Unser Haushund: Eine Spitzmaus im Wolfspelz? - Wolf-Ekkehard ...

Unser Haushund: Eine Spitzmaus im Wolfspelz? - Wolf-Ekkehard ... Unser Haushund: Eine Spitzmaus im Wolfspelz? - Wolf-Ekkehard ...

13.07.2015 Aufrufe

108of aggressive and fear responses to humans”: Diese Möglichkeit ('impeccable', ortamed to the highest degree) war also von vornherein im genetisch determiniertenVerhaltenspotential angelegt (worauf ja schon die "many records of domesticatedred foxes and others" [siehe auch unten 10)] ohne "sustained domestication" sowiedie 10% der Füchse der Ausgangspopulation mit very weak aggressive responseshindeuten). Es wurden dann immer wieder diejenigen Individuen zur weiterenFortpflanzung ausgewählt, die offenbar die meisten Domestikations-Alleleaufwiesen (gezielte Selektion auf die im Genom des Fuchses bereits angelegtesehr zahme, hundeähnliche Domestikations-Rekombinante).Dawkins fährt fort (2009/2010, pp. 74/75):"After ten generations of breeding for tameness, 18 per cent were "elite”; after 20 generations, 35 per cent; and after30 to 35 generations, "domesticated elite” individuals constituted between 70 and 80 per cent of the experimentalpopulation.”Wenn die Zahl der Allele für Zahmheit (tameness) nur gering zu sein braucht undsowieso schon vorhanden und relativ einfach und damit schnell zurekombinieren ist (d. h. nicht closely linked mit 'wilden' Genen), dann braucht dieAnzahl der Generationen mit entsprechenden Populationsgrößen bei strikterSelektion 185 auch nicht allzu groß sein, bis die annähernd besten Rekombinantengefunden sind. Weiter Dawkins (p. 75):"Such results are perhaps not too surprising, except for the astonishing magnitude and speed of the effect.”"Magnitude and speed of the effect" hängen vor allem von den oben genanntengenetischen Voraussetzungen ab. Eine noch so strikte Selektion kann überhauptnichts ausrichten, wenn nicht diese Voraussetzungen dafür gegeben sind (Zebras z.B. sind – trotz unzähliger Versuche – nie zu Reittieren gezähmt worden). Mirscheint die Selektion hier von Dawkins und anderen überbewertet zu werden.Dawkins schreibt weiter:"Thirty-five generations would pass unnoticed on the geological timescale. Even more interesting, however, werethe unexpected side-effects of the selective breeding for tameness. These were truly fascinating and genuinelyunforeseen. Darwin, the dog-lover, would have been entranced.”Sehen wir uns diese unexpected side effects nach Dawkins näher an (p. 76):"The tame foxes not only behaved like domestic dogs, they looked like them. They lost their foxy pelage andbecame piebald black and white, like Welsh collies. Their foxy prick ears were replaced by doggy floppy ears. Theirtails turned up at the end like a dog's, rather than down like a fox's brush. The females came on heat every sixmonths like a bitch, instead of every year like a vixen 186 . According to Belyaev, they even sounded like dogs."Nun einige Kommentare zu den einzelnen von Dawkins und im Wikipedia-Anfangszitat genannten Punkten. The tame foxes:1) behaved like domestic dogs (more tame, allowing them to be patted etc.).In der National Geographic vom März 2011 wird zur Forschungsarbeit vonRobert Wayne unter anderem 187 folgende aufschlussreiche Entdeckung notiert 188 :185 "Selection was strict: only about 10% of females and not more than 3-5% of males were taken from the preceding generation to produce thenext" – Trut et al. 2012, p. 15.186 "It is very important that some (tame) vixens showed oestral activity both in the autums and the spring, i. e. biannual oestruation tended toform, although fertile extra-seasonal matings are extremely rare (Fig. 2.15). […] 300 females in which extra-seasonal sexual activity wasrecorded in the course of the experiment belonged to 20 unrelated families, i.e. extra-seasonal breeding arose in 20 female founders” (Trut etal. 2012, p. 24). Auch diese Tatsache zeigt, dass diese Eigenschaft, die unabhängig voneinander 20 Mal aufgetreten ist (rekurrente Variation),genetisch "prädestiniert” ist und durch strikte Selektion immer wieder unabhängig zu Tage gefördert werden kann.

