW] AU0JFGL<br />

;\EFJGF K[4 TM JFI] VG[<br />

VJFHGL U]6JTF HF/JJF q<br />

;]WFZJF AF\WSFD JBT[ X] BF;<br />

SF/HL ,[JFDF\ VFJX[P<br />

S5FX[4 VG[ T[DF D]bItJ[ ,LD0M4<br />

;LZ;4 AA],4 BLH0M4 VF\A,L4 5L5/M<br />

VG[ AMZ0LGF D]bIF hF0M K[P<br />

CH] ;]WL SM. hF0 SF5JFDF\ VFJ[,<br />

GYL H[YL SM. J/TZ VF5JFDF\ VFJ[,<br />

GYLP<br />

5IF"JZ6 D]/E]T ;DL1FF TH7 wJFZF<br />

;\TMQF SFZS ZLT[ SZJFDF\ VFJ[, K[P<br />

;DU| ,\AF.DF\ JFCG jIJCFZ ,UEU<br />

;DFG WMZ6GM H6FIM K[P VF V\U[<br />

+6 HuIFVM GSSL SZJFDF\ VFJ[,<br />

H[DF\ ;F{YL BZFA4 ;FWFZ6<br />

5ZLl:YTL JF/F ,UEU V[S ;ZBF<br />

H\SXGM G[ 5|lTlGlW TZLS[<br />

ZFBJFDF\ VFJ[, K[4 VG[ ;F{YL<br />

VMKM 5|N]QFLT lJ:TFZ ,LW[, K[P<br />

JFI]GL U]6JTF DF8[ TDFD JFCGM<br />

S[ H[ D8LZLI, ,FJGFZ K[ T[G[<br />

D8LZLI, -M/FTF V8SFJJF -F\SJFDF\<br />

VFJX[P CM8DL1F %,Fg8DF\YL ZH<br />

5|N]QF6 VMK] SZJF TDFD SF/HL<br />

;\TMQF SFZS ZLT[ ,[JFDF\ VFJX[P<br />

TDFD Z:TF ;FO ZFBJFDF\ VFJX[<br />

VG[ N/ VG[ SFNJ N]Z SZJFDF\<br />

VFJX[P HM H~Z H6FX[ TM Z:TFGL<br />

;5F8LG 5F6L VUZ CM;YL ;FO<br />

SZJFDF\ VFJX[P %,Fg84 DXLGZL<br />

T[DH ;FWGMG[ V[JL ZLT[<br />

JF5ZJFDF\ VFJX[ S[ H[YL ZH<br />

VMKFDF\ VMKL pEL YFIP CM8<br />

DL1F %,Fg8 GHLSGF ZC[6FSYL<br />

5__ DL8Z H[8,F N]Z ZFBJDF\ VFJX[<br />

VG[ T[DF ZH N]Z SZJF DF8[GF<br />

I]GL8 ZFBJFDF\ VFJX[P lGSF, YTF<br />

D8LZLI, DF8[ 5IF"JZ6 ;]Z1FF<br />

VlWlGID !)(& C[9/GF HMUJF.VM<br />

S0S ZLT[ VD,L SZFX[P


!_ K DFUL"I Z:TM 5]6" SZJF DF8[<br />

S[8,M ;DI YJFGL VFXF K[ m<br />

!! Z:TFGL A\G[ AFH] AF\WSFDGF<br />

;DI NZdIFG VFH]AFH]GL<br />

B[TL,FIS HDLG 5Z X] V;Z<br />

YJFGL ;\EFJGF K[ m<br />

!Z HDLGGF p5,F :TZG[ YGFZ<br />

V;ZG] lJQ,[QF6 AF\WSFD SZTF<br />

5C[,F VG[ 5KL SZJFDF\<br />

VFJX[m<br />

!# 5IF"JZ6 jIJ:YF5G %,FGGF<br />

VD,LSZ6 SZJF DF8[ HJFANFZ<br />

.HFZNFZMGF GFDGL IFNL<br />

VF5JF lJG\TL K[P<br />

!$ AF\WSFD JBT[ :YFlGS ,MSMG[<br />

SZFZDF\ ZMHUFZL VF5JF<br />

DF8[ SM. VU|TF D/X[ m<br />

!5 EFZT ;ZSFZGF JG VG[ 5IF"JZ6<br />

lJEFU wJFZF VF IMHGF DF8[<br />

VF5JFD\F VFJ[, 8d;" VMO<br />

Z[OZg; VF5JF lJG\TL K[P<br />

VJFH U]6JTF o %,Fg8 VG[ ;FWGM<br />

JF5ZTL JBT[ AF\WSFDDF\ EFZT<br />

;ZSFZGF VJFH V\U[GF<br />

WFZFWMZ6M H/JFX[P JFCGMGL<br />

HF/J6L lGIDLT VG[ IMuI ZLT[<br />

SZFX[P GHLSGF ZC[6FSGF !5_<br />

