Darfur: A Jewish Response - Pears Foundation
Darfur: A Jewish Response - Pears Foundation
Darfur: A Jewish Response - Pears Foundation
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
www.pearsfoundation.org.uk<br />
Registered Charity No: 1009195<br />
© The <strong>Pears</strong> <strong>Foundation</strong> 2007<br />
<strong>Darfur</strong><br />
A <strong>Jewish</strong> <strong>Response</strong><br />
Produced by The <strong>Pears</strong> <strong>Foundation</strong><br />
With a Foreword from Henry Grunwald QC<br />
President, The Board of Deputies of British Jews
Compiled by Hannah Weisfeld<br />
Edited by Alex Singer and Charles Keidan<br />
Design and layout by Glen Powell, The Aegis Trust Media Studio<br />
Front Cover photograph shows a burning village in <strong>Darfur</strong> and is reprinted courtesy of Brian Steidle<br />
Contents<br />
Foreword 3<br />
Introduction 4<br />
Background to the Genocide 5<br />
A <strong>Jewish</strong> <strong>Response</strong> 11<br />
Action you can take<br />
What you can do in your<br />
17<br />
synagogue 19<br />
What you can do in your School<br />
What you can do in your youth<br />
24<br />
movement or <strong>Jewish</strong> society 25<br />
Films, books, articles 27<br />
Useful contacts 29<br />
Appendices<br />
Programming ideas 31<br />
Resources 34<br />
Testimonies 41<br />
Sample letter 43<br />
Maps 44<br />
Timeline of events 45<br />
Acknowledgements 48<br />
The views expressed in this document do not necessarily reflect the views of The <strong>Pears</strong> <strong>Foundation</strong>
3<br />
<strong>Darfur</strong>: A <strong>Jewish</strong> <strong>Response</strong><br />
FOREWORD<br />
“NEITHER A PERPETRATOR<br />
NOR A BYSTANDER BE”<br />
The <strong>Jewish</strong> communities of Europe know all too well how genocide can occur<br />
and what its effects can be. We still suffer from the loss of one third of the<br />
world’s <strong>Jewish</strong> population in the Holocaust. We are all too aware of what<br />
happens when good people do not stand up against prejudice and persecution.<br />
Even as Nazi persecution grew in the 1930s, the warning signs were ignored.<br />
The world stood by.<br />
Today, seventy years on, the world again stands by as the horrors of <strong>Darfur</strong> take<br />
place before its eyes.<br />
As Jews, we have a duty, not only to our fellow Jews, but also to the wider world.<br />
This booklet reminds us of that duty and of our responsibility to our fellow<br />
human beings. Even more significantly, it tells us how we can make a<br />
difference; and, make no mistake, each one of us can and must make a<br />
difference.<br />
It is too late for the hundreds of thousands who have already died. There is still<br />
time for the millions at risk, but only if the world acts.<br />
There is no excuse for standing by and doing nothing.<br />
I commend The <strong>Pears</strong> <strong>Foundation</strong> for the publication of this booklet, and, in<br />
advance, I commend you, the reader, for what you will do, when you have read<br />
it, to ensure that both the <strong>Jewish</strong> and the wider community wake up before it is<br />
too late.<br />
Henry Grunwald QC<br />
President, Board of Deputies of British Jews<br />
INTRODUCTION<br />
“If I am not for myself, who will be for me?<br />
If I am only for myself, what am I?…<br />
Since 2003, a Government backed militia called the ‘Janjaweed’<br />
has waged a campaign of ethnic cleansing and genocide<br />
against black African tribes in <strong>Darfur</strong>, western Sudan.<br />
Up to four hundred thousand men, women and children have<br />
died. A further two million people have fled their homes, with<br />
200,000 living in refugee camps in Chad and the remaining<br />
languishing in camps for internally displaced persons in <strong>Darfur</strong>.<br />
The aim of this booklet is to give <strong>Jewish</strong> communities in Europe<br />
the tools to understand and respond to this grave situation.<br />
In so doing, contributors are both drawing upon, and reinforcing,<br />
<strong>Jewish</strong> traditions of social responsibility, universal human rights<br />
and the striving to create a more just world for all its inhabitants<br />
regardless of race, religion or nationality.<br />
The opening chapter provides the background and context to the<br />
crisis; this is followed by ‘<strong>Jewish</strong> responses’, a set of <strong>Jewish</strong><br />
sources and interpretations on our imperative to fight injustice.<br />
Other sections focus on specific action that you can take,<br />
whether in your synagogue, your school or youth movement, and<br />
through various campaign organisations.<br />
Surely it is time to restore meaning to the pledge ‘Never Again’?<br />
Trevor <strong>Pears</strong><br />
Executive Chair, The <strong>Pears</strong> <strong>Foundation</strong><br />
…And if not now, when?”<br />
(Hillel)<br />
4
© Aegis Trust<br />
5<br />
<strong>Darfur</strong>: A <strong>Jewish</strong> <strong>Response</strong><br />
BACKGROUND TO THE GENOCIDE<br />
DARFUR, SUDAN<br />
<strong>Darfur</strong>, a region roughly two-thirds the size of France, is located<br />
in the west of Africa’s largest country, Sudan. The 34 million<br />
inhabitants of Sudan span multiple religious, ethnic and socioeconomic<br />
divides; an estimated 70% are Muslim, while 25% are<br />
Animist and 5% Christian,<br />
of African or Arab origin,<br />
living nomadic or<br />
sedentary lives.<br />
The six million citizens of<br />
<strong>Darfur</strong>, whilst being<br />
members of one of the<br />
estimated 36 different<br />
ethnic tribes in the area,<br />
are almost all Muslim of<br />
either African or Arab<br />
origin. Sudan was ruled<br />
as an Anglo-Egyptian<br />
Condominium from 1899<br />
until it gained<br />
independence in 1956,<br />
since when weak and<br />
unstable governance has<br />
characterised the country, according to the British Foreign Office.<br />
There is a history of peaceful coexistence between the African<br />
and Arab peoples in the <strong>Darfur</strong> region. Human Rights Watch<br />
describes how disputes were traditionally settled through<br />
mediation by their leaders, and how intermarriage between<br />
ethnic groups was common. However, the United Nations<br />
reports that since the 1970s <strong>Darfur</strong> has experienced localised<br />
violence caused partially by competition over scarce resources<br />
and severe underdevelopment and exacerbated by ethnic,<br />
economic and political marginalisation by the government.<br />
NORTH – SOUTH CIVIL WAR AND<br />
COMPREHENSIVE PEACE AGREEMENT,<br />
1983 - 2005<br />
Sudan’s longest conflict, between the Government and the<br />
Sudan People’s Liberation Movement/Army (SPLM/A), the main<br />
rebel movement in the south, ended in 2005. According to the<br />
United Nations, at least 2 million people were killed and a further<br />
4 million were displaced during the war over resources, power,<br />
the role of religion in the state, and self-determination. The<br />
present government of President Omar Hassan al-Bashir came<br />
to power in a military coup in 1989 and, ruling by decree,<br />
immediately banned all political parties except his own National<br />
Islamic Front.* Although the Comprehensive Peace Agreement<br />
of January 2005 formally ended the fighting, International Crisis<br />
Group reports that it is hampered by the continued lack of<br />
broader support throughout the country, particularly in the North.<br />
It believes that the current equation for peace in Sudan is a<br />
worrying one: the Government has the capacity to implement the<br />
agreement but lacks the political will, whereas the SPLM/A has<br />
the commitment but is weak and disorganised.<br />
* Renamed the National Congress Party in 1998<br />
Source: Aegis Trust<br />
THE CURRENT CONFLICT IN DARFUR<br />
The current crisis in <strong>Darfur</strong> began in April 2003. The indigenous<br />
farming population of <strong>Darfur</strong> has been at the centre of a brutal<br />
civil conflict between the Sudanese<br />
government and their proxy-forces,<br />
and rebel groups drawn from the Fur,<br />
Zaghawa and Masalit ethnic groups.<br />
Claiming years of political, economic<br />
and social exclusion in <strong>Darfur</strong>, and<br />
frustrated by a lack of investment,<br />
underdevelopment, neglect, poverty<br />
and racial discrimination, two<br />
Source: Aegis Trust<br />
separate groups of <strong>Darfur</strong>is emerged<br />
and rose up against the Khartoum government of President al-<br />
Bashir.<br />
Janjaweed militia moving through village, December 2004. Source Human Rights Watch<br />
THE REBEL GROUPS<br />
The mainly African-origin sedentary farmers from the Fur,<br />
Massaleet and Zagawa communities make up the Sudanese<br />
Liberation Army/Movement (SLA/SLM) and the Justice and<br />
Equality Movement (JEM). Whilst having very different ideologies<br />
they coordinated attacks on government targets. The April 2003<br />
attack on the al-Fashir airport killed some seventy members of<br />
the Sudanese army and destroyed several planes.<br />
JANJAWEED MILITIAS<br />
The government responded by launching air strikes and arming<br />
the Janjaweed. This combination of air and ground attacks has<br />
become a signature of the conflict in <strong>Darfur</strong>.<br />
The British Government acknowledges that the Government of<br />
Sudan is arming and mobilising nomadic Arab militias known as<br />
the ‘Janjaweed’. It is widely documented by humanitarian aid<br />
organisations and monitoring agencies working on the ground<br />
that the Janjaweed - armed nomadic Arab men on horses or<br />
camels - is conducting a ‘scorched earth’ policy in <strong>Darfur</strong>.<br />
Reports from Amnesty International, Human Rights Watch and<br />
the Aegis Trust illustrate the ‘systematic use of indiscriminate<br />
aerial bombardment’ of villages [by Sudanese government<br />
aircraft], and the subsequent surrounding and burning of the<br />
villages by Janjaweed militiamen who loot, slaughter and rape.<br />
© Mia Farrow<br />
6
7<br />
<strong>Darfur</strong>: A <strong>Jewish</strong> <strong>Response</strong><br />
CIVILIANS ATTACKED<br />
Although numbers are unclear, the United Nations estimates that<br />
the crisis has, since 2003, claimed over 200,000 lives, although<br />
aid agencies believe as many as 400,000 people could have<br />
been killed. Another two million civilians have been displaced<br />
and are living in refugee camps.<br />
A Sudanese helicopter gunship attacks the village of Labado in <strong>Darfur</strong><br />
© Brian Steidle<br />
There is abundant evidence - testimonies collected from<br />
witnesses, survivors and refugees by aid agencies, human rights<br />
organisations, and journalists - detailing sightings of government<br />
aircraft bombing villages, and describing armed men on<br />
horseback or camelback burning down entire villages, and using<br />
murder, rape, abduction, looting and destroying food stocks as<br />
weapons to instil fear and displace the civilian population.<br />
According to a 2005 report by the United Nations International<br />
Commission of Inquiry, there have been ‘serious violations of<br />
international human rights law and international humanitarian law,<br />
including crimes against humanity or war crimes’ perpetrated by<br />
the Government of Sudan, the Arab militias and the rebels.<br />
DARFUR PEACE AGREEMENT – MAY 2006<br />
A peace agreement was signed in May 2006 between the<br />
Sudanese government and the main faction of the rebel Sudan<br />
Liberation Army led by Minni Minawi. Two other rebel<br />
movements including JEM refused to sign however, claiming it<br />
failed to sufficiently address key issues, putting the DPA on<br />
uncertain ground from the outset. Few of the agreement’s<br />
deadlines have been met, and fighting has increased since the<br />
Agreement was signed, including a surge in fighting between<br />
and within the rebel factions.<br />
IS IT A GENOCIDE?<br />
The term ‘genocide’ was coined in the early 1930s by a <strong>Jewish</strong>-<br />
Polish lawyer, Raphael Lemkin, who, inspired partly by the crimes<br />
committed against the Armenians in the First World War,<br />
combined the Greek word ‘genos’ (race or tribe) with the Latin<br />
word ‘cide’ (to kill). After witnessing the horrors of the Holocaust<br />
- in which every member of his family except his brother and<br />
himself was killed - Dr Lemkin campaigned to have genocide<br />
recognised as a crime under international law. His efforts led to<br />
the adoption of the UN Convention on Genocide in December<br />
1948, which came<br />
into effect in<br />
January 1951.<br />
Article Two of the<br />
convention defines<br />
genocide as ‘any of<br />
the following acts<br />
committed with the<br />
intent to destroy, in<br />
whole or in part, a<br />
national, ethnic, racial or religious group, as such:<br />
(a) Killing members of the group;<br />
(b) Causing serious bodily or mental harm to members of<br />
the group;<br />
(c) Deliberately inflicting on the group conditions of life<br />
calculated to bring about its physical destruction in<br />
whole or in part;<br />
© Aegis Trust<br />
(d) Imposing measures intended to prevent births within the<br />
group;<br />
(e) Forcibly transferring children of the group to another<br />
group’<br />
THE UNITED NATIONS AND THE<br />
INTERNATIONAL COMMUNITY<br />
On 9th September 2004 Secretary of State Colin Powell<br />
declared, on behalf of the US Administration, that ‘genocide has<br />
been committed in <strong>Darfur</strong> and that the government of Sudan and<br />
the Janjaweed bear responsibility’. All signatories to the 1948<br />
Genocide Convention are obligated to ‘commit to preventing and<br />
punishing genocide’.<br />
The United Nations has shied away from labelling the events in<br />
<strong>Darfur</strong> as ‘genocide’ but stated in its 2005 International<br />
Commission of Inquiry that ‘crimes against humanity and war<br />
crimes that have been committed in <strong>Darfur</strong> may be no less<br />
serious and heinous than genocide’.<br />
Source: Aegis Trust<br />
In 2005 the UN adopted the Responsibility to Protect meaning that<br />
if a country cannot or will not protect its citizens from genocide,<br />
war crimes, crimes against humanity and ethnic cleansing, then it<br />
must accept support or assistance from other nations to end the<br />
violence. When peaceful means are exhausted and leaders of a<br />
UN member state are ‘manifestly failing to protect their<br />
populations’, then other states have the responsibility to take<br />
collective action through the Security Council.<br />
The British government ‘continues to be gravely concerned’<br />
