Integrierte Vermeidung und Verminderung der Umweltverschmutzung
Integrierte Vermeidung und Verminderung der Umweltverschmutzung Integrierte Vermeidung und Verminderung der Umweltverschmutzung
Chapter 7 The nature of the raw materials in the FDM sector and the importance of freshness, both for product quality and to prevent waste, makes collaboration between upstream and downstream partners important. It was agreed that “BAT is to seek collaboration with upstream and downstream partners, to create a chain of environmental responsibility, to minimise pollution and to protect the environment as a whole”. This is consistent with the BAT approach, not only at a site-specific level, but also on a wider scale and it may be achieved at installation level or on a wider scale via organisations representing the FDM sector. Maintenance of acceptable hygiene standards is critical in FDM installations to guarantee product quality and food safety. This strict hygiene control and the consequent requirement for regular and frequent cleaning of FDM installations and equipment have greatly influenced the BAT conclusions, especially those related directly to cleaning. Also, the recipes of some products have influenced the environmental considerations as the application of some techniques may be necessary to ensure a certain flavour, aroma or texture and this may make other techniques inapplicable. One split view was registered. One MS does not agree with the footnote in Tabelle 5.1, which shows FDM waste water quality after treatment. The footnote states that “Better levels of BOD5 and COD can be obtained. It is not always possible or cost effective to achieve the total nitrogen and phosphorus levels shown, in view of local conditions”. The MS believes that deviations from BAT, e.g. due to local conditions, are exclusively allowed to strengthen the requirements of permits. There were some discussions arising from new information introduced during the meeting. These are discussed in Section 1.5, which contains recommendations for further work. When the BAT associated level for dry dust emissions from FDM installations was discussed at the final plenary meeting, the question of whether this applied to emissions from combustion power plants in FDM installations was raised. Emissions from combustion power plants had not been a subject of the information exchange before the final meeting, so it was made clear that the BAT associated emission levels are not intended to represent BAT from such combustion plants. 7.3 Information provided The TWG comprises 16 MSs and the FDM industries also form a large proportion of the group. Many of the TWG members from industry are part of the CIAA delegation. Some of the TWG members from MSs also include industry representatives. Equipment suppliers are also represented. The environmental NGOs did not participate in the work on this document. Many reports from MSs and industry were used as sources of information in the drafting of this document, including information from example plants. The participation of individual MSs in the work, to an extent, reflected the regional distribution of the sectors. For example, several MSs participated in the work on dairies, with notable contributions from the Nordic states [42, Nordic Council of Ministers, et al., 2001], Germany [9, Verband der Deutschen Milchwirtschaft (German Dairy Association), 1999] and Italy [75, Italian contribution, 2002]. Greece, Italy, Portugal and Spain dominated the discussions about olive oil. Italy provided all of the information about pasta. Germany was one of the most active members in the information exchange process. Much of the information provided by Germany was the result of close collaboration between the German authorities and some individual FDM sectors [65, Germany, 2002], e.g. the vegetable oil and fats, dairy and brewing sectors. 616 January 2006 RHC/EIPPCB/FDM_BREF_FINAL
Chapter 7 CIAA and its member organisations provided most of the industry contributions. These included information about the majority of the individual FDM sectors, with the exceptions of meat; fish and shellfish, and fruit and vegetables. There is relatively little information specifically about the meat sector in this document and most of this was provided by the Nordic states [41, Nordic Council of Ministers, 2001] and Italy [89, Italian contribution, 2001, 91, Italian contribution, 2001]. The information about fish and shellfish processing came mainly from the Nordic states [28, Nordic Council of Ministers, 1997]. The main sources of information about fruit and vegetable processing were Belgium [31, VITO, et