DL8Z T[DH Z1FLT VG[ VGFDT<br />

H\U,GF 5__ DL8Z lJ:TFZDF\ Z!o__<br />

YL &o__ ;]WL S,FS SFD A\W<br />

ZC[X[PlTJ| VJFHGL GHLSGF T[DH<br />

S|;L\U %,Fg8GL GHLSGF<br />

SFDNFZMG[ IMuI S50F VG[ ;FWGM<br />

V5FX[P<br />

VFXZ[ #& DF;DF\ K DFUL"I Z:TM<br />

5]6" YJFGL VFXF K[P<br />

B[TL ,FIS HDLG VMKL YJFGL D]bI<br />

;\EFJGF K[P H[GF DF8[ WFZF<br />

WMZ6 D]HA J/TZ R]SJFX[P H]NF<br />

H]NF 5IF"JZ6 jIJ:YF5G 5U,FGF<br />

J056DF\ 5F6L TYF HDLG 5|N]QF6<br />

VMKFDF\ VMK] GHLSGF lJ:TFZGL<br />

HDLGDF\ YFI T[GL SF/HL ZBFX[P<br />

GF4 HDLGF p5,F :TZGL DF8L<br />

AF\WSFD JBT[ A[ Z:TFGL DwI<br />

EFUDF\ T[DH -M/FJDF\ J5ZFX[P<br />

VF SFD DF8[ .HFZNFZ CH] ;]WL<br />

GSSL SZJFDF\ VFJ[, GYLP<br />

CFP<br />

8d;" VMO Z[OZg; VF ;FY[ ;FD[, K[P


<strong>Gujarat</strong> State Road Development Corporation Ltd. Improvement and<br />

Widening of Bagodara-Wataman-Tarapur-Vasad road [ State Highway <strong>–</strong> 8 ]<br />

The earlier presentation on the proposed improvement and strengthening of Bagodara-<br />

Wataman-Tarapur-Vasad road of state highway-8.included salient features like proposed<br />

Right of Way, Construction aspects, Existing land user pattern, need of the project,<br />

environmental aspects related to water and land etc. It was also informed by the project<br />

proponent that the proposed widening shall entail additional land acquisition. After detailed<br />

deliberations by the experts, additional Terms of Reference were prescribed<br />

1. Detailed study flora & fauna of the study area and impact analysis due to proposed<br />

project<br />

2. Detailed study on hydrology, drainage pattern of the study area and impact analysis<br />

due to proposed project and mitigation measures.<br />

3. Land acquisition details and change in land use pattern due to proposed project<br />

especially with respect to agricultural land as well as likely impact.<br />

4. Impact on water bodies surrounding the project site i.e. in study area due to proposed<br />

project..<br />

5. Top soil management plan for the proposed project.<br />

6. Detailed Environmental Management Plan of the stone crushing plants, hot mix<br />

plants, Ready Mix Concrete plants that may come up temporarily for this projects.<br />

