FINITE ELEMENT CENTE - FEniCS Project

¢¡¤£ ¡¦¥ § § ¨©§ § £ ¥ § £ ¥ §
PREPRINT 2002-10
Least-Squares Finite Element Methods with Applications
in Electromagnetics
Rickard Bergström
Chalmers Finite Element Center
CHALMERS UNIVERSITY OF TECHNOLOGY
Göteborg Sweden 2002

¡ ¢ £¥¤ ¦¨§© ¦ ¦¨£¥¦¨¤ ¦¨ ¦¨ ¦¨§
Preprint 2002-10
Least-Squares Finite Element Methods with
Applications in Electromagnetics
Rickard Bergström
Chalmers Finite Element Center
Chalmers University of Technology
SE–412 96 Göteborg Sweden
Göteborg, December 2002

Least-Squares Finite Element Methods with Applications in Electromagnetics
Rickard Bergström
NO 2002-10
ISSN 1404–4382
Chalmers Finite Element Center
Chalmers University of Technology
SE–412 96 Göteborg
Sweden
Telephone: +46 (0)31 772 1000
Fax: +46 (0)31 772 3595
¡ ¡ £¢¥¤¡¦¨§©¢¦¢
Printed in Sweden
Chalmers University of Technology
Göteborg, Sweden 2002

¢¡¤£¦¥¨§©¥
!"#$ %%'&(¦ *)+),-"#!&*/.02143 5276'*8&9:;9;¦"#)=A@¤B4.
(7

§¡ ¡ ¡ § ! ¡"§$#&%(')¥ * §$#
¢¡¤£¦¥¨§¨©£¦¡¤¥
,, -/.0£§$1% )¥ 1¡2.3§4%5 £76 8¡"§$/.9¥
+
][^ª€žB‰s{sw„€o £3‰Nœp|z{swžDp| hq}€phŠLª—}Pz{sut¢‰z{Š€p|zfsw£/swt{ph…ishª
¼
sut˜m@€qo„ tl£†•¯‰oqo„‰N¡fsƒŠ€qz{p| |t‚o £½•¯zw‰…¾¡Zphoqo¿žD‰swphŠ€k-phs{s¨‰@•«t‚ˆ€p h‰@k1t{„k1y€‰y-s¢ž-z{‰€oqph…0ª
¼
p|s{s{p|kt‚¤m–o¿D‰y-k€ŠPm@zu£< h‰k-Š€qt{„‰k€s§…†mr£3Bp„…ižD‰swphŠ

Y
¦§¤©¨ _

I* *‚#&" "21-"£"2 a# ' 3©,$"¢'
L
@ Z R‰: l
Z£¤£¤£
Z ƒ Z BpnŠ€ph |‰…†žB‰swqt‚q‰k€sŸ‰@•“t‚ˆ-p†swy€DŠ-‰…½m–„k€s 8 @ „kt‚‰-ª«p–¥Ä¬-¥qª[t‚p‡t‚z‚m–ˆ€phŠ€z{m@o>ª[p|o„p‡v
…iphkt‚s¦¥¦ªÈm@k-Š2o„p‡t§¡ :©¨ >@BADC¡ @ Š-phk€‰@t{pt{ˆ€p$zwphs{y-oqt‚qk€¬iŠ€ph |‰…†žB‰swqt‚q‰k0‰@•T8¥¢Œ¿p|t­Š-phk€‰@t{p$t‚ˆ-p
Œ¿p|t¢¡
…iphs{ˆ3•¯y-k€ |t{„‰k@ADC|µ…\ ‹^8 @ ” ·G ªP tfˆ€‰o„Š-s
”
Od > ^ 9 r+C0h_ji
‘
Cedd@gf r+C0h_ µ]y€„ƒD·9_ 9
p|z{p¤¡Zp7ˆPmrœ@p qkt‚z{‰/Š€y€ |phŠm¦¡šp|„¬ˆtQ_8„k5t‚ˆ€p2œ@‰o„y-…†p¤qk1t{ph¬z{m@ö t{phz{…is9 h‰kt‚m@„k€qk€¬¦t‚ˆ-p¤ hy€zwo
u
|phŠUBp|tl¡ZphphkUt{ˆ€p3 hy-z{oƒm–k€Š®t‚ˆ-p3Š€qœ@phzw¬phk€ |p< h‰k-Š€qt{„‰k€s|¥­¦§ˆ€p½žPm@z‚m–…†p‡t‚phz i
t‚ˆ1y€s$Dp‡t{t‚p|zÅPm@o„m@k€
_
…iphkt‚sf„k3t{ˆ€p…†p|s{ˆLª—m–k€Š9o„p|t
H: …†mF¢[‹¥”šŠ€phk€‰–t‚pŸt‚ˆ€p¬oq‰Pm@oD…†p|s{ˆ0s{q›hp@¥¢‰kvÑ…½m–t{ ˜ˆ€„k-¬
…iphs{ˆ-phsŸm@zwpIm@oqo„‰N¡šp|ŠLªB€y-t¡ZpIm@sws{y€…ipÅo„‰/ rm–o«x1yPm–s{ vÑy€k€ •¯‰z{…iqtl£9m–k€Šm½…i„k€q…½m@oLm@k€¬oqp |‰k€Š€ t‚„‰@k
‰k¥“Œ¿p|t
Wx: >
Z
‹ º ¥ÄÏ”
@BADC W @
@ Š€p|}€k€phŠ"1£ ¡fqt{ÎW
W @
:! 4{´µ" g ‹8 @
” ·G »# $` {%$ f ‹¥” Z •¯‰zfm–o„o&¥ {'¡ @)( Z
¡fˆ€p|z{p*$ f qs§t‚ˆ€p4s{p‡ẗ ‰@•Ym@o„oDœph ‡t‚‰z¨žD‰@oq£/k€‰…i¤m@oqsš‰@•~Š€ph¬@z{php4o„p|s{sft‚ˆPm–k"‰zfp|x/y€m@o«t{‰,+/¥“¦§ˆ/y-sxW$qs
t‚ˆ-p¨swp|tƒ‰–•¿m@oqoPž€„p| hp|¡fqs{p¢œph ‡t‚‰zZžD‰@oq£/k€‰…i¤m@o/•¯y€k€ ‡t‚„‰@k€sZ‰–•LŠ€p|¬z{p|p¦+¡fˆ€q ˜ˆ

