PDF (Lo-Res) - Smithsonian Institution Libraries

PDF (Lo-Res) - Smithsonian Institution Libraries PDF (Lo-Res) - Smithsonian Institution Libraries

03.04.2013 Views

duboisi are larger than the largest individuals of N. nycticorax or N. caledonicus in the USNM collection. The supratendinal bridge is incompletely ossified in the three tibiotarsi of N. duboisi. The condition is unknown in N. mauritianus, whereas in N. megacephalus the supratendinal bridge is completely ossified (Milne-Edwards, 1874, pl. 14: fig. 7). The dimensions of Mascarene Nycticorax are given in Table 2. Most of the remains ofN. duboisi are larger than those of either N. megacephalus or N. mauritianus (Figure Ai-j), except for the tarsometatarsus, which is almost the same size as in N. megacephalus, and the femur, which is smaller in most dimensions than that in N. megacephalus. The ratio-diagram (Figure 2) shows the differences in the relative proportions of the bones in the three Mascarene species, compared with the modern species N. nycticorax and N cale­ SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO PALEOBIOLOGY donicus. In N. mauritianus and N. megacephalus the wings (humeri, ulnae, carpometacarpi) are considerably reduced, and the legs (particularly the femora) are longer than in modern species. In contrast, N. duboisi is larger than living species, but the proportions are almost the same. The tarsometatarsus is slightly longer than in N. nycticorax or N. caledonicus, but only two are available, and for one of them the length is estimated. The ratio-diagram clearly demonstrates that the Rodrigues and Mauritius species had a reduced flying ability, whereas the Reunion form had a flying ability quite similar to that of living species. By the proportions of the tarsometatarsus, which is short and thick, the Mascarene night herons are more similar to Nycticorax nycticorax than to other congeners, particularly N. cale- TABLE 2.—Dimensions (mm) of the long bones of Nycticorax duboisi, from Reunion, N. megacephalus, from Rodrigues, and TV. mauritianus, from Maritius. (a=data from Milne-Edwards (1874), Giinther and Newton (1879), and material at MNHN; b=data from Newton and Gadow (1893) and from material at MNHN; c=from base of glenoid facet to top of acromion; d=from the most internal part to the most external part; est.=estimated; /j=number of specimens.) Measurement Scapula length art. part (c) width art. part (d) width shaft depth shaft Coracoid internal length width midshaft depth midshaft Humerus total length distal width width midshaft depth midshaft Una total length proximal width proximal depth distal width depth ext. cond. width midshaft depth midshaft Femur total length distal width distal depth width midshaft depth midshaft Tibiotarsus total length distal width distal depth width midshaft depth midshaft Tarsometatarsus total length proximal width proximal depth distal width distal depth width midshaft depth midshaft Mean (n) 11.10 (2) 12.65 (2) 4.90 (2) 2.90 (2) - -4.8 (1) -5.4 (1) est. 137 (1) 18.4 (1) 8.1 (1) 7.2 (1) est. 155 (1) 13.5 (1) 11.5 (1) -10.3 (1) -9.0 (1) 6.20 (2) 5.65 (2) est. 85 (1) 14.8 (1) 14.2 (1) 6.6 (1) 6.2 (1) -144.5 (2) 12.87 (3) 13.2 (1) 6.80 (3) 6.03 (3) est. 97.55 (2) -13.5 (1) -13.5 (1) 14.2 (1) 7.35 (2) 6.53 (3) 4.73 (3) N. dubo isi Range 10.2-12.0 12.4-12.9 4.7-5.1 2.8-3.0 - - - - - - - - - - 6.2-6.2 5.6-5.7 - - - - - -139—150 12.4-13.2 - 6.8-6.8 5.9-6.1 95.1-est. 100 - - - 7.2-7.5 6.4-6.8 4.4-5.0 N. megacephalus Range (a) - - - est. 53.0-57.0 - - 114-119 16.5-16.8 6.9-7.0 5.9 121 - --- - - 86-90 15.0 - 6.2 - 136-140 13.0 - 6.0 _ 93-95.5 13.7-14.0 13.5 13.5-13.8 7.4 6.0-6.5 5.0 N. mauritianus Range (b) - - - est. 45.5 4.3 4.2 - - -- 111-112 - - _ _ - _ 79.3 13.8 11.7 6.4 5.8 _ _ _ _ _ 79.5-87 12.7-12.8 12.4-12.6 11.7-12.1 7.1-7.3 5.8-5.9 4.7-4.8