7. Detailed Safety provisions proposed during the construction of the project..<br />

8. Bar chart of the project specifying time period.<br />

9. Details on the consumption of water during construction and operation, source of<br />

water supply and permissions from the concerned authority in the case of ground<br />

water extraction.<br />

10. Clearance from the Forest department for the existing tree cutting and details of<br />

compensatory plantation plan.<br />

11. Detailed Environment Management Plan along with all proposed mitigation measures<br />

for both construction phase and operation phase.<br />

12. Base line status of Ambient air quality and modeling indicating the likely impact on<br />

ambient air quality due to proposed activities in operation phase.<br />

13. Detailed green-belt development plan.<br />

14. Highway design drawing with cross section showing road thickness, super elevation,<br />

road slope to drain water etc


5|lT4<br />

;Z5\RzL<br />

U,LIF6F U|FD 5\RFIT4<br />

D]PU,LIF6F4 TFPTFZF5]Z4 lHPVF6\NP<br />

HFPG\P 5LPVF.PI] q S[d5<br />

qZ__(<br />

IMHGF VD,LSZ6 V[SD<br />

C/o ZFlQ8=I WMZL DFU"<br />

5[8F lJEFU4<br />

DFPD lJEFU Sd5Fpg04<br />

VF6\NP<br />

TFo *q!_q_(P<br />

lJQFI o AUMNZF v J8FD6 v TFZF5]Z v JF;N sZFHI DFU"v (f K<br />

DFUL"I AGFJJF ;FD[ U,LIF6F UFD[ pEL YGFZ D]xS[,L<br />

AFATP<br />

VG] o VF5GM 5+ S|D\FS G\P &* TFo#q!_q_( GM 5+P<br />

VF5GF UFD 5F;[ ;FAZDTL GNLDF\ 5]ZGF SFZ6[ K[


5|lT4<br />

;Z5\RzL<br />

U,LIF6F U|FD 5\RFIT4<br />

D]PU,LIF6F4 TFPTFZF5]Z4 lHPVF6\NP<br />

HFPG\P 5LPVF.PI] q S[d5<br />

qZ__(<br />

IMHGF VD,LSZ6 V[SD<br />

C/o ZFlQ8=I WMZL DFU"<br />

5[8F lJEFU4<br />

DFPD lJEFU Sd5Fpg04<br />

VF6\NP<br />

TFo *q!_q_(P<br />

lJQFI o OT[5]ZF RMS0LYL ;FAZDTL A|LH ;]WL A\G[ ;F.0 lGSF,<br />

SZJF AFAT[P<br />

VG] o VF5GM TFo*q!_q_( GM 5+P<br />

VF5GL ZH}VFT VgJI[ H6FJJFG]\ S[ OT[5]ZF RMS0LYL ;FAZDTL<br />

A|LH ;]WL Z:TFGL A\G[ ;F.0DF\ 5F6LGF lGSF, DF8[ U8ZM AGFJL 5F6L<br />

GNLDF\ ;C[,F.YL JCL HFI T[ ZLT[ Z:TFGF HDLGGF ,[J,MGL RSF;L<br />

5F6LGF lGSF, DF8[ IMuI jIJ:YF SZJFGF VFIMHG DF8[ TF\l+S ZLT[<br />

RSF;L VFU/GL SFI"JFCL CFY WZJFDF\ VFJX[P<br />

GFIA SFI"5F,S .HG[Z<br />

5LPVF.PI] VF6\N


5|lT4<br />

;Z5\RzL<br />

