05.04.2013 Views

The Armenian Mirror-Spectator February 2, 2013

The Armenian Mirror-Spectator February 2, 2013

The Armenian Mirror-Spectator February 2, 2013

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

<strong>Mirror</strong>-<strong>Spectator</strong><br />

THE ARMENIAN<br />

Volume LXXXIII, NO. 29, Issue 4274<br />

ISTANBUL (Hetq) — Aris Nalci, a former<br />

editor of the Turkish-<strong>Armenian</strong> weekly,<br />

Agos, has called on Turkish authorities to<br />

launch a large-scale investigation into the<br />

F E B R U A R Y 2 , 2 0 1 3<br />

<strong>The</strong> First English Language <strong>Armenian</strong> Weekly in the United States Since 1932<br />

Archbishop Nourhan Manougian<br />

recent spate of attacks against <strong>Armenian</strong><br />

women in Istanbul.<br />

An article in Today’s Zaman this week<br />

states that Nalci does not think these successive<br />

assaults in the Samatya neighborhood<br />

are isolated incidents, but rather that<br />

they are connected.<br />

“<strong>The</strong> Police Department states these<br />

incidents are unrelated, but they generally<br />

say such things in similar incidents in order<br />

not to unsettle people. I think a climate of<br />

fear is being created in the neighborhood,”<br />

Nalci noted.<br />

Four attacks against elderly <strong>Armenian</strong><br />

women in the Samatya neighborhood of<br />

Istanbul’s Fatih district have occurred within<br />

the past two months. One of the woman,<br />

85-year-old Maritsa Küçük, was attacked in<br />

her apartment on December 28, 2012. She<br />

was brutally killed after being stabbed<br />

seven times.<br />

$ 2.00<br />

Archbishop Nourhan<br />

Manougian Elected 97th<br />

Patriarch of Jerusalem<br />

JERUSALEM — On Thursday, January 24, the<br />

members of the St. James Brotherhood elected<br />

Archbishop Nourhan Manougian as the new<br />

Patriarch of Jerusalem after a two-day conclave.<br />

Out of 33 members of the Brotherhood,<br />

Manougian was elected with 17 votes.<br />

Archbishop Aris Shirvanian, who has been serving<br />

as locum tenens, received 15 votes, with one<br />

blank vote cast.<br />

Now, Manougian’s election must be approved<br />

by the governments of Israel and Jordan.<br />

Manougian was born in Aleppo, Syria, and in<br />

1948, graduated from the local Haigazian<br />

School. He studied at the seminary of the<br />

see PATRIARCH, page 4<br />

Former Agos Editor Calls for<br />

Investigation of Istanbul Attacks<br />

Young Turk’s<br />

Grandson Speaks<br />

In Germany<br />

By Muriel Mirak-Weissbach<br />

Special to the <strong>Mirror</strong>-<strong>Spectator</strong><br />

BERLIN — In Germany, where the largest<br />

Turkish community outside of Turkey lives,<br />

there were two special events commemorating<br />

the life and work of Hrant Dink on<br />

the sixth anniversary of his death. Along<br />

with cultural events, like the performance<br />

of the play “Anne’s Silence,” there were presentations<br />

of a new book by a Turkish intellectual.<br />

This was not any intellectual, but<br />

Hasan Çemal, grandson of Çemal Pasha,<br />

one of the Young Turk triumvirs responsible<br />

for the <strong>Armenian</strong> Genocide, who spoke<br />

in front of standing-room-only crowds on<br />

January 18 in Berlin and January 21 in<br />

Cologne. <strong>The</strong> book he presented is titled<br />

1915 — Ermeni Soykirimi (1915 —<br />

Genocide against the <strong>Armenian</strong>s).<br />

More than a book presentation, his<br />

appearance in Germany was a courageous<br />

see ÇEMAL, page 4<br />

Hasan Çemal in Berlin<br />

Today’s Zaman reports that it spoke with<br />

Antranik Yontan, an <strong>Armenian</strong> living in the<br />

Samatya. Yontan told the newspaper that<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong>s have stopped speaking<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong> and that elderly <strong>Armenian</strong><br />

women are now afraid of going to the local<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong> church.<br />

“A climate of fear is prevalent around the<br />

neighborhood among the <strong>Armenian</strong> communities,”<br />

Yontan said.<br />

<strong>The</strong> Turkish press reports that police<br />

have released a sketch of the assailant of<br />

80-year-old Sultan Aykar, the latest<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong> woman to be attacked in<br />

Samatya on January 22.<br />

<strong>The</strong> sketch is based on camera footage<br />

showing a man smoking outside the building<br />

where Aykar was attacked.<br />

On Friday, the Istanbul branch of<br />

Turkey’s Human Rights Association (HRA)<br />

see INVESTIGATION, page 4<br />

From Home to ‘Homeland’ Actor Hrach<br />

Titizian Stays True to His Roots<br />

By Gabriella Gage<br />

<strong>Mirror</strong>-<strong>Spectator</strong> Staff<br />

LOS ANGELES — What<br />

do “Homeland,” “24,”<br />

“Mad Men,” all have in<br />

common? Each has won a<br />

Golden Globe for Best<br />

Drama Series and each<br />

has featured actor Hrach<br />

Titizian.<br />

In addition to appearing<br />

in some of the most<br />

popular television series<br />

of the past decade,<br />

Titizian has appeared on<br />

Broadway and several<br />

films such as “Float” and “<strong>The</strong> Men<br />

Who Stare at Goats.” Titizian takes his<br />

new-found popularity in stride and<br />

instead dedicates himself to his work.<br />

Raised in Glendale’s thriving<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong> community, Titizian says that<br />

Hrach Tatizian of “Homeland”<br />

his <strong>Armenian</strong> heritage helped shape<br />

him as an individual. “My parents are<br />

both full-blooded <strong>Armenian</strong>. My father<br />

was born in Lebanon and my mother in<br />

Jordan. Although I was born and raised<br />

see TITIZIAN, page 8<br />

NEWS INBRIEF<br />

Armenia Participates<br />

In Swiss Astronomy<br />

Conference<br />

GENEVA (Armenpress) — Armenia participated in<br />

the conference of the European Astronomical<br />

Society (EAS), which was held recently in<br />

Switzerland. <strong>The</strong> EAS leaders, heads of the astronomical<br />

societies of European countries and representatives<br />

of other European scientific organizations<br />

attended the conference. Such conferences<br />

also were held in 2008 in Holland and in 2012 in<br />

Switzerland. <strong>The</strong> goal of this meeting was to sum<br />

up the results of the last year, discuss future plans,<br />

continue active cooperation with national organizations,<br />

as well as to reinforce the leading role of<br />

the European astronomy.<br />

<strong>The</strong> co-founder of <strong>Armenian</strong> Astronomical<br />

Society, Areg Mirakyan, took part in the conference<br />

and delivered a report on his group’s activities in<br />

the past year and possible ways for cooperating<br />

with the EAS .<br />

Leaders of astronomical societies from Austria,<br />

Spain, Italy, Greece, Great Britain, Switzerland, the<br />

Czech Republic, Portugal, Russia, Serbia, Ukraine<br />

and France delivered reports on the current state<br />

of astronomy in different countries.<br />

OSCE Minsk Group<br />

Meets with <strong>Armenian</strong>,<br />

Azerbaijani Officials<br />

PARIS (ArmeniaNow) — Co-Chairs of the<br />

Organization for Security and Cooperation in<br />

Europe (OSCE) Minsk Group, Ambassadors Igor<br />

Popov of the Russia, Jacques Faure of France and<br />

Ian Kelly of the US, met jointly with the Foreign<br />

Minister of Armenia Eduard Nalbandian and<br />

Foreign Minister of Azerbaijan Elmar<br />

Mammadyarov, on January 28.<br />

<strong>The</strong> personal representative of the OSCE<br />

Chairperson-in-Office, Ambassador Andrzej<br />

Kasprzyk, also attended the meeting.<br />

“<strong>The</strong> co-chairs continued discussions with the<br />

ministers on the working proposal to advance<br />

the peace process, which they submitted to the<br />

sides in October 2012. <strong>The</strong>y also exchanged<br />

views on possible confidence building measures,”<br />

according to a statement posted on the<br />

OSCE’s website.<br />

<strong>The</strong> co-chairs referred to their statements of April<br />

14, 2011, and July 13, 2012, and discussed with the<br />

ministers issues pertaining to civilian flights to and<br />

from the airport in Nagorno-Karabagh.<br />

“<strong>The</strong> foreign ministers and the co-chairs stressed<br />

the importance of the OSCE Minsk Group as the<br />

framework for negotiating a settlement of the<br />

Nagorno-Karabagh conflict. <strong>The</strong> foreign ministers<br />

reiterated their support for a peaceful settlement<br />

and their determination to continue negotiations.<br />

<strong>The</strong> ministers and the co-chairs agreed to a further<br />

discussion of the peace process in the coming<br />

weeks,” the statement added.<br />

INSIDE<br />

Sotheby’s<br />

Auction Page 11<br />

INDEX<br />

Arts and Living . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10<br />

Armenia . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2<br />

Community News. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5<br />

Editorial . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14<br />

International . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3, 4


2<br />

News From Armenia<br />

Minasian Remembered<br />

At National Library<br />

YEREVAN (Hetq) — A day of remembranccee for the<br />

late Levon Minasian, the noted Iranian-<strong>Armenian</strong><br />

teacher, academic and national activist, was held on<br />

January 22 at the National Library of Armenia.<br />

For more than seven decades, Minasian headed<br />

vaariious educcaattiionaall iinsttiittuttiioonns in Nor Jughaa aand<br />

published works on <strong>Armenian</strong> history and literature,<br />

including AA HHiissttoorryy ooff tthhee AArrmmeenniiaannss ooff PPeerraa<br />

and TThhee AArrmmeenniiaann BBaarrddss ooff PPeerraa.<br />

Gor Sujyan to Represent<br />

Armenia at Eurovision<br />

YEREVAN (Armenpress) — Singer Gor Sujyan will<br />

represent Armenia in the Eurovision <strong>2013</strong> song<br />

contest taking place in Malmö, Sweden, on May 14.<br />

SSuujyann is allso a member ooff Doriianns,, the rock<br />

band that had planned on representing Armenia in<br />

“Eurovision 2012,” until Armenia withdrew from<br />

the competition due to security concerns.<br />

Sujiyan was born in July 25, 1987, in Yerevan. He<br />

is the son of guitarist, jazzman Mkrtich Sujiyan.<br />

On March 2, Armenia will hold its national finals<br />

tto sellect tthe winning song. SSujyan wiill peerfform all<br />

of the songs and television viewers and a panel of<br />

experts will vote on the winning entry.<br />

CSTO Academy to Open<br />

In Armenia in <strong>2013</strong><br />

YEREVAN (PanARMENIAN.Net) — Collective<br />

Security Treaty Organization (CSTO) Secretary<br />

General Nikolai Bordyuzha and National Security<br />

Council (NSC) Secretary Artur Baghdasaryan<br />

signed a meemorandum of unndersttannddiing oonn creation<br />

of a CSTO Academy in Armenia.<br />

According to Bordyuzha, the academy, as a scientific,<br />

educational and analytical center, will train<br />

experts to be further involved in CSTO activities.<br />

Baghdasaryan stressed the importance of the<br />

proposed academy, expressing hope for the latter to<br />

be launched during the current year.<br />

Feast of St. Sarkis<br />

Restored as Tradition<br />

YEREVAN (Armenpress) — Exhibitions dedicated to<br />

the feast of St. Sarkis have opened in the Yerevan<br />

National Centre of Aesthetics and Artists’ Union.<br />

Prime Minister Tigran Sargisian attended the exhibitions.<br />

<strong>The</strong> Press Service of the premier’s office reported<br />

that in the Yerevan National Centre of<br />

Aesthetics hosted an exhibition of works by the students<br />

at the center’s drawing studio.<br />

Sargisian congratulated the attendees on the<br />

occasion of the Feast of St. Sarkis and stated:<br />

“Each year this feast is being celebrated in a bigger<br />

fashion in the Republic of Armenia and more people<br />

are being involved in the celebrations. I am glad<br />

that the Feast of St. Sarkis is being restored as a<br />

national tradition and spreading among the<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong>s.”<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong> Chess<br />

Federation Hosts FIDE<br />

TSAKHKADZOR, Armenia (Radiolur) — President<br />

of the World Chess Federation (FIDE) Kirsan<br />

Ilyumzhinov last month held a conference in<br />

Tsakhkadzor, featuring 23 members of FIDE and<br />

representatives from the chess federations of 20<br />

countries.<br />

During the conference, Ilyumzhinov said that the<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong> Chess Federation serves an example for<br />

the 177 FIDE member states. As such, Armenia was<br />

unanimously chosen as the host country for the<br />

conference.<br />

<strong>The</strong> assembled discussed the Chess in Schools<br />

Program first implemented in Armenia.<br />

Also in attendance was President Serge Sargisian<br />

who said, “Chess is one of the best means of dialogue<br />

between cultures and civilizations. It’s our duty to<br />

cherish and disseminate the tradition of chess.”<br />

S A T U R D A Y, F E B R U A R Y 2 , 2 0 1 3 T H E A R M E N I A N M I R R O R - S P E C TAT O R<br />

ARMENIA<br />

Tekeyan Centre Fund Renovates Yerevan School<br />

YEREVAN — Tekeyan Centre Fund<br />

had a busy 2012 and welcomed the<br />

New Year with a few new projects.<br />

Among them was a photographic art<br />

exhibition named “Today I am a pure<br />

soul,” by Zherar Agavelyan, an<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong> film director born in Armenia<br />

and now living in the US. <strong>The</strong> exhibition<br />

included photographs mixed with<br />

collages.<br />

<strong>The</strong> fund sponsored the two-week<br />

exhibition by holding it at Tekeyan<br />

Centre. <strong>The</strong> official opening with many<br />

art critics and guests present started<br />

with the Fund Chairman Vartan<br />

Ouzounian’s welcoming speech.<br />

Ouzounian emphasized the importance<br />

of such events in the national and spiritual<br />

life of <strong>Armenian</strong>s.<br />

<strong>The</strong> fund’s last scholastic project of<br />

2012 involved Yerevan Tekeyan School<br />

#92. Thanks to Hrad Darian of London,<br />

a benefactor who donated 9,000<br />

pounds sterling to the fund, Tekeyan<br />

Centre was able to renovate all the windows<br />

of the school building (Block A) to<br />

keep it warm in cold weather. <strong>The</strong> fund<br />

had also fixed the gas supply to the<br />

school, which had previously caused<br />

interruptions to the heat there. <strong>The</strong><br />

Yerevan Municipality took up the fund’s<br />

Women’s Football (Soccer) Lags in Armenia<br />

By Vahe Sarukhanyan<br />

YEREVAN (Hetq) — Armenia’s<br />

Football Federation (AFF) has decided<br />

against sending women’s football<br />

teams to the European championships.<br />

In the past, the girls’ 17- and 19-yearold<br />

teams participated in the world<br />

championships. <strong>The</strong> women’s national<br />

squad used to play in the European<br />

and World Championships.<br />

<strong>The</strong> national team has played 20<br />

qualifying games in the European<br />

Championship, only winning two. <strong>The</strong>y<br />

lost 15 and three were draws.<br />

In the world championship, the team<br />

played eight and lost them all.<br />

Armenia’s national women’s football<br />

team first played in 2003 and lost 11-0<br />

against Austria. <strong>Armenian</strong> women footballers<br />

have played eight games in the<br />

UEFA <strong>2013</strong> European Championship<br />

and have lost all by large margins.<br />

<strong>The</strong>y have only scored two goals and<br />

have let in 44. <strong>The</strong> same numbers also<br />

apply to the teen teams.<br />

<strong>The</strong> reasons are clear. Women’s football<br />

in Armenia has never been placed<br />

on a firm footing. During the last years<br />

of the Soviet Union and after independence,<br />

when women’s football had just<br />

been introduced, the teams “Nairi,”<br />

“Nork” and Aparan’s “Nig” were<br />

famous. <strong>The</strong>se, however, never registered<br />

any great success and couldn’t<br />

have, given that women’s football was<br />

Students at the Yerevan School during contest<br />

initiative and sponsored the project for<br />

Block B.<br />

Thanks to Darian’s donation,<br />

Tekeyan Centre was also able to repair<br />

the school library which was named<br />

Stephan Darakjian Library in memory<br />

From Left, TCA President Vartan Ouzounian, Principal Tsovinar Mardanyan, UK<br />

Ambassador in Armenia Kathy Leach and Archbishop Vahan Hovhannesian<br />

of the benefactor’s grandfather. Present<br />

at the official opening of the library<br />

were Bishop Vahan Hovhanessian,<br />

a new feature in the Soviet Union in<br />

the late 1980s. Things got worse in the<br />

1990s. It is of note that only the teams<br />

“Banants” and “Koledj” have been<br />

playing in recent years.<br />

<strong>The</strong> reason that the national teams<br />

have been so weak is the near absence<br />

of club teams and because there is no<br />

women’s championship in Armenia. At<br />

the core of the problem, however, is<br />

the national mentality. As a result, few<br />

girls try out for football. In addition,<br />

there are no finances invested. During<br />

an event held at the end of last year<br />

Primate of the <strong>Armenian</strong> Church in the<br />

UK and Ireland, the UK Ambassador to<br />

Armenia Katherine Leach, fund chair<br />

Ouzounian, fund director Armen<br />

Tsulikyan, and many other guests.<br />

After the official ceremony and the<br />

speeches followed by a cultural program<br />

performed by the schoolchildren<br />

and a reception, the principal of the<br />

school, Tsovinar Mardanyan, showed<br />

the visiting dignitaries round the<br />

school and detailed and thanked the<br />

fund.<br />

On January 21, Tekeyan Centre Fund<br />

launched its first interscholastic project<br />

of <strong>2013</strong> to celebrate the 135th anniversary<br />

of the <strong>Armenian</strong> poet, pedagogue<br />

and political leader, Vahan Tekeyan, for<br />

whom the school is named. <strong>The</strong> project<br />

titled “Poetry Reading Festival” conducted<br />

by journalist Marieta Makaryan,<br />

includes three levels of competition<br />

which will be finalized on April 4, to<br />

commemorate the poet’s death.<br />

Schoolchildren ages 10-18 from all<br />

Vahan Tekeyan Schools in Armenia and<br />

Artsakh as well as literature teachers are<br />

going to take part in the competition.<br />

<strong>The</strong> aim of the project is to immortalize<br />

and to introduce the great poet’s<br />

life and his rich literary heritage to the<br />

young generation.<br />

where UEFA representatives were present,<br />

Marina Tashchyan, the head of<br />

the National Teams, noted that the<br />

AFF had been right in placing an<br />

emphasis on the younger girls. She<br />

said that Armenia now has five girls’<br />

teams.<br />

Sadly, in September 2011, AFF<br />

President Ruben Hayrapetyan said<br />

the following in response to a question<br />

about women’s football:<br />

“Women’s football in Armenia hasn’t<br />

developed nor will it. I have no desire<br />

to promote it.”<br />

Heifer Armenia Provides Equipment,<br />

Training to Small Dairy Producers<br />

YEREVAN — Heifer International’s Armenia program, working in collaboration<br />

with other international institutions, has provided more than<br />

104 pieces of agricultural equipment to 33 farm cooperatives through the<br />

Community Agricultural Resource Management and Competitiveness<br />

(CARMAC) project. Distributions of the agricultural equipment followed<br />

pasture management trainings in several regions of Armenia. <strong>The</strong>se training<br />

programs enable the farmers to make the best use of their land and<br />

provide better fodder for livestock. “Now everything is easier; we are able<br />

to do all the work on schedule,” said Gevorg Galstyan, president of the<br />

Nerqin Tsaghkavan Community Cooperative. “Before we got the equipment,<br />

we might have harvested only 30 percent of our optimal yield. Now<br />

we don’t face such problems any longer.”<br />

<strong>The</strong> objective of the CARMAC project is to reverse environmental damage<br />

caused by unsustainable grazing, increase the economic viability of<br />

small farms through infrastructure improvements and increase productivity<br />

to reach more markets.