!£#"$§©&%(')§©*§¦©+¢©%
¢¡¤£¦¥¨§©§¦©¢©§©
§©
hp!_3„s k€‰@t Š€p|}€k€phŠn‰k$t{ˆ€pšqkt‚phzu• m@ hp–¥ Æ7pš¡f„oqoz{p‡t‚y€zwkÅt‚‰¨t{ˆ€pƒpЀm– |tbŠ€p‡}Pk€ t‚„‰@k$‰@•€t{ˆ€„s~mrœphz{m@¬p–¥
s{qk€
m– hphs|ªPt‚ˆ€p-, _ ‹P«”lvÑk€‰zw…¢s{ hm@o„p|Š"£% r+C0h_ ˆPm–s¨Bphp|k­y€swphŠ
’"‰zwph‰Nœp|zhªB‰k9t‚ˆ€pB‰y€k€ŠPm–zw£0m@k€Š0„kt{phzw•
h‰…iž€y-t‚m–t‚q‰kPm@oqoq£4 hy€…$Dp|z{s{‰@…†p‰\ C0h_ ‹^P ”Ñvlk€‰@z{…0ªs{p|p¨²š‰/ ˜ˆ€p‡œim@k€Š

i y {¥Wª€¡fˆ€p|z{p •¯‰zfm@oqo
Z i yÅ”(: > ]@BADC ‹[|}pˆy Z |}p i yI” b c ‘‹|.€ y Z |.€ i yI” b c ‹ º ¥¡ ”
=B‹y
¥&`°`bai` ¤ _Yg• ¨_¤
¤
3©5 *-%(5 *‡"¢5+5+%(5 "2'd#+*7£# "¢' L9
Od > ^ ‹[ r+Ci Cedd@f
r+C µ]y€„ƒD·Z µi y†€•ƒB· ”k cla ‘‹[
ykp¥ƒB· ”k cl
hqk€¬It‚ˆ€pphk-phz{¬–£

§Œ¿p|t§¦m: —¥bÆ®ps{ˆ-‰ —œ¢¡£¡¥¤ ¡t‚ˆPmFt “›n&
r
¦ _ 9 9_ ‘` ¦¢`_CLK ‹ Ë ¥Ë ” £ ] " < ¦¢``…`_ ``…`
|}p¨¦ < ` Z ‹ Ë ¥ÄÏ”
¦¢`_CLK 9
m@k€Š
9_ "
|.€©¦ ` ¦¢`_CLK ‹ Ë ¥@” £ " < 9_ 9
¡Zp4¬@p|t
P‰zƒt‚ˆ-p4B‰y€k-ŠPm@zw£½t‚phzw…
r+C0h_ ¦ €„ƒ 9_ k : ] 9
k
A
9 r+C0h_ ¦ €„ƒ 9_ £
‹ Ë ¥cb”
k
£ k
¦ 9 9_ ‘` ¦¢`_CLK Z
£ k
9 9_ < " 9 9‹0 r+C
hp3qk€phx1yPm@oqqtl£ ¡fˆ€p|z{p3¡Zp3y€s{p|Š¦t‚ˆ€p†t‚z‚m–
m– hpa–wy€…iž9t{phzw…†sƒ¡Zpy-s{pŸt‚ˆ€pŸt{z{¤m–k€¬o„p¨„k€p|x/y€m@o„ tl£
„kt{phzw•
r+C0h_ µ¦ €•ƒD·9_ k cl < 9 r+C0h_ ¦
@ €„ƒ 9_ 9
r+C0h_ i _ µ]_ r+C
¦ 9
9 9 ‘ ` $`CLKš”‡¥­~„kPm–o„oq£@ª«•¯‰@zt‚ˆ-p
&('7/9 +&( 49+* 4 6¨!