5R[UFD U|FD 5\RFIT4<br />

D]P5R[UFD4 TFPTFZF5]Z4 lHPVF6\NP<br />

lJQFI o JF;N AUMNZF CF.J[GL ZH]VFT AFATP<br />

VG] o VF5GM TFo*q!_q_( GM 5+P<br />

HFPG\P 5LPVF.PI] q S[d5<br />

qZ__(<br />

IMHGF VD,LSZ6 V[SD<br />

C/o ZFlQ8=I WMZL DFU"<br />

5[8F lJEFU4<br />

DFPD lJEFU Sd5Fpg04<br />

VF6\NP<br />

TFo *q!_q_(P<br />

VF5GL ZH}VFTDF\ H6FjIF D]HA JZ;0FYL U,LIF6FGL JrR[GL<br />

ZM0GL ,\AF.DF\ 5F6LGF HyYFGL TF\l+S ZLT[ RSF;6L SZL H~lZIFT<br />

D]HAGF 5], q GF/F AGFJJFGL SFI"JFCL CFY WZFX[P<br />

GFIA SFI"5F,S .HG[Z<br />

5LPVF.PI] VF6\N


5|lT4<br />

;Z5\RzL<br />

S:AFZF U|FD 5\RFIT4<br />

D]PS:AFZF4 TFPTFZF5]Z4 lHPVF6\NP<br />

lJQFI o AUMNZF JF;N ;LS; ,[G Z:TF AFATP<br />

VG] o VF5GM TFo*q!_q_( GM 5+P<br />

HFPG\P 5LPVF.PI] q S[d5<br />

qZ__(<br />

IMHGF VD,LSZ6 V[SD<br />

C/o ZFlQ8=I WMZL DFU"<br />

5[8F lJEFU4<br />

DFPD lJEFU Sd5Fpg04<br />

VF6\NP<br />

TFo *q!_q_(P<br />

GJLG AGGFZ K DFUL"I Z:TM AFZDF;L JFCG jIJCFZ DF8[ RF,]<br />

ZC[ T[ ZLT[ H~lZIFT D]HAGL p\RF.GM SZJFDF\ VFJX[P<br />

VF5GL ZH}VFTGF D]N'F G\PZ4# VG[ $ VgJI[ H6FJJFG]\ S[4<br />

VF5GF 5+DF\ NXF"J[, VF lJ:TFZGF !5 UFDM DF8[ TF\l+S ZLT[ RSF;6L<br />

SZL 5F6LGL VFJS VG[ HFJSG[ wIFGDF\ ,. H~lZIFT D]HAGF<br />

UZGF/Fq5],GL HMUJF. SZJFDF\ VFJX[P<br />

GFIA SFI"5F,S .HG[Z<br />

5LPVF.PI] VF6\N


5|lT4<br />

;Z5\RzL<br />

8M, U|FD 5\RFIT4<br />

D]P8M,4 TFPTFZF5]Z4 lHPVF6\NP<br />

HFPG\P 5LPVF.PI] q S[d5<br />

qZ__(<br />

IMHGF VD,LSZ6 V[SD<br />

C/o ZFlQ8=I WMZL DFU"<br />

5[8F lJEFU4<br />

DFPD lJEFU Sd5Fpg04<br />

VF6\NP<br />

TFo *q!_q_(P<br />

lJQFI o TFZF5]Z YL AUMNZF CF.J[ ZM0GL 5CM/F. JWTF 8M,<br />

UFDDF\ XF/F4 D\lNZ TYF DSFGG] GSXFG YJF AFATP<br />

VG] o VF5GM TFo*q!_q_( GM 5+P<br />

VF5GL ZH}VFT VgJI[ H6FJJFG]\ S[4 VUFpGL VF5GL ZH}VFTG[<br />

wIFG[ ,. VG[ Z:TFGL 5YZ[BFG[ wIFG[ ,. TF\l+S VlE5|FI D]HA UFDGL<br />

;FD[GF T/FJGF ;FD[GF lSGFZF 5F;[YL ,. HJFG]\ VFIMHG SZ[, K[P<br />

VF5GL ZH}VFT VgJI[ ClZHG SM,MGL 5F;[ GF/F D}SJF DF8[<br />

TF\l+S H~lZIFTM RSF;L HM GF/F D}SJFGL H~lZIFT H6FX[ TM T[ V\U[<br />

AF\WSFD JBT[ SFI"JFCL CFY WZJFDF\ VFJX[P<br />

GFIA SFI"5F,S .HG[Z<br />

5LPVF.PI] VF6\N


5|lT4<br />

D[P S[PV[DP5ZLB<br />

EFZT 5[|8M,LID SM5M"Z[XG ,LP<br />

TFZF5]Z v J8FD6 ZM0<br />

U,LIF6FP #((&Z5<br />

