PDF (Lo-Res) - Smithsonian Institution Libraries

PDF (Lo-Res) - Smithsonian Institution Libraries PDF (Lo-Res) - Smithsonian Institution Libraries

03.04.2013 Views

170 cional Autonoma de Mexico, for permission to include the partial carpometacarpus from Mexico in this study; B. MacFadden, Florida Museum of Natural History, for the loan of the Leisey Shell Pit specimens; and S. Emslie, S.J. Parry, and an anonymous reviewer for comments on an earlier version of this paper. Photographs are by R. Meier and D. Watson, Natural History Museum of Los Angeles County (LACM) staff photographers; the map in Figure 2 was produced by G.T. Braden, San Bernadino County Museum (SBCM). Systematics Order CICONIIFORMES Family TERATORNITHIDAE Aiolornis, new genus TYPE SPECIES.—Teratornis incredibilis Howard, 1952; type by original description. REFERRED SPECIES.—None. ETYMOLOGY.—Aiolos, Greek, masculine, god of the winds; ornis, Greek, masculine, bird. EMENDED DIAGNOSIS.—Placed in the family Teratornithidae and differing from genera of the Vulturidae by having the os carpi ulnare with the following characters (from Howard, 1952:51): (1) attachment for Lig. ulno-ulnocarpale long, diagonal, and ridge-like (short, almost papilla-like in the Vulturidae); and (2) external prominence and attachment for Lig. ulno-ulnocarpale in close proximity (broad space separating the two in the Vulturidae). Differs from Teratornis by having the os carpi ulnare with (1) external prominence a long, prominent ridge forming one end of and extending from the facies articularis ulnaris to very near the attachment for Lig. ulno-ulnocarpale (short, rounded, not contacting facies articularis ulnaris in Teratornis); (2) attachment for Lig. ulno-ulnocarpale proportionately longer, more prominently protruding from body of bone; (3) facies articularis ulnaris narrowing slightly distad, more concave, with dorsal rim notably lower than ventral rim (narrows abruptly, less concave, with dorsal rim only slightly lower than ventral rim in Teratornis); (4) facies articularis metacarpals a slightly elongated oval, with long axis nearly aligned with long axis of facies articularis ulnaris, with external end very near facies articularis ulnaris, and lying at greater angle to facies articularis ulnaris (markedly elongated oval with long axis at low angle to that of facies articularis ulnaris and external end at some distance from facies articularis ulnaris in Teratornis); and (5) with ventral surface of bone bordering and surrounding incisura metacarpalis nearly flat (markedly concave in Teratornis). Aiolornis incredibilis (Howard, 1952), new combination HOLOTYPE.—Complete right os carpi ulnare, LACM(CIT) 5067. SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO PALEOBIOLOGY TYPE LOCALITY.—Section 7-F-310 of LACM(CIT) locality 251, Smith Creek Cave, Snake Range, 54.4 km north of Baker, White Pine County, Nevada. AGE.—Rancholabrean NALMA (North American Land Mammal Age). DIAGNOSIS.—As for genus. REFERRED MATERIAL.—Left humerus: Proximal end and portion of shaft, missing caput and much of crista deltopectoralis (Figure 1); SBCM A2239-2829, Section of Earth Sciences. The specimen was collected by Quintin Lake (PRAP), April 1993, from locality SBCM 05.006.399, which is located approximately 1 km northeast of Murrieta, Riverside County, California, at an approximate elevation of 368 m. The locality lies within the unsurveyed Temecula Land Grant (Figure 2), within the SWV4, NEtt, SWA section 9, T. 7S, R. 3W, San Bernardino Base and Meridian. The specimen was exposed in situ in an erosional gully approximately 0.15 m below grade. The partial humerus came from sediments of an unnamed sandstone and conglomerate formation that unconformably underlies the middle Pleistocene Pauba Formation and may unconformably overlie the lower Pliocene Temecula Arkose in the Elsinore Fault Zone (Kennedy, 1977). Two faunal components have been recognized from the unnamed sandstone formation, one dating to the late Blancan NALMA (late Pliocene, as interpreted by Lundelius et al., 1987) and the other to the Irvingtonian NALMA (early Pleistocene) (Scott and Cox, 1993). The partial humerus is derived from sediments that are late Blancan in age (pre-Olduvai subchron, 2.6-1.9 Ma), based on sites producing Blancan faunas in the area immediately adjacent to SBCM 05.006.399. These localities (SBCM 05.006.156, 05.006.157, 05.006.158, 05.006.159, 05.006.397) are all located within 15 m of SBCM 05.006.399 and have yielded Hypolagus sp., Prodipodomys sp., Mimomys {Ophiomys) parvus R. Wilson, and Sigmodon minor Gidley, but they lack any Pleistocene or later indicator taxa, such as Microtus sp. or Mammuthus sp. (Scott and Cox, 1993). The partial humerus is placed in the family Teratornithidae based on the following characters: (1) crista bicipitalis elongated and prominently bulbous for entire length; (2) planus interruberculare smooth, broad, and symmetrically and deeply convex in transverse section from caput to middle of crista deltopectoralis; (3) crista deltopectoralis low, very stout, curving ventrad on facies anterioris of corpus humeri just distal to end of crista bicipitalis, and tapering off gradually as it crosses to near midline of corpus humeri; and (4) distal insertion for M. pectoralis long, broad, and near midline of facies anterioris of corpus humeri. Other avian taxa, such as some of the orders Procellariformes, Pelecaniformes, and Ciconiiformes, resemble teratorns somewhat in having a bulbous crista bicipitalis. In these taxa, however, the bulbous portion is more limited, being present only at the distal end of the crista bicipitalis. In Teratornis the bulbous portion occupies the entire length of the crista bicipitalis and is more pronounced; it is missing from the only known humerus of Argentavis. Although most of the bulbous