about the ‘intolerable situation’ in <strong>Darfur</strong> yet does not refer to it as<br />
genocide. Speaking on 27th March 2007, Tony Blair stated, “We<br />
need to consider a no-fly zone to prevent the use of Sudanese<br />
air power against refugees and displaced people”. However the<br />
8
9<br />
<strong>Darfur</strong>: A <strong>Jewish</strong> <strong>Response</strong><br />
British Government’s messages are mixed, with the deportation<br />
of <strong>Darfur</strong>is from the UK back to Khartoum, along with the refusal<br />
of many asylum claims, despite the UN High Commissioner for<br />
Refugees stating it is too dangerous for them to return and<br />
despite new evidence obtained by Aegis Trust of the torture of<br />
<strong>Darfur</strong>is returned to Khartoum.<br />
The Sudanese government variously describes the conflict as<br />
‘tribal clashes’, accuses journalists and human rights groups of<br />
‘fabricating’ the situation, and denies having any control over the<br />
Janjaweed militias, despite considerable evidence collated by<br />
human rights organisations showing that militia continue to be<br />
‘paid, armed, organised and directed by army military intelligence<br />
and other officers, with assistance from civilian state and<br />
national officials’ (Human Rights Watch, 2007).<br />
THE AFRICAN UNION MISSION IN SUDAN<br />
(AMIS)<br />
The African Union mediated a ceasefire in April 2004 between<br />
the Khartoum government and <strong>Darfur</strong> rebel groups and<br />
deployed a small monitoring team. In 2005 this mandate was<br />
extended to protecting<br />
aid convoys and civilians<br />
under ‘imminent threat’.<br />
The approximately 7,000<br />
AU troops and police<br />
officers are constrained<br />
by a weak mandate and<br />
limited capacity,<br />
preventing them from<br />
proactively stopping<br />
attacks on civilians. Insufficient troop numbers, limited<br />
equipment, poor training and logistics all limit the mission’s<br />
effectiveness in protecting the civilian population.<br />
Source: Aegis Trust<br />
THE UNITED NATIONS AND THE<br />
INTERNATIONAL CRIMINAL COURT<br />
The UN already has a peacekeeping mandate for southern<br />
Sudan as part of the Comprehensive Peace Agreement. In<br />
August 2006 the UN Security Council passed Resolution 1706<br />
authorising the deployment of up to 17,300 military personnel<br />
and 3,300 civilian police to <strong>Darfur</strong>, calling for rapid reinforcement<br />
of the AU mission and a Chapter VII mandate for civilian<br />
protection. President Bashir, equating the UN Resolution to<br />
‘Western invasion’, has resisted strong diplomatic pressure for<br />
the UN to take control of the AMIS mission, and in March 2007<br />
reneged on an agreement in November 2006 to allow UN<br />
peacekeepers into <strong>Darfur</strong> to protect civilians. China’s close<br />
oil-related relationship with Sudan has raised difficulties at the<br />
United Nations Security Council where it is a permanent member<br />
with the power of veto.<br />
The Security Council passed a resolution in April 2006 imposing<br />
sanctions against four Sudanese nationals accused of war<br />
crimes in <strong>Darfur</strong>, despite its own Commission of Inquiry<br />
recommending 17 individuals for targeted sanctions.<br />
The International Criminal Court in The Hague has indicted a<br />
government Minister and a Janjaweed official, accusing them of<br />
committing war crimes.<br />
REFUGEES AND INTERNALLY DISPLACED<br />
PERSONS (IDPS)<br />
With many of the two million displaced in <strong>Darfur</strong> and Chad, and<br />
high levels of violence and insecurity around the camps and the<br />
border areas, humanitarian and aid agencies are struggling to<br />
work effectively. The UN’s emergency relief coordinator Sir John<br />
Holms reported on 27th March 2007 that aid relief for <strong>Darfur</strong>’s<br />
displaced millions is ‘on the brink of collapse’.<br />
It is common for people who leave the camps in search of<br />
firewood to be attacked by the Janjaweed; women are often<br />
gang raped and men are beaten and killed. Many international<br />
aid workers are also being evacuated as the security situation<br />
deteriorates.<br />
© Aegis Trust<br />
Source: Aegis Trust<br />
10
11<br />
<strong>Darfur</strong>: A <strong>Jewish</strong> <strong>Response</strong><br />
A JEWISH RESPONSE<br />
Following in the footsteps of our tradition<br />
The <strong>Jewish</strong> people have a great tradition of human rights<br />
activism. For example, Raphael Lemkin, a Polish refugee who<br />
found himself in the USA during the Second World War, was the<br />
person who coined the term ‘genocide’ to explain actions that<br />
meant total annihilation and destruction of one specific group of<br />
people. He wrote the UN Convention on the Prevention and<br />
Punishment of the Crime of Genocide, which was formally<br />
adopted in 1948.<br />
René Cassin was one of the principal drafters of the Universal<br />
Declaration of Human Rights. He was Chairman or Vice-<br />
Chairman of the UN Commission for Human Rights between<br />
1946 and 1959, President of the Court of Arbitration at The<br />
Hague from 1950 to 1960 and President of the European Court<br />
of Human Rights from 1965 to 1968. He was also a Nobel<br />
Peace Prize Winner in 1968.<br />
Abraham Joshua Heschel, one of the most prominent <strong>Jewish</strong><br />
theologians of the twentieth century, was famous for his<br />
friendship with Martin Luther King and his participation in the US<br />
civil rights movement.<br />
Elie Wiesel: On the Atrocities in Sudan<br />
Elie Wiesel is a renowned Shoah survivor whose memoirs were<br />
subsequently turned into a book, ‘Night’, which has been<br />
translated into over thirty different languages. He has been a<br />
campaigner and an outspoken critic of the lack of intervention by<br />
the international community in scenes of catastrophe and<br />
atrocity and most recently has spoken out at the UN on the lack<br />
of intervention in Sudan.<br />
The following remarks were delivered at the <strong>Darfur</strong> Emergency<br />
Summit, convened at the Graduate Centre of the City University<br />
of New York on 14th July 2004 by the American <strong>Jewish</strong> World<br />
Service and the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum and<br />
can be found online at: www.ajws.org.<br />
“Sudan has become today’s world capital of human pain,<br />
suffering and agony. There, one part of the population has been<br />
– and still is – subjected by another part, the dominating part, to<br />
humiliation, hunger and death. For a while, the so-called civilized<br />
world knew about it and preferred to look away. Now people<br />
know. And so they have no excuse for their passivity bordering<br />
on indifference. Those who, like you my friends, try to break the<br />
walls of their apathy deserve everyone’s support and everyone’s<br />
solidarity….<br />
…As for myself, I have been involved in the efforts to help<br />
Sudanese victims for some years. It was a direct or indirect<br />
consequence of a millennium lecture I had given in the White<br />
House on the subject, “The Perils of Indifference”. After I<br />
concluded, a woman in the audience rose and said: “I am from<br />
Rwanda.” She asked me how I could explain the international<br />
community’s indifference to the Rwandan massacres. I turned to<br />
the President [Clinton] who sat at my right and said: “Mr.<br />
President, you better answer this question. You know as well as<br />
we do that the Rwanda tragedy, which cost from 600,000 to<br />
800,000 victims, innocent men, women and children, could have<br />
been averted. Why wasn’t it?” His answer was honest and<br />
sincere: “It is true, that tragedy could have been averted. That’s<br />
why I went there to apologize in my personal name and in the<br />
name of the American people. But I promise you: it will not<br />
happen again.”<br />
The next day I received a delegation from Sudan and friends of<br />
Sudan, headed by a Sudanese refugee bishop. They informed<br />
me that two million Sudanese had already died.<br />
They said, “You are now the custodian of the President’s pledge.<br />
Let him keep it by helping stop the genocide in Sudan.”<br />
That brutal tragedy is still continuing, now in Sudan’s <strong>Darfur</strong><br />
region. Now its horrors are shown on television screens and on<br />
front pages of influential publications. Congressional delegations,<br />
special envoys and humanitarian agencies send back or bring<br />
back horror-filled reports from the scene. A million human<br />
beings, young and old, have been uprooted, deported. Scores<br />
of women are being raped every day; children are dying of<br />
disease, hunger and violence.<br />
How can a citizen of a free country not pay attention? How can<br />
anyone, anywhere not feel outraged? How can a person, whether<br />
religious or secular, not be moved by compassion? And above<br />
all, how can anyone who remembers remain silent?<br />
As a Jew who does not compare any event to the Holocaust,<br />
I feel concerned and challenged by the Sudanese tragedy.<br />
We must be involved. How can we reproach the indifference of<br />
non-Jews to <strong>Jewish</strong> suffering if we remain indifferent to another<br />
people’s plight?<br />
It happened in Cambodia, then in former Yugoslavia, and in<br />
Rwanda, now in Sudan. Asia, Europe, Africa: Three continents<br />
have become prisons, killing fields and cemeteries for countless<br />
innocent, defenseless populations. Will the plague be allowed to<br />
spread?<br />
“Lo taamod al dam réakha” is a Biblical commandment.<br />
“Thou shall not stand idly by the shedding of the blood of thy<br />
fellow man.” The word is not “akhikha,” thy <strong>Jewish</strong> brother, but<br />
“réakha,” thy fellow human being, be he or she <strong>Jewish</strong> or not.<br />
All are entitled to live with dignity and hope. All are entitled to live<br />
without fear and pain.<br />
Not to assist Sudan’s victims today would for me be unworthy of<br />
what I have learned from my teachers, my ancestors and my<br />
friends, namely that God alone is alone: His creatures must not be.<br />
What pains and hurts me most now is the simultaneity of events.<br />
While we sit here and discuss how to behave morally, both<br />
individually and collectively, over there, in <strong>Darfur</strong> and elsewhere in<br />
Sudan, human beings kill and die.<br />
Should the Sudanese victims feel abandoned and neglected, it<br />
would be our fault – and perhaps our guilt. That’s why we must<br />
intervene. If we do, they and their children will be grateful for us.<br />
As will be, through them, our own”.<br />
12
13<br />
<strong>Darfur</strong>: A <strong>Jewish</strong> <strong>Response</strong><br />
JEWISH TEXTS<br />
On saving lives<br />
You shall not stand idly by the blood of your neighbour; I am God.<br />
Vayikra, 19:16<br />
Maimonides (Rambam), one of the great <strong>Jewish</strong> scholars and theologians expanded this further:<br />
Whenever a person can save another person’s life but fails to do so, he transgresses a negative commandment, as [Lev.19:16] states: “Do<br />
not stand idly by the blood of your neighbour.” Similarly, [this commandment applies] when a person sees a colleague drowning at sea or<br />
being attacked by robbers or a wild animal, and he can save him himself or can hire others to save him. Similarly, [it applies] when he<br />
hears [others] conspiring to harm a colleague or planning a snare for him, and he does not inform him and notify him [of the danger].<br />
Rambam, Laws of the Murderer and Protecting Life, 1:14<br />
Rambam lists many different scenarios when we are obligated to save a life.<br />
Is this applicable to our responsibility to the people of <strong>Darfur</strong>?<br />
Whose lives are we responsible for?<br />
Traditionally, our sense of involvement with the fate of others has been in inverse proportion to the distance separating us and them. What<br />
has changed is that television and the Internet have effectively abolished distance. They have brought images of suffering in far-off lands<br />
into our immediate experience. Our sense of compassion for the victims of poverty, war and famine, runs ahead of our capacity to act. Our<br />
moral sense is simultaneously activated and frustrated. We feel that something should be done, but what, how, and by whom?<br />
Chief Rabbi Jonathan Sacks, The Dignity of Difference, (2006), p30<br />
Noting Rabbi Jonathan Sacks’ comments, how might the biblical phrase “You shall not stand idly by the blood of your<br />
neighbour” apply to us today as Jews living in the era of global media and communication? Who counts today as our<br />
‘neighbour’?<br />
Mishnah Sanhedrin 4:12 (according to the Kaufmann mishnah)<br />
For this reason the first human was created to teach that anyone who destroys a single soul is considered as though he had destroyed the<br />
entire world. Anyone who saves a single soul, is considered as though he has saved an entire universe.<br />
What does this suggest our responsibility is to others?<br />
Bear in mind the following text which seems to imply that all human beings are of infinite value.<br />
-<br />
And God created man in his image, in the image of God he created him; male and female he created them.<br />
What are we responsible for?<br />
Bereishit; 1:27<br />
Whoever can prevent his household from committing a sin but does not, is responsible for the sins of his household; if he can prevent the<br />
people of his city, he is responsible for the sins of his fellow citizens; if the whole world, he is responsible for the sins of the whole world.<br />
Babylonian Talmud, Shabbat 54b<br />
If I am not for myself, who will be for me?<br />
If I am only for myself what am I?<br />
If not now, when?<br />
This Text page has been adapted from a joint publication between Yeshiva University and American <strong>Jewish</strong> World Service and can be<br />
found online at www.ajws.org/uploaded_documents<br />
Hillel<br />
Pirkei Avot, 1:14<br />
14
15<br />
<strong>Darfur</strong>: A <strong>Jewish</strong> <strong>Response</strong><br />
WILL ANYTHING I DO MAKE ANY<br />
DIFFERENCE?<br />
The story of Rosenstrasse<br />
‘Until February 1943 Jews in mixed families had escaped<br />
deportation to death camps. Many, instead, had been<br />
sent to forced labour camps, and wives were pressured<br />
to divorce such husbands. Some did, but others<br />
remained loyal. In 1943, as part of the Nazis “Final<br />
Roundup” of over 60,000 Berlin Jews, they rounded up<br />
some 2500 <strong>Jewish</strong> men and boys, the husbands and<br />
sons of non-<strong>Jewish</strong> women, and imprisoned them at<br />
