Women's Decision-Making And Factors Affecting Their Choice Of ...

Women's Decision-Making And Factors Affecting Their Choice Of ... Women's Decision-Making And Factors Affecting Their Choice Of ...

epubs.surrey.ac.uk
from epubs.surrey.ac.uk More from this publisher
24.03.2013 Views

Chapter 4: Qualitative Research Introduction The previous chapter presented the first study of the thesis, a review of literature about the choice of place of birth, and identified not only a dearth of studies, but also, a weakness in the choice of methods used to collect data. Six out of nine studies included in the review used questionnaires. The thesis identified the use of questionnaires as inappropriate because the area has not been well researched. As a result, a recommendation was made that exploratory studies would be more appropriate. The task of the thesis, in the light of the results of the systematic review, is to contribute to existing knowledge by employing an appropriate method to determine women's views about factors influencing their preference for home or hospital birth. The thesis considered that a qualitative method would be more appropriate to study women's views, as it allows participants to tell their story in their own way without any suggestions from the investigator. Before a discussion of the qualitative study, it seems appropriate to first illuminate qualitative research, by discussing the paradigm of naturalistic inquiry, from which qualitative research derives. It is hoped that the discussion of qualitative research in the present chapter will attest to its appropriateness in the investigation of women's views. Qualitative research is a form of social inquiry that studies the way people interpret and make sense of their experiences, and the world in which they live. Descriptive data, in the form of people's own written or spoken words and 71

observable behaviour are used (Holloway 1997; Taylor and Bogdan 1984). The aim is to obtain nuances of descriptions from the participants' perspective about the subject of the research. The view of qualitative research is that human behaviour can be better understood in the setting in which it occurs (Guba and Lincoln 1994; Lincoln and Guba 1985). It is necessary, therefore, to describe experiences within their natural context to generate theory capable of explaining that behaviour, while at the same time preserving the meaning of the experience. Qualitative research is inductive; concepts, insights, and understandings are developed from patterns in the data (Taylor and Bogdan 1984). Qualitative research derives from the qualitative paradigm (Creswell 1994; Patton 1991), which is informed by the naturalistic or constructivist approach (Guba 1993; Lincoln and Guba 1985). Naturalistic inquiry is explained in terms of how it addresses questions concerning four philosophical categories of ontology, epistemology, logic and teleology (Creswell 1998; Maylcut and Morehouse 1994). The questions are answered by a set of postulates, or axioms, which make a claim for a way of conducting research. A postulate is something that is stipulated and given the status of acceptance in order to get on with the task at hand (Maylcut and Morehouse 1994). Postulates, therefore, provide the platform for conducting research, by shaping the way researchers approach problems, the methods they use to collect data, and the type of problems they choose to investigate. The first philosophical area is ontology, which deals with assumptions relating to the nature of reality. One key ontological question is about the nature of reality. Naturalistic inquiry posits that there are multiple realities, which are 72

observable behaviour are used (Holloway 1997; Taylor and Bogdan 1984). The<br />

aim is to obtain nuances of descriptions from the participants' perspective about<br />

the subject of the research.<br />

The view of qualitative research is that human behaviour can be better<br />

understood in the setting in which it occurs (Guba and Lincoln 1994; Lincoln and<br />

Guba 1985). It is necessary, therefore, to describe experiences within their natural<br />

context to generate theory capable of explaining that behaviour, while at the same<br />

time preserving the meaning of the experience. Qualitative research is inductive;<br />

concepts, insights, and understandings are developed from patterns in the data<br />

(Taylor and Bogdan 1984).<br />

Qualitative research derives from the qualitative paradigm (Creswell 1994;<br />

Patton 1991), which is informed by the naturalistic or constructivist approach<br />

(Guba 1993; Lincoln and Guba 1985). Naturalistic inquiry is explained in terms<br />

of how it addresses questions concerning four philosophical categories of<br />

ontology, epistemology, logic and teleology (Creswell 1998; Maylcut and<br />

Morehouse 1994). The questions are answered by a set of postulates, or axioms,<br />

which make a claim for a way of conducting research. A postulate is something<br />

that is stipulated and given the status of acceptance in order to get on with the task<br />

at hand (Maylcut and Morehouse 1994). Postulates, therefore, provide the<br />

platform for conducting research, by shaping the way researchers approach<br />

problems, the methods they use to collect data, and the type of problems they<br />

choose to investigate.<br />

The first philosophical area is ontology, which deals with assumptions<br />

relating to the nature of reality. One key ontological question is about the nature<br />

of reality. Naturalistic inquiry posits that there are multiple realities, which are<br />

72

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!