§Œ¿p|t¡ ©: y “Vy§$Š€p|k€‰@t‚pŸt{ˆ€pphz{zw‰zh¥°¦§ˆ€p|k
—œ¢¡£¡¥¤
&`…`…`_ : =B‹£ Z y†“Vy¦F” ‹ Ë ¥ l
j ”
``…`¢
&``…`Q< ``…`My“›n¢yQ``…` `…``
-@ r+C `yN`@
Z ‹ Ë ¥ lOl ”
"
C
r+C0h_ µ…y§v€„ƒB·9
3
! / 0*+&(2 / 0- 2!" F : l &( !90--¡ 3 P : !"54 F : º &( 3 <
F @
: =B‹£ Z y†“›n¢y ‘ n$y†“ly¦F”
: =B‹£ Z y†“›n¢yÅ” Z
¡fˆ€p|z{p9¡šp9y€swp9t{ˆ€p"³4m–o„phzwÀ1„kU‰zut‚ˆ€‰¬@‰kPm@oqqtl£ =B‹£ Z i
y {†Wª°„kUt‚ˆ-p0o„m@swtÅphx1yPm@oqqtl£¥
¦¨sw„k€¬It{ˆ€p-2ƒm@y€ ˜ˆ£vuŽ ˜ˆ¡šm@z{›Åqk€phx1yPm–o„qtl£3m@k€Š0Š€qœ/qŠ€„k€¬$1£V`…`…`¢ &`…``¡Zp$m–z{z{ œpm–t
yI”‡: j ª°•¯‰z i
¡fˆ€p|z{p¡špy€swphŠ2Œ¿p|…†…†m Ë ¥ l qk3t‚ˆ€po¤m–swtf„k-phx1yPm@oqqtl£¥
3 %!'d# "¢5 *-%!5 *‡"25+5+%(5 "¢')# *£#&"2' L9L
s{q…†ž€oqpÅ rm–o„ hy-o¤m–t{„‰k¤¬ œp|st{ˆPm–tŸt{ˆ€p†p|k€phzw¬@£¤k€‰@z{… ‰@•Zt‚ˆ€pnp|z{z{‰@z¡fˆ-phk®y-s{„k-¬"m9€qo„„k-prm@z¢•¯‰z{…
Î
oqprm@sutwvlswx1yPm@z{p|sIž€z{qk€ hqž€o„p|s$sw„…iž€oq£p|x/y€m@o„sÅt{ˆ€p3z{p|s{qŠ€yPm@o¸¥¤¦§ˆ/y-sn¡Zp< rm–kUswt˜mFt‚p3t‚ˆ-p
Š€p|z{qœ@phŠU•¯z{‰@…
•¯‰oqo„‰N¡f„k€¬ÅmnžB‰sut‚phzw„‰zwLphzwz{‰z§p|swt{„…†m–t‚pŸqk9t{ˆ€pphk€p|z{¬@£9k-‰z{…0¥
˜¡ œ ˜) ë ¨ y { W 8! &('7/9 +&( #& !