Rosenstrasse 2-4, the <strong>Jewish</strong> Community Centre.<br />
The Nazis wanted to keep the Rosenstrasse detention<br />
place secret, but the women found out where the men had<br />
been taken and converged there. The first day there were<br />
600 women. A solidarity emerged, and a spontaneous<br />
demonstration erupted as they shouted, “Give us our<br />
husbands back.” Other family members joined them.<br />
It was the first time there had been a public<br />
demonstration against the Nazis. The protests grew to<br />
include as many as 6,000 people over the week.<br />
The police dispersed them, warning they would shoot,<br />
but the women regrouped, without leaders or weapons.<br />
The guards pointed machine guns at them and<br />
threatened to open fire. The women held their ground<br />
and shouted, “Murderer, murderer, murderer!”<br />
After a week, propagandist Joseph Goebbels, who<br />
indicated in his diary that he was worried about the<br />
protest’s public relations impact in Germany and abroad,<br />
ordered that the Jews with Aryan spouses or parents be<br />
released. Twenty-five of those who were freed had<br />
already been sent to Auschwitz. And then the event<br />
seemed to vanish from history.’<br />
If the most brutal genocidal regime can been influenced by the<br />
power of public protest and opinion then this is proof that<br />
individuals are able to effect change.<br />
The indictments at the International Criminal Court provide some<br />
evidence that pressure is working.<br />
It is not your duty to finish the work, but you are not at liberty to<br />
neglect it.<br />
Pirkei Avot, 2: 21<br />
EXAMPLES OF INTERNATIONAL JEWISH<br />
CAMPAIGN GROUPS<br />
THE USA<br />
The American <strong>Jewish</strong> community has been instrumental in the<br />
creation and running of the Save <strong>Darfur</strong> Coalition in America.<br />
Organisations such as the American <strong>Jewish</strong> World Service<br />
(AJWS), an international development organisation, and the<br />
Religious Action Centre of the Reform Movement are on the<br />
executive committee of the coalition with many others that are<br />
national members. AJWS is also supporting those living in<br />
refugee and IDP camps in <strong>Darfur</strong> and neighbouring Chad.<br />
Hillel, which represents <strong>Jewish</strong> students on university campuses,<br />
has been encouraging <strong>Jewish</strong> students to be involved in<br />
campaigning at university, and many of the central synagogue<br />
movements and rabbinical bodies are promoting campaigning,<br />
advocating and fundraising within their constituent member<br />
communities. In Canada, Ve’ahavta, another <strong>Jewish</strong><br />
development organisation is a member of the coalition<br />
Canadians For Action in <strong>Darfur</strong>, and has supported a relief<br />
program run by Israeli Humanitarian Agencies in Chad working<br />
with refugees from <strong>Darfur</strong>.<br />
ISRAEL<br />
Over 300 <strong>Darfur</strong>is have found their way to Israel and several<br />
different organisations/groups have been established to<br />
campaign on their behalf. A Knesset Lobby for <strong>Darfur</strong><br />
Refugees has been set up by a group of MKs from across the<br />
political spectrum. The Committee for Advancement of<br />
Refugees from <strong>Darfur</strong> (CARD) is a coalition of nine NGOs that<br />
deal mainly with immigrant and workers rights, as well as<br />
individuals who are concerned about the situation of <strong>Darfur</strong>i<br />
refugees in Israel. CARD campaigns for the release of all <strong>Darfur</strong>i<br />
citizens who are currently detained within Israel and for them to<br />
be issued with identity documents and extended stay visas.<br />
Hatzilu et Amei <strong>Darfur</strong> (HAeD) has been established by a<br />
group of students in Israel from round the world studying in<br />
Yeshivot and on other gap year programmes in Israel. They<br />
campaign both for the rights of <strong>Darfur</strong>is living in Israel and for an<br />
end to the genocide. Israel for <strong>Darfur</strong> campaigns along similar<br />
lines as HAeD.<br />
EUROPE AND THE REST OF THE WORLD<br />
The Union of <strong>Jewish</strong> Students in the UK has been involved in<br />
mobilising its students on <strong>Darfur</strong>, and many of the dedicated<br />
<strong>Darfur</strong> campaign groups on university campuses have been set<br />
up by <strong>Jewish</strong> students. The European Union of <strong>Jewish</strong><br />
Students, following a visit of EUJS representatives to Rwanda in<br />
2006, now works to raise awareness of the situation in <strong>Darfur</strong><br />
amongst <strong>Jewish</strong> students in Europe, and campaigns for action<br />
at the United Nations and European Union. It is a member of<br />
the Globe for <strong>Darfur</strong> coalition of organisations, and is currently<br />
preparing a seminar on Genocide Denial for 2008. The<br />
Australasian Union of <strong>Jewish</strong> Students has been<br />
encouraging <strong>Jewish</strong> students to raise the issue of <strong>Darfur</strong> in<br />
universities in Australia and New Zealand.<br />
The Berlin <strong>Jewish</strong> Museum in conjunction with Human Rights<br />
Watch, in March 2007 ran a week a campaign week on <strong>Darfur</strong>,<br />
aiming to raise the levels of awareness of the situation. The<br />
<strong>Jewish</strong> Museum in Cape Town, in conjunction with the Aegis<br />
Trust held an exhibition on the situation in <strong>Darfur</strong>. The <strong>Pears</strong><br />
<strong>Foundation</strong> helped the Aegis Trust to establish the ‘Protect<br />
<strong>Darfur</strong>’ campaign in 2005. It is now educating and mobilising<br />
the British <strong>Jewish</strong> community through the production of ‘<strong>Darfur</strong> -<br />
A <strong>Jewish</strong> <strong>Response</strong>’, campaigning for high-level action, and<br />
supporting the work of Alliance Darc, Crisis Action, the Union of<br />
<strong>Jewish</strong> Students, the Aegis Trust and other NGOs.<br />
The contact details for organisations listed above can be<br />
found on the ‘Contacts Page’ of this booklet.<br />
16
<strong>Darfur</strong>: A <strong>Jewish</strong> <strong>Response</strong><br />
ACTION YOU CAN TAKE<br />
Demonstrate<br />
© Aegis Trust<br />
17<br />
“If every member of the House of Representatives and<br />
Senate had received 100 letters from people back<br />
home saying we have to do something about<br />
Rwanda… I think the response would have been<br />
different.”<br />
“It felt like my feet<br />
were praying.”<br />
…said Rabbi Abraham Joshua Heschel,<br />
one of the great <strong>Jewish</strong> theologians of the<br />
twentieth century, describing his<br />
experience of marching from Selma to<br />
Montgomery with Martin Luther King in<br />
1964 as part of the American Civil rights<br />
movement.<br />
Global Day for <strong>Darfur</strong> is held all over<br />
the globe to highlight the situation in<br />
Late Illinois Senator (D), Paul Simon<br />
<strong>Darfur</strong> and to pressure the international community to respond.<br />
See www.globefordarfur.org for up-to-date details of events.<br />
Write letters<br />
Write regularly to your MP and to the Secretary of State for<br />
Foreign Affairs or even the Prime Minister.<br />
You can write to your MP on www.writetothem.com or by<br />
sending it for their attention at the address below. You could<br />
also write to a representative in the House of Lords. A sample<br />
letter can be found in the Appendix.<br />
House of Commons, House of Lords,<br />
London, London,<br />
SW1A 0AA SW1A 0PW<br />
International campaign organisations and humanitarian groups<br />
suggest the following issues should be addressed in any letters<br />
to politicians:<br />
• The implementation by the United Nations of a ‘no fly<br />
zone’ over western Sudan to stop government air strikes<br />
on civilians in <strong>Darfur</strong><br />
• The implementation of additional sanctions by the<br />
European Union and the United Nations against all of<br />
the seventeen individuals identified by the United<br />
Nations International Commission of Inquiry to prevent<br />
them from travelling, and from sustaining and benefiting<br />
from the ongoing conflict by freezing their assets<br />
• The deployment of a UN peacekeeping force to Chad,<br />
to prevent voilence spilling over from <strong>Darfur</strong> and to<br />
stabilise the border areas<br />
• The deployment of a United Nations peacekeeping<br />
force to strengthen the existing African Union mission in<br />
Sudan<br />
• The removal by the British government of <strong>Darfur</strong>is in<br />
Britain back to Sudan<br />
Letters could also be written to the Chinese Embassy in London<br />
asking them to acknowledge at the United Nations the gravity of<br />
the situation in <strong>Darfur</strong>:<br />
Embassy of the People’s Republic of China in the United<br />
Kingdom, 49 Portland Place, London, W1B 1JL<br />
Divestment Campaigning<br />
The genocide is expensive: as well as the significant<br />
costs of using its army and air force to commit genocide<br />
on the people of <strong>Darfur</strong>, Human Rights Watch has also put<br />
forward significant evidence to show that the Sudanese<br />
government is increasingly treating the Janjaweed like a<br />
regular army. They show that Janjaweed fighters and<br />
officers are paid approximately double the wages of their<br />
regular army counterparts.<br />
The government of Sudan therefore needs money,<br />
and has no shortage of it: The economy in Sudan is<br />
thriving thanks to the intense involvement of foreign<br />
companies in the extraction of oil. Investment in oil rose<br />
from $128 million in 2000 to an estimated $2.3billion in<br />
2006 and growth is almost hitting double figures. Much of<br />
Sudanese oil revenue is spent on the Sudanese military;<br />
increasing Khartoum’s capability to wage its genocidal<br />
counter-insurgency campaign.<br />
Sudan Divestment UK organises and coordinates the<br />
divestment campaign in the UK. Its model targets companies<br />
that meet the following criteria:<br />
• Contribute to government revenue or government<br />
sponsored project;<br />
• Impart minimal benefit to the country’s people; and<br />
• Have demonstrated no substantial corporate<br />
governance policy regarding the <strong>Darfur</strong> situation.<br />
Targeted divestment means that companies that benefit the<br />
people of Sudan are not affected by a divestment campaign.<br />
See www.sudandivestment.org.uk for a step-by-step guide on<br />
how to divest.<br />
Raise funds for <strong>Darfur</strong><br />
Raise funds, alongside educating your community, to support<br />
the efforts of campaign organisations or humanitarian assistance<br />
agencies working for <strong>Darfur</strong>.<br />
Fundraising ideas:<br />
• Sponsored events<br />
• Supper quiz<br />
• Film screening: hire out a local cinema or hall and sell<br />
tickets to raise money and awareness. You could show<br />
films about the Rwandan genocide or <strong>Darfur</strong>, such as<br />
Shooting Dogs or Hotel Rwanda, or The Devil Came on<br />
Horseback (see Films, Books & Articles section for more<br />
ideas)<br />
• Football tournament<br />
with players wearing<br />
Protect <strong>Darfur</strong> t-shirts<br />
and wristbands<br />
© Aegis Trust<br />
18
19<br />
<strong>Darfur</strong>: A <strong>Jewish</strong> <strong>Response</strong><br />
WHAT YOU CAN DO IN YOUR SYNAGOGUE<br />
‘Religious leaders should never seek power, but neither may they<br />
abdicate their task of being a counter-voice in the conversation of<br />
mankind’<br />
Chief Rabbi Sir Jonathan Sacks, The Dignity of Difference<br />
Traditionally a synagogue is referred to as a Bet haTefillah –<br />
– House of Prayer, a Bet haMidrash –<br />
– House of Study and a Bet haKnesset –<br />
– House of Meeting. There are many<br />
different ways that synagogues can be involved in the<br />
<strong>Darfur</strong> campaign, through praying, learning about the<br />
issue, and acting on it. Rabbis and teachers have a<br />
captive audience with whom this issue can be raised. This<br />
section provides some ideas and examples of how to<br />
bring the genocide in <strong>Darfur</strong> into the forefront of the minds<br />
of your congregation.<br />
PRAY FOR DARFUR<br />
On Sunday 17th September 2006 an International Day for <strong>Darfur</strong><br />
was organised with public events staged in prominent places<br />
around the world. This included prayers for <strong>Darfur</strong> from<br />
community leaders from many different religions. Both Chief<br />
Rabbi Sir Jonathan Sacks and Rabbi Janet Burden wrote prayers<br />
that were used in this event and which are published as<br />
examples below. A prayer is also included from the<br />
Reconstructionist Siddur in America. These prayers can be used<br />
and adapted within your communities.<br />
Prayer for the people of <strong>Darfur</strong> by Chief<br />
Rabbi Sir Jonathan Sacks<br />
O God of Peace,<br />
Who commands us to seek peace,<br />
Send peace to the people of <strong>Darfur</strong>.<br />
O God of compassion,<br />
Who hears the cry of the afflicted,<br />
Hear the cry of the victims,<br />
The bereaved, the injured,<br />
And all those who live their days in fear.<br />
Rouse the hearts of the leaders of the world<br />
To put an end to the bloodshed, the violence,<br />
The rape, the starvation, and the terror,<br />
That has ravaged and endangered an entire population.<br />
Be with those who are working for peace,<br />
Or tending the sick,<br />
Or bringing food to the hungry,<br />
Or shelter to the homeless,<br />
O God of justice and love,<br />
Let us not be indifferent<br />
To the cry of the persecuted<br />
And the tears of those who have seen<br />
Their homes, their families and their communities destroyed.<br />
And may their plea and their plight<br />
Reach the ears and hearts of those who have it in their power<br />
To bring peace to a troubled region<br />
And aid to a devastated people.<br />
Oseh shalom bimromav:<br />
May You who makes peace in Your high places<br />
Help us make peace down here on earth.<br />
Amen.<br />
Prayer for the people of <strong>Darfur</strong> by Rabbi<br />
Janet Burden, West Central Liberal<br />
Synagogue and the South Bucks <strong>Jewish</strong><br />
Community<br />
Av Ha-rachamim, Source of Compassion, You have created all<br />
your children in the Divine image. We are called upon to<br />
recognise Your essence in our fellow human beings and to hold<br />
their lives as sacred.<br />
Your Torah teaches that we must not stand idly by the blood of<br />
our neighbours, nor turn away from their suffering. We are<br />
