05.03.2013 Views

Rowville-Rail-Study-Final-Stage-1-Report-FINAL

Rowville-Rail-Study-Final-Stage-1-Report-FINAL

Rowville-Rail-Study-Final-Stage-1-Report-FINAL

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

Table 10 – Summary comparison of <strong>Rowville</strong> Station options<br />

<strong>Final</strong> <strong>Stage</strong> 1 Feasibility <strong>Report</strong><br />

A <strong>Rowville</strong> rail line concept<br />

Consideration Stud Park option Wellington/Stud Roads option<br />

Access to rail<br />

station<br />

Good access (all modes) via transport hub at<br />

Stud Park<br />

Construction Requires tunnel beneath Stud Road and into<br />

Stud Park, and underground station<br />

Land Little or no land required due to use of road<br />

reservations and underground alignment<br />

Transport<br />

improvement<br />

Requires connecting bus services and other<br />

modes to improve access to Stud Park and<br />

surrounding suburbs<br />

Shorter scheme saves around xxx metres of<br />

tunnel construction and station is at the<br />

surface<br />

Land required for rail line, station, bus/car<br />

parking and access road on south side of<br />

Wellington Road<br />

Station is close to centre of catchment area Station is less well located, but train travel<br />

times would be a couple of minutes shorter<br />

Physical impacts Less impact on surroundings due to tunnel More impact on surroundings due to surface<br />

level rail<br />

Construction Significant construction impacts due to Less construction impact because of being<br />

tunnelling activities<br />

at ground level<br />

Note: Further work is required to weigh up all the differences between the options before choosing between them.<br />

6.3 Sustainability considerations<br />

Sustainability and climate change adaptation would be applicable to all aspects of the<br />

project.<br />

6.3.1 Environmental sustainability<br />

Environmentally sustainable design (ESD) initiatives would ensure that the project design is<br />

as efficient and sustainable as possible. They would focus on best practice sustainable<br />

design, environmental impacts and government policies in the following categories:<br />

pollution<br />

carbon emissions<br />

energy<br />

climate change<br />

water<br />

indoor/outdoor environmental quality<br />

community, culture and heritage<br />

economic growth<br />

management & operation<br />

materials and waste<br />

biodiversity &vegetation<br />

The Sustainability Considerations <strong>Report</strong> provides details of the methodology followed, key<br />

sustainability initiatives considered to date, a proposed integration framework for the next<br />

phases of the project, and how to establish, monitor and report on sustainability targets.<br />

In summary, the key sustainability initiatives considered so far include:<br />

cooling and heating energy of underground stations reduced by including innovative<br />

Page 48

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!