TAXI DELIVERS KNOCKOUT PUNCH - Strategy
TAXI DELIVERS KNOCKOUT PUNCH - Strategy
TAXI DELIVERS KNOCKOUT PUNCH - Strategy
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
The process<br />
This year marks the fi rst time media agencies submitted to a juried process for<br />
Media Agency of the Year. Previously, winners were determined by a straight<br />
poll of network, magazine and other media company execs from across the<br />
country. This time around, following the Agency of the Year model, their votes<br />
were used to select a shortlist of 12 top media agencies: Carat, Cossette Media,<br />
Genesis Vizeum, M2 Universal, MediaCom, Mediaedge:cia, Media Experts,<br />
Mindshare, OMD, PHD, Starcom MediaVest Group and ZenithOptimedia.<br />
Each shortlisted agency was asked to submit three case studies outlining<br />
media plans for three different brands over the past 12 months. (One<br />
shortlisted agency, Genesis Vizeum, was regrettably unable to complete the<br />
The scores<br />
media aoy methodology<br />
submission and withdrew from the competition at the eleventh hour.)<br />
Next, we chose the judges. The strategic panel was made up of six<br />
marketers, one of whom was an international judge, while the creative panel<br />
comprised media company execs and senior media agency representatives<br />
(not on the shortlist). Working in isolation, the judges gave each agency’s<br />
submission an overall score of zero to 10 based on strategic insight and the<br />
ability to execute creatively, as well as versatility across media.<br />
The cumulative scores from the creative and strategic judges were then<br />
totalled and averaged, with equal weighting, omitting any confl icts of interest.<br />
The agency with the highest fi nal score was the winner.<br />
And now the part you’ve been waiting 16 years for: a full spread of the judges’ averages that determined the 2008 Media Agency of the Year.<br />
Creative Strategic Overall<br />
Starcom MediaVest Group 9.33 Starcom MediaVest Group 8.62 Starcom MediaVest Group 8.98<br />
Mediaedge:cia 9.15 OMD 7.65 Mediaedge:cia 8.33<br />
PHD 8.15 Cossette Media 7.60 PHD 7.81<br />
MediaCom 8.13 Mediaedge:cia 7.50 MediaCom 7.76<br />
Carat 8.05 PHD 7.47 Carat 7.63<br />
ZenithOptimedia 7.75 MediaCom (tie) 7.38 ZenithOptimedia 7.57<br />
Mindshare 7.70 ZenithOptimedia (tie) 7.38 OMD 7.54<br />
OMD 7.43 Media Experts 7.37 Cossette Media 7.49<br />
Cossette Media (tie) 7.38 Carat 7.20 Media Experts 7.38<br />
Media Experts (tie) 7.38 M2 Universal 7.08 Mindshare 7.24<br />
M2 Universal 7.03 Mindshare 6.77 M2 Universal 7.06<br />
STRATEGY November 2008 91