commanded to seek peace and pursue it – not just for<br />
ourselves, but also for all peoples. And so we pray:<br />
Eternal God of truth and justice, grant wisdom to the powerful,<br />
that they may use their power to protect those who live in fear for<br />
their lives. Help those who govern remain ever mindful of the<br />
plight of the vulnerable. Give them the courage to act justly.<br />
O God, You support the falling and who lift up those who are<br />
bowed down. You are ever present in the healing powers that<br />
You have implanted within Your creatures. Help those who<br />
remain in either physical or emotional pain, and may the<br />
sufferings of the afflicted soon be ended.<br />
Prayer for Peace, Shlomit, Age 13,<br />
Jerusalem, From Shabbat Vehagim,<br />
Reconstructionist Press<br />
What shall I ask You for, God? I have everything.<br />
There’s nothing I lack. I ask only for one thing and<br />
not for myself alone; It’s for many mothers, children<br />
and fathers - Not just in this land, but in many lands<br />
hostile to each other. I’d like to ask for Peace. Yes,<br />
its Peace I want, And You, You won’t deny the<br />
single wish of a child. You created the Land of<br />
Peace, Where stands the City of Peace, Where<br />
stood the Temple of Peace, But where there is still<br />
no Peace... What shall I ask for God? I have<br />
everything. Peace is what I ask for, Only Peace.<br />
GIVE A SERMON ON DARFUR<br />
Rabbinical sermons provide a prime opportunity to both educate<br />
a community as well as provide suggestions and ideas for<br />
action. Printed below are some examples of sermons that have<br />
been written by Rabbis.<br />
Extracts from a sermon at The Hampstead<br />
Synagogue (United Synagogue) by Rabbi<br />
Dr. Michael J. Harris<br />
First day Rosh Hashana 5767, 23rd<br />
September 2006<br />
Although Rosh Hashanah is the <strong>Jewish</strong> new year, it is not just<br />
about the <strong>Jewish</strong> people but about everyone, about the whole<br />
world. Hayom harat olam – today is the birthday of the world,<br />
according to tradition the anniversary of the creation of the<br />
human race on the sixth day of creation. Hayom ya’amid<br />
bamishpat kol yetsurei olamim – the whole world is judged, not<br />
just the <strong>Jewish</strong> people. The Mishna in Rosh HaShana (1:2) says<br />
quite explicitly BeRosh HaShanah kol ba’ei ha’olam ovrin lefanav.<br />
There is a very strong universalist thrust to Rosh HaShanah and<br />
indeed to the High Holydays overall. We acknowledge God as<br />
melech al kol ha’aretz, King of the entire world, and ask that His<br />
sovereignty manifest itself over the world as a whole.<br />
With this universalist dimension of Rosh Hashanah in mind, I<br />
want to talk today about the <strong>Jewish</strong> relationship to the wider<br />
world, the non-<strong>Jewish</strong> world that is as relevant to the Yamim<br />
Noraim as the <strong>Jewish</strong> one. What is the moral attitude that<br />
traditional Judaism expects Jews to adopt towards non-Jews?<br />
Maimonides spells out the answer very clearly. Compassion<br />
towards everyone, not just Jews, is an integral part of the<br />
mitzvah of imitatio Dei, imitating God’s attributes, walking in His<br />
ways. The words he quotes in this context, from Psalm 130, are<br />
“God’s mercies extend to all His creatures”. We are to try our<br />
best to be compassionate people, because we are commanded<br />
to emulate the qualities of God, Who is compassionate. And if<br />
we are compassionate people, if we have a compassionate<br />
nature, then we will be compassionate not just to our own, not<br />
just to other Jews, but to everybody.<br />
20
21<br />
<strong>Darfur</strong>: A <strong>Jewish</strong> <strong>Response</strong><br />
What Maimonides is interested in here is the kind of people we<br />
are. Philosophers make a distinction between act-morality and<br />
agent-morality. Act-morality means my acts are right, I do the<br />
right thing. Agent-morality is a superior moral level – I don’t just<br />
do the right thing, I’m the kind of person whose good nature is<br />
such that I naturally do the right thing. I don’t need to force<br />
myself or look in a book to know what the right thing to do is.<br />
Maimonides is interested in agent morality. He says we have to<br />
strive to be the kind of people who naturally act in a<br />
compassionate way. That, he says, is what Judaism requires.<br />
And once we are that kind of person, there will automatically be<br />
no restrictions on the breadth of our reach. A naturally<br />
compassionate person can’t help being compassionate towards<br />
all, and so a naturally compassionate Jew will be incapable of<br />
limiting compassion based on ethnic or religious divisions and<br />
will reach out to non-Jews just as he or she does to Jews.<br />
It is not difficult to find concrete examples to which this noble<br />
<strong>Jewish</strong> ideal urgently needs to be applied in these very days. For<br />
any <strong>Jewish</strong> person of conscience, <strong>Darfur</strong> is a major concern this<br />
Rosh Hashanah. Terrible atrocities have already taken place there,<br />
and without an ongoing international presence things could God<br />
forbid become much worse. The lives of millions of people are at<br />
stake. Decent people said ‘Never Again’ after the Shoah and<br />
much more recently after Rwanda. This time action must match<br />
the words. All good people and governments must do everything<br />
they can to prevent further tragedy, and the <strong>Jewish</strong> community in<br />
particular must continue to help keep this issue in the public eye…<br />
‘Sudan and Our <strong>Response</strong>’<br />
by Rabbi Harold M. Schulweis, Valley Beth<br />
Shalom, California, 26th August 2005<br />
(reprinted courtesy of AJWS)<br />
What have we to do with a people we do not know, in a land we<br />
have not visited? What have we to do with people of another<br />
faith, another culture, another civilization? Have we Jews not<br />
sufficient burdens of our own? Is the struggle against anti-<br />
Semitism not enough for us? Are we so numerous that we can<br />
take on the suffering of others not our kinsmen?<br />
We Jews see with ancient eyes. We have seen the torture, the<br />
starvation, the death by disease, the rapes, the abandonment by<br />
the civilized world before. We Jews possess a terrible<br />
knowledge, an awesome wisdom we gained not out of books,<br />
but out of our own bodies. A knowledge out of the testimony of<br />
numbers seared into the skin of living human beings and the<br />
stench of burned flesh. We see with ancient eyes: We are eye<br />
witnesses to the consequences of the callousness of lethal<br />
silence. We offer testimony to the morbid symptoms of apathy,<br />
the moral laryngitis that strangles the voice of protest.<br />
We see with ancient eyes: Embassies shut down, visa denied,<br />
borders sealed off, refugee ships returned to the ports that<br />
transported the persecuted into the furnaces of hell. And we know<br />
what happens when churches are complicit with the killers of the<br />
dream. With ancient eyes we see <strong>Darfur</strong> with a shock of<br />
recognition. We experience a collective deja vu even as we speak.<br />
More than two million frightened souls fleeing homes in <strong>Darfur</strong>,<br />
400,000 helpless people murdered, the terror of the Janjaweed,<br />
which in Arabic is derived from “jan” – which means “evil”, and<br />
“jawed” – which means “horsemen,” soldiers on horses with<br />
swords, whips and truncheons, beating down a people and<br />
trampling them. We heard before the treacherous excuses, the<br />
lying alibis, the rationalizations from church and state and international<br />
bodies.<br />
We count six million alibis. They said: What can we do? We are<br />
too few, too weak, too exhausted, the enemy too implacable. Do<br />
we not have a prior responsibility to our own church, to our own<br />
parish, to our own congregants?<br />
Are these reports really genocide or just propaganda? We Jews<br />
remember what we expected sixty years ago. We prayed and<br />
hoped for a cry, a protest from out of the basilica, from out of the<br />
nave, from out of the cathedral, some proclamation of a fast,<br />
some decision to march in public, some demonstration on to the<br />
streets and marketplaces, some sob of conscience that could<br />
pierce the hardness of the heart: Can we do less? Like the<br />
Psalmist we cry to God into the ears of man: “Rouse Yourself –<br />
why do You sleep? Awaken – why do You hide Your face and<br />
ignore our affliction?”<br />
‘Praying, Reflecting… and Being Watched’,<br />
Parshat Balak, by Rabbi Kenneth Chasen,<br />
Leo Baeck Temple, Los Angeles,<br />
15th July 2005 (reprinted courtesy of AJWS)<br />
Many of you already know, from the email message that I sent<br />
out yesterday to our entire congregation, that legislation was<br />
recently introduced onto the floor of the United States Senate to<br />
make this weekend a National Weekend of Prayer and Reflection<br />
for <strong>Darfur</strong>, where genocide has been taking place for nearly two<br />
years. A national weekend of prayer and reflection about<br />
genocide. So, almost instantly, I entered into prayer and<br />
reflection. “O God,” I prayed, “let Congress stop passing<br />
legislation asking us to pray and reflect… for while we pray,<br />
hundreds of thousands of dark-skinned <strong>Darfur</strong>ians are being<br />
systematically murdered, raped, displaced and starved. God,<br />
inspire Congress to provide massive humanitarian relief that will<br />
fight the spread of disease and hunger, and to use economic<br />
and military means if necessary to stop the genocide.” And then<br />
I moved from prayer to reflection. I reflected upon Congress’<br />
failure to take this kind of action. I reflected upon the failure of<br />
Congress’ constituents… you and me… to make enough noise<br />
to force Congress to stop the killing. And then it seemed like<br />
time to stop praying and reflecting.<br />
The truth, of course, is that it was time to stop praying and<br />
reflecting – and time to start acting – almost two years ago,<br />
when this crisis began. Or, at minimum, perhaps a year ago<br />
would have been a reasonable time to stop praying and<br />
reflecting... We’ll pray and reflect – but I trust that when we’re<br />
done, we’ll be ready to make their sleep less restful. For as<br />
Abraham Joshua Heschel once taught, while only “some may be<br />
guilty, all are responsible.”<br />
… I’ve spoken with so many of our Temple members who look<br />
upon the situation in <strong>Darfur</strong> with such hopelessness. “It’s so far<br />
away,” they say, “and so systemic and beyond our control – how<br />
can we even hope to make a difference?” The best answer<br />
comes from the late Illinois Senator, Paul Simon, who said, “If<br />
every member of the House of Representatives and Senate had<br />
received 100 letters from people back home saying we have to<br />
do something about Rwanda … I think the response would have<br />
been different.”<br />
There can be no denying that the paralysis of the status quo in<br />
Washington is built upon a foundation of our silence. That is to<br />
say, elected officials will always be careful students of their<br />
constituents’ will. When large numbers of voters demand action,<br />
they act. When we say and do nothing, so do they.<br />
Congressional staffers literally count the phone calls and letters<br />
they receive on various issues. So who, then, is chiefly<br />
responsible for Congress’ failure to stop the genocide?<br />
…We have to stop the onslaught. And believe it or not, the<br />
mechanisms exist to do it. The UN’s Genocide Convention has<br />
all the necessary provisions to prevent the killings… if only we<br />
would demand their implementation. The folks on Capitol Hill<br />
might prefer it if we were content just to pray and reflect here<br />
tonight. It makes life easier on them. But our job is to make life<br />
easier on the victims, the targets of this atrocity. Will we earn<br />
blessing or curse for how we meet this moment?<br />
…The legendary founder of Chasidism, the Baal Shem Tov,<br />
made the following observation about Balaam’s ancient blessing<br />
over the Israelites. Remembering that our patriarch Jacob is<br />
renamed Israel only when he reaches a more exalted spiritual<br />
state, the Baal Shem Tov noticed an important nuance in the<br />
words of Balaam’s blessing: “How goodly are your tents, O<br />
Jacob, your dwelling places, O Israel.” Our tents – our external<br />
appearance, said the Baal Shem Tov – is that of Jacob… a lower<br />
level. But our dwelling places – the real content, the interior, the<br />
kishkes – they belong to Israel, and reflect a higher level.<br />
Praying and reflecting about genocide is all well and good, but our<br />
prayers are just the tents – the outer package, the appearance of<br />
our concern. To stop at praying and reflecting is to remain just<br />
Jacob. Acting to end the genocide of a people who look different<br />
than us, live differently than us, and suffer in places so far away as<br />
to be almost unreal to us? That’s where our inner determination<br />
shows – where we are lifted up to become Israel. May those who<br />
are watching us see Israel, and not Jacob – for when the slaughter<br />
is over, and the hundreds of thousands are never to return, we will<br />
surely want not to be remembered for curse.<br />
22
23<br />
<strong>Darfur</strong>: A <strong>Jewish</strong> <strong>Response</strong><br />
TEACHING & EDUCATING IN YOUR COMMUNITY<br />
Adult education sessions and cheder are ideal opportunities to<br />
alert members of your congregation to the situation in <strong>Darfur</strong>.<br />
There are countless resources online to aid you with the planning<br />
of sessions. Please see the contacts page for relevant websites<br />
and contact details.<br />
Suggestions for educational programmes:<br />
• Textual study session on the <strong>Jewish</strong> responsibility to act<br />
in times of distress<br />
• Use Yom Hashoah as a time to learn about genocide<br />
and the <strong>Jewish</strong> responsibility to respond<br />
• Use some of the programming ideas at the back of this<br />
booklet to educate members of the community<br />
• Arrange for your community to attend Day for <strong>Darfur</strong><br />
events. Further details can be found on-line at<br />
www.globefordarfur.org<br />
• Arrange for a <strong>Darfur</strong>i survivor to come and speak to your<br />
community about their experiences<br />
Bar/Bat Mitzvah/Chayil project<br />
‘At 13 one is ready to observe the mitzvot.’<br />
