The Armenian Mirror-Spectator February 2, 2013
The Armenian Mirror-Spectator February 2, 2013
The Armenian Mirror-Spectator February 2, 2013
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
<strong>Mirror</strong>-<strong>Spectator</strong><br />
THE ARMENIAN<br />
Volume LXXXIII, NO. 29, Issue 4274<br />
ISTANBUL (Hetq) — Aris Nalci, a former<br />
editor of the Turkish-<strong>Armenian</strong> weekly,<br />
Agos, has called on Turkish authorities to<br />
launch a large-scale investigation into the<br />
F E B R U A R Y 2 , 2 0 1 3<br />
<strong>The</strong> First English Language <strong>Armenian</strong> Weekly in the United States Since 1932<br />
Archbishop Nourhan Manougian<br />
recent spate of attacks against <strong>Armenian</strong><br />
women in Istanbul.<br />
An article in Today’s Zaman this week<br />
states that Nalci does not think these successive<br />
assaults in the Samatya neighborhood<br />
are isolated incidents, but rather that<br />
they are connected.<br />
“<strong>The</strong> Police Department states these<br />
incidents are unrelated, but they generally<br />
say such things in similar incidents in order<br />
not to unsettle people. I think a climate of<br />
fear is being created in the neighborhood,”<br />
Nalci noted.<br />
Four attacks against elderly <strong>Armenian</strong><br />
women in the Samatya neighborhood of<br />
Istanbul’s Fatih district have occurred within<br />
the past two months. One of the woman,<br />
85-year-old Maritsa Küçük, was attacked in<br />
her apartment on December 28, 2012. She<br />
was brutally killed after being stabbed<br />
seven times.<br />
$ 2.00<br />
Archbishop Nourhan<br />
Manougian Elected 97th<br />
Patriarch of Jerusalem<br />
JERUSALEM — On Thursday, January 24, the<br />
members of the St. James Brotherhood elected<br />
Archbishop Nourhan Manougian as the new<br />
Patriarch of Jerusalem after a two-day conclave.<br />
Out of 33 members of the Brotherhood,<br />
Manougian was elected with 17 votes.<br />
Archbishop Aris Shirvanian, who has been serving<br />
as locum tenens, received 15 votes, with one<br />
blank vote cast.<br />
Now, Manougian’s election must be approved<br />
by the governments of Israel and Jordan.<br />
Manougian was born in Aleppo, Syria, and in<br />
1948, graduated from the local Haigazian<br />
School. He studied at the seminary of the<br />
see PATRIARCH, page 4<br />
Former Agos Editor Calls for<br />
Investigation of Istanbul Attacks<br />
Young Turk’s<br />
Grandson Speaks<br />
In Germany<br />
By Muriel Mirak-Weissbach<br />
Special to the <strong>Mirror</strong>-<strong>Spectator</strong><br />
BERLIN — In Germany, where the largest<br />
Turkish community outside of Turkey lives,<br />
there were two special events commemorating<br />
the life and work of Hrant Dink on<br />
the sixth anniversary of his death. Along<br />
with cultural events, like the performance<br />
of the play “Anne’s Silence,” there were presentations<br />
of a new book by a Turkish intellectual.<br />
This was not any intellectual, but<br />
Hasan Çemal, grandson of Çemal Pasha,<br />
one of the Young Turk triumvirs responsible<br />
for the <strong>Armenian</strong> Genocide, who spoke<br />
in front of standing-room-only crowds on<br />
January 18 in Berlin and January 21 in<br />
Cologne. <strong>The</strong> book he presented is titled<br />
1915 — Ermeni Soykirimi (1915 —<br />
Genocide against the <strong>Armenian</strong>s).<br />
More than a book presentation, his<br />
appearance in Germany was a courageous<br />
see ÇEMAL, page 4<br />
Hasan Çemal in Berlin<br />
Today’s Zaman reports that it spoke with<br />
Antranik Yontan, an <strong>Armenian</strong> living in the<br />
Samatya. Yontan told the newspaper that<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong>s have stopped speaking<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong> and that elderly <strong>Armenian</strong><br />
women are now afraid of going to the local<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong> church.<br />
“A climate of fear is prevalent around the<br />
neighborhood among the <strong>Armenian</strong> communities,”<br />
Yontan said.<br />
<strong>The</strong> Turkish press reports that police<br />
have released a sketch of the assailant of<br />
80-year-old Sultan Aykar, the latest<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong> woman to be attacked in<br />
Samatya on January 22.<br />
<strong>The</strong> sketch is based on camera footage<br />
showing a man smoking outside the building<br />
where Aykar was attacked.<br />
On Friday, the Istanbul branch of<br />
Turkey’s Human Rights Association (HRA)<br />
see INVESTIGATION, page 4<br />
From Home to ‘Homeland’ Actor Hrach<br />
Titizian Stays True to His Roots<br />
By Gabriella Gage<br />
<strong>Mirror</strong>-<strong>Spectator</strong> Staff<br />
LOS ANGELES — What<br />
do “Homeland,” “24,”<br />
“Mad Men,” all have in<br />
common? Each has won a<br />
Golden Globe for Best<br />
Drama Series and each<br />
has featured actor Hrach<br />
Titizian.<br />
In addition to appearing<br />
in some of the most<br />
popular television series<br />
of the past decade,<br />
Titizian has appeared on<br />
Broadway and several<br />
films such as “Float” and “<strong>The</strong> Men<br />
Who Stare at Goats.” Titizian takes his<br />
new-found popularity in stride and<br />
instead dedicates himself to his work.<br />
Raised in Glendale’s thriving<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong> community, Titizian says that<br />
Hrach Tatizian of “Homeland”<br />
his <strong>Armenian</strong> heritage helped shape<br />
him as an individual. “My parents are<br />
both full-blooded <strong>Armenian</strong>. My father<br />
was born in Lebanon and my mother in<br />
Jordan. Although I was born and raised<br />
see TITIZIAN, page 8<br />
NEWS INBRIEF<br />
Armenia Participates<br />
In Swiss Astronomy<br />
Conference<br />
GENEVA (Armenpress) — Armenia participated in<br />
the conference of the European Astronomical<br />
Society (EAS), which was held recently in<br />
Switzerland. <strong>The</strong> EAS leaders, heads of the astronomical<br />
societies of European countries and representatives<br />
of other European scientific organizations<br />
attended the conference. Such conferences<br />
also were held in 2008 in Holland and in 2012 in<br />
Switzerland. <strong>The</strong> goal of this meeting was to sum<br />
up the results of the last year, discuss future plans,<br />
continue active cooperation with national organizations,<br />
as well as to reinforce the leading role of<br />
the European astronomy.<br />
<strong>The</strong> co-founder of <strong>Armenian</strong> Astronomical<br />
Society, Areg Mirakyan, took part in the conference<br />
and delivered a report on his group’s activities in<br />
the past year and possible ways for cooperating<br />
with the EAS .<br />
Leaders of astronomical societies from Austria,<br />
Spain, Italy, Greece, Great Britain, Switzerland, the<br />
Czech Republic, Portugal, Russia, Serbia, Ukraine<br />
and France delivered reports on the current state<br />
of astronomy in different countries.<br />
OSCE Minsk Group<br />
Meets with <strong>Armenian</strong>,<br />
Azerbaijani Officials<br />
PARIS (ArmeniaNow) — Co-Chairs of the<br />
Organization for Security and Cooperation in<br />
Europe (OSCE) Minsk Group, Ambassadors Igor<br />
Popov of the Russia, Jacques Faure of France and<br />
Ian Kelly of the US, met jointly with the Foreign<br />
Minister of Armenia Eduard Nalbandian and<br />
Foreign Minister of Azerbaijan Elmar<br />
Mammadyarov, on January 28.<br />
<strong>The</strong> personal representative of the OSCE<br />
Chairperson-in-Office, Ambassador Andrzej<br />
Kasprzyk, also attended the meeting.<br />
“<strong>The</strong> co-chairs continued discussions with the<br />
ministers on the working proposal to advance<br />
the peace process, which they submitted to the<br />
sides in October 2012. <strong>The</strong>y also exchanged<br />
views on possible confidence building measures,”<br />
according to a statement posted on the<br />
OSCE’s website.<br />
<strong>The</strong> co-chairs referred to their statements of April<br />
14, 2011, and July 13, 2012, and discussed with the<br />
ministers issues pertaining to civilian flights to and<br />
from the airport in Nagorno-Karabagh.<br />
“<strong>The</strong> foreign ministers and the co-chairs stressed<br />
the importance of the OSCE Minsk Group as the<br />
framework for negotiating a settlement of the<br />
Nagorno-Karabagh conflict. <strong>The</strong> foreign ministers<br />
reiterated their support for a peaceful settlement<br />
and their determination to continue negotiations.<br />
<strong>The</strong> ministers and the co-chairs agreed to a further<br />
discussion of the peace process in the coming<br />
weeks,” the statement added.<br />
INSIDE<br />
Sotheby’s<br />
Auction Page 11<br />
INDEX<br />
Arts and Living . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10<br />
Armenia . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2<br />
Community News. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5<br />
Editorial . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14<br />
International . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3, 4
2<br />
News From Armenia<br />
Minasian Remembered<br />
At National Library<br />
YEREVAN (Hetq) — A day of remembranccee for the<br />
late Levon Minasian, the noted Iranian-<strong>Armenian</strong><br />
teacher, academic and national activist, was held on<br />
January 22 at the National Library of Armenia.<br />
For more than seven decades, Minasian headed<br />
vaariious educcaattiionaall iinsttiittuttiioonns in Nor Jughaa aand<br />
published works on <strong>Armenian</strong> history and literature,<br />
including AA HHiissttoorryy ooff tthhee AArrmmeenniiaannss ooff PPeerraa<br />
and TThhee AArrmmeenniiaann BBaarrddss ooff PPeerraa.<br />
Gor Sujyan to Represent<br />
Armenia at Eurovision<br />
YEREVAN (Armenpress) — Singer Gor Sujyan will<br />
represent Armenia in the Eurovision <strong>2013</strong> song<br />
contest taking place in Malmö, Sweden, on May 14.<br />
SSuujyann is allso a member ooff Doriianns,, the rock<br />
band that had planned on representing Armenia in<br />
“Eurovision 2012,” until Armenia withdrew from<br />
the competition due to security concerns.<br />
Sujiyan was born in July 25, 1987, in Yerevan. He<br />
is the son of guitarist, jazzman Mkrtich Sujiyan.<br />
On March 2, Armenia will hold its national finals<br />
tto sellect tthe winning song. SSujyan wiill peerfform all<br />
of the songs and television viewers and a panel of<br />
experts will vote on the winning entry.<br />
CSTO Academy to Open<br />
In Armenia in <strong>2013</strong><br />
YEREVAN (PanARMENIAN.Net) — Collective<br />
Security Treaty Organization (CSTO) Secretary<br />
General Nikolai Bordyuzha and National Security<br />
Council (NSC) Secretary Artur Baghdasaryan<br />
signed a meemorandum of unndersttannddiing oonn creation<br />
of a CSTO Academy in Armenia.<br />
According to Bordyuzha, the academy, as a scientific,<br />
educational and analytical center, will train<br />
experts to be further involved in CSTO activities.<br />
Baghdasaryan stressed the importance of the<br />
proposed academy, expressing hope for the latter to<br />
be launched during the current year.<br />
Feast of St. Sarkis<br />
Restored as Tradition<br />
YEREVAN (Armenpress) — Exhibitions dedicated to<br />
the feast of St. Sarkis have opened in the Yerevan<br />
National Centre of Aesthetics and Artists’ Union.<br />
Prime Minister Tigran Sargisian attended the exhibitions.<br />
<strong>The</strong> Press Service of the premier’s office reported<br />
that in the Yerevan National Centre of<br />
Aesthetics hosted an exhibition of works by the students<br />
at the center’s drawing studio.<br />
Sargisian congratulated the attendees on the<br />
occasion of the Feast of St. Sarkis and stated:<br />
“Each year this feast is being celebrated in a bigger<br />
fashion in the Republic of Armenia and more people<br />
are being involved in the celebrations. I am glad<br />
that the Feast of St. Sarkis is being restored as a<br />
national tradition and spreading among the<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong>s.”<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong> Chess<br />
Federation Hosts FIDE<br />
TSAKHKADZOR, Armenia (Radiolur) — President<br />
of the World Chess Federation (FIDE) Kirsan<br />
Ilyumzhinov last month held a conference in<br />
Tsakhkadzor, featuring 23 members of FIDE and<br />
representatives from the chess federations of 20<br />
countries.<br />
During the conference, Ilyumzhinov said that the<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong> Chess Federation serves an example for<br />
the 177 FIDE member states. As such, Armenia was<br />
unanimously chosen as the host country for the<br />
conference.<br />
<strong>The</strong> assembled discussed the Chess in Schools<br />
Program first implemented in Armenia.<br />
Also in attendance was President Serge Sargisian<br />
who said, “Chess is one of the best means of dialogue<br />
between cultures and civilizations. It’s our duty to<br />
cherish and disseminate the tradition of chess.”<br />
S A T U R D A Y, F E B R U A R Y 2 , 2 0 1 3 T H E A R M E N I A N M I R R O R - S P E C TAT O R<br />
ARMENIA<br />
Tekeyan Centre Fund Renovates Yerevan School<br />
YEREVAN — Tekeyan Centre Fund<br />
had a busy 2012 and welcomed the<br />
New Year with a few new projects.<br />
Among them was a photographic art<br />
exhibition named “Today I am a pure<br />
soul,” by Zherar Agavelyan, an<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong> film director born in Armenia<br />
and now living in the US. <strong>The</strong> exhibition<br />
included photographs mixed with<br />
collages.<br />
<strong>The</strong> fund sponsored the two-week<br />
exhibition by holding it at Tekeyan<br />
Centre. <strong>The</strong> official opening with many<br />
art critics and guests present started<br />
with the Fund Chairman Vartan<br />
Ouzounian’s welcoming speech.<br />
Ouzounian emphasized the importance<br />
of such events in the national and spiritual<br />
life of <strong>Armenian</strong>s.<br />
<strong>The</strong> fund’s last scholastic project of<br />
2012 involved Yerevan Tekeyan School<br />
#92. Thanks to Hrad Darian of London,<br />
a benefactor who donated 9,000<br />
pounds sterling to the fund, Tekeyan<br />
Centre was able to renovate all the windows<br />
of the school building (Block A) to<br />
keep it warm in cold weather. <strong>The</strong> fund<br />
had also fixed the gas supply to the<br />
school, which had previously caused<br />
interruptions to the heat there. <strong>The</strong><br />
Yerevan Municipality took up the fund’s<br />
Women’s Football (Soccer) Lags in Armenia<br />
By Vahe Sarukhanyan<br />
YEREVAN (Hetq) — Armenia’s<br />
Football Federation (AFF) has decided<br />
against sending women’s football<br />
teams to the European championships.<br />
In the past, the girls’ 17- and 19-yearold<br />
teams participated in the world<br />
championships. <strong>The</strong> women’s national<br />
squad used to play in the European<br />
and World Championships.<br />
<strong>The</strong> national team has played 20<br />
qualifying games in the European<br />
Championship, only winning two. <strong>The</strong>y<br />
lost 15 and three were draws.<br />
In the world championship, the team<br />
played eight and lost them all.<br />
Armenia’s national women’s football<br />
team first played in 2003 and lost 11-0<br />
against Austria. <strong>Armenian</strong> women footballers<br />
have played eight games in the<br />
UEFA <strong>2013</strong> European Championship<br />
and have lost all by large margins.<br />
<strong>The</strong>y have only scored two goals and<br />
have let in 44. <strong>The</strong> same numbers also<br />
apply to the teen teams.<br />
<strong>The</strong> reasons are clear. Women’s football<br />
in Armenia has never been placed<br />
on a firm footing. During the last years<br />
of the Soviet Union and after independence,<br />
when women’s football had just<br />
been introduced, the teams “Nairi,”<br />
“Nork” and Aparan’s “Nig” were<br />
famous. <strong>The</strong>se, however, never registered<br />
any great success and couldn’t<br />
have, given that women’s football was<br />
Students at the Yerevan School during contest<br />
initiative and sponsored the project for<br />
Block B.<br />
Thanks to Darian’s donation,<br />
Tekeyan Centre was also able to repair<br />
the school library which was named<br />
Stephan Darakjian Library in memory<br />
From Left, TCA President Vartan Ouzounian, Principal Tsovinar Mardanyan, UK<br />
Ambassador in Armenia Kathy Leach and Archbishop Vahan Hovhannesian<br />
of the benefactor’s grandfather. Present<br />
at the official opening of the library<br />
were Bishop Vahan Hovhanessian,<br />
a new feature in the Soviet Union in<br />
the late 1980s. Things got worse in the<br />
1990s. It is of note that only the teams<br />
“Banants” and “Koledj” have been<br />
playing in recent years.<br />
<strong>The</strong> reason that the national teams<br />
have been so weak is the near absence<br />
of club teams and because there is no<br />
women’s championship in Armenia. At<br />
the core of the problem, however, is<br />
the national mentality. As a result, few<br />
girls try out for football. In addition,<br />
there are no finances invested. During<br />
an event held at the end of last year<br />
Primate of the <strong>Armenian</strong> Church in the<br />
UK and Ireland, the UK Ambassador to<br />
Armenia Katherine Leach, fund chair<br />
Ouzounian, fund director Armen<br />
Tsulikyan, and many other guests.<br />
After the official ceremony and the<br />
speeches followed by a cultural program<br />
performed by the schoolchildren<br />
and a reception, the principal of the<br />
school, Tsovinar Mardanyan, showed<br />
the visiting dignitaries round the<br />
school and detailed and thanked the<br />
fund.<br />
On January 21, Tekeyan Centre Fund<br />
launched its first interscholastic project<br />
of <strong>2013</strong> to celebrate the 135th anniversary<br />
of the <strong>Armenian</strong> poet, pedagogue<br />
and political leader, Vahan Tekeyan, for<br />
whom the school is named. <strong>The</strong> project<br />
titled “Poetry Reading Festival” conducted<br />
by journalist Marieta Makaryan,<br />
includes three levels of competition<br />
which will be finalized on April 4, to<br />
commemorate the poet’s death.<br />
Schoolchildren ages 10-18 from all<br />
Vahan Tekeyan Schools in Armenia and<br />
Artsakh as well as literature teachers are<br />
going to take part in the competition.<br />
<strong>The</strong> aim of the project is to immortalize<br />
and to introduce the great poet’s<br />
life and his rich literary heritage to the<br />
young generation.<br />
where UEFA representatives were present,<br />
Marina Tashchyan, the head of<br />
the National Teams, noted that the<br />
AFF had been right in placing an<br />
emphasis on the younger girls. She<br />
said that Armenia now has five girls’<br />
teams.<br />
Sadly, in September 2011, AFF<br />
President Ruben Hayrapetyan said<br />
the following in response to a question<br />
about women’s football:<br />
“Women’s football in Armenia hasn’t<br />
developed nor will it. I have no desire<br />
to promote it.”<br />
Heifer Armenia Provides Equipment,<br />
Training to Small Dairy Producers<br />
YEREVAN — Heifer International’s Armenia program, working in collaboration<br />
with other international institutions, has provided more than<br />
104 pieces of agricultural equipment to 33 farm cooperatives through the<br />
Community Agricultural Resource Management and Competitiveness<br />
(CARMAC) project. Distributions of the agricultural equipment followed<br />
pasture management trainings in several regions of Armenia. <strong>The</strong>se training<br />
programs enable the farmers to make the best use of their land and<br />
provide better fodder for livestock. “Now everything is easier; we are able<br />
to do all the work on schedule,” said Gevorg Galstyan, president of the<br />
Nerqin Tsaghkavan Community Cooperative. “Before we got the equipment,<br />
we might have harvested only 30 percent of our optimal yield. Now<br />
we don’t face such problems any longer.”<br />
<strong>The</strong> objective of the CARMAC project is to reverse environmental damage<br />
caused by unsustainable grazing, increase the economic viability of<br />
small farms through infrastructure improvements and increase productivity<br />
to reach more markets.