lHPVF6\NP<br />

HFPG\P 5LPVF.PI] q S[d5<br />

qZ__(<br />

IMHGF VD,LSZ6 V[SD<br />

C/o ZFlQ8=I WMZL DFU"<br />

5[8F lJEFU4<br />

DFPD lJEFU Sd5Fpg04<br />

VF6\NP<br />

TFo *q!_q_(P<br />

lJQFI o AUMNZF v TFZF5]Z K DFUL"I Z:TF AFAT[P<br />

VG] o VF5GM TFo*q!_q_( GM 5+P<br />

VF5GL ZH]VFT VgJI[ U,LIF6FvOT[5]Z RMS0L 5F;[ JFCG<br />

jIJCFZGL H~lZIFT D]HA VF.PVFZP;LPGL HMUJF. D]HA TF\l+S ZLT[<br />

RSF;6L SZL IMuI SFI"JFCL CFY WZFX[P<br />

GFIA SFI"5F,S .HG[Z<br />

5LPVF.PI] VF6\N


<strong>Annexure</strong> C<br />

Representation of affected persons during<br />

Public Hearing and reply of representative of<br />

applicant.<br />

Sr.<br />

No.<br />

Name of Person and his<br />

representation<br />

1 Paryavaran Mitra letter dated<br />

23-9-08<br />

2 Galiyana Gram Panchayat<br />

letter no. 67 dated 3-10-08<br />

3 Galiyana Gram Panchayat<br />

letter dated 7-10-08<br />

4 Pachegam Gram Panchayat<br />

letter dated 7-10-08<br />

5 Kasbara Gram Panchayat<br />

letter dated 7-10-08<br />

6 Toll Gram Panchayat letter<br />

dated 7-10-08<br />

Reply from<br />

GSRDC<br />

Reply from GSRDC<br />

Reply from GSRD<br />

Reply from GSRD<br />

Reply from GSRD<br />

Reply from GSRD<br />

Reply from GSRD<br />

Remarks


7 M/s. K.M. Parikh letter dated<br />

7-10-08<br />

To<br />

Paryavaran Mitra,<br />

502, Raj Avenue,<br />

Bhaskarnagar Road,<br />

Nr. Thaltej Cross Road,<br />

Thaltej, Ahmedabad - 380059<br />

Reply from GSRD<br />

No. PIU/Camp/2008<br />

Project Implementation Unit<br />

C/o National Highway Sub<br />

Division<br />

R&B D Compound, Anand<br />

Dt: 7-10-2008<br />

Sub : Environmental Public Hearing of expansion of SH-8 Wataman<br />

Tarapur Six Lane Highway at Tarapur on 7-10-08<br />

Ref : Your letter no. PM/MP/115/2008 dated 23-09-2008.<br />

With reference to your subject the comments / suggestions /<br />

observation regarding project EIA report raised vide your letter under<br />

reference our reply is enclosed herewith.<br />

D.A.: As above.<br />

Dy. Executive Engineer


Project Implementation Unit<br />

GSRDC, Anand<br />

Copy submitted to: Regional Officer, <strong>Gujarat</strong> <strong>Pollution</strong> <strong>Control</strong> <strong>Board</strong>,<br />

