Lawyers Manual - Unified Court System

Lawyers Manual - Unified Court System Lawyers Manual - Unified Court System

24.03.2013 Views

328 Lori Cohen employment authorization, either concurrently with the T visa application or any time thereafter. During the period between receiving the T visa and adjusting status to permanent resident, she must maintain continuous physical presence in the United States and good moral character, and either show that she had cooperated in any reasonable request for investigation of the trafficking or demonstrate extreme hardship involving unusual and severe harm if removed from the United States. 84 If the client meets these requirements, both she and her derivative family members should receive lawful permanent residence. U Visa 85 The U visa assists victims of certain crimes (and in some cases their parents) who have suffered “substantial physical or mental abuse” from the criminal activity, and who have stepped forward to cooperate with law enforcement investigations or prosecutions. 86 Like the T visa, the U visa permits the inclusion of certain qualified relatives. 87 Also like the T visa, the U visa classifies recipients as “nonimmigrants,” but allows them to seek permanent resident status after three years. The statute encompasses not only domestic violence, but many other crimes such as sexual assault, felonious assault, unlawful criminal restraint, and torture. 88 Regulations have not yet been promulgated to implement and issue U visas, although USCIS has issued a draft U visa application for comment. At present, practitioners are obtaining interim relief by filing a cover letter that details the grounds for the victim’s U visa eligibility, law enforcement certification, and a sheet with basic identification data. 89 The law enforcement certification must state that the alien victim “has been helpful, is being helpful, or is likely to be helpful” in the investigation or prosecution of the qualifying criminal activity. The certification may be signed by a federal, state or local law enforcement official, or by a prosecutor, judge, or other authority investigating the criminal activity. 90 There is no requirement that a defendant actually be convicted, or even arrested, for a victim to qualify for U status. Upon showing prima facie eligibility, the applicant will receive deferred action status until the U visa regulations are issued. In the interim, victims may submit an employment authorization application with their request for deferred action, and, once granted, renew their work permit annually. Pursuant to a January 2006 policy memorandum, USCIS will count the period that a victim has deferred action status per a grant of interim relief towards the three years required to apply for adjustment of status. 91 Like the T visa, most bars to inadmissibility are waived, but without the T visa’s requirement that there be a nexus between the ground of inadmissibility and the criminal activity. 92

Asylum and Related Remedies Representing Immigrant Victims of Domestic Violence 329 Domestic violence survivors, as victims of gender-based persecution, also may seek immigration relief in the United States by filing an application for asylum. An asylum applicant must show that she is unable or unwilling to return to her home country because she suffered persecution or has a “well-founded fear” of future persecution on account of her race, religion, nationality, political opinion, or membership in a particular social group. 93 A “well-founded fear” of persecution does not require absolute certainly of persecution, and the Supreme Court has found that an individual who has a 10% chance of being persecuted may meet the standard. 94 Asylum applications based upon gender-related persecution are typically categorized as “social group” claims. Members of a “particular social group” share an immutable characteristic that they cannot change or should not be required to change, such as gender, family membership, or marital status. 95 While initially resistant to gender-based social group claims, immigration law has evolved to offer protection to women fleeing female genital mutilation (also referred to as “female genital cutting”), forced arranged marriage, honor killing, and prostitution. 96 Gender-based claims often overlap with other protected grounds such as political opinion and religion, however, and the asylum applicant should include as many of them as possible in her application. 97 Although the current legal landscape is still in flux, asylum or its related remedies, withholding of removal and Convention Against Torture (CAT) relief, may be the only route for some women who fear domestic violence or other forms of gender-based persecution abroad and now seek shelter in the United States. Matter of R-A- and Its Aftermath The leading case addressing asylum eligibility for domestic violence survivors is Matter of R-A-. 98 In R-A-, a Guatemalan woman named Rodi Alvarado sought asylum after suffering substantial violence at the hands of her husband, a former soldier. Her repeated pleas for help from the Guatemalan authorities were rejected. Ms. Alvarado fled to the United States and was placed into deportation proceedings. While the immigration judge found that the abuse she had suffered constituted persecution, the Board of Immigration Appeals (“BIA”), the appellate body for the immigration courts, reversed on the grounds that victims of domestic violence did not constitute a “particular social group” for asylum purposes. 99 The INS subsequently reversed its earlier opposition to

328 Lori Cohen<br />

employment authorization, either concurrently with the T visa application or any<br />

time thereafter. During the period between receiving the T visa and adjusting<br />

status to permanent resident, she must maintain continuous physical presence in<br />

the United States and good moral character, and either show that she had<br />

cooperated in any reasonable request for investigation of the trafficking or<br />

demonstrate extreme hardship involving unusual and severe harm if removed<br />

from the United States. 84 If the client meets these requirements, both she and her<br />

derivative family members should receive lawful permanent residence.<br />

U Visa 85<br />

The U visa assists victims of certain crimes (and in some cases their parents)<br />

who have suffered “substantial physical or mental abuse” from the criminal<br />

activity, and who have stepped forward to cooperate with law enforcement<br />

investigations or prosecutions. 86 Like the T visa, the U visa permits the inclusion<br />

of certain qualified relatives. 87 Also like the T visa, the U visa classifies recipients<br />

as “nonimmigrants,” but allows them to seek permanent resident status after three<br />

years. The statute encompasses not only domestic violence, but many other crimes<br />

such as sexual assault, felonious assault, unlawful criminal restraint, and torture. 88<br />

Regulations have not yet been promulgated to implement and issue U visas,<br />

although USCIS has issued a draft U visa application for comment. At present,<br />

practitioners are obtaining interim relief by filing a cover letter that details the<br />

grounds for the victim’s U visa eligibility, law enforcement certification, and a<br />

sheet with basic identification data. 89 The law enforcement certification must<br />

state that the alien victim “has been helpful, is being helpful, or is likely to be<br />

helpful” in the investigation or prosecution of the qualifying criminal activity.<br />

The certification may be signed by a federal, state or local law enforcement<br />

official, or by a prosecutor, judge, or other authority investigating the criminal<br />

activity. 90 There is no requirement that a defendant actually be convicted, or<br />

even arrested, for a victim to qualify for U status.<br />

Upon showing prima facie eligibility, the applicant will receive deferred<br />

action status until the U visa regulations are issued. In the interim, victims may<br />

submit an employment authorization application with their request for deferred<br />

action, and, once granted, renew their work permit annually. Pursuant to a<br />

January 2006 policy memorandum, USCIS will count the period that a victim<br />

has deferred action status per a grant of interim relief towards the three years<br />

required to apply for adjustment of status. 91 Like the T visa, most bars to<br />

inadmissibility are waived, but without the T visa’s requirement that there be a<br />

nexus between the ground of inadmissibility and the criminal activity. 92

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!