109"…delving into the DNA of our closest companions can deliver some tantalizing insights. In 2009 UCLA biologistRobert Wayne led a study comparing the wolf and dog genomes. The finding that made headlines was that dogsoriginated from gray wolves not in East Asia, as other researchers had argued, but in the Middle East. Less noticedby the press was a brief aside in which Wayne and his colleagues identified a particular short DNA sequence, locatednear a gene called WBSCR17, that was very different in the two species. That region of the genome, they suggested,could be a potential target for "genes that are important in the early domestication of dogs." In humans, theresearchers went on to note, WBSCR17 is at least partly responsible for a rare genetic disorder called Williams-Beurensyndrome. Williams-Beuren is characterized by elfin features, a shortened nose bridge, and "exceptionalgregariousness"— its sufferers are often overly friendly and trusting of strangers.After the paper was published, Wayne says, "the number one email we got was from parents of children sufferingfrom Williams-Beuren. They said, Actually our children remind us of dogs in terms of their ability to read behaviorand their lack of social barriers in their behavior." The elfin traits also seemed to correspond to aspects of thedomestication phenotype. Wayne cautions against making one-to-one parallels between domestication genes andsomething as genetically complex as Williams-Beuren. The researchers are "intrigued," he says, and hoping toexplore the connection further.""Seit 1993 ist die genetische Ursache für das WBS [Williams-Beuren-Syndrom]im Detail bekannt: Auf dem siebten Chromosom fehlen mindestens 23nebeneinanderliegende Gene, was eine ganz eigentümliche Mischung vonMerkmalen zur Folge hat" (FAZ Wissen). 189"Übergroße Kontaktfreudigkeit und völlige Arglosigkeit" gehören gemäß dem inder FAZ beschriebenen Fallbeispiel zu den Merkmalen des Syndroms beimMenschen.Oder gemäß Wiki: "Ein auffälliges Merkmal ist die häufige Distanzlosigkeitgegenüber fremden Menschen: Während Regelkinder übliche Phasen desFremdelns durchleben, sind Kinder mit WBS oft durchgehend offene,kontaktfreudige und gesellige Kinder." 190Dass Verlustmutationen bei Haustieren von großem Interesse für die Züchtung seinkönnen, haben wir oben schon wiederholt unterstrichen. Ein weiteres Beispielmöchte ich hier kurz mit Shearman and Wilton aus ihren Review-Artikel von 2011erwähnen:"Loss-of-function mutations in myostatin (MSTN) is a good example of a trait transferrable between species usingcomparative genomics. It causes increased muscle mass in several species, including dogs and horses (see [42] forreview). Heterozygosity for a MSTN mutation has been found to increase racing ability in both whippets and racinghorses [43, 44]." 191187 Die im Folgenden genannte particular short DNA sequence, located near a gene called WBSCR17 ist jedoch nur einer von mehrerenKandidaten. Im Supplement lesen wir zum Thema Discussion of the best hits: "The highest ranked signal falls in a region containing anunknown gene in EntrezGene with high amino acid sequence similarity to a neurotrimin gene (NTM, OMIM: 607938) and an opioid receptor(OPCML, OMIM: 600632; Supplemental Fig. 17). The former is a cell adhesion gene involved in neurite formation and the latter binds opioidalkaloids in the presence of acidic lipids, is generally highly conserved, and is important in stress response. The next strongest signals(Supplemental Fig. 17a-c) are near ryanodine receptor 3 (RYR3, OMIM: 180903), associated with acquired memory, and adenylate cyclase 8(ADCY8, OMIM: 103070)9,10, which is implicated in sensitization to pain in mice and memory formation in humans. Our fourth and fifthstrongest signatures are near a cluster of interleukin family 1 genes (Supplemental Fig. 17d) and a region containing two genes from thecarnosinase dipeptidase family (CNDP1, OMIM 609064 and CNDP2, OMIM 169800; Supplemental Fig. 18). CNDP1 is a neurotransmitterexpressed in the brain, which degrades carnosine, a dipeptide primarily found in muscle tissue, while CNDP2 is a non-specific peptidaseexpressed predominantly in the kidney and liver. Examining FST alone, we found 12 consecutive SNPs in the top 5th percentile for normalizedFST values located at the SLC24A4 gene, a gene whose polymorphisms in humans are associated with hair and eye color11. We observe asingle SNP with a high FST value in the WBSCR17 gene. The deletion of this gene and neighboring genes gives rise to Williams-Beurensyndrome in humans (OMIM: 194050; Supplemental Fig. 16). While outliers of the genome are not necessarily the result of adaptive evolution,we propose the gene regions mentioned above are interesting candidates for loci involved in the phenotypic evolution of dogs from their wolfancestors.” https://www.eeb.ucla.edu/Faculty/Novembre/vonHoldtEtAl2010Nature-s1.pdf (Siehe auch Zitat auf der nächsten Seite.)188 http://ngm.nationalgeographic.com/print/2011/03/taming-wild-animals/ratliff-text189http://www.faz.net/aktuell/wissen/mensch-gene/williams-beuren-syndrom-so-viel-freundlichkeit-ist-nicht-normal-1257656.html (FrankfurterAllgemeine Sonntagszeitung vom 17. 7. 2005, Nr. 28, p. 29.)190 http://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Williams-Beuren-Syndrom191 J. R. Shearman and A. N. Wilton (2011): Origins of the Domestic Dog and the Rich Potential for Gene Mapping. Genetical ResearchInternational: http://www.hindawi.com/journals/gri/2011/579308/

