IHgIIOJOHIj - World Health Organization Regional Office for Europe

CTpaTerHeli. B o6LC[eM CAepxcHSaioivaA 3(1)CbeKTiiBHOCTb CypOBbIX
HaKa3aHHii 3a BO)KAeHHe B HeTpe3BOM COCTOAHilH MO)KeT 6bITb
cHI-vKeHa, ecnH CyAbH HnH npHCAxcxble 6yuyr pacCMaTpHBaTb
HaKa3aHide, KaK LIpe3MepHOe H, TâKHM O6pa3OM, HeOXOTHO O6BHHATb
H51H BbIHOCHTb npHrosop. ECTb OCHOBaHHA nonaraTb, vTo yrpo3a
TIOpeMHOrO 3aKnlOiieHFi5I MO)KeT O6naAaTb 0006bIM CAep)KHBaK)IIjHM
3(p(beKTOM, XOTA 3TOT 34)(tieKT, BII,TZHMO MeHbnIe nOTeHIjHanbH0r0
3(14eKTa npHOCTaHOBKH j(eFiCTBHA npaB (Voas, 1986, Ross, 1985).
7.1.4 Jl@4@HN@ 17FO,g@N, MHOrOKpaTHO HapyWNBWNX 3aKOH
O BO)KA@HHH B H@Tp@3BOM COCTOAHHN, KaK np@B@HTNBHaA
CTpaT@rIAA
.1110Ai3, KoTOpbie nOABeprnHCb Haxa3aHFiIO 3a BO)KAeHHe B
HeTpe3BOM COCTOAHHH 6onee TIeM OAHH pa3, oC06eHH0 3a KOpoTKNN
nepllOA BpeMeHH, CKOpee BcerO, MHOrO nbK)T. B pe3ynbTaTe neTleHHe
MO)KeT 6bITb Ha3Ha4eHO CyAOM KaK TIaCTb ilni! anbTepHaTHBa
TiOpeMHOMy 3aKnIOTieHHIo. KpaTKHe 3aMeTlaHHA 06 3(14eKTHBHOCTH
Ha3HaTMeHHOrO CyAOM neTIeHHA npHBOAATCA nO3)Ke B rnase 9 B
KOHTeKCTe 6051ee HIHpOKOIi AHCKyCCHH 06 34)(beKTHBHOCTH neTleHliA.
.11eTleHHe nK)Aeii, MHOëOKpaTHO HapyIIIFiBIIIi-iX 3aKOH O BO)K,TjeHHH
B HeTpe3BOM COCTOAHilH ABnAeTCA npHMepOM napaAOKCa
np0(pHnaKTHKH. TaKHe BOAHTenH, ilMeA BbICOKyK) CTeneHb nHTIHOrO
pHCKa, He CO3AaK)T 60nbHIHHCTBa CB513aHHbIX C ânKOrOneM npo6neM
(Perrine, Peck and Fell 1989). CAepxcHBaHHe 6yAymero so)iCAexHA B
HeTpe3BOM COCTOAHHi! CpeAH BcerO HaCeneHilA, TaKilM O6pa3OM,
ABnAeTCA HaH60nee 3(I(beKTHBHOii CTpaTerHeiï.
7.2 HA3HA4EHVIE BO,gNTEJ1EM
OAHOii H3 cTpaTerHii COKpameHHA CB513aHHbIX C anKOrOneM
aBTOKaTaCTpo(l), ABnAeTCA Ha3HaTieHHe OnpeAenëHHOrO TlneHa AaHHOH
rpynnbi nioAeH, KOTOpble co6HpaioTCA BMeCTe sbinHTb, BoAHTeneM,
KOTOpbIÎ! He 6yAeT nHTb Hni! BbinbeT nHIIlb HeMHOrO. l'1CHOnb3OBaHHe
"Ha3HaTleHHOrO BOAIiTenA" ABn51eTC5I nonynApHOi%I CTpaTerHeii BO
MHOrHX cTpaHaX. AnbTepHaTHBOi%I ABnAeTCA CTpaTerHA 6e30naCHOiï
e3AbI, KOrAa nblOn.[He HaHHMaIOT KOrO-51H60 N51H HM 06ecneTlHBaK)T
HanHTIHe BO3MO)KHOCTH 6e3onaCHO AOeXaTb OT MecTa BbIHHBKH AO
AoMa (Apsler, 1988). geMOHCTpauHOHHble npOrpaMMbl, HalueneHHble
226