NUMBER 89 donicus. In the case of N. megacephalus and N. mauritianus, however, the robustness of the tarsometatarsus is probably accentuated by the reduced flying ability (Table 3). The Reunion night heron had green feet and had gray plumage flecked with white, a description that fits very well with the juvenile plumage of Nycticorax nycticorax. REMARKS.—Cowles (1994) thought that the species name Ardea duboisi, created by Rothschild (1907), was a nomen nudum, but actually this name, published with a description, is valid. It has been used several times (Hachisuka, 1953; Greenway, 1967) and therefore must be retained, in conformity with the law of priority. Many other accepted scientific names of Mascarene birds are based on similar descriptions. The description given by Dubois is as follows: "Bitterns or Great throats, large as big capons [domestic fowl, Gallus gallus (Linnaeus)], but fat and good [to eat]. They have grey plumage, Cor. Hum. Uln. Cpm. Fern. Tbt. Tmt. -80 I 60 I 40 -20 20 40 I each feather tipped with white, the neck and beak like a heron and the feet green, made like the feet of the 'Poullets dTnde' [domestic turkey, Meleagris gallopavo (Linnaeus)]. That lives on fish" (Barre and Barau, 1982:30, our translation). Dubois' words "Butors ou Grands Gauziers" were left in French by 01- TABLE 3.—Robustness index of the tarsometatarsus in different modem and extinct species of the genus Nycticorax. (Robustness index = midshaft width x 100/ total length; «=number of specimens.) Species Nycticorax nycticorax nycticorax Nycticorax caledonicus Nycticorax melanolophus Nycticorax (Gorsachius) leuconotus Nycticorax megacephalus Nycticorax mauritianus Nycticorax duboisi 60 I Mean 6.25 5.87 5.44 5.02 6.57 7.23 -6.77 Range 5.60-6.59 5.49-6.20 - - 6.32-6.99 7.17-7.29 6.73--6.80 n 11 4 1 1 3 2 2 0 Nycticorax caledonicus, standard ^ N. nycticorax C^mean cf N. nycticorax cf, mean • Nycticorax mauritianus # Nycticorax megacephalus O Nycticorax duboisi FIGURE 2.—Ratio-diagram of the dimensions of the main long bones of the three species of Nycticorax of the Mascarenes. The standard is a male N. caledonicus from New Caledonia (USNM 561542). For iV. nycticorax the dimensions are the means of three females (USNM 292037, 319467, 430526) and nine males (USNM 289884, 292036, 430527, 432698, 488680, 489903, 499390, 501991, 610609). For N. megacephalus the data are from Milne-Edwards (1874), and for N. mauritianus the data are the means of the dimensions given by Newton and Gadow (1893) plus those of the fossil material in the MNHN collection. Coracoid measurement is of internal length; for other bones, measurement is of total length. When measurements are not known, successive points are united by dashed lines. (Cor.=coracoid, Cpm.=carpometacarpus, Fem.=femur, Hum.=humerus, Tbt.=tibiotarsus, Tmt.=tarsometatarsus, Uln.=ulna.)

duboisi are larger than the largest individuals of N. nycticorax<br />

or N. caledonicus in the USNM collection.<br />

The supratendinal bridge is incompletely ossified in the<br />

three tibiotarsi of N. duboisi. The condition is unknown in N.<br />

mauritianus, whereas in N. megacephalus the supratendinal<br />

bridge is completely ossified (Milne-Edwards, 1874, pl. 14:<br />

fig. 7). The dimensions of Mascarene Nycticorax are given in<br />

Table 2. Most of the remains ofN. duboisi are larger than those<br />

of either N. megacephalus or N. mauritianus (Figure Ai-j), except<br />

for the tarsometatarsus, which is almost the same size as in<br />

N. megacephalus, and the femur, which is smaller in most dimensions<br />

than that in N. megacephalus.<br />

The ratio-diagram (Figure 2) shows the differences in the relative<br />

proportions of the bones in the three Mascarene species,<br />

compared with the modern species N. nycticorax and N cale­<br />

SMITHSONIAN CONTRIBUTIONS TO PALEOBIOLOGY<br />

donicus. In N. mauritianus and N. megacephalus the wings<br />

(humeri, ulnae, carpometacarpi) are considerably reduced, and<br />

the legs (particularly the femora) are longer than in modern<br />

species. In contrast, N. duboisi is larger than living species, but<br />

the proportions are almost the same. The tarsometatarsus is<br />

slightly longer than in N. nycticorax or N. caledonicus, but<br />

only two are available, and for one of them the length is estimated.<br />

The ratio-diagram clearly demonstrates that the Rodrigues<br />

and Mauritius species had a reduced flying ability,<br />

whereas the Reunion form had a flying ability quite similar to<br />

that of living species.<br />

By the proportions of the tarsometatarsus, which is short and<br />

thick, the Mascarene night herons are more similar to Nycticorax<br />

nycticorax than to other congeners, particularly N. cale-<br />

TABLE 2.—Dimensions (mm) of the long bones of Nycticorax duboisi, from Reunion, N. megacephalus, from<br />