S A T U R D A Y, F E B R U A R Y 2 , 2 0 1 3 T H E A R M E N I A N M I R R O R - S P E C TAT O R 3<br />

INTERNATIONAL<br />

Religious Leaders Join in Call for<br />

Two-State Solution in Middle East<br />

By Arthur Hagopian<br />

JERUSALEM — Leading figures<br />

among the <strong>Armenian</strong> and Greek<br />

Orthodox ecumenical movement in<br />

the US have joined a pride of other<br />

leaders of Christian, Moslem and<br />

Jewish religious and lay organizations<br />

and institutions, pledging to mobilize<br />

support for peace in the Middle East.<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong> Archbishop Vicken<br />

Aykazian, the director of ecumenical<br />

affairs for <strong>Armenian</strong> Orthodox<br />

Church in America Father Mark Arey,<br />

the director of the Office of<br />

Ecumenical Affairs for the Greek<br />

Orthodox Archdiocese of America,<br />

believe time is running out for both<br />

Israelis and Palestinians.<br />

<strong>The</strong> loose umbrella of the US<br />

National Interreligious Leadership<br />

Initiative (NILI) for Peace in the<br />

Middle East , which includes<br />

<strong>The</strong>odore Cardinal McCarrick,<br />

Archbishop Emeritus of Washington,<br />

Imam Mohammed Magid, President,<br />

Islamic Society of North America, and<br />

Rabbi Peter Knobel, past president,<br />

Central Conference of American<br />

Rabbis, warns that the possibility of a<br />

two-state solution to the Israeli-<br />

Palestinian conflict was waning, and<br />

urged immediate, sustained US leadership<br />

before darkness falls on the<br />

hopes for a peaceful resolution.”<br />

Among the other leaders are<br />

Kathryn Mary Lohre, president,<br />

National Council of Churches of<br />

Christ (US) and Richard Stearns,<br />

president, World Vision US.<br />

Aykazian was in Jerusalem last<br />

week to participate in the elections<br />

for a new <strong>Armenian</strong> patriarch and<br />

had been one of the contenders for<br />

the position.<br />

<strong>The</strong> group believes the most viable<br />

solution to the Arab-Israeli conflict is<br />

a two-state agreement that provides<br />

for a secure and recognized Israel living<br />

in peace alongside a viable and<br />

independent Palestinian state.<br />

“With the support of the international<br />

community, Israelis and<br />

Palestinians can achieve a lasting<br />

peace. A new dawn is<br />

possible,” they said in a<br />

statement they released.<br />

Mourning the lives<br />

lost and shattered during<br />

the recent violence<br />

that gripped the region,<br />

the group warned that<br />

what had been seen,<br />

over the past years, “will<br />

keep happening if movement<br />

towards a viable<br />

two state-solution continues<br />

to stagnate.”<br />

As things stand now,<br />

“the status quo is unsustainable<br />

and dangerous to both<br />

Israelis and Palestinians,” they conceded,<br />

but stressed now is not the<br />

time for “another cycle of recriminations.<br />

It is time to break the cycle of<br />

violence with bold initiatives for<br />

peace.”<br />

“<strong>The</strong> current dangerous stalemate,<br />

including the legacy of past failed<br />

peacemaking efforts, undermines our<br />

security and that of others, destabilizes<br />

the region, fuels terrorism and<br />

extremism, allows continuing Israeli<br />

settlement expansion and prolongs<br />

Palestinian disunity. <strong>The</strong>se realities<br />

and the absence of negotiations<br />

threaten to kill the prospect of a<br />

viable two-state peace agreement, the<br />

only realistic solution to the conflict,”<br />

they said.<br />

<strong>The</strong>y urged strong and determined<br />

action, proposing a peace of the<br />

brave, because as people of faith, “we<br />

proclaim that we should never underestimate<br />

what is possible.”<br />

“We know the challenges are<br />

daunting, but we believe a bold new<br />

initiative for an Israeli-Palestinian<br />

peace settlement should be an immediate<br />

priority of the new<br />

[US] Administration in<br />

<strong>2013</strong>. We fear the<br />

opportunity for a peaceful<br />

resolution is rapidly<br />

waning and the current<br />

stagnation encourages<br />

the rejectionists on<br />

both sides,” the statement<br />

said.<br />

<strong>The</strong>y noted that the<br />

US “has unique lever-<br />

age and credibility in<br />

the region” and that no<br />

past progress towards<br />

peace has occurred in<br />

the Arab-Israeli conflict without US<br />

leadership, facilitation or staunch<br />

support.<br />

“Once again, we need active, fair<br />

and firm US leadership to help break<br />

the current deadlock and to achieve a<br />

two-state peace agreement now<br />

before it is too late,” they added.<br />

<strong>The</strong>y pledged to mobilize the<br />

strong support that exists in churches,<br />

synagogues and mosques across<br />

the US, in the push for peace.<br />

“Twilight is upon us; but the<br />

hope for a new dawn remains. Let<br />

us together bring the new light of<br />

hope and work for negotiations<br />

leading to a final status agreement,”<br />

they added.<br />

Tinderbox Next Door: Growing Ethnic<br />

Protests in Azerbaijan may ‘Detonate’ War<br />

By Naira Hayrumyan<br />

ISMAYILLI, Azerbaijan<br />

(ArmeniaNow) — <strong>The</strong> wave of protests<br />

that struck Azerbaijan last week may<br />

act as a detonator for military conflict in<br />

the South Caucasus.<br />

<strong>The</strong> incident is reminiscent of the<br />

beginning of the Arab Spring, says head<br />

of the Analytical Center on<br />

Globalization and Regional<br />

Cooperation, political analyst Stepan<br />

Grigoryan.<br />

“It is possible that the Azerbaijani<br />

side will try to escalate the situation<br />

along the line of contact of the armed<br />

forces of Nagorno-Karabagh and<br />

Azerbaijan,” Grigoryan said.<br />

Andrei Areshev of the Center for<br />

Central Asia Studies and Caucasus<br />

Institute of Oriental Studies of the<br />

Russian Academy of Sciences agreed<br />

that Azerbaijani authorities will attempt<br />

to redirect the anger of the society<br />

towards Karabagh.<br />

“<strong>The</strong> authorities will agitate patriotic<br />

feelings among people to shift their<br />

attention from internal problems to the<br />

‘enemies’, and in Azerbaijan, <strong>Armenian</strong>s<br />

and Karabagh are considered to be<br />

these enemies,” he said.<br />

Protesters in Ismayilli burned a car<br />

and a hotel owned by representatives of<br />

the leading party’s clan. This caused a<br />

wave of protests across the country,<br />

eventually reaching the capital, Baku.<br />

It is worth noting that this occurred on<br />

the same day that Mexico City authorities<br />

dismantled the monument to former<br />

President Heydar Aliyev. This served as a<br />

major blow to the credibility of the Aliyev<br />

regime and also as a sign that the West<br />

may seek to dismantle the regime.<br />

It seems likely that the West and the<br />

local opposition will be make moves to<br />

change the regime in the upcoming<br />

elections, given several conflicts<br />

between oil companies and the regime.<br />

Last year saw a conflict between Aliyev<br />

and British Petroleum, which is the<br />

main investor in the oil sector of<br />

Azerbaijan. Rumors that oil reserves in<br />

the region were dwindling cast further<br />

doubts about the Aliyev regime’s ability<br />

For Your Internal News of Armenia<br />

Log on to www.AZG.am<br />

In English, <strong>Armenian</strong>, Russian and Turkish<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong> Archbishop<br />

Vicken Aykazian<br />

to manage its natural resources.<br />

On January 27, the police forbid Isa<br />

Gambar, the leader of the main opposition<br />

party Musavat, to enter the city of<br />

Lankaran in the south of Azerbaijan.<br />

Two weeks prior, a Gambar motorcade<br />

was also attacked at the entrance to<br />

Lankaran by assailants allegedly trained<br />

by the Aliyev authorities.<br />

Lankaran, like Guba and Ismayilli, is a<br />

Lezghian-populated region of<br />

Azerbaijan. Experts say the reactivation<br />

of the Lezghian national movement in<br />

Azerbaijan poses a serious threat to the<br />

Aliyev regime. If the national movements<br />

of the Lezghians and Talyshes,<br />

Iranian peoples who have lived in<br />

Turkic Azerbaijan since 1918, gain<br />

momentum, it could lead to the collapse<br />

of the Azerbaijani state. It is this very<br />

threat that is causing Aliyev to embark<br />

on a military gamble in Karabagh by<br />

unleashing a war against the de-facto<br />

independent republic.<br />

South Caucasus geopolitics expert,<br />

Anzhela Elibegova, said that the<br />

Kurdish component should not be forgotten<br />

when assessing the overall conflict.<br />

“<strong>The</strong> Azerbaijani opposition media<br />

write regularly that Kurds in Azerbaijan<br />

enjoy ‘special’ rights. In Nakhichevan,<br />

the conventional homeland of Heydar<br />

Aliyev, the majority of the population<br />

today are Kurds, but during the years of<br />

the Aliyev rule they have settled on<br />

lands historically inhabited by the<br />

Talyshes and Lezgins,” said Elibegova.<br />

International News<br />

Aronian Takes Second<br />

Place at Tata Steel<br />

WIJK AAN ZEE, Netherlands (ArmeniaNow) —<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong> grandmaster Levon Aronian said his second-place<br />

performance at the Tata Steel<br />

Tournament in the Netherlands last week was a<br />

“good result.”<br />

<strong>The</strong> GGrouup A Touurnaament bbrouught together 14<br />

grandmasters and ended in a victory by the topranked<br />

player in the world, Magnus Carlsen, of<br />

Norway. Finishing second, Aronian, currently the<br />

world’s number three player, outdid Viswanathan<br />

Anand from India.<br />

“Remembering the positions I would have [duringg<br />

some of the ggames] at the tournament, I can’’t<br />

say that I am very satisfied with my performance.<br />

Though I really missed several important [opportunities,]<br />

second place is quite a good result,” said<br />

Aronian.<br />

Ukrainian Museum of<br />

National History Hosts<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong> Exhibit<br />

KIEV, Ukraine (Pan<strong>Armenian</strong>.net) — <strong>The</strong> Ukrainian<br />

Museum of National History is showcasing an<br />

exhibit documenting the history of UUkraine’s<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong> community.<br />

<strong>The</strong> exposition includes rare photographs, documents,<br />

awards, printed editions, national costumes,<br />

household items and other artifacts reflecting the<br />

Ukrainian-<strong>Armenian</strong>s’ long history.<br />

<strong>The</strong> leader of the Union of <strong>Armenian</strong>s of Ukraine,<br />

Vilen Shatvoryan, said of the exhibit, “Kiev attaches<br />

special importance to <strong>Armenian</strong> cultural and historic<br />

heritage.”<br />

<strong>The</strong> number of <strong>Armenian</strong>s in Ukraine totals<br />

99,894 according to the 2001 Ukrainian census.<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong>s first appeared in Ukraine during the<br />

Kievan Rus period. During the 10th century, individual<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong> merchants, mercenaries and<br />

craftsmen served in the courts of various<br />

Ruthenian rulers.<br />

he Donetsk Oblast (province) holds the greatest<br />

number of <strong>Armenian</strong>s in Ukraine.<br />

Azeri Forces Hold Drills<br />

On Karabagh Border,<br />

Violate Ceasefire<br />

BAKU (PanARMENIAN.Net) — Nearly 200 instances<br />

of ceasefire violation by Azeri armed forces were<br />

reported at the line of contact between Nagorno<br />

Karabagh and Azerbaijan from January 20 to 26.<br />

Azerbaijan fired over 700 shots from various caliber<br />

weapons in the direction of Karabagh positions,<br />

NKR defense army’s press service reports.<br />

Also, all through the last week, Azeri air forces<br />

conducted drills along the line of contact.<br />

Former President<br />

Aliyev’s Statue Removed<br />

From Mexico City Park<br />

MEXICO CITY (PanARMENIAN.Net) — A life-size<br />

bronze statue of Azerbaijan’s former president,<br />

Heydar Aliyev ,was removed from Mexico City’s<br />

main avenue, on Saturday, January 26 morning. It<br />

was instead relocated to a site in the suburbs.<br />

In November, an advisory commission issued a<br />

recommendation to remove the statue. <strong>The</strong> rights<br />

groups said they were offended by a monument of<br />

a “dictator” erected in one of the busiest areas in<br />

the city.<br />

Azerbaijan has paid around $5 million for the<br />

renovation of part of Chapultepec Park, where the<br />

statue is was installed, and other public works.<br />

<strong>The</strong> protesters have objected to Aliyev’s statue<br />

saying that he was an authoritarian figure, who led<br />

Azerbaijan first as Communist Party boss during<br />

Soviet times and then as president from 1993 until<br />

his death in 2003.<br />

Baku warned earlier of damage to Azerbaijan’s<br />

relations with Mexico if the statue is removed,<br />

including the potential cuts to Azerbaijani investments<br />

in Mexico.


4<br />

By Hrant Gadarigian<br />

ISTANBUL (Hetq) — To get a better insight<br />

into the recent attacks against elderly <strong>Armenian</strong><br />

women in Istanbul, Hetq contacted Fethiye<br />

Çetin, a prominent lawyer and human rights<br />

S A T U R D A Y, F E B R U A R Y 2 , 2 0 1 3 T H E A R M E N I A N M I R R O R - S P E C TAT O R<br />

advocate working in Turkey.<br />

Çetin has served as an attorney for the family<br />

of Hrant Dink and is the author of My<br />

Grandmother, a book describing how and when<br />

she found out about her <strong>Armenian</strong> roots.<br />

Hrant Gadarigian (HG): Recently, former<br />

Agos Editor Aris Nalci told Today’s Zaman that<br />

he believed these attacks were organized and<br />

called on Turkish officials to launch a comprehensive<br />

investigation. Would you agree with his<br />

assessment?<br />

Fethiye Çetin (FÇ): I would also agree that<br />

these actions are organized and planned. At<br />

first, the police promoted the line that they<br />

were violent robberies, however no such evidence<br />

was to be found in the homes of the victims.<br />

In addition, witnesses claim that the<br />

attackers always had an accomplice or two nearby.<br />

We have been focusing our attention on<br />

Samatya of late, but it must be said that attacks<br />

directed against Christians have been occurring<br />

all over the country as well. <strong>The</strong> latest was the<br />

exposure of an organized gang that attempted<br />

to murder a Christian priest in Kocaeli. All this<br />

attests to the fact that the events are systematic<br />

in nature and not random.<br />

HG: Being close to certain segments of the<br />

Istanbul-<strong>Armenian</strong> community, how would you<br />

describe the emotional state within the community<br />

in light of these incidents?<br />

INTERNATIONAL<br />

Young Turk’s Grandson in Germany<br />

ÇEMAL, from page 1<br />

intervention into the dialogue process<br />

among Turks, Germans, <strong>Armenian</strong>s and<br />

Kurds about the Genocide, aimed at working<br />

through the common past in the search for<br />

truth and, thereby, for understanding and<br />

reconciliation. Ilyas Kevork Uyar, chairman<br />

of the Diocese Board of the <strong>Armenian</strong><br />

Church and also defense lawyer for the<br />

Turkish-German author Dogan Akhanli,<br />

introduced him at Cologne university, saying<br />

he hoped that Çemal’s experience, as someone<br />

who has worked through the past and<br />

acknowledged the genocide of 1.5 million<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong>s, would serve as an example for<br />

others to follow. Not only in Turkey, he said,<br />

did denial persist but also in Germany, where<br />

certain nationalistic Turkish associations<br />

have organized protests against the<br />

“<strong>Armenian</strong> lies,” etc.<br />

Hasan Çemal, speaking in German, introduced<br />

himself to the audience of about 400<br />

Germans mainly of Turkish and <strong>Armenian</strong><br />

descent, then read a speech in Turkish which<br />

was simultaneously translated by Osman<br />

Okkam, journalist, film maker and<br />

spokesman for the KulturForum<br />

TürkeiDeutschland, which had sponsored the<br />

event. <strong>The</strong> subject was how to liberate oneself<br />

from falsified history, a process that is intimately<br />

tied to one’s sense of personal identity.<br />

Çemal cited cases of two of his associates,<br />

who did not dare admit that their mothers<br />

were <strong>Armenian</strong> and Kurdish, respectively.<br />

That two of the best writers in Turkey had to<br />

lie about their mothers’ ethnic background,<br />

he said, was very sad; the Kurds “had to fight<br />

to prove that they existed, whereas the<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong>s had to fight to prove that they<br />

had been eliminated.” In the case of the<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong>s it was not only the physical elimi-<br />

Archbishop Nourhan<br />

Manougian Elected 97th<br />

Patriarch of Jerusalem<br />

PATRIARCH, from page 1<br />

Catholicosate of Cilicia in Antelias, Lebanon. In<br />

1966, he was accepted to the theological seminary<br />

of the <strong>Armenian</strong> Patriarchate of<br />

Jerusalem. His days as a student at the<br />

Patriarchate culminated in his ordination to the<br />

priesthood and his membership in the St. James<br />

Brotherhood in 1971.<br />

A year later, he was appointed the pastor of<br />

the <strong>Armenian</strong>s of Switzerland. Subsequently, he<br />

returned to the Middle East and served as the<br />

pastor to the <strong>Armenian</strong> communities of Jaffa<br />

and Haifa. In 1980, he was assigned the position<br />

of pastor of the <strong>Armenian</strong> community of<br />

Holland.<br />

Manougian visited the US and pursued his<br />

graduate studies at New York’s General<br />

<strong>The</strong>ological Seminary. He subsequently served<br />

the Eastern Diocese as the pastor of St. Mark<br />

Church of Springfield, Mass., and then St.<br />

Kevork Church of Houston, Texas.<br />

Upon returning to Jerusalem, Manougian was<br />

elected Grand Sacristan of the Holy See in<br />

1998. A year later, Catholicos of All <strong>Armenian</strong>s<br />

Karekin II elevated him to the rank of bishop.<br />

(Editor’s note: We congratulate Archbishop<br />

Manougian on being elected the 97th Patriarch<br />

of the Holy See of Jerusalem and wish him<br />

every success in his challenging mission.)<br />

nation of the people but also the “cultural<br />

assassination,” whereby official Turkish history<br />

makes no reference to the existence of<br />

their civilization.<br />

Falsified history began with the birth of<br />

the modern Turkish republic, which was no<br />

state founded on the rule of law, but a place<br />

where everyone was forced to lie. Though he<br />

was a 1965 graduate in political science, he<br />

had been totally ignorant of the facts of 1915-<br />

1916. He did not know that the <strong>Armenian</strong>s<br />

had populated the territory earlier, nor that<br />

there had been Kurdish rebellions. It was<br />

only in 2005, when a conference on the<br />

Kurdish issue was convened, that one could<br />

talk about it. <strong>The</strong>n and thereafter, it was forbidden<br />

however to utter the name Dersim,<br />

where an uprising had been brutally suppressed.<br />

<strong>The</strong> situation he described was characterized<br />

by “fear, fear of history, fear of phantoms;”<br />

no one dared to challenge official historiography<br />

for fear of being labeled a “traitor.”<br />

One friend who had done so and been<br />

labeled a traitor was Taner Akçam, the leading<br />

Turkish scholar of the Genocide. Akçam<br />

had insisted on questioning the taboos, prejudices<br />

and clichés, and overcoming them.<br />

Çemal then gave a personal account of his<br />

struggle to deal with the taboos. At the end<br />

of March 2011, he was at UCLA, preparing a<br />

speech for a conference. While sitting at his<br />

computer, he asked himself, “Should I use<br />

the word ‘genocide’ or not?” He wanted to<br />

speak of <strong>Armenian</strong>s’ fears and pain and to<br />

express his empathy. “But what pain? From<br />

‘genocide’ or in general?” he asked himself.<br />

“Why was it so difficult to use this word?” He<br />

knew, he said, that the Committee of Unity<br />

and Progress, the Young Turks, had<br />

embraced a policy to remove all non-Turks<br />

INVESTIGATION, from page 1<br />

claimed that the recent attacks on Turkish<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong> women in Samatya weren’t motivated<br />

