Download File

Download File Download File

studentszine.com
from studentszine.com More from this publisher
07.04.2013 Views

202 THE MANSARD GALLERY he is highly sensitive by which I mean that his reactions to what he sees are intense and peculiar. But these reactions, one fancies, he likes to take home, meditate, criticize, and reduce finally to a rigorously definite conception. And this conception he has the power to translate into a beautifully logical and harmonious form. Power he seems never to lack : it would be almost impossible to paint better. I do not know which of Marchand's three pictures is the best ; but whichever it be, it is the best picture in the gallery. With de Vlaminck it is from a word to a blow, from a thrilling emotion to a finished picture. If Marchand is like a minor Milton the is comparison not one to be pressed de Vlaminck is like Keats. He is the most lyrical of the younger Frenchmen the flash ; and sparkle of his is pictures the wonderfully close expression of a tremblingly delighted sensibility. Yet there is nothing sketchy about them. Consider his landscape (No. 65), and you will be astonished to find what a solid, self-supporting design these delicately graded tones and lightly brushed forms compose. Only one Englishman holds his own with the French painters, and he, of course, is Duncan Grant. The challenge to another very interesting young Englishman is, how-

THE MANSARD GALLERY 203 ever, more marked since the de Vlaminck of which I have just spoken has as its rival on the wall, at right angles to it, The Mill (No. 32), by Mark Gertler. The comparison made, what first strikes one is that the Gertler, for all its assertion of strength and its emphatic, heavy accents, looks flimsy beside its lightly brushed and airy neighbour. But The Mill is not the piece by which Gertler should be judged ; let us look rather at his large and elaborate Swing Boats. I have seen better Gertlers than this ; the insistent repetition of not very interesting forms makes it come perilously near what Mr. Fry calls in his preface " merely ornamental pattern-making," but it is a picture that enables one to see pretty clearly the strength and weakness of this remarkable person. With a greater artistic gift, Mark Gertler's conviction and conscience would suffice to make him a painter of the first magnitude. Unfortunately, his artistic gift, one inclines to suppose, is precisely that irreducible minimum without which an artist cannot exist. That is his weakness. His strength is that he exploits that minimum uncompromisingly to its utmost possibility. Gertler is one who will never say an idle word in paint, no matter how charming or interesting or amusing it might be. In his pictures you will look in vain for a single

THE MANSARD GALLERY 203<br />

ever, more marked since the de Vlaminck of<br />

which I have just spoken has as its rival on<br />

the wall, at right angles to it, The Mill (No. 32),<br />

by Mark Gertler. The comparison made, what<br />

first strikes one is that the Gertler, for all its<br />

assertion of strength and its emphatic, heavy<br />

accents, looks flimsy beside its lightly brushed<br />

and airy neighbour. But The Mill is not the<br />

piece by which Gertler should be judged ;<br />

let<br />

us look rather at his large and elaborate Swing<br />

Boats. I have seen better Gertlers than this ;<br />

the insistent repetition of not very interesting<br />

forms makes it come perilously near what<br />

Mr. Fry calls in his preface " merely ornamental<br />

pattern-making," but it is a picture<br />

that enables one to see pretty clearly the<br />

strength<br />

and weakness of this remarkable<br />

person.<br />

With a greater artistic<br />

gift, Mark Gertler's<br />

conviction and conscience would suffice to<br />

make him a painter of the first magnitude.<br />

Unfortunately, his artistic gift, one inclines to<br />

suppose, is precisely that irreducible minimum<br />

without which an artist cannot exist. That is<br />

his weakness. His strength is that he exploits<br />

that minimum uncompromisingly to its utmost<br />

possibility. Gertler is one who will never say<br />

an idle word in paint, no matter how charming<br />

or interesting or amusing it might be. In his<br />

pictures you will look in vain for a single

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!