Download File

Download File Download File

studentszine.com
from studentszine.com More from this publisher
09.04.2013 Views

A DRAMATIC CRITIC blush, as if an amateur of painting were to say, "You will be delighted with M. Blank's pictures. He has some unpleasant mannerisms, to be sure, — his coloring is poor and his drawing incorrect; but in spite of these, you are sure to like his work." Or as if an acquaintance were to recommend for confidential clerk a young man who was a little weak on the score of honesty and accuracy, but, aside from these trifling mannerisms, had every desirable qualification. The view which a majority of Mr. Irving's American auditors naturally take, at first, of his inost conspicuous faults is highly unfavorable. It is, indeed, the view which the more critical portion of his English audiences took when they were beginning to make his acquaintance. And the difference in the attitudes of the French and the English nations towards the art of acting cannot be better indicated than in this: that Mr. Irving, in spite of his faults, is to-day accepted and recognized as the [ 196 ]

HENRY IRVING greatest actor of his land; while, if he had been a Frenchman, he and his " manner- isms " would not have been tolerated on the Parisian stage for a month, and prob- abl}' not for a single performance. In Mr. William Archer's exceedingly brilliant " study " of Mr. Irving, which was printed in London a few years ago, it was said that the English critics, " obeying an inevitable tendency of dramatic criti- cism," have " made Mr. Irving a law unto himself." In this country, the dangers attendant upon close familiarity with the actor do not beset us; and I plead an American's " innocence of eye " — to use Mr. Ruskin's happy phrase — in extenu- ation of my somewhat premature attempt to determine Mr. Irving's rank as an artist. The disadvantages of slight acquaintance with the actor, on the part of the general audience or the particular critic, are of course plain. But it is most interesting and suggestive to see how swiftly and how [ 197 ]

HENRY IRVING<br />

greatest actor of his land; while, if he had<br />

been a Frenchman, he and his " manner-<br />

isms " would not have been tolerated on<br />

the Parisian stage for a month, and prob-<br />

abl}' not for a single performance.<br />

In Mr. William Archer's exceedingly<br />

brilliant " study " of Mr. Irving, which was<br />

printed in London a few years ago, it was<br />

said that the English critics, " obeying<br />

an inevitable tendency of dramatic criti-<br />

cism," have " made Mr. Irving a law unto<br />

himself." In this country, the dangers<br />

attendant upon close familiarity with the<br />

actor do not beset us; and I plead an<br />

American's " innocence of eye " — to use<br />

Mr. Ruskin's happy phrase — in extenu-<br />

ation of my somewhat premature attempt<br />

to determine Mr. Irving's rank as an artist.<br />

The disadvantages of slight acquaintance<br />

with the actor, on the part of the general<br />

audience or the particular critic, are of<br />

course plain. But it is most interesting and<br />

suggestive to see how swiftly and how<br />

[ 197 ]

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!