˜ˆ€ t‚›ŸŠ€‰@…½m@qk3¡fqt{ˆ0 |‰z{k-phz{s|¥
rm–s{pŸ•¯‰z¢mI¬phk€p|z‚m@o[Œ¿qž€s{
Ÿ$ ^¡ ¥I˜§¦©¨+¡¨ ¡ ¤ ˜¢š2œ¢¡^˜)
ë
}Pk€Š®‹
Z
”a{ˆ\ ‹|qp Z 8f”9pˆ\ C
£
º
¤
º
¤
: j Z Np¥ƒz: j ‰@kNP Z ‹ Ë ¥ l – r”
„sZm@kPm@o £/s{phŠ½„k 2šˆ-phkLª 3yLª-m–k€Š%$ȉy2µ F·>ª1¡fˆ€phzwpqt“qsZswˆ€‰N¡fk3t‚ˆPm–t“t‚ˆ-phz{p¨p‡Â„sut‚sšmy€k€qx1y€p
ž€zw‰€o„p|…
;
j •¯‰zfm@o„o&8¡fqt{ˆN|.€ : j ¥
s{‰@o„y-t{„‰kL¥Y—y-zwt‚ˆ-phz{…i‰zwp@ª
: j m@k-Š3t‚ˆ1y€s
: j ª€m–k€Š%! swy€ ˜ˆ0t{ˆPm–t§ tƒs{m–t‚qsw}Pp|sƒt‚ˆ€pm@y/Â-qo„„m@zw£I¡Zprm@À†ž€z{‰@€o„p|…"»
…†m@À1„k€¬m|€7
}Pk€Š8!
C ‹8f”ƒs{y€ ˜ˆ0t‚ˆPmFt {ˆ\
Z | ”: > ]@BADC ‹[| €1‹”_ r+C y 2
‹|9! ” Z ” b c“ ]
Cedd@f Od >
r+C y 2 €•ƒB·Z ”k cl Z ‹{µM_
|p@ªBs{p|p 2š‰sut˜m@Bpho[m–k€Š 3Ÿm–y€¬piµ lOl ·¸¥
h‰@k1œ@phzw¬phk€
hm–t‚q‰k€shª~‰k€p3¡šm@kt‚snt‚‰¤…iprm@swy€z{p

£
Cedd@f Od >
Cedd@f Od >
Od > Cedd@f
Z µMƒ € 2 ·¤”k ‘‹|.€
> :
£
€„ƒD·¤”k
^ ‹”_¢|;p
Z µM_ r+C g p‰ƒD·¤”k cl ‘0‹^_ r+C $Z µ 2 €ƒB· ”k cl ‘0‹[|€
Z µ 2 €ƒB· ”k cla
Cedd@f Od > ^ ‹^_¢| p
Z µ]_ r+C ¢pvƒD·¤”k cl ‘‹[|;p
Z µ +€ƒD·¤”k cla ‘‹[|;p
Z µ 2 €ƒB· ”k
Cedd@f Od >
‹0 C0h_ji ^ C0h_ |.€ ?‘ r+C0h_ µ ‹H“›n È”€„ƒD·Z r+C0h_ µ ‰€„ƒB· ”k cla
‘‹[
C0h_ |.€ ?‘ r+C0h_ µq‹ H“lnÈ”2€„ƒD·Z r+C0h_ µ ‰€„ƒD·¤”k £
l
‘‹0
j
•¯‰z$m@o„o {=\ C ‹^8f”‡¥¦§ˆ€„s$ž€z{‰-o„ph… qs¡Zpho„oZžD‰@s{phŠ´m@k-Š¦¡šp
€„ƒD·¤”k cl
Æ®pŸt{ˆ/y-s¨¬p‡t
Cedd@f Od >
f : >
¡f‚f
]@BADC ‹^_ r+C y g Z y g ” b)c “ ‹^_ r+C y g Z y g
^
” bdca ‹ Ë ¥º j ”
” bdc “ ‹”_ r+C y 2 Z y 2
‘ ]
‹[|.€
Z µ…y 2
€„ƒB· ”k cl ‘‹|.€
Z µ]y 2
: >
]@BADC?^ ‹[| pz_$|}p¢ Z _ r+C g ” b c “ ‹[| eZ _ r+C g ” b c ‘‹|.€
Z | € 2 ” b ca
‘ ]
‹[|.€
Z µ 2 €„ƒB· ”k cl ‘‹[|.€
Z µ 2 €„ƒB· ”k
> ]@BADC*^ ‹[|}p Z |}p g ” bdc ‘‹[|.€
Z | € 2 ” bdc ‘‹”_ r+C$Z |.€ g ” bdca
:
‘ ]
]@BADC*^ ‹[|}p Z |}p ”7bdc&‘‹[| €
Z |.€ ”7bdca
‘ ]
]@BADC*^ ‹[|}pU‹ H“lnÈ” Z | p ” bdc ‘‹[|.€/‹ 4“lnD” Z |.€ ” bdca
: >
‘ ]
r+C0h_ µ]_ r+C ‹!“—nÈ”&p‰ƒD·Z i _& r+C0h_ µM_ r+C ¢pvƒB· ”k cl
‘
_ r+C_¢|;p

