IHgIIOJOHIj - World Health Organization Regional Office for Europe

nCCneAOBaTenbCKne napaAnrMbl, KOTOpbMe npnMeHSinnCb AnSI OL(eHKn
er0 344eKTHBHOCTH Ha nHAHBnAyanbHOM yposHe He ,ganli
nOJIHOLIeHHbIX pe3ynbTaTOB. HeKOTOpbie MOryT Aaxce Bo3pa3nTb, LITO
npNpOAHaSi CyLL[HOCTb rpynn B3aHMOHOMOLLtH C HX CHOHTaHHbIM,
He(l)OpManbHblM Ha6opOM He nOAAaeTCSI Bb160pKe H KOHTpOniO, LITO
OTHOCHTCSI H K AA KaK OpraHI-i3aLjHH CaMOnOMOn[H.
9.2.4 flporpaMMbi pea6NnHTaL.4NN "Inn BopNTeneH,
3apepNCaHHbAx 3a ynpaeneHNe TpaHCnopTOM B HeTpe3BOM
COCTOIH Il II
14c110n63OBaHHe 06pa30BaHnsl H pea6HnHTaL[HH B xaLiecTSe
anbTepHaTnBbI Ha3HaLlaeMbIX CyAOM nerânbHblX CaHKL[HN nIOASIM,
OCy)KAeHHbIM 3a BO)KAeHne B HeTpe3BOM COCTOSIHnH, CTa614nbH0
noBblLnaeTCSI Bo MHOrHX cTpai-iax c 1970-x roAos (Mäkelä et al 1981).
B HeKOTOpbIX CTpaHaX 3Tn nporpaMMbI HCHOnb3yIOTC5I BMeCTO
TpaAnLWOHHbIX KapaTenbH6IX CaHKIjHN, TaKHX KaK 3aKnIOLIeHHe,
LnTpa(ibI HAN aHHynnpOBaHHe BOAHTenbCKHX npaB. B 06LLjeM, OL[eHKa
npOBeAeHHOrO B COeAHHëHHbIX 111TaTaX HCCneAOBaHHSI, nOKa3bIBaeT
B nyLILIIeM CnyLlae He6onblHoH 3(1(:PeKT HeKOTOpbIX Bo3AeiiCTBHIi Ha
BO3HHKHOBeHHe peLIHAHBOB H CB5I3aHHOe C anKOrOneM nOBeAeHne
(Wells - Parker et al 1989). 3HaH o nOAo6HOM CKpOMHOM 344eKTe,
MbI MO)KeM npeAnono)KnTb, LITO HCH0n630BaHHe o6pa3osaHHx H
pea6HnnTaL[nn BO3MO)KHO nyLILUe, LIeM OTCyTCTBHe KaKHX-nH60
AeiïCTBHiï, HO OHO He SIBnSIeTCSI nOAXOASIILteii 3aMeHOii CaHKnnii n0
BOAHTenbCKHM npaBaM (Hagen 1985). OAHO HccneAosanne, TeM He
McHee, yrsepxcAaeT, LITO A06aBneHHe pea6HnnTaLtnOHHOIi npOrpaMMbI K
CaHKLjHSiM AaëT nOJIO)KHTenbHbIFi 34)43eKT (Mann et al 1994).
9.3 AOKA3ATEJ1bCTBA BJ111AHVIA HA YPOBHE
HACEJIEHVIA 11H,gV1BVI,gYAJ1bHO HAf1PABJ1EHHbIX
BO3,qEVICTB1,I0, HAL.IEJ1EHHbIX HA 3J1OYflOTPE6J1EHVIE
AJIKOt-OJ1EM
3Aecb MbI Bo3BpaüjaeMCSI K BOHpOCy, MO)KHO nH nyTeM
CyMMnpOBaHnSI HHAHBHAyanbHbIX HHTepBeHLIHIi y3HaTb 06 FIX
H3MepSIeMOM HOJIO)KHTenbHOM BnHSIHHH Ha HaCeneHne. Pa60Ta B 3TOM
HanpaBneHHH pa3BHBaeTC5I, HO AO cnX nop HaXOAHTCSI Ha
OTHOCHTen6H0 paHHeil CTâAHH. 11p14 3KCTpanOnHpOBaHHH pe3ynbTaTOB
HCCneAOBaHHii Ha HHAHBHAyanbHOM yposHe MO)KHO O)KHAaTb, LITO
281