BUYING GUIDE - Wine Enthusiast
BUYING GUIDE - Wine Enthusiast
BUYING GUIDE - Wine Enthusiast
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
tain fruit. Ripe plums and cherries are accented with<br />
hints of dried leaves, tobacco, and sweet herb. Baking<br />
spices reflect its 20 months in oak, and the wine has a<br />
soft finish that is ideal for immediate enjoyment. Editors’<br />
Choice. —P.G.<br />
abv: 14.2% Price: $25<br />
88<br />
Steppe Cellars 2008 Merlot (Columbia<br />
Valley). At first, a rush of front-loaded plum<br />
and blackberry fruit hits the palate, then the flavors<br />
seem to sag a bit entering the midpalate. A wall of stillto-be-resolved<br />
oak leads into a hard, astringent, somewhat<br />
woody finish. Yet there is a substantial and wellbuilt<br />
wine here, waiting to resolve its components into<br />
a more seamless whole. Retasted after being open a full<br />
day, it showed well, suggesting good aging potential.<br />
—P.G.<br />
abv: 14.4% Price: $28<br />
86<br />
Kirkland Signature 2010 Merlot (Columbia<br />
Valley). For full review see page 11. Best<br />
Buy.<br />
abv: 14.5% Price: $9<br />
SYRAH<br />
94<br />
Dunham 2008 Lewis Vineyard Syrah (Columbia<br />
Valley). For full review see page 4.<br />
Cellar Selection.<br />
abv: NA Price: $75<br />
93<br />
Dusted Valley 2008 Rachis Syrah (Columbia<br />
Valley). A new entry in the Dusted<br />
Valley lineup, this offering is co-fermented with Viognier<br />
and includes a small amount of Petite Sirah as well.<br />
It shows real depth and power, a concentrated explosion<br />
of boysenberry and black cherry fruit, annotated with<br />
clove and anise. A delicious underpinning of mineral<br />
and graphite anchor the lengthy finish. —P.G.<br />
abv: 14.7% Price: $53<br />
93<br />
JM Cellars 2009 Syrah (Columbia Valley).<br />
This wine kept improving in the glass over<br />
a period of hours, and as it did so, the score kept rising.<br />
Initial scents of Bourbon barrel gave way to rich blueberry<br />
and black cherry fruit, set in a roasted, potent mix<br />
of darker flavors. Smoke, coffee liqueur, a whiff of stem,<br />
a streak of vanilla, all tightly wound and elevated with<br />
scents of citrus peel. Editors’ Choice. —P.G.<br />
abv: 14.5% Price: $32<br />
93<br />
JM Cellars 2009 Boushey Vineyard Syrah<br />
(Yakima Valley). An elegant showcase for<br />
the Boushey fruit, this new JM Cellars release displays<br />
refined raspberry fruit, coated in silky cocoa and almond<br />
butter. Firmly acidic, sleek and racy, it gains complexity<br />
and texture through a lingering, tobacco-laden<br />
finish. Editors’ Choice. —P.G.<br />
abv: 14.9% Price: $45<br />
92<br />
Dunham 2009 Syrah (Columbia Valley).<br />
Thick, oaky and loaded with toasty highlights,<br />
this substantial Syrah slathers its fruit in a heavy coat of<br />
caramel, buttered nuts and spice. Delicious and supple,<br />
its naturally juicy acidity keeps the wine lively. With substantial<br />
breathing time, boysenberry fruit melds with<br />
streaks of roasted coffee, clove and tobacco. Editors’<br />
Choice. —P.G.<br />
abv: 13.8% Price: $35<br />
92<br />
Steppe Cellars 2008 StoneTree Vineyard<br />
Syrah (Wahluke Slope). An unusual and<br />
compelling effort, this opens with lush, generous fruit<br />
flavors of both red and black berries, highlighted with<br />
orange peel. Excellent depth and texture, with a fullbodied<br />
middle and palate-pleasing minerality. Gains<br />
complexity through a lingering finish. Editors’ Choice.<br />
—P.G.<br />
abv: 14.6% Price: $28<br />
90<br />
Dusted Valley 2009 Stained Tooth Syrah<br />
(Columbia Valley). Substantial and muscular,<br />
still quite tight and unyielding, this grudgingly displays<br />
purple fruits in a mix of roasted coffee beans, clove and<br />
black olive. If past releases are any indication, this will<br />
continue to evolve and expand as it gets a bit more bottle<br />
time. —P.G.<br />
abv: 15.2% Price: $32<br />
89<br />
McCrea Cellars 2007 Boushey Grande<br />
Côte Vineyard Syrah (Yakima Valley).<br />
Round, ripe and quite pretty cherry fruit flavors, showing<br />
a hint of loam and a briny note. Tannins have<br />
smoothed out, and the length is better than average.<br />
Score could improve with further bottle age. —P.G.<br />
abv: 14.8% Price: $36<br />
89<br />
Smasne Cellars 2008 Block #3 Lawrence<br />
Vineyard Syrah (Columbia Valley).<br />
Tart and juicy, with crisply-rendered berry and plum<br />