S A T U R D A Y, F E B R U A R Y 2 , 2 0 1 3 T H E A R M E N I A N M I R R O R - S P E C TAT O R 3<br />
INTERNATIONAL<br />
Religious Leaders Join in Call for<br />
Two-State Solution in Middle East<br />
By Arthur Hagopian<br />
JERUSALEM — Leading figures<br />
among the <strong>Armenian</strong> and Greek<br />
Orthodox ecumenical movement in<br />
the US have joined a pride of other<br />
leaders of Christian, Moslem and<br />
Jewish religious and lay organizations<br />
and institutions, pledging to mobilize<br />
support for peace in the Middle East.<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong> Archbishop Vicken<br />
Aykazian, the director of ecumenical<br />
affairs for <strong>Armenian</strong> Orthodox<br />
Church in America Father Mark Arey,<br />
the director of the Office of<br />
Ecumenical Affairs for the Greek<br />
Orthodox Archdiocese of America,<br />
believe time is running out for both<br />
Israelis and Palestinians.<br />
<strong>The</strong> loose umbrella of the US<br />
National Interreligious Leadership<br />
Initiative (NILI) for Peace in the<br />
Middle East , which includes<br />
<strong>The</strong>odore Cardinal McCarrick,<br />
Archbishop Emeritus of Washington,<br />
Imam Mohammed Magid, President,<br />
Islamic Society of North America, and<br />
Rabbi Peter Knobel, past president,<br />
Central Conference of American<br />
Rabbis, warns that the possibility of a<br />
two-state solution to the Israeli-<br />
Palestinian conflict was waning, and<br />
urged immediate, sustained US leadership<br />
before darkness falls on the<br />
hopes for a peaceful resolution.”<br />
Among the other leaders are<br />
Kathryn Mary Lohre, president,<br />
National Council of Churches of<br />
Christ (US) and Richard Stearns,<br />
president, World Vision US.<br />
Aykazian was in Jerusalem last<br />
week to participate in the elections<br />
for a new <strong>Armenian</strong> patriarch and<br />
had been one of the contenders for<br />
the position.<br />
<strong>The</strong> group believes the most viable<br />
solution to the Arab-Israeli conflict is<br />
a two-state agreement that provides<br />
for a secure and recognized Israel living<br />
in peace alongside a viable and<br />
independent Palestinian state.<br />
“With the support of the international<br />
community, Israelis and<br />
Palestinians can achieve a lasting<br />
peace. A new dawn is<br />
possible,” they said in a<br />
statement they released.<br />
Mourning the lives<br />
lost and shattered during<br />
the recent violence<br />
that gripped the region,<br />
the group warned that<br />
what had been seen,<br />
over the past years, “will<br />
keep happening if movement<br />
towards a viable<br />
two state-solution continues<br />
to stagnate.”<br />
As things stand now,<br />
“the status quo is unsustainable<br />
and dangerous to both<br />
Israelis and Palestinians,” they conceded,<br />
but stressed now is not the<br />
time for “another cycle of recriminations.<br />
It is time to break the cycle of<br />
violence with bold initiatives for<br />
peace.”<br />
“<strong>The</strong> current dangerous stalemate,<br />
including the legacy of past failed<br />
peacemaking efforts, undermines our<br />
security and that of others, destabilizes<br />
the region, fuels terrorism and<br />
extremism, allows continuing Israeli<br />
settlement expansion and prolongs<br />
Palestinian disunity. <strong>The</strong>se realities<br />
and the absence of negotiations<br />
threaten to kill the prospect of a<br />
viable two-state peace agreement, the<br />
only realistic solution to the conflict,”<br />
they said.<br />
<strong>The</strong>y urged strong and determined<br />
action, proposing a peace of the<br />
brave, because as people of faith, “we<br />
proclaim that we should never underestimate<br />
what is possible.”<br />
“We know the challenges are<br />
daunting, but we believe a bold new<br />
initiative for an Israeli-Palestinian<br />
peace settlement should be an immediate<br />
priority of the new<br />
[US] Administration in<br />
<strong>2013</strong>. We fear the<br />
opportunity for a peaceful<br />
resolution is rapidly<br />
waning and the current<br />
stagnation encourages<br />
the rejectionists on<br />
both sides,” the statement<br />
said.<br />
<strong>The</strong>y noted that the<br />
US “has unique lever-<br />
age and credibility in<br />
the region” and that no<br />
past progress towards<br />
peace has occurred in<br />
the Arab-Israeli conflict without US<br />
leadership, facilitation or staunch<br />
support.<br />
“Once again, we need active, fair<br />
and firm US leadership to help break<br />
the current deadlock and to achieve a<br />
two-state peace agreement now<br />
before it is too late,” they added.<br />
<strong>The</strong>y pledged to mobilize the<br />
strong support that exists in churches,<br />
synagogues and mosques across<br />
the US, in the push for peace.<br />
“Twilight is upon us; but the<br />
hope for a new dawn remains. Let<br />
us together bring the new light of<br />
hope and work for negotiations<br />
leading to a final status agreement,”<br />
they added.<br />
Tinderbox Next Door: Growing Ethnic<br />
Protests in Azerbaijan may ‘Detonate’ War<br />
By Naira Hayrumyan<br />
ISMAYILLI, Azerbaijan<br />
(ArmeniaNow) — <strong>The</strong> wave of protests<br />
that struck Azerbaijan last week may<br />
act as a detonator for military conflict in<br />
the South Caucasus.<br />
<strong>The</strong> incident is reminiscent of the<br />
beginning of the Arab Spring, says head<br />
of the Analytical Center on<br />
Globalization and Regional<br />
Cooperation, political analyst Stepan<br />
Grigoryan.<br />
“It is possible that the Azerbaijani<br />
side will try to escalate the situation<br />
along the line of contact of the armed<br />
forces of Nagorno-Karabagh and<br />
Azerbaijan,” Grigoryan said.<br />
Andrei Areshev of the Center for<br />
Central Asia Studies and Caucasus<br />
Institute of Oriental Studies of the<br />
Russian Academy of Sciences agreed<br />
that Azerbaijani authorities will attempt<br />
to redirect the anger of the society<br />
towards Karabagh.<br />
“<strong>The</strong> authorities will agitate patriotic<br />
feelings among people to shift their<br />
attention from internal problems to the<br />
‘enemies’, and in Azerbaijan, <strong>Armenian</strong>s<br />
and Karabagh are considered to be<br />
these enemies,” he said.<br />
Protesters in Ismayilli burned a car<br />
and a hotel owned by representatives of<br />
the leading party’s clan. This caused a<br />
wave of protests across the country,<br />
eventually reaching the capital, Baku.<br />
It is worth noting that this occurred on<br />
the same day that Mexico City authorities<br />
dismantled the monument to former<br />
President Heydar Aliyev. This served as a<br />
major blow to the credibility of the Aliyev<br />
regime and also as a sign that the West<br />
may seek to dismantle the regime.<br />
It seems likely that the West and the<br />
local opposition will be make moves to<br />
change the regime in the upcoming<br />
elections, given several conflicts<br />
between oil companies and the regime.<br />
Last year saw a conflict between Aliyev<br />
and British Petroleum, which is the<br />
main investor in the oil sector of<br />
Azerbaijan. Rumors that oil reserves in<br />
the region were dwindling cast further<br />
doubts about the Aliyev regime’s ability<br />
For Your Internal News of Armenia<br />
Log on to www.AZG.am<br />
In English, <strong>Armenian</strong>, Russian and Turkish<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong> Archbishop<br />
Vicken Aykazian<br />
to manage its natural resources.<br />
On January 27, the police forbid Isa<br />
Gambar, the leader of the main opposition<br />
party Musavat, to enter the city of<br />
Lankaran in the south of Azerbaijan.<br />
Two weeks prior, a Gambar motorcade<br />
was also attacked at the entrance to<br />
Lankaran by assailants allegedly trained<br />
by the Aliyev authorities.<br />
Lankaran, like Guba and Ismayilli, is a<br />
Lezghian-populated region of<br />
Azerbaijan. Experts say the reactivation<br />
of the Lezghian national movement in<br />
Azerbaijan poses a serious threat to the<br />
Aliyev regime. If the national movements<br />
of the Lezghians and Talyshes,<br />
Iranian peoples who have lived in<br />
Turkic Azerbaijan since 1918, gain<br />
momentum, it could lead to the collapse<br />
of the Azerbaijani state. It is this very<br />
threat that is causing Aliyev to embark<br />
on a military gamble in Karabagh by<br />
unleashing a war against the de-facto<br />
independent republic.<br />
South Caucasus geopolitics expert,<br />
Anzhela Elibegova, said that the<br />
Kurdish component should not be forgotten<br />
when assessing the overall conflict.<br />
“<strong>The</strong> Azerbaijani opposition media<br />
write regularly that Kurds in Azerbaijan<br />
enjoy ‘special’ rights. In Nakhichevan,<br />
the conventional homeland of Heydar<br />
Aliyev, the majority of the population<br />
today are Kurds, but during the years of<br />
the Aliyev rule they have settled on<br />
lands historically inhabited by the<br />
Talyshes and Lezgins,” said Elibegova.<br />
International News<br />
Aronian Takes Second<br />
Place at Tata Steel<br />
WIJK AAN ZEE, Netherlands (ArmeniaNow) —<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong> grandmaster Levon Aronian said his second-place<br />
performance at the Tata Steel<br />
Tournament in the Netherlands last week was a<br />
“good result.”<br />
<strong>The</strong> GGrouup A Touurnaament bbrouught together 14<br />
grandmasters and ended in a victory by the topranked<br />
player in the world, Magnus Carlsen, of<br />
Norway. Finishing second, Aronian, currently the<br />
world’s number three player, outdid Viswanathan<br />
Anand from India.<br />
“Remembering the positions I would have [duringg<br />
some of the ggames] at the tournament, I can’’t<br />
say that I am very satisfied with my performance.<br />
Though I really missed several important [opportunities,]<br />
second place is quite a good result,” said<br />
Aronian.<br />
Ukrainian Museum of<br />
National History Hosts<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong> Exhibit<br />
KIEV, Ukraine (Pan<strong>Armenian</strong>.net) — <strong>The</strong> Ukrainian<br />
Museum of National History is showcasing an<br />
exhibit documenting the history of UUkraine’s<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong> community.<br />
<strong>The</strong> exposition includes rare photographs, documents,<br />
awards, printed editions, national costumes,<br />
household items and other artifacts reflecting the<br />
Ukrainian-<strong>Armenian</strong>s’ long history.<br />
<strong>The</strong> leader of the Union of <strong>Armenian</strong>s of Ukraine,<br />
Vilen Shatvoryan, said of the exhibit, “Kiev attaches<br />
special importance to <strong>Armenian</strong> cultural and historic<br />
heritage.”<br />
<strong>The</strong> number of <strong>Armenian</strong>s in Ukraine totals<br />
99,894 according to the 2001 Ukrainian census.<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong>s first appeared in Ukraine during the<br />
Kievan Rus period. During the 10th century, individual<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong> merchants, mercenaries and<br />
craftsmen served in the courts of various<br />
Ruthenian rulers.<br />
he Donetsk Oblast (province) holds the greatest<br />
number of <strong>Armenian</strong>s in Ukraine.<br />
Azeri Forces Hold Drills<br />
On Karabagh Border,<br />
Violate Ceasefire<br />
BAKU (PanARMENIAN.Net) — Nearly 200 instances<br />
of ceasefire violation by Azeri armed forces were<br />
reported at the line of contact between Nagorno<br />
Karabagh and Azerbaijan from January 20 to 26.<br />
Azerbaijan fired over 700 shots from various caliber<br />
weapons in the direction of Karabagh positions,<br />
NKR defense army’s press service reports.<br />
Also, all through the last week, Azeri air forces<br />
conducted drills along the line of contact.<br />
Former President<br />
Aliyev’s Statue Removed<br />
From Mexico City Park<br />
MEXICO CITY (PanARMENIAN.Net) — A life-size<br />
bronze statue of Azerbaijan’s former president,<br />
Heydar Aliyev ,was removed from Mexico City’s<br />
main avenue, on Saturday, January 26 morning. It<br />
was instead relocated to a site in the suburbs.<br />
In November, an advisory commission issued a<br />
recommendation to remove the statue. <strong>The</strong> rights<br />
groups said they were offended by a monument of<br />
a “dictator” erected in one of the busiest areas in<br />
the city.<br />
Azerbaijan has paid around $5 million for the<br />
renovation of part of Chapultepec Park, where the<br />
statue is was installed, and other public works.<br />
<strong>The</strong> protesters have objected to Aliyev’s statue<br />
saying that he was an authoritarian figure, who led<br />
Azerbaijan first as Communist Party boss during<br />
Soviet times and then as president from 1993 until<br />
his death in 2003.<br />
Baku warned earlier of damage to Azerbaijan’s<br />
relations with Mexico if the statue is removed,<br />
including the potential cuts to Azerbaijani investments<br />
in Mexico.
4<br />
By Hrant Gadarigian<br />
ISTANBUL (Hetq) — To get a better insight<br />
into the recent attacks against elderly <strong>Armenian</strong><br />
women in Istanbul, Hetq contacted Fethiye<br />
Çetin, a prominent lawyer and human rights<br />
S A T U R D A Y, F E B R U A R Y 2 , 2 0 1 3 T H E A R M E N I A N M I R R O R - S P E C TAT O R<br />
advocate working in Turkey.<br />
Çetin has served as an attorney for the family<br />
of Hrant Dink and is the author of My<br />
Grandmother, a book describing how and when<br />
she found out about her <strong>Armenian</strong> roots.<br />
Hrant Gadarigian (HG): Recently, former<br />
Agos Editor Aris Nalci told Today’s Zaman that<br />
he believed these attacks were organized and<br />
called on Turkish officials to launch a comprehensive<br />
investigation. Would you agree with his<br />
assessment?<br />
Fethiye Çetin (FÇ): I would also agree that<br />
these actions are organized and planned. At<br />
first, the police promoted the line that they<br />
were violent robberies, however no such evidence<br />
was to be found in the homes of the victims.<br />
In addition, witnesses claim that the<br />
attackers always had an accomplice or two nearby.<br />
We have been focusing our attention on<br />
Samatya of late, but it must be said that attacks<br />
directed against Christians have been occurring<br />
all over the country as well. <strong>The</strong> latest was the<br />
exposure of an organized gang that attempted<br />
to murder a Christian priest in Kocaeli. All this<br />
attests to the fact that the events are systematic<br />
in nature and not random.<br />
HG: Being close to certain segments of the<br />
Istanbul-<strong>Armenian</strong> community, how would you<br />
describe the emotional state within the community<br />
in light of these incidents?<br />
INTERNATIONAL<br />
Young Turk’s Grandson in Germany<br />
ÇEMAL, from page 1<br />
intervention into the dialogue process<br />
among Turks, Germans, <strong>Armenian</strong>s and<br />
Kurds about the Genocide, aimed at working<br />
through the common past in the search for<br />
truth and, thereby, for understanding and<br />
reconciliation. Ilyas Kevork Uyar, chairman<br />
of the Diocese Board of the <strong>Armenian</strong><br />
Church and also defense lawyer for the<br />
Turkish-German author Dogan Akhanli,<br />
introduced him at Cologne university, saying<br />
he hoped that Çemal’s experience, as someone<br />
who has worked through the past and<br />
acknowledged the genocide of 1.5 million<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong>s, would serve as an example for<br />
others to follow. Not only in Turkey, he said,<br />
did denial persist but also in Germany, where<br />
certain nationalistic Turkish associations<br />
have organized protests against the<br />
“<strong>Armenian</strong> lies,” etc.<br />
Hasan Çemal, speaking in German, introduced<br />
himself to the audience of about 400<br />
Germans mainly of Turkish and <strong>Armenian</strong><br />
descent, then read a speech in Turkish which<br />
was simultaneously translated by Osman<br />
Okkam, journalist, film maker and<br />
spokesman for the KulturForum<br />
TürkeiDeutschland, which had sponsored the<br />
event. <strong>The</strong> subject was how to liberate oneself<br />
from falsified history, a process that is intimately<br />
tied to one’s sense of personal identity.<br />
Çemal cited cases of two of his associates,<br />
who did not dare admit that their mothers<br />
were <strong>Armenian</strong> and Kurdish, respectively.<br />
That two of the best writers in Turkey had to<br />
lie about their mothers’ ethnic background,<br />
he said, was very sad; the Kurds “had to fight<br />
to prove that they existed, whereas the<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong>s had to fight to prove that they<br />
had been eliminated.” In the case of the<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong>s it was not only the physical elimi-<br />
Archbishop Nourhan<br />
Manougian Elected 97th<br />
Patriarch of Jerusalem<br />
PATRIARCH, from page 1<br />
Catholicosate of Cilicia in Antelias, Lebanon. In<br />
1966, he was accepted to the theological seminary<br />
of the <strong>Armenian</strong> Patriarchate of<br />
Jerusalem. His days as a student at the<br />
Patriarchate culminated in his ordination to the<br />
priesthood and his membership in the St. James<br />
Brotherhood in 1971.<br />
A year later, he was appointed the pastor of<br />
the <strong>Armenian</strong>s of Switzerland. Subsequently, he<br />
returned to the Middle East and served as the<br />
pastor to the <strong>Armenian</strong> communities of Jaffa<br />
and Haifa. In 1980, he was assigned the position<br />
of pastor of the <strong>Armenian</strong> community of<br />
Holland.<br />
Manougian visited the US and pursued his<br />
graduate studies at New York’s General<br />
<strong>The</strong>ological Seminary. He subsequently served<br />
the Eastern Diocese as the pastor of St. Mark<br />
Church of Springfield, Mass., and then St.<br />
Kevork Church of Houston, Texas.<br />
Upon returning to Jerusalem, Manougian was<br />
elected Grand Sacristan of the Holy See in<br />
1998. A year later, Catholicos of All <strong>Armenian</strong>s<br />
Karekin II elevated him to the rank of bishop.<br />
(Editor’s note: We congratulate Archbishop<br />
Manougian on being elected the 97th Patriarch<br />
of the Holy See of Jerusalem and wish him<br />
every success in his challenging mission.)<br />
nation of the people but also the “cultural<br />
assassination,” whereby official Turkish history<br />
makes no reference to the existence of<br />
their civilization.<br />
Falsified history began with the birth of<br />
the modern Turkish republic, which was no<br />
state founded on the rule of law, but a place<br />
where everyone was forced to lie. Though he<br />
was a 1965 graduate in political science, he<br />
had been totally ignorant of the facts of 1915-<br />
1916. He did not know that the <strong>Armenian</strong>s<br />
had populated the territory earlier, nor that<br />
there had been Kurdish rebellions. It was<br />
only in 2005, when a conference on the<br />
Kurdish issue was convened, that one could<br />
talk about it. <strong>The</strong>n and thereafter, it was forbidden<br />
however to utter the name Dersim,<br />
where an uprising had been brutally suppressed.<br />
<strong>The</strong> situation he described was characterized<br />
by “fear, fear of history, fear of phantoms;”<br />
no one dared to challenge official historiography<br />
for fear of being labeled a “traitor.”<br />
One friend who had done so and been<br />
labeled a traitor was Taner Akçam, the leading<br />
Turkish scholar of the Genocide. Akçam<br />
had insisted on questioning the taboos, prejudices<br />
and clichés, and overcoming them.<br />
Çemal then gave a personal account of his<br />
struggle to deal with the taboos. At the end<br />
of March 2011, he was at UCLA, preparing a<br />
speech for a conference. While sitting at his<br />
computer, he asked himself, “Should I use<br />
the word ‘genocide’ or not?” He wanted to<br />
speak of <strong>Armenian</strong>s’ fears and pain and to<br />
express his empathy. “But what pain? From<br />
‘genocide’ or in general?” he asked himself.<br />
“Why was it so difficult to use this word?” He<br />
knew, he said, that the Committee of Unity<br />
and Progress, the Young Turks, had<br />
embraced a policy to remove all non-Turks<br />
INVESTIGATION, from page 1<br />
claimed that the recent attacks on Turkish<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong> women in Samatya weren’t motivated<br />
by robbery.<br />
In its report on the attacks, the HRA said<br />
they could be part of an “ethnic cleansing” campaign<br />
