Ancient Scottish ballads, recovered from tradition, and never before ...

Ancient Scottish ballads, recovered from tradition, and never before ... Ancient Scottish ballads, recovered from tradition, and never before ...

29.03.2013 Views

178 A' that Peggy left behind Was a cot-house and a wee kail-yardie; Now I think she is better by far, Than tho' she had got a lawland lairdie.

LADY MARGARET, In Mr. Jamieson's collection will be found, un- der the title of " Burd Ellen," a different ver- sion of this ballad, containing several emenda- tions by that gentleman of very doubtful pro- priety; particularly the addition of the three concluding stanzas, whereby the character of the catastrophe is entirely changed. Instead of winding up the story in a happy manner, he, adopting the idea of Mrs. Hampden Pye, who wrote a ballad on the same subject, has chosen to give it a fatal termination; while Child Wa- ters, (another copy published by Percy), and all the versions the Editor has seen, give it a favourable conclusion.

LADY MARGARET,<br />

In Mr. Jamieson's collection will be found, un-<br />

der the title of " Burd Ellen," a different ver-<br />

sion of this ballad, containing several emenda-<br />

tions by that gentleman of very doubtful pro-<br />

priety; particularly the addition of the three<br />

concluding stanzas, whereby the character of<br />

the catastrophe is entirely changed. Instead<br />

of winding up the story in a happy manner, he,<br />

adopting the idea of Mrs. Hampden Pye, who<br />

wrote a ballad on the same subject, has chosen<br />

to give it a fatal termination; while Child Wa-<br />

ters, (another copy published by Percy), <strong>and</strong><br />

all the versions the Editor has seen, give it a<br />

favourable conclusion.

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!