ALPHA DELTA KAPPA DECEMBER 2010 - Gedung Kuning

ALPHA DELTA KAPPA DECEMBER 2010 - Gedung Kuning ALPHA DELTA KAPPA DECEMBER 2010 - Gedung Kuning

gedungkuning.com
from gedungkuning.com More from this publisher
02.03.2013 Views

Education in Mexico and the United States Becoming Bi-Cultural By Eloisa Cudney ImmedIate Past mexIco NatIoNal PresIdeNt Many years ago my father’s company transferred him from Mexico City to Los Angeles. My first encounter with the American public school system took place when I enrolled in Beverly Hills High School. The experience was quite shocking for a 14-year-old who barely spoke English. To begin with, I did not have to wear a uniform, and there was someone called a “counselor” who, with my father translating for me, made up “my” program for the first semester. Wasn’t there an established program for all the students alike? My program consisted of only five subjects per semester instead of the 14 I had in Mexico the previous year. The first day in my new school arrived. The front lawn seemed ominous and huge, compared to the typical school in Mexico. My dad took me to the principal’s office where the dean of girls, Mrs. Pauley, greeted me. A locker was assigned to me in a hallway that looked cavernous and silent. Everyone was already in class. Mrs. Pauley accompanied me and introduced me to my first class which was senior Spanish. The counselor thought that the best way for me to learn English was by being with students who were learning Spanish. That didn’t work because the teacher, Señor Padilla, didn’t speak Spanish well. I got a “C” that day on my first Spanish test. I didn’t understand the questions and didn’t dare get up and ask the teacher because in Mexico no student gets up during a test. When the bell rang, I didn’t know what to do. In Mexico the teachers changed classrooms, not the students. All the sounds of locker doors slamming, kids talking and bells ringing seemed to invade my whole body, frightening me. Mrs. Pauley saw me and came to my rescue, taking me to my locker to put away the Spanish textbook. That was another first. In Mexico my mother would take me to a bookstore to buy my textbooks for the year and cover them. In Beverly High the books were lent to me for a semester, and the books were kept in my locker, not in a compartment under the seat of “my” desk. Mrs. Pauley took me to my next class. Of course I was late and wondered if I would ever make a class on time during such a short break. The class was English I. That hour went by as a complete blank. I didn’t understand a thing. All I knew was that I was left with I got a “C” that day on my first Spanish test. I didn’t understand the questions and didn’t dare get up and ask the teacher because in Mexico no student gets up during a test. 30 Excellence in Action for World Understanding a copy of Ayn Rand’s “The Fountainhead”—to be read that week—and a grammar handbook. Luckily that’s where I met my first friend, Deanne Gross, and she remained my friend during the next three-and-a-half years. We had English and biology together, and she helped me during recess. I had never been to a school cafeteria before nor paid for my lunch at school. As a matter of fact, my parents had not given me any money. The first day, Deanne shared some of her lunch with me and then took me to the gym after recess. I had taken physical education before, but not used a dressing room with showers and chosen the sport I wanted to play that quarter. That first day I just watched everyone swim and was assigned a second locker for my gym clothes. By the end of the day, I was exhausted and dying to go home. A long time has passed since that fateful day, and I have since returned to Mexico and become a teacher. The reason I became a teacher was not because I had a degree in education. I actually went to college to study theater arts and had a minor in education. The main reason was that I had become quite fluent in English. So, when I went to enroll my children in a private school in Mexico City, I was asked to give English classes. This meant I would be working at the same school my kids were attending and, as a fringe benefit, my kids would receive a scholarship from kindergaten through second grade. It also meant that, Ø

