Download (12MB) - University of Salford Institutional Repository

Download (12MB) - University of Salford Institutional Repository Download (12MB) - University of Salford Institutional Repository

usir.salford.ac.uk
from usir.salford.ac.uk More from this publisher
21.02.2013 Views

etween viewer and the viewed, perceived as a saturated -metaphorical lack of [...] difference between viewer and fiction'; this effect can be achieved in different ways, and what Grodal says about certain films 'reducing a given agent's ability to act, and emphasizing the agent's perceptions and expressions of emotions', a process that reduces 'the possibilities of making an objective time-space' is applicable to this sequence (Grodal, 1997: 164-165). Symbiotic fusion occurs between the viewer's gaze and Joe's as, enchanted, they contemplate Caterina s s face and the moon (see image). Here, the mise-en-scene plays on the universal human experience of enchantment at ^J ; , *., • the fascinating spectacle of the moon, and evokes poetic traditions of comparing female beauty to it. In this way, the scene loses its time-space definition by taking on a subjective quality that shapes viewers' perception in a poetic form. As Grodal suggests, the 'deformation of canonical narratives may often lead to felt subjectivity' in the absence of a clear link between given sequences and the rest of the narrative flow; he adds that the 'schemata of acts plays a key role in felt objectivity; if they are missing, feelings of subjectivity and dreaminess will be created' (Grodal, 1997: 135). Moreover, the unspecific temporal sequencing of these moments in the life of Joe and his mother is a key element creating the subjective perception, given that 'many films produce subjectivity and dreaminess by totally dissolving the objective time-structure' (Grodal, 1997: 136). Conclusion In critical terms, apart from a contemporary review praising the film's 'exceptional plastic beauty' while simultaneously criticizing its lack of complexity, (Conrad 1979: 103) La lima 290

was considered to be Bertolucci's return to his beloved Parma. But he replied that the screenplay merely included generic mentions of the Po countryside with no precise references. He stressed that he had been unaware of filming in the same location through which Gina had passed in Before the Revolution when she returns to Milan; it was only his fall from the dolly during filming that led him to wonder whether this was a sign of having been too daring in bringing 'the mother' to the same spot (Socci, 1996: 63). It is understandable that Bertolucci wanted to place dramatic emphasis on the incestuous relationship depicted in the film, as it was an ingredient with the potential to generate publicity after Last Tango in Paris. Nevertheless, the film fails to emulate the impact of Before the Revolution or Tango, and the preceding analysis has highlighted the main weaknesses that led to this result: the lack of narrative coherence, psychological justification, and, indeed, drama in portraying the incestuous attraction between Caterina and Joe, a defect accentuated by the flimsy and ambiguous secondary storylines and characters which neither shed light on the protagonists' behaviour and existence (in the Hollywood tradition) nor draw attention to wider socio-economic circumstances (in the traditions of European cinema). The incoherent fusion of styles and moods in La lima plus the absence of any intellectual framework apart from self-referentiality and evocations of the work of directors such as Pasolini - also lead to a problematic viewing experience. Regarding the lack of coherent dramatic progression from the beginning of the story, this almost predisposes viewers to scrutinizing the motives that lead to the mother/son incest. Finding none, the film's narrative development is likely to elicit cognitive rejection and unsympathetic affective responses. If the film is setting out to represent the Oedipus complex - either as an individual drama or as a projection of a social issue - then it is missing one of its key tenets; hostility towards the parent of the same sex. As far as father figures are concerned, Joe has no competition or opposition, whereas his real competition for his 291

etween viewer and the viewed, perceived as a saturated -metaphorical lack <strong>of</strong> [...] difference<br />

between viewer and fiction'; this effect can be achieved in different ways, and what Grodal<br />

says about certain films 'reducing a given agent's ability to act, and emphasizing the agent's<br />

perceptions and expressions <strong>of</strong> emotions', a process that reduces 'the possibilities <strong>of</strong> making<br />

an objective time-space' is applicable to this sequence (Grodal, 1997: 164-165).<br />

Symbiotic fusion occurs between the<br />

viewer's gaze and Joe's as, enchanted, they<br />

contemplate Caterina s s face and the moon (see<br />

image). Here, the mise-en-scene plays on the<br />

universal human experience <strong>of</strong> enchantment at ^J ; , *., •<br />

the fascinating spectacle <strong>of</strong> the moon, and<br />

evokes poetic traditions <strong>of</strong> comparing female<br />

beauty to it. In this way, the scene loses its time-space definition by taking on a subjective<br />

quality that shapes viewers' perception in a poetic form. As Grodal suggests, the<br />

'deformation <strong>of</strong> canonical narratives may <strong>of</strong>ten lead to felt subjectivity' in the absence <strong>of</strong> a<br />

clear link between given sequences and the rest <strong>of</strong> the narrative flow; he adds that the<br />

'schemata <strong>of</strong> acts plays a key role in felt objectivity; if they are missing, feelings <strong>of</strong><br />

subjectivity and dreaminess will be created' (Grodal, 1997: 135). Moreover, the unspecific<br />

temporal sequencing <strong>of</strong> these moments in the life <strong>of</strong> Joe and his mother is a key element<br />

creating the subjective perception, given that 'many films produce subjectivity and<br />

dreaminess by totally dissolving the objective time-structure' (Grodal, 1997: 136).<br />

Conclusion<br />

In critical terms, apart from a contemporary review praising the film's 'exceptional plastic<br />

beauty' while simultaneously criticizing its lack <strong>of</strong> complexity, (Conrad 1979: 103) La lima<br />

290

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!