¡fqk€¬Åp|swt‚q…½mFt‚p¨•¯‰zƒt{ˆ€pphzwz{‰zf„k

yPm–Š€z‚m–t{„ ¢p‡•¯phz{p|k€ hp
Œ[qk€prm–z
j 0 l
j º Ï 0 joj v
¨‰i‰@•~p|o„p|…†p|k1t{s
k€‰/Š€phs l l
j ËË Ëb v
¨‰n‰@•
p l
j rts ‹j
£j lNË ”
£jl p l
j rts ‹j
£j j
l ” £j ?p l
j rts
@f
¢¡ b0 ‹>¹”
¢£¥¤3‹>¹” Ë £Ë@ËË p l
j r§¦
‹j
£j 0” Ë l
£ p l
j r§¦
‹j
£j j ” Ë l
£b Ïmp l
j r§¦
£
¡4‹>¹” Ï £# p l
j r+Cg ‹j
£j Ë@Ë ” Ï ©¨
j º p l
j r+Cg ‹j
£j
l ” Ï
£0 Ë^l p l
j r+Cg
¦ m@€o„p l »0¦§ˆ€p­ |‰…iž€y-t‚p|Š …†m@¬k€p‡t‚q 0p|k€phzw¬„p|si•¯‰@z†Êbzw‰€o„p|… l ªšy-s{„k-¬¦Œ«Ž-Y‘“’ m–k€Š ž€qph |p|¡f„swp
£
L q5+%!61-"
%
^¡ ¥I˜/( œ ¡¨ ¡ ¤ ˜ 2œ¢¡^˜)
Ÿ$
¤
l º
o„qk€prm–znm@k€Š x1yPm–Š€z‚m–t{„ 0žD‰@oq£/k€‰…i¤m@oZphoqph…iphkt‚s|ª§ h‰…ižPm@zwphŠ ¡fqt‚ˆ z{p‡•¯phz{p|k€ hp"œ@m–o„y€p|s§t‚ˆ€p"z{p|o¤m–t{qœp
phzwz{‰zš„sƒ¬ œp|k

10 0 Air
10 −1 Error indicator
§ © ') § © ¢)%
£
)© '§©
&¢
!£ §! $¢&%
Fe
Cu
Total
Least−squares functional
10 −1
10 −2
10 −2
10 −3
10 −3
10 −4
10 −4
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
x 10 5
10 −5
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
x 10 5
£¢ ¥¤¦¢§¢ § ©¨¢ ©¢ ¢-© ¢
¢¡¤£¡
£¢¢©!&
Ë » 2š‰…iž€y-t‚m–t‚q‰k€s[•¯‰zYÊbz{‰@€o„p|… l ¡fqt{ˆÅx1yPm@Š€z{m–t‚q ‹¯s{‰oq„Š$oq„k€p|s˜”[m@k€ŠÅoq„k€phm@zZ‹ ŠPm–s{ˆ€p|ŠIo„„k-phs˜”
~q¬y€z{p
‡t‚q‰k€sh¥ Pm@sw„s§•¯y€k€
1.00
1.00
Iron
Air
0.20
0.05
Air
0.20
0.30
0.05
0.10
Copper
1.00
0.30
0.20 2.00
1.00
0.30
0.20
2.00
Iron
Copper
0.20
0.01
¡£ §! ¢ #"
~q¬y€z{pbÏ-»«³p|‰…†p‡t‚zu£‰@•/t‚ˆ€p°tl¡Z‰¨mFÂqsw£/…†…ip|t{z{q Yž€z{‰@€o„p|…†s|¥ ¦§ˆ€p°Š€q…†p|k€s{q‰k€s[m@zwp°¬qœ@phk4„k…†p‡t‚p|z{sh¥
lNË

l Ï
}Pp|o„Š9o„qk€phs§qk"mIswo„„ |pt‚ˆ€zw‰y€¬ˆ9t‚ˆ-pt{ˆ€z{p|pŠ€„…iphk€sw„‰k€m@oÈsw‰o„y-t{„‰k

phoqph…iphkt‚s lNºb0jº l ##bË v
¨‰i‰@•
º Ë 0 ºb ¢‰n‰@•~k-‰Š€p|s
@f
©¡ l ‹>¹” ?p l
j rts ‹j
£º j j ” 0
£ 0 Ë p l
j rts ‹j
l
£ºb ” l£j º p l
j r¡
¢£ ¤

lb
§ © ') § © ¢)%
£
)© '§©
&¢
1
0.9
0.8
Air
Fe
Cu
Total
10 0 Error indicator
Least−squares functional
0.7
0.6
10 −1
0.5
0.4
0.3
10 −2
0.2
0.1
0
0 1 2 3 4 5 6
x 10 5
10 −3
0 1 2 3 4 5 6
x 10 5
£¢ ¥¤¦¢§¢ § ©¨¢ ©¢ ¢-© ¢
¢¡¤£¡
£¢¢©!&
2š‰…iž€y-t‚m–t‚q‰k€s[•¯‰zYÊbz{‰@€o„p|… º ¡fqt{ˆÅx1yPm@Š€z{m–t‚q ‹¯s{‰oq„Š$oq„k€p|s˜”[m@k€ŠÅoq„k€phm@zZ‹ ŠPm–s{ˆ€p|ŠIo„„k-phs˜”
~q¬y€z{p¦0»
‡t‚q‰k€sh¥ Pm@sw„s§•¯y€k€
}Pp|o„Š9o„qk€phs§qk"mIswo„„ |pt‚ˆ€zw‰y€¬ˆ9t‚ˆ-pt{ˆ€z{p|pŠ€„…iphk€sw„‰k€m@oÈsw‰o„y-t{„‰k