al., 2001, 32, Van Bael J., 1998] and Italy [89, Italian contribution, 2001, 91, Italian contribution, 2001]. The importance of hygiene throughout the whole FDM sector is shown by the fact that information and comments about cleaning came from several MSs and from CIAA. Most of the information about air abatement techniques was provided by CIAA [34, Willey A R and Williams D A, 2001] and Germany [65, Germany, 2002], although this contained relatively little information about emission levels or about the application or applicability of the techniques in the overall FDM sector or the individual sectors. A high proportion of the information about waste water and its treatment was provided by the UK [13, Environment Agency of England and Wales, 2000] and Germany [65, Germany, 2002]. Information about waste water treatment in individual sectors was provided by various MSs and industry. Information was also gathered during site visits made during the period 2001 – 2003, i.e. before the second draft was completed. The sites visited included two dairies, one in Hungary and one in Germany; four breweries, one in Hungary, one in Finland and two in Spain; a sugar refinery in Finland; a meat processing installation in Spain; two champagne installations in France, a sugar installation practising landspreading in France and several olive oil producers in Spain. Several meetings were held with CIAA on behalf of its members. Meetings were also held with German, Finnish and Spanish TWG members and with the Brewers of Europe. The formal consultations on the draft document also prompted the submission of a huge amount of information, relatively late in the process instead of, as requested, before the first draft. The consultations provided the main opportunities for the TWG to verify information already submitted. Almost half of the TWG members attended the final plenary meeting. The MSs on the FDM TWG were well represented at the final plenary meeting and were active in the discussions. The industry representatives were also active. A high proportion of the industry delegation represented the sugar sector. The information exchange and the preparation of this document has been a positive development in the prevention and control of pollution for the sectors concerned. It has provided a first-time opportunity for individual sectors to learn about techniques that have been proven to work well in others, on a Europe-wide scale. The structure of this document promotes this understanding, by focusing on the processes and practices that are common for all or many of the FDM sectors and describing their application and applicability. For example, some techniques reported for the canning of fish were recognised as being applicable for preservation in cans, bottles and jars and for foods other than fish. Consequently, some techniques originally reported for individual sectors, have been determined to be BAT in others. RHC/EIPPCB/FDM_BREF_FINAL January 2006 617
- Seite 625 und 626: Abbildung 4.75: Kontinuierliche Kaf
- Seite 627 und 628: 4.7.8.4.3 Kaffeeröstung mit nachfo
- Seite 629 und 630: 4.7.8.4.4 Nutzung von Biofiltern in
- Seite 631 und 632: Kapitel 4 Abbildung 4.22 zeigt die
- Seite 633 und 634: Kapitel 4 Die Filtration durch nat
- Seite 635 und 636: Kapitel 4 Nicht ausreichend gefüll
- Seite 637 und 638: Angewandte Technik Veraltete Techni
- Seite 639 und 640: Kapitel 4 Im Laugenbad werden die G
- Seite 641 und 642: Wirtschaftlichkeit Kosteneinsparung
- Seite 643 und 644: Kapitel 4 Maßnahme Verfahren Besch
- Seite 645 und 646: Wassersparmaßnahme Typische Verrin
- Seite 647 und 648: Kapitel 4 Kaltwasser für Aufgaben
- Seite 649 und 650: Kapitel 4 gesteuerte Auffüllventil
- Seite 651 und 652: Parameter Einheit Menge Wasserverbr
- Seite 653 und 654: 5 BESTE VERFÜGBARE TECHNIKEN Kapit
- Seite 655 und 656: 5.1 Allgemeine BVT für den gesamte
- Seite 657 und 658: Kapitel 5 7 Führen einer genauen I
- Seite 659 und 660: Kapitel 5 • Überlegungen zur Ent
- Seite 661 und 662: Kapitel 5 2 Verwendung von Reinigun
- Seite 663 und 664: Kapitel 5 Zur Vermeidung von Luftem
- Seite 665 und 666: Kapitel 5 18 Trocknung (siehe Absch
- Seite 667 und 668: Kapitel 5 4 Schälen von Obst und G
- Seite 669 und 670: Energieverbrauch Wasserverbrauch Ab
- Seite 671: Kapitel 5 Vermeidung der Produktion
- Seite 675: 7 CONCLUDING REMARKS 7.1 Timing of
- Seite 679 und 680: Chapter 7 The legislative requireme
- Seite 681: Chapter 7 • the application of no
- Seite 684 und 685: References 39 Verband der Deutschen
- Seite 686 und 687: References 91 Italian contribution
- Seite 688 und 689: References 183 CIAA-UNAFPA (2003).