NUMBER 89 171 M FIGURE 1.—New partial humerus referred to Aiolornis incredibilis: A, anterior, B, dorsal, and c, posterior views. The position of the line of insertion of M. latissimus dorsi (arrows) is unique among teratorns. Scale bar=5 cm. portion in the partial humerus under discussion is missing, enough of the base is present to document its presence and its size. Similarly, some other avian taxa have a proportionately broad and convex planus intertuberculare, but we know of none that approaches the symmetrical, smooth, deep convexity seen in teratorns. We know of no other group of birds in which the crista deltopectoralis curves ventrad onto the facies anterioris of the corpus humeri. Among the New World vultures, condors share the trait of having a large distal insertion for M. pectoralis, but it is much smaller, more oval or tear-drop shaped, and positioned closer to the facies dorsalis of the humerus. The partial humerus differs from Argentavis and Teratornis, the only two of the three genera of the family for which the humerus is known, by the following: (1) facies dorsalis fairly flat for length of attachment of M. latissimus dorsi, becoming slightly convex near its distal end (sloping anteriad proximally, changing to convex distally in Argentavis and Teratornis); (2) facies posterioris and facies dorsalis meet at near right angle, with line of insertion of M. latissimus dorsi following a welldefined "corner" of margo anteriodorsalis (line of insertion at angle to margo dorsalis, crossing facies posterioris from distal to proximal in Argentavis and Teratornis); (3) corpus humeri in

170<br />

cional Autonoma de Mexico, for permission to include the partial<br />

carpometacarpus from Mexico in this study; B. MacFadden,<br />

Florida Museum of Natural History, for the loan of the<br />

Leisey Shell Pit specimens; and S. Emslie, S.J. Parry, and an<br />

anonymous reviewer for comments on an earlier version of this<br />

paper. Photographs are by R. Meier and D. Watson, Natural<br />

History Museum of <strong>Lo</strong>s Angeles County (LACM) staff photographers;<br />