109"…delving into the DNA of our closest companions can deliver some tantalizing insights. In 2009 UCLA biologistRobert Wayne led a study comparing the wolf and dog genomes. The finding that made headlines was that dogsoriginated from gray wolves not in East Asia, as other researchers had argued, but in the Middle East. Less noticedby the press was a brief aside in which Wayne and his colleagues identified a particular short DNA sequence, locatednear a gene called WBSCR17, that was very different in the two species. That region of the genome, they suggested,could be a potential target for "genes that are <strong>im</strong>portant in the early domestication of dogs." In humans, theresearchers went on to note, WBSCR17 is at least partly responsible for a rare genetic disorder called Williams-Beurensyndrome. Williams-Beuren is characterized by elfin features, a shortened nose bridge, and "exceptionalgregariousness"— its sufferers are often overly friendly and trusting of strangers.After the paper was published, Wayne says, "the number one email we got was from parents of children sufferingfrom Williams-Beuren. They said, Actually our children remind us of dogs in terms of their ability to read behaviorand their lack of social barriers in their behavior." The elfin traits also seemed to correspond to aspects of thedomestication phenotype. Wayne cautions against making one-to-one parallels between domestication genes andsomething as genetically complex as Williams-Beuren. The researchers are "intrigued," he says, and hoping toexplore the connection further.""Seit 1993 ist die genetische Ursache für das WBS [Williams-Beuren-Syndrom]<strong>im</strong> Detail bekannt: Auf dem siebten Chromosom fehlen mindestens 23nebeneinanderliegende Gene, was eine ganz eigentümliche Mischung vonMerkmalen zur Folge hat" (FAZ Wissen). 189"Übergroße Kontaktfreudigkeit und völlige Arglosigkeit" gehören gemäß dem inder FAZ beschriebenen Fallbeispiel zu den Merkmalen des Syndroms be<strong>im</strong>Menschen.Oder gemäß Wiki: "Ein auffälliges Merkmal ist die häufige Distanzlosigkeitgegenüber fremden Menschen: Während Regelkinder übliche Phasen desFremdelns durchleben, sind Kinder mit WBS oft durchgehend offene,kontaktfreudige und gesellige Kinder." 190Dass Verlustmutationen bei Haustieren von großem Interesse für die Züchtung seinkönnen, haben wir oben schon wiederholt unterstrichen. Ein weiteres Beispielmöchte ich hier kurz mit Shearman and Wilton aus ihren Review-Artikel von 2011erwähnen:"Loss-of-function mutations in myostatin (MSTN) is a good example of a trait transferrable between species usingcomparative genomics. It causes increased muscle mass in several species, including dogs and horses (see [42] forreview). Heterozygosity for a MSTN mutation has been found to increase racing ability in both whippets and racinghorses [43, 44]." 