- Seite 690 und 691: References 229 EC (1990). "Council
- Seite 693 und 694: GLOSSARY HINWEIS: Die deutschsprach
- Seite 695 und 696: Glossary great deal of silica is al
- Seite 697 und 698: Glossary Vinasses A by-product that
- Seite 699 und 700: Glossary ISCST Industrial source co
- Seite 701 und 702: Currency abbreviations Abbreviation
- Seite 703 und 704: GLOSSAR Glossar Dieses Glossar dien
- Seite 705 und 706: Glossar Eutrophierung Verschmutzung
- Seite 707 und 708: Glossar Schale Die äußere, eine F
- Seite 709 und 710: Glossar DDGS Feste und gelöste Sto
- Seite 711 und 712: Glossar PET Polyethylenterephtalat
- Seite 713 und 714: Einheitenzeichen Einheiten zeichen
Chapter 7<br />
CIAA and its member organisations provided most of the industry contributions. These included<br />
information about the majority of the individual FDM sectors, with the exceptions of meat; fish<br />
and shellfish, and fruit and vegetables. There is relatively little information specifically about<br />
the meat sector in this document and most of this was provided by the Nordic states [41, Nordic<br />
Council of Ministers, 2001] and Italy [89, Italian contribution, 2001, 91, Italian contribution,<br />
2001]. The information about fish and shellfish processing came mainly from the Nordic states<br />
[28, Nordic Council of Ministers, 1997]. The main sources of information about fruit and<br />
vegetable processing were Belgium [31, VITO, et al., 2001, 32, Van Bael J., 1998] and Italy<br />
[89, Italian contribution, 2001, 91, Italian contribution, 2001].<br />
The importance of hygiene throughout the whole FDM sector is shown by the fact that<br />
information and comments about cleaning came from several MSs and from CIAA.<br />
Most of the information about air abatement techniques was provided by CIAA [34, Willey A R<br />
and Williams D A, 2001] and Germany [65, Germany, 2002], although this contained relatively<br />
little information about emission levels or about the application or applicability of the<br />
techniques in the overall FDM sector or the individual sectors.<br />
A high proportion of the information about waste water and its treatment was provided by the<br />
UK [13, Environment Agency of England and Wales, 2000] and Germany [65, Germany, 2002].<br />
Information about waste water treatment in individual sectors was provided by various MSs and<br />
industry.<br />
Information was also gathered during site visits made during the period 2001 – 2003, i.e. before<br />
the second draft was completed. The sites visited included two dairies, one in Hungary and one<br />
in Germany; four breweries, one in Hungary, one in Finland and two in Spain; a sugar refinery<br />
in Finland; a meat processing installation in Spain; two champagne installations in France, a<br />
sugar installation practising landspreading in France and several olive oil producers in Spain.<br />
Several meetings were held with CIAA on behalf of its members. Meetings were also held with<br />
German, Finnish and Spanish TWG members and with the Brewers of Europe.<br />
The formal consultations on the draft document also prompted the submission of a huge amount<br />
of information, relatively late in the process instead of, as requested, before the first draft. The<br />
consultations provided the main opportunities for the TWG to verify information already<br />
submitted.<br />
Almost half of the TWG members attended the final plenary meeting. The MSs on the FDM<br />
TWG were well represented at the final plenary meeting and were active in the discussions. The<br />
industry representatives were also active. A high proportion of the industry delegation<br />
represented the sugar sector.<br />
The information exchange and the preparation of this document has been a positive<br />
development in the prevention and control of pollution for the sectors concerned. It has<br />
provided a first-time opportunity for individual sectors to learn about techniques that have been<br />
proven to work well in others, on a Europe-wide scale. The structure of this document promotes<br />
this <strong>und</strong>erstanding, by focusing on the processes and practices that are common for all or many<br />
of the FDM sectors and describing their application and applicability. For example, some<br />
techniques reported for the canning of fish were recognised as being applicable for preservation<br />
in cans, bottles and jars and for foods other than fish. Consequently, some techniques originally<br />
reported for individual sectors, have been determined to be BAT in others.<br />
RHC/EIPPCB/FDM_BREF_FINAL January 2006 617