the map in Figure 2 was produced by G.T. Braden,<br />

San Bernadino County Museum (SBCM).<br />

Systematics<br />

Order CICONIIFORMES<br />

Family TERATORNITHIDAE<br />

Aiolornis, new genus<br />

TYPE SPECIES.—Teratornis incredibilis Howard, 1952; type<br />

by original description.<br />

REFERRED SPECIES.—None.<br />

ETYMOLOGY.—Aiolos, Greek, masculine, god of the winds;<br />

ornis, Greek, masculine, bird.<br />

EMENDED DIAGNOSIS.—Placed in the family Teratornithidae<br />

and differing from genera of the Vulturidae by having the os<br />

carpi ulnare with the following characters (from Howard,<br />

1952:51): (1) attachment for Lig. ulno-ulnocarpale long, diagonal,<br />

and ridge-like (short, almost papilla-like in the Vulturidae);<br />

and (2) external prominence and attachment for Lig.<br />

ulno-ulnocarpale in close proximity (broad space separating<br />

the two in the Vulturidae).<br />

Differs from Teratornis by having the os carpi ulnare with<br />

(1) external prominence a long, prominent ridge forming one<br />

end of and extending from the facies articularis ulnaris to very<br />

near the attachment for Lig. ulno-ulnocarpale (short, rounded,<br />

not contacting facies articularis ulnaris in Teratornis); (2) attachment<br />

for Lig. ulno-ulnocarpale proportionately longer,<br />

more prominently protruding from body of bone; (3) facies articularis<br />

ulnaris narrowing slightly distad, more concave, with<br />

dorsal rim notably lower than ventral rim (narrows abruptly,<br />

less concave, with dorsal rim only slightly lower than ventral<br />

rim in Teratornis); (4) facies articularis metacarpals a slightly<br />

elongated oval, with long axis nearly aligned with long axis of<br />

facies articularis ulnaris, with external end very near facies articularis<br />

ulnaris, and lying at greater angle to facies articularis<br />

ulnaris (markedly elongated oval with long axis at low angle to<br />

that of facies articularis ulnaris and external end at some distance<br />

from facies articularis ulnaris in Teratornis); and (5) with<br />

ventral surface of bone bordering and surrounding incisura<br />

metacarpalis nearly flat (markedly concave in Teratornis).<br />

Aiolornis incredibilis (Howard, 1952), new combination<br />

HOLOTYPE.—Complete right os carpi ulnare, LACM(CIT)<br />

5067.<br />

SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO PALEOBIOLOGY<br />

TYPE LOCALITY.—Section 7-F-310 of LACM(CIT) locality<br />

251, Smith Creek Cave, Snake Range, 54.4 km north of Baker,<br />

White Pine County, Nevada.<br />

AGE.—Rancholabrean NALMA (North American Land<br />

Mammal Age).<br />

DIAGNOSIS.—As for genus.<br />

REFERRED MATERIAL.—Left humerus: Proximal end and<br />

portion of shaft, missing caput and much of crista deltopectoralis<br />

(Figure 1); SBCM A2239-2829, Section of Earth Sciences.<br />

The specimen was collected by Quintin Lake (PRAP), April<br />

1993, from locality SBCM 05.006.399, which is located approximately<br />

1 km northeast of Murrieta, Riverside County,<br />

California, at an approximate elevation of 368 m. The locality<br />

lies within the unsurveyed Temecula Land Grant (Figure 2),<br />

within the SWV4, NEtt, SWA section 9, T. 7S, R. 3W, San Bernardino<br />

Base and Meridian. The specimen was exposed in situ<br />

in an erosional gully approximately 0.15 m below grade.<br />

The partial humerus came from sediments of an unnamed<br />

sandstone and conglomerate formation that unconformably underlies<br />

the middle Pleistocene Pauba Formation and may unconformably<br />

overlie the lower Pliocene Temecula Arkose in<br />

the Elsinore Fault Zone (Kennedy, 1977). Two faunal components<br />

have been recognized from the unnamed sandstone formation,<br />

one dating to the late Blancan NALMA (late Pliocene,<br />

as interpreted by Lundelius et al., 1987) and the other to the<br />

Irvingtonian NALMA (early Pleistocene) (Scott and Cox,<br />

1993). The partial humerus is derived from sediments that are<br />

late Blancan in age (pre-Olduvai subchron, 2.6-1.9 Ma), based<br />

on sites producing Blancan faunas in the area immediately adjacent<br />

to SBCM 05.006.399. These localities (SBCM<br />

05.006.156, 05.006.157, 05.006.158, 05.006.159, 05.006.397)<br />

are all located within 15 m of SBCM 05.006.399 and have<br />

yielded Hypolagus sp., Prodipodomys sp., Mimomys {Ophiomys)<br />

parvus R. Wilson, and Sigmodon minor Gidley, but they<br />

lack any Pleistocene or later indicator taxa, such as Microtus<br />

sp. or Mammuthus sp. (Scott and Cox, 1993).<br />

The partial humerus is placed in the family Teratornithidae<br />

based on the following characters: (1) crista bicipitalis elongated<br />

and prominently bulbous for entire length; (2) planus interruberculare<br />

smooth, broad, and symmetrically and deeply convex<br />

in transverse section from caput to middle of crista<br />

deltopectoralis; (3) crista deltopectoralis low, very stout, curving<br />

ventrad on facies anterioris of corpus humeri just distal to<br />

end of crista bicipitalis, and tapering off gradually as it crosses<br />

to near midline of corpus humeri; and (4) distal insertion for M.<br />

pectoralis long, broad, and near midline of facies anterioris of<br />

corpus humeri.<br />

Other avian taxa, such as some of the orders Procellariformes,<br />

Pelecaniformes, and Ciconiiformes, resemble teratorns<br />

somewhat in having a bulbous crista bicipitalis. In these taxa,<br />

however, the bulbous portion is more limited, being present<br />

only at the distal end of the crista bicipitalis. In Teratornis the<br />

bulbous portion occupies the entire length of the crista bicipitalis<br />

and is more pronounced; it is missing from the only<br />

known humerus of Argentavis. Although most of the bulbous

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!