You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
Michael Kugelman<br />
8. Ensure that security and political tensions are not allowed<br />
to derail trade diplomacy. To protect the integrity of both trade<br />
normalization and the broader peace process, <strong>India</strong> should not impose<br />
punitive trade measures on <strong>Pakistan</strong>, or close its borders, in the<br />
event of isolated terrorist attacks perpetrated by <strong>Pakistan</strong>-based extremists<br />
(who might like nothing better than to spark a harsh <strong>India</strong>n<br />
response). Both sides should take care not to allow new security or<br />
political tensions to spill into trade or economic relations. Suspending<br />
trade in retaliation for developments on the security front will further<br />
undercut trust, and complicate efforts to establish a stable and longterm<br />
bilateral economic and political relationship.<br />
9. Act now, before the opportunity is lost. Economic circumstances<br />
dictate that each side act expeditiously to cement trade normalization.<br />
Comparative advantage exists not only in terms of goods<br />
to be traded, but also business climate (<strong>Pakistan</strong> is currently ranked<br />
higher than <strong>India</strong> on numerous doing-business and infrastructuralefficiency<br />
measures). This could change, however, if <strong>India</strong> lowers<br />
its business costs and upgrades its infrastructure. Additionally,<br />
rich-country trading partners are facing economic slowdowns, and<br />
Europe’s financial crisis has contributed to diminished exports and<br />
portfolio capital, as well as to reduced GDP growth in developing<br />
countries. This all provides an added incentive to ramp up <strong>Pakistan</strong>-<br />
<strong>India</strong> trade.<br />
The Perilous PaTh forWard<br />
Some of these recommendations—establishing a more permissive visa<br />
regime, easing transit and transport bottlenecks, instituting grievance redressal<br />
mechanisms—are already being addressed. Others—rejuvenating<br />
SAFTA, unilaterally removing tariffs—will require more time.<br />
Additionally, old habits die hard. Over the course of 2012, <strong>Pakistan</strong>i<br />
and <strong>India</strong>n media reports periodically highlighted setbacks to trade<br />
normalization that were linked to political or security concerns. At one<br />
point, a senior <strong>India</strong>n official stated that momentum had slowed because<br />
Islamabad was linking trade “to progress on bigger issues such as<br />
| 14 |