for the next 15 years, they would attend the same school and be in the same building. The preschool, elementary, middle and high schools were simply different sections within the building. This is typical of a private Mexican school. The education system in Mexico is complex. For example, in the private school where I taught, students spoke at least two languages because most private schools are bilingual. Students who wanted to get a bachelor’s degree outside Mexico ranked in the top 10 percent with their SAT scores. A large number of students graduated and went on to Ivy League universities such as Brown, Harvard and MIT. The rest of the graduating class would go on to Mexican universities and then get master’s degrees. Seldom did a student stop with just a high school education, and private education in Mexico is a norm for those who can afford it. There are many types of private schools geared toward specific needs and segments of the population. Some are run by different religious organizations and others are laic (secular) with an emphasis on science and languages. Some are run under the auspices of foreign countries to insure that their co-nationals follow the same programs and system as they would in their native country. Most students who go to these schools will attend a university in the country whose programs the school follows. For example, students who go to a British school in Mexico will try to attend a university in England. All private schools must also comply with the programs set by the Mexican Education Secretariat (SEP), and teachers at a private school must be authorized by the SEP. Preschool and elementary school teachers must have a degree in education and be Ever since that first day at Beverly Hills High School, I have experienced, suffered and enjoyed the differences of education in both countries. credited by the SEP. Foreign unified free textbooks and are language teachers in preschool able to translate the lessons to and elementary school must be the local Indian languages are authorized to work as teachers hard to find. by the SEP, but do not need a de- Free textbooks are given gree in second language educa- to every student nationwide, tion. Most private schools offer a including to those in private foreign language beginning with schools, through 6th grade. preschool. Many middle and These books are the basis of the high school teachers are profes- elementary school programs sionals who give one or two and were the collaboration of classes a day. For example, biol- many education experts. In ogy teachers are often doctors, some areas of the country, these but they do not have teaching books are probably the only degrees. books that a child may read The school programs are and are meant to be part of the content-based. Some subjects family’s private library. They are are given every day while others excellent textbooks, but many may be given twice a week. Once of the public school teachers are a student goes into a Mexican not qualified to use them. university, the programs focus Mexico encounters another entirely on the chosen degree. If tremendous challenge with the someone decides to change his/ very powerful teachers’ union, her field of study after one year headed by a woman who is so in college, he/she loses those politically strong that she has credits and must start again. By the means to disrupt the com- the time you get a bachelor’s plete Mexican public education degree, you have completed the system. A teacher must belong equivalent of a master’s program to this union in order to work in the United States. in the public school system. One would think that if The union decides who may or private schools must follow the may not get a teaching position. SEP’s programs and can have Once a person has this authori- such wonderful results, then the zation, it is practically impossible public schools must be equally to fire him or her. The position good, but that is not the case. As is his or hers for life. a country, Mexico ranks quite Ever since that first day low in reading comprehension, at Beverly Hills High School, writing and mathematics. This I have experienced, suffered is due to many problems within and enjoyed the differences of the SEP. Education is central- education in both countries. I’ve ized and is part of the federal become completely bi-cultural government. The programs and have gained a tremendous are designed in Mexico City at wealth of pedagogic choices, the SEP’s headquarters. Rural which has richly enhanced my areas have completely different teaching. I learned that there educational needs. In many of are positive and negative aspects these areas native Indian lan- to both educational systems. guages are spoken and educa- Recognizing these differences tion in these languages is just and taking advantage of the beginning. Trained teachers more effective options helps who know how to use the SEP’s both teachers and students.t Excellence in Action for World Understanding 31