by robbery.<br />

In its report on the attacks, the HRA said<br />

they could be part of an “ethnic cleansing” campaign<br />

and called for the immediate apprehension<br />

of the culprits.<br />

<strong>The</strong> organization has sent its report to the<br />

Turkish Ministry of the Interior.<br />

Meanwhile, Agos editor Rober Koptas told<br />

from the Ottoman Empire. “I knew it. Why<br />

didn’t I want to use ‘genocide’ if I knew this?”<br />

he asked. He put in the word “genocide,” but<br />

then erased it.<br />

His confrontation with this loaded term<br />

had a history. Earlier, in 2008, he had travelled<br />

to Yerevan and visited the Genocide<br />

monument to pay his respects to the memory<br />

of Hrant Dink. He had contemplated the<br />

profound emotions felt at sundown, when<br />

reflecting on the pain of the <strong>Armenian</strong> victims,<br />

and, at sunrise, had realized “how<br />

absurd it was to deny genocide.” In March<br />

2011, in Los Angeles, the process went further.<br />

“I had mentioned the Young Turks and<br />

their crimes against humanity. I was convinced<br />

of the need to stop denial, but I still<br />

hesitated to use the term.” He asked himself<br />

if it was fear. <strong>The</strong>n he reflected on his age.<br />

“How old am I and how long do I have left to<br />

fight for democracy?” he asked. “How long<br />

do I have not to use this word?” <strong>The</strong>n, he<br />

related, “I put in the word. I wrote: ‘I know<br />

your pain from the Genocide.’”<br />

He characterized the phenomenon as “selfviolence,”<br />

a well-known psychological phenomenon.<br />

“We need to deal with prejudices,”<br />

he said and referenced the historical precedents<br />

in Germany, the “best example to<br />

understand taboos and also liberation from<br />

them.” He concluded his speech with an<br />

appeal, “that the truth may come to light.”<br />

During the question-and-answer session, he<br />

elaborated on the German precedent, recalling<br />

the decisive role played by the so-called<br />

‘68er generation of youth who confronted<br />

their parents about their roles under Nazism.<br />

He also highlighted the gesture of Willy<br />

Brandt, who in 1970, fell to his knees before<br />

the Warsaw Ghetto monument, to express<br />

acknowledgement and regret for the crimes<br />

FÇ: <strong>The</strong>se attacks have created fear and anxiety<br />

for <strong>Armenian</strong>s and Christians living in<br />

Turkey. An <strong>Armenian</strong> woman living in the<br />

Samatya neighborhood responded to a Milliyet<br />

reporter by stating, “Let us die in our beds.”<br />

<strong>The</strong>se few words clearly describe the emotional<br />

state of <strong>Armenian</strong>s.<br />

HG: If the attacks are indeed premeditated<br />

Today’s Zaman that the ministry should establish<br />

a commission to conduct a comprehensive<br />

investigation of the matter.<br />

“None of the politicians and state officials has<br />

released any statement on the issue yet, which<br />

also increases the concerns of the <strong>Armenian</strong>s<br />

living in Samatya. <strong>The</strong> interior minister, the<br />

Istanbul governor or the Istanbul police chief<br />

should give detailed information to the public<br />

regarding these incidents,” Koptas said.<br />

Garo Paylan, an <strong>Armenian</strong> community<br />

of Nazi Germany. When asked about his own<br />

family and how they dealt with his grandfather’s<br />

role, he said his family was very apolitical.<br />

His father, Çemal Pasha’s son, was born<br />

in 1900, and the only thing discussed at<br />

home about 1915 was the official version:<br />

there was war, there had been deportations,<br />

there were massacres — nothing more.<br />

It was only in the 1970s, after the first<br />

Turkish diplomats had been killed by ASALA,<br />

that he, then a journalist at Çumhuriyet, and<br />

his colleagues raised questions: why are they<br />

killing these diplomats? What do they want?<br />

What did our forefathers do to the<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong>s? <strong>The</strong>reafter came his first investigations<br />

and articles on the issue. Initially, he<br />

too “defended the raison d’état” and then,<br />

after meeting Taner Akçam and Dink, delved<br />

into more serious research and arrived at the<br />

truth. It was his contact with Dink, and then<br />

his murder, that was decisive. Dink “had to<br />

sacrifice his life for this,” he said, his murder<br />

turned the tide. Since then there have been<br />

initiatives, solidarity petitions, open discussions,<br />

debates and demonstrations. Asked by<br />

moderator Raffi Kantian what he expected by<br />

2015, he said, “I cannot foresee or predict<br />

what will happen. What is important is to<br />

continue to fight for democracy and for dialogue.”<br />

This man’s appearance in Germany was a<br />

bombshell. And the attempts on the part of<br />

nationalist Kemalist groups to disturb the<br />

commemorations through provocations were<br />

only further proof of this fact. His personal<br />

courage deserves respect and support. Not<br />

only has he faced hostility in the Kemalist<br />

camp, but has laid bare his personal, internal<br />

confrontation with the official denialist propaganda<br />

in a fashion that helps others —<br />

including <strong>Armenian</strong>s in the diaspora — understand<br />

better what kinds of<br />

psychological/political problems serious<br />

Turkish intellectuals have to work through in<br />

their search for the truth.<br />

Fethiye Çetin Discusses Climate of Fear in Turkey<br />

Fethiye Çetin<br />

and organized, by whom and for what aim?<br />

FÇ: To date, not one of the criminals has<br />

been discovered. I believe that these incidents<br />

must be connected to the words uttered by the<br />

Minister of Internal Affairs at last year’s Khojaly<br />

Meeting. For this reason, I fear that similar incidents<br />

will only increase and worsen in the lead<br />

up to 2015.<br />

HG: All the victims have been elderly<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong> women who live alone. Does this factor<br />

have any particular significance?<br />

FÇ: I think they have chosen elderly women<br />

who live alone because they don’t want any eyewitnesses.<br />

Also, they want to create an even<br />

larger climate of fear in the <strong>Armenian</strong> community.<br />

HG: What must Turkish authorities do,<br />

which they aren’t now, to prevent the reoccurrence<br />

of such attacks in the future and to prove<br />

that they are truly concerned with the safety of<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong> citizens of Turkey?<br />

FÇ: It is vital to expose the culprits as soon<br />

as possible and the forces pulling the strings.<br />

<strong>The</strong> authorities must publicly address the community<br />

and state that those responsible will be<br />

severely punished. <strong>The</strong> authorities must keep<br />

this issue on their agenda. Through various<br />

events and pronouncements, the public at large<br />

must be made aware that mentality causing<br />

these attacks is bankrupt.<br />

Former Agos Editor Calls for Investigation of Istanbul Attacks<br />

activist, told Today’s Zaman that he found it surprising<br />

that Turkish police have yet to track<br />

down the attackers despite the numerous security<br />

cameras in the neighborhood and the<br />

increased police presence.<br />

“We are deeply concerned that these incidents<br />

are an organized crime targeting <strong>Armenian</strong>s. This is<br />

why the police should be more attentive to these<br />

assaults. <strong>The</strong> fact that no concrete development has<br />

taken place regarding the assaults gives us doubt<br />

about the sincerity of the police,” Paylan noted.


TCA Arshag Dickranian<br />

School Student Wins<br />

AP Scholar Award<br />

LOS ANGELES — Aram Ekimyan, a<br />

senior at the Tekeyan Cultural<br />

Association’s (TCA) Arshag Dickranian<br />

School, has received the Advanced<br />

Placement (AP) Scholar Award in recognition<br />

of his commendable college-level<br />

achievement on Advanced Placement<br />

Program Examinations in 2012. Ekimyan<br />

has also received the AP Scholar with<br />

Distinction Award, which is granted to<br />

students who receive an average score of<br />

at least 3.5 on all AP exams<br />

taken, and scores of 3 or higher on five or<br />

more of these exams.<br />

With this accomplishment, Ekimyan<br />

has set the bar<br />

high and has<br />

become an<br />

example for students<br />

at TCA<br />

A r s h a g<br />

D i c k r a n i a n<br />

School and all to<br />

follow. Students<br />

at the school are<br />

inspired to work<br />

Aram Ekimyan<br />

harder to<br />

achieve the same<br />

or even excel,<br />

especially with the new courses which<br />

have been added to the school’s educational<br />

program since the beginning of the<br />

2012-<strong>2013</strong> scholastic year.<br />

Students at TCA Arshag Dickranian<br />

School are eligible to receive AP courses<br />

in US history, calculus, art history, government,<br />

psychology and English literature,<br />

based on their overall performance.<br />

<strong>The</strong> school also plans to add AP courses<br />

in world history, statistics, physics, studio,<br />

government, European history and environmental<br />

science to its program by the<br />

beginning of the next academic year.<br />

Attaining high scores in the AP tests<br />

increases the chance for students to<br />

receive scholarships.<br />

For more information visit<br />

www.dickranianschool.org.<br />

Fresno State Presents<br />

‘<strong>Armenian</strong> Jerusalem: Past<br />

And Present’ Symposium<br />

FRESNO — A symposium, “<strong>Armenian</strong><br />

Jerusalem: Past and Present,” organized by the<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong> Studies Program at Fresno State, in<br />

cooperation with Save the ArQ, will be held at<br />

7:30 p.m. on Friday, <strong>February</strong> 8.<br />

<strong>The</strong> symposium will be held in the University<br />

Business Center, Alice Peters Auditorium,<br />

Room 191, on the Fresno State campus and is<br />

part of the <strong>Armenian</strong> Studies Program Spring<br />

<strong>2013</strong> Lecture Series. A hors d’oeuvres reception<br />

will be held 6:30-7:30 p.m. in the gallery<br />

next to the auditorium. <strong>The</strong> lecture is funded in<br />

part by the Leon S. Peters Foundation.<br />

Save the ArQ is a 501(c)3 organization dedicated<br />

to preserving the <strong>Armenian</strong> Quarter of<br />

Jerusalem. <strong>The</strong> non-profit organization aims to<br />

create awareness of the significant religious,<br />

cultural, and historical presence of <strong>Armenian</strong>s<br />

in Jerusalem and to encourage the revitalization<br />

of the <strong>Armenian</strong> Quarter in the Old City.<br />

<strong>The</strong> <strong>Armenian</strong> Quarter encompasses one-sixth<br />

of the Old City which the <strong>Armenian</strong>s have<br />

inhabited since the fourth century.<br />

Four papers will present various facets on the<br />

Holy City of Jerusalem, a place of great significance<br />

in <strong>Armenian</strong> history. Each of the papers<br />

focuses on an interesting aspect of the city, and<br />

the <strong>Armenian</strong> Patriarchate of Jerusalem.<br />

Tamar Boyadjian (UCLA) will present a paper<br />

on “Lament for the City: Jerusalem and the<br />

see LECTURE, page 6<br />

S A T U R D A Y, F E B R U A R Y 2 , 2 0 1 3 T H E A R M E N I A N M I R R O R - S P E C TAT O R<br />

Community News<br />

Memorial for Khachadour P. Garabedian is unveiled in Philadelphia as a tribute to<br />

the only known <strong>Armenian</strong> to have served in combat during the American Civil War<br />

with Gary Koltookian, left, and Paul Sookiasian.<br />

Chance Discovery Leads to<br />

Rare <strong>Armenian</strong> Hero<br />

CHELMSFORD, Mass. — Like a model ship wedged inside a bottle, Gary<br />

Koltookian feels that’s where he belongs.<br />

It would be quite natural for the antique bottle-collector. One look at his collection<br />

and you’ll see why. His business<br />

card reads “Bottle Gary” and that is how<br />

By Tom Vartabedian<br />

people around the Merrimack Valley<br />

know this community activist.<br />

One day in 1991, Koltookian was<br />

meandering through a flea market in Hollis, NH, searching for bottles, when he<br />

crossed paths with a document that caught his attention.<br />

<strong>The</strong>re, in some remote part of the country, Koltookian’s eyes were drawn to an<br />

1855 Lowell Courier on a dealer’s table, containing an advertisement placed in<br />

that paper by a chap named “Menas Garabed,” cabinet-maker, who once lived in<br />

his very own community — next city over.<br />

“Wow. 1855. An <strong>Armenian</strong> in Lowell,” he thought to himself.<br />

Eventually he found out that his full name was given name was Khachadour P.<br />

Garabedian and he worked in the Lowell mills and became the only known<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong> to have fought during the American Civil War.<br />

Koltookian gathered information from mid-century Lowell newspapers, old<br />

Lowell city directories, a record book of Union Navy officers and from National<br />

Archives, namely the military pensions division.<br />

From the documents, he learned that Garabedian was discharged as a sailor in<br />

Philadelphia, worked, married, died and was buried there upon his death in 1881.<br />

He called his nephew’s father-in-law in Philadelphia to investigate the gravesite<br />

and was stunned by the news. <strong>The</strong>re was no surviving marker or stone commemorating<br />

Garabedian’s death.<br />

Based upon the information he had received, Koltookian wrote an article for the<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong> <strong>Mirror</strong>-<strong>Spectator</strong> in 2004 telling Garabedian’s story which caught the<br />

attention of Paul Sookiasian.<br />

<strong>The</strong> Philadelphia college student read his article and was inspired to raise funds<br />

for a fitting memorial. With the aid of the Philadelphia <strong>Armenian</strong>-American<br />

Veterans, enough money was collected for the project.<br />

Last October — eight years after that article was published — a dedication ceremony<br />

and requiem was conducted at Garabedian’s final resting place in<br />

Lansdowne, Penn., where a traditional <strong>Armenian</strong> khatchkar was erected in his<br />

honor.<br />

“<strong>The</strong>re were not many <strong>Armenian</strong>s in America during the 1860s,” said<br />

Koltookian, whose ancestors arrived here after the turn of the century. “Those like<br />

Khachadour were among the few making America their home.”<br />

<strong>The</strong> 78-year-old Koltookian is a retired social studies teacher, historian,<br />

researcher, collector and member of the Lowell Historical Society. He has served<br />

on local <strong>Armenian</strong> Genocide commemoration committees and belongs to the<br />

Merrimack Valley Knights of Vartan.<br />

He will present a talk on the subject Thursday, <strong>February</strong> 7, at noon, during an<br />

Avak luncheon at St. Gregory <strong>Armenian</strong> Church, 158 Main St., North Andover. <strong>The</strong><br />

public is invited to attend.<br />

Razmik Panossian<br />

Appointed Director of<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong> Communities<br />

Department of<br />

Gulbenkian Foundation<br />

5<br />

LISBON — <strong>The</strong> Calouste Gulbenkian<br />

Foundation announced this week the appointment<br />

of Dr. Razmik Panossian as the new director<br />

of the <strong>Armenian</strong> Communities Department<br />

in Lisbon.<br />

Panossian holds a doctorate from the<br />

London School of Economics and Political<br />

Science, where he also taught. He has published<br />

widely on <strong>Armenian</strong>-related issues,<br />

including a critically-acclaimed book on<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong> national identity. He has extensive<br />

experience in senior management, including the<br />

administration of multi-million dollar programs,<br />

as well as the allocation and distribution of<br />

international development grants. For many<br />

years he served as the director of Policy,<br />

Programmes and Planning at a Canadian governmental<br />

organization based in Montreal. He<br />

has worked for the United Nations<br />

Development Programme. He is fluent in<br />

English, French and <strong>Armenian</strong>.<br />

“I am both thrilled and humbled by this<br />

appointment,” said Panossian. “This is one of<br />

the most important positions in the <strong>Armenian</strong><br />

Diaspora. I am looking forward to continuing<br />

the work of my predecessors and further<br />

strengthening and expanding the activities of<br />

the Calouste Gulbenkian Foundation in a<br />

focused and systematic manner within<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong> communities around the world.”<br />

Martin Essayan, the trustee responsible for<br />

the <strong>Armenian</strong> Communities Department, and<br />

great-grandson of Calouste Gulbenkian, said: “I<br />

am delighted that Dr. Panossian will be the new<br />

director of the <strong>Armenian</strong> Communities<br />

Department. He comes with outstanding credentials<br />

for this role and brings the international,<br />

integrative perspective we need. <strong>The</strong><br />

appointment followed a global search during<br />

which we were able to consider many excellent<br />

candidates.”<br />

Panossian was born in Lebanon and immigrated<br />

to Canada at the age of 12.<br />

<strong>The</strong> Calouste Gulbenkian Foundation is one<br />

of the top-10 foundations in Europe and one of<br />

the largest in the world with assets of 3 billion<br />

euros and annual spending of around 100 million<br />

euros. It operates in four areas defined in<br />

its statutes: Arts, Education, Science, and<br />

Social Welfare. It was founded by Calouste<br />

Sarkis Gulbenkian, an <strong>Armenian</strong> businessman<br />

and art collector who became a British citizen,<br />

conducted much of his work in Britain and<br />

France, and finally settled in Portugal. <strong>The</strong><br />

foundation was established in Portugal in 1956,<br />

a year after his death.<br />

<strong>The</strong> <strong>Armenian</strong> Communities Department<br />

dates back to the creation of the foundation<br />

and was set up by the founder’s son-in-law<br />

Kevork Essayan. Since then the trustee in<br />

charge has always been a member of the<br />

founder’s family. <strong>The</strong> mission of the department<br />

is “to create a viable future for the <strong>Armenian</strong><br />

people in which their culture and language are<br />

preserved and valued.”<br />

Razmik Panossian


6 S A T U R D A Y, F E B R U A R Y 2 , 2 0 1 3<br />

T H E A R M E N I A N M I R R O R - S P E C TAT O R<br />

BOSTON — <strong>The</strong> <strong>Armenian</strong> International<br />

Women’s Association (AIWA) is now accepting<br />

applications for scholarship awards for the<br />

<strong>2013</strong>-2014 academic year.<br />

In addition to awards in the humanities and<br />

social sciences, grants are available to students<br />

in the sciences through the Lucy Kasparian<br />

Aharonian scholarships, granted by AIWA in<br />

conjunction with the Society for Women<br />

Engineers — Boston Chapter.<br />

Students in the fields of science, mathematics,<br />

engineering, technology, computer sciences<br />

and architecture are eligible for<br />

Aharonian awards of $2,000 to $6,000 (juniors<br />

and seniors) or up to $10,000 (master’s and<br />

PhD students).<br />

In addition, AIWA offers a number of scholarships<br />

for female students in all academic<br />

fields, ranging in value from $2,000 to $500.<br />

<strong>The</strong> program was initiated with the Agnes K.<br />

Missirian Scholarship, which was established<br />

in memory of the professor of management at<br />

Bentley College (Waltham, Mass.), a strong<br />

advocate for women’s rights.<br />

Also available for students in all academic<br />

fields are the Dr. Carolann S. Najarian, Ethel<br />

Jafferian Duffett, Rose A. Hovannesian and<br />

Zarouhi Y. Getsoyan scholarships.<br />

AIWA scholarships are awarded annually to<br />

full-time female students of <strong>Armenian</strong> descent<br />

attending accredited colleges or universities.<br />

Students entering their junior or senior year<br />

in college, as well as graduate students, are eligible<br />

to apply for the awards, which are based<br />

on financial need and merit.<br />

<strong>The</strong> awards in the sciences were initiated in<br />

2007 in memory of the late Lucy Kasparian<br />

Aharonian, an active member of the Society of<br />

Women Engineers, who enjoyed a long career<br />

in software engineering even while raising a<br />

family. With degrees in Mathematics and<br />

Business Administration, she worked for several<br />

major firms in the Boston area and also<br />

taught on various levels. Later she successfully<br />

embarked on a second career as a basket<br />

artist.<br />

Applications for all AIWA scholarships for<br />

the <strong>2013</strong>-2014 academic year are available on-<br />

ADVERTISE IN THE MIRROR<br />

COMMUNITY NEWS<br />

AIWA Scholarship Applications Now Available, Including Special Awards in the Sciences<br />