and called for the immediate apprehension<br />
of the culprits.<br />
<strong>The</strong> organization has sent its report to the<br />
Turkish Ministry of the Interior.<br />
Meanwhile, Agos editor Rober Koptas told<br />
from the Ottoman Empire. “I knew it. Why<br />
didn’t I want to use ‘genocide’ if I knew this?”<br />
he asked. He put in the word “genocide,” but<br />
then erased it.<br />
His confrontation with this loaded term<br />
had a history. Earlier, in 2008, he had travelled<br />
to Yerevan and visited the Genocide<br />
monument to pay his respects to the memory<br />
of Hrant Dink. He had contemplated the<br />
profound emotions felt at sundown, when<br />
reflecting on the pain of the <strong>Armenian</strong> victims,<br />
and, at sunrise, had realized “how<br />
absurd it was to deny genocide.” In March<br />
2011, in Los Angeles, the process went further.<br />
“I had mentioned the Young Turks and<br />
their crimes against humanity. I was convinced<br />
of the need to stop denial, but I still<br />
hesitated to use the term.” He asked himself<br />
if it was fear. <strong>The</strong>n he reflected on his age.<br />
“How old am I and how long do I have left to<br />
fight for democracy?” he asked. “How long<br />
do I have not to use this word?” <strong>The</strong>n, he<br />
related, “I put in the word. I wrote: ‘I know<br />
your pain from the Genocide.’”<br />
He characterized the phenomenon as “selfviolence,”<br />
a well-known psychological phenomenon.<br />
“We need to deal with prejudices,”<br />
he said and referenced the historical precedents<br />
in Germany, the “best example to<br />
understand taboos and also liberation from<br />
them.” He concluded his speech with an<br />
appeal, “that the truth may come to light.”<br />
During the question-and-answer session, he<br />
elaborated on the German precedent, recalling<br />
the decisive role played by the so-called<br />
‘68er generation of youth who confronted<br />
their parents about their roles under Nazism.<br />
He also highlighted the gesture of Willy<br />
Brandt, who in 1970, fell to his knees before<br />
the Warsaw Ghetto monument, to express<br />
acknowledgement and regret for the crimes<br />
FÇ: <strong>The</strong>se attacks have created fear and anxiety<br />
for <strong>Armenian</strong>s and Christians living in<br />
Turkey. An <strong>Armenian</strong> woman living in the<br />
Samatya neighborhood responded to a Milliyet<br />
reporter by stating, “Let us die in our beds.”<br />
<strong>The</strong>se few words clearly describe the emotional<br />
state of <strong>Armenian</strong>s.<br />
HG: If the attacks are indeed premeditated<br />
Today’s Zaman that the ministry should establish<br />
a commission to conduct a comprehensive<br />
investigation of the matter.<br />
“None of the politicians and state officials has<br />
released any statement on the issue yet, which<br />
also increases the concerns of the <strong>Armenian</strong>s<br />
living in Samatya. <strong>The</strong> interior minister, the<br />
Istanbul governor or the Istanbul police chief<br />
should give detailed information to the public<br />
regarding these incidents,” Koptas said.<br />
Garo Paylan, an <strong>Armenian</strong> community<br />
of Nazi Germany. When asked about his own<br />
family and how they dealt with his grandfather’s<br />
role, he said his family was very apolitical.<br />
His father, Çemal Pasha’s son, was born<br />
in 1900, and the only thing discussed at<br />
home about 1915 was the official version:<br />
there was war, there had been deportations,<br />
there were massacres — nothing more.<br />
It was only in the 1970s, after the first<br />
Turkish diplomats had been killed by ASALA,<br />
that he, then a journalist at Çumhuriyet, and<br />
his colleagues raised questions: why are they<br />
killing these diplomats? What do they want?<br />
What did our forefathers do to the<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong>s? <strong>The</strong>reafter came his first investigations<br />
and articles on the issue. Initially, he<br />
too “defended the raison d’état” and then,<br />
after meeting Taner Akçam and Dink, delved<br />
into more serious research and arrived at the<br />
truth. It was his contact with Dink, and then<br />
his murder, that was decisive. Dink “had to<br />
sacrifice his life for this,” he said, his murder<br />
turned the tide. Since then there have been<br />
initiatives, solidarity petitions, open discussions,<br />
debates and demonstrations. Asked by<br />
moderator Raffi Kantian what he expected by<br />
2015, he said, “I cannot foresee or predict<br />
what will happen. What is important is to<br />
continue to fight for democracy and for dialogue.”<br />
This man’s appearance in Germany was a<br />
bombshell. And the attempts on the part of<br />
nationalist Kemalist groups to disturb the<br />
commemorations through provocations were<br />
only further proof of this fact. His personal<br />
courage deserves respect and support. Not<br />
only has he faced hostility in the Kemalist<br />
camp, but has laid bare his personal, internal<br />
confrontation with the official denialist propaganda<br />
in a fashion that helps others —<br />
including <strong>Armenian</strong>s in the diaspora — understand<br />
better what kinds of<br />
psychological/political problems serious<br />
Turkish intellectuals have to work through in<br />
their search for the truth.<br />
Fethiye Çetin Discusses Climate of Fear in Turkey<br />
Fethiye Çetin<br />
and organized, by whom and for what aim?<br />
FÇ: To date, not one of the criminals has<br />
been discovered. I believe that these incidents<br />
must be connected to the words uttered by the<br />
Minister of Internal Affairs at last year’s Khojaly<br />
Meeting. For this reason, I fear that similar incidents<br />
will only increase and worsen in the lead<br />
up to 2015.<br />
HG: All the victims have been elderly<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong> women who live alone. Does this factor<br />
have any particular significance?<br />
FÇ: I think they have chosen elderly women<br />
who live alone because they don’t want any eyewitnesses.<br />
Also, they want to create an even<br />
larger climate of fear in the <strong>Armenian</strong> community.<br />
HG: What must Turkish authorities do,<br />
which they aren’t now, to prevent the reoccurrence<br />
of such attacks in the future and to prove<br />
that they are truly concerned with the safety of<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong> citizens of Turkey?<br />
FÇ: It is vital to expose the culprits as soon<br />
as possible and the forces pulling the strings.<br />
<strong>The</strong> authorities must publicly address the community<br />
and state that those responsible will be<br />
severely punished. <strong>The</strong> authorities must keep<br />
this issue on their agenda. Through various<br />
events and pronouncements, the public at large<br />
must be made aware that mentality causing<br />
these attacks is bankrupt.<br />
Former Agos Editor Calls for Investigation of Istanbul Attacks<br />
activist, told Today’s Zaman that he found it surprising<br />
that Turkish police have yet to track<br />
down the attackers despite the numerous security<br />
cameras in the neighborhood and the<br />
increased police presence.<br />
“We are deeply concerned that these incidents<br />
are an organized crime targeting <strong>Armenian</strong>s. This is<br />
why the police should be more attentive to these<br />
assaults. <strong>The</strong> fact that no concrete development has<br />
taken place regarding the assaults gives us doubt<br />
about the sincerity of the police,” Paylan noted.
TCA Arshag Dickranian<br />
School Student Wins<br />
AP Scholar Award<br />
LOS ANGELES — Aram Ekimyan, a<br />
senior at the Tekeyan Cultural<br />
Association’s (TCA) Arshag Dickranian<br />
School, has received the Advanced<br />
Placement (AP) Scholar Award in recognition<br />
of his commendable college-level<br />
achievement on Advanced Placement<br />
Program Examinations in 2012. Ekimyan<br />
has also received the AP Scholar with<br />
Distinction Award, which is granted to<br />
students who receive an average score of<br />
at least 3.5 on all AP exams<br />
taken, and scores of 3 or higher on five or<br />
more of these exams.<br />
With this accomplishment, Ekimyan<br />
has set the bar<br />
high and has<br />
become an<br />
example for students<br />
at TCA<br />
A r s h a g<br />
D i c k r a n i a n<br />
School and all to<br />
follow. Students<br />
at the school are<br />
inspired to work<br />
Aram Ekimyan<br />
harder to<br />
achieve the same<br />
or even excel,<br />
especially with the new courses which<br />
have been added to the school’s educational<br />
program since the beginning of the<br />
2012-<strong>2013</strong> scholastic year.<br />
Students at TCA Arshag Dickranian<br />
School are eligible to receive AP courses<br />
in US history, calculus, art history, government,<br />
psychology and English literature,<br />
based on their overall performance.<br />
<strong>The</strong> school also plans to add AP courses<br />
in world history, statistics, physics, studio,<br />
government, European history and environmental<br />
science to its program by the<br />
beginning of the next academic year.<br />
Attaining high scores in the AP tests<br />
increases the chance for students to<br />
receive scholarships.<br />
For more information visit<br />
www.dickranianschool.org.<br />
Fresno State Presents<br />
‘<strong>Armenian</strong> Jerusalem: Past<br />
And Present’ Symposium<br />
FRESNO — A symposium, “<strong>Armenian</strong><br />
Jerusalem: Past and Present,” organized by the<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong> Studies Program at Fresno State, in<br />
cooperation with Save the ArQ, will be held at<br />
7:30 p.m. on Friday, <strong>February</strong> 8.<br />
<strong>The</strong> symposium will be held in the University<br />
Business Center, Alice Peters Auditorium,<br />
Room 191, on the Fresno State campus and is<br />
part of the <strong>Armenian</strong> Studies Program Spring<br />
<strong>2013</strong> Lecture Series. A hors d’oeuvres reception<br />
will be held 6:30-7:30 p.m. in the gallery<br />
next to the auditorium. <strong>The</strong> lecture is funded in<br />
part by the Leon S. Peters Foundation.<br />
Save the ArQ is a 501(c)3 organization dedicated<br />
to preserving the <strong>Armenian</strong> Quarter of<br />
Jerusalem. <strong>The</strong> non-profit organization aims to<br />
create awareness of the significant religious,<br />
cultural, and historical presence of <strong>Armenian</strong>s<br />
in Jerusalem and to encourage the revitalization<br />
of the <strong>Armenian</strong> Quarter in the Old City.<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Armenian</strong> Quarter encompasses one-sixth<br />
of the Old City which the <strong>Armenian</strong>s have<br />
inhabited since the fourth century.<br />
Four papers will present various facets on the<br />
Holy City of Jerusalem, a place of great significance<br />
in <strong>Armenian</strong> history. Each of the papers<br />
focuses on an interesting aspect of the city, and<br />
the <strong>Armenian</strong> Patriarchate of Jerusalem.<br />
Tamar Boyadjian (UCLA) will present a paper<br />
on “Lament for the City: Jerusalem and the<br />
see LECTURE, page 6<br />
S A T U R D A Y, F E B R U A R Y 2 , 2 0 1 3 T H E A R M E N I A N M I R R O R - S P E C TAT O R<br />
Community News<br />
Memorial for Khachadour P. Garabedian is unveiled in Philadelphia as a tribute to<br />
the only known <strong>Armenian</strong> to have served in combat during the American Civil War<br />
with Gary Koltookian, left, and Paul Sookiasian.<br />
Chance Discovery Leads to<br />
Rare <strong>Armenian</strong> Hero<br />
CHELMSFORD, Mass. — Like a model ship wedged inside a bottle, Gary<br />
Koltookian feels that’s where he belongs.<br />
It would be quite natural for the antique bottle-collector. One look at his collection<br />
and you’ll see why. His business<br />
card reads “Bottle Gary” and that is how<br />
By Tom Vartabedian<br />
people around the Merrimack Valley<br />
know this community activist.<br />
One day in 1991, Koltookian was<br />
meandering through a flea market in Hollis, NH, searching for bottles, when he<br />
crossed paths with a document that caught his attention.<br />
<strong>The</strong>re, in some remote part of the country, Koltookian’s eyes were drawn to an<br />
1855 Lowell Courier on a dealer’s table, containing an advertisement placed in<br />
that paper by a chap named “Menas Garabed,” cabinet-maker, who once lived in<br />
his very own community — next city over.<br />
“Wow. 1855. An <strong>Armenian</strong> in Lowell,” he thought to himself.<br />
Eventually he found out that his full name was given name was Khachadour P.<br />
Garabedian and he worked in the Lowell mills and became the only known<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong> to have fought during the American Civil War.<br />
Koltookian gathered information from mid-century Lowell newspapers, old<br />
Lowell city directories, a record book of Union Navy officers and from National<br />
Archives, namely the military pensions division.<br />
From the documents, he learned that Garabedian was discharged as a sailor in<br />
Philadelphia, worked, married, died and was buried there upon his death in 1881.<br />
He called his nephew’s father-in-law in Philadelphia to investigate the gravesite<br />
and was stunned by the news. <strong>The</strong>re was no surviving marker or stone commemorating<br />
Garabedian’s death.<br />
Based upon the information he had received, Koltookian wrote an article for the<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong> <strong>Mirror</strong>-<strong>Spectator</strong> in 2004 telling Garabedian’s story which caught the<br />
attention of Paul Sookiasian.<br />
<strong>The</strong> Philadelphia college student read his article and was inspired to raise funds<br />
for a fitting memorial. With the aid of the Philadelphia <strong>Armenian</strong>-American<br />
Veterans, enough money was collected for the project.<br />
Last October — eight years after that article was published — a dedication ceremony<br />
and requiem was conducted at Garabedian’s final resting place in<br />
Lansdowne, Penn., where a traditional <strong>Armenian</strong> khatchkar was erected in his<br />
honor.<br />
“<strong>The</strong>re were not many <strong>Armenian</strong>s in America during the 1860s,” said<br />
Koltookian, whose ancestors arrived here after the turn of the century. “Those like<br />
Khachadour were among the few making America their home.”<br />
<strong>The</strong> 78-year-old Koltookian is a retired social studies teacher, historian,<br />
researcher, collector and member of the Lowell Historical Society. He has served<br />
on local <strong>Armenian</strong> Genocide commemoration committees and belongs to the<br />
Merrimack Valley Knights of Vartan.<br />
He will present a talk on the subject Thursday, <strong>February</strong> 7, at noon, during an<br />
Avak luncheon at St. Gregory <strong>Armenian</strong> Church, 158 Main St., North Andover. <strong>The</strong><br />
public is invited to attend.<br />
Razmik Panossian<br />
Appointed Director of<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong> Communities<br />
Department of<br />
Gulbenkian Foundation<br />
5<br />
LISBON — <strong>The</strong> Calouste Gulbenkian<br />
Foundation announced this week the appointment<br />
of Dr. Razmik Panossian as the new director<br />
of the <strong>Armenian</strong> Communities Department<br />
in Lisbon.<br />
Panossian holds a doctorate from the<br />
London School of Economics and Political<br />
Science, where he also taught. He has published<br />
widely on <strong>Armenian</strong>-related issues,<br />
including a critically-acclaimed book on<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong> national identity. He has extensive<br />
experience in senior management, including the<br />
administration of multi-million dollar programs,<br />
as well as the allocation and distribution of<br />
international development grants. For many<br />
years he served as the director of Policy,<br />
Programmes and Planning at a Canadian governmental<br />
organization based in Montreal. He<br />
has worked for the United Nations<br />
Development Programme. He is fluent in<br />
English, French and <strong>Armenian</strong>.<br />
“I am both thrilled and humbled by this<br />
appointment,” said Panossian. “This is one of<br />
the most important positions in the <strong>Armenian</strong><br />
Diaspora. I am looking forward to continuing<br />
the work of my predecessors and further<br />
strengthening and expanding the activities of<br />
the Calouste Gulbenkian Foundation in a<br />
focused and systematic manner within<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong> communities around the world.”<br />
Martin Essayan, the trustee responsible for<br />
the <strong>Armenian</strong> Communities Department, and<br />
great-grandson of Calouste Gulbenkian, said: “I<br />
am delighted that Dr. Panossian will be the new<br />
director of the <strong>Armenian</strong> Communities<br />
Department. He comes with outstanding credentials<br />
for this role and brings the international,<br />
integrative perspective we need. <strong>The</strong><br />
appointment followed a global search during<br />
which we were able to consider many excellent<br />
candidates.”<br />
Panossian was born in Lebanon and immigrated<br />
to Canada at the age of 12.<br />
<strong>The</strong> Calouste Gulbenkian Foundation is one<br />
of the top-10 foundations in Europe and one of<br />
the largest in the world with assets of 3 billion<br />
euros and annual spending of around 100 million<br />
euros. It operates in four areas defined in<br />
its statutes: Arts, Education, Science, and<br />
Social Welfare. It was founded by Calouste<br />
Sarkis Gulbenkian, an <strong>Armenian</strong> businessman<br />
and art collector who became a British citizen,<br />
conducted much of his work in Britain and<br />
France, and finally settled in Portugal. <strong>The</strong><br />
foundation was established in Portugal in 1956,<br />
a year after his death.<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Armenian</strong> Communities Department<br />
dates back to the creation of the foundation<br />
and was set up by the founder’s son-in-law<br />
Kevork Essayan. Since then the trustee in<br />
charge has always been a member of the<br />
founder’s family. <strong>The</strong> mission of the department<br />
is “to create a viable future for the <strong>Armenian</strong><br />
people in which their culture and language are<br />
preserved and valued.”<br />
Razmik Panossian
6 S A T U R D A Y, F E B R U A R Y 2 , 2 0 1 3<br />
T H E A R M E N I A N M I R R O R - S P E C TAT O R<br />
BOSTON — <strong>The</strong> <strong>Armenian</strong> International<br />
Women’s Association (AIWA) is now accepting<br />
applications for scholarship awards for the<br />
<strong>2013</strong>-2014 academic year.<br />
In addition to awards in the humanities and<br />
social sciences, grants are available to students<br />
in the sciences through the Lucy Kasparian<br />
Aharonian scholarships, granted by AIWA in<br />
conjunction with the Society for Women<br />
Engineers — Boston Chapter.<br />
Students in the fields of science, mathematics,<br />
engineering, technology, computer sciences<br />
and architecture are eligible for<br />
Aharonian awards of $2,000 to $6,000 (juniors<br />
and seniors) or up to $10,000 (master’s and<br />
PhD students).<br />
In addition, AIWA offers a number of scholarships<br />
for female students in all academic<br />
fields, ranging in value from $2,000 to $500.<br />
<strong>The</strong> program was initiated with the Agnes K.<br />
Missirian Scholarship, which was established<br />
in memory of the professor of management at<br />
Bentley College (Waltham, Mass.), a strong<br />
advocate for women’s rights.<br />
Also available for students in all academic<br />
fields are the Dr. Carolann S. Najarian, Ethel<br />
Jafferian Duffett, Rose A. Hovannesian and<br />
Zarouhi Y. Getsoyan scholarships.<br />
AIWA scholarships are awarded annually to<br />
full-time female students of <strong>Armenian</strong> descent<br />
attending accredited colleges or universities.<br />
Students entering their junior or senior year<br />
in college, as well as graduate students, are eligible<br />
to apply for the awards, which are based<br />
on financial need and merit.<br />
<strong>The</strong> awards in the sciences were initiated in<br />
2007 in memory of the late Lucy Kasparian<br />
Aharonian, an active member of the Society of<br />
Women Engineers, who enjoyed a long career<br />
in software engineering even while raising a<br />
family. With degrees in Mathematics and<br />
Business Administration, she worked for several<br />
major firms in the Boston area and also<br />
taught on various levels. Later she successfully<br />