Vadodara for favour of information.<br />

Letter from Paryavaran Mitra Ahmedabad letter dtd 23-9-2008<br />

Sr.No. Question Reply from GSRDC<br />

1 Who has prepared EIA report for the<br />

Project? Please give member name and<br />

qualification with experience of EIA<br />

preparation team.<br />

2 How much land would be acquired for<br />

the project?<br />

3 Give land use break up of acquired<br />

land?<br />

4 What is mode of compensation for<br />

acquired land for private land owners?<br />

5 How many trees would be cut during<br />

expansion? What are the main species<br />

of trees to be cut?<br />

6 Whether compensation has been given<br />

for cut trees in private / government<br />

land? If yes please give details thereof.<br />

M/s Frischmann Prabhu I Pvt Ltd has<br />

prepared the EIA report. The following<br />

members has prepared EIA report,<br />

1. Mr. Nambiar ME (Env) 15 Yrs<br />

2. Mr. K.S.Shah B.E. 35 Yrs<br />

3. Mr. Bharat Manek B.E. 12 Yrs<br />

Approximately 311 ha. of land will<br />

required to be acquired for the project<br />

(including Two bypasses namely Borsad<br />

Bypass and Vasad Bypass respectively)<br />

The land use break up of acquired land:<br />

Agricultural land <strong>–</strong> 90%<br />

Barren Land<br />

Commercial <strong>–</strong> 10%<br />

Residential<br />

Provisions of as per land acquisition Act,<br />

1894<br />

Approximately 1700 trees will be cut for<br />

expansion main species are Neem, Siras,<br />

babul, khijadia, pipal, ambli, & bordi are<br />

to be cut.<br />

So far no tree is cut hence no<br />

compensation is paid.


7 Environmental baseline monitoring has<br />

not been carried out satisfactorily<br />

8 Please justify only 3 air quality<br />

monitoring station in 100 km stretch of<br />

highways<br />

9 Air quality and noise quality are<br />

already in poor conditions. At time of<br />

construction quality would be worsen.<br />

What special care would be taken to<br />

preserve / improve air and noise quality<br />

during construction?<br />

Environmental baseline monitoring is<br />

carried out satisfactorily by the expert.<br />

The traffic characteristics are more or less<br />

homogenous throughout the entire stretch-<br />

three locations were chosen to represent<br />

the potential worst scenarios as well as<br />

well as normal scenarios, more or less<br />

equidistant from each other- two are busy<br />

junctions, and third is a comparatively less<br />

polluted area<br />

All vehicles for air quality delivering<br />

materials to the site shall be covered to<br />

avoid spillage of materials. Every<br />

precaution to reduce the level of dust<br />

emission for the hot mix plant up to the<br />

satisfaction. All existing highways and<br />

roads works shall be kept clean and clear<br />

of all dust/mud. If required the Engineer,<br />

the road surfaces shall be hosed or<br />

watered using necessary equipment.<br />

Plants, machinery and equipment shall be<br />

so handled (including dismantling) so as<br />

to minimize generation dust. The hot <strong>–</strong><br />

mix plant be sited at least 500 m from the<br />

nearest habitation, shall be fitted with dust<br />

extraction units in order. The discharge<br />

standards promulgated under the<br />

Environment Protection Act, 1986 shall<br />

be strictly adhered to.<br />

The for noise quality plants and<br />

equipment used in construction (including<br />

the aggregate crushing plant) shall strictly<br />

conform to the GOI noise standards.<br />

Maintenance of vehicles shall be regular<br />

and proper. In construction sites within<br />

150 m of the nearest habitation and 500 m<br />

of protected and reserved forests. Workers


10 What is expected completion time of<br />

six lane highway project?<br />

11 What would be impact on surrounding<br />

agriculture land during construction<br />

phase on both side of road?<br />

12 Whether topsoil analysis before and<br />

after construction is proposed to assess<br />

impact on soil?<br />

13 Please given detail list of contractors<br />

who are responsible for implementation<br />

of Environment Management Plan.<br />

14 Whether local people will get priority<br />

in contract employment during<br />

construction?<br />

15 Please give TOR of the of the Project<br />

given by MoEF.<br />

in vicinity of strong noise and workers<br />

working with or in crushing, compaction,<br />

or concrete mixing operations shall be<br />

provided with protective clothing and<br />

appliances.<br />

The expected completion time period of<br />

six lanes highway project is 36 months.<br />

Loss of agricultural land is the only<br />

significant impact -It shall be<br />

compensated as per norms. Environmental<br />

management measures elaborated under<br />

various headings will ensure that the<br />

impacts due to water & soil pollution is<br />

minimum on the nearby land.<br />

No, top soil is going to be utilized for<br />

construction but the same will be utilized<br />

in median & slope.<br />

Contractor is yet to be finalized.<br />

Yes<br />

TOR given by MoEF is attached herewith.