Rodrigues, and TV. mauritianus, from Maritius. (a=data from Milne-Edwards (1874), Giinther and Newton<br />

(1879), and material at MNHN; b=data from Newton and Gadow (1893) and from material at MNHN; c=from<br />

base of glenoid facet to top of acromion; d=from the most internal part to the most external part; est.=estimated;<br />

/j=number of specimens.)<br />

Measurement<br />

Scapula<br />

length art. part (c)<br />

width art. part (d)<br />

width shaft<br />

depth shaft<br />

Coracoid<br />

internal length<br />

width midshaft<br />

depth midshaft<br />

Humerus<br />

total length<br />

distal width<br />

width midshaft<br />

depth midshaft<br />

Una<br />

total length<br />

proximal width<br />

proximal depth<br />

distal width<br />

depth ext. cond.<br />

width midshaft<br />

depth midshaft<br />

Femur<br />

total length<br />

distal width<br />

distal depth<br />

width midshaft<br />

depth midshaft<br />

Tibiotarsus<br />

total length<br />

distal width<br />

distal depth<br />

width midshaft<br />

depth midshaft<br />

Tarsometatarsus<br />

total length<br />

proximal width<br />

proximal depth<br />

distal width<br />

distal depth<br />

width midshaft<br />

depth midshaft<br />

Mean (n)<br />

11.10 (2)<br />

12.65 (2)<br />

4.90 (2)<br />

2.90 (2)<br />

-<br />

-4.8 (1)<br />

-5.4 (1)<br />

est. 137 (1)<br />

18.4 (1)<br />

8.1 (1)<br />

7.2 (1)<br />

est. 155 (1)<br />

13.5 (1)<br />

11.5 (1)<br />

-10.3 (1)<br />

-9.0 (1)<br />

6.20 (2)<br />

5.65 (2)<br />

est. 85 (1)<br />

14.8 (1)<br />

14.2 (1)<br />

6.6 (1)<br />

6.2 (1)<br />

-144.5 (2)<br />

12.87 (3)<br />

13.2 (1)<br />

6.80 (3)<br />

6.03 (3)<br />

est. 97.55 (2)<br />

-13.5 (1)<br />

-13.5 (1)<br />

14.2 (1)<br />

7.35 (2)<br />

6.53 (3)<br />

4.73 (3)<br />

N. dubo isi<br />

Range<br />

10.2-12.0<br />

12.4-12.9<br />

4.7-5.1<br />

2.8-3.0<br />

-<br />

-<br />

-<br />

-<br />

-<br />

-<br />

-<br />

-<br />

-<br />

-<br />

6.2-6.2<br />

5.6-5.7<br />

-<br />

-<br />

-<br />

-<br />

-<br />

-139—150<br />

12.4-13.2<br />

-<br />

6.8-6.8<br />

5.9-6.1<br />

95.1-est. 100<br />

-<br />

- -<br />

7.2-7.5<br />

6.4-6.8<br />

4.4-5.0<br />

N. megacephalus<br />

Range (a)<br />

-<br />

- -<br />

est. 53.0-57.0<br />

-<br />

-<br />

114-119<br />

16.5-16.8<br />

6.9-7.0<br />

5.9<br />

121<br />

- ---<br />

-<br />

-<br />

86-90<br />

15.0<br />

-<br />

6.2<br />

-<br />

136-140<br />

13.0<br />

-<br />

6.0<br />

_<br />

93-95.5<br />

13.7-14.0<br />

13.5<br />

13.5-13.8<br />

7.4<br />

6.0-6.5<br />

5.0<br />

N. mauritianus<br />

Range (b)<br />

-<br />

-<br />

-<br />

est. 45.5<br />

4.3<br />

4.2<br />

-<br />

- --<br />

111-112<br />

-<br />

-<br />

_<br />

_<br />

-<br />

_<br />

79.3<br />

13.8<br />

11.7<br />

6.4<br />

5.8<br />

_<br />

_<br />

_<br />

_<br />

_<br />

79.5-87<br />

12.7-12.8<br />

12.4-12.6<br />

11.7-12.1<br />

7.1-7.3<br />

5.8-5.9<br />

4.7-4.8

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!