embarked on a second career as a basket<br />
artist.<br />
Applications for all AIWA scholarships for<br />
the <strong>2013</strong>-2014 academic year are available on-<br />
ADVERTISE IN THE MIRROR<br />
COMMUNITY NEWS<br />
AIWA Scholarship Applications Now Available, Including Special Awards in the Sciences<br />
WASHINGTON — Dr. Carolann Najarian attended the celebrations following<br />
the Congressional Swearing-in Ceremony of the 113th Congress<br />
on January 3, Inauguration Day. Above, from left, are, from left,<br />
House Minority Leader Rep. Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.), Najarian, Jessica<br />
Nahagian and Linda Kaboolian.<br />
Fresno State Presents ‘<strong>Armenian</strong> Jerusalem:<br />
Past and Present’ Symposium<br />
LECTURE, from page 5<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong>s in the Medieval Period.” Her talk<br />
will discuss the relationship between the<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong>s and the city of Jerusalem in the<br />
Middle Ages, focusing primarily on the period<br />
most commonly referred to as the early crusades,<br />
1095-1191 AD. Some of the questions<br />
she will explore are: What was the <strong>Armenian</strong><br />
presence in crusader Jerusalem, and what were<br />
the attitudes of the <strong>Armenian</strong>s towards the<br />
European crusaders? What role did the<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong>s of Jerusalem and surrounding principalities<br />
play in the crusades?<br />
Barlow Der Mugrdechian (California State<br />
University, Fresno) will present a paper on<br />
“<strong>Armenian</strong> Jerusalem Through the Eyes of a<br />
Pilgrim.” His paper will be based on his personal<br />
experiences as a traveler to Jerusalem,<br />
since 1985. Why has Jerusalem occupied such<br />
an important space in the consciousness of<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong>s? What has continued to attract<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong> pilgrims to visit Jerusalem?<br />
Sergio La Porta (California State University,<br />
Fresno) will present “Negotiating the Sacred<br />
and the Secular: <strong>The</strong> <strong>Armenian</strong> Heritage in<br />
Jerusalem.” <strong>The</strong> <strong>Armenian</strong> presence in<br />
Jerusalem stretches back over hundreds of<br />
years. While much of the connection between<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong>s and Jerusalem has been and contin-<br />
ues to be religious in nature, and more specifically<br />
related to pilgrimage, there has also been<br />
a strong and significant secular dimension to<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong>s in Jerusalem. His talk will highlight<br />
how the sacred and secular coexist in this<br />
unique environment.<br />
Bedross Der Matossian (University of<br />
Nebraska-Lincoln) will present “Jerusalem in a<br />
Critical Period: Challenges Facing the New<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong> Patriarch of Jerusalem.” <strong>The</strong><br />
<strong>Armenian</strong> Patriarchate of Jerusalem is one of<br />
the most important spiritual, cultural, and<br />
national centers for the <strong>Armenian</strong>s around the<br />
globe and has faced enormous challenges in<br />
the course of its more than 1700 year history<br />
and has been able to overcome many types of<br />
adversities. However, the challenges in the<br />
21st century have taken a new shape. <strong>The</strong> talk<br />
will identify the challenges facing the<br />
Patriarchate, the newly elected <strong>Armenian</strong><br />
patriarch, and the community, and will suggest<br />
pragmatic remedies to political, religious,<br />
social, and economic challenges and discuss<br />
the ways in which the Diaspora can bring its<br />
share in assisting the Patriarchate and the<br />
community.<br />
<strong>The</strong> lecture is free and open to the public.<br />
For more information on the lecture contact<br />
the <strong>Armenian</strong> Studies Program.<br />
line (www.aiwainternational.org) or can be<br />
requested by mail (65 Main St., #3A,<br />
Watertown, MA 02472). <strong>The</strong> deadline for applications<br />
is April 16. Winners will be announced<br />
at the association’s annual meeting in May.<br />
In addition, students residing in California<br />
558 MOUNT AUBURN STREET<br />
WATERTOWN, MA 02472<br />
Edward D. Jamakordzian, Jr. d/b/a<br />
Edward D. Jamie, Jr.<br />
Funeral Chapel<br />
Serving the entire <strong>Armenian</strong> Community<br />
Any Hour • Any Distance • Any Location<br />
Call (718) 224-2390 Toll Free (888) 224-6088<br />
Bus. Reg. 189-06 Liberty Ave., Hollis, NY 11412<br />
Consultation Office: 217-04 Northern Blvd., (Suite 23), Bayside,NY 11361<br />
are eligible to apply for the Hasmik<br />
Mgrdichian Scholarships awarded by the<br />
AIWA/LA Affiliate. Four grants of $2,500<br />
each are available for the <strong>2013</strong>-2014 academic<br />
year. Full information is available on the<br />
AIWA/LA website (www.aiwala.org).<br />
SCHOLARSHIPS AVAILABLE<br />
for<br />
Students of <strong>Armenian</strong> Descent<br />
Having Completed One Year of College by June <strong>2013</strong><br />
Application and other information may be obtained<br />
from<br />
Tibrevank Alumni, Inc.<br />
Vahan Adjemian Scholarship Fund<br />
P.O. Box 14<br />
Palisades Park, NJ 07650<br />
or<br />
www.vahanadjemianscholarship.org<br />
Deadline for returning completed applications: April 30, <strong>2013</strong><br />
Telephone (617) 924-7400<br />
Aram Bedrosian<br />
Funeral Home, Inc.<br />
Continuous Service By <strong>The</strong> Bedrosian Family Since 1945<br />
MARION BEDROSIAN<br />
PAUL BEDROSIAN<br />
LARRY BEDROSIAN<br />
Giragosian<br />
F U N E R A L H O M E<br />
James “Jack” Giragosian, CPC<br />
Mark J. Giragosian<br />
Funeral Counselors<br />
576 Mt. Auburn Street, Watertown, MA 02472, TEL: 617-924—0606<br />
www.giragosianfuneralhome.com<br />
DENNIS M. DEVENEY & SONS<br />
Cemetery Monuments<br />
Specializing in<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong> Designs and Lettering<br />
701 Moody St. Waltham, MA 02543<br />
(781) 891-9876 www.NEMonuments.com
By Douglas Rooks<br />
WATERVILLE, Maine (Bangor Daily News) —<br />
When Paul Boghossian launched the partnership<br />
that restored the historic Hathaway Mill in<br />
Waterville five years ago, he had no idea he would<br />
have to wait until <strong>2013</strong> to start renovations on<br />
the other two buildings in the mammoth<br />
Lockwood Mills complex.<br />
Back in 2007, there had been no Wall Street<br />
collapse, nor tighter lending standards adopted in<br />
its wake. He also had a North Carolina business<br />
partner who had been hailed as a master of mill<br />
restorations and headed his own capital investment<br />
firm.<br />
Almost simultaneously, development money<br />
vanished, as did his business partner, leaving<br />
Boghossian the sole developer to finish restoration<br />
of the former Hathaway Shirt factory. Today,<br />
the complex houses 67 apartments and 130,000<br />
square feet of office and retail space and<br />
Boghossian is ready to turn his full attention to<br />
the Lockwood Mill complex.<br />
At just shy of 500,000 square feet, it’s one of<br />
the largest remaining 19th-century industrial<br />
sites in Maine, and is immediately adjacent to<br />
Waterville’s downtown. <strong>The</strong> Main Street shopping<br />
district lies just across a six-lane approach<br />
road to the bridge to Winslow.<br />
Reconfiguring traffic so that Waterville has a<br />
pedestrian-friendly downtown is just one of the<br />
issues Boghossian is tackling in his most recent<br />
project, which includes refurbishing the two<br />
buildings in Lockwood Mills complex previously<br />
occupied by Central Maine Power Co (CMP) and<br />
Marden’s, and putting them before the planning<br />
board and city council, so far to generally favorable<br />
receptions.<br />
He envisions a hotel, restaurants, retail and<br />
office space, and many new apartments — one of<br />
the most successful features of the Hathaway renovation.<br />
“When I was trying to show an apartment<br />
there recently, I had to show my own unit,” he<br />
said. “None of the others were vacant.”<br />
Boghossian, a Colby College graduate who<br />
began his career restoring mills in his native<br />
Rhode Island, also wants the city to commit to $1<br />
million in road and intersection improvements<br />
that include restoring two-way traffic to Main<br />
Street and replacing the six-lane arterial — which<br />
he called “hopelessly inefficient” — with a roundabout<br />
similar to the one that originally marked<br />
S A T U R D A Y, F E B R U A R Y 2 , 2 0 1 3 T H E A R M E N I A N M I R R O R - S P E C TAT O R<br />
the site.<br />
Waterville Mayor Karen Heck said the traffic<br />
plan is doable, and necessary to re-create the<br />
downtown ambience that once brought shoppers<br />
from around the region.<br />
“Paul has invested years of his life and millions<br />
of dollars in our city,” Heck said. “It’s about time<br />
we reciprocated.”<br />
Boghossian said redeveloping the two buildings,<br />
collectively about the same size as the<br />
Hathaway Creative Center that he renovated and<br />
reopened in 2008, will cost as much as $25 million.<br />
<strong>The</strong> overhaul of the National Historic<br />
Register properties will use both federal and state<br />
historic tax credits.<br />
“That’s what makes projects like this viable,”<br />
he said. “It’s like having 55-cent dollars when you<br />
go to the bank.”<br />
He’s learned some valuable lessons in financing,<br />
he says, following the almost four years it took to<br />
partially extricate himself from an original partnership<br />
with Tom Niemann, a North Carolina developer<br />
who owns the Kennebec Arsenal in Augusta.<br />
That long-stalled project has resulted in the state<br />
exploring litigation to reclaim the property.<br />
Problems, Boghossian says, began almost<br />
immediately after the finishing touches were put<br />
on the Hathaway project in the winter of 2008-09.<br />
Niemann was supposed to manage the two largely<br />
vacant Marden’s and CMP buildings and bring<br />
in financing to replace the $500,000 Boghossian<br />
had invested in them, supposedly for the shortterm<br />
only.<br />
“He never brought in a dime,” Boghossian said<br />
of Niemann. “And he didn’t even pay the electric<br />
bill or fill the oil tanks. <strong>The</strong> tenants were repeatedly<br />
given shutoff notices.”<br />
Boghossian started foreclosure proceedings<br />
that dragged on for years that ultimately resulted<br />
in default judgments in September, making him<br />
sole owner of the Marden’s and CMP buildings.<br />
Niemann remains the largest single owner of the<br />
Hathaway building, though with a minority share.<br />
Boghossian concedes some of the delays would<br />
have happened anyway, even without the wrinkle<br />
of the failed partnership.<br />
“<strong>The</strong>re was no financing for this kind of project<br />
after the financial crash, and it isn’t likely that<br />
we’d have been able to sign up anchor tenants,”<br />
he said.<br />
Now that the economic forecast has brightened<br />
a bit, he thinks it is time to go forward with the<br />
Lockwood project.<br />
<strong>The</strong> middle CMP building, at 53,000 square<br />
feet and two stories, and the Marden’s building<br />
COMMUNITY NEWS<br />
Mill Redevelopment Could Spur Waterville Renaissance<br />
that overlooks downtown — four-and-a-half stories<br />
and 168,000 square feet — lend themselves more<br />
to housing than commercial development, more<br />
so even than the Hathaway project, said<br />
Boghossian, who contrasts Hathaway’s fully occupied<br />
apartments with the about 80 percent occupancy<br />
rate of its office space and a lower proportion<br />
of the first-floor retail.<br />
“<strong>The</strong>se two buildings are narrower, and we’ll be<br />
able to get away from the longer, deeper spaces<br />
that makes the Hathaway units relatively large for<br />
downtown living,” he said.<br />
Many of the Hathaway apartments are 1,000<br />
square feet or larger, and carry market-based<br />
rents of $1,000 a month. <strong>The</strong> units offered in the<br />
other buildings will run from 500-800 square feet,<br />
and average 650 square feet, which will make<br />
rents about $750.<br />
“In this market, that’s much more affordable<br />
and increases their appeal,” he said.<br />
<strong>The</strong> Marden’s building has drawn considerable<br />
interest from hoteliers, says Boghossian, and<br />
could support an 80-room inn with a large restaurant,<br />
along with retail units and some housing.<br />
“That’s one of the things downtown needs to put<br />
it back on the map,” he said. Existing hotels and<br />
motels are all clustered around Waterville’s two<br />
interstate exits, the closest well over a mile away.<br />
Boghossian is thinking even further down the<br />
road, to a possible cooperative program with<br />
Thomas College, which offers a popular program<br />
in hotel management.<br />
“<strong>The</strong>y’re always looking for places to intern,<br />
while hotel chains are also looking for good<br />
employees,” he said. “It could be an excellent<br />
match.”<br />
If a hotel is constructed in the mill buildings, a<br />
parking structure across the street on a cityowned<br />
lot would be needed. Boghossian envisions<br />
a series of walkways connecting the three<br />
buildings and the garage, so that — as in other<br />
northern cities — tenants could access the entire<br />
complex, and reach their cars, without ever having<br />
to step outside.<br />
When he is having a difficult moment, as<br />
Boghossian said he does, now and then, he takes<br />
inspiration from the original story of the<br />
Lockwood Mills. When a group of wealthy<br />
Waterville citizens decided the time was ripe for<br />
a major industrial expansion in the 1870s, they<br />
chose Amos D. Lockwood, who had built mills in<br />
Boston and Providence, RI, as their designer and<br />
engineer.<br />
Not only was Lockwood a skilled building<br />
designer, but he was “a practical genius” when it<br />
came to waterpower, Boghossian said, and in<br />
charting the intricate channels of penstocks,<br />
sluiceways and millwheels that went into making<br />
an efficient 19th century plant. By 1876, 33,000<br />
textile spindles were in operation and the<br />
Lockwood Co. employed 1,300 people at its peak,<br />
with production continuing until 1955; Hathaway<br />
Shirt lasted another 40 years.<br />
“<strong>The</strong> owners were so impressed that they<br />
named their company not after themselves, but<br />
their builder,” Boghossian said.<br />
In bringing these mill buildings back to life, he<br />
says he hopes to replicate a similar brand of persistence<br />
and ingenuity.<br />
Businesses Lose $650<br />
Billion Turning<br />
Businesses anti-Social<br />
By Wilson Dizard<br />
NEW YORK (New York Post) — How can US<br />
businesses recoup $650 billion in lost productivity<br />
a year due to social media in the workplace?<br />
A Miami-based e-commerce company, 1saleaday.com,<br />
got so fed up with its workers wasting<br />
away precious minutes on social media that in<br />
2011 it banned and blocked sites like Facebook<br />
and Twitter.<br />
After worker morale plummeted, management<br />
decided in November to introduce a social<br />
network just for employees, a Twitter clone<br />
called Yammer, and found that productivity and<br />
mood improved.<br />
“Instead of trying to suppress their addiction,<br />
we tried to channel it,” said Eli Federman, a<br />
spokesman for 1saleaday. “It actually increased<br />
productivity by creating an environment where<br />
people collaborate on various projects using<br />
the site.”<br />
<strong>The</strong> company’s story highlights how businesses<br />
with lots of young, computer-bound<br />
employees are trying to figure out how to keep<br />
the attention of people who are paid $14 an<br />
hour for mind-numbing data-entry jobs. It also<br />
shows a growing divide among American workers,<br />
between social media haves and have-nots.<br />
<strong>The</strong> split breaks along the level of competition<br />
for skilled, creative hires. Companies<br />
searching for the best and brightest won’t be so<br />
uncool as to ban social media, but businesses<br />
that just need nimble, youthful fingers for keyboards<br />
have the upper hand and can wring out<br />
more labor by banning social media.<br />
Huge, a DUMBO-based online advertising<br />
company where workers can bring their dogs,<br />
bikes and skateboards to the office, doesn’t<br />
impose restrictions on its employees’ use of<br />
Facebook.<br />
“In general, the only rule is, ‘Think about<br />
what you’re doing, don’t share confidential<br />
information, etc.,’” said Sam Weston, a<br />
spokesman for Huge. “But the question isn’t so<br />
much the medium, it’s the people. Do you have<br />
people who are responsible and smart and who<br />
care enough about what they’re doing to be<br />
engaged in the workplace, or not?”<br />
At one Wall Street firm, however, management<br />
doesn’t have the same outlook. One<br />
employee, who spoke on condition of anonymity,<br />
said the firewall at the office, which prohibits<br />
social media and even Gmail, is reminiscent of<br />
“Stalinist Russia.”<br />
“I think a reasonable, little five-minute break<br />
to check in with the world is fine,” the employee<br />
said.<br />
Alexis Ohanian, a founder of startups including<br />
the popular link site Reddit, said competition<br />
for skilled workers discourages tech companies<br />
from doing anything draconian.<br />
“Employers hiring tech talent already have to<br />
intensely compete for talent, so something like<br />
a ‘no social media’ policy is a deal-breaker for<br />
most of those folks,” Ohanian said.<br />
“I’m a very pro-social media employer: If you<br />
get your work done, go ahead and look at some<br />
cat photos (then share them because your<br />
increased clout will pay dividends for me later,<br />
when you promote projects we’re working on),”<br />
he added.<br />
7
8 S A T U R D A Y, F E B R U A R Y 2 , 2 0 1 3 T H E A R M E N I A N M I R R O R - S P E C TAT O R<br />
TITIZIAN, from page 1<br />
in the States, I went to <strong>Armenian</strong> school all the<br />
way up to high school. I’m so glad they did that<br />
for me. I speak, read and write fluently in<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong> and that’s a blessing. I hope to do the<br />
same for my children.”<br />
Titizian first fell in love with acting in college.<br />
“I didn’t get involved in acting until my second<br />
year of college... I was 20. I wish I had gotten<br />
started much younger, but I guess everything<br />
happens for a reason.”<br />
After taking a college acting class, Titizian<br />
decided to make a go of it. “I did background<br />
work for a TV show and watched the actors and<br />
told myself ‘I can do that.’ So that was it. I<br />
dropped out of college and took professional acting<br />
classes, got my first set of headshots and hustled<br />
to get an agent. I can’t believe it has already<br />
been 13 years.”<br />
Titizian has played the role of CIA agent<br />
Danny Galvez for the past two seasons of the hit<br />
Showtime drama, “Homeland,” which chronicles<br />
a US-marine-turned-terrorist and features an allstar<br />
cast including Claire Danes, Damian Lewis<br />
and Mandy Patinkin. How did Tatizian land the<br />
role? “<strong>The</strong> casting process for ‘Homeland’ was<br />
interesting. I was in New York finishing up the<br />
last two weeks of a play on Broadway and I got<br />
a call to audition for ‘Homeland.’ It was just a<br />
pilot that had gotten picked up for series, so<br />
nobody had heard of it, let alone watched it,” said<br />
Tatizian.<br />
Timing and a positive attitude always help. “I<br />
didn’t get it. But the people liked me and I had<br />
worked with them before on ‘24’ […] so there was<br />
this role they were having trouble casting. <strong>The</strong><br />
character was Hispanic, but they wanted me to<br />
do it, so they changed it and made him half<br />
Lebanese and half Hispanic. I still had to audition<br />
for it, because I had to get approved by the<br />
network.”<br />
With one phone call, Titizian was on the next<br />
flight to North Carolina to start filming. “I’m<br />
glad it worked out the way it did because the role<br />
I initially auditioned for was much smaller. You<br />
never know how things work out in this business.<br />
And no one including myself expected the<br />
show to be as big of a hit as it turned out to be.<br />
You just can’t tell those things until they start<br />
airing. And it was a hit right out of the gates and<br />
got bigger and bigger each week. It’s very cool to<br />
be a part of it.”<br />
After a successful finish to season two and various<br />
