Download File

Download File Download File

studentszine.com
from studentszine.com More from this publisher
07.04.2013 Views

220 CONTEMPORARY ART But this difference between the atmosphere of London and of Paris brings up a question that had best be stated at once. What are the causes of British ? provincialism Though its existence is a fact that runs right through the history of British art, it would be rash to assume that the causes have always been the same. For instance, the geographical isolation of England may at one time have been a cause that has been removed ; by railways and steamboats. It will be sensible to speak in this article only of present causes of present ills. Some people will have it that the insignificance of English art is very simply to be explained by a complete absence of native talent ; but the mere inspection of English children's and students' work suffices to dispose of this too convenient hypothesis. In no country, perhaps, except France, is there more of that raw material from which good art is made. More plausible is the theory that the vast and towering greatness of English litera- ture overhangs and starves all other forms of expression. In such a land as this it seems natural that any sense of art or power of creation should drift towards literature, and almost inevitable that the painters themselves should be half poets at heart, hardly convinced of the intrinsic value of their own medium,

CONTEMPORARY ART 221 tending ever to substitute literary for plastic significance. Every critic is on the watch for a literary symbol and the chance of an alle- gorical interpretation, every cultivated amateur is eager to spy out an adroitly placed anecdote or shaft of pictorial satire ; only with great pains is any one induced to regard a picture as an independent creation of form. In so literary a society it seems paradoxical almost to believe in pure painting ; and, in despair, we cry out that no country can be expected to excel, at one time, in two arts. We forget Athens and Tuscany we also ; forget France. For more than two hundred years France has led the visual art of Europe ; and if English painting were ever to become one-tenth part as good as French literature I, for my part, should be as pleased as surprised. Of music I say nothing ; yet in that art too France was beginning, just before the war, to challenge, not very formidably perhaps, the pre-eminence of Germany and to stand as the fair rival of Russia. What hampers English artists most is, unless I mistake, the atmosphere in which they work. In France in Germany too, they say there is a fairly large, authoritative, and intensely serious public composed of artists, critics, and competent amateurs. This public knows so well what it is about that no painter, be he

CONTEMPORARY ART 221<br />

tending ever to substitute literary for plastic<br />

significance. Every critic is on the watch for<br />

a literary symbol and the chance of an alle-<br />

gorical interpretation, every cultivated amateur<br />

is eager to spy out an adroitly placed anecdote<br />

or shaft of pictorial satire ; only with great<br />

pains is any one induced to regard a picture<br />

as an independent creation of form. In so<br />

literary a society it seems paradoxical almost<br />

to believe in pure painting ; and, in despair,<br />

we cry out that no country can be expected<br />

to excel, at one time, in two arts. We forget<br />

Athens and Tuscany we also ;<br />

forget France.<br />

For more than two hundred years France has<br />

led the visual art of Europe ; and if English<br />

painting were ever to become one-tenth part<br />

as good as French literature I, for my part,<br />

should be as pleased as surprised. Of music<br />

I say nothing ; yet in that art too France<br />

was beginning, just before the war, to challenge,<br />

not very formidably perhaps, the pre-eminence<br />

of Germany and to stand as the fair rival of<br />

Russia.<br />

What hampers English artists most is, unless<br />

I mistake, the atmosphere in which they work.<br />

In France in Germany too, they say there<br />

is a fairly large, authoritative, and intensely<br />

serious public composed of artists, critics, and<br />

competent amateurs. This public knows so<br />

well what it is about that no painter, be he

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!