PDF (Lo-Res) - Smithsonian Institution Libraries
PDF (Lo-Res) - Smithsonian Institution Libraries
PDF (Lo-Res) - Smithsonian Institution Libraries
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
NUMBER 89 57<br />
vittata macgillivrayi. Data herein show that P. vittata is distinct<br />
from P. macgillivrayi, and both are distinct from P. salvini, so<br />
the Amsterdam prion should not be listed as Pachyptila vittata.<br />
The 20 species of seabird recorded herein as fossils from<br />
Amsterdam Island underestimate the total because the Sooty<br />
Albatross {Phoebetria fusca) and the Antarctic Tem {Sterna<br />
vittata) presently breed on Amsterdam (Jouventin et al.,1984)<br />
but are not represented among the fossils. Micol and Jouventin<br />
(1995) noted that at least one Phoebetria fusca had been identified<br />
in fossil material, but no material was seen by THW to<br />
substantiate this.<br />
Jouventin (1994) and Micol and Jouventin (1995) reported<br />
the supposed presence of two extinct species of Pterodroma<br />
and two extinct storm-petrels. This study finds no evidence for<br />
any extinct procellarid having previously existed on Amsterdam<br />
Island. Procellaria cinerea, Pterodroma macroptera, and<br />
P. mollis are common as fossils and undoubtedly bred there.<br />
The large number of P. baraui bones from site 8 suggests this<br />
species also was breeding on Amsterdam; in contrast, the few<br />
bones of P. arminjoniana could be from nonbreeding visitors,<br />
or possibly from skua kills.<br />
SIZE RANGES OF SPECIES<br />
Pterodroma macroptera: Several species of seabirds represented<br />
in the fossil fauna of Amsterdam Island are smaller than<br />
conspecific populations in the New Zealand region. Data in<br />
Appendix 1 show that P. macroptera from Amsterdam are<br />
smaller than Australasian and South Atlantic specimens. The<br />
specimens available from Eclipse Island in Western Australia<br />
are of similar size to the Amsterdam specimens, but the one<br />
specimen from Coffin Island is larger than any Amsterdam<br />
specimen and is within the size range for P. macroptera gouldi.<br />
Measurements given in Marchant and Higgins (1990) show<br />
that P. m. macroptera is a little smaller than P. m. gouldi. They<br />
also show that males are slightly larger than females in most<br />
measurements, but there is no detectable dimorphism in the<br />
fossil sample, which has apparently normal, unimodal, size distributions.<br />
Pterodroma mollis: The limited evidence suggests that P.<br />
mollis from Amsterdam is smaller than Australasian and Atlantic<br />
birds. Measurements in Marchant and Higgins (1990), however,<br />
indicate no geographical or sexual size variation. The fossil<br />
samples have mainly unimodal size distributions (Figure 8)<br />
except for humeri, where the distribution is bimodal, suggesting<br />
that there may be some sexual dimorphism.<br />
Procellaria cinerea: The Amsterdam Procellaria cinerea<br />
have bone lengths 4%-6% smaller than birds from the New<br />
Zealand region. Measurements of birds from the Crozet and<br />
Kerguelen islands and from New Zealand (Marchant and Higgins,<br />
1990) also indicate that Indian Ocean birds are smaller<br />
than New Zealand ones. Some sexual dimorphism is apparent<br />
in external measurements in Marchant and Higgins (1990), although<br />
their two data sets are contradictory: in one the males<br />
are larger and in the other the females are larger. Measurements<br />
of sexed skeletons in our comparative series (3 males, 7 females)<br />
suggest that females are smaller, although the small<br />
sample size precludes meaningful statistical comparison. The<br />
fossil bones have a length distribution (Figure 12) that trends in<br />
most cases toward bimodality, compared to the unimodal (apparently<br />
normal) distributions of Pterodroma macroptera and<br />
Pachyptila macgillivrayi (Figures 7, 10). If the modem sample<br />
is representative, then the larger bones probably represent<br />
males.<br />
Pachyptila macgillivrayi: The differences detailed above<br />
show that the Amsterdam prion is a distinct species, P.<br />
macgillivrayi, that is endemic to the Amsterdam-St. Paul<br />
group. The very large samples of long bones are apparently<br />
normally distributed and unimodal, suggesting there is no sexual<br />
size dimorphism. Sexual dimorphism in prions is generally<br />
slight, although Genevois and Bretagnolle (1995) found male<br />
Thin-billed Prions (P. belcheri) to be larger overall and to have<br />
larger bills than do females.<br />
Puffinus assimilis: There are several subspecies of P. assimilis<br />
in the southern oceans region. The nominate race from<br />
Norfolk Island (P. assimilis assimilis) is the smallest (Appendix<br />
5). The two New Zealand subspecies, P. a. haurakiensis<br />
and P. a. kermadecensis, are of similar size and are larger than<br />
P. a. assimilis but are smaller than P. a. elegans, from farther<br />
south in the Antipodes (Appendix 5). None of the beach-cast<br />
specimens from New Zealand west-coast beaches are large<br />
enough to be P. a. elegans, and they are considered to be P. a.<br />
kermadecensis (J.A. Bartle, pers. comm., 18 June 1995; verified<br />
in many cases by the species of lice present). Size variation<br />
therefore appears to be clinal, with larger birds in the<br />
south.<br />
Puffinus assimilis bones from Amsterdam are on average<br />
slightly smaller than those of P. a. elegans from the Antipodes<br />
but are much larger than those of the other subspecies considered<br />
above, and so they are probably referable to P. assimilis<br />
elegans. This subspecies ranges from the Antipodes and<br />
Chatham islands in the New Zealand region to Tristan da Cunha<br />
and Gough Island (Marchant and Higgins, 1990).<br />
Pelecanoides urinatrix: As discussed above, there is considerable<br />
variation in mean size of individuals between populations<br />
in this species. Although some of the variation may be<br />
clinal, with more southern populations comprising larger individuals,<br />
this is not the case in New Zealand, where populations<br />
in Cook Strait and farther north are distinctly larger than those<br />
around Stewart Island and on the Chatham Islands. The limited<br />
data presented herein suggest that the Amsterdam birds are<br />
smaller than those from Heard Island, significantly smaller<br />
than those from the lower latitude populations in the Cook<br />
Strait-Wellington region of New Zealand, and similar to those<br />
from slightly higher latitudes on Southeast Island, in the<br />
Chatham Group. Size variation in Pelecanoides is thus not well<br />
explained by clinal factors.