WASHINGTON — Dr. Carolann Najarian attended the celebrations following<br />

the Congressional Swearing-in Ceremony of the 113th Congress<br />

on January 3, Inauguration Day. Above, from left, are, from left,<br />

House Minority Leader Rep. Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.), Najarian, Jessica<br />

Nahagian and Linda Kaboolian.<br />

Fresno State Presents ‘<strong>Armenian</strong> Jerusalem:<br />

Past and Present’ Symposium<br />

LECTURE, from page 5<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong>s in the Medieval Period.” Her talk<br />

will discuss the relationship between the<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong>s and the city of Jerusalem in the<br />

Middle Ages, focusing primarily on the period<br />

most commonly referred to as the early crusades,<br />

1095-1191 AD. Some of the questions<br />

she will explore are: What was the <strong>Armenian</strong><br />

presence in crusader Jerusalem, and what were<br />

the attitudes of the <strong>Armenian</strong>s towards the<br />

European crusaders? What role did the<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong>s of Jerusalem and surrounding principalities<br />

play in the crusades?<br />

Barlow Der Mugrdechian (California State<br />

University, Fresno) will present a paper on<br />

“<strong>Armenian</strong> Jerusalem Through the Eyes of a<br />

Pilgrim.” His paper will be based on his personal<br />

experiences as a traveler to Jerusalem,<br />

since 1985. Why has Jerusalem occupied such<br />

an important space in the consciousness of<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong>s? What has continued to attract<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong> pilgrims to visit Jerusalem?<br />

Sergio La Porta (California State University,<br />

Fresno) will present “Negotiating the Sacred<br />

and the Secular: <strong>The</strong> <strong>Armenian</strong> Heritage in<br />

Jerusalem.” <strong>The</strong> <strong>Armenian</strong> presence in<br />

Jerusalem stretches back over hundreds of<br />

years. While much of the connection between<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong>s and Jerusalem has been and contin-<br />

ues to be religious in nature, and more specifically<br />

related to pilgrimage, there has also been<br />

a strong and significant secular dimension to<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong>s in Jerusalem. His talk will highlight<br />

how the sacred and secular coexist in this<br />

unique environment.<br />

Bedross Der Matossian (University of<br />

Nebraska-Lincoln) will present “Jerusalem in a<br />

Critical Period: Challenges Facing the New<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong> Patriarch of Jerusalem.” <strong>The</strong><br />

<strong>Armenian</strong> Patriarchate of Jerusalem is one of<br />

the most important spiritual, cultural, and<br />

national centers for the <strong>Armenian</strong>s around the<br />

globe and has faced enormous challenges in<br />

the course of its more than 1700 year history<br />

and has been able to overcome many types of<br />

adversities. However, the challenges in the<br />

21st century have taken a new shape. <strong>The</strong> talk<br />

will identify the challenges facing the<br />

Patriarchate, the newly elected <strong>Armenian</strong><br />

patriarch, and the community, and will suggest<br />

pragmatic remedies to political, religious,<br />

social, and economic challenges and discuss<br />

the ways in which the Diaspora can bring its<br />

share in assisting the Patriarchate and the<br />

community.<br />

<strong>The</strong> lecture is free and open to the public.<br />

For more information on the lecture contact<br />

the <strong>Armenian</strong> Studies Program.<br />

line (www.aiwainternational.org) or can be<br />

requested by mail (65 Main St., #3A,<br />

Watertown, MA 02472). <strong>The</strong> deadline for applications<br />

is April 16. Winners will be announced<br />

at the association’s annual meeting in May.<br />

In addition, students residing in California<br />

558 MOUNT AUBURN STREET<br />

WATERTOWN, MA 02472<br />

Edward D. Jamakordzian, Jr. d/b/a<br />

Edward D. Jamie, Jr.<br />

Funeral Chapel<br />

Serving the entire <strong>Armenian</strong> Community<br />

Any Hour • Any Distance • Any Location<br />

Call (718) 224-2390 Toll Free (888) 224-6088<br />

Bus. Reg. 189-06 Liberty Ave., Hollis, NY 11412<br />

Consultation Office: 217-04 Northern Blvd., (Suite 23), Bayside,NY 11361<br />

are eligible to apply for the Hasmik<br />

Mgrdichian Scholarships awarded by the<br />

AIWA/LA Affiliate. Four grants of $2,500<br />

each are available for the <strong>2013</strong>-2014 academic<br />

year. Full information is available on the<br />

AIWA/LA website (www.aiwala.org).<br />

SCHOLARSHIPS AVAILABLE<br />

for<br />

Students of <strong>Armenian</strong> Descent<br />

Having Completed One Year of College by June <strong>2013</strong><br />

Application and other information may be obtained<br />

from<br />

Tibrevank Alumni, Inc.<br />

Vahan Adjemian Scholarship Fund<br />

P.O. Box 14<br />

Palisades Park, NJ 07650<br />

or<br />

www.vahanadjemianscholarship.org<br />

Deadline for returning completed applications: April 30, <strong>2013</strong><br />

Telephone (617) 924-7400<br />

Aram Bedrosian<br />

Funeral Home, Inc.<br />

Continuous Service By <strong>The</strong> Bedrosian Family Since 1945<br />

MARION BEDROSIAN<br />

PAUL BEDROSIAN<br />

LARRY BEDROSIAN<br />

Giragosian<br />

F U N E R A L H O M E<br />

James “Jack” Giragosian, CPC<br />

Mark J. Giragosian<br />

Funeral Counselors<br />

576 Mt. Auburn Street, Watertown, MA 02472, TEL: 617-924—0606<br />

www.giragosianfuneralhome.com<br />

DENNIS M. DEVENEY & SONS<br />

Cemetery Monuments<br />

Specializing in<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong> Designs and Lettering<br />

701 Moody St. Waltham, MA 02543<br />

(781) 891-9876 www.NEMonuments.com


By Douglas Rooks<br />

WATERVILLE, Maine (Bangor Daily News) —<br />

When Paul Boghossian launched the partnership<br />

that restored the historic Hathaway Mill in<br />

Waterville five years ago, he had no idea he would<br />

have to wait until <strong>2013</strong> to start renovations on<br />

the other two buildings in the mammoth<br />

Lockwood Mills complex.<br />

Back in 2007, there had been no Wall Street<br />

collapse, nor tighter lending standards adopted in<br />

its wake. He also had a North Carolina business<br />

partner who had been hailed as a master of mill<br />

restorations and headed his own capital investment<br />

firm.<br />

Almost simultaneously, development money<br />

vanished, as did his business partner, leaving<br />

Boghossian the sole developer to finish restoration<br />

of the former Hathaway Shirt factory. Today,<br />

the complex houses 67 apartments and 130,000<br />

square feet of office and retail space and<br />

Boghossian is ready to turn his full attention to<br />

the Lockwood Mill complex.<br />

At just shy of 500,000 square feet, it’s one of<br />

the largest remaining 19th-century industrial<br />

sites in Maine, and is immediately adjacent to<br />

Waterville’s downtown. <strong>The</strong> Main Street shopping<br />

district lies just across a six-lane approach<br />

road to the bridge to Winslow.<br />

Reconfiguring traffic so that Waterville has a<br />

pedestrian-friendly downtown is just one of the<br />

issues Boghossian is tackling in his most recent<br />

project, which includes refurbishing the two<br />

buildings in Lockwood Mills complex previously<br />

occupied by Central Maine Power Co (CMP) and<br />

Marden’s, and putting them before the planning<br />

board and city council, so far to generally favorable<br />

receptions.<br />

He envisions a hotel, restaurants, retail and<br />

office space, and many new apartments — one of<br />

the most successful features of the Hathaway renovation.<br />

“When I was trying to show an apartment<br />

there recently, I had to show my own unit,” he<br />

said. “None of the others were vacant.”<br />

Boghossian, a Colby College graduate who<br />

began his career restoring mills in his native<br />

Rhode Island, also wants the city to commit to $1<br />

million in road and intersection improvements<br />

that include restoring two-way traffic to Main<br />

Street and replacing the six-lane arterial — which<br />

he called “hopelessly inefficient” — with a roundabout<br />

similar to the one that originally marked<br />

S A T U R D A Y, F E B R U A R Y 2 , 2 0 1 3 T H E A R M E N I A N M I R R O R - S P E C TAT O R<br />

the site.<br />

Waterville Mayor Karen Heck said the traffic<br />

plan is doable, and necessary to re-create the<br />

downtown ambience that once brought shoppers<br />

from around the region.<br />

“Paul has invested years of his life and millions<br />

of dollars in our city,” Heck said. “It’s about time<br />

we reciprocated.”<br />

Boghossian said redeveloping the two buildings,<br />

collectively about the same size as the<br />

Hathaway Creative Center that he renovated and<br />

reopened in 2008, will cost as much as $25 million.<br />

<strong>The</strong> overhaul of the National Historic<br />

Register properties will use both federal and state<br />

historic tax credits.<br />

“That’s what makes projects like this viable,”<br />

he said. “It’s like having 55-cent dollars when you<br />

go to the bank.”<br />

He’s learned some valuable lessons in financing,<br />

he says, following the almost four years it took to<br />

partially extricate himself from an original partnership<br />

with Tom Niemann, a North Carolina developer<br />

who owns the Kennebec Arsenal in Augusta.<br />

That long-stalled project has resulted in the state<br />

exploring litigation to reclaim the property.<br />

Problems, Boghossian says, began almost<br />

immediately after the finishing touches were put<br />

on the Hathaway project in the winter of 2008-09.<br />

Niemann was supposed to manage the two largely<br />

vacant Marden’s and CMP buildings and bring<br />

in financing to replace the $500,000 Boghossian<br />

had invested in them, supposedly for the shortterm<br />

only.<br />

“He never brought in a dime,” Boghossian said<br />

of Niemann. “And he didn’t even pay the electric<br />

bill or fill the oil tanks. <strong>The</strong> tenants were repeatedly<br />

given shutoff notices.”<br />

Boghossian started foreclosure proceedings<br />

that dragged on for years that ultimately resulted<br />

in default judgments in September, making him<br />

sole owner of the Marden’s and CMP buildings.<br />

Niemann remains the largest single owner of the<br />

Hathaway building, though with a minority share.<br />

Boghossian concedes some of the delays would<br />

have happened anyway, even without the wrinkle<br />

of the failed partnership.<br />

“<strong>The</strong>re was no financing for this kind of project<br />

after the financial crash, and it isn’t likely that<br />

we’d have been able to sign up anchor tenants,”<br />

he said.<br />

Now that the economic forecast has brightened<br />

a bit, he thinks it is time to go forward with the<br />

Lockwood project.<br />

<strong>The</strong> middle CMP building, at 53,000 square<br />

feet and two stories, and the Marden’s building<br />

COMMUNITY NEWS<br />

Mill Redevelopment Could Spur Waterville Renaissance<br />

that overlooks downtown — four-and-a-half stories<br />

and 168,000 square feet — lend themselves more<br />

to housing than commercial development, more<br />

so even than the Hathaway project, said<br />

Boghossian, who contrasts Hathaway’s fully occupied<br />

apartments with the about 80 percent occupancy<br />

rate of its office space and a lower proportion<br />

of the first-floor retail.<br />

“<strong>The</strong>se two buildings are narrower, and we’ll be<br />

able to get away from the longer, deeper spaces<br />

that makes the Hathaway units relatively large for<br />

downtown living,” he said.<br />

Many of the Hathaway apartments are 1,000<br />

square feet or larger, and carry market-based<br />

rents of $1,000 a month. <strong>The</strong> units offered in the<br />

other buildings will run from 500-800 square feet,<br />

and average 650 square feet, which will make<br />

rents about $750.<br />

“In this market, that’s much more affordable<br />

and increases their appeal,” he said.<br />

<strong>The</strong> Marden’s building has drawn considerable<br />

interest from hoteliers, says Boghossian, and<br />

could support an 80-room inn with a large restaurant,<br />

along with retail units and some housing.<br />

“That’s one of the things downtown needs to put<br />

it back on the map,” he said. Existing hotels and<br />

motels are all clustered around Waterville’s two<br />

interstate exits, the closest well over a mile away.<br />

Boghossian is thinking even further down the<br />

road, to a possible cooperative program with<br />

Thomas College, which offers a popular program<br />

in hotel management.<br />

“<strong>The</strong>y’re always looking for places to intern,<br />

while hotel chains are also looking for good<br />

employees,” he said. “It could be an excellent<br />

match.”<br />

If a hotel is constructed in the mill buildings, a<br />

parking structure across the street on a cityowned<br />

lot would be needed. Boghossian envisions<br />

a series of walkways connecting the three<br />

buildings and the garage, so that — as in other<br />

northern cities — tenants could access the entire<br />

complex, and reach their cars, without ever having<br />

to step outside.<br />

When he is having a difficult moment, as<br />

Boghossian said he does, now and then, he takes<br />

inspiration from the original story of the<br />

Lockwood Mills. When a group of wealthy<br />

Waterville citizens decided the time was ripe for<br />

a major industrial expansion in the 1870s, they<br />

chose Amos D. Lockwood, who had built mills in<br />

Boston and Providence, RI, as their designer and<br />

engineer.<br />

Not only was Lockwood a skilled building<br />

designer, but he was “a practical genius” when it<br />

came to waterpower, Boghossian said, and in<br />

charting the intricate channels of penstocks,<br />

sluiceways and millwheels that went into making<br />

an efficient 19th century plant. By 1876, 33,000<br />

textile spindles were in operation and the<br />

Lockwood Co. employed 1,300 people at its peak,<br />

with production continuing until 1955; Hathaway<br />

Shirt lasted another 40 years.<br />

“<strong>The</strong> owners were so impressed that they<br />

named their company not after themselves, but<br />

their builder,” Boghossian said.<br />

In bringing these mill buildings back to life, he<br />

says he hopes to replicate a similar brand of persistence<br />

and ingenuity.<br />

Businesses Lose $650<br />

Billion Turning<br />

Businesses anti-Social<br />

By Wilson Dizard<br />

NEW YORK (New York Post) — How can US<br />

businesses recoup $650 billion in lost productivity<br />

a year due to social media in the workplace?<br />

A Miami-based e-commerce company, 1saleaday.com,<br />

got so fed up with its workers wasting<br />

away precious minutes on social media that in<br />

2011 it banned and blocked sites like Facebook<br />

and Twitter.<br />

After worker morale plummeted, management<br />

decided in November to introduce a social<br />

network just for employees, a Twitter clone<br />

called Yammer, and found that productivity and<br />

mood improved.<br />

“Instead of trying to suppress their addiction,<br />

we tried to channel it,” said Eli Federman, a<br />

spokesman for 1saleaday. “It actually increased<br />

productivity by creating an environment where<br />

people collaborate on various projects using<br />

the site.”<br />

<strong>The</strong> company’s story highlights how businesses<br />

with lots of young, computer-bound<br />

employees are trying to figure out how to keep<br />

the attention of people who are paid $14 an<br />

hour for mind-numbing data-entry jobs. It also<br />

shows a growing divide among American workers,<br />

between social media haves and have-nots.<br />

<strong>The</strong> split breaks along the level of competition<br />

for skilled, creative hires. Companies<br />

searching for the best and brightest won’t be so<br />

uncool as to ban social media, but businesses<br />

that just need nimble, youthful fingers for keyboards<br />

have the upper hand and can wring out<br />

more labor by banning social media.<br />

Huge, a DUMBO-based online advertising<br />

company where workers can bring their dogs,<br />

bikes and skateboards to the office, doesn’t<br />

impose restrictions on its employees’ use of<br />

Facebook.<br />

“In general, the only rule is, ‘Think about<br />

what you’re doing, don’t share confidential<br />

information, etc.,’” said Sam Weston, a<br />

spokesman for Huge. “But the question isn’t so<br />

much the medium, it’s the people. Do you have<br />

people who are responsible and smart and who<br />

care enough about what they’re doing to be<br />

engaged in the workplace, or not?”<br />

At one Wall Street firm, however, management<br />

doesn’t have the same outlook. One<br />

employee, who spoke on condition of anonymity,<br />

said the firewall at the office, which prohibits<br />

social media and even Gmail, is reminiscent of<br />

“Stalinist Russia.”<br />

“I think a reasonable, little five-minute break<br />

to check in with the world is fine,” the employee<br />

said.<br />

Alexis Ohanian, a founder of startups including<br />

the popular link site Reddit, said competition<br />

for skilled workers discourages tech companies<br />

from doing anything draconian.<br />

“Employers hiring tech talent already have to<br />

intensely compete for talent, so something like<br />

a ‘no social media’ policy is a deal-breaker for<br />

most of those folks,” Ohanian said.<br />

“I’m a very pro-social media employer: If you<br />

get your work done, go ahead and look at some<br />

cat photos (then share them because your<br />

increased clout will pay dividends for me later,<br />

when you promote projects we’re working on),”<br />

he added.<br />

7


8 S A T U R D A Y, F E B R U A R Y 2 , 2 0 1 3 T H E A R M E N I A N M I R R O R - S P E C TAT O R<br />

TITIZIAN, from page 1<br />

in the States, I went to <strong>Armenian</strong> school all the<br />

way up to high school. I’m so glad they did that<br />

for me. I speak, read and write fluently in<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong> and that’s a blessing. I hope to do the<br />

