The Fate of Western Hungary 1918-1921 - Corvinus Library ...

The Fate of Western Hungary 1918-1921 - Corvinus Library ... The Fate of Western Hungary 1918-1921 - Corvinus Library ...

hungarianhistory.com
from hungarianhistory.com More from this publisher
04.04.2013 Views

territory along the Raba River, with Szentgotthárd as its center, all the way to the Styrian border. According to Patry’s suggestion, essentially the western portion of Trans-Danubia, with a population of approx. 900,000 (of which only 38.3% or 345,000 were Germans), would have been transferred to German- Austrian rule. For this, Hungary would have received, in exchange, Bosnia- Herzegovina and the southern part of Dalmatia, with about 2.2 million South Slav subjects. 5 Patry’s article did not find wide support in Austria. The newspaper that originally ran Patry’s piece in 1906, the Viennese Altdeutsches Tagblatt, also reprinted it in the form of a flyer, titled Westungarn zu Deutschösterreich [Western Hungary to German-Austria], and distributed it in Hungary. On its front page, it demanded the annexation of Western Hungary to a not-yetexisting German-Austria that was still a part of the German Empire. Around this time, the Croats petitioned to have Dalmatia annexed to Croatia. The flyer seized this opportunity to foment dissension with Hungary, which – as it stated – “the weak emperor allowed to grow in size at the expense of its loyal nations.” It proclaimed that the non-Hungarian speaking people of Hungary awaited their liberation from a forcible Hungarian rule. It graciously allowed the annexation of Dalmatia to Croatia, under the aegis of the Hungarian Holy Crown but, in that case, Austria is entitled to compensation by the Hungarian territory between the Danube and Raba rivers, which was partially populated by Germans. The flyer also added demands over and above the original article and went on to lay claim to the cities of Pozsony for reason of it being partly German, Győr for economic reasons, Komárom for military reasons, then laid claim to the purely Hungarian island of Csallóköz (Žitný ostrov) and Szigetköz for its rich agricultural lands. This contagion was carefully planted in Austrian society, and it made its way to Western Hungary, as well. As but one minor example, Dr. János Wurditsch of Szentmargitbánya, who received his degree at the medical school of the University of Vienna, for years, infected the minds of his sick and healthy patients with this. 6 In the matter of the dissemination of the German-language flyer, at the February 22, 1908 meeting of the Hungarian Diet, Hugo Laehne, member for the Kőszeg riding, addressed a question to the prime minister, Sándor Wekerle (1848-1921). He suggested that Patry’s flyer be officially confiscated and banning its dissemination in the country, 7 as well as curbing the Greater Germany sympathies. (Patry’s circular appeared again in 5 The ideas of Josef Patry and similar ones by Austrian politicians are covered in more detail by Schlag, Gerald: Aus Trümmern geboren… Burgenland 1918-1921 [Born from the rubble… Burgenland 1918-1921]. Eisenstadt, 2001, pp. 38–48. 6 Sopronyi-Thurner, Mihály: A magyar igazság kálváriája [The Calvary of Hungarian truth]. In: Sopron és Sopronvármegye ismertetője 1914–1934 [Sopron and Sopron County Review]. Összeáll. Horváth László, Madarász Gyula, Zsadányi Oszkár. Sopron, 1934, pp. 38–39. (Hereafter referred to as: Sopron and …, 1934.) 7 Nagy, Iván dr. vitéz: Nyugatmagyarország Ausztriában [Western Hungary in Austria]. Pécs, 1937, p. 23. 8

1918, in its second edition. 8 ) Germans have been slowly settling in western Hungary for centuries. The suggestion that the area be annexed to Austria was proposed even more strongly two years later, during the 1908 so-called Bosnian Crisis, by the editorials of the Vienna newspaper, Österreichische Rundschau. At this time, the Hungarian press was demanding that Bosnia-Herzegovina be annexed to Hungary. In response, certain Austrian circles counter-proposed that, in exchange, Hungary cede to Austria the four western counties of Moson, Sopron, Vas and Pozsony, with special mention of the city of Pozsony. The situation was finally settled when, on November 6, 1908, Austrian Emperor (and Hungarian king) Franz Joseph (1848-1916), citing the prerogative of the Hungarian Holy Crown, announced the addition of Bosnia-Herzegovina into the Austro-Hungarian Monarchy. The topic of ceding of the four mentioned counties to Austria – and the emphasized demand for Pozsony – continued to remain on the agenda. In fact, it made its way into Archduke Franz Ferdinand’s (1863-1914) plans for the creation of Gross-Österreich [Greater Austria]. The question was also hotly debated in 1918 by the Austrian-German officers on the battlefields. The issue was tabled in the Austrian parliament in September. 9 This movement gained new momentum when, a day after Charles IV’s Schönbrunn Manifesto, on November 12, 1918 the interim Austrian National Assembly proclaimed the country a republic. Next, it went on to declare that the new state is to be called German-Austria (Deutschösterreich) and it is joining (Anschluss) democratic Germany. Here we must recount the fateful events that led up to the previous events. The last prime minister of (pre-Trianon) historic Hungary, Sándor Wekerle, who made numerous attempts to prevent the breakup of the Monarchy, stated “for the opinion of the Hungarian nation at large”: “Unfortunately, now after the fact, I can say that ex-king Charles (Habsburg IV) was not honest. He asked István Tisza to go down and hold talks with the South Slavs and, behind our back, he also empowered Korosetz to create against us the Yugoslav state. This Korosetz had such great influence over the ex-king that he [the ex-king] immediately passed on every understanding I had with him [again the ex-king] to Korosetz so that he [Korosetz] could immediately begin countermeasures against me. It happened often that, if I reminded the king of his previous promises, he claimed he could not remember them. You have no idea how often 8 Patry, Josef: Westungarn zu Deutschösterreich. Ein Vorschlag zur Lösung der deutsch-ungarischen Frage. [Western Hungary to German Austria. Proposal for the solution of the Western Hungarian question]. 2 nd . ed. Wien, 1918. 9 Gagyi, Jenő: A nyugatmagyarországi kérdés [The Western Hungary question]. Budapest, 1921, pp. 4–5; Angyal, Dávid: A boszniai válság története [History of the Bosnian crisis]. Budapest, 1932; Gulya, Károly: Az annexiós válság és az Osztrák– Magyar Monarchia balkáni politikája [The annexation crisis and the Balcan policies of the Austro-Hungarian Monarchy]. In: Acta Universitatis Szegediensis. Acta Historica, vol. 20, Szeged, 1965. 9