fruit flavors. As with all the Smasne wines, the oak is a<br />
large presence, here adding a striking note of clove. The<br />
tannins hint at a slight green streak, but the overall balance<br />
is fine. —P.G.<br />
abv: 13.9% Price: $32<br />
88<br />
McCrea Cellars 2007 Cuvée Orleans Syrah<br />
(Yakima Valley). Dusty and toasty aromas<br />
over sweet plum fruit, with a streak of mocha running<br />
sharply down the center. Svelt and open, yet still sharp<br />
and showing a little bite in the back. —P.G.<br />
abv: 14.8% Price: $40<br />
OTHER RED WINES<br />
90<br />
Airfield Estates 2010 Tempranillo (Yakima<br />
Valley). Much improved from past efforts,<br />
this firm and fruity Tempranillo has a lush core of boysenberry<br />
and black cherry fruit. It’s finished with screwcap,<br />
and may require decanting to push it open, but it<br />
will reward your patience with a deep and focused wine<br />
that has some cellar potential. —P.G.<br />
abv: 14.1% Price: $25<br />
90<br />
Smasne Cellars 2009 Upland Vineyard<br />
Grenache (Snipes Mountain District).<br />
Dried leaf and cherry tobacco scents highlight this wellmade<br />
Grenache. It includes just a whiff or two of the<br />
classic funk, but the rich black-cherry fruit is the real<br />
star, well-ripened and leading into a clean, lingering finish.<br />
—P.G.<br />
abv: 13.9% Price: $30<br />
90<br />
Stottle 2008 Tempranillo (Horse Heaven<br />
Hills). Stottle does an especially good job with<br />
Tempranillo, sourced from the same site as its Nebbiolo.<br />
Fruity and fleshy, loaded with bright berry notes, it<br />
reflects its 21 months in barrel in its complex streaks of<br />
spice, chocolate and butterscotch. —P.G.<br />
abv: 13.9% Price: $26<br />
89<br />
Stottle 2008 Barbera (Columbia Valley).<br />
Solidly varietal flavors of strawberry and Bing<br />
cherry fruit anchor this well-made, 100% Barbera. The<br />
wine has both depth and polish, with some varietal tartness<br />
running through a medium length finish. It makes<br />
a good case for Barbera’s potential in Washington state.<br />
—P.G.<br />
abv: 13.5% Price: $26<br />
88<br />
Airfield Estates 2010 Pinot Noir (Yakima<br />
Valley). This has a soft entry, its fruit beginning<br />
to show secondary flavors of bakery pastries. Mulberry<br />
and prune, soft and spicy, make for a pleasing, accessible<br />
wine that finishes with a lick of cinnamon. It is already<br />
drinking well. —P.G.<br />
abv: 14.1% Price: $32<br />
88<br />
Dusted Valley 2009 Stone Tree Vineyard<br />
Mourvèdre (Wahluke Slope). Round and<br />
fruity, with a generous mix of berry and cherry, and no<br />
discernible oak influence, this pleasing Mourvèdre lets<br />
the fruit be the star. Nicely balanced and drinking well<br />
already, it carries a hint of mineral/metal in the finish.<br />
—P.G.<br />
abv: 15% Price: $39<br />
88<br />
Steppe Cellars 2008 StoneTree Vineyard<br />
Malbec (Wahluke Slope). It drinks bigger<br />
than the listed 14% alcohol, but remains all in proportion.<br />
Tangy cherry and plum fruit flavors are wrapped<br />
in spice, cinnamon especially. A coffee scent carries<br />
through on the palate, infusing the finish. —P.G.<br />
abv: 14% Price: $28<br />
88<br />
Smasne Cellars 2008 Phinny Hill Vineyard<br />
Petit Verdot (Horse Heaven Hills).<br />
Dark and chocolaty, with grainy tannins under deep cassis<br />
and black cherry fruit. Full-bodied and chewy, with<br />
coffee grounds and spices filling in the finish. —P.G.<br />
abv: 13.9% Price: $35<br />
86<br />
Smasne Cellars 2008 Phinny Hill Vineyard<br />
Malbec (Horse Heaven Hills). From a<br />
well-regarded site in the Horse Heaven Hills, this pure<br />
Malbec is clean and well-proportioned, but a bit on the<br />
simple side. Plain red fruit flavors, accented with light<br />
barrel notes, quickly fade on the delicate finish. —P.G.<br />
abv: 13.9% Price: $32<br />
85<br />
Smasne Cellars 2008 Phinny Hill Vineyard<br />
Carmenère (Horse Heaven Hills). A<br />
heavily pungent scent of bell pepper is partially cloaked<br />
in mocha flavors but seeps through on the palate. An uneasy<br />
truce between the vegetal fruit and the chocolaty<br />
barrel keeps this wine in an awkward condition; more<br />
bottle time may soften it but it can’t ripen it. —P.G.<br />
abv: 13.9% Price: $28<br />
85<br />
Stottle 2007 Nebbiolo (Horse Heaven<br />
Hills). Pure Nebbiolo from the Elerding Vine-<br />
<strong>Wine</strong>Mag.com | 61