¨‰n•¯y€zwt{ˆ€phzfz{p|swt{z{„ ‡t‚q‰k€sfm@ž€ž-oq£3‰@k9t{ˆ€pphoqph |t{z{q }PphoqŠL¥
t‚ˆ-pm–„zh¥
0 l
: “!U£¢!y „kQ8 @LZ ‹>¥ l m”
|}p¡
~ „kQ8 @LZ ‹>/¥ l P”
|}pˆ\:
p¥ƒB·D: j ‰kQP @O Z ‹>¥Ë m”
µ¥
p¥ƒB·D: j ‰kQP @O Z ‹>/¥Ë P”
µ]\
-» 3p‡t˜m@qo ‰–•“t{ˆ€pÅ…iphswˆ7mF• t‚phzm@ŠPm@ž-t{qœ@pÅz{p‡}Pk€ph…iphkth¥$¦§ˆ€pIžPm–zwtŸswˆ€‰N¡fk7qsŸm½t‚‰ž2œ/qp|¡‰@•
~q¬y€z{p
t{ˆ€p„zw‰k9 h‰zwp4‰–•YÊbz{‰@€o„p|… º ¥
t‚ˆ-p4qkt‚phzw„‰zš‰@•
MON©"†"R§S©# *-%a ©'
¥L
hpt‚ˆ€p hy-z{z{p|kt­qs"sw„k1y€s{‰@„ŠPm@om–k€Š t{ˆ€p•¯z{phx1y€p|k€ |£„s9oq‰ ¡ª¨¡šp7y€s{p t‚ˆ€p x1yPm@s{qswt‚m–t‚q t{„…ip‡v
Žqk€
p|x1yPm–t‚q‰k€s ˆPm@zw…†‰@k€„
| €•y.: j „kQ8 @LZ ‹>¥ l r”
¡fˆ€p|z{p
y : _$\ Z
‹>¥º m”
~N: ~ £h‘ ¤
£
‹>/¥º P”
l —”Y„…iž€oq„phs t‚ˆPm–ta|X€ ~z: j ¥Y¦§ˆ-p¨qk1t{phzu• m@ hpf h‰@k€Š€qt{„‰k-s°•¯‰@zYt‚ˆ€qs“ž-z{‰€oqph…
¨‰–t‚p§t‚ˆPmFtZp|x1yPm–t‚q‰k­‹>¥
h‰…iphs t‚ˆ-phk0Dp|
µ~I€„ƒB·D: j ‰kQP @O Z ‹>¥Ë r”
µ]y†€„ƒB·D: j ‰kQP @O Z
‹>/¥Ë ŠP”
m– hp†m@k€Š5µ€Ä·°Š-phk€‰@t{phs4t‚ˆ€p©–wy€…iž¦m@ |z{‰sws4t{ˆ€p†swy€zw• m– hp3m–s
¡fˆ€p|z{pHƒ´„s4m0y€k€qt4k€‰@z{…†m@o~t‚‰0t‚ˆ€pi„kt{phzw•
|pm_ f : l qkt{ˆ€pn¡fˆ€‰o„pIzwph¬q‰kLª¿t‚ˆ-pi…†m@¬k-p|t‚q Å}PphoqŠ7qsŸ h‰kt{„k1y€‰y€s4‰Nœp|zswy€zw• m@ |phs|¥
Bp|•¯‰zwp@¥½Ž„k€
|‰…†žB‰k€p|ktš‰@•¿t{ˆ€p¨p|o„p| |t‚zw„ f}PphoqŠLª¦ ¨§ ª1¡fˆ€„oqpÅ‹¸¥Ë N”b„…iž€o„qphs
¦§ˆ€ps{m@…ip¨qs“t{z{y€p¢•¯‰zZt{ˆ€p¨t‚m@k€¬p|k1t{¤m@o—
t‚ˆ€m–t©
€oƒV: j ªL¡fˆ-phz{p Š€phk€‰–t‚phst‚ˆ-pÅ}PphoqŠ qk€s{qŠ€p$t{ˆ€pim@o„y€…i„k-„y€…Áž€o„m–t‚p–ªLs{qk€ hp ~V: j qk