awards, fans will have to wait to see more<br />
from Agent Galvez. “As for season three, I don’t<br />
even know if I’ll be back or not, so I don’t have<br />
the slightest clue what’s in store for the show or<br />
for Danny Galvez. But the writers are very smart<br />
and I trust whatever they do will be great,” said<br />
Titizian.<br />
Titizian has appeared in numerous television<br />
series and films, but says his favorite role actually<br />
was in a play. “Playing the ghost of Uday<br />
Hussein would top the list,” said Tatizian. He is<br />
referring to his 2011 stint on Broadway in<br />
“Bengal Tiger at the Baghdad Zoo,” starring<br />
Robin Williams. According to Titizian, his character<br />
“was sadistic, evil, funny, charming, juicy<br />
and believe it or not, likable. ... At least the way<br />
I played it. I would be very pleasantly surprised<br />
to get a role like that on TV.”<br />
Acclimating to the grueling scheduling and<br />
repetition of theater is no easy task. “It’s very<br />
challenging for me, but the payoff is not like any<br />
other,” he said. “[<strong>The</strong>] feeling you get when<br />
you’re performing in front of so many people is<br />
incomparable.”<br />
“Being on Broadway is probably every performer’s<br />
dream, especially working with Robin<br />
Williams, [who is] someone I always admired<br />
growing up.”<br />
Titizian looks forward to future stints on<br />
Broadway. “As for returning, yes, I would love to<br />
do that sometime in the future, when I’m ready<br />
again,” he said.<br />
In a business that often rewards style over substance,<br />
one thing that makes Titizian stand out<br />
is his grounding in tradition. “I feel it’s very<br />
important to recognize your heritage and your<br />
ancestry and keep the culture alive. I’m very<br />
proud to be <strong>Armenian</strong> and although every agent<br />
and manager I met told me to change my name,<br />
I could never get myself to do it,” he said. “If it<br />
takes longer for people to see me a certain way,<br />
consider me for certain roles or get in certain<br />
doors, so be it. At least I can go to bed every<br />
night with my dignity.”<br />
It seems that Titizian’s hard work and positive<br />
attitude has paid off. Titizian was honored as this<br />
year’s ARPA international breakthrough performer<br />
of the year in Los Angeles. “It’s always a<br />
good feeling to be honored for anything. <strong>The</strong><br />
ARPA award was special because I had a film in<br />
that festival a few years back and the people<br />
involved are really great. That night was loads of<br />
fun and I’m fortunate to have been a recipient.<br />
Being recognized in that way gives you some<br />
sense of ‘I guess I’m doing something right.’”<br />
In the midst of his success, Titizian is also making<br />
time for his personal life. “Well, I’m getting<br />
married in April, so the wedding planning is definitely<br />
taking some work.” In between wedding<br />
planning and auditioning, he will be producing a<br />
film that shoots in March and also teaching classes<br />
on Tuesday nights. “Otherwise, my main focus<br />
is acting and auditions are back to normal now<br />
that the holidays are over, so hopefully the next<br />
gig is not too far away,” he said.<br />
“That’s the scary thing about this business,<br />
but also the beautiful thing about this business.<br />
You’ll get a call today and you’re on a flight<br />
tomorrow. So you just have to stay sane and<br />
trust that the work will come,” he said.<br />
COMMUNITY NEWS<br />
From Home to ‘Homeland’ Hrach Titizian Stays True to His Roots<br />
Hrach Titizian
NEW YORK — Camp Nubar is not yet in session,<br />
but AGBU families in the greater New<br />
York-New Jersey area are showing their camp<br />
spirit more than ever through a series of celebratory<br />
events dedicated to its 50th anniversary.<br />
<strong>The</strong> milestone year started this fall with<br />
the Parents’ Night Out, and continued this past<br />
weekend during the first-ever Camp Nubar<br />
Alumni Basketball Tournament and Annual<br />
S A T U R D A Y, F E B R U A R Y 2 , 2 0 1 3 T H E A R M E N I A N M I R R O R - S P E C TAT O R<br />
Winter Reunion.<br />
On Saturday, January 12, 2012, dozens of former<br />
counselors — some of whom joined Camp<br />
Nubar a decade ago — went head to head on the<br />
basketball courts of St. Leon <strong>Armenian</strong> Church<br />
in Fair Lawn, NJ. <strong>The</strong>y were cheered on by<br />
campers both past and present who turned out<br />
in large numbers for the Annual Winter<br />
Reunion and were clad in 50th anniversary<br />
gear, including t-shirts, bags and wristbands,<br />
designed especially for the occasion. Before filling<br />
the stands, the attendees gathered for the<br />
unveiling of the Special Edition Color War<br />
Poster, featuring Blue and Gold team banners<br />
from across camp history, as well as for a photo<br />
slideshow of the past summer.<br />
Parents’ Night Out, which was held on<br />
Thursday, November 15, 2012, also showcased<br />
a special collection of photographs: those that<br />
brought to life Camp Nubar’s spring-fed lake,<br />
acres of pristine forests and Catskill Mountain<br />
ranges — the natural beauty that has drawn<br />
back generation after generation. An intimate<br />
evening for families and friends, Parents’ Night<br />
Out gathered longtime camp alumni, as well as<br />
those who recently joined the Camp Nubar<br />
Check us out at<br />
www.mirrorspectator.com<br />
New York<br />
M E T R O<br />
Camp Nubar Ushers in 50th Anniversary Year with a Series of Celebratory Events<br />
Camp Nubar supporters and alumni celebrate<br />
Camp’s 50th anniversary at Parent’s Night Out.<br />
community, to the Harvest Bistro & Bar in<br />
Closter, NJ. <strong>The</strong>re, the guests reminisced about<br />
summers past, discussed plans for the upcoming<br />
year and took in the striking photographs.<br />
<strong>The</strong> exhibit featured the work of two AGBU<br />
members: AGBU Young Professionals of<br />
Greater New York (YPGNY) longtime core committee<br />
member Vadim Krisyan, who adds the<br />
Camp Nubar photos to his growing portfolio<br />
and YP supporter Shant Madjarian, who has<br />
honed his eye as the founder of a local design<br />
firm. Though neither has been a camper, both<br />
participated in this summer’s annual YPGNY<br />
City Escape retreat to Camp Nubar and were<br />
immediately inspired by their surroundings.<br />
<strong>The</strong>ir talent and enthusiasm, and that of the<br />
Camp Nubar 50th Anniversary Committee<br />
members, is making the celebratory year an<br />
unforgettable one. As committee member and<br />
camp alumna Nancy Zoraian commented, “It<br />
was so nice to be part of such a warm and festive<br />
evening. But Parents’ Night Out was only<br />
the beginning. Our committee represents a mix<br />
of generations, from older alumni, to parents of<br />
campers, to AGBU’s innovative young professionals,<br />
who are bringing so many fresh ideas to<br />
the table. <strong>The</strong>ir energy is amazing and inspiring<br />
— and together we are making each event dedicated<br />
to the 50th anniversary more spectacular<br />
By Kevin McGarry<br />
NEW YORK (New York Times) — Located in<br />
a Maya Lin-rehabbed former trolley repair shop<br />
around the corner from MoMA PS1 in Long<br />
Island City, Queens, SculptureCenter is one of<br />
New York City’s oldest artist-founded institutions<br />
at 85 years of age. <strong>The</strong> main gallery is a<br />
towering, slightly dilapidated room, and taking<br />
residence there this winter is “Retainer,” a<br />
sculpture by the Iranian-born, Berlin-based<br />
artist Nairy Baghramian. This commission is<br />
her first exhibition in the United States, though<br />
in Europe she’s well known for her manually<br />
and mechanically manipulated forms that are<br />
by turns delicate and inscrutable.<br />
“Retainer” is more a system of sculptures<br />
than a uniform object. In Baghramian’s words,<br />
“it’s a collection of single, individual,<br />
autonomous pieces that occupy the space —<br />
the gaps between them are part of it. Some are<br />
connected, some alone, some in networks, but<br />
in the end it is all one installation.” <strong>The</strong> piece’s<br />
protagonist is a ring of large, fleshy shapes<br />
held at eye height by a lattice of spindly<br />
chrome supports that evoke a design showroom<br />
as readily as the dentist’s chair. Bonded<br />
together, these elements resemble pieces of<br />
huge alien jewelry.<br />
<strong>The</strong> work’s strong material presence is no<br />
accident, and its fabrication is quite involved.<br />
<strong>The</strong> process began with a prototype<br />
Baghramian engineered herself; then she produced<br />
the structural elements of the piece and<br />
than the last.”<br />
Parents’ Night Out launched not only a year<br />
of festivities, but a year of fundraising, as well.<br />
Throughout the evening, bids on the photographs,<br />
as well as substantial contributions<br />
from Barry and Andrea Halejian, Jack and Carol<br />
Margossian and Armen and Brenda Shahinian,<br />
and other AGBU supporters brought the total<br />
Camp Nubar donations to date to more than<br />
$40,000. Camp Nubar has also received a<br />
pledge from an anonymous benefactor, who has<br />
agreed to match the first $100,000 raised.<br />
Together, the funds will help Camp Nubar construct<br />
a brand new a pavilion, a common space<br />
in the heart of the camp where youth will cre-<br />
Some of Camp Nubar’s youngest members catch up at the Annual Winter Reunion in New Jersey.<br />
ate and learn together.<br />
Camp Nubar families have even more to look<br />
forward to in the coming months: on Friday,<br />
July 26, the 50th anniversary celebration will<br />
take place at Guastavino’s restaurant in New<br />
York City. Tickets are on sale now. On Sunday,<br />
July 28, Camp Nubar will hold its annual Open<br />
House and honor the five-decade anniversary.<br />
To learn about Camp Nubar’s upcoming 50th<br />
anniversary events, make a donation to Camp<br />
Nubar or purchase 50th anniversary gear and<br />
tickets, visit: www.campnubar.org/50.<br />
Photography prints from Parents’ Night Out will<br />
be sold in limited quantities throughout the year.<br />
Nairy Baghramian at SculptureCenter<br />
their chromium plating with a metal workshop.<br />
<strong>The</strong> shapes are poured polycarbonate in the<br />
hue of what she calls a “noncolor,” then coated<br />
in another layer of silicon that is wiped, blurred<br />
and troweled to achieve its nuanced, industrialorganic<br />
texture.<br />
Responding to the history of<br />
SculptureCenter’s use — not as a former repair<br />
shop but as a well-trafficked art venue —<br />
Baghramian has moved the wall labels that typically<br />
indicate an exhibition’s beginning to the<br />
gallery’s back door. <strong>The</strong> intent, she says, was “to<br />
force people to bump into the installation from<br />
the back, so that they’re immediately placed in<br />
the space when they enter.” Just as viewers<br />
encounter her mélange of materials and production<br />
methods as unified art objects, “this<br />
way the building, the space, the institution and<br />
the work coalesce as a conglomerate that causes<br />
a multilayered reaction.”<br />
<strong>The</strong>re are other components of “Retainer” in<br />
an annex behind the main room: a photograph<br />
of a horse’s leg in yellow casts at the joints,<br />
metal shapes attached to the walls, a small table<br />
with a base echoing a horse’s hoof. “Every part<br />
of the show correlates to an idea of supporting<br />
the body, but also to the word ‘snag’” — the title<br />
of the photograph — “or ‘catch,’ in reference to<br />
the German expression ‘Pferdefuss,’ meaning<br />
the foot of the horse.” Full of these well-formed<br />
hitches, Baghramian’s show is a microcosmic<br />
reminder of just how productive problems can<br />
be in evoking a thing’s essence.<br />
“Retainer” is on view through March 25 at<br />
SculptureCenter, 44-19 Purves St., in Long<br />
Island City, NY.<br />
9
10 S A T U R D A Y, F E B R U A R Y 2 , 2 0 1 3<br />
T H E A R M E N I A N M I R R O R - S P E C TAT O R<br />
New Guide to<br />
Armenia And Artsakh<br />
Highlights Ecology<br />
And Conservation<br />
LOS ANGELES — An all-new edition<br />
of Armenia’s best-selling travel guide,<br />
<strong>The</strong> Stone Garden Travel Guide:<br />
Armenia and Karabakh, will be published<br />
in <strong>February</strong>.<br />
<strong>The</strong> new 320-page book contains<br />
updated and expanded information for<br />
the <strong>2013</strong>-14 tourist seasons and features<br />
27 color maps and more than 140<br />
color photographs.<br />
A never-before-published map of historic<br />
Armenia, which was created shortly<br />
after the Genocide, is also featured in<br />
the book.<br />
<strong>The</strong> Stone Garden Travel Guide is<br />
the first comprehensive guidebook to<br />
Armenia and Karabagh (Artsakh), and<br />
is also the only guidebook for the<br />
region that emphasizes conservation<br />
and ecology. <strong>The</strong> book is Award Finalist<br />
for Best Travel Guide by the<br />
Independent Publishers Association.<br />
CNN Traveller magazine calls the<br />
book “an excellent guide, written with<br />
real passion for the subject.” <strong>The</strong> book<br />
features maps from <strong>The</strong> American<br />
University of Armenia’s “Birds of<br />
Armenia Project” and highlights con-<br />
Cover of <strong>The</strong> Stone Garden Travel<br />
Guide: Armenia and Karabakh<br />
servation issues that confront Armenia,<br />
in addition to covering all the information<br />
about cultural sites and getting<br />
around that every traveler expects in a<br />
guidebook.<br />
Author-photographer Matthew<br />
Karanian and photographer Robert<br />
Kurkjian have each spent more than a<br />
decade living and working in Armenia<br />
while researching and writing this and<br />
previous editions of the book. Each of<br />
them first traveled to Armenia in 1995<br />
to work as professors at the American<br />
University of Armenia. Karanian is an<br />
attorney. Kurkjian is an environmental<br />
scientist.<br />
<strong>The</strong>ir writing and photography about<br />
Armenia has also been featured in magazines<br />
and newspapers of wide distribution<br />
in the US, Europe, and Canada,<br />
including in CNN Traveller magazine,<br />
Arthur Frommer’s Budget Travel,<br />
Geographical, Global Adventure, Photo<br />
Life and Photo District News.<br />
<strong>The</strong> new book will be available from<br />
Amazon.com and from select bookstores<br />
in mid-<strong>February</strong>. To pre-order directly<br />
from the publisher before <strong>February</strong> 28,<br />
send check or money order for $25 post<br />
paid to: Stone Garden Productions; PO<br />
Box 7758; Northridge, CA 91327.<br />
Arts & Living<br />
A ceramic Khatchkar by Dr. Jack Hachigian<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong> Cross Serves<br />
As Inspiration for<br />
Ceramic Art<br />
YEREVAN (Clay/Technical magazine) — As I drove through the countryside, on<br />
a visit to the nation of Armenia, I was struck by the numerous crosses carved into<br />
stone. <strong>The</strong>se large monoliths,<br />
called khatchkars, or “cross-<br />
By Jack Hachigian, PhD<br />
stones,” often made from<br />
Armenia’s native tufa stone,<br />
dotted the landscape. <strong>The</strong>y are<br />
magnificent works of art, at once formidable and delicate. <strong>The</strong> <strong>Armenian</strong> tradition<br />
of carving crosses into stone is an ancient one, going at least as far back as 600 AD.<br />
During this visit to the land of my ancestors, I stopped by the main historical<br />
library in the capital city of Yerevan. I viewed a collection of antique manuscripts<br />
encased in UV protective<br />
glass cases. <strong>The</strong>se<br />
very old works of handscribed<br />
books were<br />
beautifully illustrated in<br />
color and represented<br />
another strain of<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong> art: the illumination.<br />
I was overwhelmed<br />
by the beauty<br />
of these tiny works. <strong>The</strong><br />
little paintings glowed<br />
with gold and jewel<br />
toned paints. It was awe<br />
inspiring to imagine<br />
monks in the distant<br />
past toiling over these<br />
manuscripts and in the<br />
present day to observe<br />
monks conducting<br />
research using these<br />
same ancient works.<br />
My interest in Biblical<br />
illuminations began to<br />
take the form of<br />
research. I visited other<br />
important collections of<br />
these old manuscripts,<br />
one in a monastery in<br />
Ceramic Khatchkars by Dr. Jack Hachigian<br />
Vienna, Austria, and another in a monastery on the island of San Lazzaro, just off<br />
the coast of Venice, Italy. I began to examine various texts and original Greek and<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong> sources.<br />
My research eventually took me to the illuminations from the Trebezond region<br />
of ancient Armenia, now in present day Turkey. A number of ruins of monasteries<br />
and churches still remain in this region, which is located in the eastern part of the<br />
Anatolian peninsula, bordering on the Black Sea. From the ninth to the 14th centuries,<br />
monks and scribes in this region toiled to copy Biblical writings, using the<br />
unique <strong>Armenian</strong> script and alphabet, illuminating their work as they went. Rooms<br />
of scribes worked for years to produce these books. <strong>The</strong> illuminations come in different<br />
styles and art historians have traced them to different monks from<br />
see KHATCHKAR, page 12<br />
Chamber Music<br />
Concert at ALMA<br />
Rescheduled for<br />
<strong>February</strong> 10<br />
WATERTOWN — <strong>The</strong> Chamber Music<br />
Concert at the <strong>Armenian</strong> Library and Museum<br />
of America (ALMA) initially planned for January<br />
27 will take place on Sunday, <strong>February</strong> 10, at 4<br />
p.m., due to illness. Pieces by composers<br />
Babajanian, Schulhoff and Zemlinsky will be<br />
performed by students of the Walnut Hill<br />
School for the Arts.<br />
This collaboration between ALMA and the<br />
school includes the performance of a very special<br />
piece of <strong>Armenian</strong> chamber music,<br />
Babajanian’s Piano Trio, which combines traditional<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong> melodies with richly Romantic<br />
textures, and serves as a musical testament to<br />
the feelings of nationalist identity of the<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong> people under Soviet domination. <strong>The</strong><br />
chamber groups will also present Erwin<br />
Schulhoff’s Concertino for flute, viola and double<br />
bass, and Alexander Zemlinsky's Trio for<br />
clarinet, cello and piano.<br />
Tickets will be available at the door only. It is<br />
free for students.<br />
Refreshments will be served following program.<br />
Arno Babajanian (1921-1983)<br />
Hasmik Harutyunyan to<br />
Present Workshop on<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong> Song and Dance<br />
FRESNO — Hasmik Harutyunyan will present<br />
a workshop on <strong>Armenian</strong> song and dance, from<br />
2 to 5 p.m. on Saturday, <strong>February</strong> 2, in the<br />
South Gym, room 133, of Fresno State campus.<br />
<strong>The</strong> workshop is co-sponsored by the<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong> Students Organization and<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong> Studies Program at Fresno State and<br />
is partially funded by the Associated Students,<br />
Inc. of Fresno State.<br />
Participation in the workshop is free, but participants<br />
are asked to bring only soft-soled<br />
shoes.<br />
Harutyunyan was born in Yerevan and has<br />
extensive experience studying <strong>Armenian</strong> dance<br />
and music in Armenia. She will be demonstrating<br />
folk dances from the various provinces of<br />
historic Armenia, in their original form. Dances<br />
will include the Gyovend, Kochari, Tamzara,<br />
Ververi, Mayroke, Pampouri and others, such as<br />
Hamshen dances and dances especially for<br />
women.<br />
Harutyunyan will also teach <strong>Armenian</strong> folk<br />
songs, including lullabies, from historic<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong> provinces. In Armenia, she is known<br />
for her work with the Shoghaken Folk<br />
Ensemble and for her renditions of <strong>Armenian</strong><br />
lullabies. Her performances are often broadcast<br />
on <strong>Armenian</strong> National Radio and presented at<br />
traditional music festivals around the world.<br />
For more information about the workshop,<br />
contact the <strong>Armenian</strong> Studies Program at<br />
Fresno State.
