04.03.2013 Views

BULETINUL INSTITUTULUI POLITEHNIC DIN IAŞI - Universitatea ...

BULETINUL INSTITUTULUI POLITEHNIC DIN IAŞI - Universitatea ...

BULETINUL INSTITUTULUI POLITEHNIC DIN IAŞI - Universitatea ...

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

Bul. Inst. Polit. Iaşi, t. LVI (LX), f. 2, 2010 249<br />

group, we can also use CMM’s or CNC-milling machines but equipped with<br />

laser beam probes (ex. Renishaw, Metris LC Mitutoyo), or associated optical<br />

sensors (ex. CCD cameras) [2].<br />

3. Advantages and Weak Points of Different Scanning Equipments<br />

Scanning<br />

equipments<br />

Advantages Week points<br />

Laser Precise and fast scanning on Z-axis (0.001 mm) Equipment high price<br />

Non-contact method It is not possible to scan reflective<br />

materials<br />

It is possible to scan soft materials (or liquids) Scanning in X- and Y-axis is<br />

inaccurate<br />

(0.035 – 0.060 mm)<br />

It is not possible to scan notches<br />

areas or steep surfaces due to<br />

additional reflections.<br />

Sensibility to air dust<br />

CCD Fast<br />

High price of equipments<br />

cameras It is possible to use two or three cameras Accuracy decreases linear with<br />

simultaneously<br />

camera distance<br />

Insensible to part color<br />

Scanning angle is equal regardless<br />

the shape of part’s surface; in case<br />

of steep angles the measurement in<br />

inaccurate<br />

Non-contact method, it is possible to scan soft By camera scanning, a very sharp<br />

materials<br />

picture is required; simultaneous<br />

scanning of far and closer surfaces<br />

demonstrates linear deviation of<br />

results depending on focal distances<br />

In case of special coaxial lightning it is possible to In case of oily or wet parts the<br />

scan small diameters and high depths on Z-axis measurement in inaccurate<br />

It is possible to scan very small areas: 1 mm 2 (one<br />

scan only needed) – accuracy is above few<br />

micrometers<br />

Scanning on flat surfaces is very fast<br />

Dust causes bad scanning<br />

Contact Very precise on all axis (depends on scanning It’s inadequate for soft materials.<br />

(classic) equipment)<br />

Fast scanning of known geometrical parts Scanning unknown surfaces is either<br />

impossible<br />

inaccurate<br />

or very slow and<br />

Contact<br />

Precise scanning of coins or similar geometries<br />

Manual or automatic scanning possibility<br />

Hand-held scanning equipment is useful for<br />

scanning big products (airplanes, ships, big<br />

machines or devices)<br />

Precise on all axis (0.001 mm) Minimum diameter of stylus is 0.3<br />

digitizers<br />

mm, scanning surface roughness is<br />

(Renishaw)<br />

not possible<br />

Relatively low price It not possible to scan soft materials<br />

It is possible to use different styluses for different Though material of stylus is wear<br />

surfaces<br />

resistant, it’s surface wears in time<br />

Oil, liquid or dust do not interfere with the Scanning speed is lower (compared<br />

scanning process<br />

It is possible to scan unknown steep surfaces<br />

to non-contact systems)

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!