territory along the Raba River, with Szentgotthárd as its center, all the way to<br />

the Styrian border. According to Patry’s suggestion, essentially the western<br />

portion <strong>of</strong> Trans-Danubia, with a population <strong>of</strong> approx. 900,000 (<strong>of</strong> which only<br />

38.3% or 345,000 were Germans), would have been transferred to German-<br />

Austrian rule. For this, <strong>Hungary</strong> would have received, in exchange, Bosnia-<br />

Herzegovina and the southern part <strong>of</strong> Dalmatia, with about 2.2 million South<br />

Slav subjects. 5<br />

Patry’s article did not find wide support in Austria. <strong>The</strong> newspaper that<br />

originally ran Patry’s piece in 1906, the Viennese Altdeutsches Tagblatt, also<br />

reprinted it in the form <strong>of</strong> a flyer, titled Westungarn zu Deutschösterreich<br />

[<strong>Western</strong> <strong>Hungary</strong> to German-Austria], and distributed it in <strong>Hungary</strong>. On its<br />

front page, it demanded the annexation <strong>of</strong> <strong>Western</strong> <strong>Hungary</strong> to a not-yetexisting<br />

German-Austria that was still a part <strong>of</strong> the German Empire. Around<br />

this time, the Croats petitioned to have Dalmatia annexed to Croatia. <strong>The</strong> flyer<br />

seized this opportunity to foment dissension with <strong>Hungary</strong>, which – as it stated<br />

– “the weak emperor allowed to grow in size at the expense <strong>of</strong> its loyal<br />

nations.” It proclaimed that the non-Hungarian speaking people <strong>of</strong> <strong>Hungary</strong><br />

awaited their liberation from a forcible Hungarian rule. It graciously allowed<br />

the annexation <strong>of</strong> Dalmatia to Croatia, under the aegis <strong>of</strong> the Hungarian Holy<br />

Crown but, in that case, Austria is entitled to compensation by the Hungarian<br />

territory between the Danube and Raba rivers, which was partially populated by<br />

Germans. <strong>The</strong> flyer also added demands over and above the original article and<br />

went on to lay claim to the cities <strong>of</strong> Pozsony for reason <strong>of</strong> it being partly<br />

German, Győr for economic reasons, Komárom for military reasons, then laid<br />

claim to the purely Hungarian island <strong>of</strong> Csallóköz (Žitný ostrov) and Szigetköz<br />

for its rich agricultural lands. This contagion was carefully planted in Austrian<br />

society, and it made its way to <strong>Western</strong> <strong>Hungary</strong>, as well. As but one minor<br />

example, Dr. János Wurditsch <strong>of</strong> Szentmargitbánya, who received his degree at<br />

the medical school <strong>of</strong> the University <strong>of</strong> Vienna, for years, infected the minds <strong>of</strong><br />

his sick and healthy patients with this. 6 In the matter <strong>of</strong> the dissemination <strong>of</strong> the<br />

German-language flyer, at the February 22, 1908 meeting <strong>of</strong> the Hungarian<br />

Diet, Hugo Laehne, member for the Kőszeg riding, addressed a question to the<br />

prime minister, Sándor Wekerle (1848-<strong>1921</strong>). He suggested that Patry’s flyer<br />

be <strong>of</strong>ficially confiscated and banning its dissemination in the country, 7 as well<br />

as curbing the Greater Germany sympathies. (Patry’s circular appeared again in<br />

5 <strong>The</strong> ideas <strong>of</strong> Josef Patry and similar ones by Austrian politicians are covered in more<br />

detail by Schlag, Gerald: Aus Trümmern geboren… Burgenland <strong>1918</strong>-<strong>1921</strong> [Born from<br />

the rubble… Burgenland <strong>1918</strong>-<strong>1921</strong>]. Eisenstadt, 2001, pp. 38–48.<br />

6 Sopronyi-Thurner, Mihály: A magyar igazság kálváriája [<strong>The</strong> Calvary <strong>of</strong> Hungarian<br />

truth]. In: Sopron és Sopronvármegye ismertetője 1914–1934 [Sopron and Sopron<br />

County Review]. Összeáll. Horváth László, Madarász Gyula, Zsadányi Oszkár. Sopron,<br />

1934, pp. 38–39. (Hereafter referred to as: Sopron and …, 1934.)<br />

7 Nagy, Iván dr. vitéz: Nyugatmagyarország Ausztriában [<strong>Western</strong> <strong>Hungary</strong> in Austria].<br />

Pécs, 1937, p. 23.<br />

8

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!