annual report print final.qxd - Asian Centre for Human Rights

INDIA HUMAN RIGHTS REPORT 2005 Bihar
against such brutal killings is welcome, the
miscarriage of justice against the Dalits
require little introduction. The petitions
pending before the courts for prosecution
of the alleged culprits responsible for the
massacre of the Dalits have been
collapsing one by one due to the
unwillingness of the State to establish
accountability.
In the Laxmanpur Bathe massacre on
the intervening night of 1 and 2 December
1997, Ranvir Sena men massacred 59
Dalits of which 26 were women and 19
were children under the age of 10. On 6
December 1997, Justice Amir Das
Commission was constituted to “probe the
nexus between the Ranvir Sena and
political elements’’. It had a six-month
term. Seven years have passed but the
commission continues its endless hearings.
Informant Vinod Paswan filed a First
Information Report No. 126/97 with
Mehandia police station. After the filing of
charge sheets, the trial started in February
1999. Six years later, even charges have
not been framed against the 24 accused.
Except two, the rest have been released on
bail. During the framing of charges all the
accused must be present physically in the
court. For the past 20 hearings, all the
accused never appeared. On 10 July 2004,
Buxar Jail officials informed the court
about a Home Department
‘’administrative decision’’ not to produce
accused Pramod Singh, the main accused,
in any court. Earlier there were reports that
informant Vinod Paswan was being
threatened by Birendra Singh, one of the
main accused. Neither Paswan nor Singh
could be traced in the village. 50
In the Shanker Bigha massacre in
Jehanabad, 23 Dalits were killed by
suspected Ranvir Senas on 25 January
1999. An FIR was lodged at Mehandia
police station case no 5/99. There are 24
accused and 76 witnesses. Two charge
sheets have been filed 37/03 of 15 August
2003 and 67/2000 of 26 February 2000.
On 2 November 2003, the case was
transferred from the chief judicial
magistrate to the sub-divisional judicial
magistrate, Jehanabad, for framing of
charges. However, charges could not be
framed because all the accused must be
present in court on the same day for
framing of charges. This has not happened
yet. Two accused, Parmeshwar Singh and
Kamlesh Bhat, are in jail and the rest have
been released on bail. 51
On 10 February 1999, 12 Dalits were
massacred at Narayanpur in Jehnabad. The
Narayanpur massacre was a political
landmark in Bihar’s rocky history. The
National Democratic Alliance government
dismissed the Rabri Devi government only
to be reinstated later. An FIR 17/99 was
filed. A case was registered (State vs
Sidhan Singh & others 5/2001) in which
12 persons were named and 32-35
unnamed accused. The trial commenced
on 22 February 2002; but the case is
collapsing, as the witnesses are turning
hostile under duress. 52
Even in the Bara massacre case of 12
February 1992 in which 36 people of the
upper-castes were killed by the MCC,
41