Judah ben Teima, Pirkei Avot 5:24<br />
‘Bar or Bat Mitzvah literally translates as ‘son or daughter of<br />
the commandment’ - or even better, as someone who is old<br />
enough to be responsible for the mitzvot…Bar or Bat Mitzvah<br />
tells the community that you are no longer just a child but a<br />
mature Jew who is ready to take on religious responsibilities’<br />
Rabbi Jeffrey Salkin, ‘Putting God on your guest list; How to<br />
claim the spiritual meaning of your Bar/Bat Mitzvah’/Chayil<br />
In every community there are rites of passage where a child<br />
enters into the <strong>Jewish</strong> religion as an adult. In preparation they<br />
begin to explore what it means to take on the responsibilities of<br />
Judaism and to understand more fully the obligations of the<br />
<strong>Jewish</strong> people including the role of Judaism in the wider world.<br />
Preparation for a Bar or Bat Mitzvah/Chayil is a good opportunity<br />
to look at global issues from a <strong>Jewish</strong> perspective.<br />
Ideas…<br />
• The genocide in <strong>Darfur</strong> could be the Tikkun<br />
Olam/Tsedakah project of the class. This allows the<br />
class to learn about the situation and also to raise<br />
money. If it is an ongoing project over the course of<br />
someone’s Bar or Bat Mitzvah/ Chayil preparation then it<br />
takes on a new meaning as a part of a journey to <strong>Jewish</strong><br />
adulthood.<br />
• As a class visit the Imperial War Museum Holocaust<br />
Exhibition or Beth Shalom Holocaust Memorial Museum<br />
in Nottinghamshire. Here they can learn about the<br />
tragedy that befell the <strong>Jewish</strong> people and about the<br />
current situation in <strong>Darfur</strong>.<br />
• In the USA a Bar Mitzvah boy learned about the situation<br />
in <strong>Darfur</strong> and decided to use his Bar Mitzvah as an<br />
opportunity to educate his friends and family who were<br />
invited to share his special day. Inside every invitation<br />
was a postcard which he asked them to post to<br />
President George W. Bush asking the USA to help<br />
protect the civilian population of <strong>Darfur</strong>. This story can<br />
be found in full on www.babaganewz.com<br />
• Use one of the programming ideas in the back of this<br />
booklet with a Bar/Bat Mitzvah/Chayil class and discuss<br />
whether, as <strong>Jewish</strong> adults, they feel that they have an<br />
obligation to act.<br />
WHAT YOU CAN DO IN YOUR SCHOOL<br />
Run an assembly on <strong>Darfur</strong><br />
If you are a teacher or a student arrange to run an assembly on<br />
<strong>Darfur</strong> to educate the students and the teachers about the<br />
situation. This could be either a one-off assembly or a series of<br />
assemblies. For example:<br />
• Assembly 1: What is happening in <strong>Darfur</strong>?<br />
• Assembly 2: Run an assembly on refugees and asylum<br />
seekers. This will help students to understand the<br />
differences between these terms and also why people<br />
end up being refugees<br />
• Assembly 3: Invite a <strong>Darfur</strong>i asylum seeker/refugee to<br />
come and speak in assembly<br />
• Assembly 4: Invite a representative from one of the<br />
campaigning organisation listed in the Contacts Page to<br />
meet with the students<br />
Run a school-wide educational campaign on <strong>Darfur</strong><br />
Ask each subject teacher to give over one of their lessons to<br />
educating about <strong>Darfur</strong>. For example:<br />
• Geography: The human and physical geography of the<br />
region<br />
• History: The history of the conflict in <strong>Darfur</strong><br />
• <strong>Jewish</strong> Studies: The <strong>Jewish</strong> obligation to respond to<br />
people in need<br />
• Art: Create wall displays or visual images of <strong>Darfur</strong> to<br />
use in the school<br />
• PSHE: What can you do? Use this class to look at the<br />
different ways that people can get involved in the<br />
campaign to Save and Protect <strong>Darfur</strong><br />
Use any of the programming ideas at the back of this booklet to<br />
help you with your lesson planning<br />
Run school wide fundraising campaign for <strong>Darfur</strong><br />
© Aegis Trust<br />
• Raise funds, alongside educating your schoo,l to<br />
support the efforts campaign organisations or<br />
humanitarian assistance agencies working on the<br />
<strong>Darfur</strong> Campaign.<br />
24
25<br />
<strong>Darfur</strong>: A <strong>Jewish</strong> <strong>Response</strong><br />
WHAT YOU CAN DO IN YOUR YOUTH<br />
MOVEMENT OR JEWISH SOCIETY<br />
Youth movements and <strong>Jewish</strong> societies are the perfect way to<br />
get the youth of the <strong>Jewish</strong> community mobilised on issues.<br />
Social Action Campaigns<br />
Many youth movements choose one social action issue that they<br />
take on as a youth movement for the year. Why not take on<br />
<strong>Darfur</strong> and put it into as many different aspects of your<br />
movement programming as possible. For example you could<br />
incorporate it into weekly meetings, camps and involve your<br />
students on their campuses.<br />
Run a one-off activity<br />
© Aegis Trust<br />
If your time is limited it is possible to run a one-off activity on<br />
<strong>Darfur</strong> and at the end of the activity for your members<br />
(chanichim) and leaders (madrichim) to partake in a small piece<br />
of activism. Use any of the programming ideas at the back of<br />
this booklet to help you with this.<br />
Programme <strong>Darfur</strong> into your<br />
summer or winter camps<br />
(machanot)<br />
Why not dedicate part or all of a<br />
camp to <strong>Darfur</strong>? You may well<br />
have a set theme to your camp<br />
already which is part of a<br />
broader movement educational<br />
process. You could incorporate<br />
<strong>Darfur</strong> into this by having one<br />
day on your camp that is set<br />
aside for social action or for a<br />
movement wide campaign that<br />
every member is participating in<br />
over the summer or winter. You can run activities on many<br />
different aspects of the genocide in <strong>Darfur</strong>. For example:<br />
1. What is the situation in <strong>Darfur</strong>?<br />
2. What does it have to do with us as Jews – from a<br />
historical perspective and from the perspective of <strong>Jewish</strong><br />
responsibility<br />
3. What happens to those who survive? Looking at the<br />
plight of refugees and how they are treated round the<br />
world and in the UK<br />
4. What can you do? How to get involved in the campaign<br />
to Protect <strong>Darfur</strong><br />
5. Arrange for a <strong>Darfur</strong>i survivor to visit your camp<br />
Get your students involved in <strong>Darfur</strong><br />
© Aegis Trust<br />
There are numerous ways to involve students in campaigning on<br />
<strong>Darfur</strong> and many student unions have societies dedicated to<br />
campaigning on <strong>Darfur</strong>. Here are some tips from the Aegis Trust<br />
for how to get involved as a student:<br />
• Email, telephone or write to your constituency MP about<br />
the situation in <strong>Darfur</strong>. Lobbying your MP really does<br />
make a difference and they will reply to you. Be persistent<br />
& repeat fortnightly or monthly<br />
• Email or write to the Secretary of State for International<br />
Development and the Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs<br />
• Keep genocide in the public consciousness: write an<br />
article on <strong>Darfur</strong> for your student newspaper. Derby Aegis<br />
Society received 2 media awards for its submissions to<br />
‘Dusted’ on <strong>Darfur</strong><br />
© Aegis Trust<br />
• Contact mainstream national media asking them to<br />
provide more detailed coverage of <strong>Darfur</strong><br />
• Start a Student Society if there isn’t one at your university,<br />
or get actively involved in an existing one<br />
• Print off fifty copies of each Protect <strong>Darfur</strong> Campaign<br />
Poster and stick them up around campus! An extremely<br />
cheap and effective way to raise awareness of genocide<br />
in <strong>Darfur</strong><br />
• Organise or join an existing rally, a Global Day for <strong>Darfur</strong>,<br />
or publicity-generating event such as a public<br />
demonstration or ‘die-in’<br />
• Consider a divestment campaign in your university<br />
© Aegis Trust / David Parry<br />
26
27<br />
<strong>Darfur</strong>: A <strong>Jewish</strong> <strong>Response</strong><br />
FILMS, BOOKS, ARTICLES<br />
FILMS AND DOCUMENTARIES<br />
BOOKS<br />
• 100 Days (2004)<br />
• Behind Enemy Lines (2001)<br />
• Chronicle Of A Genocide Foretold (1996)<br />
• <strong>Darfur</strong> Diaries (2006)<br />
• Hotel Rwanda (2004)<br />
• Itsembatsemba: Rwanda One Genocide Later (1996)<br />
• Shake Hands With the Devil: The Journey of Roméo<br />
Dallaire (2004)<br />
• Shooting Dogs (2005)<br />
• Sometimes in April (2005)<br />
• The Devil Came on Horseback (2007)<br />
• The Last Just Man (2002)<br />
• Welcome to Sarajevo (1997)<br />
Barnett, Michael (2003) Eye Witness to a Genocide: The<br />
United Nations and Rwanda, Cornell University Press<br />
Burg, Steven L. and Shoup, Paul S. (1999) The War in<br />
Bosnia: Ethnic Conflict and International Intervention,<br />
M.E. Sharpe<br />
Caputo, Philip (2005) Acts of Faith, Knopf Publishing<br />
Group<br />
Courtemanche, Gil (2004) A Sunday at the Pool in Kigali,<br />
Cannongate Books<br />
Dallaire, General Romeo (2005) Shake Hands with the<br />
Devil, Arrow<br />
De Waal, Alex and Flint, Julie (2005) <strong>Darfur</strong>: a short<br />
history of a long war, Zed Books<br />
Eggers, David (2006) What is the What?, McSweeney’s<br />
Gourevitch, Philip (2000) We wish to inform you that<br />
tomorrow we will be killed with our families, Picador<br />
Hatzfeld, Jean (2006) Machete Season: The Killers in<br />
Rwanda Speak, Picador<br />
Hecht, Joan (2005) The Journey of the Lost Boys: A<br />
Story of Courage, Faith and the Sheer Determination to<br />
Survive by a Group of Young Boys Called ‘The Lost Boys<br />
of Sudan’, Allswell Press<br />
Judah, Tim (1997) The Serbs: History, Myth and the<br />
Destruction of Yugoslavia, Yale University Press<br />
Keane, Fergal (1996) Letter to Daniel: Dispatches from<br />
the Heart, Penguin Books<br />
Keane, Fergal (1999) Letters Home, Penguin Books<br />
Keane, Fergal (1996) Season of Blood: Rwandan<br />
Journey, Penguin Books<br />
Koff, Clea (2005) The Bone Woman: Among the Dead in<br />
Rwanda, Bosnia, Croatia and Kosovo, Atlantic Books<br />
Lebor, Adam (2006) ‘Complicity with Evil’: The United<br />
Nations in the Age of Modern Genocide, Yale University<br />
Press<br />
Marlowe, Jen, Bain, Aisha and Shapiro, Adam (2006)<br />
The <strong>Darfur</strong> Diaries: Stories of Survival, Nation Books<br />
Melvern, Linda (2006) Conspiracy to Murder: The<br />
Rwandan Genocide, Verso Books<br />
Prunier, Gerard (2005) <strong>Darfur</strong>: the Ambiguous Genocide,<br />
Cornell University Press<br />
Prunier, Gerard (1995) The Rwanda Crisis: History of a<br />
Genocide, Columbia University Press<br />
Reeves, Eric (2007) A Long Day’s Dying: Critical<br />
Moments in the <strong>Darfur</strong> Genocide, The Key Publishing<br />
House<br />
Rohde, David (1997) Endgame: The Betrayal and Fall of<br />
Srebrenica, Europe’s Worst Massacre since World War II,<br />
Farrar, Straus and Girou<br />
Steidle, Brian and Steidle Wallace, Gretchen (2007) The<br />
Devil Came on Horseback: Bearing Witness to the<br />
Genocide in <strong>Darfur</strong>, PublicAffairs<br />
Suljagic, Emir (2005) Postcards from the Grave, Saqi<br />
Books<br />
ARTICLES AND IMPORTANT DOCUMENTS ABOUT<br />
DARFUR<br />
• Amnesty International Report on the spread of the<br />
Janjaweed into eastern Chard: ‘Chad: Civilians Under<br />
Attack’ (1 March 2007), http://web.amnesty.org/library<br />
• Documents from the International Criminal Court (ICC),<br />
including Prosecutor’s Application for the first <strong>Darfur</strong>related<br />
indictments, (27 February 2007)<br />
http://www.icc-cpi.int/cases/<strong>Darfur</strong>.html<br />
• ‘How John Q. Citizen Can Affect <strong>Darfur</strong>’, Colin Thomas-<br />
Jensen, Fort Worth Star Telegram (9th January 2007),<br />
www.crisisgroup.org/home/index.cfm?id=4605&l=1<br />
• Human Rights Watch Report on <strong>Darfur</strong>,<br />
http://hrw.org/doc?t=africa&c=darfur<br />
• Report on the International Committee on Intervention<br />
and State Sovereignty, ‘Responsibility to Protect’<br />
document, www.iciss.ca/report-en.asp<br />
• Sudan Comprehensive Peace Agreement – Key<br />
Provisions, (9 January 2005)<br />
www.iss.co.za/AF/profiles/Sudan/darfur/cpaprov.htm<br />
• United Nations Report of the High-Level on the situation<br />
of human rights in <strong>Darfur</strong> pursuant to Human Rights<br />
Council decision S-4/1010, www.ohchr.org/English<br />
28
29<br />
<strong>Darfur</strong>: A <strong>Jewish</strong> <strong>Response</strong><br />
USEFUL CONTACTS<br />
Aegis Trust: www.aegistrust.org UK’s leading Genocide<br />
Prevention Organisation, also see www.protectdarfur.org<br />
American <strong>Jewish</strong> World Service: www.ajws.org <strong>Jewish</strong><br />
International Development Organisation<br />
Amnesty International: www.amnesty.org.uk International<br />
human rights organisation<br />
Beth Shalom: www.bethshalom.com Holocaust Memorial and<br />
education centre in Nottinghamshire<br />
CARD: www.hotline.org.il/english/news/2006/Hotline122306.htm<br />
The Committee for Advancement of Refugees from <strong>Darfur</strong>,<br />
based in Israel<br />
Crisis Action: www.crisisaction.org Independent, non-profit<br />
organisation which aims to help avert conflicts, prevent human<br />
rights abuses and ensure governments fulfill their obligations to<br />
protect civilians<br />
<strong>Darfur</strong> Divestment Worldwide: www.darfurdivestment.org<br />
International campgaign dedicated to divestment from Sudan<br />
Genocide Intervention Network:<br />
www.genocideintervention.net US-based organisation dedicated<br />
to ending genocide<br />
HAe<strong>Darfur</strong>: www.haedarfur.org Israel-based organisation<br />
campaigning on the genocide and for the rights of Sudanese<br />
refugees in Israel<br />
Holocaust Educational Trust: www.het.org.uk<br />
Hands Up for <strong>Darfur</strong>: www.handsupfordarfur.co.uk<br />
Human Rights Watch: www.hrw.org<br />
Israel for <strong>Darfur</strong>: www.israelfordarfur.org Israel-based<br />
organisation campaigning on the genocide and for the rights of<br />
Sudanese refugees in Israel<br />
IsraAid: www.israaid.org.il Coordinating body of Israel-based<br />
international development organisations<br />
The <strong>Jewish</strong> Council for Racial Equality: www.jcore.org.uk<br />