h‰k-Š€qt{„‰k€sƒm@ž€ž€oq„phŠ0m@zwp
¦§ˆ€p4D‰y-k€ŠPm@zu£<
j ‰kQP Z p¥ƒN:
y†€„ƒN: j ‰kQP £
MON©" 17"¢'d# P 'jR§S©5+"¢'=Y %(5 S1-#+*-%!
‘Yœp|kit{ˆ€‰y€¬Ît{ˆ€pƒ…†m@¬k€p‡t‚„ Z}PphoqŠI„sY |‰kt‚„k1y€‰@y€sb„kÅt{ˆ€pš¡fˆ€‰oqp§z{p|¬„‰kȪ@¡šp§sut‚qo„o/ˆPmrœp§t‚‰Ÿqk1t{z{‰/Š€y€ |p
¥)L
h‰@k1t{„k1y€‰y-s¨phoqph…iphkt‚s¨m@o„‰@k€¬it{ˆ€p$swy€zw• m– hphs|ªÈŠ€y-p$t‚‰it‚ˆ€p9–wy€…†ž"„k9t‚ˆ€pk€‰zw…½m@o[ |‰…†žB‰k€p|kt
t‚ˆ-p$Š€qs{
: ‹ Z \2”‡»~}Pk-Š¥¤8swy€ ˜ˆ"t{ˆPm–t
¤
b ‹¦¤
Z
= i
b ‹¦¤
Z
= ¤Ÿ”T: G i
9 |}p¥\ “ ¤ “;~ £9_b)c ‘ 9 |.€/‹”_$\¤”9_b)ca
‘
Od G ^ 9 r+C0h_ µ
Cedd@f
Cedd@f Od G ^ 9 r+C0h_ µ]\ pzƒD·9_
l
‹>¥±Ïm”
‹>/¥ÄÏP”
hp|…†p|ktŸ‰@•°t‚ˆ€p$‰y-t‚p|zŸD‰@y€k€ŠPm@zu£­qsk€‰@ts{žBph h }PphŠqk2Š€phsw hzw„ž-t{„‰k¤‰@•°t{ˆ€pÅt‚p|swtŸ hm@s{p–¥Æ7p
¦§ˆ€pIž€o„m@
|o„‰swphŠ½t{ˆ€p¨ |‰„oBm@k€Š†t‚ˆ€p¨m@o„y€…i„k-„y€…ž€o¤mFt‚p¢„k3m4 hy€Bp¨‰–•[m@ž€ž€zw‰rÂ-q…½mFt‚pho £It‚ˆ€zwphp¢t‚„…iphs°t‚ˆ-p
ˆPmrœp¨phk€
s{q›hp‰@•~mIs{„Š-p4qk¥ 0@m”
‘‹[|}pˆ\}“ ¤
Z |}p i
\}“ i$”7bdc
Z | €/‹^_ i \­”{”-b)c Z ‘‹[|.€/‹”_$\¤”
i ¤”T: G
>w‹
‹-~ £
Z |}p i \}“ i$” bdc£ ‹>/¥10–P”
]@BADC

m@ |pt‚phzw…†s|ª
m@k€Š9•¯‰zƒt{ˆ€p„kt‚p|zw•
C ‹§¤
Z
= ¤”T: ] i
=_‹§¤
Z i
=
G
‹§¤
Z i
Cedd@f Od G
Z €„ƒ¿”k¡¢
r+C pzƒD·Z µi£pzƒD·¤”k cl ‹>¥m”
‹[ µ
€„ƒ Z
i r+C ‘‹0
Od G ^ ‹[ r+C µ]\ p¥ƒD·Z µ i \ pzƒB· ”k cl ‹>/¥c@P”
Cedd@f
r+C µ]_e\ €§ƒD·Z µ]_ i \ €„ƒB· ”k cla Z ‘‹0
‹0 r+C
µ¥ p¥ƒB·Z µi p¥ƒD·¤”k ‹>¥@ r”
¤”T: r+C µ]_e\}€„ƒD·Z µ]_ i \ €„ƒB· ”k £ ‘‹0
¤”T: ]
h‰…iž€oqp‡Â"œph ‡t‚‰z}€pho„Š-sh¥jlkž€z‚m@‡t‚qs{p@ª
¨‰@t{pÅt‚ˆPmFt„k2t{ˆ€phswpIp‡Âž€zwphs{sw„‰k-s¡Zpnm@zwpÅŠ€prm–o„„k-¬½¡fqt{ˆ2
t‚ˆ l º y-k€À1k€‰N¡fk$œ–m@z{„m@€o„p|sh¥
‰k€p“s{p|žPm@z{m–t‚p|s«t{ˆ€pZzwprm@o/m@k-Šq…½m@¬@„kPm@zu£¨ž€m@zwt{s~m@k-Š4t{ˆ/y-s~ˆPm@s[t‚‰f¡Z‰z{À¡f
&l%!k3 Sv# # *7%! ©T1H5+"¢'-S1‚#&'
¥ %
‡t‚p|ŠLª„k5t{ˆ€pm@€swphk€ |p7‰@•4sw„k€¬y-o¤m@zwqt‚qphs|ªft{ˆ€„s½ž€z{‰-o„ph… h‰y-o„ŠÇDp¤sw‰oqœ@phŠ s{y€ | hp|s{sw•¯y-o„oq£
Ψs9pÐÂ-žBph
¡fk0„k9 „¬y€zwp lOl ‹¸m”Ð¥Y¦§ˆ€pŸ hy-z{z{p|kt‚s
¡fqt{ˆ9Œ«Ž-Y‘“’7¥¨2š‰…ižPm@zw„sw‰k½¡fqt{ˆ