<strong>Gujarat</strong> State Road Development Corporation Ltd. Improvement and<br />

Widening of Bagodara-Wataman-Tarapur-Vasad road [ State Highway <strong>–</strong> 8 ]<br />

The earlier presentation on the proposed improvement and strengthening of Bagodara-<br />

Wataman-Tarapur-Vasad road of state highway-8.included salient features like proposed<br />

Right of Way, Construction aspects, Existing land user pattern, need of the project,<br />

environmental aspects related to water and land etc. It was also informed by the project<br />

proponent that the proposed widening shall entail additional land acquisition. After detailed<br />

deliberations by the experts, additional Terms of Reference were prescribed<br />

1. Detailed study flora & fauna of the study area and impact analysis due to proposed<br />

project<br />

2. Detailed study on hydrology, drainage pattern of the study area and impact analysis<br />

due to proposed project and mitigation measures.<br />

3. Land acquisition details and change in land use pattern due to proposed project<br />

especially with respect to agricultural land as well as likely impact.<br />

4. Impact on water bodies surrounding the project site i.e. in study area due to proposed<br />

project..<br />

5. Top soil management plan for the proposed project.<br />

6. Detailed Environmental Management Plan of the stone crushing plants, hot mix<br />

plants, Ready Mix Concrete plants that may come up temporarily for this projects.<br />

7. Detailed Safety provisions proposed during the construction of the project..<br />

8. Bar chart of the project specifying time period.<br />

9. Details on the consumption of water during construction and operation, source of<br />

water supply and permissions from the concerned authority in the case of ground<br />

water extraction.<br />

10. Clearance from the Forest department for the existing tree cutting and details of<br />

compensatory plantation plan.


11. Detailed Environment Management Plan along with all proposed mitigation measures<br />

for both construction phase and operation phase.<br />

12. Base line status of Ambient air quality and modeling indicating the likely impact on<br />

ambient air quality due to proposed activities in operation phase.<br />

13. Detailed green-belt development plan.<br />

14. Highway design drawing with cross section showing road thickness, super elevation,<br />

road slope to drain water etc<br />

To<br />

Sarpanch<br />

Galiyana Gram Panchayat,<br />

Tal. Tarapur,<br />

Dist. Anand<br />

No. PIU/Camp/2008<br />

Project Implementation Unit<br />

C/o National Highway Sub<br />

Division<br />

R&B D Compound, Anand<br />

Dt: 7-10-2008<br />

Sub : Problems due to Six laning of Bagodara -Wataman - Tarapur -<br />

Vasad Road S H-8.<br />

Ref : Your letter dated 3-10-2008.<br />

You have represented regarding flood due to Sabarmati river<br />

near your village in last three years and water logging due to roads, the<br />

necessary action will be taken after verifying the possibilities of providing


additional CD works in proposed six laning after considering quantum of<br />

water.<br />

To<br />

Sarpanch<br />

Galiyana Gram Panchayat,<br />

Tal. Tarapur,<br />

Dist. Anand<br />

Dy. Executive Engineer<br />

PIU, Anand<br />

No. PIU/Camp/2008<br />

Project Implementation Unit<br />

C/o National Highway Sub<br />

Division<br />

R&B D Compound, Anand<br />

Dt: 7-10-2008<br />

Sub : Regarding Water Disposal from Fatepura Crossing to Sabarmati<br />

Bridge.<br />

Ref : Your letter dated 7-10-2008.<br />

With reference to your representation for disposal of flood<br />

water, road side drainage on both sides of the road from Fatepura Crossing<br />

to Sabarmati Bridge, the levels of the road sides will be checked and as per<br />

technical requirement, onward necessary action will be taken.