<strong>Jewish</strong> organisation involved in race equality in the UK and<br />
refugee/asylum seeker campaigns<br />
Make Poverty History <strong>Jewish</strong> Coalition: www.eljc.org/mph<br />
Coalition of <strong>Jewish</strong> organisations, movements and synagogue<br />
bodies in the UK tackling poverty-related and social justice<br />
issues together<br />
RenéCassin: www.renecassin.org <strong>Jewish</strong> human rights group<br />
based in the UK<br />
Refugee Council: www.refugeecouncil.org.uk<br />
Save <strong>Darfur</strong>: www.savedarfur.org US-based organisation<br />
campaigning for <strong>Darfur</strong><br />
Sudan Divestment UK: www.sudandivestment.org.uk<br />
Organisation dedicated to running a Sudan Divestment<br />
Campaign in the UK<br />
TheyWorkforYou.com: www.theyworkforyou.com Website<br />
where you can find out who your MP is and what they have said<br />
about Sudan in Parliament<br />
Tzedek: www.tzedek.org.uk <strong>Jewish</strong> international development<br />
and educational charity based in the UK<br />
WriteToThem.Com: www.writetothem.com Website you can<br />
use to write directly to your MP<br />
World <strong>Jewish</strong> Relief: www.worldjewishrelief.org.uk Charity<br />
providing emergency and development aid to those in need<br />
throughout the world. You can send money to <strong>Darfur</strong> through<br />
WJR.<br />
Ve’ahavta www.veahavta.org Canadian based <strong>Jewish</strong><br />
international development organisation<br />
APPENDICES<br />
Contents<br />
I Programming ideas for young people 31<br />
II Resources for Activities 34<br />
Newspaper headlines: Quotes about<br />
immigrants 34<br />
Important definitions 35<br />
Myths and Facts 36<br />
UN Convention on the Prevention and<br />
Punishment of the Crime of Genocide 38<br />
<strong>Jewish</strong> Sources 39<br />
Quotes from survivor testimonies 41<br />
IV Sample letter 43<br />
V Maps 44<br />
VI Timeline of events 45<br />
VII Acknowledgements 48<br />
30
31<br />
<strong>Darfur</strong>: A <strong>Jewish</strong> <strong>Response</strong><br />
I PROGRAMMING IDEAS FOR YOUNG PEOPLE<br />
Programme 1: Genocide – what should<br />
the <strong>Jewish</strong> response be?<br />
Aims:<br />
• To understand what genocide is<br />
• To think about and discuss whether we have a particular<br />
responsibility to respond to genocide as Jews who<br />
ourselves have experienced a genocide<br />
• To think about what the phrase ‘Never Again’ means<br />
and whether this applies only to the <strong>Jewish</strong> people<br />
You will need:<br />
Trigger:<br />
Large paper<br />
A copy of the ‘Genocide Convention’<br />
Copies of the ‘Testimonies’ page<br />
Letter writing material including sample letters and<br />
addresses (this can be found in the ‘Action You Can<br />
Take’ section in this booklet)<br />
Brainstorm: Stick a large sheet of paper on the wall. Ask the<br />
group to try and define what a genocide is and write it up on the<br />
sheet of paper.<br />
Method:<br />
Divide your participants into small groups. Give each group a<br />
copy of the ‘Quotes from Testimonies’ page with each quote on<br />
separate pieces of paper cut up. Ask each group to decide<br />
what they think the phrases are describing.<br />
When they have guessed, tell them that they are quotes about<br />
four different genocides – The Holocaust, the genocide in<br />
Bosnia, Rwanda and the genocide in Sudan. Ask them to try<br />
and separate them into three different piles according to what<br />
they are describing.<br />
When they have completed this exercise ask one of the<br />
participants to read the Genocide Convention out to the rest of<br />
the group so everyone is clear on the accepted definition of<br />
genocide. It is a long document so if you feel it is too long read<br />
Articles 1,2,3 as these explain what constitutes genocide in<br />
international law. It is important to explain that the convention<br />
came into effect to ensure that no crime as great as the<br />
Holocaust would ever be committed again. Note the date of its<br />
adoption – 1948, 3 years after the end of the Second World War.<br />
Conclusion:<br />
Stick 4 envelopes around the room with the following statements<br />
on them and ask each participant to write their response to each<br />
statement on a small piece of paper and to put it inside the<br />
envelope. When they have done this for each envelope they<br />
should sit in small groups or as one large group and read the<br />
responses to each statement and discuss them.<br />
1. The genocide in <strong>Darfur</strong> is not something that is a<br />
concern of people living in the UK<br />
2. As the <strong>Jewish</strong> people, who know first-hand what it<br />
means to live through genocide, we have a special<br />
responsibility to help protect the civilians of <strong>Darfur</strong><br />
3. I feel that it is a <strong>Jewish</strong> obligation to help those that are<br />
suffering<br />
4. The UK government has a responsibility to look after<br />
those that are fleeing from Sudan and arriving in Britain<br />
as asylum seekers<br />
5. ‘We always hear the words ‘Never again’ – are we taking<br />
that literally?’ (Rabbi Jonathan Sacks) What is your<br />
opinion?<br />
Programme 2: Raising awareness about<br />
<strong>Darfur</strong><br />
Aims:<br />
• To raise awareness about the situation in <strong>Darfur</strong><br />
• To explore what happens to those who are affected by<br />
the genocide<br />
• To understand how to get involved in the campaign and<br />
how you can make a difference<br />
You will need:<br />
Trigger:<br />
A copy of the ‘Eye Witness Accounts’ sheet<br />
Copies of ‘Map of <strong>Darfur</strong>’<br />
A copy of the film ‘Tomorrow is too late’ which can be<br />
obtained from the Aegis Trust or can be found on-line<br />
at: www.protectdarfur.org/Multimedia.htm<br />
Copies of the ‘Background to <strong>Darfur</strong>’ section of this<br />
booklet<br />
The time-line with each event written on a separate<br />
sheet of paper but without the dates<br />
A blank time-line stuck to the wall<br />
Ask the group to brainstorm the word genocide; what they think it<br />
means and who is affected by it. If <strong>Darfur</strong> is not mentioned<br />
explain to them that there is a genocide taking place in <strong>Darfur</strong> and<br />
that the aim of the session is to learn more about the situation.<br />
Method:<br />
Play the ‘Tomorrow is Too Late’ film (4 minutes)<br />
Hand out the maps of Sudan and explain exactly where <strong>Darfur</strong> is<br />
in relation to the rest of the country. It may be helpful for you to<br />
put a map of Africa on the wall so that participants can see<br />
where Sudan is in relation to the rest of the continent.<br />
Read some of the ‘Eye-Witness Accounts’<br />
Build a time line of the conflict in Sudan: Put out on the ground<br />
sheets of paper (each sheet should have written on it one of the<br />
events in the timeline but with no date). You can choose which<br />
parts of the time line you think are relevant i.e. you do not have<br />
to include every detail. Give each person a copy of the<br />
‘Background to the genocide’ and together the group has to<br />
construct the chronology of events that have taken place in<br />
Sudan by sticking each event in order on the blank time line on<br />
the wall. Whoever is running the activity should explain the<br />
events as they are put on the wall.<br />
N.B if the group is too big this activity can be done in several<br />
smaller groups<br />
Conclusion:<br />
What can you do? This part of the session should be used for<br />
action. E.g. Ensure you have all the names of the relevant MPs<br />
etc and each person can write to their MP or plan a Divestment<br />
campaign or fundraiser. See the ‘Action You Can Take’ section<br />
for more ideas.<br />
Programme 3: What is a refugee?<br />
Aim:<br />
The aim of this programme is to explore what refugees and<br />
asylum seekers are and to understand the differences between<br />
them. There are approximately 1500 <strong>Darfur</strong>i refugees and<br />
asylum seekers in the UK and understanding the terms on which<br />
they are here and the status they are given is very important.<br />
You will need:<br />
Copies of the ‘Important Definitions Sheet’<br />
Copies of the ‘Myths and Facts Sheet’<br />
32
33<br />
<strong>Darfur</strong>: A <strong>Jewish</strong> <strong>Response</strong><br />
Trigger:<br />
Copies of ‘<strong>Jewish</strong> texts about refugees’<br />
Copy of the ‘newspaper headlines’<br />
Large paper and pens<br />
(5mins) Ask the group to move around the room and stand in<br />
correspondence to what they think about the following<br />
statements. One end of the room should be labelled ‘strongly<br />
agree’ and the other end of the room should be labelled<br />
‘strongly disagree’:<br />
1. Most asylum seekers are illegal and should be sent<br />
home<br />
2. If there were fewer asylum seekers there would be more<br />
spaces in hospitals<br />
3. People from other countries make the UK a more<br />
interesting place to be<br />
4. The UK should stop letting so many immigrants in<br />
5. Most asylum seekers and refugees should stay in the<br />
country because they deserve to be here<br />
Ask them to write down where they stood for each one so the<br />
activity can be repeated at the end and their answers can be<br />
compared.<br />
Method:<br />
(5mins) Brainstorm all the different reasons that people might<br />
come to the country to live<br />
(15min) Split into smaller groups and ask them to draw around a<br />
person and turn the drawing into what they think is a stereotypical<br />
refugee. When they have completed this they should<br />
come back together and feedback to each other what they<br />
thought.<br />
(10mins) What is an asylum seeker? What is a refugee?<br />
In small groups give out copies of the ‘important definitions’ with<br />
the definition headings separately. Ask them to match each<br />
definition to each heading. Come back together and go through<br />
all the definitions and check that they are correct.<br />
(10min) Split the group into pairs and give each pair the sheet on<br />
‘<strong>Jewish</strong> Sources and Refugees’ and ask them to read them and<br />
discuss briefly the contents. Get feedback from the pairs what<br />
their reactions are to these texts.<br />
(30min) Using the ‘Newspaper headlines’ sheet lay out all of the<br />
quotes on the floor with the dates removed and ask everyone to<br />
read them all and pick one which they agree/disagree with. Ask<br />
each person to say which one they picked and why. Ask them<br />
to guess when each one was written and then tell them (some of<br />
the headlines are contemporary and others are about Jews<br />
written in the early 20th century)<br />
Conclusion:<br />
(10min) Repeat exercise in the trigger so each person can see<br />
whether their opinions have changed. If there is more time<br />
and/or the group would like to discuss it further you can look at<br />
the myths/fact sheet in this booklet.<br />
II RESOURCES FOR ACTIVITIES<br />
Newspaper headlines: Quotes about<br />
Immigrants<br />
They are overrunning the country. They are trying to enter the<br />
medical profession in great numbers (Sunday Express, June<br />
1938)<br />
…are pouring in from every port of this country (Daily Mail 1938)<br />
The most cautious estimate is 50,000 bogus asylum seekers and<br />
illegals a year slipping into Britain (The Sun, 29 September 2003)<br />
…so-called asylum seekers who, in reality, seek no more than<br />
access to our welfare system (Leader comment, Sunday<br />
Express, 2 May 2004)<br />
One in five flock here; asylum: we’re too damn soft (Daily Star, 23<br />
January 2004)<br />
And they will stop bogus asylum seekers from getting NHS care,<br />
saving £1billion of taxpayers’ cash (The Sun, 31 July 2003)<br />
The ‘scum of the earth’ (Dover Express, 1938)<br />
The ‘flood is sinking Britain’ (Daily Star, 1938)<br />
East of Aldgate one walks into a foreign town (Major Evans<br />
Gordon, MP for Stepney, 1887)<br />
…under the constant danger of being driven from my home,<br />
pushed out into the streets, not by the natural increase of our own<br />
population but by the off-scum of Europe (Major Evans Gordon,<br />
MP for Stepney, 1887)<br />
Britain Is The Asylum Capital Of The World (The Express, 23<br />
March 2005)<br />
Kick Out This Scum (Daily Star, 2 March 2003)<br />
Refugees get jobs; Britons get dole (Sunday Pictorial, 1938)<br />
They will find these places literally infested with aliens (politician<br />
Sir Ernest Wild in 1919)<br />
...That the dirty, destitute, diseased, verminous and criminal<br />
foreigner who dumps himself on our soil and rates simultaneously,<br />
shall be forbidden to land. (An editorial in the Manchester<br />
Evening Chronicle in 1905)<br />
34
35<br />
<strong>Darfur</strong>: A <strong>Jewish</strong> <strong>Response</strong><br />
IMPORTANT DEFINITIONS Courtesy of JCORE MYTHS AND FACTS Courtesy of the Refugee Council<br />
A refugee is:<br />
• Someone who has fled their home and country because<br />
of fear or persecution.<br />
• They are people who have not been protected by their<br />
own government.<br />
• Refugees have been given refugee status by the<br />
government of a new country. This means they are<br />
allowed to stay indefinitely and have the same rights as<br />
any other citizens.<br />
An asylum seeker is:<br />
• Someone who has formally applied for asylum (a place<br />
of safety) in a new country.<br />
• Asylum seekers want to be recognised as refugees but<br />
are waiting for a government to decide on their<br />
application.<br />
Unaccompanied asylum seeking children are:<br />
• Children and young people under 18 years who have<br />
been separated from both parents and are not being<br />
cared for by an adult.<br />
An Internally displaced person:<br />
• Has had to leave their home but has not crossed an<br />
international border<br />
Indefinite leave to remain<br />
• Status given when you have been granted leave to<br />
remain in the UK but are not subject under immigration<br />
law to any conditions or restrictions on your period of<br />
stay.<br />
National Asylum Support Service (NASS)<br />
• Part of the Home Office, set up in 1999. It provides<br />
support to destitute asylum seekers and administers the<br />
asylum support system.<br />
Section 4 Support<br />
• An asylum seeker whose asylum claim has finally been<br />
refused and has no means of support, may be eligible<br />
for shelter and food vouchers, on condition that he/she<br />
agrees to return “voluntarily”, even if his/her country of<br />
origin is not safe. This may be granted if:<br />
- the individual is unable to travel out of the UK<br />