¥¨§& §© ¢¡ ¢ ¢©!
¢¡¤£
¦ ¤£¢ © §© © ¢¦¥ "%¨§ "$©©¨ %
¢ ¢)% &¢ )© ' ¢§©
£
© ¢ ©¢ ¡¢ ©&
10 x 10−3 x [m]
calculated data
measurements
280
8
260
6
240
220
Re(B z
)
4
2
|| R(u h
) || 0
200
180
0
160
−2
140
−4
0 0.05 0.1 0.15 0.2 0.25
120
5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12
Number of elements
x 10 4
¢ "
„¬y€zwp lOl » 2š‰@…†ž€yt˜m–t{„‰k€sƒ•¯‰@zfÊ°zw‰€oqph… Ë ¡fqt{ˆ9o„„k-prm@zƒ€m@s{qsƒ•¯y€k€ |t{„‰k-sh¥
~q¬y€zwp l º »°p| |t‚‰@z¢ž-o„‰@tf‰@•«t‚ˆ-p4qk€Š€y€ |phŠ0 hy€zwz{p|k1t¢qk9t{ˆ€p4m@o„y-…†qk€„y€… ž€o„m–t‚pŸ‰–•YÊbz{‰@€o„p|… Ë ¥
º j

|z{ z{p|s{qŠ€yPm@o[m@s§zwp|}Pk-ph…iphkẗ t‚phzw„‰kÈ»
9 |}p ‘qU£¢(_$\ ‹¸¥¡ 9_ ”
: \
‘ 9 |}pˆ\}“ ¤ “X~ £9_
‘ 9 |.€/‹”_$\¤”9_ Z
º'l

¤`T¤^¤e‰¤ ¤¢¡
l ·~„zwswtuvl‰zwŠ€phzƒsu£/swt‚p|…Áo„phm@swt¢s{x1yPm–z{phs¢ž€ˆ€qo„‰sw‰ž€ˆ£¥
µ
¤§¦©¨¨ ¤ ¦£¢¥¡ ¢ ¥¨ ¤¨ £ ¨ ¤¡¦ ¢ ¤ ¥
£¥¤
· 2¨¥PΨ…iz{‰y- ˜ˆ€p@ª 2¨¥—²šp|z{kPm–z{Š€¸ª—’7¥¨3Ÿm@y€¬@p@ªPm@k-Š $¥B³qz‚m@y€o tr¥ °ph |t{‰z§žB‰@t‚p|k1t{¤m@oqs§„k
µº
!" < & 4( $ $5'

l F·Œb¥€¦ y-z{k€p|zh¥“²šphk- ˜ˆ€…½m–z{À

º Ï

¥ )£ $¢ © §© ' §©*§$© © ¢ ¢ ¢ ¢ ©& § ¢ ¢¦¢' §! ¢
¢¤£¤£¦¥¨§¦£¦¥
¡¨ ¡¨ ¡ ¡
©
¢© § £¤£!¢% © ' £ § ¢ §$¦
@&¡ 11 ¡28AB ¡2DC*¡2 @
?
¥ §¦) ¢ § ¢ § ¢ ¢§© § )© ' ¢§© © ¢ '£ §! ¢ GF ¢ ¡¢ ¡¢ ©&
¢¤£¤£¦¥¨§¦£¤E
¡ ¤ ¡ ¡ AHI2 &¡2KJ ')* 9 ¡2
¥ © § ¢

¥ ¥¤¢ ©& ¢ ¢ ¢ ¢ ©& ¡¢ ¥&§ ¨§