To<br />

Sarpanch<br />

Pachegam Gram Panchayat,<br />

Tal. Tarapur,<br />

Dist. Anand<br />

Sub : Regarding Vasad - Bagodara Highway.<br />

Ref : Your letter dated 7-10-2008.<br />

Dy. Executive Engineer<br />

PIU, Anand<br />

No. PIU/Camp/2008<br />

Project Implementation Unit<br />

C/o National Highway Sub<br />

Division<br />

R&B D Compound, Anand<br />

Dt: 7-10-2008<br />

CD works / bridges shall be provided between Varasda to<br />

Galiana after technical verification of hydraulic calculations.<br />

Dy. Executive Engineer<br />

PIU, Anand


To<br />

Sarpanch<br />

Kasbara Gram Panchayat,<br />

Kasbara<br />

Tal. Tarapur,<br />

Dist. Anand<br />

No. PIU/Camp/2008<br />

Project Implementation Unit<br />

C/o National Highway Sub<br />

Division<br />

R&B D Compound, Anand<br />

Dt: 7-10-2008<br />

Sub : Regarding Bagodara - Vasad Six lane road.<br />

Ref : Your letter dated 7-10-2008.<br />

The top level of proposed six lane road will be raised to such a<br />

way that traffic movement remains for all seasons.<br />

Regarding point no. 2, 3 and 4 of your representation it is to<br />

state that, the CD work / Bridge will be provided as per the requirement<br />

after necessary technical checking of the water flow of all the 15 villages of<br />

this area will be considered.<br />

Dy. Executive Engineer


To<br />

Sarpanch<br />

Toll Gram Panchayat,<br />

Toll, Tal. Tarapur,<br />

Dist. Anand<br />

PIU, Anand<br />

No. PIU/Camp/2008<br />

Project Implementation Unit<br />

C/o National Highway Sub<br />

Division<br />

R&B D Compound, Anand<br />

Dt: 7-10-2008<br />

Sub : Damages to School, Temple and houses due to widening of<br />

Tarapur - Bagodara road.<br />

Ref : Your letter dated 7-10-2008.<br />

With reference to your representation it is to state that,<br />

Considering your previous representation, it has been planned to aligned<br />

the road on opposite side of village and near the bank of lake.<br />

Regarding your representation for providing CD works near<br />

Harijan Colony, the technical requirement will be checked and if required,<br />

CD works shall be provided during construction phase.<br />

Dy. Executive Engineer<br />

PIU, Anand


To<br />

Sarpanch<br />

Gaiyana Gram Panchayat,<br />

Galiyana,<br />

Tal. Tarapur,<br />

Dist. Anand<br />

No. PIU/Camp/2008<br />

Project Implementation Unit<br />

C/o National Highway Sub<br />

Division<br />

R&B D Compound, Anand<br />

Dt: 7-10-2008<br />

Sub : Creation of Problems to Galiaya Village due to Six laning of<br />

Bagodara - Vataman - Tarapur - Vasad Road (SH - 8).<br />

Ref : Your letter no. 67 dated 3-10-2008.<br />

It is represented that, during last three years, the flood water of<br />

Sabarmati River could not be disposed off through CD work of the road<br />

near your village. possibilities of providing additional CD works shall be<br />

technically checked after considering quantum of water the action shall be<br />

taken for the proposed six-lane road.<br />

Dy. Executive Engineer<br />

PIU, Anand


To<br />

M/s. K.M. Parikh<br />

Bharat Petroleum Corporation Limited,<br />

Tarapur - Vataman Road,<br />

Galiyana - 388625<br />

Dist. Anand<br />

No. PIU/Camp/2008<br />

Project Implementation Unit<br />

C/o National Highway Sub<br />

Division<br />

R&B D Compound, Anand<br />

Dt: 7-10-2008<br />

Sub : Regarding Bagodara - Tarapur Six lane Road.<br />

Ref : Your letter dated 7-10-2008.<br />

In response to your representation, as per requirement of<br />

traffic, the provision of IRC Technical scrutiny the necessary action shall<br />

be taken near Galiyana - Fatepur Crossing.<br />

Dy. Executive Engineer<br />

PIU, Anand

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!