(because they are ill or pregnant)<br />
- the individual has been given permission to take out<br />
a Judicial Review of the asylum claim<br />
- the individual has already applied for travel documents<br />
- the Home Office claims there is no safe route of<br />
return to individual’s country<br />
- there are exceptional circumstances<br />
Asylum Support<br />
• Accommodation and financial help provided for asylum<br />
seekers whilst their claim is being considered by the UK<br />
government. If further enquiries are made as to the<br />
individual’s application, he/she has five working days to<br />
provide the required information. Failure to do so<br />
results in withdrawal of state provision.<br />
Limited leave to remain<br />
• The application is made in respect of a person who, at<br />
the time of making the application, has limited leave to<br />
enter or stay in the United Kingdom which was granted<br />
outside the provisions of the immigration rules on the<br />
rejection of his asylum claim, and needs to stay in the<br />
United Kingdom outside the provisions of the<br />
immigration rules.<br />
Appeal<br />
• A legal proceeding in which the individual resorts to a<br />
higher court for the purpose of obtaining a review of a<br />
lower court decision and a reversal of the lower court’s<br />
judgment or the granting of a new trial.<br />
Here are some examples of myths that have been printed in<br />
British newspapers:<br />
“ILLEGAL REFUGEES TARGETED ON<br />
TUBE”<br />
The Facts<br />
(The Observer, 11 July 2004)<br />
A refugee is someone who has applied for asylum and has by<br />
law been granted refugee status. ‘Illegal refugees’ do not exist,<br />
neither do ‘illegal asylum seekers’, another variation of this<br />
commonly used mistake. The fact that an asylum seeker may<br />
have entered the country illegally does not mean their case lacks<br />
credibility: the reverse is often true. It is virtually impossible for<br />
people fleeing persecution to reach Britain without resorting to<br />
the use of false documents.<br />
“…SO-CALLED ASYLUM SEEKERS WHO,<br />
IN REALITY, SEEK NO MORE THAN<br />
ACCESS TO OUR WELFARE SYSTEM”<br />
The Facts<br />
(Sunday Express, 2 May 2004)<br />
Asylum seekers cannot claim mainstream welfare benefits.<br />
If destitute, they can apply to the National Asylum Support<br />
Service (NASS), the Government department responsible for<br />
destitute asylum applicants, for basic food and shelter. A single<br />
adult is eligible for £38.96 a week, equivalent to 70% of basic<br />
income support. In December 2003, around 80,000 asylum<br />
seekers were receiving Home Office support, compared with<br />
15.5 million Britons on benefits (excluding retirement pensions),<br />
meaning that 0.5% of those claiming government support were<br />
asylum seekers.<br />
“AND THEY WILL STOP BOGUS ASYLUM<br />
SEEKERS FROM GETTING NHS CARE,<br />
SAVING £1 BILLION OF TAXPAYERS’<br />
CASH”<br />
The Facts<br />
(The Sun, 31 July 2003)<br />
A Home Office report shows that people born outside the UK,<br />
including asylum seekers, contribute 10% more to the economy<br />
in taxes and national insurance than they consume in benefits<br />
and public services - equivalent to a boost to the economy of<br />
£2.6 billion in 1998/99.<br />
Refugees bring with them a wealth of skills and experience.<br />
According to a recent research commissioned by the Department<br />
for Work and Pensions, 53% of refugees have academic<br />
qualifications. The NHS already relies heavily on foreign labour:<br />
according to the Greater London Authority, 23% of doctors and<br />
47% of nurses working within the NHS were born outside the UK.<br />
Since July 2002, asylum seekers have been barred from working<br />
until they receive a positive decision on their claim. Although<br />
demonised for draining UK public services, asylum seekers are<br />
forced to depend on government support – they cannot<br />
contribute to the UK taxation system and are barred from using<br />
the wealth of skills and experience they bring to the UK.<br />
“ASYLUM CRISIS AS AMNESTY DEAL FOR<br />
15,000 TURNS INTO STAMPEDE”<br />
The Facts<br />
Daily Mail, 28 December 2005<br />
There was no crisis. Applications for the amnesty are made in<br />
writing - no-one was stampeding anywhere. Since the amnesty<br />
was announced in October 2003, the Home Office has found<br />
that more families are eligible for leave to remain than they had<br />
originally expected, some having been in the UK awaiting an<br />
asylum decision for over three years.<br />
36
37<br />
<strong>Darfur</strong>: A <strong>Jewish</strong> <strong>Response</strong><br />
The Facts<br />
“ASYLUM SEEKERS SENT TO MORE<br />
AFFLUENT AREAS”<br />
Daily Mail, 23 December 2005<br />
The reality is that most asylum seekers’ accommodation is in<br />
crowded and deprived urban areas. They are housed in poor<br />
quality accommodation – often previously hard to let –<br />
sometimes in areas where research has shown they are more<br />
likely to face racial harassment. A Home Office report looking at<br />
the problems caused said there might be a case for changing<br />
the policy so that some asylum seekers would be sent to<br />
relatively less problematic areas.<br />
“BRITAIN IS THE ASYLUM CAPITAL OF THE<br />
WORLD”<br />
The Facts<br />
The Express, 23 March 2005<br />
The UK is home to just 3% of nearly 9.2 million refugees worldwide.<br />
Two thirds of the world’s refugees are living in developing<br />
countries, often in refugee camps. Africa and Asia between<br />
them host over 70% of the world’s refugees while Europe looks<br />
after just 22%. In 2005, the UK ranked 14th in the league table<br />
of EU countries for the number of asylum applications per head<br />
of population.<br />
The Facts<br />
“HALT THIS CROOKED TIDE”<br />
The News of the World, 30 January 2005<br />
A report by the Association of Chief Police Officers stated that<br />
the “vast majority of people seeking asylum are law abiding<br />
citizens.” In fact, asylum seekers are much more likely to be the<br />
victims of crime than the perpetrators. A study conducted by<br />
Refugee Action found that one in five of their clients had<br />
experienced some kind of harassment, while 83% of asylum<br />
seeking women do not go out at night for fear of being abused<br />
and harassed.<br />
“ASYLUM SEEKERS GIVEN VOTES TO GET<br />
LOANS”<br />
The Facts<br />
Mail on Sunday, 1 May 2005<br />
Asylum seekers are not allowed to vote in local or general<br />
elections in the UK, nor do they have any access to loans.<br />
People can only register on the electoral roll if they are British,<br />
Commonwealth, Irish or EU citizens. Far from getting extra help,<br />
asylum seekers receive just 70% of income support (£40 per<br />
week). They are not allowed work so are forced to live in<br />
poverty. In 2002, a joint Refugee Council/Oxfam report found that<br />
85% of organisations working with asylum seekers said their<br />
clients experienced hunger while 95% said they could not afford<br />
clothes or shoes.<br />
CONVENTION ON THE PREVENTION AND<br />
PUNISHMENT OF THE CRIME OF GENOCIDE<br />
Adopted by Resolution 260 (III) A of the United Nations General<br />
Assembly on 9 December 1948.<br />
Article 1<br />
The Contracting Parties confirm that genocide, whether<br />
committed in time of peace or in time of war, is a crime under<br />
international law which they undertake to prevent and to punish.<br />
Article 2<br />
In the present Convention, genocide means any of the following<br />
acts committed with intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a<br />
national, ethnical, racial or religious group, as such:<br />
Article 3<br />
• (a) Killing members of the group;<br />
• (b) Causing serious bodily or mental harm to members<br />
of the group;<br />
• (c) Deliberately inflicting on the group conditions of life<br />
calculated to bring about its physical destruction in<br />
whole or in part;<br />
• (d) Imposing measures intended to prevent births within<br />
the group;<br />
• (e) Forcibly transferring children of the group to another<br />
group.<br />
The following acts shall be punishable:<br />
• (a) Genocide;<br />
• (b) Conspiracy to commit genocide;<br />
• (c) Direct and public incitement to commit genocide;<br />
• (d) Attempt to commit genocide;<br />
• (e) Complicity in genocide.<br />
Article 4<br />
Persons committing genocide or any of the other acts<br />
enumerated in Article 3 shall be punished, whether they are<br />
constitutionally responsible rulers, public officials or private<br />
individuals.<br />
38
39<br />
<strong>Darfur</strong>: A <strong>Jewish</strong> <strong>Response</strong><br />
JEWISH SOURCES<br />
You shall not wrong a stranger or oppress him, for you were strangers in the land of Egypt. You shall not ill-treat any widow or orphan.<br />
If you do mistreat them, I will heed their outcry as soon as they cry out to Me, and My anger shall blaze forth and I will put you to the<br />
sword, and your own wives shall become widows and your children orphans.<br />
Exodus 22:20–23<br />
The stranger who resides with you shall be to you as one of your citizens; you shall love him as yourself, for you were strangers in the<br />
land of Egypt: I the Lord, am your God.<br />
You shall not take vengeance or bear a grudge against your countrymen. Love your fellow as yourself. I am the Lord.<br />
Leviticus 19:33–34<br />
Leviticus 19:18<br />
When you reap the harvest in your field and overlook a sheaf in the field, do not turn back to get it; it shall go to the stranger, the<br />
fatherless, and the widow — in order that the Lord your God may bless you in all your undertakings. When you beat down the fruit of<br />
your olive trees, do not go over them again; that shall go to the stranger, the fatherless, and the widow. When you gather the grapes of<br />
your vineyard, do not pick it over again; that shall go to the stranger, the fatherless, and the widow. Always remember that you were a<br />
slave in the land of Egypt; therefore do I enjoin you to observe this commandment.<br />
Some questions to ask about these texts:<br />
1. What do I think and feel about this text?<br />
2. What different ways can we read this text?<br />
3. What moral or ethical principles, values or lessons can be learnt?<br />
4. How does it relate to us and our world today?<br />
Deuteronomy 24:17–22<br />
40
41<br />
<strong>Darfur</strong>: A <strong>Jewish</strong> <strong>Response</strong><br />
QUOTES FROM SURVIVOR TESTIMONIES<br />
Nazi Germany<br />
‘When we arrived, the dead were not carried away any more, you<br />
stepped over them, you fell over them if you couldn’t walk. It was<br />
agonising...people begging for water’.<br />
‘Gi was executed…along with his brother and 18 other resistance<br />
fighters. He was 20 years old’.<br />
‘Thomas was tortured and condemned to death…at the age of<br />
20, he was executed by a…firing squad.’<br />
‘My mother died slowly of hunger.’<br />
‘state-sponsored racism produced…economic boycotts…and<br />
the violence…all of which aimed to systematically isolate…and<br />
drive them out of the country’<br />
‘was characterized by the efficient and systematic attempt on an<br />
industrial scale to assemble and kill as many people as possible,<br />
using all of the resources and technology available to the…state.’<br />
‘The…machinery was dedicated to<br />
eradicating millions of people it deemed<br />
undesirable’<br />
‘They knew and did nothing, … did everything in their power to<br />
avoid dealing with the problem.’<br />
‘The Holocaust tragedy was possible due to the complicity of<br />
leaders of state institutions’<br />
Bosnia<br />
‘They would just line them up and shoot them into the pits. The<br />
approximately one hundred guys whom they interrogated and<br />
who had dug the mass graves then had to fill them in’<br />
‘whoever tried to escape was shot’<br />
‘The actions of the international community encouraged, aided,<br />
and emboldened the executioners. ...’<br />
‘We were given orders to execute these<br />
men…I was simply compelled to…my<br />
commander said if I felt sorry for these<br />
people that I should line up with them’<br />
‘Therefore, we had to, as quickly as possible, pack things . . . we<br />
could only take, just enough, perhaps, for the child, one change,<br />
a few pairs of her clothes, some bread, and quickly leave the<br />
house. This we did in a very short time, and we left the house.’<br />
‘They were separating boys from 12 years of age and old men to<br />
77 years of age.’<br />
‘The soldier asked why the child was crying and she explained<br />
that he was hungry. The soldier made a comment like, ‘He won’t<br />
be hungry anymore.’ He slit the child’s throat in front of<br />
everybody’<br />
‘The vast amount of planning and high-level coordination invested<br />
in killing thousands of men in a few days is apparent from the<br />
scale and the methodical nature in which the executions were<br />
carried out.’<br />
Rwanda<br />
‘All the preconditions for genocide were present: a well organised<br />
civil service, … a disciplined and orderly population, reasonably<br />
good communications and a coherent ideology containing the<br />
necessary lethal potential.’<br />
‘even in the cases where people did not move spontaneously but<br />
were forced to take part in the killings, they were helped along in<br />
violence by the mental and emotional lubricant of ideology’<br />
‘And people were often accused of having a false identity card,<br />
especially if they were tall and with a straight nose and thin lips’<br />
‘In time of war, people who refuse to carry out orders to commit<br />
violent acts can be killed’<br />
‘Many were betrayed by their neighbours’<br />
‘Sexual abuse of women was common and they were often<br />
brutally raped and killed’<br />
‘At massacre sites, corpses, many of them<br />
those of children, have been methodically<br />
dismembered and the body parts stacked<br />
in neat separate piles.’<br />
‘One should never forget how great were the horrors which the<br />
survivors experienced’<br />
‘In such extreme cases, even the refusal to kill was a heroic act’<br />
‘Either you took part in the massacre or else you were massacred<br />
yourself’<br />
<strong>Darfur</strong><br />
‘They took dozens of other girls and made us walk for three<br />
hours. During the day we were beaten and they were telling us:<br />
“You… we will exterminate you, you have no God.” At night we<br />
were raped several times.’<br />
‘Massive human rights violations committed in the region include:<br />
extra-judicial executions, unlawful killings of civilians, torture,<br />
rapes, abductions, destruction of villages and property, looting of<br />
cattle and property, the destruction of the means of livelihood of<br />