same for my children.”<br />

Titizian first fell in love with acting in college.<br />

“I didn’t get involved in acting until my second<br />

year of college... I was 20. I wish I had gotten<br />

started much younger, but I guess everything<br />

happens for a reason.”<br />

After taking a college acting class, Titizian<br />

decided to make a go of it. “I did background<br />

work for a TV show and watched the actors and<br />

told myself ‘I can do that.’ So that was it. I<br />

dropped out of college and took professional acting<br />

classes, got my first set of headshots and hustled<br />

to get an agent. I can’t believe it has already<br />

been 13 years.”<br />

Titizian has played the role of CIA agent<br />

Danny Galvez for the past two seasons of the hit<br />

Showtime drama, “Homeland,” which chronicles<br />

a US-marine-turned-terrorist and features an allstar<br />

cast including Claire Danes, Damian Lewis<br />

and Mandy Patinkin. How did Tatizian land the<br />

role? “<strong>The</strong> casting process for ‘Homeland’ was<br />

interesting. I was in New York finishing up the<br />

last two weeks of a play on Broadway and I got<br />

a call to audition for ‘Homeland.’ It was just a<br />

pilot that had gotten picked up for series, so<br />

nobody had heard of it, let alone watched it,” said<br />

Tatizian.<br />

Timing and a positive attitude always help. “I<br />

didn’t get it. But the people liked me and I had<br />

worked with them before on ‘24’ […] so there was<br />

this role they were having trouble casting. <strong>The</strong><br />

character was Hispanic, but they wanted me to<br />

do it, so they changed it and made him half<br />

Lebanese and half Hispanic. I still had to audition<br />

for it, because I had to get approved by the<br />

network.”<br />

With one phone call, Titizian was on the next<br />

flight to North Carolina to start filming. “I’m<br />

glad it worked out the way it did because the role<br />

I initially auditioned for was much smaller. You<br />

never know how things work out in this business.<br />

And no one including myself expected the<br />

show to be as big of a hit as it turned out to be.<br />

You just can’t tell those things until they start<br />

airing. And it was a hit right out of the gates and<br />

got bigger and bigger each week. It’s very cool to<br />

be a part of it.”<br />

After a successful finish to season two and various<br />

awards, fans will have to wait to see more<br />

from Agent Galvez. “As for season three, I don’t<br />

even know if I’ll be back or not, so I don’t have<br />

the slightest clue what’s in store for the show or<br />

for Danny Galvez. But the writers are very smart<br />

and I trust whatever they do will be great,” said<br />

Titizian.<br />

Titizian has appeared in numerous television<br />

series and films, but says his favorite role actually<br />

was in a play. “Playing the ghost of Uday<br />

Hussein would top the list,” said Tatizian. He is<br />

referring to his 2011 stint on Broadway in<br />

“Bengal Tiger at the Baghdad Zoo,” starring<br />

Robin Williams. According to Titizian, his character<br />

“was sadistic, evil, funny, charming, juicy<br />

and believe it or not, likable. ... At least the way<br />

I played it. I would be very pleasantly surprised<br />

to get a role like that on TV.”<br />

Acclimating to the grueling scheduling and<br />

repetition of theater is no easy task. “It’s very<br />

challenging for me, but the payoff is not like any<br />

other,” he said. “[<strong>The</strong>] feeling you get when<br />

you’re performing in front of so many people is<br />

incomparable.”<br />

“Being on Broadway is probably every performer’s<br />

dream, especially working with Robin<br />

Williams, [who is] someone I always admired<br />

growing up.”<br />

Titizian looks forward to future stints on<br />

Broadway. “As for returning, yes, I would love to<br />

do that sometime in the future, when I’m ready<br />

again,” he said.<br />

In a business that often rewards style over substance,<br />

one thing that makes Titizian stand out<br />

is his grounding in tradition. “I feel it’s very<br />

important to recognize your heritage and your<br />

ancestry and keep the culture alive. I’m very<br />

proud to be <strong>Armenian</strong> and although every agent<br />

and manager I met told me to change my name,<br />

I could never get myself to do it,” he said. “If it<br />

takes longer for people to see me a certain way,<br />

consider me for certain roles or get in certain<br />

doors, so be it. At least I can go to bed every<br />

night with my dignity.”<br />

It seems that Titizian’s hard work and positive<br />

attitude has paid off. Titizian was honored as this<br />

year’s ARPA international breakthrough performer<br />

of the year in Los Angeles. “It’s always a<br />

good feeling to be honored for anything. <strong>The</strong><br />

ARPA award was special because I had a film in<br />

that festival a few years back and the people<br />

involved are really great. That night was loads of<br />

fun and I’m fortunate to have been a recipient.<br />

Being recognized in that way gives you some<br />

sense of ‘I guess I’m doing something right.’”<br />

In the midst of his success, Titizian is also making<br />

time for his personal life. “Well, I’m getting<br />

married in April, so the wedding planning is definitely<br />

taking some work.” In between wedding<br />

planning and auditioning, he will be producing a<br />

film that shoots in March and also teaching classes<br />

on Tuesday nights. “Otherwise, my main focus<br />

is acting and auditions are back to normal now<br />

that the holidays are over, so hopefully the next<br />

gig is not too far away,” he said.<br />

“That’s the scary thing about this business,<br />

but also the beautiful thing about this business.<br />

You’ll get a call today and you’re on a flight<br />

tomorrow. So you just have to stay sane and<br />

trust that the work will come,” he said.<br />

COMMUNITY NEWS<br />

From Home to ‘Homeland’ Hrach Titizian Stays True to His Roots<br />

Hrach Titizian


NEW YORK — Camp Nubar is not yet in session,<br />

but AGBU families in the greater New<br />

York-New Jersey area are showing their camp<br />

spirit more than ever through a series of celebratory<br />

events dedicated to its 50th anniversary.<br />

<strong>The</strong> milestone year started this fall with<br />

the Parents’ Night Out, and continued this past<br />

weekend during the first-ever Camp Nubar<br />

Alumni Basketball Tournament and Annual<br />

S A T U R D A Y, F E B R U A R Y 2 , 2 0 1 3 T H E A R M E N I A N M I R R O R - S P E C TAT O R<br />

Winter Reunion.<br />

On Saturday, January 12, 2012, dozens of former<br />

counselors — some of whom joined Camp<br />

Nubar a decade ago — went head to head on the<br />

basketball courts of St. Leon <strong>Armenian</strong> Church<br />

in Fair Lawn, NJ. <strong>The</strong>y were cheered on by<br />

campers both past and present who turned out<br />

in large numbers for the Annual Winter<br />

Reunion and were clad in 50th anniversary<br />

gear, including t-shirts, bags and wristbands,<br />

designed especially for the occasion. Before filling<br />

the stands, the attendees gathered for the<br />

unveiling of the Special Edition Color War<br />

Poster, featuring Blue and Gold team banners<br />

from across camp history, as well as for a photo<br />

slideshow of the past summer.<br />

Parents’ Night Out, which was held on<br />

Thursday, November 15, 2012, also showcased<br />

a special collection of photographs: those that<br />

brought to life Camp Nubar’s spring-fed lake,<br />

acres of pristine forests and Catskill Mountain<br />

ranges — the natural beauty that has drawn<br />

back generation after generation. An intimate<br />

evening for families and friends, Parents’ Night<br />

Out gathered longtime camp alumni, as well as<br />

those who recently joined the Camp Nubar<br />

Check us out at<br />

www.mirrorspectator.com<br />

New York<br />

M E T R O<br />

Camp Nubar Ushers in 50th Anniversary Year with a Series of Celebratory Events<br />

Camp Nubar supporters and alumni celebrate<br />

Camp’s 50th anniversary at Parent’s Night Out.<br />

community, to the Harvest Bistro & Bar in<br />

Closter, NJ. <strong>The</strong>re, the guests reminisced about<br />

summers past, discussed plans for the upcoming<br />

year and took in the striking photographs.<br />

<strong>The</strong> exhibit featured the work of two AGBU<br />

members: AGBU Young Professionals of<br />

Greater New York (YPGNY) longtime core committee<br />

member Vadim Krisyan, who adds the<br />

Camp Nubar photos to his growing portfolio<br />

and YP supporter Shant Madjarian, who has<br />

honed his eye as the founder of a local design<br />

firm. Though neither has been a camper, both<br />

participated in this summer’s annual YPGNY<br />

City Escape retreat to Camp Nubar and were<br />

immediately inspired by their surroundings.<br />

<strong>The</strong>ir talent and enthusiasm, and that of the<br />

Camp Nubar 50th Anniversary Committee<br />

members, is making the celebratory year an<br />

unforgettable one. As committee member and<br />

camp alumna Nancy Zoraian commented, “It<br />

was so nice to be part of such a warm and festive<br />

evening. But Parents’ Night Out was only<br />

the beginning. Our committee represents a mix<br />

of generations, from older alumni, to parents of<br />

campers, to AGBU’s innovative young professionals,<br />

who are bringing so many fresh ideas to<br />

the table. <strong>The</strong>ir energy is amazing and inspiring<br />

— and together we are making each event dedicated<br />

to the 50th anniversary more spectacular<br />

By Kevin McGarry<br />

NEW YORK (New York Times) — Located in<br />

a Maya Lin-rehabbed former trolley repair shop<br />

around the corner from MoMA PS1 in Long<br />

Island City, Queens, SculptureCenter is one of<br />

New York City’s oldest artist-founded institutions<br />

at 85 years of age. <strong>The</strong> main gallery is a<br />

towering, slightly dilapidated room, and taking<br />

residence there this winter is “Retainer,” a<br />

sculpture by the Iranian-born, Berlin-based<br />

artist Nairy Baghramian. This commission is<br />

her first exhibition in the United States, though<br />

in Europe she’s well known for her manually<br />

and mechanically manipulated forms that are<br />

by turns delicate and inscrutable.<br />

“Retainer” is more a system of sculptures<br />

than a uniform object. In Baghramian’s words,<br />

“it’s a collection of single, individual,<br />

autonomous pieces that occupy the space —<br />

the gaps between them are part of it. Some are<br />

connected, some alone, some in networks, but<br />

in the end it is all one installation.” <strong>The</strong> piece’s<br />

protagonist is a ring of large, fleshy shapes<br />

held at eye height by a lattice of spindly<br />

chrome supports that evoke a design showroom<br />

as readily as the dentist’s chair. Bonded<br />

together, these elements resemble pieces of<br />

huge alien jewelry.<br />

<strong>The</strong> work’s strong material presence is no<br />

accident, and its fabrication is quite involved.<br />

<strong>The</strong> process began with a prototype<br />

Baghramian engineered herself; then she produced<br />

the structural elements of the piece and<br />

than the last.”<br />

Parents’ Night Out launched not only a year<br />

of festivities, but a year of fundraising, as well.<br />

Throughout the evening, bids on the photographs,<br />

as well as substantial contributions<br />

from Barry and Andrea Halejian, Jack and Carol<br />

Margossian and Armen and Brenda Shahinian,<br />

and other AGBU supporters brought the total<br />

Camp Nubar donations to date to more than<br />

$40,000. Camp Nubar has also received a<br />

pledge from an anonymous benefactor, who has<br />

agreed to match the first $100,000 raised.<br />

Together, the funds will help Camp Nubar construct<br />

a brand new a pavilion, a common space<br />

in the heart of the camp where youth will cre-<br />

Some of Camp Nubar’s youngest members catch up at the Annual Winter Reunion in New Jersey.<br />

ate and learn together.<br />

Camp Nubar families have even more to look<br />

forward to in the coming months: on Friday,<br />

July 26, the 50th anniversary celebration will<br />

take place at Guastavino’s restaurant in New<br />

York City. Tickets are on sale now. On Sunday,<br />

July 28, Camp Nubar will hold its annual Open<br />

House and honor the five-decade anniversary.<br />

To learn about Camp Nubar’s upcoming 50th<br />

anniversary events, make a donation to Camp<br />

Nubar or purchase 50th anniversary gear and<br />

tickets, visit: www.campnubar.org/50.<br />

Photography prints from Parents’ Night Out will<br />

be sold in limited quantities throughout the year.<br />

Nairy Baghramian at SculptureCenter<br />

their chromium plating with a metal workshop.<br />

<strong>The</strong> shapes are poured polycarbonate in the<br />

hue of what she calls a “noncolor,” then coated<br />

in another layer of silicon that is wiped, blurred<br />

and troweled to achieve its nuanced, industrialorganic<br />

texture.<br />

Responding to the history of<br />

SculptureCenter’s use — not as a former repair<br />

shop but as a well-trafficked art venue —<br />

Baghramian has moved the wall labels that typically<br />

indicate an exhibition’s beginning to the<br />

gallery’s back door. <strong>The</strong> intent, she says, was “to<br />

force people to bump into the installation from<br />

the back, so that they’re immediately placed in<br />

the space when they enter.” Just as viewers<br />

encounter her mélange of materials and production<br />

methods as unified art objects, “this<br />

way the building, the space, the institution and<br />

the work coalesce as a conglomerate that causes<br />

a multilayered reaction.”<br />

<strong>The</strong>re are other components of “Retainer” in<br />

an annex behind the main room: a photograph<br />

of a horse’s leg in yellow casts at the joints,<br />

metal shapes attached to the walls, a small table<br />

with a base echoing a horse’s hoof. “Every part<br />

of the show correlates to an idea of supporting<br />

the body, but also to the word ‘snag’” — the title<br />

of the photograph — “or ‘catch,’ in reference to<br />

the German expression ‘Pferdefuss,’ meaning<br />

the foot of the horse.” Full of these well-formed<br />

hitches, Baghramian’s show is a microcosmic<br />

reminder of just how productive problems can<br />

be in evoking a thing’s essence.<br />

“Retainer” is on view through March 25 at<br />

SculptureCenter, 44-19 Purves St., in Long<br />

Island City, NY.<br />

9


10 S A T U R D A Y, F E B R U A R Y 2 , 2 0 1 3<br />

T H E A R M E N I A N M I R R O R - S P E C TAT O R<br />

New Guide to<br />

Armenia And Artsakh<br />

Highlights Ecology<br />

And Conservation<br />

LOS ANGELES — An all-new edition<br />

of Armenia’s best-selling travel guide,<br />

<strong>The</strong> Stone Garden Travel Guide:<br />

Armenia and Karabakh, will be published<br />

in <strong>February</strong>.<br />

<strong>The</strong> new 320-page book contains<br />

updated and expanded information for<br />

the <strong>2013</strong>-14 tourist seasons and features<br />

27 color maps and more than 140<br />

color photographs.<br />

A never-before-published map of historic<br />

Armenia, which was created shortly<br />

after the Genocide, is also featured in<br />

the book.<br />

<strong>The</strong> Stone Garden Travel Guide is<br />

the first comprehensive guidebook to<br />

Armenia and Karabagh (Artsakh), and<br />

is also the only guidebook for the<br />

region that emphasizes conservation<br />

and ecology. <strong>The</strong> book is Award Finalist<br />

for Best Travel Guide by the<br />

Independent Publishers Association.<br />

CNN Traveller magazine calls the<br />

book “an excellent guide, written with<br />

real passion for the subject.” <strong>The</strong> book<br />

features maps from <strong>The</strong> American<br />

University of Armenia’s “Birds of<br />

Armenia Project” and highlights con-<br />

Cover of <strong>The</strong> Stone Garden Travel<br />

Guide: Armenia and Karabakh<br />

servation issues that confront Armenia,<br />

in addition to covering all the information<br />

about cultural sites and getting<br />

around that every traveler expects in a<br />

guidebook.<br />

Author-photographer Matthew<br />

Karanian and photographer Robert<br />

Kurkjian have each spent more than a<br />

decade living and working in Armenia<br />

while researching and writing this and<br />

previous editions of the book. Each of<br />

them first traveled to Armenia in 1995<br />

to work as professors at the American<br />

University of Armenia. Karanian is an<br />

attorney. Kurkjian is an environmental<br />

scientist.<br />

<strong>The</strong>ir writing and photography about<br />

Armenia has also been featured in magazines<br />

and newspapers of wide distribution<br />

in the US, Europe, and Canada,<br />

including in CNN Traveller magazine,<br />

Arthur Frommer’s Budget Travel,<br />

Geographical, Global Adventure, Photo<br />

Life and Photo District News.<br />

<strong>The</strong> new book will be available from<br />

Amazon.com and from select bookstores<br />

in mid-<strong>February</strong>. To pre-order directly<br />

from the publisher before <strong>February</strong> 28,<br />

send check or money order for $25 post<br />

paid to: Stone Garden Productions; PO<br />

Box 7758; Northridge, CA 91327.<br />

Arts & Living<br />

A ceramic Khatchkar by Dr. Jack Hachigian<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong> Cross Serves<br />

As Inspiration for<br />

Ceramic Art<br />

YEREVAN (Clay/Technical magazine) — As I drove through the countryside, on<br />

a visit to the nation of Armenia, I was struck by the numerous crosses carved into<br />

stone. <strong>The</strong>se large monoliths,<br />

called khatchkars, or “cross-<br />

By Jack Hachigian, PhD<br />

stones,” often made from<br />

Armenia’s native tufa stone,<br />

dotted the landscape. <strong>The</strong>y are<br />

magnificent works of art, at once formidable and delicate. <strong>The</strong> <strong>Armenian</strong> tradition<br />

of carving crosses into stone is an ancient one, going at least as far back as 600 AD.<br />

During this visit to the land of my ancestors, I stopped by the main historical<br />

library in the capital city of Yerevan. I viewed a collection of antique manuscripts<br />

encased in UV protective<br />

glass cases. <strong>The</strong>se<br />

very old works of handscribed<br />

books were<br />

beautifully illustrated in<br />

color and represented<br />

another strain of<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong> art: the illumination.<br />

I was overwhelmed<br />

by the beauty<br />

of these tiny works. <strong>The</strong><br />

little paintings glowed<br />

with gold and jewel<br />

toned paints. It was awe<br />

inspiring to imagine<br />

monks in the distant<br />

past toiling over these<br />

manuscripts and in the<br />

present day to observe<br />

monks conducting<br />

research using these<br />

same ancient works.<br />

My interest in Biblical<br />

illuminations began to<br />

take the form of<br />

research. I visited other<br />

important collections of<br />

these old manuscripts,<br />

one in a monastery in<br />

Ceramic Khatchkars by Dr. Jack Hachigian<br />

Vienna, Austria, and another in a monastery on the island of San Lazzaro, just off<br />

the coast of Venice, Italy. I began to examine various texts and original Greek and<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong> sources.<br />

My research eventually took me to the illuminations from the Trebezond region<br />

of ancient Armenia, now in present day Turkey. A number of ruins of monasteries<br />

and churches still remain in this region, which is located in the eastern part of the<br />

Anatolian peninsula, bordering on the Black Sea. From the ninth to the 14th centuries,<br />

monks and scribes in this region toiled to copy Biblical writings, using the<br />

unique <strong>Armenian</strong> script and alphabet, illuminating their work as they went. Rooms<br />

of scribes worked for years to produce these books. <strong>The</strong> illuminations come in different<br />

styles and art historians have traced them to different monks from<br />

see KHATCHKAR, page 12<br />

Chamber Music<br />

Concert at ALMA<br />

Rescheduled for<br />

<strong>February</strong> 10<br />

WATERTOWN — <strong>The</strong> Chamber Music<br />

Concert at the <strong>Armenian</strong> Library and Museum<br />

of America (ALMA) initially planned for January<br />

27 will take place on Sunday, <strong>February</strong> 10, at 4<br />

p.m., due to illness. Pieces by composers<br />

Babajanian, Schulhoff and Zemlinsky will be<br />

performed by students of the Walnut Hill<br />

School for the Arts.<br />

This collaboration between ALMA and the<br />

school includes the performance of a very special<br />

piece of <strong>Armenian</strong> chamber music,<br />

Babajanian’s Piano Trio, which combines traditional<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong> melodies with richly Romantic<br />

textures, and serves as a musical testament to<br />

the feelings of nationalist identity of the<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong> people under Soviet domination. <strong>The</strong><br />

chamber groups will also present Erwin<br />

Schulhoff’s Concertino for flute, viola and double<br />

bass, and Alexander Zemlinsky's Trio for<br />

clarinet, cello and piano.<br />

Tickets will be available at the door only. It is<br />

free for students.<br />

Refreshments will be served following program.<br />

Arno Babajanian (1921-1983)<br />

Hasmik Harutyunyan to<br />

Present Workshop on<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong> Song and Dance<br />

FRESNO — Hasmik Harutyunyan will present<br />

a workshop on <strong>Armenian</strong> song and dance, from<br />

2 to 5 p.m. on Saturday, <strong>February</strong> 2, in the<br />

South Gym, room 133, of Fresno State campus.<br />

<strong>The</strong> workshop is co-sponsored by the<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong> Students Organization and<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong> Studies Program at Fresno State and<br />

is partially funded by the Associated Students,<br />

Inc. of Fresno State.<br />

Participation in the workshop is free, but participants<br />

are asked to bring only soft-soled<br />

shoes.<br />

Harutyunyan was born in Yerevan and has<br />

extensive experience studying <strong>Armenian</strong> dance<br />

and music in Armenia. She will be demonstrating<br />

folk dances from the various provinces of<br />

historic Armenia, in their original form. Dances<br />

will include the Gyovend, Kochari, Tamzara,<br />

Ververi, Mayroke, Pampouri and others, such as<br />

Hamshen dances and dances especially for<br />

women.<br />

Harutyunyan will also teach <strong>Armenian</strong> folk<br />

songs, including lullabies, from historic<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong> provinces. In Armenia, she is known<br />

for her work with the Shoghaken Folk<br />

Ensemble and for her renditions of <strong>Armenian</strong><br />

lullabies. Her performances are often broadcast<br />

on <strong>Armenian</strong> National Radio and presented at<br />

traditional music festivals around the world.<br />

For more information about the workshop,<br />

contact the <strong>Armenian</strong> Studies Program at<br />

Fresno State.