for the next 15 years, they would<br />

attend the same school and be in<br />

the same building. The preschool,<br />

elementary, middle and<br />

high schools were simply different<br />

sections within the building.<br />

This is typical of a private<br />

Mexican school.<br />

The education system in<br />

Mexico is complex. For example,<br />

in the private school<br />

where I taught, students spoke<br />

at least two languages because<br />

most private schools are bilingual.<br />

Students who wanted to<br />

get a bachelor’s degree outside<br />

Mexico ranked in the top 10 percent<br />

with their SAT scores. A<br />

large number of students graduated<br />

and went on to Ivy League<br />

universities such as Brown,<br />

Harvard and MIT. The rest<br />

of the graduating class would<br />

go on to Mexican universities<br />

and then get master’s degrees.<br />

Seldom did a student stop with<br />

just a high school education, and<br />

private education in Mexico is a<br />

norm for those who can afford it.<br />

There are many types of<br />

private schools geared toward<br />

specific needs and segments of<br />

the population. Some are run by<br />

different religious organizations<br />

and others are laic (secular)<br />

with an emphasis on science and<br />

languages. Some are run under<br />

the auspices of foreign countries<br />

to insure that their co-nationals<br />

follow the same programs and<br />

system as they would in their native<br />

country. Most students who<br />

go to these schools will attend a<br />

university in the country whose<br />

programs the school follows.<br />

For example, students who go to<br />

a British school in Mexico will<br />

try to attend a university in England.<br />

All private schools must<br />

also comply with the programs<br />

set by the Mexican Education<br />

Secretariat (SEP), and teachers<br />

at a private school must be<br />

authorized by the SEP.<br />

Preschool and elementary<br />

school teachers must have a<br />

degree in education and be<br />

Ever since that first day at Beverly Hills High<br />

School, I have experienced, suffered and enjoyed<br />

the differences of education in both countries.<br />

credited by the SEP. Foreign unified free textbooks and are<br />

language teachers in preschool able to translate the lessons to<br />

and elementary school must be the local Indian languages are<br />

authorized to work as teachers hard to find.<br />

by the SEP, but do not need a de- Free textbooks are given<br />

gree in second language educa- to every student nationwide,<br />

tion. Most private schools offer a including to those in private<br />

foreign language beginning with schools, through 6th grade.<br />

preschool. Many middle and These books are the basis of the<br />

high school teachers are profes- elementary school programs<br />

sionals who give one or two and were the collaboration of<br />

classes a day. For example, biol- many education experts. In<br />

ogy teachers are often doctors, some areas of the country, these<br />

but they do not have teaching books are probably the only<br />

degrees.<br />

books that a child may read<br />

The school programs are and are meant to be part of the<br />

content-based. Some subjects family’s private library. They are<br />

are given every day while others excellent textbooks, but many<br />

may be given twice a week. Once of the public school teachers are<br />

a student goes into a Mexican not qualified to use them.<br />

university, the programs focus Mexico encounters another<br />

entirely on the chosen degree. If tremendous challenge with the<br />

someone decides to change his/ very powerful teachers’ union,<br />

her field of study after one year headed by a woman who is so<br />

in college, he/she loses those politically strong that she has<br />

credits and must start again. By the means to disrupt the com-<br />

the time you get a bachelor’s plete Mexican public education<br />

degree, you have completed the system. A teacher must belong<br />

equivalent of a master’s program to this union in order to work<br />

in the United States.<br />

in the public school system.<br />

One would think that if The union decides who may or<br />

private schools must follow the may not get a teaching position.<br />

SEP’s programs and can have Once a person has this authori-<br />

such wonderful results, then the zation, it is practically impossible<br />

public schools must be equally to fire him or her. The position<br />

good, but that is not the case. As is his or hers for life.<br />

a country, Mexico ranks quite Ever since that first day<br />

low in reading comprehension, at Beverly Hills High School,<br />

writing and mathematics. This I have experienced, suffered<br />

is due to many problems within and enjoyed the differences of<br />

the SEP. Education is central- education in both countries. I’ve<br />

ized and is part of the federal become completely bi-cultural<br />

government. The programs and have gained a tremendous<br />

are designed in Mexico City at wealth of pedagogic choices,<br />

the SEP’s headquarters. Rural which has richly enhanced my<br />

areas have completely different teaching. I learned that there<br />

educational needs. In many of are positive and negative aspects<br />

these areas native Indian lan- to both educational systems.<br />

guages are spoken and educa- Recognizing these differences<br />

tion in these languages is just and taking advantage of the<br />

beginning. Trained teachers more effective options helps<br />

who know how to use the SEP’s both teachers and students.t<br />

Excellence in Action for World Understanding<br />

31

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!