LONDON — Sotheby’s will hold “At <strong>The</strong> Crossroads,”<br />
the first-ever selling exhibition of Contemporary Art<br />
from Central Asia and the Caucasus. This pioneering<br />
exhibition, which encompasses art from the mountains<br />
of Caucasus to Kazakhstan’s steppe and the Chinese<br />
borders, will take place at Sotheby’s New Bond Street<br />
premises from Monday, March 4 until Tuesday, March<br />
12.<br />
“At <strong>The</strong> Crossroads” will include around 50 contemporary<br />
artworks in various media by artists from across<br />
Central Asia and the Caucasus, including Armenia,<br />
Azerbaijan, Georgia, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan<br />
and Uzbekistan. <strong>The</strong> exhibition will showcase non-conformist<br />
as well as socialist-realist art from the 1960s,<br />
right the way through to emerging contemporary practices.<br />
Commenting on this pioneering initiative, Jo<br />
Vickery, senior director and head of Sotheby’s<br />
Russian Art Department in London, said: “Countries<br />
throughout the Caucasus and Central Asia have experienced<br />
rapid growth in recent years and this is also<br />
true of the art scene there. New collectors, art institutions<br />
and galleries are emerging every day, and it is<br />
an exciting new geography for Sotheby’s to explore.<br />
We are therefore delighted to present this landmark<br />
selling exhibition, which encompasses the diverse<br />
artistic practices of the region that combine ancient<br />
historical roots with techniques at the forefront of<br />
contemporary art.”<br />
Three <strong>Armenian</strong> artists are represented in the exhibit.<br />
<strong>The</strong>y are Armen Gevorgyan,Vruyr Galstyan and Ruben<br />
Grigorian.<br />
For Gevorgyan, the role of agriculture in <strong>Armenian</strong><br />
society is one he wants to stress. In this work that was<br />
made after his eponymous 1988 sculpture, Armen<br />
Gevorgyan, a prominent <strong>Armenian</strong> sculptor, addresses<br />
the philosophical concept of the cycle of life. <strong>The</strong> broken<br />
wheel carries special meaning for the <strong>Armenian</strong> people,<br />
whose national consciousness has been formed by long<br />
history of resettlement. Gevorgyan invites the viewer to<br />
contemplate on the broken life cycles of those whose<br />
memories are filled with long journeys and a lost motherland.<br />
Throughout his career Galstyan has used color in a<br />
variety of ways to explore, in depth, the complex concepts<br />
of man’s position in space and time. His stylistic<br />
approach in the 1960s can be seen to be distinct from<br />
that in his later period of the 1970s and 1980s.<br />
Both Galstyan’s early and late periods are characterized<br />
by the dominance of whites and blacks. However,<br />
while his 1960s compositions have a muted harmony of<br />
pastel hues, he increasingly preferred contrasting and<br />
almost violent colors in his later career. “Memory,”<br />
1973, is a cornerstone piece of Galstyan’s later period. It<br />
is in essence a self-portrait and is central to the development<br />
of his mature oeuvre. In this work the artist<br />
explores the painting medium itself, through the dense<br />
S A T U R D A Y, F E B R U A R Y 2 , 2 0 1 3<br />
ARTS & LIVING<br />
application of paint and an intense and contrasting<br />
color palette. <strong>The</strong> thick black contours remain from his<br />
earlier works but these now serve to separate the contrasting<br />
color shapes that construct the pictorial plane.<br />
In “Memory,” he develops a complex approach to the linearity<br />
of form and the<br />
interplay of color planes<br />
by striking an improbable<br />
fusion between<br />
Modernist discourse and<br />
that of deeply traditional<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong> medieval illuminated<br />
manuscripts and<br />
carpet patterns.<br />
Grigorian studied at<br />
the Panos Terlemezian<br />
Art College in Yerevan<br />
from 1971 to 1977 and at<br />
the Yerevan State<br />
Institute of Fine Arts<br />
between 1978 and 1984.<br />
<strong>The</strong> following year he<br />
was became a member of<br />
the Artists’ Union of<br />
Armenia. He first exhibited<br />
with the 3rd Floor<br />
group and since then has<br />
exhibited regularly in various<br />
international locations<br />
including Buenos<br />
Aires, Chicago, Moscow,<br />
London, Germany and<br />
Yerevan. Since 2000 he<br />
has worked at the<br />
National Cinema Centre<br />
in Yerevan. His oeuvre<br />
consists largely of precise,<br />
naturalistic paintings<br />
depicting surrealistic<br />
imagery, but he has<br />
also illustrated a number<br />
of children’s books.<br />
He said that in his<br />
T H E A R M E N I A N M I R R O R - S P E C TAT O R<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong> Artists Part of First Sotheby’s Sale and Exhibition<br />
Of Contemporary Art from Caucasus and Central Asia<br />
“Memory” by Vruyr Galstyan<br />
SOTHEBY’S PHOTO<br />
“Enigma” by Ruben Grigorian<br />
“Disintegration” by Armen Gevorgyan<br />
SOTHEBY’S PHOTO<br />
works, he tries to “unite the surrounding world with the<br />
parallel mystic reality. Imagination is the most important<br />
element in art and the passages opened by it transport<br />
us into the Past and into the Future.”<br />
For more information, visit Sotheby’s website.<br />
SOTHEBY’S PHOTO<br />
11
12<br />
Love and<br />
Whiskey at the<br />
Blind Donkey<br />
By Jessica Gelt<br />
ASEDENA, Calif. (LA Times) — <strong>The</strong><br />
new Blind Donkey bar is the work of the<br />
beer-minded men behind Verdugo Bar,<br />
the Surly Goat and the Little Bear, and as<br />
such it exudes a pleasing masculinity. <strong>The</strong><br />
decor is stripped down to a few framed<br />
photographs of donkeys; a large, slightly<br />
crooked bar; a massive gilded mirror<br />
(good for casting wayward glances at<br />
other lonely drinkers) and a smattering of<br />
communal wooden tables.<br />
Ryan Sweeney, the tattooed maestro<br />
and mouthpiece for the group’s bars (his<br />
partners include John Bower, Brandon<br />
Bradford and Alen Aivazian) says the<br />
Donkey currently carries nearly 115 different<br />
kinds of whiskey. That’s a lot of<br />
love, perusing the menu of American,<br />
Scottish, Irish and Canadian offerings<br />
and resolving to have a second glass of<br />
something peaty.<br />
Manager Penny Wilhelm is behind the<br />
bar. Blond and gregarious, Wilhelm is<br />
developing an encyclopedic knowledge of<br />
whiskey so she can help patrons with the<br />
understandably taxing decision-making<br />
process.<br />
“I spend my days reading books,” says<br />
Wilhelm, producing a large volume titled,<br />
World Whiskey: A Nation-by-Nation<br />
Guide to the Best.<br />
What’s Wilhelm’s favorite whiskey at<br />
the moment?<br />
Wilhelm picks up a bottle of Templeton<br />
rye and points out that it was “Al<br />
Capone’s drink of choice.”<br />
<strong>The</strong> Templeton rye, which is well-aged<br />
and spicy with strong notes of wood and<br />
caramel, is used in the Donkey’s version<br />
of the Old Fashioned. Called Butler’s Old<br />
Fashioned, the drink features seasonal<br />
jam, in this case cinnamon plum.<br />
Visitors may also order a basket of deep<br />
fried pickle chips with barbecue sauce<br />
and jalapeño ranch. Sweeney is quick to<br />
point out that the Donkey is a bar that<br />
serves food. Not a restaurant.<br />
S A T U R D A Y, F E B R U A R Y 2 , 2 0 1 3 T H E A R M E N I A N M I R R O R - S P E C TAT O R<br />
TORONTO — <strong>The</strong> Asia Minor Catastrophe<br />
and the Ottoman Greek Genocide: Essays on<br />
Asia Minor, Pontos, and Eastern Thrace,<br />
1913–1923, edited by George N. Shirinian,<br />
executive director of the Zoryan Institute, is a<br />
compilation of innovative papers given by distinguished<br />
scholars at two academic conferences<br />
organized by the Asia Minor and Pontos<br />
Hellenic Research Center in Chicago.<br />
“Our knowledge of the catastrophic events<br />
affecting millions of people caught up in the<br />
huge political and social transformation connected<br />
with the dissolution of the Ottoman<br />
Empire and the rise of the Turkish Republic has<br />
not received the scholarly attention it deserves.<br />
Even the best studied of these tragic events, the<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong> Genocide, has been deprived of a certain<br />
panoramic contextualization of a tragedy<br />
which touched profoundly the lives of several<br />
other religious and ethnic groups, such as the<br />
Greeks and Assyrians,” observed <strong>The</strong>ofanis G.<br />
Stavrou, professor of history at the University<br />
of Minnesota.<br />
LONDON — In her new book, Transnational<br />
Culture, Transnational Identity (I.B. Tauris,<br />
2011), Maria Koundoura, associate professor of<br />
literature at Emerson College, breaks new<br />
ground in her comparative analysis of Peter<br />
Balakian’s Black Dog of Fate, Orhan Pamuk’s<br />
Istanbul, and Elif Shafak’s novel, <strong>The</strong> Bastard<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong> Cross Serves as Inspiration for Ceramic Art<br />
KHATCHKAR, from page 10<br />
different regions and at different times. <strong>The</strong><br />
movable type printing press had not yet been<br />
invented. This would only happen in 1439, and<br />
it is known to have reached Constantinople 100<br />
years later. It is unclear when it reached these<br />
monks some distance from Constantinople.<br />
It is interesting to note that <strong>Armenian</strong> crosses<br />
are not crucifixes. <strong>The</strong> illuminated crosses<br />
were not heavy or strongly religious but rather<br />
light and uplifting, engendering a feeling of<br />
spirituality. I was fascinated by their variety,<br />
beauty and the scope of the crosses.<br />
<strong>The</strong> influence of these two traditions:<br />
Khatchkars, in Armenia, and the crosses drawn<br />
in illuminations, evoked a strong desire in me to<br />
fuse and extend these two art forms of the<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong> cross.<br />
Keeping with what I saw in the ancient<br />
manuscripts, I wanted to create the intricate<br />
crosses in various colors. I decided to continue<br />
the tradition of carving crosses in relief like the<br />
“cross-stones,” but using a modern approach<br />
and thus I began to examine the possible use of<br />
ceramics.<br />
Within a short time I had created a number<br />
of ceramic crosses. Ultimately I created many<br />
designs, which were inspired by those I saw in<br />
the Illuminations. Others were abstractions of<br />
them, or sprang from my imagination.<br />
<strong>The</strong> works are now found in a number of private<br />
collections. I was also honored when an<br />
artist from Zimbabwe purchased one of my<br />
ARTS & LIVING<br />
New Book on Greek, <strong>Armenian</strong> Genocides<br />
A Khatchkar in Armenia<br />
works.<br />
(Dr. Hachigian’s work will be available at the<br />
Knights of Vartan <strong>Armenian</strong> Art Night on<br />
March 2, at the Newport Beach Country Club,<br />
1600 E. Coast Highway, Newport Beach. Or,<br />
make a donation to the “Friends of the<br />
Centennial Monument” on the website<br />
www.monument100.org and obtain his work in<br />
gratitude for a donation.)<br />
This book and its careful treatment of the<br />
Greek experience within the broader genocide of<br />
the Christian minorities in the Ottoman Empire<br />
aims to fill a gap in the scholarly literature on the<br />
Greek Genocide and is one of the first to treat<br />
the genocidal experiences of the <strong>Armenian</strong>s,<br />
Assyrians and Greeks in a comparative manner<br />
and as an integrated history. As Prof. Roger W.<br />
Smith, chair of Zoryan’s Academic Board, has<br />
written, “Only the comparative approach can<br />
yield carefully delimited generalizations about<br />
the nature and mechanics of genocide as a general<br />
problem of humanity.”<br />
<strong>The</strong> studies presented in this groundbreaking<br />
book are thoroughly documented and include<br />
revealing and previously unpublished American<br />
diplomatic reports on the destruction of<br />
Smyrna. In addition to the historical chapters,<br />
essays explore such subjects as the multigenerational<br />
effects of the Greek Genocide and the<br />
difficulties of Asia Minor refugee identity in<br />
Greece, Turkey’s present day obligations under<br />
the Treaty of Lausanne, and the challenges of<br />
Book on Transnational Literature Compares<br />
Balakian, Pamuk and Shafak<br />
of Istanbul, in what appears to be the first<br />
scholarly work comparing modern <strong>Armenian</strong><br />
and Turkish writers.<br />
In her chapter titled “<strong>The</strong> Spaces of Memory<br />
in Transnational Culture,” Koundoura explores<br />
and theorizes, using theorists Walter Benjamin,<br />
Paul de Man and Frederic Jamieson among others,<br />
the ways Pamuk and Balakian’s memoirs<br />
and Shafak’s novel engage history, memory and<br />
loss and how transnational visions of language<br />
and culture inform literature in the new global<br />
age of literature. As the book jacket notes, “this<br />
book will be invaluable for readers of cultural<br />
and post colonial studies, diaspora and globalization<br />
studies, and world literature.”<br />
Koundoura is also the editor the journal<br />
Modern Greek Studies and the author of <strong>The</strong><br />
Greek Idea: <strong>The</strong> Formation of National and<br />
Transnational Identities.<br />
obtaining recognition for the Ottoman genocides.<br />
A list of the contents is given below.<br />
Prof. Vahakn N. Dadrian, Zoryan’s director of<br />
genocide research, writes, “This book makes a<br />
valuable contribution to our understanding of<br />
the Greek experience of genocide during the<br />
early part of the 20th century and its aftermath.<br />
It shows how interrelated were the experiences<br />
of the <strong>Armenian</strong>s, Assyrians and Greeks<br />
during the end of the Ottoman Empire and the<br />
establishment of the Turkish Republic.”<br />
<strong>The</strong> contributors to the book are Shirinian;<br />
Tessa Hofmann: “<strong>The</strong> Genocide against the<br />
Christians in the Late Ottoman Period,<br />
1912–1922;” Taner Akçam: “<strong>The</strong> Greek<br />
Deportations and Massacres of 1913–1914: A<br />
Trial Run for the <strong>Armenian</strong> Genocide;”<br />
Matthias Bjørnlund: “<strong>The</strong> Persecution of<br />
Greeks and <strong>Armenian</strong>s in Smyrna, 1914–1916:<br />
A Special Case in the Course of the Late<br />
Ottoman Genocides;” Harry J. Psomiades:<br />
“Greece in Asia Minor: <strong>The</strong> Greek Naval<br />
Bombardment of Samsun [Amisos], June 7,<br />
1922;” Constantine G. Hatzidimitriou: “<strong>The</strong><br />
Destruction of Smyrna in 1922: American<br />
Sources and Turkish Responsibility;” Alexander<br />
Kitroeff: “Asia Minor Refugees in Greece: A<br />
History of Identity and Memory, 1920s–1980s;”<br />
Van Coufoudakis: “From Lausanne (1923) to<br />
Cyprus (2009): Turkey’s Violations of<br />
International Law and the Destruction of<br />
Historic Hellenic Communities” and Robert J.<br />
Pranger: “US Policy Obstacles in Recognizing<br />
the Genocides of Christian Minorities in the<br />
Late Ottoman Empire: Challenges and<br />
Opportunities.”<br />
Shirinian said, “<strong>The</strong> contributors to this volume<br />
and the Asia Minor and Pontos Hellenic<br />
Research Center hope that this wide-ranging<br />
collection of studies helps bring a measure of<br />
understanding and openness to the discussion<br />
of the Greek Genocide. This is a story of great<br />
human tragedy and suffering, of great power<br />
politics and miscalculation. By promoting<br />
awareness of this history, we hope to prevent<br />
the recurrence of another, ‘Great Catastrophe.’”<br />
To order a copy contact Zoryan at<br />
zoryan@zoryaninstitute.org.<br />
SCHOLARSHIPS AVAILABLE<br />
for<br />
Students of <strong>Armenian</strong> Descent<br />
Having Completed One Year of College by June <strong>2013</strong><br />
Application and other information may be obtained<br />
from<br />
Tibrevank Alumni, Inc.<br />
Vahan Adjemian Scholarship Fund<br />
P.O. Box 14<br />
Palisades Park, NJ 07650<br />
or<br />
www.vahanadjemianscholarship.org<br />
Deadline for returning completed applications: April 30, <strong>2013</strong>
WASHINGTON — As part of its ongoing program<br />
to promote teaching of genocide and<br />
human rights and the lessons of the <strong>Armenian</strong><br />
Genocide, the <strong>Armenian</strong> National Institute<br />
(ANI) announced the release by Routledge publishers<br />
of the fourth edition of Centuries of<br />
Genocide: Essays and Eyewitness Accounts, by<br />
Samuel Totten and William S. Parsons, the<br />
genocide and human rights studies textbook<br />
widely used in college and high school courses.<br />
<strong>The</strong> fourth edition of Centuries of Genocide:<br />
Essays and Eyewitness Accounts addresses<br />
examples of genocides perpetrated in the nineteenth,<br />
twentieth, and twenty-first centuries.<br />
Each chapter of the book is written by a recognized<br />
expert in the field.<br />
<strong>The</strong> chapter on the <strong>Armenian</strong> Genocide,<br />
which has appeared since the first edition of the<br />
publication, previously issued under the title<br />
Century of Genocide, is authored by ANI<br />
Director Dr. Rouben Adalian. For this new and<br />
expanded edition, the chapter was updated to<br />
reflect the growing scholarship on the subject.<br />
<strong>The</strong> book is framed by an introductory essay<br />
that spells out definitional issues. To help readers<br />
learn about the similarities and differences<br />
among the various cases, each case is structured<br />
around specific leading questions. In<br />
every chapter authors address: Who committed<br />
the genocide? How was the genocide committed?<br />
Why was the genocide committed? Who<br />
were the victims? What were the outstanding<br />
S A T U R D A Y, F E B R U A R Y 2 , 2 0 1 3 T H E A R M E N I A N M I R R O R - S P E C TAT O R 13<br />
historical forces? What was the long-range<br />
impact? What were the responses? How do<br />
scholars interpret this genocide? How does<br />
learning about this genocide contribute to the<br />
field of study?<br />
Dr. Maureen Hiebert from the University of<br />
Calgary, who specializes in genocide, government,<br />
politics, and international law, described<br />
ARTS & LIVING<br />
Fourth Edition of Centuries of Genocide Textbook Issued<br />
C A L E N D A R<br />
MASSACHUSETTS<br />
FEBRUARY 9 — Sisters’ Academy Annual Valentine’s Party, presenting<br />
Elie Berberian and Band, Oakley Country Club, 410 Belmont<br />
St., Watertown; information: Nageeb Diarbakerly at (617) 480-3700.<br />
FEBRUARY 23 — “Armenia Unseen — Among the Mountains,<br />
Valleys and Villages,” a visual representation by Joe Dagdigian,<br />
sponsored by the Lowell “Aharonian” Gomideh, 6 p.m., St. Gregory<br />
Church, 158 Main St., North Andover; dinner and program; update<br />
on events in Syria by Rev. Karekin Bedourian, pastor; all proceeds<br />
benefiting the Syrian-<strong>Armenian</strong> Relief Fund; $20 adults; $10 students.<br />
the publication as: “A welcome new edition to<br />
an already influential series, Centuries of<br />
Genocide adds new cases spanning the 19th to<br />
the 21st centuries and the four corners of the<br />
globe. Each chapter offers up-to-date research<br />
and analysis by some of the leading scholars in<br />
the field on the causes, processes, and aftermath<br />
of genocide, along with searing first-person<br />
eyewitness accounts that starkly illustrate<br />
the human experience, and tragic cost, of genocidal<br />
violence.”<br />
Dr. Ervin Staub of the University of<br />
Massachusetts at Amherst and author of<br />
Overcoming Evil: Genocide, Violent Conflict<br />
and Terrorism and <strong>The</strong> Roots of Evil: <strong>The</strong><br />
Origins of Genocide and Other Group<br />
Violence, comments: “In this deeply humane<br />
book, fired by the passion of the editors and<br />
authors to understand the roots of genocides so<br />
that we can prevent this scourge of humanity,<br />
eminent experts give up-to-date accounts of 15<br />
genocides. <strong>The</strong> scholarship of the authors is<br />
outstanding, the chapters in the book highly<br />
readable and compelling. While most of the<br />
chapters are about genocides in the 20th century,<br />
the book now contains chapters about<br />
genocides in the 19th century and the first<br />
genocide in the 21st Century. <strong>The</strong> personal<br />
accounts included truly reach the heart.”<br />
Co-editor of Centuries of Genocide William S.<br />
Parsons, who is chief of staff for the United<br />
States Holocaust Memorial Museum in<br />
Sponsor a Teacher in Armenia and Karabagh <strong>2013</strong><br />
Since its inception in 2001, TCA’s ‘Sponsor<br />
a Teacher’ program has raised over $563,000<br />
and reached out to 4,440 teachers and<br />
school workers in Armenia and Karabagh.<br />
✄<br />
On <strong>February</strong> 23, St. Gregory<br />
Church of North Andover, 158<br />
Main St., will host “Armenia<br />
Unseen — Among the Mountains,<br />
Valleys and Villages,” a visual<br />
representation by Joe Dagdigian.<br />
<strong>The</strong> event will take place at 6<br />
p.m., and will feature dinner and<br />
the program; all proceeds benefiting<br />
the Syrian-<strong>Armenian</strong> Relief<br />
fund; $20 adults; $10 students.<br />
❑ Yes, I want to sponsor teachers in Armenia and Karabagh to continue<br />
helping them to educate the children, our future leaders. I would like to have<br />
the teacher’s name and address.<br />
❑ $160<br />
Name<br />
Address<br />
❑ $ 320 ❑ $ 480 ❑ other $—————————<br />
City<br />
Tel:<br />
State Zip code<br />
Make check payable to: Tekeyan Cultural Association – Memo: Sponsor a Teacher 2010<br />
Mail your check with this form to:<br />
TCA Sponsor a Teacher<br />
5326 Valverde, Houston, TX 77056<br />
Your donation is Tax Deductible.<br />
Washington, DC, has devoted 30 years of his<br />
career to Holocaust education. In 1991,<br />
Parsons was invited to join the Museum’s<br />
Education Committee to share his innovative<br />
ideas for teaching about prejudice and racism.<br />
He is also the co-author of the teachers’ guide<br />
Facing History and Ourselves: Holocaust and<br />
Human Behavior.<br />
Dr. Samuel Totten, University of Arkansas,<br />
Fayetteville, professor of Curriculum and<br />
Instruction, has written extensively on teaching,<br />
preventing, intervening and documenting<br />
genocide. He is the author of Teaching About<br />
Genocide, Dictionary of Genocide, co-editor<br />
with Steven Jacobs of Pioneers of Genocide<br />
Studies, which included a contribution by<br />
Adalian, and was an associate editor with<br />
Adalian, Jacobs, and Eric Markusen of the<br />
Encyclopedia of Genocide under the chief editorship<br />
of Israel W. Charny, executive director<br />
of the Institute on the Holocaust and Genocide<br />
in Jerusalem. Totten is also the co-founding editor<br />
of Genocide Studies and Prevention: An<br />
International Journal published by the<br />
University of Toronto Press and the Zoryan<br />
Institute. During the summer of 2004, Totten<br />
served as one of the 24 investigators with the<br />
US State Department’s Atrocities<br />
Documentation Project, interviewing black<br />
African refugees along the Chad/Sudan border<br />
in order to collect data for the express purpose<br />
of ascertaining whether genocide had been perpetrated<br />
in Darfur.<br />
As part of its continuing service to educators<br />
and to coincide with the release of Centuries of<br />
Genocide, ANI has expanded its Resource<br />
Guide and other sections of the Education component<br />
of the ANI website. Dozens of resources<br />
selected for their instructional value are listed<br />
for the benefit of students and teachers.<br />
Educators interested in teaching about the role<br />
of American humanitarianism and involvement<br />
in responding to the <strong>Armenian</strong> crisis can also<br />
benefit from the recently issued fact sheet summarizing<br />
“<strong>The</strong> United States Record on the<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong> Genocide: A Proud Chapter in<br />
American History,” prepared by the <strong>Armenian</strong><br />
Assembly of America.<br />
Author Margaret Ajemian<br />
Ahnert Speaks at<br />
Pepperdine University<br />
MALIBU, Calif. — On Wednesday November<br />
14, Margaret Ajemian Ahnert, presented her<br />
book, <strong>The</strong> Knock at the Door, a mother-daughter<br />
survival story, at Pepperdine University.<br />
Ahnert, a member of the National League of<br />
American Pen Women and an award-winning<br />
author, spoke to a crowd of more than 200 hundred<br />
students.<br />
<strong>The</strong> event opened with a brief screening of an<br />
interview with Ahnert conducted by Chuck<br />
Margaret Ajemian Ahnert<br />
Scarborough of NBC television in September<br />
2012, in which Ahnert discusses her own mother’s<br />
Genocide survival story.<br />
<strong>The</strong> event was followed by a question and<br />
answer period, during which, Ahnert discussed<br />
her relationship with her mother and her own<br />
experiences confronting Genocide deniers during<br />
her five-year book tour.