LONDON — Sotheby’s will hold “At <strong>The</strong> Crossroads,”<br />

the first-ever selling exhibition of Contemporary Art<br />

from Central Asia and the Caucasus. This pioneering<br />

exhibition, which encompasses art from the mountains<br />

of Caucasus to Kazakhstan’s steppe and the Chinese<br />

borders, will take place at Sotheby’s New Bond Street<br />

premises from Monday, March 4 until Tuesday, March<br />

12.<br />

“At <strong>The</strong> Crossroads” will include around 50 contemporary<br />

artworks in various media by artists from across<br />

Central Asia and the Caucasus, including Armenia,<br />

Azerbaijan, Georgia, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan<br />

and Uzbekistan. <strong>The</strong> exhibition will showcase non-conformist<br />

as well as socialist-realist art from the 1960s,<br />

right the way through to emerging contemporary practices.<br />

Commenting on this pioneering initiative, Jo<br />

Vickery, senior director and head of Sotheby’s<br />

Russian Art Department in London, said: “Countries<br />

throughout the Caucasus and Central Asia have experienced<br />

rapid growth in recent years and this is also<br />

true of the art scene there. New collectors, art institutions<br />

and galleries are emerging every day, and it is<br />

an exciting new geography for Sotheby’s to explore.<br />

We are therefore delighted to present this landmark<br />

selling exhibition, which encompasses the diverse<br />

artistic practices of the region that combine ancient<br />

historical roots with techniques at the forefront of<br />

contemporary art.”<br />

Three <strong>Armenian</strong> artists are represented in the exhibit.<br />

<strong>The</strong>y are Armen Gevorgyan,Vruyr Galstyan and Ruben<br />

Grigorian.<br />

For Gevorgyan, the role of agriculture in <strong>Armenian</strong><br />

society is one he wants to stress. In this work that was<br />

made after his eponymous 1988 sculpture, Armen<br />

Gevorgyan, a prominent <strong>Armenian</strong> sculptor, addresses<br />

the philosophical concept of the cycle of life. <strong>The</strong> broken<br />

wheel carries special meaning for the <strong>Armenian</strong> people,<br />

whose national consciousness has been formed by long<br />

history of resettlement. Gevorgyan invites the viewer to<br />

contemplate on the broken life cycles of those whose<br />

memories are filled with long journeys and a lost motherland.<br />

Throughout his career Galstyan has used color in a<br />

variety of ways to explore, in depth, the complex concepts<br />

of man’s position in space and time. His stylistic<br />

approach in the 1960s can be seen to be distinct from<br />

that in his later period of the 1970s and 1980s.<br />

Both Galstyan’s early and late periods are characterized<br />

by the dominance of whites and blacks. However,<br />

while his 1960s compositions have a muted harmony of<br />

pastel hues, he increasingly preferred contrasting and<br />

almost violent colors in his later career. “Memory,”<br />

1973, is a cornerstone piece of Galstyan’s later period. It<br />

is in essence a self-portrait and is central to the development<br />

of his mature oeuvre. In this work the artist<br />

explores the painting medium itself, through the dense<br />

S A T U R D A Y, F E B R U A R Y 2 , 2 0 1 3<br />

ARTS & LIVING<br />

application of paint and an intense and contrasting<br />

color palette. <strong>The</strong> thick black contours remain from his<br />

earlier works but these now serve to separate the contrasting<br />

color shapes that construct the pictorial plane.<br />

In “Memory,” he develops a complex approach to the linearity<br />

of form and the<br />

interplay of color planes<br />

by striking an improbable<br />

fusion between<br />

Modernist discourse and<br />

that of deeply traditional<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong> medieval illuminated<br />

manuscripts and<br />

carpet patterns.<br />

Grigorian studied at<br />

the Panos Terlemezian<br />

Art College in Yerevan<br />

from 1971 to 1977 and at<br />

the Yerevan State<br />

Institute of Fine Arts<br />

between 1978 and 1984.<br />

<strong>The</strong> following year he<br />

was became a member of<br />

the Artists’ Union of<br />

Armenia. He first exhibited<br />

with the 3rd Floor<br />

group and since then has<br />

exhibited regularly in various<br />

international locations<br />

including Buenos<br />

Aires, Chicago, Moscow,<br />

London, Germany and<br />

Yerevan. Since 2000 he<br />

has worked at the<br />

National Cinema Centre<br />

in Yerevan. His oeuvre<br />

consists largely of precise,<br />

naturalistic paintings<br />

depicting surrealistic<br />

imagery, but he has<br />

also illustrated a number<br />

of children’s books.<br />

He said that in his<br />

T H E A R M E N I A N M I R R O R - S P E C TAT O R<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong> Artists Part of First Sotheby’s Sale and Exhibition<br />

Of Contemporary Art from Caucasus and Central Asia<br />

“Memory” by Vruyr Galstyan<br />

SOTHEBY’S PHOTO<br />

“Enigma” by Ruben Grigorian<br />

“Disintegration” by Armen Gevorgyan<br />

SOTHEBY’S PHOTO<br />

works, he tries to “unite the surrounding world with the<br />

parallel mystic reality. Imagination is the most important<br />

element in art and the passages opened by it transport<br />

us into the Past and into the Future.”<br />

For more information, visit Sotheby’s website.<br />

SOTHEBY’S PHOTO<br />

11


12<br />

Love and<br />

Whiskey at the<br />

Blind Donkey<br />

By Jessica Gelt<br />

ASEDENA, Calif. (LA Times) — <strong>The</strong><br />

new Blind Donkey bar is the work of the<br />

beer-minded men behind Verdugo Bar,<br />

the Surly Goat and the Little Bear, and as<br />

such it exudes a pleasing masculinity. <strong>The</strong><br />

decor is stripped down to a few framed<br />

photographs of donkeys; a large, slightly<br />

crooked bar; a massive gilded mirror<br />

(good for casting wayward glances at<br />

other lonely drinkers) and a smattering of<br />

communal wooden tables.<br />

Ryan Sweeney, the tattooed maestro<br />

and mouthpiece for the group’s bars (his<br />

partners include John Bower, Brandon<br />

Bradford and Alen Aivazian) says the<br />

Donkey currently carries nearly 115 different<br />

kinds of whiskey. That’s a lot of<br />

love, perusing the menu of American,<br />

Scottish, Irish and Canadian offerings<br />

and resolving to have a second glass of<br />

something peaty.<br />

Manager Penny Wilhelm is behind the<br />

bar. Blond and gregarious, Wilhelm is<br />

developing an encyclopedic knowledge of<br />

whiskey so she can help patrons with the<br />

understandably taxing decision-making<br />

process.<br />

“I spend my days reading books,” says<br />

Wilhelm, producing a large volume titled,<br />

World Whiskey: A Nation-by-Nation<br />

Guide to the Best.<br />

What’s Wilhelm’s favorite whiskey at<br />

the moment?<br />

Wilhelm picks up a bottle of Templeton<br />

rye and points out that it was “Al<br />

Capone’s drink of choice.”<br />

<strong>The</strong> Templeton rye, which is well-aged<br />

and spicy with strong notes of wood and<br />

caramel, is used in the Donkey’s version<br />

of the Old Fashioned. Called Butler’s Old<br />

Fashioned, the drink features seasonal<br />

jam, in this case cinnamon plum.<br />

Visitors may also order a basket of deep<br />

fried pickle chips with barbecue sauce<br />

and jalapeño ranch. Sweeney is quick to<br />

point out that the Donkey is a bar that<br />

serves food. Not a restaurant.<br />

S A T U R D A Y, F E B R U A R Y 2 , 2 0 1 3 T H E A R M E N I A N M I R R O R - S P E C TAT O R<br />

TORONTO — <strong>The</strong> Asia Minor Catastrophe<br />

and the Ottoman Greek Genocide: Essays on<br />

Asia Minor, Pontos, and Eastern Thrace,<br />

1913–1923, edited by George N. Shirinian,<br />

executive director of the Zoryan Institute, is a<br />

compilation of innovative papers given by distinguished<br />

scholars at two academic conferences<br />

organized by the Asia Minor and Pontos<br />

Hellenic Research Center in Chicago.<br />

“Our knowledge of the catastrophic events<br />

affecting millions of people caught up in the<br />

huge political and social transformation connected<br />

with the dissolution of the Ottoman<br />

Empire and the rise of the Turkish Republic has<br />

not received the scholarly attention it deserves.<br />

Even the best studied of these tragic events, the<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong> Genocide, has been deprived of a certain<br />

panoramic contextualization of a tragedy<br />

which touched profoundly the lives of several<br />

other religious and ethnic groups, such as the<br />

Greeks and Assyrians,” observed <strong>The</strong>ofanis G.<br />

Stavrou, professor of history at the University<br />

of Minnesota.<br />

LONDON — In her new book, Transnational<br />

Culture, Transnational Identity (I.B. Tauris,<br />

2011), Maria Koundoura, associate professor of<br />

literature at Emerson College, breaks new<br />

ground in her comparative analysis of Peter<br />

Balakian’s Black Dog of Fate, Orhan Pamuk’s<br />

Istanbul, and Elif Shafak’s novel, <strong>The</strong> Bastard<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong> Cross Serves as Inspiration for Ceramic Art<br />

KHATCHKAR, from page 10<br />

different regions and at different times. <strong>The</strong><br />

movable type printing press had not yet been<br />

invented. This would only happen in 1439, and<br />

it is known to have reached Constantinople 100<br />

years later. It is unclear when it reached these<br />

monks some distance from Constantinople.<br />

It is interesting to note that <strong>Armenian</strong> crosses<br />

are not crucifixes. <strong>The</strong> illuminated crosses<br />

were not heavy or strongly religious but rather<br />

light and uplifting, engendering a feeling of<br />

spirituality. I was fascinated by their variety,<br />

beauty and the scope of the crosses.<br />

<strong>The</strong> influence of these two traditions:<br />

Khatchkars, in Armenia, and the crosses drawn<br />

in illuminations, evoked a strong desire in me to<br />

fuse and extend these two art forms of the<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong> cross.<br />

Keeping with what I saw in the ancient<br />

manuscripts, I wanted to create the intricate<br />

crosses in various colors. I decided to continue<br />

the tradition of carving crosses in relief like the<br />

“cross-stones,” but using a modern approach<br />

and thus I began to examine the possible use of<br />

ceramics.<br />

Within a short time I had created a number<br />

of ceramic crosses. Ultimately I created many<br />

designs, which were inspired by those I saw in<br />

the Illuminations. Others were abstractions of<br />

them, or sprang from my imagination.<br />

<strong>The</strong> works are now found in a number of private<br />

collections. I was also honored when an<br />

artist from Zimbabwe purchased one of my<br />

ARTS & LIVING<br />

New Book on Greek, <strong>Armenian</strong> Genocides<br />

A Khatchkar in Armenia<br />

works.<br />

(Dr. Hachigian’s work will be available at the<br />

Knights of Vartan <strong>Armenian</strong> Art Night on<br />

March 2, at the Newport Beach Country Club,<br />

1600 E. Coast Highway, Newport Beach. Or,<br />

make a donation to the “Friends of the<br />

Centennial Monument” on the website<br />

www.monument100.org and obtain his work in<br />

gratitude for a donation.)<br />

This book and its careful treatment of the<br />

Greek experience within the broader genocide of<br />

the Christian minorities in the Ottoman Empire<br />

aims to fill a gap in the scholarly literature on the<br />

Greek Genocide and is one of the first to treat<br />

the genocidal experiences of the <strong>Armenian</strong>s,<br />

Assyrians and Greeks in a comparative manner<br />

and as an integrated history. As Prof. Roger W.<br />

Smith, chair of Zoryan’s Academic Board, has<br />

written, “Only the comparative approach can<br />

yield carefully delimited generalizations about<br />

the nature and mechanics of genocide as a general<br />

problem of humanity.”<br />

<strong>The</strong> studies presented in this groundbreaking<br />

book are thoroughly documented and include<br />

revealing and previously unpublished American<br />

diplomatic reports on the destruction of<br />

Smyrna. In addition to the historical chapters,<br />

essays explore such subjects as the multigenerational<br />

effects of the Greek Genocide and the<br />

difficulties of Asia Minor refugee identity in<br />

Greece, Turkey’s present day obligations under<br />

the Treaty of Lausanne, and the challenges of<br />

Book on Transnational Literature Compares<br />

Balakian, Pamuk and Shafak<br />

of Istanbul, in what appears to be the first<br />

scholarly work comparing modern <strong>Armenian</strong><br />

and Turkish writers.<br />

In her chapter titled “<strong>The</strong> Spaces of Memory<br />

in Transnational Culture,” Koundoura explores<br />

and theorizes, using theorists Walter Benjamin,<br />

Paul de Man and Frederic Jamieson among others,<br />

the ways Pamuk and Balakian’s memoirs<br />

and Shafak’s novel engage history, memory and<br />

loss and how transnational visions of language<br />

and culture inform literature in the new global<br />

age of literature. As the book jacket notes, “this<br />

book will be invaluable for readers of cultural<br />

and post colonial studies, diaspora and globalization<br />

studies, and world literature.”<br />

Koundoura is also the editor the journal<br />

Modern Greek Studies and the author of <strong>The</strong><br />

Greek Idea: <strong>The</strong> Formation of National and<br />

Transnational Identities.<br />

obtaining recognition for the Ottoman genocides.<br />

A list of the contents is given below.<br />

Prof. Vahakn N. Dadrian, Zoryan’s director of<br />

genocide research, writes, “This book makes a<br />

valuable contribution to our understanding of<br />

the Greek experience of genocide during the<br />

early part of the 20th century and its aftermath.<br />

It shows how interrelated were the experiences<br />

of the <strong>Armenian</strong>s, Assyrians and Greeks<br />

during the end of the Ottoman Empire and the<br />

establishment of the Turkish Republic.”<br />

<strong>The</strong> contributors to the book are Shirinian;<br />

Tessa Hofmann: “<strong>The</strong> Genocide against the<br />

Christians in the Late Ottoman Period,<br />

1912–1922;” Taner Akçam: “<strong>The</strong> Greek<br />

Deportations and Massacres of 1913–1914: A<br />

Trial Run for the <strong>Armenian</strong> Genocide;”<br />

Matthias Bjørnlund: “<strong>The</strong> Persecution of<br />

Greeks and <strong>Armenian</strong>s in Smyrna, 1914–1916:<br />

A Special Case in the Course of the Late<br />

Ottoman Genocides;” Harry J. Psomiades:<br />

“Greece in Asia Minor: <strong>The</strong> Greek Naval<br />

Bombardment of Samsun [Amisos], June 7,<br />

1922;” Constantine G. Hatzidimitriou: “<strong>The</strong><br />

Destruction of Smyrna in 1922: American<br />

Sources and Turkish Responsibility;” Alexander<br />

Kitroeff: “Asia Minor Refugees in Greece: A<br />

History of Identity and Memory, 1920s–1980s;”<br />

Van Coufoudakis: “From Lausanne (1923) to<br />

Cyprus (2009): Turkey’s Violations of<br />

International Law and the Destruction of<br />

Historic Hellenic Communities” and Robert J.<br />

Pranger: “US Policy Obstacles in Recognizing<br />

the Genocides of Christian Minorities in the<br />

Late Ottoman Empire: Challenges and<br />

Opportunities.”<br />

Shirinian said, “<strong>The</strong> contributors to this volume<br />

and the Asia Minor and Pontos Hellenic<br />

Research Center hope that this wide-ranging<br />

collection of studies helps bring a measure of<br />

understanding and openness to the discussion<br />

of the Greek Genocide. This is a story of great<br />

human tragedy and suffering, of great power<br />

politics and miscalculation. By promoting<br />

awareness of this history, we hope to prevent<br />

the recurrence of another, ‘Great Catastrophe.’”<br />

To order a copy contact Zoryan at<br />

zoryan@zoryaninstitute.org.<br />

SCHOLARSHIPS AVAILABLE<br />

for<br />

Students of <strong>Armenian</strong> Descent<br />

Having Completed One Year of College by June <strong>2013</strong><br />

Application and other information may be obtained<br />

from<br />

Tibrevank Alumni, Inc.<br />

Vahan Adjemian Scholarship Fund<br />

P.O. Box 14<br />

Palisades Park, NJ 07650<br />

or<br />

www.vahanadjemianscholarship.org<br />

Deadline for returning completed applications: April 30, <strong>2013</strong>


WASHINGTON — As part of its ongoing program<br />

to promote teaching of genocide and<br />

human rights and the lessons of the <strong>Armenian</strong><br />

Genocide, the <strong>Armenian</strong> National Institute<br />

(ANI) announced the release by Routledge publishers<br />

of the fourth edition of Centuries of<br />

Genocide: Essays and Eyewitness Accounts, by<br />

Samuel Totten and William S. Parsons, the<br />

genocide and human rights studies textbook<br />

widely used in college and high school courses.<br />

<strong>The</strong> fourth edition of Centuries of Genocide:<br />

Essays and Eyewitness Accounts addresses<br />

examples of genocides perpetrated in the nineteenth,<br />

twentieth, and twenty-first centuries.<br />

Each chapter of the book is written by a recognized<br />

expert in the field.<br />

<strong>The</strong> chapter on the <strong>Armenian</strong> Genocide,<br />

which has appeared since the first edition of the<br />

publication, previously issued under the title<br />

Century of Genocide, is authored by ANI<br />

Director Dr. Rouben Adalian. For this new and<br />

expanded edition, the chapter was updated to<br />

reflect the growing scholarship on the subject.<br />

<strong>The</strong> book is framed by an introductory essay<br />

that spells out definitional issues. To help readers<br />

learn about the similarities and differences<br />

among the various cases, each case is structured<br />

around specific leading questions. In<br />

every chapter authors address: Who committed<br />

the genocide? How was the genocide committed?<br />

Why was the genocide committed? Who<br />

were the victims? What were the outstanding<br />

S A T U R D A Y, F E B R U A R Y 2 , 2 0 1 3 T H E A R M E N I A N M I R R O R - S P E C TAT O R 13<br />

historical forces? What was the long-range<br />

impact? What were the responses? How do<br />

scholars interpret this genocide? How does<br />

learning about this genocide contribute to the<br />

field of study?<br />

Dr. Maureen Hiebert from the University of<br />

Calgary, who specializes in genocide, government,<br />

politics, and international law, described<br />

ARTS & LIVING<br />

Fourth Edition of Centuries of Genocide Textbook Issued<br />

C A L E N D A R<br />

MASSACHUSETTS<br />

FEBRUARY 9 — Sisters’ Academy Annual Valentine’s Party, presenting<br />

Elie Berberian and Band, Oakley Country Club, 410 Belmont<br />

St., Watertown; information: Nageeb Diarbakerly at (617) 480-3700.<br />

FEBRUARY 23 — “Armenia Unseen — Among the Mountains,<br />

Valleys and Villages,” a visual representation by Joe Dagdigian,<br />

sponsored by the Lowell “Aharonian” Gomideh, 6 p.m., St. Gregory<br />

Church, 158 Main St., North Andover; dinner and program; update<br />

on events in Syria by Rev. Karekin Bedourian, pastor; all proceeds<br />

benefiting the Syrian-<strong>Armenian</strong> Relief Fund; $20 adults; $10 students.<br />

the publication as: “A welcome new edition to<br />

an already influential series, Centuries of<br />

Genocide adds new cases spanning the 19th to<br />

the 21st centuries and the four corners of the<br />

globe. Each chapter offers up-to-date research<br />

and analysis by some of the leading scholars in<br />

the field on the causes, processes, and aftermath<br />

of genocide, along with searing first-person<br />

eyewitness accounts that starkly illustrate<br />

the human experience, and tragic cost, of genocidal<br />

violence.”<br />

Dr. Ervin Staub of the University of<br />

Massachusetts at Amherst and author of<br />

Overcoming Evil: Genocide, Violent Conflict<br />

and Terrorism and <strong>The</strong> Roots of Evil: <strong>The</strong><br />

Origins of Genocide and Other Group<br />

Violence, comments: “In this deeply humane<br />

book, fired by the passion of the editors and<br />

authors to understand the roots of genocides so<br />

that we can prevent this scourge of humanity,<br />

eminent experts give up-to-date accounts of 15<br />

genocides. <strong>The</strong> scholarship of the authors is<br />

outstanding, the chapters in the book highly<br />

readable and compelling. While most of the<br />

chapters are about genocides in the 20th century,<br />

the book now contains chapters about<br />

genocides in the 19th century and the first<br />

genocide in the 21st Century. <strong>The</strong> personal<br />

accounts included truly reach the heart.”<br />

Co-editor of Centuries of Genocide William S.<br />

Parsons, who is chief of staff for the United<br />

States Holocaust Memorial Museum in<br />

Sponsor a Teacher in Armenia and Karabagh <strong>2013</strong><br />

Since its inception in 2001, TCA’s ‘Sponsor<br />

a Teacher’ program has raised over $563,000<br />

and reached out to 4,440 teachers and<br />

school workers in Armenia and Karabagh.<br />

✄<br />

On <strong>February</strong> 23, St. Gregory<br />

Church of North Andover, 158<br />

Main St., will host “Armenia<br />

Unseen — Among the Mountains,<br />

Valleys and Villages,” a visual<br />

representation by Joe Dagdigian.<br />

<strong>The</strong> event will take place at 6<br />

p.m., and will feature dinner and<br />

the program; all proceeds benefiting<br />

the Syrian-<strong>Armenian</strong> Relief<br />

fund; $20 adults; $10 students.<br />

❑ Yes, I want to sponsor teachers in Armenia and Karabagh to continue<br />

helping them to educate the children, our future leaders. I would like to have<br />

the teacher’s name and address.<br />

❑ $160<br />

Name<br />

Address<br />

❑ $ 320 ❑ $ 480 ❑ other $—————————<br />

City<br />

Tel:<br />

State Zip code<br />

Make check payable to: Tekeyan Cultural Association – Memo: Sponsor a Teacher 2010<br />

