SAGA-BOOK - Viking Society Web Publications

SAGA-BOOK - Viking Society Web Publications SAGA-BOOK - Viking Society Web Publications

vsnrweb.publications.org.uk
from vsnrweb.publications.org.uk More from this publisher
23.03.2013 Views

Saga-Book of the Viking Society speaking loudly to alert Aron, who kills him, defenceless and unsuspecting as soon as he sets foot over the threshold. Then they make free with the farm for the night. 36 It seems significant that Arons saga provides no convincing alternative to this tale, merely saying that Aron went there alone, and that the outcome was that Sigmundr was killed without much ado pvi at Sigmundr var uti staddrF' This is, moreover, the only passage in which Sturla is more detailed than the biography. The uncertain certainty of this relatively weak account in Arons saga is suspect in the extreme, and gives the impression that the author was not ignorant of the story the way Sturla told it but was deliberately whitewashing his hero. It is as though he were able to cope with the minor cases in which Aron appeared less favourably than was desired, but his imagination failed to invent a plausible rejection of what amounted to cowardice. One of the best episodes in the saga is the fight which took place at Geirpj6fsfjar

On Arons saga Hjorleifssonar 149 Other evidence of this sort does not suggest any precise knowledge of Sturla's history on the part of the biographer, but there are instances which could be interpreted as showing that the earlier account had for example been read once, but badly remembered. The attack on Valshamarr takes place at night according to Sturla, and by day in Arons saga, though the latter does not stress that it js daylight. 39 The events of the episode are indeed more convincing if darkness is assumed. Aron and Haf'porir are able to make their way back to the lamb-shed unseen; Eirikr birch-leg does not recognise whom he has killed, though the difference between the younger and older man (Aron and his uncle) would have been apparent by daylight: Aron's whole escape is more readily credible. In a similar way the Islendinga saga version of Eyj6lfr's last defence reads more logically, though we have to rely on Resensb6k for the equivalent passage of Arons saga, and the manuscript shows some sign of corruption at this point.t? Eyj6lfr is given no motive for remaining on the island in the younger story, but j slendinga saga provides the convincing reason that he wanted to damage the ferry boat in order to forestall pursuit. He is heard at his work and attacked. This is far more satisfactory. In both these cases the prevalent illogicality of Arons saga points to a certain lack of confidence in the author, which could be explained by a partial digestion of source material. Other differences of circumstance seem to show entirely different sources of information, Arons saga says that Sturla Sighvatsson arranged a special meeting with the Hrafnssons at which he charged them with harbouring Aron and settled the forfeit due, whereas t slendinga saga records that they were formally summoned at the Assembly, and that BOI5varr :P6rl'5arson stood as guarantor '9Sturl. I 307; II 265-7 . .. Sturl, I 292; II 25I.

Saga-Book of the <strong>Viking</strong> <strong>Society</strong><br />

speaking loudly to alert Aron, who kills him, defenceless<br />

and unsuspecting as soon as he sets foot over the<br />

threshold. Then they make free with the farm for the<br />

night. 36 It seems significant that Arons saga provides no<br />

convincing alternative to this tale, merely saying that<br />

Aron went there alone, and that the outcome was that<br />

Sigmundr was killed without much ado pvi at Sigmundr<br />

var uti staddrF' This is, moreover, the only passage in<br />

which Sturla is more detailed than the biography.<br />

The uncertain certainty of this relatively weak account<br />

in Arons saga is suspect in the extreme, and gives the<br />

impression that the author was not ignorant of the<br />

story the way Sturla told it but was deliberately whitewashing<br />

his hero. It is as though he were able to cope<br />

with the minor cases in which Aron appeared less<br />

favourably than was desired, but his imagination failed<br />

to invent a plausible rejection of what amounted to<br />

cowardice.<br />

One of the best episodes in the saga is the fight which<br />

took place at Geirpj6fsfjar

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!