191187 Die <strong>im</strong> Folgenden genannte particular short DNA sequence, located near a gene called WBSCR17 ist jedoch nur einer von mehrerenKandidaten. Im Supplement lesen wir zum Thema Discussion of the best hits: "The highest ranked signal falls in a region containing anunknown gene in EntrezGene with high amino acid sequence s<strong>im</strong>ilarity to a neurotr<strong>im</strong>in gene (NTM, OMIM: 607938) and an opioid receptor(OPCML, OMIM: 600632; Supplemental Fig. 17). The former is a cell adhesion gene involved in neurite formation and the latter binds opioidalkaloids in the presence of acidic lipids, is generally highly conserved, and is <strong>im</strong>portant in stress response. The next strongest signals(Supplemental Fig. 17a-c) are near ryanodine receptor 3 (RYR3, OMIM: 180903), associated with acquired memory, and adenylate cyclase 8(ADCY8, OMIM: 103070)9,10, which is <strong>im</strong>plicated in sensitization to pain in mice and memory formation in humans. Our fourth and fifthstrongest signatures are near a cluster of interleukin family 1 genes (Supplemental Fig. 17d) and a region containing two genes from thecarnosinase dipeptidase family (CNDP1, OMIM 609064 and CNDP2, OMIM 169800; Supplemental Fig. 18). CNDP1 is a neurotransmitterexpressed in the brain, which degrades carnosine, a dipeptide pr<strong>im</strong>arily found in muscle tissue, while CNDP2 is a non-specific peptidaseexpressed predominantly in the kidney and liver. Examining FST alone, we found 12 consecutive SNPs in the top 5th percentile for normalizedFST values located at the SLC24A4 gene, a gene whose polymorphisms in humans are associated with hair and eye color11. We observe asingle SNP with a high FST value in the WBSCR17 gene. The deletion of this gene and neighboring genes gives rise to Williams-Beurensyndrome in humans (OMIM: 194050; Supplemental Fig. 16). While outliers of the genome are not necessarily the result of adaptive evolution,we propose the gene regions mentioned above are interesting candidates for loci involved in the phenotypic evolution of dogs from their wolfancestors.” https://www.eeb.ucla.edu/Faculty/Novembre/vonHoldtEtAl2010Nature-s1.pdf (Siehe auch Zitat auf der nächsten Seite.)188 http://ngm.nationalgeographic.com/print/2011/03/taming-wild-an<strong>im</strong>als/ratliff-text189http://www.faz.net/aktuell/wissen/mensch-gene/williams-beuren-syndrom-so-viel-freundlichkeit-ist-nicht-normal-1257656.html (FrankfurterAllgemeine Sonntagszeitung vom 17. 7. 2005, Nr. 28, p. 29.)190 http://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Williams-Beuren-Syndrom191 J. R. Shearman and A. N. Wilton (2011): Origins of the Domestic Dog and the Rich Potential for Gene Mapping. Genetical ResearchInternational: http://www.hindawi.com/journals/gri/2011/579308/

Hurra! Ihre Datei wurde hochgeladen und ist bereit für die Veröffentlichung.

Erfolgreich gespeichert!

Leider ist etwas schief gelaufen!