Mail your check with this form to:<br />

TCA Sponsor a Teacher<br />

5326 Valverde, Houston, TX 77056<br />

Your donation is Tax Deductible.<br />

Washington, DC, has devoted 30 years of his<br />

career to Holocaust education. In 1991,<br />

Parsons was invited to join the Museum’s<br />

Education Committee to share his innovative<br />

ideas for teaching about prejudice and racism.<br />

He is also the co-author of the teachers’ guide<br />

Facing History and Ourselves: Holocaust and<br />

Human Behavior.<br />

Dr. Samuel Totten, University of Arkansas,<br />

Fayetteville, professor of Curriculum and<br />

Instruction, has written extensively on teaching,<br />

preventing, intervening and documenting<br />

genocide. He is the author of Teaching About<br />

Genocide, Dictionary of Genocide, co-editor<br />

with Steven Jacobs of Pioneers of Genocide<br />

Studies, which included a contribution by<br />

Adalian, and was an associate editor with<br />

Adalian, Jacobs, and Eric Markusen of the<br />

Encyclopedia of Genocide under the chief editorship<br />

of Israel W. Charny, executive director<br />

of the Institute on the Holocaust and Genocide<br />

in Jerusalem. Totten is also the co-founding editor<br />

of Genocide Studies and Prevention: An<br />

International Journal published by the<br />

University of Toronto Press and the Zoryan<br />

Institute. During the summer of 2004, Totten<br />

served as one of the 24 investigators with the<br />

US State Department’s Atrocities<br />

Documentation Project, interviewing black<br />

African refugees along the Chad/Sudan border<br />

in order to collect data for the express purpose<br />

of ascertaining whether genocide had been perpetrated<br />

in Darfur.<br />

As part of its continuing service to educators<br />

and to coincide with the release of Centuries of<br />

Genocide, ANI has expanded its Resource<br />

Guide and other sections of the Education component<br />

of the ANI website. Dozens of resources<br />

selected for their instructional value are listed<br />

for the benefit of students and teachers.<br />

Educators interested in teaching about the role<br />

of American humanitarianism and involvement<br />

in responding to the <strong>Armenian</strong> crisis can also<br />

benefit from the recently issued fact sheet summarizing<br />

“<strong>The</strong> United States Record on the<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong> Genocide: A Proud Chapter in<br />

American History,” prepared by the <strong>Armenian</strong><br />

Assembly of America.<br />

Author Margaret Ajemian<br />

Ahnert Speaks at<br />

Pepperdine University<br />

MALIBU, Calif. — On Wednesday November<br />

14, Margaret Ajemian Ahnert, presented her<br />

book, <strong>The</strong> Knock at the Door, a mother-daughter<br />

survival story, at Pepperdine University.<br />

Ahnert, a member of the National League of<br />

American Pen Women and an award-winning<br />

author, spoke to a crowd of more than 200 hundred<br />

students.<br />

<strong>The</strong> event opened with a brief screening of an<br />

interview with Ahnert conducted by Chuck<br />

Margaret Ajemian Ahnert<br />

Scarborough of NBC television in September<br />

2012, in which Ahnert discusses her own mother’s<br />

Genocide survival story.<br />

<strong>The</strong> event was followed by a question and<br />

answer period, during which, Ahnert discussed<br />

her relationship with her mother and her own<br />

experiences confronting Genocide deniers during<br />

her five-year book tour.


14 S A T U R D A Y, F E B R U A R Y 2 , 2 0 1 3 T H E A R M E N I A N M I R R O R - S P E C TAT O R<br />

<strong>Mirror</strong>-<br />

T H E A R M E N I A N<br />

<strong>Spectator</strong><br />

Established 1932<br />

An ADL Publication<br />

EDITOR<br />

Alin K. Gregorian<br />

ASSISTANT EDITOR<br />

Gabriella Gage<br />

ASSOCIATE EDITOR<br />

Aram Arkun<br />

ART DIRECTOR<br />

Marc Mgrditchian<br />

SENIOR EDITORIAL COLUMNIST:<br />

Edmond Azadian<br />

CONTRIBUTORS:<br />

Florence Avakian, Elizabeth Aprahamian,<br />

Daphne Abeel, Dr. Haroutiune<br />

Arzoumanian, Taleen Babayan, Prof.<br />

Vahakn N. Dadrian, Diana Der<br />

Hovanessian, Philip Ketchian, Kevork<br />

Keushkerian, Sonia Kailian-Placido,<br />

Harut Sassounian, Mary Terzian, Hagop<br />

Vartivarian, Naomi Zeytoonian<br />

CORRESPONDENTS:<br />

Armenia - Hagop Avedikian<br />

Boston - Nancy Kalajian<br />

Philadelphia - Lisa Manookian<br />

Contributing Photographers:<br />

Jacob Demirdjian, Harry Koundakjian, Jirair<br />

Hovsepian<br />

<strong>The</strong> <strong>Armenian</strong> <strong>Mirror</strong>-<strong>Spectator</strong> is published<br />

weekly, except two weeks in July, by:<br />

Baikar Association, Inc.<br />

755 Mt. Auburn St., Watertown, MA 02472-1509<br />

Telephone: 617-924-4420<br />

FAX: 617-924-2887<br />

www. mir rorspectator. com<br />

E-Mail: editor@mirrorspectator.com<br />

For advertising: mirrorads@aol.com<br />

SUBSCRIPTION RATES:<br />

U.S.A. $80 a year<br />

Canada $125 a year<br />

Other Countries $190 a year<br />

© 2011 <strong>The</strong> <strong>Armenian</strong> <strong>Mirror</strong>-<strong>Spectator</strong><br />

Periodical Class Postage Paid at Boston, MA<br />

and additional mailing offices.<br />

ISSN 0004-234X<br />

POSTMASTER: Send address changes to <strong>The</strong><br />

<strong>Armenian</strong> <strong>Mirror</strong>-<strong>Spectator</strong>, P.O. Box 302,<br />

Watertown, MA 02471-0302<br />

Other than the editorial, views and opinions<br />

expressed in this newspaper do not necessarily<br />

eflect the policies of the publisher.<br />

Copying for other than personal use or<br />

internal reference is prohibited without<br />

express permission of the copyright<br />

owner. Address requests for reprints or<br />

back issues to:<br />

Baikar Association, Inc.<br />

755 Mt. Auburn St., Watertown, MA 02472-1509<br />

COMMENTARY<br />

A Thaw in <strong>Armenian</strong>-Georgian Relations<br />

By Edmond Y. Azadian<br />

During the Soviet era, <strong>Armenian</strong>-Georgian relations could not be<br />

anything except what Kremlin rulers prescribed for the region. But<br />

the undercurrent resentments continued to run deep down for a<br />

variety of reasons. For centuries <strong>Armenian</strong>s represented the business<br />

elite in Georgia. <strong>The</strong>y also built the capital city of Tbilisi,<br />

which, before the Bolshevik revolution of 1917 was called the<br />

“Paris of Caucasus.” When the revolution swept the region,<br />

Georgia was in a very unique situation, because, under the guise<br />

of the proletariat taking over the wealth of the bourgeoisie, the<br />

Georgians usurped the properties of the <strong>Armenian</strong>s.<br />

Throughout the Soviet period, the Tbilisi government implemented<br />

an almost identical policy towards Javakhk which Azeris<br />

were implementing in Karabagh, leaving the two ancient <strong>Armenian</strong><br />

regions under the authority of Georgia and Azerbaijan, respectively,<br />

underdeveloped. <strong>The</strong> poverty of Javakhk <strong>Armenian</strong>s today is the<br />

legacy of that discriminatory policy.<br />

After the collapse of the Soviet Empire, the undercurrent of<br />

mutual resentment floated to the surface.<br />

Successive leaders like Shevardnadze, Gamsakhurdia and<br />

Saakashvili pursued a policy of depopulating the <strong>Armenian</strong><br />

regions. <strong>The</strong>y further threatened to bring the exiled Meskhetian<br />

Turks from Central Asia and settle them in Javakhk. That was a<br />

two-throng policy to please the Turks in Ankara and Baku as well<br />

as scare the indigenous <strong>Armenian</strong>s. Almost 200,000 <strong>Armenian</strong>s<br />

emigrated from Georgia after its independence. To be fair, the emigration<br />

cannot be attributed solely to the policies of the government,<br />

since a larger ratio has also left the Republic of Armenia as<br />

well.<br />

Although there are five <strong>Armenian</strong> members in the Georgian<br />

Parliament, their clout is minimal. <strong>The</strong>y are insensitive to the needs<br />

and the problems of the <strong>Armenian</strong> community, very much like the<br />

Amiras in the Ottoman era, who tended to preserve their own turf.<br />

Although Georgia and Armenia are the only two Christian<br />

nations in the Caucasus region, their relations have been cool, to<br />

say the least. Georgia has not yet recognized the <strong>Armenian</strong><br />

Genocide and has persistently voted along with Azerbaijan at the<br />

UN.<br />

<strong>The</strong> continuing cold war also has its impact in the region. As<br />

much as Armenia is considered a vanguard post for Russia in the<br />

Caucasus, Georgia similarly is considered a vanguard post of<br />

NATO, albeit a virtual one. Through the direct aid and investments,<br />

the European Union and the US have tried to make Georgia a<br />

showcase for the West. And the US-trained Saakashvili tried to<br />

uproot the corruption endemic throughout the former Soviet<br />

republics, but recent scandals have revealed that the reforms have<br />

been achieved at a heavy cost and brutal and repressive measures.<br />

Those scandals cost President Saakashvili the recent parliamentary<br />

elections, and led to the emergence of the billionaire Bidzina<br />

Ivanishvili as the new prime minister. Cohabitation has seen some<br />

tensions between the two leaders, especially when the new prime<br />

minister began a purge of the adherents of the president’s party.<br />

During these developments, Patriarch Ilya II switched his allegiance<br />

to the winning side, Ivanishvili’s Georgian Dream party.<br />

Ivanishvili began his foreign policy with regards to the <strong>Armenian</strong><br />

Republic on the wrong foot, through an untoward remark, but he<br />

has taken corrective action since.<br />

Preserving the <strong>Armenian</strong><br />

Language at Home and<br />

Abroad<br />

To <strong>The</strong> Editor:<br />

I was just reading in the January 26 edition<br />

of the <strong>Armenian</strong> <strong>Mirror</strong>-<strong>Spectator</strong> about a<br />

family that came from Syria to live in Armenia<br />

and found it easier to learn and speak Russian<br />

in Armenia to get around.<br />

<strong>The</strong>y found a lot of words were in Russian<br />

Notice to Contributors<br />

<strong>The</strong> <strong>Armenian</strong> <strong>Mirror</strong>-<strong>Spectator</strong> welcomes articles, commentaries and community<br />

news from our readers. In order to assure the accurate and timely publication of articles<br />

submitted, please note the following policies:<br />

— All articles submitted should be typed, double (or triple) spaced and printed in a type size<br />

large enough to be clearly legible (10 point or larger). Submissions that do not conform to<br />

these specifications will be assigned lowest priority.<br />

— Articles sent by fax are acceptable, and e-mail submissions are encouraged.<br />

— All submissions should include the name of a contact person and a daytime<br />

COMMENTARY<br />

LETTERS<br />

rather than <strong>Armenian</strong>.<br />

I am sick to read that <strong>Armenian</strong>s in Armenia<br />

know less of their native <strong>Armenian</strong> language<br />

than they do Russian.<br />

When I visited Armenia in August 2009, I<br />

thought my speaking Western <strong>Armenian</strong> was<br />

the reason they could not understand me. As<br />

it turned out, they could not speak their own<br />

native language, which I thought was<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong>.<br />

I know that <strong>Armenian</strong>s that come here from<br />

Armenia to get their driver’s licenses take<br />

their driving test in Russian instead of<br />

His recent visit to Armenia marked a definite thaw in the relations<br />

between the two neighbors. A symbolic gesture was the<br />

release of Javakhk political prisoner Vahakn Chakhalian, who had<br />

been jailed on trumped-up charges at a kangaroo court and sentenced<br />

to a 10-year term.<br />

Going beyond symbolism, Ivanishvili discussed the possibility of<br />

reactivating the Abkhazian rail system, which will benefit Armenia<br />

economically and help Russia to transport goods to the region.<br />

<strong>The</strong> idea is, of course, an anathema to the previous administration,<br />

which refuses to do any business with Abkhazia, as long as<br />

its remains outside of Tbilisi’s jurisdiction. <strong>The</strong>refore, it was not a<br />

surprise to hear Saakashvili’s public rebuke of the idea. He also<br />

raised hell for Chakhalian’s release.<br />

<strong>The</strong> prime minister also praised Georgian <strong>Armenian</strong>s for their<br />

loyalty and their contributions to the country. He said that there<br />

are 300,000 <strong>Armenian</strong>s living in Georgia, although that figure may<br />

be much more, but Ivanishvili was relying on their votes during the<br />

next election.<br />

Besides President Saakashvili, Georgia’s foreign minister also<br />

made a hostile remark, while his superior was still in Yerevan. He<br />

stated that Georgia would see the Karabagh problem resolved with<br />

the territorial integrity of Azerbaijan intact.<br />

Georgia has developed complex relations with Azerbaijan and<br />

Turkey. <strong>The</strong> former provides cheap gas and the latter has made<br />

substantive investments in Georgia. It will not be easy to wean<br />

Tbilisi from those two nations, as much as the new Georgian leader<br />

is seeking to improve the relations with Moscow.<br />

Georgian-<strong>Armenian</strong> relations have not always been warm, but<br />

since the August 2008 war with Russia, they have even been more<br />

inflamed, as the Tbilisi administration considers Yerevan as the<br />

base for Russian influence in the region. And for that very same<br />

reason, Ivanishvili’s visit to Armenia was interpreted as testing the<br />

waters to find out the potential of an eventual rapprochement with<br />

Moscow.<br />

Georgia is a vital link for Armenia’s foreign trade as 70 percent<br />

of overland transportation of goods transit through the Georgian<br />

territory. Yet the road system still remains precarious, since several<br />

months in the year, the roads are snow-covered, especially in the<br />

region of Upper Larse. <strong>The</strong> project of digging an expensive tunnel<br />

through those mountains still remains on the drawing board. Once<br />

the Georgian authorities realize the dividends of the project, they<br />

may act on it and the corollary beneficiary will become Armenia.<br />

At this time, there is a cautious movement towards normalizing<br />

relations between the two neighbors. No matter how willing or sincere<br />

Ivanishvili may be, he has yet to consolidate his power in the<br />

country. He may launch an adventurous political course when he<br />

fully holds the reigns of the power in his country.<br />

Another debate which is raging simultaneously in the region is<br />

the opening of the Stepanakert Airport for civil aviation, a project<br />

which the Azeris oppose violently. Armenia cannot risk a retaliation<br />

by beginning to operate the airport, especially since some<br />

members of the European Union may consider that move as a<br />

“provocation.” But once Russia decides that a strategic asset right<br />

next to the Iranian border is being threatened, they may join forces<br />

with Karabagh to thwart the Azeri threat, especially after the abandonment<br />

of the Kabala Station in the Azeri territory.<br />

After facing so much economic and military pressure, Armenia<br />

would welcome a respite. If the Georgians move in a positive direction<br />

toward Armenia, that move will certainly be guided by their<br />

self-interest, yet Armenia will benefit from the thaw.<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong> because it is easier for them. This I<br />

know for a fact.<br />

We <strong>Armenian</strong>s should learn to stand on our<br />

own two feet and not lean on Russia’s shoulder.<br />

I am a proud <strong>Armenian</strong>, but when I read<br />

stories like this, I am saddened that we have<br />

become this low.<br />

I remember why my grandparents, uncles,<br />

aunts and cousins died. <strong>The</strong>y died to keep<br />

their <strong>Armenian</strong> language and their Christian<br />

faith.<br />

–Mel Menasian<br />

Methuen, Mass<br />

telephone number.<br />

— Deadline for submission of all articles and advertising is 12 noon on Monday of the<br />

week of publication.<br />

— Photos will be published without charge at the discretion of the editors and art director.<br />

Photos will be returned only if a self-addressed and stamped envelope is included.<br />

— <strong>The</strong> M-S will publish only one article about an upcoming organizational event. For<br />

major special events, exceptions may be made only by special arrangement with the<br />

editors.<br />

— Telephone numbers, ticket prices and other details (at the discretion of the editors) will<br />

not be included in press releases, but should be reserved for calendar listings and advertisements.