14 S A T U R D A Y, F E B R U A R Y 2 , 2 0 1 3 T H E A R M E N I A N M I R R O R - S P E C TAT O R<br />
<strong>Mirror</strong>-<br />
T H E A R M E N I A N<br />
<strong>Spectator</strong><br />
Established 1932<br />
An ADL Publication<br />
EDITOR<br />
Alin K. Gregorian<br />
ASSISTANT EDITOR<br />
Gabriella Gage<br />
ASSOCIATE EDITOR<br />
Aram Arkun<br />
ART DIRECTOR<br />
Marc Mgrditchian<br />
SENIOR EDITORIAL COLUMNIST:<br />
Edmond Azadian<br />
CONTRIBUTORS:<br />
Florence Avakian, Elizabeth Aprahamian,<br />
Daphne Abeel, Dr. Haroutiune<br />
Arzoumanian, Taleen Babayan, Prof.<br />
Vahakn N. Dadrian, Diana Der<br />
Hovanessian, Philip Ketchian, Kevork<br />
Keushkerian, Sonia Kailian-Placido,<br />
Harut Sassounian, Mary Terzian, Hagop<br />
Vartivarian, Naomi Zeytoonian<br />
CORRESPONDENTS:<br />
Armenia - Hagop Avedikian<br />
Boston - Nancy Kalajian<br />
Philadelphia - Lisa Manookian<br />
Contributing Photographers:<br />
Jacob Demirdjian, Harry Koundakjian, Jirair<br />
Hovsepian<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Armenian</strong> <strong>Mirror</strong>-<strong>Spectator</strong> is published<br />
weekly, except two weeks in July, by:<br />
Baikar Association, Inc.<br />
755 Mt. Auburn St., Watertown, MA 02472-1509<br />
Telephone: 617-924-4420<br />
FAX: 617-924-2887<br />
www. mir rorspectator. com<br />
E-Mail: editor@mirrorspectator.com<br />
For advertising: mirrorads@aol.com<br />
SUBSCRIPTION RATES:<br />
U.S.A. $80 a year<br />
Canada $125 a year<br />
Other Countries $190 a year<br />
© 2011 <strong>The</strong> <strong>Armenian</strong> <strong>Mirror</strong>-<strong>Spectator</strong><br />
Periodical Class Postage Paid at Boston, MA<br />
and additional mailing offices.<br />
ISSN 0004-234X<br />
POSTMASTER: Send address changes to <strong>The</strong><br />
<strong>Armenian</strong> <strong>Mirror</strong>-<strong>Spectator</strong>, P.O. Box 302,<br />
Watertown, MA 02471-0302<br />
Other than the editorial, views and opinions<br />
expressed in this newspaper do not necessarily<br />
eflect the policies of the publisher.<br />
Copying for other than personal use or<br />
internal reference is prohibited without<br />
express permission of the copyright<br />
owner. Address requests for reprints or<br />
back issues to:<br />
Baikar Association, Inc.<br />
755 Mt. Auburn St., Watertown, MA 02472-1509<br />
COMMENTARY<br />
A Thaw in <strong>Armenian</strong>-Georgian Relations<br />
By Edmond Y. Azadian<br />
During the Soviet era, <strong>Armenian</strong>-Georgian relations could not be<br />
anything except what Kremlin rulers prescribed for the region. But<br />
the undercurrent resentments continued to run deep down for a<br />
variety of reasons. For centuries <strong>Armenian</strong>s represented the business<br />
elite in Georgia. <strong>The</strong>y also built the capital city of Tbilisi,<br />
which, before the Bolshevik revolution of 1917 was called the<br />
“Paris of Caucasus.” When the revolution swept the region,<br />
Georgia was in a very unique situation, because, under the guise<br />
of the proletariat taking over the wealth of the bourgeoisie, the<br />
Georgians usurped the properties of the <strong>Armenian</strong>s.<br />
Throughout the Soviet period, the Tbilisi government implemented<br />
an almost identical policy towards Javakhk which Azeris<br />
were implementing in Karabagh, leaving the two ancient <strong>Armenian</strong><br />
regions under the authority of Georgia and Azerbaijan, respectively,<br />
underdeveloped. <strong>The</strong> poverty of Javakhk <strong>Armenian</strong>s today is the<br />
legacy of that discriminatory policy.<br />
After the collapse of the Soviet Empire, the undercurrent of<br />
mutual resentment floated to the surface.<br />
Successive leaders like Shevardnadze, Gamsakhurdia and<br />
Saakashvili pursued a policy of depopulating the <strong>Armenian</strong><br />
regions. <strong>The</strong>y further threatened to bring the exiled Meskhetian<br />
Turks from Central Asia and settle them in Javakhk. That was a<br />
two-throng policy to please the Turks in Ankara and Baku as well<br />
as scare the indigenous <strong>Armenian</strong>s. Almost 200,000 <strong>Armenian</strong>s<br />
emigrated from Georgia after its independence. To be fair, the emigration<br />
cannot be attributed solely to the policies of the government,<br />
since a larger ratio has also left the Republic of Armenia as<br />
well.<br />
Although there are five <strong>Armenian</strong> members in the Georgian<br />
Parliament, their clout is minimal. <strong>The</strong>y are insensitive to the needs<br />
and the problems of the <strong>Armenian</strong> community, very much like the<br />
Amiras in the Ottoman era, who tended to preserve their own turf.<br />
Although Georgia and Armenia are the only two Christian<br />
nations in the Caucasus region, their relations have been cool, to<br />
say the least. Georgia has not yet recognized the <strong>Armenian</strong><br />
Genocide and has persistently voted along with Azerbaijan at the<br />
UN.<br />
<strong>The</strong> continuing cold war also has its impact in the region. As<br />
much as Armenia is considered a vanguard post for Russia in the<br />
Caucasus, Georgia similarly is considered a vanguard post of<br />
NATO, albeit a virtual one. Through the direct aid and investments,<br />
the European Union and the US have tried to make Georgia a<br />
showcase for the West. And the US-trained Saakashvili tried to<br />
uproot the corruption endemic throughout the former Soviet<br />
republics, but recent scandals have revealed that the reforms have<br />
been achieved at a heavy cost and brutal and repressive measures.<br />
Those scandals cost President Saakashvili the recent parliamentary<br />
elections, and led to the emergence of the billionaire Bidzina<br />
Ivanishvili as the new prime minister. Cohabitation has seen some<br />
tensions between the two leaders, especially when the new prime<br />
minister began a purge of the adherents of the president’s party.<br />
During these developments, Patriarch Ilya II switched his allegiance<br />
to the winning side, Ivanishvili’s Georgian Dream party.<br />
Ivanishvili began his foreign policy with regards to the <strong>Armenian</strong><br />
Republic on the wrong foot, through an untoward remark, but he<br />
has taken corrective action since.<br />
Preserving the <strong>Armenian</strong><br />
Language at Home and<br />
Abroad<br />
To <strong>The</strong> Editor:<br />
I was just reading in the January 26 edition<br />
of the <strong>Armenian</strong> <strong>Mirror</strong>-<strong>Spectator</strong> about a<br />
family that came from Syria to live in Armenia<br />
and found it easier to learn and speak Russian<br />
in Armenia to get around.<br />
<strong>The</strong>y found a lot of words were in Russian<br />
Notice to Contributors<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Armenian</strong> <strong>Mirror</strong>-<strong>Spectator</strong> welcomes articles, commentaries and community<br />
news from our readers. In order to assure the accurate and timely publication of articles<br />
submitted, please note the following policies:<br />
— All articles submitted should be typed, double (or triple) spaced and printed in a type size<br />
large enough to be clearly legible (10 point or larger). Submissions that do not conform to<br />
these specifications will be assigned lowest priority.<br />
— Articles sent by fax are acceptable, and e-mail submissions are encouraged.<br />
— All submissions should include the name of a contact person and a daytime<br />
COMMENTARY<br />
LETTERS<br />
rather than <strong>Armenian</strong>.<br />
I am sick to read that <strong>Armenian</strong>s in Armenia<br />
know less of their native <strong>Armenian</strong> language<br />
than they do Russian.<br />
When I visited Armenia in August 2009, I<br />
thought my speaking Western <strong>Armenian</strong> was<br />
the reason they could not understand me. As<br />
it turned out, they could not speak their own<br />
native language, which I thought was<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong>.<br />
I know that <strong>Armenian</strong>s that come here from<br />
Armenia to get their driver’s licenses take<br />
their driving test in Russian instead of<br />
His recent visit to Armenia marked a definite thaw in the relations<br />
between the two neighbors. A symbolic gesture was the<br />
release of Javakhk political prisoner Vahakn Chakhalian, who had<br />
been jailed on trumped-up charges at a kangaroo court and sentenced<br />
to a 10-year term.<br />
Going beyond symbolism, Ivanishvili discussed the possibility of<br />
reactivating the Abkhazian rail system, which will benefit Armenia<br />
economically and help Russia to transport goods to the region.<br />
<strong>The</strong> idea is, of course, an anathema to the previous administration,<br />
which refuses to do any business with Abkhazia, as long as<br />
its remains outside of Tbilisi’s jurisdiction. <strong>The</strong>refore, it was not a<br />
surprise to hear Saakashvili’s public rebuke of the idea. He also<br />
raised hell for Chakhalian’s release.<br />
<strong>The</strong> prime minister also praised Georgian <strong>Armenian</strong>s for their<br />
loyalty and their contributions to the country. He said that there<br />
are 300,000 <strong>Armenian</strong>s living in Georgia, although that figure may<br />
be much more, but Ivanishvili was relying on their votes during the<br />
next election.<br />
Besides President Saakashvili, Georgia’s foreign minister also<br />
made a hostile remark, while his superior was still in Yerevan. He<br />
stated that Georgia would see the Karabagh problem resolved with<br />
the territorial integrity of Azerbaijan intact.<br />
Georgia has developed complex relations with Azerbaijan and<br />
Turkey. <strong>The</strong> former provides cheap gas and the latter has made<br />
substantive investments in Georgia. It will not be easy to wean<br />
Tbilisi from those two nations, as much as the new Georgian leader<br />
is seeking to improve the relations with Moscow.<br />
Georgian-<strong>Armenian</strong> relations have not always been warm, but<br />
since the August 2008 war with Russia, they have even been more<br />
inflamed, as the Tbilisi administration considers Yerevan as the<br />
base for Russian influence in the region. And for that very same<br />
reason, Ivanishvili’s visit to Armenia was interpreted as testing the<br />
waters to find out the potential of an eventual rapprochement with<br />
Moscow.<br />
Georgia is a vital link for Armenia’s foreign trade as 70 percent<br />
of overland transportation of goods transit through the Georgian<br />
territory. Yet the road system still remains precarious, since several<br />
months in the year, the roads are snow-covered, especially in the<br />
region of Upper Larse. <strong>The</strong> project of digging an expensive tunnel<br />
through those mountains still remains on the drawing board. Once<br />
the Georgian authorities realize the dividends of the project, they<br />
may act on it and the corollary beneficiary will become Armenia.<br />
At this time, there is a cautious movement towards normalizing<br />
relations between the two neighbors. No matter how willing or sincere<br />
Ivanishvili may be, he has yet to consolidate his power in the<br />
country. He may launch an adventurous political course when he<br />
fully holds the reigns of the power in his country.<br />
Another debate which is raging simultaneously in the region is<br />
the opening of the Stepanakert Airport for civil aviation, a project<br />
which the Azeris oppose violently. Armenia cannot risk a retaliation<br />
by beginning to operate the airport, especially since some<br />
members of the European Union may consider that move as a<br />
“provocation.” But once Russia decides that a strategic asset right<br />
next to the Iranian border is being threatened, they may join forces<br />
with Karabagh to thwart the Azeri threat, especially after the abandonment<br />
of the Kabala Station in the Azeri territory.<br />
After facing so much economic and military pressure, Armenia<br />
would welcome a respite. If the Georgians move in a positive direction<br />
toward Armenia, that move will certainly be guided by their<br />
self-interest, yet Armenia will benefit from the thaw.<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong> because it is easier for them. This I<br />
know for a fact.<br />
We <strong>Armenian</strong>s should learn to stand on our<br />
own two feet and not lean on Russia’s shoulder.<br />
I am a proud <strong>Armenian</strong>, but when I read<br />
stories like this, I am saddened that we have<br />
become this low.<br />
I remember why my grandparents, uncles,<br />
aunts and cousins died. <strong>The</strong>y died to keep<br />
their <strong>Armenian</strong> language and their Christian<br />
faith.<br />
–Mel Menasian<br />
Methuen, Mass<br />
telephone number.<br />
— Deadline for submission of all articles and advertising is 12 noon on Monday of the<br />
week of publication.<br />
— Photos will be published without charge at the discretion of the editors and art director.<br />
Photos will be returned only if a self-addressed and stamped envelope is included.<br />
— <strong>The</strong> M-S will publish only one article about an upcoming organizational event. For<br />
major special events, exceptions may be made only by special arrangement with the<br />
editors.<br />
— Telephone numbers, ticket prices and other details (at the discretion of the editors) will<br />
not be included in press releases, but should be reserved for calendar listings and advertisements.