the population attacked and forced displacement.’<br />
‘Children have been summarily or indiscriminately killed, tortured,<br />
abducted and forcibly displaced; girls have, like women, been<br />
the particular target of rapes, abductions and sexual slavery.’<br />
‘men were taken away and then executed…while women were<br />
shot when trying to escape from the village.’<br />
“They slit the throat of my only child in<br />
front of my eyes. I don’t know where my<br />
wife is and what happened to her. It is<br />
only because one of the soldiers was<br />
merciful that I was not killed.”<br />
‘There is no place here for the Negroes any more’<br />
‘Government forces were either involved or direct witnesses.’<br />
‘Reporting this to the soldiers did not make sense. They are part<br />
of it.’<br />
© Brian Steidle<br />
42
43<br />
<strong>Darfur</strong>: A <strong>Jewish</strong> <strong>Response</strong><br />
SAMPLE LETTER<br />
Dear<br />
I am writing to you as a matter of urgency regarding the situation in <strong>Darfur</strong>, western Sudan.<br />
As you will be aware there has been a wave of violence over the past four years against those of<br />
black African descent living in the area. Cautious estimates are that 200,000 people have been<br />
murdered, although many humanitarian and campaign organisations suggest it is more likely that<br />
400,000 people have been killed, with violence, gang rapes and forced displacement also taking<br />
place.<br />
Whilst I support Tony Blair’s recent statement that there is a need for a ‘no fly zone’ over Sudan,<br />
these words must be coupled with action. The no fly zone must be pushed for at the United<br />
Nations, alongside the deployment of a UN peacekeeping force along the Chad-<strong>Darfur</strong> border.<br />
Statements are of no use to the vulnerable people of <strong>Darfur</strong> unless they are turned into a reality.<br />
Additionally I ask you to address the situation in the UK of detaining and deporting of asylum<br />
seekers back to Khartoum, Sudan. Not only does this put individuals in huge danger but sending<br />
asylum seekers back to Khartoum, the capital city from where the government-backed violent<br />
regime is organised, sends a message to the Sudanese government that the UK does not<br />
recognise the gravity of the situation in <strong>Darfur</strong>. The UN High Commissioner for Refugees has<br />
recommended that it is too dangerous to deport <strong>Darfur</strong>i asylum seekers back to Sudan.<br />
I urge you to challenge this policy of the Home Office immediately.<br />
Please keep me updated on any developments in relation to <strong>Darfur</strong>.<br />
Yours sincerely<br />
MAPS<br />
Map of Sudan with <strong>Darfur</strong> region shaded<br />
© Aegis Trust<br />
MAP OF VILLAGES IN DARFUR REGION<br />
Courtesy of Human Rights Watch<br />
Google Earth, the search engine’s online mapping engine, has published aerial photographs of the <strong>Darfur</strong> region, showing more than 1,600<br />
damaged and destroyed villages, displaced people and IDP camps. In some areas the resolution is high enough to show the burnt ruins of<br />
individual homes, schools, and other structures destroyed by Janjaweed militia and Sudanese forces. The new initiative, called ‘Crisis in<br />
<strong>Darfur</strong>’, in partnership with the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum, can be viewed at earth.google.com.<br />
44
45<br />
<strong>Darfur</strong>: A <strong>Jewish</strong> <strong>Response</strong><br />
TIMELINE - THE DARFUR CRISIS<br />
Sources: Protect <strong>Darfur</strong>, BBC Online, Reuters<br />
April 2003 – The Sudan Liberation Army (SLA) attacks<br />
Government forces in <strong>Darfur</strong>.<br />
April 2003 – Refugees begin arriving in eastern Chad to escape<br />
the fighting. Large numbers of civilians become internally<br />
displaced people (IDPs) within <strong>Darfur</strong>. Another rebel group, the<br />
Justice and Equality Movement (JEM) emerges in <strong>Darfur</strong>.<br />
May 2003 – Air raids are conducted on African villages in <strong>Darfur</strong>.<br />
The Government of Sudan instructs the national media not to<br />
report about the situation in <strong>Darfur</strong> under any circumstances.<br />
September 2003 – Refugee numbers in Chad reach 65,000. UN<br />
agencies estimate at least 500,000 people in <strong>Darfur</strong> need<br />
humanitarian aid.<br />
Early December 2003 – A fresh round of attacks by Arab<br />
Janjaweed militias prompts at least 10,000 new refugees to<br />
stream into Chad. The Sudanese Government begins policy of<br />
restricting humanitarian access by refusing or delaying travel<br />
permits to <strong>Darfur</strong>.<br />
23 January 2004 – At least 18,000 refugees enter Chad in one<br />
week as militia attacks inside <strong>Darfur</strong> intensify.<br />
19 March 2004 – In a media interview, UN Humanitarian<br />
Coordinator for Sudan Mukesh Kapila says the situation in <strong>Darfur</strong><br />
is comparable to what happened in the Rwandan genocide of<br />
1994.<br />
19 April 2004 – A humanitarian ceasefire is signed between the<br />
SLA, JEM and the Sudanese Government. Atrocities continue.<br />
May 2004 - Establishment of the African Union observer mission<br />
to monitor the humanitarian ceasefire.<br />
25 May 2004 – Expressing its deep concern about reports of<br />
human rights abuses, the Security Council issues a presidential<br />
statement calling on Khartoum to neutralise and disarm the<br />
Janjaweed.<br />
30 June 2004 – Kofi Annan arrives on a three day visit to Sudan<br />
and Chad and holds talks with Sudanese Government officials<br />
and United States Secretary of State Colin Powell about the<br />
situation in <strong>Darfur</strong> and the obstacles faced by humanitarian<br />
workers in distributing aid. A large number of senior officials<br />
from European countries also visit during this period including<br />
UK Secretary of State for International Development, Hilary Benn<br />
and UK Foreign Minister, Jack Straw.<br />
30 July 2004 – Security Council adopts Resolution 1556 which<br />
threatens ‘economic measures’ against Sudan if it does not<br />
make progress in allowing humanitarian aid and in disarming the<br />
Janjaweed as promised in a Communiqué the Sudanese<br />
Governemnt signed during Kofi Annan’s visit. The Resolution<br />
passes 13-0 with China and Pakistan abstaining.<br />
August 2004 – The first AU protection force troops arrive to<br />
protect the AU observers monitoring the humanitarian ceasefire.<br />
After insistence from the Rwandan Government the troops are<br />
given a mandate allowing them to protect civilians in the<br />
immediate vicinity under immediate threat.<br />
2 September 2004 – Jan Pronk, the UN Special Representative<br />
to Sudan tells the Security Council that Khartoum has not<br />
disarmed the Janjaweed nor stopped their attacks against<br />
civilians. He calls for the AU mission to be expanded in size and<br />
mandate so that IDPs are better protected.<br />
18 September 2004 – Security Council adopts Resolution 1564<br />
which says it will consider more measures, including sanctions, if<br />
Khartoum does not comply with earlier resolutions or with plans<br />
to expand the AU mission. The resolution also requests that the<br />
Secretary General quickly set up an International Commission of<br />
Inquiry to ascertain whether acts of genocide have been<br />
committed. The Resolution is passed 11-0 with Algeria, China,<br />
Pakistan and the Russian Federation abstaining.<br />
30 September 2004 – In a Brief to the Security Council<br />
following their assessment mission to Dafur Louise Arbour, High<br />
Commissioner for Human Rights and Juan Méndez, Special<br />
Advisor to the Secretary General on Genocide Prevention<br />
recommend that international police officers must be deployed if<br />
the IDPs are to have any confidence that they will be protected if<br />
or when they leave their camps.<br />
4 October 2004 – Kofi Annan proposes four ways in which the<br />
UN can assist the AU to expand its mission, including by setting<br />
up a <strong>Darfur</strong> regional office of the UN Advance Mission in Sudan<br />
(UNAMIS).<br />
January 2005 – A UN report accuses the government and<br />
militias of systematic abuses in <strong>Darfur</strong>, but stops short of calling<br />
the violence genocide. Recommends that the Security Council<br />
refer the situation in <strong>Darfur</strong> to the International Criminal Court.<br />
6 March 2005 – Concerned that the world was not moving fast<br />
enough on <strong>Darfur</strong>, Kofi Annan summons Security Council<br />
members to a meeting to press for a stronger international force<br />
on the ground in the region.<br />
24 March 2005 – Resolution 1590 is passed by the UN Security<br />
Council establishing a peacekeeping force in South Sudan.<br />
<strong>Darfur</strong> is tagged onto the resolution with the force in the South to<br />
co-ordinate with the AU force in <strong>Darfur</strong>. The Resolution requests<br />
that Kofi Annan report back to the Council in 30 days on ways in<br />
which the Southern Force can support the African Union mission.<br />
31 March 2005 – The Security Council passes a Resolution<br />
1593 referring <strong>Darfur</strong> to the ICC. The UK International<br />
Development Select Committee publishes a report which is<br />
scathing of British policy on <strong>Darfur</strong>.<br />
April – July 2005 – Incidence of aerial attacks decreases. This<br />
is thought to reflect the fact that most villages have already been<br />
destroyed as much as reflecting any policy change on the part<br />
of the Sudanese Government.<br />
May 2005 – AU Peace and Security Council decides to increase<br />
its force size from 3,300 to 7,700.<br />
16 September 2005 – At the UN World Summit, states agree to<br />
the Responsibility to Protect Principle. Under this principle,<br />
where states fail to protect their own civilians, other states have a<br />
responsibility to intervene to protect those civilians, including by<br />
taking action under Chapter VII of the UN Charter should<br />
peaceful means prove inadequate.<br />
January 2006 – Tensions increase on the Chad/Sudan border.<br />
Chad accuses Sudan of supporting Chadian rebels whilst Sudan<br />
accuses Chad of supporting the SLA. Some refugees cross<br />
back into <strong>Darfur</strong> due to insecurity in Chad.<br />
10 March 2006 – The AU agrees in principle to the transfer of<br />
AMIS to the UN and gives a green light to the UN to begin<br />
planning for a force in the region but under pressure from<br />
Sudan, AU Foreign Ministers fail to agree a date, agreeing only<br />
to extend the mandate of the AMIS until September 2006.<br />
Sudan says it will only consider accepting a UN force once a<br />
peace deal is agreed.<br />
April 2006 – Sudan prevents a UN military assessment mission<br />
from visiting to <strong>Darfur</strong> to gather information necessary for the<br />
planning of the UN force for <strong>Darfur</strong>.<br />
May 2006 – Khartoum government and the main rebel faction in<br />
<strong>Darfur</strong>, the Sudan Liberation Movement, sign a peace accord.<br />
Two smaller rebel groups reject the deal. Fighting continues.<br />
August 2006 – Sudan rejects a United Nations resolution calling<br />
for a UN peacekeeping force in <strong>Darfur</strong>, saying it would<br />
compromise Sudanese sovereignty.<br />
October 2006 – Jan Pronk, the UN’s top official in Sudan, is<br />
expelled.<br />
November 2006 – African Union extends mandate of its peacekeeping<br />
force in <strong>Darfur</strong> for another six months.<br />
46
47<br />
<strong>Darfur</strong>: A <strong>Jewish</strong> <strong>Response</strong><br />
December 2006 – Sudan agrees in principle to accept the<br />
deployment of UN troops in <strong>Darfur</strong> as part of an expanded<br />
peacekeeping force.<br />
February 2007 – The first indictments at the International<br />
Criminal Court: Ahmad Harun, Sudan’s State Minister for<br />
Humanitarian Affairs and formerly State Minister of the Interior,<br />
and Ali Kushayb, one of the leaders of the Janjaweed, for war<br />
crimes and crimes against humanity in <strong>Darfur</strong>.<br />
April 2007 – Five Senegalese soldiers serving with the African<br />
Union are shot dead in <strong>Darfur</strong>. Sudanese army clashes with<br />
Chadian soldiers in <strong>Darfur</strong>, with several deaths. Sudan vows ‘a<br />
firm response’.<br />
April 2007 – United Nations team in eastern Chad find around<br />
400 decomposing bodies in villages where hundreds of homes<br />
had been burned to the ground by militias. UN official describes<br />
scenes as ‘apocalyptic’.<br />
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS<br />
This booklet would not have been possible without the hard<br />
work, support and expertise of the following people:<br />
Rabbi Janet Burden – West Central Liberal Synagogue and the<br />
South Bucks <strong>Jewish</strong> Community<br />
Brendan Cox – Crisis Action<br />
Rabbi Jeremy Gordon – St Albans Masorti Synagogue<br />
Henry Grunwald – Board of Deputies of British Jews<br />
Rabbi Michael Harris – The Hampstead Synagogue<br />
Marc Kaye – UJIA Makor<br />
Chief Rabbi Sir Jonathan Sacks – Chief Rabbi of the United<br />
Hebrew Congregations of the Commonwealth<br />
Dr James Smith – The Aegis Trust<br />
Rabbi Jonathan Wittenberg – New North London Synagogue<br />
Dr Raphael Zarum – London School of <strong>Jewish</strong> Studies<br />
The <strong>Pears</strong> <strong>Foundation</strong> also thanks the following<br />
organisations:<br />
The Aegis Trust, Alliance Darc, American <strong>Jewish</strong> World Service,<br />
Amnesty International, Assembly of Masorti Synagogues, BBC<br />
Online, Board of Deputies of British Jews, British Foreign and<br />
Commonwealth Office, Crisis Action, Human Rights Watch,<br />
<strong>Jewish</strong> Council for Racial Equality, <strong>Jewish</strong> Community Centre for<br />
London, London School of <strong>Jewish</strong> Studies, Liberal Judaism,<br />
Make Poverty History <strong>Jewish</strong> Coalition, Movement for Reform<br />
Judaism, Refugee Council, RenéCassin, United <strong>Jewish</strong> Israel<br />
Appeal, Tzedek, World <strong>Jewish</strong> Relief, United Synagogue<br />
Editorial Team: Charles Keidan, Alex Singer, Hannah Weisfeld<br />
With support from Lisa Capelouto and Amy Philip<br />
Peer reviewed by Brendan Cox, Elliott Goldstein<br />
Design and layout by Glen Powell, The Aegis Trust<br />
48
This booklet has been printed on paper made from recycled fibre and fibre sourced from sustainable forests.<br />
Printed by MPC Print Solutions on 9Lives 55 and 80 silk recycled paper.