Turkey Should Be Kept in the<br />

Dark on <strong>Armenian</strong> Genocide<br />

Centennial Plans<br />

It is no secret that <strong>Armenian</strong> communities around the<br />

world are busy planning scores of projects for the 100th<br />

anniversary of the <strong>Armenian</strong> Genocide on April 24, 2015.<br />

It is also no secret that the Turkish government and its<br />

agents are closely monitoring all announced <strong>Armenian</strong><br />

plans, so Ankara can prepare its counter-moves to the anticipated<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong> “tsunami.”<br />

By publicizing their plans more than two years before<br />

the centennial, <strong>Armenian</strong>s would be providing Turkish<br />

denialists valuable intelligence and sufficient lead-time to<br />

figure out how best to disrupt <strong>Armenian</strong> commemorative<br />

activities.<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong>s must realize that succeeding Turkish governments<br />

have had a long history of genocide denial. In fact,<br />

the crime of genocide and its cover up were designed simultaneously<br />

almost a century ago by the Young Turk regime.<br />

Furthermore, as a powerful state, Turkey is eager and willing<br />

to use its considerable resources to counter <strong>Armenian</strong><br />

political initiatives around the globe. Ankara routinely pressures,<br />

threatens, and even blackmails all individuals, orga-<br />

By Raffi Bedrosyan<br />

S A T U R D A Y, F E B R U A R Y 2 , 2 0 1 3 T H E A R M E N I A N M I R R O R - S P E C TAT O R 15<br />

My Turn<br />

By Harut Sassounian<br />

On the sixth anniversary of his assassination<br />

and more significantly, on the sixth<br />

anniversary of the Turkish state’s inability or<br />

unwillingness to find his real killers, Hrant<br />

Dink was remembered by tens of thousands<br />

of people in many countries and in Turkey,<br />

including Istanbul, Ankara, Izmir, Diyarbakir,<br />

Malatya and Bodrum. International, Turkish<br />

and <strong>Armenian</strong> speakers reiterated his vision<br />

and message of direct dialogue between<br />

Turks and <strong>Armenian</strong>s. Year by year, instead<br />

of gradually diminishing in numbers toward<br />

oblivion as is the case for other assassinated<br />

journalists in Turkey, there is a snowballing<br />

increase in number and intensity of people<br />

attending the Dink commemorations,<br />

protesting and demanding justice, as well as<br />

adopting Dink’s messages with more determination.<br />

It is not the tiny <strong>Armenian</strong> community<br />

in Turkey, but Turks (and Kurds)<br />

from all walks of life who have embraced<br />

Dink as a tragic hero.<br />

<strong>The</strong> momentum is building to declare Dink<br />

a martyr, in fact, the first shared martyr by<br />

historically opposing nations Armenia and<br />

Turkey.<br />

But what exactly was Dink’s message? He<br />

would define <strong>Armenian</strong>s and Turks as two<br />

sick people, clinical cases, <strong>Armenian</strong>s suffering<br />

from trauma (obsessed with 1915), Turks suffering<br />

from paranoia (fear of consequences of<br />

acknowledging 1915). He would advocate<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong>s and Turks to be each other’s doctors,<br />

with dialogue as the only prescription.<br />

And he would clap his large hands vigorously,<br />

exclaiming that “there is no other medicine,<br />

no other doctor, no, no, no.”<br />

He knew dialogue would be useless if one<br />

couldn’t discuss the painful 1915, but only<br />

pleasant subjects such as Turks and<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong>s’ shared values, shared culture,<br />

shared foods like dolma and kebab. He knew<br />

that dialogue would also be useless if one is<br />

unable to really ‘listen and hear,’ in addition<br />

to talking. And most importantly, he knew<br />

that dialogue would be useless if one didn’t<br />

know the real historical facts of 1915. After<br />

being systematically brainwashed by the<br />

COMMENTARY<br />

nizations, and states that acknowledge the facts of the<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong> Genocide.<br />

A small example of such ominous developments<br />

occurred recently when a production team announced<br />

plans to make a major movie on the <strong>Armenian</strong> Genocide,<br />

based on Micheline Aharonian Marcom’s novel, Three<br />

Apples Fell from Heaven. Sona Tatoyan, the film’s producer,<br />

gave an interview to a Turkish newspaper while visiting<br />

Istanbul last month, probably unaware that the<br />

Turkish media is notorious for distorting <strong>Armenian</strong><br />

Genocide related topics. Ms. Tatoyan was fortunate that she<br />

was interviewed by Radikal, one of Turkey’s more reputable<br />

newspapers, known for its liberal views on the<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong> Genocide. Even then, there were some minor distortions<br />

in Radikal’s report. What made matters worse was<br />

the translation of the Tatoyan interview into English by a<br />

little-known website called Al-Monitor, seriously distorting<br />

her views.<br />

For example, Ms. Tatoyan’s statement to Radikal, that<br />

the bones of Genocide victims were protruding from the<br />

sands of the Syrian desert in Der Zor and Ras al-Ayn, was<br />

misrepresented by Al-Monitor as: “We were crushing skulls<br />

and tossing bones.” Worse yet, Al-Monitor falsely quoted<br />

Ms. Tatoyan stating: “<strong>The</strong>y [<strong>Armenian</strong>s] should forget the<br />

Genocide.” In reality, she had said: “Making peace with<br />

Anatolia, with Turks, does not mean forgetting the genocide<br />

or condoning the politics of denial in Turkey.”<br />

Ms. Tatoyan was naturally upset by the distortions of her<br />

deeply held convictions on the <strong>Armenian</strong> Genocide. In a<br />

subsequent interview with Asbarez newspaper, she categorically<br />

denied having ever told <strong>Armenian</strong>s to forget the<br />

genocide. “I have not made such a statement. How could I<br />

have? How could I have said anything like that in an interview<br />

about a film on the <strong>Armenian</strong> Genocide I am helping<br />

create?”<br />

state with ever changing official versions of<br />

1915 history, people in Turkey have now<br />

finally started to learn the true historic facts,<br />

reasons and consequences of 1915, not a socalled<br />

Turkish version versus <strong>Armenian</strong> version.<br />

So, if and when there is willingness to<br />

talk and listen, both sides can and should<br />

engage in direct dialogue, without the need<br />

to convince third parties to pressure the<br />

other side.<br />

Dink studied zoology and he would explain<br />

that if you remove any living organism from<br />

its natural environment, you would cause its<br />

extinction. He would then say: “If you<br />

remove an entire people from its land where<br />

it has lived continuously for 3000 years, even<br />

if you transport them with great care in ‘golden<br />

airplanes,’ this would still be similar to<br />

taking an axe to the roots of an ancient tree.”<br />

He didn’t need to explain 1915 with long<br />

words; in a corner of Agos, every week, he<br />

would place some facts about a village or<br />

town in Anatolia, could be in the west, east,<br />

north, south or central Anatolia, giving the<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong> and total population numbers, the<br />

names and numbers of churches and schools<br />

there before 1915. He would have photos of<br />

these active <strong>Armenian</strong> churches and schools<br />

in that village or town before 1915, and photos<br />

of these non-existent churches or schools<br />

today, totaling more than 4000 buildings.<br />

That would be enough for anyone to understand<br />

the reality of 1915.<br />

But he wouldn’t only talk about the<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong>s gone or dead in 1915. He would<br />

be much more interested in talking about the<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong>s who remained, who stayed in<br />

Anatolia, those people who stayed and survived,<br />

but no longer as <strong>Armenian</strong>s. <strong>The</strong>se<br />

were the <strong>Armenian</strong>s who stayed and survived,<br />

by converting to Islam, by assimilating<br />

into Turkish, Kurdish or Alawi identities.<br />

<strong>The</strong>se were the <strong>Armenian</strong> girls and boys captured<br />

or sold, kept hidden, protected or married<br />

to Turks and Kurds. <strong>The</strong>se were some<br />

entire <strong>Armenian</strong> villages that converted to<br />

Islam, or stayed protected by friendly<br />

Kurdish and Alawi leaders.<br />

Dink was obsessed with this subject. What<br />

happened to these people? Did they secretly<br />

keep their <strong>Armenian</strong> identity? Did they pass<br />

it on to the next generations? Where are they<br />

now? How many are there? If there are hidden<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong>s, what would be the trigger<br />

for them to come out of hiding?<br />

Genocide is not a single event but a continuous<br />

process. It is not only denial of a<br />

genocide that continues it, but assimilation<br />

and conversion also continue it. Scholars<br />

have recently started defining genocide not<br />

only as destruction of the oppressed nation,<br />

but also construction of the oppressor nation<br />

— using assimilation and conversion processes.<br />

For <strong>Armenian</strong>s, these processes continued<br />

on all fronts.<br />

Dink didn’t or couldn’t write much about<br />

this sensitive subject, but he was preoccupied<br />

by it, gathering stories, anecdotal evidence,<br />

always encouraging others to find out more.<br />

Obviously, this was not a subject that could<br />

be researched openly and scientifically, but<br />

whenever a new revelation came out about<br />

hidden <strong>Armenian</strong>s in Anatolia, he would get<br />

excited. His lawyer, Fethiye Cetin’s My<br />

Grandmother was only an example of the<br />

fate of the hidden <strong>Armenian</strong>s. In an interview<br />

with London filmmaker Nouritsa Matossian<br />

for the documentary “Hrant Dink: A Heart<br />

Of Two Nations,” Nouritsa asked him: “Do<br />

you see <strong>Armenian</strong> faces in Anatolia?” Dink:<br />

“Yes, often.” Nouritsa: “Apparitions.” Dink:<br />

“Apparitions and real ones.”<br />

<strong>The</strong> answer to the question that kept him wondering<br />

— what would be the trigger for the hidden<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong>s to come out, came four years too<br />

late for Dink to witness unfortunately.<br />

<strong>The</strong> trigger was the reconstruction of the<br />

Diyarbakir Surp Giragos Church in 2011.<br />

Thousands of Anatolian people, young and<br />

old, Turkish and Kurdish in appearance and<br />

identity, returned to their <strong>Armenian</strong> roots<br />

with the reopening of this church. Some<br />

were baptized in the church, some changed<br />

their Turkish names to <strong>Armenian</strong> originals,<br />

some changed their identity to <strong>Armenian</strong> but<br />

remained Moslem (a new phenomenon of<br />

Moslem <strong>Armenian</strong>s,) some started learning<br />

the <strong>Armenian</strong> language.<br />

Dink would have danced with joy to see an<br />

eleven year old Kurdish girl, not only learning<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong> but also singing <strong>Armenian</strong><br />

songs at the first <strong>Armenian</strong> concert in the<br />

Diyarbakir Surp Giragos Church in 2012.<br />

Dink would have danced on the table, as he<br />

Since Al-Monitor’s article was in English, most non-<br />

Turkish speakers read the distorted version of Ms.<br />

Tatoyan’s interview, which was widely disseminated on the<br />

internet. Many readers were terribly disappointed by what<br />

they thought were her views on the <strong>Armenian</strong> Genocide.<br />

This is a serious blow to her efforts because making a<br />

major movie is a costly undertaking that requires a huge<br />

investment. When potential financial supporters are turned<br />

off, it could have a devastating impact on the future of her<br />

project.<br />

However, Ms. Tatoyan remains deeply committed to her<br />

film. She realizes that “during the production of the film,<br />

there will be constant attempts to distract us, to take our<br />

attention away from our goal of producing a great historical<br />

epic film on the <strong>Armenian</strong> Genocide. <strong>The</strong> best way to<br />

counter such attempts is to stay focused on the film and<br />

produce it for the world to see. <strong>The</strong> film speaks for itself,”<br />

she told Asbarez.<br />

It is unclear if the distortions of Ms. Tatoyan’s interview<br />

resulted from poor translation or intentionally done to<br />

undermine a major movie on the <strong>Armenian</strong> Genocide.<br />

Nevertheless, between now and April 24, 2015, <strong>Armenian</strong>s<br />

could encounter a multitude of sinister Turkish schemes to<br />

quash <strong>Armenian</strong> initiatives aiming to demand justice from<br />

Turkey.<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong>s should be alert and circumspect in publicizing<br />

their plans for the 100th anniversary of the <strong>Armenian</strong><br />

Genocide. Very few details should be disclosed to the public<br />

during the planning stages of special events and projects.<br />

<strong>The</strong> Turkish government should be prevented from<br />

learning about planned <strong>Armenian</strong> activities as much as possible<br />

in order to deny Ankara advance knowledge and time<br />

to counter and undermine <strong>Armenian</strong> righteous demands<br />

on the centennial of one of the 20th century’s most<br />

heinous crimes against humanity.<br />

About Hrant, the Anatolian <strong>Armenian</strong><br />

was photographed on a happy occasion, to<br />

see a thousand people from Adiyaman,<br />

Amasya, Arapkir, Dersim, Diyarbakir, Elazig,<br />

Harput, Hemshin, Istanbul, Kastamonu,<br />

Kayseri, Malatya, Musadagh, Sason, Sinop,<br />

Sivas, Tokat, Van and Yozgat organize activities<br />

together to celebrate the Surp Hagop<br />

Day, singing <strong>Armenian</strong> songs, even though<br />

none knew how to speak <strong>Armenian</strong>.<br />

Dink was an Anatolian <strong>Armenian</strong> and<br />

wished to have the same democratic rights as<br />

all other citizens of the state, without being<br />

excluded, without being discriminated, without<br />

being pressured to lose his identity.<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong>s wished to have exactly the same<br />

things 100 years ago — no more, no less. <strong>The</strong><br />

state felt threatened and when fear was combined<br />

with opportunity, it wiped out the<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong> identity in Anatolia to build a<br />

Turkish identity to the exclusion of all others,<br />

including Greeks, Assyrians and Kurds.<br />

<strong>The</strong> enormous transfer of wealth and<br />

assets from the <strong>Armenian</strong>s to the Turks has<br />

added to the fear and paranoia of the state in<br />

facing its past. A new Turkish identity, which<br />

does not fear threatened from the diversity of<br />

minority identities, needs to be created in<br />

Turkey in order to face both the past and the<br />

future. <strong>The</strong> state has finally started this<br />

process with the Kurds, but not the<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong>s. <strong>The</strong> Kurds have started this<br />

process with the <strong>Armenian</strong>s, openly acknowledging<br />

their role in 1915, and starting to<br />

make amends. It is hoped that Turks will see<br />

the light and follow them.<br />

(Raffi Bedrosyan is a civil engineer as<br />

well as a concert pianist, living in Toronto.<br />

For the past several years, he has donated<br />

proceeds from his concerts and CDs to the<br />

construction of school, highway, water and<br />

gas projects in Armenia and Karabagh —<br />

projects in which he also participated as a<br />

voluntary engineer. He helped organize<br />

the Diyarbakir/ Dikranagerd Surp Giragos<br />

Church reconstruction project, and with<br />

his articles, he promoted the significance<br />

of this historic project as the first<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong> reclaim of church properties in<br />

Anatolia after 1915. In September 2012, he<br />

gave the first <strong>Armenian</strong> piano concert in<br />

the Surp Giragos Church since 1915.)


16<br />

By Gayane Mkrtchyan<br />

Armenia’s government appears to be dragging<br />

its feet over changing the rules for military<br />

conscription, a year after a pan-European<br />

court ruled that Jehovah’s Witnesses had been<br />

mistreated as conscientious objectors.<br />

In November 2011, the European Court of<br />

Human Rights (ECHR) ruled that Armenia<br />

should pay compensation to 17 men who were<br />

detained and wrongly accused of desertion.<br />

In 2005, the men withdrew from a civilian<br />

service scheme intended to give committed<br />

pacifists like Jehovah’s Witnesses an alternative<br />

to mandatory conscription. Civilian service<br />

had been launched the previous year as<br />

part of Armenia’s obligations as a Council of<br />

Europe member.<br />

<strong>The</strong> men were assigned civilian work in<br />

schools, hospitals and elsewhere, but left six<br />

months later when they realized they were<br />

actually under military command, something<br />

that went against their absolute commitment<br />

to pacifism.<br />

“We were told this was civilian service, but<br />

it turned out to be military after all,” said Hayk<br />

Khachatryan, one of the 17 men who were<br />

arrested, held in detention for months and<br />

charged with desertion.<br />

<strong>The</strong> ECHR found that since Armenia had no<br />

legislation that made it a crime to withdraw<br />

from alternative service, detaining and charging<br />

the men was unlawful.<br />

In response to the ruling, the <strong>Armenian</strong> government<br />

acknowledged that military control of<br />

civilian service was a problem, and began<br />

drafting changes to the law in March 2012.<br />

<strong>The</strong> amendments now being proposed<br />

would differentiate between “alternative mili-<br />

S A T U R D A Y, F E B R U A R Y 2 , 2 0 1 3 T H E A R M E N I A N M I R R O R - S P E C TAT O R<br />

Armenia Slow to Pass Conscientious Objection<br />

Law for Jehovah’s Witnesses<br />

tary service” and “alternative labor service” —<br />

the latter structured to rule out any military<br />

involvement, so that the most committed of<br />

conscientious objectors could take part.<br />

Alternative military service would last 30<br />

months and alternative labor service 36<br />

months, as opposed to the standard two years<br />

served by conscript soldiers.<br />

Ten months on, it is unclear when the draft<br />

amendments will be completed by the Justice<br />

Ministry committee tasked with producing<br />

them.<br />

Artur Ispiryan, who works for the legal<br />

department of the Jehovah’s Witnesses, said,<br />

“<strong>The</strong> first version of the bill said that regional<br />

governors would oversee alternative service…<br />

but that point was removed. At the moment, it<br />

isn’t clear what this will be replaced with, but<br />

it’s essential that supervision is exclusively<br />

civilian in nature. That isn’t just what we want;<br />

it’s an international standard.”<br />

According to the Jehovah’s Witnesses,<br />

around 30 of their members are currently in<br />

jail for refusing to perform military service.<br />

Courts in Armenia are currently reviewing 25<br />

cases, so further convictions are possible.<br />

Several dozen Jehovah’s Witnesses still have<br />

complaints pending at the ECHR, and the government<br />

has asked them to withdraw their<br />

cases while the law is changed.<br />

Stepan Danielyan, head of the Cooperation<br />

for Democracy Centre, believes the government<br />

remains wary of changing the law, even<br />

though the ECHR ruling made it clear this<br />

was essential.<br />

“<strong>The</strong> delay stems from the fact that the<br />

Defense Ministry and the government have no<br />

clear idea about what to do with the law,”<br />

Danielyan said. “<strong>The</strong>y don’t want a conflict<br />

with the OSCE or with other international<br />

organizations. But on the other hand, passing<br />

the legal amendments could be risky because<br />

there are also other people who don’t want to<br />

do military service out of conviction.”<br />

Alexander Amaryan heads the Centre for<br />

Assistance and Rehabilitation for Victims of<br />

Destructive Sects, which is hostile to the<br />

Jehovah’s Witnesses, and he claims that conscription-age<br />

men join the group simply to get<br />

out of joining the army.<br />

“For young people who don’t want to serve<br />

in the army, the easiest way of avoiding it is to<br />

join the Jehovah’s Witnesses,” he said.<br />

<strong>The</strong> Jehovah’s Witnesses say they are happy<br />

to provide membership lists to show that this<br />

is not the case.<br />

“It isn’t that easy to become a Jehovah’s<br />

Witness,” Ispiryan said in response to the allegation<br />

of fraudulent members. “<strong>The</strong>re have<br />

been no cases of this.”<br />

Trainee priests of the <strong>Armenian</strong> Apostolic<br />

Church, the country’s main faith group, are<br />

able to avoid conscription. But church<br />

spokesman Vahram Melikyan insisted that<br />

Apostolic Church clergy should not be compared<br />

with others who decided not to join the<br />

military.<br />

In addition, he said, “<strong>The</strong>re are cases where<br />

our students don’t take up their exemption<br />

and go off to serve in the army for two years,<br />

and then return to continue their [seminary]<br />

education.”<br />

Avetik Ishkhanyan, head of the <strong>Armenian</strong><br />

Helsinki Group, said the government should<br />

focus on real draft-dodgers. Official figures<br />

show that since 2002, about 10,000 people<br />

have avoided conscription, and only 444 of<br />

them were Jehovah’s Witnesses.<br />

(Gayane Mkrtchyan is a journalist with<br />

ArmeniaNow.com. This column was written<br />

for the Institute for War and Peadce Reporting<br />

[IWPR.])<br />

Dubai Firm to Invest in<br />

<strong>Armenian</strong> Rail Project<br />

DUBAI (ConstructionWeekOnline) — A<br />

Dubai-based investment firm is to play a<br />

key role in establishing a new $3-billion<br />

high speed rail and road projects in the<br />

Republic of Armenia.<br />

Rasia, which has offices in Emirates<br />

Towers, is leading a consortium of companies<br />

which will work on the Southern<br />

Armenia Railway and Southern Armenia<br />

High Speed Road Projects, Gagik<br />

Beglaryan, minister of transport and communication,<br />

announced.<br />

He said in a statement that a tripartite<br />

memorandum of understanding has been<br />

signed between Rasia, South Caucasus<br />

Railway, and the Ministry of Transport<br />

and Communication of the Republic of<br />

Armenia.<br />

<strong>The</strong> Southern Armenia Railway is set to<br />

be a 316-kilometer-long electrified single<br />

track railway, which will connect Gavar,<br />

near Lake Sevan, to the southern border<br />

of Armenia by Meghri and will be integrated<br />

with the existing central railway<br />

system of Armenia.<br />

It will be operated by South Caucasus<br />

Railway and the operating railway system<br />

of Iran, the statement said.<br />

<strong>The</strong> Southern Armenia High Speed<br />

Road is to be constructed in the southern<br />

province of Syunik, and will be a 110-kilometer-long<br />

expressway connecting Sisian<br />

to Meghri.<br />

Both projects will play a role in improving<br />

regional connectivity, driving economic<br />

growth and creating the shortest transportation<br />

route from the ports of the<br />

Black Sea to the ports of the Gulf.<br />

“When the projects are completed,<br />

transport costs and times for the region<br />

are expected to improve substantially, fostering<br />

greater regional trade and economic<br />

growth while dramatically strengthening<br />

the <strong>Armenian</strong> economy,” the statement<br />

said.

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!