Turkey Should Be Kept in the<br />
Dark on <strong>Armenian</strong> Genocide<br />
Centennial Plans<br />
It is no secret that <strong>Armenian</strong> communities around the<br />
world are busy planning scores of projects for the 100th<br />
anniversary of the <strong>Armenian</strong> Genocide on April 24, 2015.<br />
It is also no secret that the Turkish government and its<br />
agents are closely monitoring all announced <strong>Armenian</strong><br />
plans, so Ankara can prepare its counter-moves to the anticipated<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong> “tsunami.”<br />
By publicizing their plans more than two years before<br />
the centennial, <strong>Armenian</strong>s would be providing Turkish<br />
denialists valuable intelligence and sufficient lead-time to<br />
figure out how best to disrupt <strong>Armenian</strong> commemorative<br />
activities.<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong>s must realize that succeeding Turkish governments<br />
have had a long history of genocide denial. In fact,<br />
the crime of genocide and its cover up were designed simultaneously<br />
almost a century ago by the Young Turk regime.<br />
Furthermore, as a powerful state, Turkey is eager and willing<br />
to use its considerable resources to counter <strong>Armenian</strong><br />
political initiatives around the globe. Ankara routinely pressures,<br />
threatens, and even blackmails all individuals, orga-<br />
By Raffi Bedrosyan<br />
S A T U R D A Y, F E B R U A R Y 2 , 2 0 1 3 T H E A R M E N I A N M I R R O R - S P E C TAT O R 15<br />
My Turn<br />
By Harut Sassounian<br />
On the sixth anniversary of his assassination<br />
and more significantly, on the sixth<br />
anniversary of the Turkish state’s inability or<br />
unwillingness to find his real killers, Hrant<br />
Dink was remembered by tens of thousands<br />
of people in many countries and in Turkey,<br />
including Istanbul, Ankara, Izmir, Diyarbakir,<br />
Malatya and Bodrum. International, Turkish<br />
and <strong>Armenian</strong> speakers reiterated his vision<br />
and message of direct dialogue between<br />
Turks and <strong>Armenian</strong>s. Year by year, instead<br />
of gradually diminishing in numbers toward<br />
oblivion as is the case for other assassinated<br />
journalists in Turkey, there is a snowballing<br />
increase in number and intensity of people<br />
attending the Dink commemorations,<br />
protesting and demanding justice, as well as<br />
adopting Dink’s messages with more determination.<br />
It is not the tiny <strong>Armenian</strong> community<br />
in Turkey, but Turks (and Kurds)<br />
from all walks of life who have embraced<br />
Dink as a tragic hero.<br />
<strong>The</strong> momentum is building to declare Dink<br />
a martyr, in fact, the first shared martyr by<br />
historically opposing nations Armenia and<br />
Turkey.<br />
But what exactly was Dink’s message? He<br />
would define <strong>Armenian</strong>s and Turks as two<br />
sick people, clinical cases, <strong>Armenian</strong>s suffering<br />
from trauma (obsessed with 1915), Turks suffering<br />
from paranoia (fear of consequences of<br />
acknowledging 1915). He would advocate<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong>s and Turks to be each other’s doctors,<br />
with dialogue as the only prescription.<br />
And he would clap his large hands vigorously,<br />
exclaiming that “there is no other medicine,<br />
no other doctor, no, no, no.”<br />
He knew dialogue would be useless if one<br />
couldn’t discuss the painful 1915, but only<br />
pleasant subjects such as Turks and<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong>s’ shared values, shared culture,<br />
shared foods like dolma and kebab. He knew<br />
that dialogue would also be useless if one is<br />
unable to really ‘listen and hear,’ in addition<br />
to talking. And most importantly, he knew<br />
that dialogue would be useless if one didn’t<br />
know the real historical facts of 1915. After<br />
being systematically brainwashed by the<br />
COMMENTARY<br />
nizations, and states that acknowledge the facts of the<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong> Genocide.<br />
A small example of such ominous developments<br />
occurred recently when a production team announced<br />
plans to make a major movie on the <strong>Armenian</strong> Genocide,<br />
based on Micheline Aharonian Marcom’s novel, Three<br />
Apples Fell from Heaven. Sona Tatoyan, the film’s producer,<br />
gave an interview to a Turkish newspaper while visiting<br />
Istanbul last month, probably unaware that the<br />
Turkish media is notorious for distorting <strong>Armenian</strong><br />
Genocide related topics. Ms. Tatoyan was fortunate that she<br />
was interviewed by Radikal, one of Turkey’s more reputable<br />
newspapers, known for its liberal views on the<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong> Genocide. Even then, there were some minor distortions<br />
in Radikal’s report. What made matters worse was<br />
the translation of the Tatoyan interview into English by a<br />
little-known website called Al-Monitor, seriously distorting<br />
her views.<br />
For example, Ms. Tatoyan’s statement to Radikal, that<br />
the bones of Genocide victims were protruding from the<br />
sands of the Syrian desert in Der Zor and Ras al-Ayn, was<br />
misrepresented by Al-Monitor as: “We were crushing skulls<br />
and tossing bones.” Worse yet, Al-Monitor falsely quoted<br />
Ms. Tatoyan stating: “<strong>The</strong>y [<strong>Armenian</strong>s] should forget the<br />
Genocide.” In reality, she had said: “Making peace with<br />
Anatolia, with Turks, does not mean forgetting the genocide<br />
or condoning the politics of denial in Turkey.”<br />
Ms. Tatoyan was naturally upset by the distortions of her<br />
deeply held convictions on the <strong>Armenian</strong> Genocide. In a<br />
subsequent interview with Asbarez newspaper, she categorically<br />
denied having ever told <strong>Armenian</strong>s to forget the<br />
genocide. “I have not made such a statement. How could I<br />
have? How could I have said anything like that in an interview<br />
about a film on the <strong>Armenian</strong> Genocide I am helping<br />
create?”<br />
state with ever changing official versions of<br />
1915 history, people in Turkey have now<br />
finally started to learn the true historic facts,<br />
reasons and consequences of 1915, not a socalled<br />
Turkish version versus <strong>Armenian</strong> version.<br />
So, if and when there is willingness to<br />
talk and listen, both sides can and should<br />
engage in direct dialogue, without the need<br />
to convince third parties to pressure the<br />
other side.<br />
Dink studied zoology and he would explain<br />
that if you remove any living organism from<br />
its natural environment, you would cause its<br />
extinction. He would then say: “If you<br />
remove an entire people from its land where<br />
it has lived continuously for 3000 years, even<br />
if you transport them with great care in ‘golden<br />
airplanes,’ this would still be similar to<br />
taking an axe to the roots of an ancient tree.”<br />
He didn’t need to explain 1915 with long<br />
words; in a corner of Agos, every week, he<br />
would place some facts about a village or<br />
town in Anatolia, could be in the west, east,<br />
north, south or central Anatolia, giving the<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong> and total population numbers, the<br />
names and numbers of churches and schools<br />
there before 1915. He would have photos of<br />
these active <strong>Armenian</strong> churches and schools<br />
in that village or town before 1915, and photos<br />
of these non-existent churches or schools<br />
today, totaling more than 4000 buildings.<br />
That would be enough for anyone to understand<br />
the reality of 1915.<br />
But he wouldn’t only talk about the<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong>s gone or dead in 1915. He would<br />
be much more interested in talking about the<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong>s who remained, who stayed in<br />
Anatolia, those people who stayed and survived,<br />
but no longer as <strong>Armenian</strong>s. <strong>The</strong>se<br />
were the <strong>Armenian</strong>s who stayed and survived,<br />
by converting to Islam, by assimilating<br />
into Turkish, Kurdish or Alawi identities.<br />
<strong>The</strong>se were the <strong>Armenian</strong> girls and boys captured<br />
or sold, kept hidden, protected or married<br />
to Turks and Kurds. <strong>The</strong>se were some<br />
entire <strong>Armenian</strong> villages that converted to<br />
Islam, or stayed protected by friendly<br />
Kurdish and Alawi leaders.<br />
Dink was obsessed with this subject. What<br />
happened to these people? Did they secretly<br />
keep their <strong>Armenian</strong> identity? Did they pass<br />
it on to the next generations? Where are they<br />
now? How many are there? If there are hidden<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong>s, what would be the trigger<br />
for them to come out of hiding?<br />
Genocide is not a single event but a continuous<br />
process. It is not only denial of a<br />
genocide that continues it, but assimilation<br />
and conversion also continue it. Scholars<br />
have recently started defining genocide not<br />
only as destruction of the oppressed nation,<br />
but also construction of the oppressor nation<br />
— using assimilation and conversion processes.<br />
For <strong>Armenian</strong>s, these processes continued<br />
on all fronts.<br />
Dink didn’t or couldn’t write much about<br />
this sensitive subject, but he was preoccupied<br />
by it, gathering stories, anecdotal evidence,<br />
always encouraging others to find out more.<br />
Obviously, this was not a subject that could<br />
be researched openly and scientifically, but<br />
whenever a new revelation came out about<br />
hidden <strong>Armenian</strong>s in Anatolia, he would get<br />
excited. His lawyer, Fethiye Cetin’s My<br />
Grandmother was only an example of the<br />
fate of the hidden <strong>Armenian</strong>s. In an interview<br />
with London filmmaker Nouritsa Matossian<br />
for the documentary “Hrant Dink: A Heart<br />
Of Two Nations,” Nouritsa asked him: “Do<br />
you see <strong>Armenian</strong> faces in Anatolia?” Dink:<br />
“Yes, often.” Nouritsa: “Apparitions.” Dink:<br />
“Apparitions and real ones.”<br />
<strong>The</strong> answer to the question that kept him wondering<br />
— what would be the trigger for the hidden<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong>s to come out, came four years too<br />
late for Dink to witness unfortunately.<br />
<strong>The</strong> trigger was the reconstruction of the<br />
Diyarbakir Surp Giragos Church in 2011.<br />
Thousands of Anatolian people, young and<br />
old, Turkish and Kurdish in appearance and<br />
identity, returned to their <strong>Armenian</strong> roots<br />
with the reopening of this church. Some<br />
were baptized in the church, some changed<br />
their Turkish names to <strong>Armenian</strong> originals,<br />
some changed their identity to <strong>Armenian</strong> but<br />
remained Moslem (a new phenomenon of<br />
Moslem <strong>Armenian</strong>s,) some started learning<br />
the <strong>Armenian</strong> language.<br />
Dink would have danced with joy to see an<br />
eleven year old Kurdish girl, not only learning<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong> but also singing <strong>Armenian</strong><br />
songs at the first <strong>Armenian</strong> concert in the<br />
Diyarbakir Surp Giragos Church in 2012.<br />
Dink would have danced on the table, as he<br />
Since Al-Monitor’s article was in English, most non-<br />
Turkish speakers read the distorted version of Ms.<br />
Tatoyan’s interview, which was widely disseminated on the<br />
internet. Many readers were terribly disappointed by what<br />
they thought were her views on the <strong>Armenian</strong> Genocide.<br />
This is a serious blow to her efforts because making a<br />
major movie is a costly undertaking that requires a huge<br />
investment. When potential financial supporters are turned<br />
off, it could have a devastating impact on the future of her<br />
project.<br />
However, Ms. Tatoyan remains deeply committed to her<br />
film. She realizes that “during the production of the film,<br />
there will be constant attempts to distract us, to take our<br />
attention away from our goal of producing a great historical<br />
epic film on the <strong>Armenian</strong> Genocide. <strong>The</strong> best way to<br />
counter such attempts is to stay focused on the film and<br />
produce it for the world to see. <strong>The</strong> film speaks for itself,”<br />
she told Asbarez.<br />
It is unclear if the distortions of Ms. Tatoyan’s interview<br />
resulted from poor translation or intentionally done to<br />
undermine a major movie on the <strong>Armenian</strong> Genocide.<br />
Nevertheless, between now and April 24, 2015, <strong>Armenian</strong>s<br />
could encounter a multitude of sinister Turkish schemes to<br />
quash <strong>Armenian</strong> initiatives aiming to demand justice from<br />
Turkey.<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong>s should be alert and circumspect in publicizing<br />
their plans for the 100th anniversary of the <strong>Armenian</strong><br />
Genocide. Very few details should be disclosed to the public<br />
during the planning stages of special events and projects.<br />
<strong>The</strong> Turkish government should be prevented from<br />
learning about planned <strong>Armenian</strong> activities as much as possible<br />
in order to deny Ankara advance knowledge and time<br />
to counter and undermine <strong>Armenian</strong> righteous demands<br />
on the centennial of one of the 20th century’s most<br />
heinous crimes against humanity.<br />
About Hrant, the Anatolian <strong>Armenian</strong><br />
was photographed on a happy occasion, to<br />
see a thousand people from Adiyaman,<br />
Amasya, Arapkir, Dersim, Diyarbakir, Elazig,<br />
Harput, Hemshin, Istanbul, Kastamonu,<br />
Kayseri, Malatya, Musadagh, Sason, Sinop,<br />
Sivas, Tokat, Van and Yozgat organize activities<br />
together to celebrate the Surp Hagop<br />
Day, singing <strong>Armenian</strong> songs, even though<br />
none knew how to speak <strong>Armenian</strong>.<br />
Dink was an Anatolian <strong>Armenian</strong> and<br />
wished to have the same democratic rights as<br />
all other citizens of the state, without being<br />
excluded, without being discriminated, without<br />
being pressured to lose his identity.<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong>s wished to have exactly the same<br />
things 100 years ago — no more, no less. <strong>The</strong><br />
state felt threatened and when fear was combined<br />
with opportunity, it wiped out the<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong> identity in Anatolia to build a<br />
Turkish identity to the exclusion of all others,<br />
including Greeks, Assyrians and Kurds.<br />
<strong>The</strong> enormous transfer of wealth and<br />
assets from the <strong>Armenian</strong>s to the Turks has<br />
added to the fear and paranoia of the state in<br />
facing its past. A new Turkish identity, which<br />
does not fear threatened from the diversity of<br />
minority identities, needs to be created in<br />
Turkey in order to face both the past and the<br />
future. <strong>The</strong> state has finally started this<br />
process with the Kurds, but not the<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong>s. <strong>The</strong> Kurds have started this<br />
process with the <strong>Armenian</strong>s, openly acknowledging<br />
their role in 1915, and starting to<br />
make amends. It is hoped that Turks will see<br />
the light and follow them.<br />
(Raffi Bedrosyan is a civil engineer as<br />
well as a concert pianist, living in Toronto.<br />
For the past several years, he has donated<br />
proceeds from his concerts and CDs to the<br />
construction of school, highway, water and<br />
gas projects in Armenia and Karabagh —<br />
projects in which he also participated as a<br />
voluntary engineer. He helped organize<br />
the Diyarbakir/ Dikranagerd Surp Giragos<br />
Church reconstruction project, and with<br />
his articles, he promoted the significance<br />
of this historic project as the first<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong> reclaim of church properties in<br />
Anatolia after 1915. In September 2012, he<br />
gave the first <strong>Armenian</strong> piano concert in<br />
the Surp Giragos Church since 1915.)
16<br />
By Gayane Mkrtchyan<br />
Armenia’s government appears to be dragging<br />
its feet over changing the rules for military<br />
conscription, a year after a pan-European<br />
court ruled that Jehovah’s Witnesses had been<br />
mistreated as conscientious objectors.<br />
In November 2011, the European Court of<br />
Human Rights (ECHR) ruled that Armenia<br />
should pay compensation to 17 men who were<br />
detained and wrongly accused of desertion.<br />
In 2005, the men withdrew from a civilian<br />
service scheme intended to give committed<br />
pacifists like Jehovah’s Witnesses an alternative<br />
to mandatory conscription. Civilian service<br />
had been launched the previous year as<br />
part of Armenia’s obligations as a Council of<br />
Europe member.<br />
<strong>The</strong> men were assigned civilian work in<br />
schools, hospitals and elsewhere, but left six<br />
months later when they realized they were<br />
actually under military command, something<br />
that went against their absolute commitment<br />
to pacifism.<br />
“We were told this was civilian service, but<br />
it turned out to be military after all,” said Hayk<br />
Khachatryan, one of the 17 men who were<br />
arrested, held in detention for months and<br />
charged with desertion.<br />
<strong>The</strong> ECHR found that since Armenia had no<br />
legislation that made it a crime to withdraw<br />
from alternative service, detaining and charging<br />
the men was unlawful.<br />
In response to the ruling, the <strong>Armenian</strong> government<br />
acknowledged that military control of<br />
civilian service was a problem, and began<br />
drafting changes to the law in March 2012.<br />
<strong>The</strong> amendments now being proposed<br />
would differentiate between “alternative mili-<br />
S A T U R D A Y, F E B R U A R Y 2 , 2 0 1 3 T H E A R M E N I A N M I R R O R - S P E C TAT O R<br />
Armenia Slow to Pass Conscientious Objection<br />
Law for Jehovah’s Witnesses<br />
tary service” and “alternative labor service” —<br />
the latter structured to rule out any military<br />
involvement, so that the most committed of<br />
conscientious objectors could take part.<br />
Alternative military service would last 30<br />
months and alternative labor service 36<br />
months, as opposed to the standard two years<br />
served by conscript soldiers.<br />
Ten months on, it is unclear when the draft<br />
amendments will be completed by the Justice<br />
Ministry committee tasked with producing<br />
them.<br />
Artur Ispiryan, who works for the legal<br />
department of the Jehovah’s Witnesses, said,<br />
“<strong>The</strong> first version of the bill said that regional<br />
governors would oversee alternative service…<br />
but that point was removed. At the moment, it<br />
isn’t clear what this will be replaced with, but<br />
it’s essential that supervision is exclusively<br />
civilian in nature. That isn’t just what we want;<br />
it’s an international standard.”<br />
According to the Jehovah’s Witnesses,<br />
around 30 of their members are currently in<br />
jail for refusing to perform military service.<br />
Courts in Armenia are currently reviewing 25<br />
cases, so further convictions are possible.<br />
Several dozen Jehovah’s Witnesses still have<br />
complaints pending at the ECHR, and the government<br />
has asked them to withdraw their<br />
cases while the law is changed.<br />
Stepan Danielyan, head of the Cooperation<br />
for Democracy Centre, believes the government<br />
remains wary of changing the law, even<br />
though the ECHR ruling made it clear this<br />
was essential.<br />
“<strong>The</strong> delay stems from the fact that the<br />
Defense Ministry and the government have no<br />
clear idea about what to do with the law,”<br />
Danielyan said. “<strong>The</strong>y don’t want a conflict<br />
with the OSCE or with other international<br />
organizations. But on the other hand, passing<br />
the legal amendments could be risky because<br />
there are also other people who don’t want to<br />
do military service out of conviction.”<br />
Alexander Amaryan heads the Centre for<br />
Assistance and Rehabilitation for Victims of<br />
Destructive Sects, which is hostile to the<br />
Jehovah’s Witnesses, and he claims that conscription-age<br />
men join the group simply to get<br />
out of joining the army.<br />
“For young people who don’t want to serve<br />
in the army, the easiest way of avoiding it is to<br />
join the Jehovah’s Witnesses,” he said.<br />
<strong>The</strong> Jehovah’s Witnesses say they are happy<br />
to provide membership lists to show that this<br />
is not the case.<br />
“It isn’t that easy to become a Jehovah’s<br />
Witness,” Ispiryan said in response to the allegation<br />
of fraudulent members. “<strong>The</strong>re have<br />
been no cases of this.”<br />
Trainee priests of the <strong>Armenian</strong> Apostolic<br />
Church, the country’s main faith group, are<br />
able to avoid conscription. But church<br />
spokesman Vahram Melikyan insisted that<br />
Apostolic Church clergy should not be compared<br />
with others who decided not to join the<br />
military.<br />
In addition, he said, “<strong>The</strong>re are cases where<br />
our students don’t take up their exemption<br />
and go off to serve in the army for two years,<br />
and then return to continue their [seminary]<br />
education.”<br />
Avetik Ishkhanyan, head of the <strong>Armenian</strong><br />
Helsinki Group, said the government should<br />
focus on real draft-dodgers. Official figures<br />
show that since 2002, about 10,000 people<br />
have avoided conscription, and only 444 of<br />
them were Jehovah’s Witnesses.<br />
(Gayane Mkrtchyan is a journalist with<br />
ArmeniaNow.com. This column was written<br />
for the Institute for War and Peadce Reporting<br />
[IWPR.])<br />
Dubai Firm to Invest in<br />
<strong>Armenian</strong> Rail Project<br />
DUBAI (ConstructionWeekOnline) — A<br />
Dubai-based investment firm is to play a<br />
key role in establishing a new $3-billion<br />
high speed rail and road projects in the<br />
Republic of Armenia.<br />
Rasia, which has offices in Emirates<br />
Towers, is leading a consortium of companies<br />
which will work on the Southern<br />
Armenia Railway and Southern Armenia<br />
High Speed Road Projects, Gagik<br />
Beglaryan, minister of transport and communication,<br />
announced.<br />
He said in a statement that a tripartite<br />
memorandum of understanding has been<br />
signed between Rasia, South Caucasus<br />
Railway, and the Ministry of Transport<br />
and Communication of the Republic of<br />
Armenia.<br />
<strong>The</strong> Southern Armenia Railway is set to<br />
be a 316-kilometer-long electrified single<br />
track railway, which will connect Gavar,<br />
near Lake Sevan, to the southern border<br />
of Armenia by Meghri and will be integrated<br />
with the existing central railway<br />
system of Armenia.<br />
It will be operated by South Caucasus<br />
Railway and the operating railway system<br />
of Iran, the statement said.<br />
<strong>The</strong> Southern Armenia High Speed<br />
Road is to be constructed in the southern<br />
province of Syunik, and will be a 110-kilometer-long<br />
expressway connecting Sisian<br />
to Meghri.<br />
Both projects will play a role in improving<br />
regional connectivity, driving economic<br />
growth and creating the shortest transportation<br />
route from the ports of the<br />
Black Sea to the ports of the Gulf.<br />
“When the projects are completed,<br />
transport costs and times for the region<br />
are expected to improve substantially, fostering<br />
greater regional trade and economic<br />
growth while dramatically strengthening<br />
the <strong>Armenian</strong> economy,” the statement<br />
said.